In a landmark decision in early June, Gov. Charlie Crist vetoed Florida House Bill 1143, better known as the “Ultrasound Amendment.”
This bill, which was passed in April by the Florida Legislature, required women to view an ultrasound of the fetus or sign an opt-out form during the first trimester when terminating a pregnancy.
In a letter sent June 11 to interim Secretary of State Dawn Roberts, Crist acknowledged his own personal view of life but vetoed the amendment, deeming “personal views should not result in laws that unwisely expand the role of government and coerce people to obtain medical tests or procedures that are not medically necessary. In this case, such action would violate a woman’s right to privacy.”
The Florida Catholic Conference, a supporter of the bill, expressed “extreme disappointment” with the veto.
In a statement released on its website, the Conference said that “HB 1143 would have ensured that all women seeking an abortion during their first trimester are afforded the opportunity to become fully informed before choosing to have an abortion.”
Supporters also said that the opt-out clause in the House Bill would protect women who choose not to view an ultrasound.
UCF senior Krystle McMullan, a legal studies major, agrees with the Catholic Conference.
“[The bill] does not require or force a woman to view an ultrasound of the fetus,” McMullan said. “She can choose to ‘opt out,’ meaning she still has full control over her decision. With that said, I do not see the basis of Gov. Crist’s veto; I do not think he should have vetoed the bill.”
Brandon Campbell, a senior legal studies major, also shared his thoughts about the bill.
“Viewing the fetus she’s going to terminate only adds more knowledge and understanding to the reality of her decision,” Campbell said.
Supporters of the veto, such as the American Civil Liberties Union of Florida, see this as a great victory.
The ACLU website states that they “stand firmly behind the governor’s decision,” and the group sees the veto as a victory for women’s rights as well as reproductive rights, health care, privacy and personal freedom.
In the eyes of the ACLU, this bill would “have drastically undermined access to reproductive healthcare for Florida women and allowed government to dictate what types of health insurance coverage private employers may offer their employees.”
The College Democrats at UCF actively worked to push Crist into a veto.
“The College Democrats at UCF stand against legislation at any level that would serve to inhibit a woman’s constitutionally protected right to choose to end a pregnancy,” Jay Shannon, the president of the group, said in a statement.
In addition, Shannon pointed out that the group’s agreement “with the governor’s decision is uncanny to our party’s respect for the Constitution and the rights it bestows upon the people of the United States.”
On the campaign frontline, the opponents of Crist for the U.S. Senate used this veto to cast him as an opportunist who will pander for votes.
In a statement, Marco Rubio, the Republican candidate in the election, lambasted Crist for his decision.
“Once again, Charlie Crist has put politics ahead of principled policy-making … now Gov. Crist’s veto also clears the way for taxpayer funding of abortion in Florida,” Rubio said.
Rubio also took a dig at Crist, adding, “[Crist’s] latest decision is only the latest in a long litany of examples in which he has broken his word to Floridians.”
On the other side of the aisle, Democratic candidate Kendrick Meek didn’t have any kind words to say of the governor’s veto.
In a statement released on his website, Meek said that “Gov. Crist’s veto today was a no-brainer. The governor can never escape his anti-choice past however hard he tries to run away from it.”