Column: Catholicism’s failures in the modern world

By Karen Sisk

To me, excommunication conjures up medieval torture chambers, witch-hunts and the Spanish Inquisition.

Sister Margaret McBride was excommunicated—exiled from the church—by Bishop Thomas J. Olmstead within the last year for a decision she made last November at St. John’s Hospital and Medical Center in Phoenix, Arizona.

The hospital admitted a 27-year-old woman who was 11 weeks pregnant with her fifth child suffering from pulmonary hypertension. The woman’s chance of mortality, according to a hospital document, was “close to 100 percent.”

Her death would have also killed her unborn child.

McBride, an administrator and liaison to the diocese, decided to save the woman’s life by agreeing to perform an abortion.

It’s difficult to understand why the church thought that saving a woman to raise her other four children rather than allowing her to die with the one that was not going to make it was grounds for excommunication.

The Catholic Church does have Directive 47 in the United States ethical guidelines for health care providers that allow procedures that would kill the fetus to save the mother when necessary.

Bishop Olmstead—a staunch advocate of the anti-abortion rights movement—did not think this case an exemption.

Would he think any case an exemption?

This story is contemporary with the discovery that our current Pope Benedict XVI had a role in the cover-up of Father Lawrence C. Murphy’s molestation of as many as 200 deaf boys in Wisconsin.

As then-Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the pope headed the Congregation for the Doctrine of Faith from 1981-2005 where he decided the fate of priests accused of crimes such as sexual abuse.

Our current pope actually stopped the canonical trial that could’ve led to Father Murphy’s dismissal from the church. Instead, Father Murphy was quietly moved to another area in which he was still in contact with children.

Only 20 percent of 3,000 priests accused of sexual abuse were given full canonical trials within the last decade. Only a handful of those priests were defrocked—dismissed from their jobs.

None were excommunicated.

The difference between excommunication and being defrocked is important.

When the Catholic Church excommunicates a member, that person is banned from participating in the church in any capacity.

Apology and penance—admitting wrong doing and atoning—are the only way back.

When a member of the clergy is defrocked, he may still participate in the church but loses the right to perform sacraments with some exceptions.

Why aren’t more priests that have sexually abused children defrocked?

Apparently, the Catholic Church cares more about unborn children than the ones that already have been.

At least, that is the message that I’ve gotten from the church over the last 20 years and is why I no longer associate with it outside of the occasional wedding or funeral.

I wonder if Sister McBride had been Father McBride if the sentence would’ve been the same. Although, Father McBride may just have let the woman die on principle because that is what Bishop Olmstead believes that Sister McBride ought to have done.

I disagree completely.

Read more here: http://www.ocolly.com/catholicism-s-failures-in-the-modern-world-1.1492317
Copyright 2026 The Daily OCollegian