When MGMT came out with their Oracular Spectacular in 2008, a few sharp lines were drawn through the indie-rock world, though it never really seemed like the band’s Ben Goldwasser and Andrew VanWyngarden meant for it to happen. In one camp was the MGMT-has-just-written-the-seminal-album-of-my-generation indie kids, then the MGMT-is-a-God-awful-corporate-shill-of-a-band bloggers who primarily manifested with that opinion (an, unfortunately, valid one) after Oracular became as wildly successful as it did.
Then you had the majority: those who loved MGMT, maybe even saw them on their Oracular tour, and yet only had three songs from the album on their iPods. (If I had to guess, “Time to Pretend,” “Kids” and “Electric Feel,” right?) It’s not that they didn’t like the rest of the album. They hadn’t heard it. MGMT was a singles-band; they didn’t provide too much impetus to look at their non-singles between plays of “Kids,” which was, in MGMT’s defense (a place I’ve had to unwillingly be, more often than not), a shame.
Because, when I saw MGMT play at Bonnaroo Music Festival last year, it wasn’t a pounding rendition of “Electric Feel” that almost blew the tent down — it was their less single-friendly tracks like “The Youth” and “Weekend Wars” that stuck with me almost a year later. Maybe it was that we were all packed in so tightly it was tough to tell the dividing line between individual people — or maybe it was the contact high emanating off the band and, well, the rest of the crowd — but MGMT showed me that night what they can do with their music after everyone stops dancing and the lights come back on.
And that’s exactly what MGMT is trying to show everyone with their new Congratulations, an album the band has specially deemed one without any big singles. It seems like a lot of the record is indeed a bit of a lashing-out against those fans with only three MGMT songs on their iPod — not to say that’s a bad thing. It’s an album full of Oracular’s psychedelic non-singles like “The Handshake” and “The Youth,” only more fleshed-out and focused, with a few extra, liberal dashes of that word “psychedelic.” So I’m betting that the people who got past “Time to Pretend” and into those non-singles off of Oracular will probably love Congratulations.
“Flash Delirium” comes closest to sounding like a single and, not surprisingly, it’s also the best song on the record. In fact, all the best parts of the album are the catchy, toe-tapping parts that made us like MGMT in the first place. They don’t quite earn the 12 minutes of “Siberian Breaks,” and songs like “Someone’s Missing” build up to a poppy conclusion that just leaves me wondering why they aren’t just doing that throughout the rest of the album, but bright, singalong songs like the titular “Congratulations” and “Flash Delirium” certainly make it a worthwhile listen.
What the boys of MGMT may not realize is that those people with three MGMT songs on their iPods are often also their biggest fans. While it’s not holy-jeebus-terrible like Lil Wayne’s Rebirth earlier this year, both it and Congratulations have a hanging sense of hubris to them — this is a nice movement for MGMT to show they’re not just complete flash-in-the-pan, that-was-so-2008’ers, but it also seems, like Weezy, that they need some humbling here. They need to understand that writing singles for people to dance their hearts out to isn’t glib or inartistic, and understand that people loved Oracular’s singles more than the rest because those were the best songs on the album. Their new record could have done with a few songs to at least start our shuffles on, and, given that MGMT gave the latter part of the decade a few of its most resounding, thoroughly danceable Pop songs, that just seems like a wasted opportunity.
MGMT’s Congratulations will be officially released April 13 but, until then, you can stream the whole darn thing (and the insane video for “Flash Delirium”) at the band’s Web site, whoismgmt.com.