Judge reverses orders

By Brendan McNally

Judge Thomas K. Kistler joined another county judge Wednesday when he reversed the provisions of two criminal record expungement orders that would have forced The Daily Collegian to destroy stories pertaining to certain criminal defendants.

Judge Bradley P. Lunsford had signed three similar amended orders Tuesday to reverse a problem he said was created by mistake.

The situation arose when attorney Joseph Amendola made modifications to the standard language of five expungement orders, alterations which directed The Daily Collegian and The Centre Daily Times to wipe from their archives any stories pertaining to five of his defendants.

Despite those modifications, Amendola said he does not believe the Collegian should have to “redact” any stories.

“I wanted to kind of get a dialogue started to see if there was some middle ground to reach understanding, while still realizing there is a big First Amendment issue here,” Amendola said.

Amendola said his records show he has submitted 36 other expungement orders that were modified in a way that would direct The Daily Collegian and The Centre Daily Times to destroy more stories if signed by a judge.

He said that — to his knowledge — those orders have not been signed by a judge.

Kistler and Lunsford could not be reached by press time Wednesday to confirm whether the remaining 36 modified orders had been signed.

Jeffrey Bower, The Daily Collegian’s attorney, said Tuesday he has never seen an expungement order directing a newspaper to destroy stories and called the orders “very unusual.”

The standard expungement order would have directed all government agencies to destroy the criminal records of the five defendants, but would have allowed The Daily Collegian and Centre Daily Times to keep stories related to those defendants in their archives.

Amendola said he modified the language of the standard order because one of his clients is having trouble finding employment– even after her criminal record was expunged — because when prospective employers Google her name, they have access to a 1992 Collegian article detailing a criminal incident she was involved with.

Lunsford said he did not know the expungement order modifications had been made, and he would not have signed off on the changes had he been aware.

Read more here: http://www.collegian.psu.edu/archive/2010/07/08/judge_reverses_orders.aspx
Copyright 2026 Daily Collegian