Arizona immigration law stirs emotions in Florida

By Brandon Hamilton

For the U.S. government and the state of Arizona, April will be remembered as a monumental turning point in the history of the country.

On April 23, Arizona Gov. Jan Brewer signed one of the nation’s toughest legislations to combat illegal immigration.

According to documents, Senate Bill 1070 is designed to work together with law enforcement to discourage and deter the unlawful entry and presence of immigrants in the United States.

“The bill I’m about to sign into law, Senate Bill 1070, represents another tool for our state to use as we work to solve a crisis we did not create and the federal government has refused to fix,” Brewer said before signing the bill into law.

Her views were met with little optimism.

After the signing of the bill, President Barack Obama said in a release that the efforts in Arizona “threatened to undermine basic notions of fairness that we cherish as Americans.”

For many UCF students, the signing of the law signified a return to a past where discrimination and racial profiling were prevalent in our society.

Issues of racial discrimination have been a key factor for students and their opposition against the bill because most immigrants are of Hispanic descent.

Accounting major Oris Rodriguez, 20, said the bill undermines what the U.S. stands for.

“I think it is profiling, and it shouldn’t be allowed,” said Rodriguez, who is currently serving as president of the Hispanic American Student Association at UCF.

Brewer also said racial discrimination or racial profiling in Arizona would not be tolerated.

At the time of signing, she issued an executive order to develop training for state law enforcement to prevent racial discrimination or racial profiling.

“With me being Hispanic with blond hair and light skin, I wouldn’t be stopped, but because of my dad’s skin color, he would be,” Rodriguez said.

The bill in fact allows law enforcement to stop any citizen “where reasonable suspicion exists that the person is an alien who is unlawfully present in the United States.”

If the bill in fact does what it is designed for, the use of law enforcement is the only way to fight illegal immigration and border security.

With the decision to arrest immigrants left up to law enforcement, can they be fair and nonjudgmental in the process?

Critics believe the answer is no.

In 2008, the Center for Immigration Studies estimated there were 11.2 million illegal immigrants in the U.S.

The Department of Homeland Security listed 10.8 million unauthorized immigrants living in the U.S. in 2009.

The Center for Immigration Studies also reported that the federal government estimated the number of illegal immigrants to be on the rise in Arizona, from 330,000 to 560,000 in 2008.

In Florida, there were an estimated 720,000 undocumented immigrants in 2009, according to the Miami Herald.

Evan Mateer, 21, believed when the bill was first published it contained many errors which deterred him from supporting it.

“I was not 100 percent on how it was written, because it was too harsh and could open up opportunities for people to sue their local police department and civil rights violations,” said Mateer, who is currently serving as chairman for the College Republicans at UCF.

Mateer also understands the bill and why the state of Arizona created a bill to counter illegal immigration. Solving illegal immigration was a substantial enough reason to create the bill, he said.

“Arizona is really being hurt with illegal immigration,” he said. “Immigration brings in hard-working people, but the problem is when it is not managed.”

He also said that issues occur when immigrants can’t be tracked and are unable to provide financially for themselves.

The bill also makes it against the law to house illegal immigrants, also known as the “smuggling of human beings.” This means if anybody, including family members, is caught housing aliens, then they could be subject to arrest and violations. The violations could include a misdemeanor and a fine up to $1,000, according to the bill.

Anthropology major Lili Milanes, 20, said she thinks immigration is not a problem in America.

Milanes, who is Cuban, says immigrants do the work that many students and people no longer want to do.

“Would you like to go out in the fields?” Milanes asked.

She also said that the process to become a legal citizen should be more inclusive and easier.

She believes the economy would be affected if immigrants were removed.

The state of Florida has not made any plans to form any kind of immigration bill, although some political leaders have expressed their opinions.

Arizona is also the only current state with a bill targeting illegal immigration.

If Florida became involved in the immigration process, Rodriguez said HASA would get involved and voice its opinion, beginning locally at UCF.

“I thought, as a country, we were past this,” Rodriguez said.

Read more here: http://www.centralfloridafuture.com/arizona-immigration-law-stirs-emotions-in-florida-1.2273328
Copyright 2026 Central Florida Future