Column: Media cannot condemn critical discussions of Israel

By Derrick Skaug

When White House Press Corps legend Helen Thomas said the Israelis should “get the hell out of Palestine,” mainstream media began its feeding frenzy. Their appalling knee-jerk reaction to come to the defense of Israel and condemn anyone who dare criticize the U.S. unquestioning support of Israel serves as a reminder of what is wrong with political discourse in the media. Speaking openly about Israel has become dangerous, even for Thomas, who has established herself for more than 50 years as a respected, honest journalist.

Thomas’ tactless statement that “they should go home, to Poland, Germany and America,” showed a much more spiteful and bitter side then what she said in her apology statement. In reference to her previous words about Israel, she said, “they do not reflect my heartfelt belief that peace will come to the Middle East only when all parties recognize the need for mutual respect and tolerance.” However, the political firing squad did not let up. She has been forced into retirement from the Hearst Foundation and has lost her seat in the White House Press Corps.

Lanny Davis, former White House spokesman for President Bill Clinton, said, “If she had asked all blacks to go back to Africa, what would White House Correspondents’ Association’s position be as to whether she deserved White House press room credentials — much less a privileged honorary seat?” His comparison shows a warped and illogical understanding of history.

European settlers kidnapped Africans and took them to America as slaves. Jewish settlers and survivors of the Holocaust chose to go to Israel where the U.S. spearheaded the UN’s effort to recognize the new nation of Israel, in turn displacing thousands of Palestinians.

Thomas has been accused of bigotry and anti-Semitism. Ari Fleischer, former press secretary to President George W. Bush, wrote in an e-mail to the Huffington Post that Thomas’ comments amount to “religious cleansing.” This is political hyperbole bordering on lies. Thomas’ statements did not attack religion or suggest genocide. She made a statement in support of a policy, albeit a misguided one. Her statements merely reflect frustration regarding the treatment of Palestinians by what she perceives as a country set up for imperialistic goals. The Congressional Research Service estimates a conservative total of U.S. military and economic aid to Israel at $106 billion from 1949 to 2009, without accounting for inflation. One could argue Israel is practically a U.S. military base in the Middle East.

To say that Israelites should leave Israel to Palestinians is as realistic as saying European Americans should relinquish the United States to Native Americans. The logical and realistic option is working toward finding a peaceful and equitable way of allowing all people to enjoy the resources of the land. Whether this means Israel offering Palestinians citizenship rights or a two-state solution remains to be seen.

The treatment of Palestinian citizens has damaged our relations severely with the Middle East. Though Thomas’ remarks were counterproductive to achieving peace in the Middle East, so is the attitude that anyone who speaks negatively about Israel must be silenced.

Read more here: http://www.dailyevergreen.com/story/31945
Copyright 2026 Daily Evergreen