Disarmed: Supreme Court ruling not to affect Pitt State

By Whitney Saporito

The U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling against a Chicago ban on handguns raised questions among students as to what effect it would have on PSU’s campus gun ban.

Jamie Brooksher, general counsel for Pittsburg State, says the ruling will have no effect on the campus gun ban.

“I think what’s going to happen from this is it’s not going to change our ban on campus whatsoever,” Brooksher said. “It doesn’t sound like the Supreme Court is going to open this up for a free for all. Their main point in doing this is that people are allowed to have guns in their homes.”

Brooksher says the Supreme Court ruling, handed down on June 28, says that the Second Amendment does apply to the states. She says the opinion explicitly states that guns in schools may still be restricted.

Although the Supreme Court ruling will not change the ban at PSU or other college campuses throughout the country, some Pitt State students believe it should.

Stephen Artinger, senior in political science, says it is hard to limit gun rights to certain places.

“I believe we have a constitutional right to have guns,” Artinger said. “There is a difference between what is right and what is constitutional. As far as handguns, I believe that we should have the right to carry.”

Darren Botello-Samson, assistant professor in political science, says although the ruling does not change the ban on campus it could get people talking.

“The decision itself isn’t going to have a direct legal effect,” Botello-Samson said. “If we want to talk about a longer social effect, what this kind of decision might do is either polarize the population on this particular issue or mobilize a certain segment of society to push forward on this.”

Botello-Samson says because the ruling allows states to set reasonable restrictions, the gun ban on campus should not be affected.

“It’s going to be hard for an individual to interpret the decision to say that states can’t prohibit guns on school grounds,” Botello-Samson said.

Some Pitt State students say they are content with the current gun restrictions on campus.

Martha Smalley, freshman in Spanish, says she supports the right to bear arms, just not in certain places.

“Schools are one of them, especially with stress levels of students,” Smalley said. “I don’t think it would be a good idea.”

Travis Spickert-Fulton, sophomore in computer science, says he fully supports the campus gun ban.

“The issue is, literally, does your right to bear arms infringe on other people’s rights in general,” Spickert-Fulton said. “On a campus where police are patrolling, you expect to be safe so guns really are not necessary.”

Brooksher says the Pitt State gun ban is a state law and that the federal ruling does not mandate that the state change that law.

“Schools are allowed to restrict guns on campus,” Brooksher said. “Another consideration would be state law. This is the Supreme Court saying that the Second Amendment applies to the state, that’s federal law. State law also applies, so states can have their own restrictions or non-restrictions. If our state decided to change the law, they could.”

Botello-Samson says the ruling does not make it very clear what kinds of regulations are permissible.

“The court explicitly states that this ruling isn’t supposed to be read in a way that means that states and municipalities can’t have reasonable restrictions against gun use,” Botello-Samson said. “What they simply said was this doesn’t mean you have the right to possess any type of firearm at any place at any time.”

Read more here: http://media.www.psucollegio.com/media/storage/paper437/news/2010/07/08/FrontPage/Disarmed-3922976.shtml
Copyright 2026 Collegio