Editorial: Health-reform sea change

By Daily Iowan Editorial Board

In the turbulent waters of American health care, it used to be all about your place in the food chain: The sickly little fish got treated (at a price) by the bigger fish, but ultimately both were swallowed by the biggest “chicken of the sea,” the insurance company (with a little help from some pharmaceutical red herrings). But unfortunately for these health-care Poseidons, policy changes in the last four months alone have turned the medical-insurance industry into chum — and Shark Week is coming.

Insurers and patients alike are hurrying to comply with the new requirements of the federal Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, the controversial set of laws passed by Congress and signed into law by President Obama in late March; the rules will take permanent effect in 2014. Designed to rein in explosive medical costs and insurance premiums, guarantee insurance coverage to all Americans, and make Medicare more affordable, the Affordable Care Act infamously met great resistance from insurance lobbyists and most notably, every Republican representative in Congress.

The DI Editorial Board is noticing a positive sea change this summer in issues surrounding the reform bill, though. Not only has a recent poll found that an increasing percentage of Americans support the passage and provisions of the Affordable Care Act, Iowa’s attorney general is one of an elite group of three working on behalf of the legislation to defend it in cases brought to the Supreme Court by disgruntled states.

In April, immediately following the passage of the bill, approval ratings for the act hovered at a meager 46 percent; May ratings did not fare much better, with that percentage falling to 41 percent of Americans favoring the legislation, according to polls by the Kaiser Family Foundation. The survey conducted in mid-June, however, showed that number of people rising to a solid 48 percent — a sign that the changes are gaining traction with the American public.

The DI Editorial Board views the support of the legislation as essential to its integration into the medical and insurance spheres; now, the positive aspects of the reform can come to light. The Obama administration also announced its latest effort to increase public support on July 1 with Healthcare.gov, a site intended to circulate information on the new health-industry norms. It also assists visitors in choosing among “public and private health-insurance options in their states,” said Robert Pear of the New York Times.

July 1 also saw a hearing on Virginia’s legal challenge to the federal government’s authority to require all individual citizens to purchase insurance coverage. The Affordable Care Act, in theory, would work on a nationwide scale under the premise that all citizens, sick or healthy, rich or poor, will pay into a pool that balances out costs over time. The DI Editorial Board sees this as not only reasonable but as finally providing a fundamental human right to those with pre-exiting conditions or those who could not afford coverage in the past.

“The pending challenge to the constitutionality of the act has been brought by several state governors and attorneys general purporting to represent the people of their respective states and the interests of the states in general,” said Elizabeth Wydra, the chief counsel of the Constitutional Accountability Center. Should these cases reach the U.S. Supreme Court (assuming they are not dismissed by district courts), three attorneys general have stepped forward to express their continued support of the Affordable Care Act’s constitutional legality.

One is Iowa Attorney General Tom Miller, who has petitioned to file an amicus brief on behalf of our state. Along with the attorneys general of Vermont and Oregon, Miller wrote: “Without a national solution to the health-care crisis, [our states] would be forced to spend more and more on health care and yet slide further and further away from their obligation to protect the health and well-being of their citizens.”

As for the legality of the bill, Miller also noted, in an April article written in conjunction with Ohio Attorney General Richard Cordary on Politico.com: “Under long-settled Supreme Court precedents, Congress has ample power under the commerce clause of the Constitution to legislate on health care.”

We could not agree more with both points; as college students just starting out in the workforce in coming years, the looming threat of reduced or nonexistent benefits and health insurance used to be an unending source of trepidation, both economically and politically.

The judge in the Virginia reform-bill lawsuit said he would rule within 30 days, and oral arguments in a lawsuit involving 20 other states are slated to begin in September. But we are seeing promising signs that Iowans are beginning to reject their role at the bottom of the profit-seeking food chain and swimming to less industry-polluted, more healthful waters.

Read more here: http://www.dailyiowan.com/2010/07/12/Opinions/17901.html
Copyright 2026 The Daily Iowan