Father’s Day advertising is usually shallow. Most commercials go something like: “Your father’s a man, men like manly stuff, our [big screen, chainsaw, jackhammer, flamethrower, tank] is manly, so stop by our manly store to buy a manly gift for the manly man that is your father, man.”
While contemplating which Hallmark card would best fit the 2-in-1 automatic assault shotgun/fly fishing rod I had just purchased, I heard a Father’s Day ad from the Dave Thomas Foundation for Adoption (Dave Thomas, the founder of Wendy’s, is the pioneering genius who let me swap my French fries for a baked potato). After that, I heard another adoption ad, and yet another. Father’s Day was finally making an emotional appeal.
This was shortly after I read Peter Singer’s interesting philosophical piece in The New York Times, “Should This Be the Last Generation?” In it, he considers whether bringing a child into existence is a good thing. He conveys his central argument with the help of philosopher David Benatar, author of “Better Never to Have Been: The Harm of Coming into Existence.” Singer states that “To bring into existence someone who will suffer is, Benatar argues, to harm that person, but to bring into existence someone who will have a good life is not to benefit him or her.”
Simply put, not existing guarantees no suffering. But even existing and having a good life is neutral, because if you were never born you wouldn’t care whether you were happy. It is a difficult assertion to grapple with, and I find it can only be countered by a belief in the innate goodness of being. But there is a way to skip the difficult philosophical question altogether. Why not adopt?
The truth is that there are children out there who already exist and are already suffering. Taking them into your arms and giving them a family is an act that requires no philosophical deliberation. It is undeniably positive.
Furthermore, the fact that suffering children already exist is yet another blow against the morality of creating your own children. I was raised by my biological parents, and their standard of living has given me a happy life. But I know that my coming into existence has denied the chance of some other already existing child to be adopted by my parents and have my happy life. My existence has led to the suffering and possibly the deaths of even more than one child, as the money and time my parents spent on my Western standard of living could have easily supported the lives of several children in Africa.
This is the debt of my birth, as it is the burden of all happy, planned non-adopted children. I intend to repay it through my charity and my words. Future fathers, consider adoption. Don’t let social stigmas supersede your conscience. A rose is a rose is a rose. A father is a father is a father. And his child is his child is his child.