Iowa senators question Big Ten’s charitable status

By Jordan Garretson

Conference expansion has prompted Iowa’s U.S. senators to question the Big Ten’s status as a charitable organization.

In a letter dated June 10 to Big Ten Commissioner Jim Delany, Republican Charles Grassley and Democrat Tom Harkin requested financial information and an explanation of why conferences such as the Big Ten should remain tax-exempt amid apparent financial motivations for realignment.

The Big Ten operates as a charitable organization under federal tax code. Grassley is the ranking member on the U.S. Senate Finance Committee, which oversees tax-exempt organizations.

The letter noted the Big Ten’s primary exempt purpose, according to its Form 990 (a form that the IRS uses to assess public charities’ compliance with tax laws), is “to regulate intercollegiate athletics as institutional activities to encourage sound academic practices for student-athletics and to establish harmonious relationship among member institutions.”

In contrast, the letter said, “It appears that the majority of the Big Ten’s operations revolve around NCAA athletics and the marketing, promotion, and revenue-generating activities affiliated with those athletics activities. Moreover, most of the discussions surrounding the potential realignment of member institutions from one league to another appear to be designed not to further the charitable operation of the Big Ten.”

The letter cites an Associated Press report that said Big 12 members each received between $7 million and $10 million last year. The Big Ten — whose revenue is significantly increased by the Big Ten Network — distributed some $22 million to its member institutions.

In light of this report, the letter says invitations to the Big Ten seem to be extended solely to improve the “financial bottom line” for member institutions, because invitations appear to be extended based on the location of institutions in “major media markets.”

The letter then asks the Big Ten to provide “detailed justification and responses” regarding the conference’s tax-exempt charitable status. Some of the specific requests include: a copy of the conference’s most recent Form 990, a comprehensive breakdown of all program service revenue, an explanation of how any expansion of the conference furthers the charitable purpose of the conference, and all copies of proposed “expansion, merger, or consolidation” plans the conference has considered and an explanation of how the conference chose which schools to invite.

Grassley and Harkin also said in the letter they wish to better understand the relationship between the conference and the Big Ten Network.

The lawmakers’ letter considers the speculation of conference realignment resulting in “four ‘super’ conferences” and questions the difference between such a scenario and professional sports associations such as the NFL or MLB.

Thus, the letter requests an explanation of why such conferences should continue to be tax-exempt, what requirements member schools must meet to be in the conference, as well as what the costs are to meet such requirements and how these costs affect tuition and other costs for those schools’ students.

The Big Ten officially announced the approval of Nebraska as its 12th school June 11.

Harkin’s press secretary, Bergen Kenny, did not immediately return a voice mail left Thursday.

Read more here: http://www.dailyiowan.com/2010/06/25/Sports/17692.html
Copyright 2026 The Daily Iowan