In wake of expansion, Big Ten’s divisional alignment uncertain

By Brendan Monahan

Penn State has been Big Ten football champions three times — splitting the championship twice with Ohio State.

With Nebraska joining the conference, a shared title won’t happen again unless the Big Ten makes an unforeseen move to not create two divisions.

Big Ten Commissioner Jim Delany said Friday three factors will help determine the division breakdown: rivalries, geography and competitive fairness. The conference will try to balance the three in making its decision.

“I’d assume the drive is monetary,” former Penn State President Bryce Jordan said Saturday.

For the Big Ten to save money on travel, the easiest solution is using a geographic format by dividing the conference among an East-West or North-South line.

In an East-West scenario, three of college football’s top-seven most successful programs — Ohio State, Michigan and Penn State — would be in the East division while Nebraska, fourth among wins all-time, would fall in the West.

“Part of the Big 12’s problem was the North-South split,” Nebraska football play-by-play announcer Greg Sharpe said, citing the conference’s imbalance of competition.

A North-South plan would include the same type of imbalance. It would pit rivals Michigan and Ohio State in different divisions as well as separate Penn State and its Land Grant Trophy rival Michigan State. But a set, annual crossover game would solve the rivalry problems.

Still, in that situation, Nebraska, Penn State and Ohio State would make up the South division, while Michigan would be in the North.

But, divisions based on competitive fairness, such as putting Penn State and Nebraska together and Ohio State and Michigan with each other, would cause loftier travel expenses, not to mention Penn State losing fairly recent rivalry games to Ohio State and Michigan.

Penn State quarterback Matt McGloin sees those rivalries possibly continuing in a different way.

“If we had a conference title game, and we were playing Michigan or Ohio State in the game that would just make it even bigger,” said McGloin on Thursday at a Penn State Special Olympics event.

The East-West divide seems the most plausible even if competition is unfairly split. Though set crossover games would solve any rivalry dilemma, long-standing competition between Ohio State and Michigan ensures those two schools should be in the same division.

An East-West conference doesn’t split up any rivals, can create new rivalries based on geographic proximity and lowers travel costs.

“If you split it, you split it geographically,” Sharpe said.

Read more here: http://www.collegian.psu.edu/archive/2010/06/15/in_wake_of_expansion_divisiona.aspx
Copyright 2026 Daily Collegian