Editorial: Boycott of Arizona’s illegal immigration law goes too far

By Oklahoma Daily Editorial Board

We all know about Arizona’s new law, SB 1070. It’s the state’s anti-immigration law, the one that says cops can ask any suspicious-acting person to see papers identifying them as American (though what suspicious activities they are talking about no one knows). The law has unleashed debates, hate speech and, unfortunately, a hatred of Arizona.

But, even though a majority of Arizonans support this law, many do not, and it is not fair to hurt those people by boycotting the state, which many groups are doing. Whole cities, such as Boston and Los Angeles, have called on its citizens to not travel to Arizona. Groups have relocated their events to other cities. Sports organizations are moving championships to other states. Even Hall and Oates canceled a July 3 show. The situation is getting worse and worse.

Recently, a group of musicians have joined together to boycott the state and cancel shows there, calling this the Sound Strike. Organized by Rage Against the Machine frontman Zack de la Rocha, bands such as Nine Inch Nails, Maroon 5 and musician Kanye West have pledged to not perform in the state until SB 1070 is overturned. This causes venues to lose millions in revenue, potentially harming local jobs and citizens.

And now, the U.S. Department of Justice is suing the state, saying Arizona overstepped Constitutional law by creating its own immigration laws, something the Constitution states the federal government is suppose to do. Now, instead of just Arizona losing money, everyone’s taxpayer money will be going toward this lawsuit.

It’s a lose-lose situation. People should not boycott the state because it’ll hurt jobs and cause more suffering in an already sufferable economy. Yet, supporting Arizona feels like supporting this law. It is similar to when the United States invaded Iraq in 2003. We wouldn’t want other countries to boycott us, because polls showed a majority of our citizens did not support the war. Our government’s goals were not ours. But because we voted them into office, we had to live with them.

But to bring this closer to home, we live in what is arguably the most conservative state in the nation (not one of Oklahoma’s 77 counties voted for Barack Obama in the 2008 election). Our representatives, the people we have voted into office, have made us look more racist and close-minded than any other state in the nation. Yet, we don’t want people to shut us out from jobs and money that we all need to live. We ask that the country sees us, not as one delusional entity, but as a state of people with different points of view that unfortunately, get overshadowed by a few with power and money.

But there is a bright side to all of this: Arizona out “Oklahoma”ed Oklahoma. For once, Oklahoma is not the state the Union is looking down upon for being racist and out of touch with reality. And for that, we thank Arizona.

Read more here: http://oudaily.com/news/2010/jul/08/our-view-arizona-boycott-goes-too-far/
Copyright 2026 Oklahoma Daily