Column: One blind eye – The history education system in America

By Whitney Hopple

Over the course of the last five months, I was fortunate enough to have the opportunity to work with international students at Oregon State U.

I worked with one student in particular for several weeks on his essay about the American history education system.

He proposed a question that is worth considering, now more than ever, both in and out of the classroom: Where is the balance between ignoring American mistakes throughout our history and encouraging patriotism through discussing only successful events?

In my experience with history classes in the K-12 education system, I remember the classes as being fun and full of group projects with friends discussing “gung-ho” American victories. It truly encouraged and emphasized the importance of patriotism.

On the other hand, military losses or economic downfalls were taught but never in the context of what mistakes we made and how to fix them in the future.

When discussing more sensitive subjects, such as the Vietnam War, no one dares to say it was probably not the best judgment made by the American government.

Even my parents cautioned me not to say something like this, because “we lost a lot of good men out there.”

This type of response seemed typical and showed respect for the soldiers who fought for our freedom.

However, we fail to understand that admitting something less than victory, especially in this case, was not in spite of the honorable men who fought in the name of patriotism, but rather to shine light on the hasty political decision-making that cost them their lives.

Because we do not teach future generations to consider the oftentimes flawed political agendas that have cost many admirable men and women their lives in the past, we continue to make the same mistakes today.

The war in Iraq exemplifies our attitude toward not evaluating all aspects of the situation. Afghani-sheltered terrorist bombers attacked our country, yet we invaded and occupied Iraq to change their political system instead.

The convoluted nature of our political system continues to impact other areas of our policy-making as well. The downfall of the American economy is reflected even at the level of a middle class consumer who now buys goods made in China instead of the United States.

We overemphasized the value of goods such as oil and corn to the point that we are producing monocultures that will soon drain the fertility of our land and devastate our environment.

Corn, one of the American products that is still consumed domestically and exported to other countries, is now being tainted with genetically modified organisms (GMOs) that countries such as Germany and France have banned due to potential health hazards.

Even though we no longer dominate the world economy, our pride remains strong. Our national ego gives precedence to a strong sense of patriotism, which is putting the valuable lessons we could learn from a realistic portrayal of our faults at stake.

However, I believe a recent event may be the push we need to understand that admitting our error and learning from it is more beneficial than our current attitude of prideful ignorance.

The BP oil spill has been covered on every news channel for weeks. Will the devastation of BP be washed away in history, or will it signify a turning point in which we must learn to acknowledge our mistakes and change our ways?

Because of the spill, political corruption stemming from the money made through the development of the oil industry has surfaced.

Evidence supporting a reformed energy policy and the apparent flaw in the current one has gained the attention of the public in such a way that people want to know both sides of the situation; they want to know where the current policy has failed, in addition to potential solutions.

The key, in this instance, is the public’s sincere interest in finding the political flaw in environmental policy that favors oil corporations. There is a level of admittance that leads me to believe we can acknowledge our mistake and learn from it.

I believe the spill, although devastating to our environment, has provided enough of a shock to finally gain public attention. Despite the lack of discussion in education systems, society is becoming more curious about the perspective it has been taught in the past, or seen in the media.

The initiative of the public to find out what we have not been told – and to discover the mistakes in our politics and our policy – shows that we want to know both sides of our history, even if the education systems don’t.

– Whitney Hopple is an Oregon State U. freshman in mechanical engineering.

Read more here: http://media.barometer.orst.edu/media/storage/paper854/news/2010/06/30/Forum/One-Blind.Eye.The.History.Education.System.In.America-3922654.shtml
Copyright 2026 OSU Daily Barometer