Column: Caging criticism

By Matt Poarch

Most of us grew up loving zoos. From monkeys to lions to snakes and bears, there are enough zoo animals to satisfy almost any child’s idea of the coolest animal. Going to the zoo today though comes with the chance of running into an animal rights protest from groups like People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals (PETA) or In Defense of Animals (IDA). It is somewhat frustrating and counterproductive that they have set their sights on zoos, when zoos provide excellent opportunities for education and conservation through their work.

PETA has a list of complaints about zoos ranging from low investment in animal care, low educational value and little investment in conservation. With a very cursory glance, they seem to raise some valid issues. The reality, however, is that their complaints are founded on incomplete and incorrect information. A document of their stance on zoos is readily available at Peta.org.

The latest fuss in the area has been about lonely elephants. At the San Antonio Zoo, an elephant named Lucky spent time alone in her enclosure due to the death of the other elephant. This upset the IDA, who responded by staging protests outside the park and harassing visitors inside. They wanted Lucky to go free to a sanctuary.

“They mainly stayed outside,” said Dawn Koehler of the San Antonio Zoo, “and left [the inside of the park] when we asked them to.” She declined further comment on the protests.

What they overlooked was the fact that at 50-years-old, Lucky is well beyond her years of being able to survive outside of a zoo environment. Before the arrival of Boo, another aging elephant, Lucky had 8 keepers who went above and beyond in their work, shattering claims of psychological suffering. A similar story occurred at the Dallas Zoo recently.

PETA claims that zoos do not raise money for conservation, but rather for captive breeding programs. Association of Zoos and Aquariums (AZA)-accredited parks spend 90 million dollars annually on conservation programs that extend beyond their fences. Four thousand projects in over 100 countries have been funded by the AZA. As for captive breeding, PETA neglects to mention some animals are almost extinct or gone in the wild, but are being restored in captivity.

To claim that education in zoos is missing is absurd. Citing the observation of a curator at the National Zoo, PETA states that displays do not matter and that many are inadequate or do not contain useful information. Again, this is a broad, inaccurate statement. I have personally witnessed a very successful education program at the San Antonio Zoo, which has been enjoyed by park visitors and extends to local science teachers and schools.

“I would say you learn a lot at zoo, if you read the signs,” said Jake Wimberley, senior wildlife and fisheries sciences major, “You aren’t going to get anything out of it if you don’t read the signs.”

Even a senior in wildlife and fisheries, who has studied birds, fish, mammals, invertebrates, and evolution for the past three years still learns a lot by going to the zoo. For the majority of people who do not get to study animals for a living, a visit to the zoo may be their only opportunity to see exotic animals up close. When these once distant animals become tangible, interest and concern for the well-being of the creatures will grow.

PETA’s list of complaints goes on, each with its own applicable rebuttal, but the case against zoos just does not stand up to scrutiny. The fact that these groups would have zoos shut down is entirely contradictory to what the organization should be standing for. AZA-accredited zoos and aquariums (San Antonio, Houston, Dallas, Ft. Worth and Cameron Park are all accredited) are outstanding entities for conservation and animal education. If you haven’t been to a zoo in a long time, I urge you to go again this summer. Time and money spent are both worthwhile investments in education and in conservation.

Read more here: http://www.thebatt.com/opinion/caging-criticism-1.1492855
Copyright 2026 The Battalion