It is both frustrating and intriguing to see a performer develop onstage in the span of an evening. On the one hand, you attend a live show expecting everything to be perfect – the lighting, the sound quality, the performing and when, initially, it isn’t any of those things it leaves something to be desired of the spectacle. On the other hand, there’s something beautiful about a band growing comfortable and building a familiarity with the space and the spectators. She & Him’s performance at the Fox Theater in Oakland, California was a mixture of these things, starting out too fast and at times insincere, but steadily becoming more courageous, as if growing up right before our eyes.
On the first warm night of the season, the immense Fox was abuzz with a diverse community of fans, from teenage Deschanel-wannabes in floral skirts to chic cocktail-sipping 20-somethings to middle-aged married couples. The anticipation was heady and palpable, even in the cavernous Fox.
M. Ward, better known as the Him in She & Him, started the set accompanied by a bassist, guitarist and drummer, and two backing vocalists. The crowd cheered and whistled enthusiastically, and then went wild as Deschanel walked briskly onstage. Clad in a tiny blue dress and stockings, she appeared charming and girlish. The band jumped right into their first song, the upbeat “I Was Made For You,” with Deschanel hopping up and down to the beat, clapping a tambourine above her head. Ward stood calmly to the side, plucking away at his guitar and giving her center stage, but Deschanel seemed hardly comfortable there. Watching her sing the first few songs of the set was less inspiring and more amusing, like observing an energetic child at her first recital. But the excitement was infectious, and despite Deschanel’s sometimes over-eager enthusiasm, it was hard not to smile.
Ward has undeniable stage presence that immediately overcomes Deschanel’s when he takes the mic. The familiar songs sounded jarringly up-tempo compared to the album versions, but Ward exemplified the steadiness the band required. He also kept Deschanel grounded, as she jumped and skipped between her mic and keyboard. Expectations that Deschanel would remain childish, however, quickly melted away as she crooned “Take It Back,” a softer number the pair played alone lit by two solitary spotlights. Here, Deschanel completely embraced the full range of her voice, and seemed at ease on the stage for the first time all night. Ward came in for a few harmonies, his slow voice mellow and soothing.
The remainder of the set and the two encores were a mixture of She & Him favorites and covers of classics including Louis Armstrong’s and Ella Fitzgerald’s “Would You Like To Take A Walk.” With their romantically old sound, blending ’60s and ’70s country with elements of blues and doo-wop, She & Him sound inherently grown-up. But the true magic was watching Deschanel, with Ward by her side, evolve from a love-struck little girl to a wiser young chanteuse, all within a matter of an hour and a half.