Column: Answering for animal activists

By Kelly Anderson

Those who have any inclination towards the well-being of animals, particularly those in zoos, are immediately considered to be an animal extremist or a member of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals. Forget any of the facts, figures and scientific reports some people may hold: we’re just considered crazy. Though there are definitely people who tend to follow their hearts over their brains, animal lovers are considered extreme. The issue going on over elephants in zoos is not a matter of animal extremists versus zoo officials, it’s a battle between old science and new science.

The column “Caging Criticism” proves just my point. People aren’t listening past the names of animal rights organizations, like In Defense of Animals, to see the solid information held behind them. The column took it a step further, making several erroneous assumptions, some of which included the age of elephants in zoos. It cited 50-year-old Lucky from the San Antonio Zoo as being “well beyond her years,” which only by zoo terms would be correct, but that is not old for elephants living in the wild or on conservations..

This takes us back to the topic of old science versus new science because the number one killer of elephants in captivity is arthritis. Zoo officials and the Association of Zoos and Aquariums refute this; however, field researchers have found that elephants can travel 20 miles a day, something they cannot do in half-acre exhibits. This decrease in muscle movement and the fact many zoos still have outdated and compact substrata is directly on-setting arthritis.

In the wild, 50 years is not unreasonably old for an elephant.  In fact, in Amboseli National Park, a huge refuge for wild elephants in Africa, Echo gave birth at 60 years old, and researchers have documented and proven the lifespan of wild elephants to be 65 years and up. Fifty is old… if you’re earth’s largest land mammal and have been living on less than half an acre for your entire life. I’d be about ready to die, too.

Zoos are not conserving the elephant species; it is killing them off faster than they can reproduce them. It’s not educating children to show them elephants swaying back and forth all day — a sign of mental stress — and living in unnatural habitats with one or two other elephants. In the wild, they live with 10 or 20 other elephants in complex social groups. Zoos are not saving the species.

The article also stated Association of Zoos and Acquariums-accredited zoos donated more than $90 million annually on conservation projects, which sounds like a large number until you break it down. With 221 zoos in the nation, that’s roughly $400 thousand per zoo — a pathetic number considering the San Antonio Zoo’s director, Stephen McCusker, has paychecks that just about top that.

So it boils down to science. Don’t believe any of it? Ask Joyce Poole, one of the world’s most renowned elephant researchers. Recently, she has publicly condemned the San Antonio Zoo for its inadequate exhibit. So who’s the expert here? Zoo officials guided by old school methods put in place countless decades ago or actual field researchers who watch and learn about the species on a daily basis?

Read more here: http://www.thebatt.com/opinion/answering-for-animal-activists-1.1493576
Copyright 2026 The Battalion