
Author Archives | Truitt Clark
Not Now, Martin by Lanah Marie Jose
Posted on 22 January 2016.
Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Not Now, Martin by Lanah Marie Jose
Not Now, Martin by Lanah Marie Jose
Posted on 22 January 2016.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Not Now, Martin by Lanah Marie Jose
Board of Regents overturns student expulsion
Posted on 22 January 2016.
On Monday, Jan. 4, 2016, “John Doe A” and Tech were notified that the discretionary review committee of the Board of Regents (BOR) of the University System of Georgia had reversed the decision of President G.P. “Bud” Peterson to expel Doe. Doe was expelled from Tech six months ago after being found responsible for violating of the Student Sexual Misconduct Policy and is currently pursuing an injunction against the university to overturn his expulsion.
The allegations against Doe were first reported to the Office of Student Integrity (OSI) on April 15, 2015, by fellow Tech student “John Roe.” Roe alleged that Doe had sexual relations with him when Roe was incapacitated and unable to give consent. The incident had taken place in an off-campus house almost a year earlier on April 30, 2014, at Doe’s residence after the Marching Band’s annual roving performance during finals week. Doe and Roe are members of the GT Marching Band and brothers of Kappa Kappa Psi and have hooked up once prior to the alleged incident. Both students admitted to consuming alcohol the night of the
alleged incident.
Throughout the course of the night, the pair discussed potentially hooking up again through Facebook Messenger; however, there were varying accounts of the contents of the messages. Doe alleged in his official complaint that when Roe showed the conversation to Peter Paquette, assistant dean of students and the director of OSI, the messages were “radically edited versions” that created a false impression of the conversation. Doe also alleged that Roe had contacted him two months prior requesting that he delete all of their Facebook messages, to which Doe complied. Paquette noted in his final investigation report that he reached out to Doe with information from Georgia Tech Cyber Security on how to retrieve his texts and messages and followed up on progress a few days later. According to its policy, Facebook will not recover copies of the deleted messages unless served with a subpoena in the context of a criminal lawsuit. The messages from Roe were accepted as evidence for the final investigative report.
In both the final investigative report and Doe’s complaint, it was stated that Doe met with Paquette at 9 a.m. on May 1, 2015, to review Paquette’s investigative report and respond to the charges. However, in the filed complaint, it was noted that Doe was scheduled for a counseling session at 10 a.m. in the same building — an appointment that Paquette was aware of — leaving Doe with only an hour to review the 13-page document detailing the charges against him, summaries of all the witness statements, and Paquette’s findings regarding the investigation. No identities of witnesses were provided to Doe, and there is no recording or transcript of the witness statements. Paquette’s final report was released on May 13, 2015, and found Doe in violation of the Non-Consensual Sexual Intercourse provision of the Student Code of Conduct.
Doe is being represented by Andrew T. Miltenberg, a lawyer based in New York City, and Jonathan E. Hawkins, a lawyer located in Atlanta with all inquires deferred to Miltenberg. Miltenberg was profiled in New York Magazine as “an advocate and resource for some of the thousands of male students who are accused of sexual misconduct on college campuses every year” and has as acted as an adviser to over 60 students in their college hearings. His highest profile-case was defending Columbia student Paul Nungesser after his classmate Emma Sulkowicz accused him of sexual assault in the spring of 2012.
Miltenberg expressed concern over Tech’s single-investigator process, particularly in the fact that Paquette conducted his interviews ex parte.
“One of the guiding principles of this country, … as far as the judicial system, is the full and fair opportunity to be heard and to face your accuser. [When] you realize that you’re really taking away from someone and their future, I think we have to rethink this idea that you’re not able to have an open hearing or at least confront the accuser,” Miltenberg said.
One of Miltenberg’s biggest issues with how the case was handled was how Roe was able to file a report more than 11 months after the incident happened.
“How do you really test the credibility and strength of the charges a year later? … . You certainly better make sure that everyone’s memories and recollections are sharp when you have that hearing … . The only way … is to have some sort of limit on the time during which complaints can be made.”
Tech’s current Code of Conduct states that concerns need to be brought forward within 30 days of discovery; however, the Sexual Misconduct Policy does not set a statue of limitations
as it is based on a trauma-informed approach to investigating in the effort not to re-victimize the complainant.
On June 9, 2015, Doe received notice that the Sexual Misconduct Appellate Committee decided to overturn the original decision. It is the Board of Regent’s policy that either party may file an appeal with the Institute President within five business days of the Appellate Committee’s decision, which means that Roe needed to file the appeal by the end of June 16, 2015. Roe’s parents filed an appeal on June 17, 2015, which Doe’s complaint argued was “procedurally improper” as Institute’s procedures require the students themselves to prepare and file their appeals. The appeal was also filed a day late. President Peterson still accepted the appeal and made the final decision to uphold Paquette’s decision on July 23, 2015, stating that “[he] found not compelling reason to change Dean Paquette’s original decision.”
Doe then filed an appeal to the BOR, whose committee vacated the decision and remanded the case back to Tech on Oct. 15, 2015, with no further explanation. On Nov. 10, 2015, Doe was contacted by Burns Newsome, the Director of Compliance Programs that the Appellate Committee had recommended that the original decision by Paquette be upheld. President Peterson adopted the committee’s decision on Nov. 30, 2015, upholding the decision. Doe then filed another appeal to the BOR on Dec. 4, 2015, as well as a motion for preliminary injunction on Dec. 15, 2015, in hopes to expediently reverse the decision for expulsion before classes started on Jan. 11, 2016. At the time, the BOR was not expected to meet again in 2015. On Dec. 29, 2015, the aforementioned discretionary committee determined that “there was insufficient evidence to support the decision” and that President Peterson’s decision was “erroneous.” Six days later, the BOR’s Committee on Organization and Law met but did not modify the decision, allowing Doe to return to Tech. Doe’s motion for a preliminary injunction is ongoing.
Tech refused to comment on the ongoing litigation. In Tech’s response to John Doe’s motion for preliminary injunction, the lawyers for the university argued that “[Doe’s] request for injunctive relief is moot” as the complaint and motion were originally filed when Doe’s appeal to the [BOR] was still pending but now has been heard and overturned. The response also states that Doe “has failed to state a vaild claim for a violation of his due process rights” and was given several opportunities to provide his account of events and any evidence to Paquette, a committee, President Peterson and the BOR. The document also notes that “there’s no allegation that [Doe] wasn’t given opportunity to provide his own statements or evidence to the decision maker of witnesses he believed to have value.”
When asked for his final thoughts on how his client’s proceedings were handled, Miltenberg stated that “it really is a monument to everything that is wrong with the current climate of sexual assault hearing.”
Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Board of Regents overturns student expulsion
Board of Regents overturns student expulsion
Posted on 22 January 2016.

On Monday, Jan. 4, 2016, “John Doe A” and Tech were notified that the discretionary review committee of the Board of Regents (BOR) of the University System of Georgia had reversed the decision of President G.P. “Bud” Peterson to expel Doe. Doe was expelled from Tech six months ago after being found responsible for violating of the Student Sexual Misconduct Policy and is currently pursuing an injunction against the university to overturn his expulsion.
The allegations against Doe were first reported to the Office of Student Integrity (OSI) on April 15, 2015, by fellow Tech student “John Roe.” Roe alleged that Doe had sexual relations with him when Roe was incapacitated and unable to give consent. The incident had taken place in an off-campus house almost a year earlier on April 30, 2014, at Doe’s residence after the Marching Band’s annual roving performance during finals week. Doe and Roe are members of the GT Marching Band and brothers of Kappa Kappa Psi and have hooked up once prior to the alleged incident. Both students admitted to consuming alcohol the night of the
alleged incident.
Throughout the course of the night, the pair discussed potentially hooking up again through Facebook Messenger; however, there were varying accounts of the contents of the messages. Doe alleged in his official complaint that when Roe showed the conversation to Peter Paquette, assistant dean of students and the director of OSI, the messages were “radically edited versions” that created a false impression of the conversation. Doe also alleged that Roe had contacted him two months prior requesting that he delete all of their Facebook messages, to which Doe complied. Paquette noted in his final investigation report that he reached out to Doe with information from Georgia Tech Cyber Security on how to retrieve his texts and messages and followed up on progress a few days later. According to its policy, Facebook will not recover copies of the deleted messages unless served with a subpoena in the context of a criminal lawsuit. The messages from Roe were accepted as evidence for the final investigative report.
In both the final investigative report and Doe’s complaint, it was stated that Doe met with Paquette at 9 a.m. on May 1, 2015, to review Paquette’s investigative report and respond to the charges. However, in the filed complaint, it was noted that Doe was scheduled for a counseling session at 10 a.m. in the same building — an appointment that Paquette was aware of — leaving Doe with only an hour to review the 13-page document detailing the charges against him, summaries of all the witness statements, and Paquette’s findings regarding the investigation. No identities of witnesses were provided to Doe, and there is no recording or transcript of the witness statements. Paquette’s final report was released on May 13, 2015, and found Doe in violation of the Non-Consensual Sexual Intercourse provision of the Student Code of Conduct.
Doe is being represented by Andrew T. Miltenberg, a lawyer based in New York City, and Jonathan E. Hawkins, a lawyer located in Atlanta with all inquires deferred to Miltenberg. Miltenberg was profiled in New York Magazine as “an advocate and resource for some of the thousands of male students who are accused of sexual misconduct on college campuses every year” and has as acted as an adviser to over 60 students in their college hearings. His highest profile-case was defending Columbia student Paul Nungesser after his classmate Emma Sulkowicz accused him of sexual assault in the spring of 2012.
Miltenberg expressed concern over Tech’s single-investigator process, particularly in the fact that Paquette conducted his interviews ex parte.
“One of the guiding principles of this country, … as far as the judicial system, is the full and fair opportunity to be heard and to face your accuser. [When] you realize that you’re really taking away from someone and their future, I think we have to rethink this idea that you’re not able to have an open hearing or at least confront the accuser,” Miltenberg said.
One of Miltenberg’s biggest issues with how the case was handled was how Roe was able to file a report more than 11 months after the incident happened.
“How do you really test the credibility and strength of the charges a year later? … . You certainly better make sure that everyone’s memories and recollections are sharp when you have that hearing … . The only way … is to have some sort of limit on the time during which complaints can be made.”
Tech’s current Code of Conduct states that concerns need to be brought forward within 30 days of discovery; however, the Sexual Misconduct Policy does not set a statue of limitations
as it is based on a trauma-informed approach to investigating in the effort not to re-victimize the complainant.
On June 9, 2015, Doe received notice that the Sexual Misconduct Appellate Committee decided to overturn the original decision. It is the Board of Regent’s policy that either party may file an appeal with the Institute President within five business days of the Appellate Committee’s decision, which means that Roe needed to file the appeal by the end of June 16, 2015. Roe’s parents filed an appeal on June 17, 2015, which Doe’s complaint argued was “procedurally improper” as Institute’s procedures require the students themselves to prepare and file their appeals. The appeal was also filed a day late. President Peterson still accepted the appeal and made the final decision to uphold Paquette’s decision on July 23, 2015, stating that “[he] found not compelling reason to change Dean Paquette’s original decision.”
Doe then filed an appeal to the BOR, whose committee vacated the decision and remanded the case back to Tech on Oct. 15, 2015, with no further explanation. On Nov. 10, 2015, Doe was contacted by Burns Newsome, the Director of Compliance Programs that the Appellate Committee had recommended that the original decision by Paquette be upheld. President Peterson adopted the committee’s decision on Nov. 30, 2015, upholding the decision. Doe then filed another appeal to the BOR on Dec. 4, 2015, as well as a motion for preliminary injunction on Dec. 15, 2015, in hopes to expediently reverse the decision for expulsion before classes started on Jan. 11, 2016. At the time, the BOR was not expected to meet again in 2015. On Dec. 29, 2015, the aforementioned discretionary committee determined that “there was insufficient evidence to support the decision” and that President Peterson’s decision was “erroneous.” Six days later, the BOR’s Committee on Organization and Law met but did not modify the decision, allowing Doe to return to Tech. Doe’s motion for a preliminary injunction is ongoing.
Tech refused to comment on the ongoing litigation. In Tech’s response to John Doe’s motion for preliminary injunction, the lawyers for the university argued that “[Doe’s] request for injunctive relief is moot” as the complaint and motion were originally filed when Doe’s appeal to the [BOR] was still pending but now has been heard and overturned. The response also states that Doe “has failed to state a vaild claim for a violation of his due process rights” and was given several opportunities to provide his account of events and any evidence to Paquette, a committee, President Peterson and the BOR. The document also notes that “there’s no allegation that [Doe] wasn’t given opportunity to provide his own statements or evidence to the decision maker of witnesses he believed to have value.”
When asked for his final thoughts on how his client’s proceedings were handled, Miltenberg stated that “it really is a monument to everything that is wrong with the current climate of sexual assault hearing.”
Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Board of Regents overturns student expulsion
SGA passes bill on Student Center funding
Posted on 22 January 2016.

A referendum on funding for the Student Center’s “Re(in)novation” effort was approved by both the Graduate Student Senate and Undergraduate House of Representatives on Jan. 20.
Bill number 16J116, which passed the Graduate Student Senate with 28 in favor, two against and passed the Undergraduate House of Representatives unanimously, allows the Student Center project to move ahead with a student body vote on mandatory fee increases to fund the expansion and rebranding.
The vote comes with two contingencies: first, that the fees will not exceed $85 per student per semester, and second that the fee not take effect until the new facilities open, ensuring that only students who stand to benefit from the project will be paying for it.
The student body vote on the fee is currently set to take place on March 9. Until then, Student Center personnel are planning to kick off a promotional campaign to educate students on why they should vote “yes.”
“We’re kicking off the start of the campaign on Jan. 22, and it’ll run until voting, which begins on March 9 and ends March 16,” said Lindsay Bryant, interim director of the Student Center and associate director of Student Center Programs. “[The campaign] is going to be LEGO-themed.
“The idea is ‘help build a better …’ and then a blank, so students can fill it in, whether it’s a better student organization space or a better lounge. But, visually, what people are going to see is LEGOs.
“What we’re doing within the Student Center is marketing around themes of what we want the new space to be. Every week, we’re going to be tabling and ‘teaser-ing’ to really get students to understand what it is they’re voting on. What I’m hoping with these really robust campaign efforts is that we’re really able to let the community know that they need to vote.”
The Re(in)novation campaign will also address the lack of concrete plans for exactly what the renovation will entail.
“It’s so important for the campus to understand that yes, there are lots of decisions that are yet to be made, but that those decisions will be made collectively,” said Rich Steele, senior director of Auxiliary Services. “I would say that students will have a primary voice as we move forward. We’ll seek out student voices and student opinions about what this ‘Campus Center’ should accomplish, because if we don’t listen well, we know it won’t be successful.”
The March referendum, however, is not about the specific content of the renovation.
“What we’re asking students in the resolution is this: Do they want a new Student Center, and do they want to pay a fee of at most $85 to build it? There aren’t many times when students are getting a new fee that they’ve voted on, so what we’re trying to do is get engaged with the campus,” Bryant said. “All the research we’ve done shows that we need a new building, but we really want to get students’ voices as well.
“I think it’s difficult when you’re voting and you don’t know exactly what’s going in there, but you have to look at it in that by voting yes, you’re saying we need a new student center. None of us know exactly what that’s going to look like, but you’re really voting to help build a better Tech.”
The student body vote will not, however, be the last step necessary to implement the fees and move forward with the project.
“Depending on the vote, we’ll take the fee proposal to the mandatory student fee committee, which is a campus committee,” Steele said. “That process would start in November of 2016, and the results of that process would be forwarded to the President for review before he potentially sends it to the Board of Regents [in April 2017].”
“There are still many hurdles to cross — not just convincing students that this would be a good investment of their money, but also to convince the Board of Regents that this is a fee students are willing to pay,” Steele said.
“We haven’t seen a new fee approved by the Board of Regents in a number of year because they’re committed to keeping the cost of education in Georgia as low as possible, which is understandable and something that we all support. But in order to move forward with the project of this size, we can’t ask the state for funds. Therefore, we have to find a way to pay for this from our own sources.”
The ballot will be online beginning March 9 for one week, concluding on March 16. Students will be able to vote either “yes,” in favor of a fee increase to fund the project or “no” against the fee increase. The specific language of the ballot will be released to the student body a few days prior to voting for review.
Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on SGA passes bill on Student Center funding
SGA passes bill on Student Center funding
Posted on 22 January 2016.

A referendum on funding for the Student Center’s “Re(in)novation” effort was approved by both the Graduate Student Senate and Undergraduate House of Representatives on Jan. 20.
Bill number 16J116, which passed the Graduate Student Senate with 28 in favor, two against and passed the Undergraduate House of Representatives unanimously, allows the Student Center project to move ahead with a student body vote on mandatory fee increases to fund the expansion and rebranding.
The vote comes with two contingencies: first, that the fees will not exceed $85 per student per semester, and second that the fee not take effect until the new facilities open, ensuring that only students who stand to benefit from the project will be paying for it.
The student body vote on the fee is currently set to take place on March 9. Until then, Student Center personnel are planning to kick off a promotional campaign to educate students on why they should vote “yes.”
“We’re kicking off the start of the campaign on Jan. 22, and it’ll run until voting, which begins on March 9 and ends March 16,” said Lindsay Bryant, interim director of the Student Center and associate director of Student Center Programs. “[The campaign] is going to be LEGO-themed.
“The idea is ‘help build a better …’ and then a blank, so students can fill it in, whether it’s a better student organization space or a better lounge. But, visually, what people are going to see is LEGOs.
“What we’re doing within the Student Center is marketing around themes of what we want the new space to be. Every week, we’re going to be tabling and ‘teaser-ing’ to really get students to understand what it is they’re voting on. What I’m hoping with these really robust campaign efforts is that we’re really able to let the community know that they need to vote.”
The Re(in)novation campaign will also address the lack of concrete plans for exactly what the renovation will entail.
“It’s so important for the campus to understand that yes, there are lots of decisions that are yet to be made, but that those decisions will be made collectively,” said Rich Steele, senior director of Auxiliary Services. “I would say that students will have a primary voice as we move forward. We’ll seek out student voices and student opinions about what this ‘Campus Center’ should accomplish, because if we don’t listen well, we know it won’t be successful.”
The March referendum, however, is not about the specific content of the renovation.
“What we’re asking students in the resolution is this: Do they want a new Student Center, and do they want to pay a fee of at most $85 to build it? There aren’t many times when students are getting a new fee that they’ve voted on, so what we’re trying to do is get engaged with the campus,” Bryant said. “All the research we’ve done shows that we need a new building, but we really want to get students’ voices as well.
“I think it’s difficult when you’re voting and you don’t know exactly what’s going in there, but you have to look at it in that by voting yes, you’re saying we need a new student center. None of us know exactly what that’s going to look like, but you’re really voting to help build a better Tech.”
The student body vote will not, however, be the last step necessary to implement the fees and move forward with the project.
“Depending on the vote, we’ll take the fee proposal to the mandatory student fee committee, which is a campus committee,” Steele said. “That process would start in November of 2016, and the results of that process would be forwarded to the President for review before he potentially sends it to the Board of Regents [in April 2017].”
“There are still many hurdles to cross — not just convincing students that this would be a good investment of their money, but also to convince the Board of Regents that this is a fee students are willing to pay,” Steele said.
“We haven’t seen a new fee approved by the Board of Regents in a number of year because they’re committed to keeping the cost of education in Georgia as low as possible, which is understandable and something that we all support. But in order to move forward with the project of this size, we can’t ask the state for funds. Therefore, we have to find a way to pay for this from our own sources.”
The ballot will be online beginning March 9 for one week, concluding on March 16. Students will be able to vote either “yes,” in favor of a fee increase to fund the project or “no” against the fee increase. The specific language of the ballot will be released to the student body a few days prior to voting for review.
Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on SGA passes bill on Student Center funding
Taking a second look at the southern racism editorial
Posted on 22 January 2016.

When I first read Mr. Johnson’s piece on racism in the South, I assumed that it was what it appeared to be: an opinion article that hypocritically attacked open racism by using the techniques and arguments presented by racists in order to justify their actions. The piece is antagonistic, even hateful, and does not directly address the issues that are the root cause of racism nor identify them. I then took a second look at the piece and realized that its construction could be intentional — perhaps, then, the criticism I have is that it does not go far enough. The piece is so much like the arguments it may seek to mock that it is nearly indistinguishable from them, making it extremely difficult to determine whether it is hypocritical or satirical.
Assuming that the piece is satirical, it does an excellent job of mimicking the sort of culture it mocks. It contains anecdotal evidence, folksy appeal, reduction of complex problems and willful ignorance of underlying or root causes of the issue it tirades against. The piece seems to seek to demonize a specific race based on this evidence, much like the “BLACK-ON-BLACK CRIME” Facebook posts mentioned in the article. For example, at one point, the piece argues that racism towards whites cannot exist because white people are not oppressed, reducing the idea of racism to a simplistic view convenient to the piece then goes on to mention how the aforementioned Facebook posts use a specific view of an issue to justify their cause instead of looking at it analytically. The comparison is obvious, given time to reflect, but is perhaps too subtle to notice at first glance — which, given the nature of the piece, could cause readers to form a knee-jerk opinion of the piece which does not consider it as satirical, as I did.
The opinion piece deserves a good bit of praise for how it captures the issue of racism in a satirical framework. The piece builds up to full-blown racism against whites, wrapped in the issue of open racism, a beautiful analogy for open racism wrapped, respectively, in the issue of crime within the African-American community. The major issue with this, of course, is the notion that sufficiently advanced parody is indistinguishable from the real thing. The piece seems openly racist because it is, in essence, openly racist. It maintains that white people cannot understand nor form valid opinions on diversity, and that they, for some reason, intentionally perpetrate racism despite knowledge of its existence. This is done in the pursuit, I presume, of mocking similar “BLACK-ON-BLACK CRIME” Facebook posts, but it is perhaps a bit too sincere in its parody. By nature of replicating its source material, it is antagonistic and self-serving, which could cause some readers to disengage before realizing the connection. Perhaps this is valuable in its own right, as it could mimic the reaction many have to the Facebook posts, but I would argue that the broader appeal comes from being more obviously satirical. To put it another way, the Facebook posts breed antagonism, so the likelihood of a piece intentionally replicating those posts breeding antagonism is very high.
None of this is to say that the piece is not intelligently written. It is, as I have argued, an excellently written parody of antagonistic, racist, reductionist articles that circulate on websites like Facebook. The inherent problem is that the article replicates these too well. It is more likely to breed antagonism than to cause reflection on the broader debate of open racism and is obfuscated well enough that I still have doubts as to whether this is a satirical or merely hypocritical piece. I hope that, at the very least, this letter causes some to take a second look at the piece and possibly draw some different conclusions about its nature and intent.
Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Taking a second look at the southern racism editorial
Taking a second look at the southern racism editorial
Posted on 22 January 2016.

When I first read Mr. Johnson’s piece on racism in the South, I assumed that it was what it appeared to be: an opinion article that hypocritically attacked open racism by using the techniques and arguments presented by racists in order to justify their actions. The piece is antagonistic, even hateful, and does not directly address the issues that are the root cause of racism nor identify them. I then took a second look at the piece and realized that its construction could be intentional — perhaps, then, the criticism I have is that it does not go far enough. The piece is so much like the arguments it may seek to mock that it is nearly indistinguishable from them, making it extremely difficult to determine whether it is hypocritical or satirical.
Assuming that the piece is satirical, it does an excellent job of mimicking the sort of culture it mocks. It contains anecdotal evidence, folksy appeal, reduction of complex problems and willful ignorance of underlying or root causes of the issue it tirades against. The piece seems to seek to demonize a specific race based on this evidence, much like the “BLACK-ON-BLACK CRIME” Facebook posts mentioned in the article. For example, at one point, the piece argues that racism towards whites cannot exist because white people are not oppressed, reducing the idea of racism to a simplistic view convenient to the piece then goes on to mention how the aforementioned Facebook posts use a specific view of an issue to justify their cause instead of looking at it analytically. The comparison is obvious, given time to reflect, but is perhaps too subtle to notice at first glance — which, given the nature of the piece, could cause readers to form a knee-jerk opinion of the piece which does not consider it as satirical, as I did.
The opinion piece deserves a good bit of praise for how it captures the issue of racism in a satirical framework. The piece builds up to full-blown racism against whites, wrapped in the issue of open racism, a beautiful analogy for open racism wrapped, respectively, in the issue of crime within the African-American community. The major issue with this, of course, is the notion that sufficiently advanced parody is indistinguishable from the real thing. The piece seems openly racist because it is, in essence, openly racist. It maintains that white people cannot understand nor form valid opinions on diversity, and that they, for some reason, intentionally perpetrate racism despite knowledge of its existence. This is done in the pursuit, I presume, of mocking similar “BLACK-ON-BLACK CRIME” Facebook posts, but it is perhaps a bit too sincere in its parody. By nature of replicating its source material, it is antagonistic and self-serving, which could cause some readers to disengage before realizing the connection. Perhaps this is valuable in its own right, as it could mimic the reaction many have to the Facebook posts, but I would argue that the broader appeal comes from being more obviously satirical. To put it another way, the Facebook posts breed antagonism, so the likelihood of a piece intentionally replicating those posts breeding antagonism is very high.
None of this is to say that the piece is not intelligently written. It is, as I have argued, an excellently written parody of antagonistic, racist, reductionist articles that circulate on websites like Facebook. The inherent problem is that the article replicates these too well. It is more likely to breed antagonism than to cause reflection on the broader debate of open racism and is obfuscated well enough that I still have doubts as to whether this is a satirical or merely hypocritical piece. I hope that, at the very least, this letter causes some to take a second look at the piece and possibly draw some different conclusions about its nature and intent.
Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Taking a second look at the southern racism editorial
Protecting the interests of student athletes
Posted on 22 January 2016.

Sports and American higher education are inextricable. The former is fundamental to fostering school pride, providing thousands of jobs nationwide and extending often underprivileged students the chance to earn a free education with their athletic talent. Of course, the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) also represents an industry in which high-revenue football and basketball teams bring in gaudy revenue. That money goes towards new stadiums, better practice facilities, and the generous salaries of head coaches. Not a cent goes to the players. This has finally begun to change with cases like O’Bannon v. NCAA and Northwestern University’s football team unionizing.
Colleges and the NCAA respond that their players are students first and athletes second; they are amateurs who are compensated via a scholarship. This education doesn’t come without strings. Academic scandals have marred the reputations of many institutions because athletes have been funneled through a series of insipid coursework designed to artificially raise their GPAs so they can focus on what “really” matters: the big game. Should an athlete suffer a career-ending injury, his or her scholarship is suddenly in limbo — a remarkably transactional approach for an organization that prides itself on “safeguarding” the interests of athletes.
Nevertheless, a fully subsidized education can be incredibly meaningful, particularly athletes who would otherwise be unable to afford college. Many do take advantage of the opportunity presented to them and find success, regardless of whether they become professional athletes. So, unlike so many others, I will not use this space to advocate that schools pay their athletes. The NCAA’s restrictions are not only unfair, but directly contrary to its self-stated mission: to ensure that student-athletes are well-prepared for life after college.
Collegiate athletics’ most draconian restriction is arguably the inability for players to profit from their own likeness. For years, colleges and the NCAA itself have profited from the success of their athletes; popular video games offer uncanny versions of athletes (the crux of the aforementioned O’Bannon class action), complete with accurate skill traits. Meanwhile, successful universities cash in with significant television contracts. University of Georgia wide receiver A.J. Green was suspended for four games in 2010 for auctioning his jersey. Meanwhile, the school sold fundamentally the same thing without offering him a cent. Green is now an NFL star, and despite his suspension, the Cincinnati Bengals didn’t shy away from picking him early.
But A.J. Green represents the elite few who are incredibly gifted, manage to avoid injury, and succeed at the next level. For most college athletes, making money from their own likenesses can be vital to buying necessities as food and clothing. The current system doesn’t even allow coaches to use their considerable wealth to fill these gaps; legendary North Carolina State basketball coach Jim Valvano once bought an impoverished player a round-trip plane ticket home so he could attend his grandmother’s funeral. Per the New York Times, the basketball program was sanctioned for this impermissible benefit. Perhaps these restrictions were initially well-intended, but safeguards have morphed into obstacles. Just as an English major at school on scholarship can write a book using the university’s resources and then publish it without backlash, there’s no reason a talented basketball player shouldn’t be able to parlay his on-court ability into a compensated autograph session, should the demand exist.
We have seen significant progress in the rights of student-athletes. Long the unappreciated cog in college athletics’ money-making product, it’s time to offer them more than respect: a share of the pie. Compensation is difficult; the counterarguments are clear. Is it fair to pay a college football player as much as a college volleyball player, if the former brings in more money than the latter? How does a salary affect the workman’s compensation debate (after all, the term ‘student-athlete’ was coined to avoid such payments)? But giving each student the chance to profit from his or her likeness isn’t just simple; it is as the free market would intend. The lessons learned from cultivating and maintaining a brand, the fundamentals of entrepreneurship, may even finally provide a meaningful step towards the NCAA’s goal of a meaningful education.
Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Protecting the interests of student athletes
It’s up to us to ensure that the justice system on campus is fair to all
Posted on 22 January 2016.
In the last few months, a light has begun to shine into the darkness of OSI’s investigatory techniques. Starting small, with only a few whispers and hints that something was wrong, it has grown over the break into two independent lawsuits, with a third rumored to be on the way. This metaphorical light is now blinding, and we cannot afford to ignore the perversion of due process that our campus justice system has become.
Last semester, in response to these failings and the general lack of knowledge surrounding OSI’s techniques, SCORCH, or the Student Council On Rights and Constitutionality in Hearings, was formed. Taking our cues, and the inspiration for our name, from the national organization of FIRE, a group dedicated to protecting student rights, we sought to shine a light into the inky blackness of OSI’s investigatory techniques and poorly documented reports. What we found was disquieting. OSI’s conduct under Peter Paquette has not only been extremely slanted and biased, it has bordered on malicious.
Numerous incidents were discovered where Paquette had deliberately withheld evidence, ignored blatant contradictions in witness statements, and selectively scheduled interviews so that the accused in multiple cases would have little to no time to form an effective defense. Whether or not those accused were guilty was not our impetus; we were concerned with how they were found guilty. According to the AJC, in the past five years, OSI has handled roughly eight separate cases of sexual assault. Out of those cases, seven, or 87.5 percent of the accused, were found responsible and expelled. This past year alone, there were three cases. All three were found responsible. In his time at Georgia Tech, Paquette has damaged campus race relations and destroyed countless young lives, even forcing one student to admit his bisexuality to his parents far before he was ready. OSI under Paquette has turned into a boogeyman of Tech, a far cry from the institute of justice it is supposed to be.
It doesn’t have to be like this. The task force, created last fall by President Peterson in the wake of the Phi Delta Theta incident, has released their findings. In this report, they lay out five separate areas in which OSI’s investigatory and judicial techniques have failed, among them, poor case investigatory procedures, aggregation of unrelated charges, a lacking appeals process, a lack of OSI oversight, and the formalization of findings. By far the best of their conclusions is that there currently exists no oversight of OSI; they propose a mechanism by which the bias of the hearing officer could be challenged, and this is the way forward.
While it is too late for many who have had their lives wrecked under OSI, we can yet prevent further damage. Removing Paquette, even if only by relieving him of his duties as the director of OSI, is the first step. From there, the Board of Regents will be rewriting Title IX policy on a statewide level this year; also this year, Georgia Tech will be revisiting its Student Code of Conduct. And so, to President Peterson, I make this simple request; involve us in the discussion. We are the students of Georgia Tech, we are your constituency. We are the future alumni of this school, and we will remember our time at it, pleasant or not, for the rest of our lives. The Student Code of Conduct regulates the behavior of students, and as such, the student body should have a direct hand in the creation and regulation of its policies.
To the Student Body as a whole, Georgia Tech is our school. If these issues are something you care about, please, get involved. Whether that means volunteering, not staying quiet about a time you or a friend were the victim of OSI or even just discussing these issues, remember that we must be the advocates of our own cause. Tech gives us a great deal, and as such, we owe it to ourselves and to those who will come here years later to ensure that it remains an institution where students can learn freely without fear of an overzealous bureaucracy breathing down their neck.
We have been given the problem. And like so many of the problems we are given at Georgia Tech, now it is up to us to solve it.
Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on It’s up to us to ensure that the justice system on campus is fair to all