Column: Voters should base decisions on substance, not impulse

By Thomas Lott

With the Major League Baseball all-star game coming up, I started to think about voting. I think it is great that people can vote for their favorite players around the league and feel they have control over something in a professional sport.

However, this system has some serious flaws. These flaws do not just show in voting for all-star teams, but also for elections for political offices.

One of my biggest complaints with voting for professional all-star teams is the idea of the snub. This is when a player who deserves to be on a roster is left off of it. It happens every single year. One of the clearest snubs I remember from recent memory is the case of Joey Votto.

Joey Votto is the first baseman for the Cincinnati Reds. He is tied for second in the league in home runs, in the top 15 in on-base percentage and runs batted in and reached base in 41 consecutive games at one point this year. He was left off the roster.

Someone who was not only on the roster, but is in the starting lineup is Atlanta Braves outfielder Jason Heyward.  Heyward stormed onto the scene this year as a 20-year-old rookie, and started off the season as a leader in many statistical categories for offense. He has cooled off as of late, and is hitting only .251 while currently sitting on the disabled list.

Fans voted Heyward in because of all the hype he was given at the beginning of theseason. Many commentators had him as a shoe-in for the National League Rookie of the Year, and with the way he started his season, it seemed as if he would live up to this billing.

Now, do not get me wrong. Heyward has put up amazing numbers, but to put him in the starting line-up for the all-star game is a joke, especially if you leave a guy like Votto off the roster completely.

Major League Baseball has tried to remedy this problem by creating the final vote for the all-star game. This is a chance for fans to vote in one last player who may have been left off the roster for whatever reason. The problem with this, once again, is that fans get to cast the final vote.

There is a very good chance that Votto could be left off the roster again because of another rookie who is on that list: Stephen Strasburg.

Anyone who watches SportsCenter knows who Strasburg is. He is the young phenomenon who supposedly throws consistently in the high nineties and could cure cancer one day. Or at least this is what ESPN wants you to think.

He has been very good in his time in the majors this year. However, he has only pitched 36 innings. He has a very good chance to make the all-star team with only 36 innings pitched, and Votto could be left off after carrying his team to the top spot in the National League Central.

I wrote all this because I am informed and passionate about this subject. I will tell you right now ­— I am no expert on political races. I could not tell you what Bill White or Rick Perry’s stances are for the upcoming gubernatorial election. Because of this, if the election was tomorrow, I would not vote.

I understand our forefathers fought for our right to have a say in the election of our leaders, but I also believe they would not want us to vote for someone when we have no idea what they stand for. We would not be making an informed decision, and in a sense actually cause harm to the democratic system.

I used the example of the baseball all-star game because people do not just vote for political parties. But, I believe the thought process is often quite similar. People vote for names they know, or in the matter of politics, parties they affiliate themselves with.

When people cast these votes and do not make informed decisions, bad things can happen.  To be honest with you, it happened the second time with the Bush administration. It may have been time for him to go. I think it also happened with the Obama administration — people did not realize he would force his agenda onto us and drag some of us kicking and screaming the whole way.

All of this happened because people were not informed. I hope people make good decisions this year in the elections and elect leaders who will make us go in the right direction. But if we do not know what they stand for and they make bad decisions, we will be to blame for electing them.

Read more here: http://www.dailytoreador.com/opinions/lott-voters-should-base-decisions-on-substance-not-impulse-1.2279078
Copyright 2026 Daily Toreador