Author Archives | the Technique Editorial Board

Consensus opinion: Tech protects student expression

Policies in a changing free speech landscape

 

The Tech community often feels the effect of changes in the federal government, as the recipient of over $100 million of federal funding per month. Even this week, the government shutdown forced the Institute to limit hiring new personnel, consulting services and major contracts and purchases, reminding us that federal policy shapes our campus in material ways. However, the reach of the federal government goes beyond funding; it also influences the limits of free speech. 

Earlier this month, the Technique editorial board discussed growing barriers to free speech at the federal level, particularly regarding the growing regulatory role of the Federal Communications Commission. To understand how free speech changes affect Tech, The Technique spoke with Dr. LuoLuo Hong, the Vice President of Student Engagement and Well-Being, about freedom of expression at the Institute. 

Despite challenges to free expression at the federal level, Tech remains strong in its commitment to protecting First Amendment rights. 

One of the common quantifiers for free speech on university campuses is the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) ratings. FIRE assesses campus free speech annually by surveying students on their experience in several free speech categories, analyzing each school’s policies on student expression and inspecting how schools respond to controversies. This year, Tech ranked 29 out of 257, dropping from fifth place last year. 

The rankings alone cannot encompass the state of freedom of expression on campus, with FIRE having surveyed less than one percent of Tech students. Even so, its system rewards accessible information regarding free speech on campuses and provides guidance on policies that support expression, like institute neutrality, by which universities do not take political stances. 

Tech adheres to the University System of Georgia’s policy requiring institute neutrality, which ensures all students feel safe and supported in their education and in their freedom of expression. Notably, the Institute opened campus to both Democratic and Republican political candidates before the 2024 election; this impartiality cues to students that Tech is a space for everyone. 

However, when politics and student well-being become intertwined, institute neutrality becomes more difficult. 

Two years ago, before adopting institutional neutrality, President Ángel Cabrera shared a letter expressing his sympathy with those afflicted by the Oct. 7th attacks in Israel. Dr. Hong said in our conversation if the same statement were made today, it could be reconsidered under the Institute’s current neutrality policy. 

This has already made an impact, when in February, Tech restructured student resource centers following a “Dear Colleague Letter” from the Department of Education’s Office of Civil Rights. The letter outlined policies around DEI initiatives in schools that receive federal funding, but despite the clear intersection of student life and legislation, the Institute focused on what changes students could anticipate rather than commenting on the policy change. 

Just as we seek to represent Tech in the professional world, we want Tech to represent us in the academic world; it makes sense that we would want to know what Tech values. While upholding neutrality requires students to find other avenues for solidarity, it is a worthy exchange to protect all students’ speech. But, should state or federal laws interfere with Tech’s educational mission, the Institute must defend the rights of its students.

A 2022 state law designated all unrestricted outdoor areas of state campuses as free speech zones. As a result, Tech cannot deny protest in dedicated areas of campus, so long as the group adheres to time, place and manner restrictions. Such restrictions include limiting protest during finals, quelling noise level or regulating the size of posters. 

However, Tech takes measures beyond state requirements to actively protect free campus speech. Staff and faculty can join the volunteer observer program, which allows them to train to be multi-partial witnesses to expressive activities, and act as eyewitnesses or mitigate possible conflict. 

While students may disagree with protesters’ messages or find protests inconvenient, feeling unsafe or being unable to freely express oneself is a far greater inconvenience. 

Tech must continue to support free speech, not just with policy and didactics, but financially.  Tech must continue to fund Registered Student Organizations that serve as student platforms for speech. 

However, there are limitations to Tech’s ability to regulate speech. This is particularly true online where people can make inflammatory comments anonymously. For cases where Tech cannot protect us, they provide students the tools to use free speech effectively and respectfully through a civil discourse training course mandatory for students matriculating in Fall 2025 onward. 

Though these differences in language and context may seem insignificant, the conscious demarcation of spaces and roles protects us and our rights, especially in spaces outside of Tech’s jurisdiction. 

Tech’s policy of institute neutrality, free speech zones and mandatory civil discourse training provides a strong foundation for free speech protection on campus. However, Tech can only do so much alone. Tech students must do what they do best and lead by example — not just in engineering or value rankings, but in creating the space to uplift voices and new ideas that allow for innovation and growth.

 

The post Consensus opinion: Tech protects student expression appeared first on Technique.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Consensus opinion: Tech protects student expression

Consensus opinion: Tech protects student expression

Policies in a changing free speech landscape

 

The Tech community often feels the effect of changes in the federal government, as the recipient of over $100 million of federal funding per month. Even this week, the government shutdown forced the Institute to limit hiring new personnel, consulting services and major contracts and purchases, reminding us that federal policy shapes our campus in material ways. However, the reach of the federal government goes beyond funding; it also influences the limits of free speech. 

Earlier this month, the Technique editorial board discussed growing barriers to free speech at the federal level, particularly regarding the growing regulatory role of the Federal Communications Commission. To understand how free speech changes affect Tech, The Technique spoke with Dr. LuoLuo Hong, the Vice President of Student Engagement and Well-Being, about freedom of expression at the Institute. 

Despite challenges to free expression at the federal level, Tech remains strong in its commitment to protecting First Amendment rights. 

One of the common quantifiers for free speech on university campuses is the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE) ratings. FIRE assesses campus free speech annually by surveying students on their experience in several free speech categories, analyzing each school’s policies on student expression and inspecting how schools respond to controversies. This year, Tech ranked 29 out of 257, dropping from fifth place last year. 

The rankings alone cannot encompass the state of freedom of expression on campus, with FIRE having surveyed less than one percent of Tech students. Even so, its system rewards accessible information regarding free speech on campuses and provides guidance on policies that support expression, like institute neutrality, by which universities do not take political stances. 

Tech adheres to the University System of Georgia’s policy requiring institute neutrality, which ensures all students feel safe and supported in their education and in their freedom of expression. Notably, the Institute opened campus to both Democratic and Republican political candidates before the 2024 election; this impartiality cues to students that Tech is a space for everyone. 

However, when politics and student well-being become intertwined, institute neutrality becomes more difficult. 

Two years ago, before adopting institutional neutrality, President Ángel Cabrera shared a letter expressing his sympathy with those afflicted by the Oct. 7th attacks in Israel. Dr. Hong said in our conversation if the same statement were made today, it could be reconsidered under the Institute’s current neutrality policy. 

This has already made an impact, when in February, Tech restructured student resource centers following a “Dear Colleague Letter” from the Department of Education’s Office of Civil Rights. The letter outlined policies around DEI initiatives in schools that receive federal funding, but despite the clear intersection of student life and legislation, the Institute focused on what changes students could anticipate rather than commenting on the policy change. 

Just as we seek to represent Tech in the professional world, we want Tech to represent us in the academic world; it makes sense that we would want to know what Tech values. While upholding neutrality requires students to find other avenues for solidarity, it is a worthy exchange to protect all students’ speech. But, should state or federal laws interfere with Tech’s educational mission, the Institute must defend the rights of its students.

A 2022 state law designated all unrestricted outdoor areas of state campuses as free speech zones. As a result, Tech cannot deny protest in dedicated areas of campus, so long as the group adheres to time, place and manner restrictions. Such restrictions include limiting protest during finals, quelling noise level or regulating the size of posters. 

However, Tech takes measures beyond state requirements to actively protect free campus speech. Staff and faculty can join the volunteer observer program, which allows them to train to be multi-partial witnesses to expressive activities, and act as eyewitnesses or mitigate possible conflict. 

While students may disagree with protesters’ messages or find protests inconvenient, feeling unsafe or being unable to freely express oneself is a far greater inconvenience. 

Tech must continue to support free speech, not just with policy and didactics, but financially.  Tech must continue to fund Registered Student Organizations that serve as student platforms for speech. 

However, there are limitations to Tech’s ability to regulate speech. This is particularly true online where people can make inflammatory comments anonymously. For cases where Tech cannot protect us, they provide students the tools to use free speech effectively and respectfully through a civil discourse training course mandatory for students matriculating in Fall 2025 onward. 

Though these differences in language and context may seem insignificant, the conscious demarcation of spaces and roles protects us and our rights, especially in spaces outside of Tech’s jurisdiction. 

Tech’s policy of institute neutrality, free speech zones and mandatory civil discourse training provides a strong foundation for free speech protection on campus. However, Tech can only do so much alone. Tech students must do what they do best and lead by example — not just in engineering or value rankings, but in creating the space to uplift voices and new ideas that allow for innovation and growth.

 

The post Consensus opinion: Tech protects student expression appeared first on Technique.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Consensus opinion: Tech protects student expression

Consensus Opinion: Free speech comes at a cost

The chaos surrounding ABC’s removal and reinstatement of “Jimmy Kimmel Live!” in the last month exemplifies what critics have long suspected of the Trump Administration: that free speech is becoming expensive. 

This saga did not begin weeks ago when Jimmy Kimmel commented on the assasination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk, nor with CBS’s cancellation of “The Late Show” with Stephen Colbert in July. It began a decade ago, during President Donald Trump’s first presidential campaign in 2015. 

For years, Trump has raised doubts about the credibility of the media, from deeming some outlets as “fake news” to urging rally crowds to jeer at the press. Trump continued to take aim at the media while in his first term in office, attempting to ban a CNN reporter from the press pool and calling the press “the enemy of the people.” 

Late night shows play a crucial role in the media landscape, embodying the convergence of entertainment and news. “Saturday Night Live” sketches and late-night show monologues point out the absurdities in politics and make news engaging to audiences. These comedians and satirists serve to put news in context; they do not aim to be a  replacement for raw news sources. But, that does not make them exempt from criticism. 

On his show, Kimmel argued that Trump loyalists were trying to score political points off Kirk’s murder. Kimmel stated that the “MAGA gang” was “trying to characterize this kid who murdered Charlie Kirk as anything other than one of them.”

Days after Kimmel’s show aired, reports confirmed that Kirk’s suspected killer leaned left politically, at which point Federal Communications Commission (FCC) Chair Brendan Carr began his effort against Kimmel. Carr told right-wing podcaster Benny Johnson that the FCC could revoke ABC affiliate licences to encourage The Walt Disney Company, which owns ABC, to punish Kimmel. 

Kimmel’s comment was misleading — at the time of airing, law enforcement had not yet revealed the political leaning of the suspected assassin. However, misinformation does not begin and end with Kimmel. Trump similarly speculated that the “radical left” was responsible for Kirk’s murder before any details about the shooter were released. Yet, only one of these people faced retribution from the FCC. It is this imbalance that underscores a transition of the FCC from a regulator to a political weapon. 

This double standard is dangerous, but completely predictable. 

After losing the 2020 presidential election, the Trump campaign did not just return with a vengeance, they returned with a plan. Trump has denied affiliation with the policy blueprint  “Project 2025” written by the Heritage foundation, a right-wing think tank. Even so, bit by bit, the Trump administration has implemented many of the ideas outlined in the plan to reshape the federal government. 

Carr is the author of the “Project 2025” chapter on the FCC. In the chapter, he details how a president could act to skew the political balance of the FCC in favor of his own political party and how the FCC could limit Big Tech’s promotion of diverse political viewpoints. 

The FCC will not stop at Kimmel. In the weeks following the Kimmel fiasco, Carr has appeared on radio shows and Fox News promising that the FCC will ensure that TV does not air biased broadcasts to better serve the public interests. Trump echoed his sentiments, posting on Truth Social calling on NBC to remove late-night shows hosted by Seth Meyers and Jimmy Fallon from air. 

Unlike many politicians shaped by military service or legal careers, Trump is a businessman. He campaigned on his ability to negotiate to get what he wants. 

The news media has a bottom line just like any other American industry, and their ability to conduct business is regulated by the federal government. These free speech battles do not just play out in the press, they play out in balance sheets. 

Just days after CBS announced the cancellation of “The Late Show,” the Trump administration approved the pending merger between Paramount Global, CBS’s parent company, and Skydance Media. 

When the Walt Disney Company announced “Jimmy Kimmel Live!” would return to ABC,  Nexstar Media Group and Sinclair Broadcast Group initially still refused to air Kimmel’s show. Collectively the groups operate over 60 ABC affiliate stations. Carr applauded their efforts to preempt the show. But this is not just ideological alignment; the parent companies of Sinclair and Nexstar are each seeking a merger that requires Trump administration approval. 

Free speech is not free if the path to get there is litigious and expensive. Free speech is not free if the attorney general of the United States threatens to “go after” people who engage in hate speech, despite the fact that hate speech is protected under the First Amendment. 

This is not about one comedian’s misleading monologue, it is about the survival of free speech when corporate and government interests converge.

The post Consensus Opinion: Free speech comes at a cost appeared first on Technique.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Consensus Opinion: Free speech comes at a cost

ICE Raid at Hyundai Metaplant

Intersection of immigration and industry

Last week, the largest single immigration raid in Homeland Security history took place at the Hyundai Motor Group Metaplant in Ellabell, Ga. Though this operation occurred 200 miles from Atlanta, its effects reverberate across Tech’s campus and around the world. 

Of the 475 people arrested, 300 were South Korean nationals hired to oversee the ongoing construction of the plant. The majority of people arrested did not work directly for Hyundai; they were mostly subcontractors on expired visas or visa waivers that prohibited them from working.

The raid encompasses many of the ongoing political debates in the country — not just immigration. 

The plant, which Hyundai and LG Energy Solution co-own, is part of a $7.6 billion deal that Gov. Brian Kemp unveiled in 2022. It is the largest economic development project in state history, backed by nearly $2 billion in tax-payer funded incentives. Hyundai, based out of South Korea, is poised to make Georgia into an electric vehicle hub. South Korea is Georgia’s third-largest trading partner; since taking office in 2019, Kemp has visited the country twice. 

Georgia’s relationship with Hyundai has not only provided numerous benefits for clean energy enthusiasts, it has led to major changes on campus. In 2022, Hyundai funded a $120,000 STEM scholarship at Tech. Not even a year later, Tech and Hyundai announced their partnership, including multi-decade investment in research and athletics. 

Given all these benefits, there should be an easier way for immigrants to obtain documented status. Though H1B visas allow highly-skilled workers to enter the country, these visas cost thousands of dollars. Policymakers should provide some accelerated, low-cost channels for people filling jobs that we cannot easily fill ourselves. 

But it does not just fall on higher-levels of government to resolve this issue — the contractor that sent these workers on improper visas must be held accountable. Companies are responsible for the safety of their employees, particularly in the face of complex bureaucratic issues that workers may not have the resources to handle on their own. 

This raid was part of a broader immigration crackdown from President Donald Trump, and Kemp has not strayed far from that agenda.

However, interestingly, those detained in the raid will be able to return to South Korea fairly quickly. The Department of Homeland Security held detainees at a detention facility near the Fla. border until the South Korean government negotiated their return by charter plane on Sunday. A plane left from Seoul, South Korea on Wednesday to pick up the detainees for “voluntary departure.” The ability of the South Korean government to negotiate a flight home for its detained citizens is notable since it is not a privilege that all countries have received. 

In Trump’s first term in office, immigration detention centers separated families at the southern border and infamously put children in chain-link enclosures as their cases were processed. SMore recently, since taking office this year, the U.S. and Colombia nearly entered a trade war after the Colombian President blocked two U.S. military flights carrying undocumented immigrants from entering the country. 

If one group of people is held inhumanely in detention centers for weeks or months and another can fly home quickly and comfortably, immigration policy needs reform. There must be the opportunity for due process and fair treatment under the law; treatment cannot be fair if it is dependent on the value of a passport. The immigration debate is complex, but immigration officials should apply immigration law equally regardless of the bargaining power of one’s home country. The South Korean immigrants detained in Ellabell were able to return home on a plane after high-level negotiations, not held in a crowded detention center or inhumanely transported back and forth across borders. 

This is not the first time that the Hyundai Metaplant has been the setting for a political battle.

In 2018, Kemp campaigned as a Trump-loyalist, known for his ads where he proclaimed to be prepared to round up illegal immigrants in his truck and use his Second Amendment right to defend his daughter from the young man trying to date her. 

Kemp lauds the plant as an economic win for Georgians, but perhaps more strikingly, the deal is popular across the aisle. Democratic U.S. Senator Jon Ossoff has expressed his support for the plant and its investment in electric vehicle manufacturing. However, the hub has faced its share of criticism. Some Republicans attacked the plant’s reliance on clean energy tax incentives backed by former President Joe Biden. Since taking office this year, President Donald Trump has begun to dismantle these Biden-era policies. 

That immigration raid in Ellabell was not an isolated event — it was the result of years of policy and decade-long political campaigns. Those policies have an impact on Tech students entering the workforce now, and will continue to  impact Tech students years from now — from engineers to INTA majors. Going into midterm elections in 2026, Tech students need to remain aware of the intersection of immigration policy, political alliances and industry — it could be a key determination in their future.

The post ICE Raid at Hyundai Metaplant appeared first on Technique.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ICE Raid at Hyundai Metaplant

Voting legislation in Georgia

On Friday, Aug. 22, Georgia election officials cancelled nearly half a million voter registrations across the state. Affected voters had 40 days to respond to the mailed notification before cancellation, and only 5,500 managed to do so before the deadline. 

This is one of the largest clearances of the voter registration log in U.S. history, and another point on a long list of electoral headlines in Georgia in the last several years. 

Georgia’s status as a “battleground state” can feel literal at times — in just the last couple years, our state has been the setting for electoral legal clashes, presidential debates and rallies.

As voters, we should  push for transparency as these developments take hold, particularly in the face of misinformation and controversies surrounding the voting process. We must consider why politicians are invested in Georgia elections, as well as the cumulative effect of how these legislative and non-legislative changes play a role in how Georgians vote. 

Georgia is part of a 24-state partnership in the Electronic Registration Information Center (ERIC), which collects records when voters move, get a driver’s license or register to vote and change registrations accordingly. However, of the 471,000 registrations cancelled, ERIC was responsible for less than half of cancellations. The Secretary of State’s office carried out the rest, cancelling registration for voters who have not participated in the last two general elections or whose election mail was undeliverable. 

Though clearing backlogs is a routine procedure, the cancellations expanded beyond the regular cancellations by ERIC. Considered in the context of the many changes to the voting process in Georgia, removing swaths of previously eligible voters from records is noteworthy. 

Barriers to participating in elections in Georgia are real and well-established.

After the most recent redistricting of Georgia political maps in 2020, a 2023 court challenge resulted in a redrawing of the map on the basis of racial discrimination. Though the redrawing did not change the number of Republican and Democratic representatives, it is clear that Georgia is not exempt from system-level problems that hurt certain voting blocs. 

Among these systemic issues are the high barriers to register to vote in the first place. Georgia law dictates that voters must be registered to vote 29 days before election day to participate in the election, one of the earliest registration deadlines in the country. The “Election Integrity Act of 2021” reduced the amount of time Georgia residents can request to vote by mail or absentee, making the deadline to request a ballot two Fridays before election day. Moreover, the act requires that drop box locations must be inside early voting locations and can only take place during early voting days and hours. As students, early voting in our county during a break or voting by mail is often our best option, and limiting these time windows makes it harder for us to participate in elections. This change will also affect people who physically cannot vote at a polling place as well as people who work long hours and cannot submit their vote before close. 

Though not impossible to vote in Georgia by any means — Georgia reached a record high of 5.29 million voters in the 2024 general election — these changes create challenges Georgians must overcome to vote. Election security is necessary, but there are numerous safe and secure elections that have fewer obstacles to participation which exist in other states and have previously existed in Georgia. Over a third of U.S. states have same day voter registration and polls in nearly every other state are open later than they are in Georgia.

In view of the voting conversation is not just legislation, but the national narrative surrounding the democratic process. 

Following the 2020 election, the Trump campaign and a Republican elector each filed lawsuits in Georgia alleging constitutional violations and fraud in Georgia elections; a federal judge rejected both cases. Despite overwhelming evidence that the votes were accurate, President Donald Trump brazenly stated that fraud had taken place. The suits continued, with former Trump attorney Sidney Powell alleging that voting machines were rigged, a case that was also dismissed. These allegations came to a head with President Trump famously calling Georgia secretary of state Brad Raffensperger and asking Raffensperger to “find 11,780 votes.”

Any one of these laws or false claims may not be enough for one to lose faith in voting systems. However, all together, it is easy to understand why someone may be exhausted from this incessant conflict over a right that is foundational to the United States. 

Considering this long-standing history of Trump lawsuits and crimes regarding elections, it is unsurprising that in the last few weeks, President Trump has promised to lead a movement to end mail-in ballots and voting machines. Though he does not have the unique power to change how elections are carried out, at the very least, it brought the question of election security to the national stage. Undermining elections on the basis of misinformation with the possibility of codifying these changes into law opens up the threat of a world of more lawsuits and contests in our democratic processes in future elections. 

In the U.S., the best tool we have to express ourselves is our vote. If you are a Georgia voter, check your voter registration at mvp.sos.ga.gov/s/. Make sure your voice can be heard. Remain cognizant of the discussions that affect your representation, your life and your community.

The post Voting legislation in Georgia appeared first on Technique.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Voting legislation in Georgia

Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications

In late April, the Justice Department (DOJ) initiated an investigation into claims of discrimination against white men at the student-run law journal, the Harvard Law Review, with a hearing now set for July 21. 

The investigation epitomizes President Donald Trump’s yearslong attack on the press for alleged corruption and bias and the administration’s more recent crackdown on higher education. As a top research university, Tech has already felt the effects of federal and state legislation shaping what projects receive funding and how our resource centers are structured. However, Tech is not alone in seeing how systemic change in higher education bleeds into the lives of all Americans.

The Harvard Law Review operates independently of Harvard University and is widely considered the one of the most prestigious law journals in the United States, with high-level courts using articles from the Law Review to support rulings and develop arguments. It is undoubtedly important to investigate and condemn instances of racism and bias when they occur, particularly in fields as impactful as the legal one. 

More broadly speaking, independent student publications, including the Technique, have a responsibility to take claims of discrimination seriously which may lead to biased hiring or reporting. Dually, publication’s independence from university and government oversight without fear of retribution allows them to cover difficult issues honestly and impartially. A publication is only as comprehensive as the voices and subject matters it chooses to present. This issue extends beyond student background; for example, college campus publications must consider club participation, field of study and personal interests when researching for news that impacts their readers.

The federal investigation into The Law Review calls into question the point at which biases are severe enough to require intervention from a higher body, whether it be a university or government. 

The case, as far as the government has disclosed, is predicated on the testimony of one cooperating witness, Harvard Law graduate Daniel Wasserman. In documents obtained by the Washington Free Beacon, editors at the Law Review make note of the racial and educational background of various authors and where their perspective may be limiting or may provide a new angle on a topic.

Interpreting the law is inherently biased, therefore it is necessary to include as many perspectives on a given subject as possible. Choosing to uplift a variety of expert voices, not just one, accounts for more biases and therefore tends to represent more of the people that the law presides over. 

The Law Review boasts an impressive roster of influential alumni including former President Barack Obama and late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, both of whom shaped laws and articulated important decisions in the government to Americans. Obama’s election was not a diversity hire by the American public; he is a gifted speaker and politician that struck home for a majority of voters — twice. It is impossible to know if working on the Law Review specifically propels alumni’s careers, but it is impossible to deny that the Law Review generates highly regarded information and interpretations. 

All publications should have the shared goal of generating the highest quality of content to inform their audience. Publications have an obligation to find the reporters and investigators that understand and can talk about issues clearly. They also have a duty to be thorough and cover a variety of topics within their scope, not just the headlines or titles that are interesting to one type of person. Finding the right writer or speaker to cover a topic is not dependent on if they align with the issue or affected group — it is dependent on their ability to holistically capture a subject matter. 

However, the looming threat of litigation or financial abandonment directed at student publications from the source that funds them tends to silent student voices even further if applied wantonly. The accusations levied against the Law Review and the ensuing investigation hurt the freedom of the press on college campuses and also stifles a voice that supports the system of checks and balances that maintain our democracy. If bias is the root cause of the concern, limiting research and threatening student publications is not the solution.

The post Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications appeared first on Technique.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications

Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications

In late April, the Justice Department (DOJ) initiated an investigation into claims of discrimination against white men at the student-run law journal, the Harvard Law Review, with a hearing now set for July 21. 

The investigation epitomizes President Donald Trump’s yearslong attack on the press for alleged corruption and bias and the administration’s more recent crackdown on higher education. As a top research university, Tech has already felt the effects of federal and state legislation shaping what projects receive funding and how our resource centers are structured. However, Tech is not alone in seeing how systemic change in higher education bleeds into the lives of all Americans.

The Harvard Law Review operates independently of Harvard University and is widely considered the one of the most prestigious law journals in the United States, with high-level courts using articles from the Law Review to support rulings and develop arguments. It is undoubtedly important to investigate and condemn instances of racism and bias when they occur, particularly in fields as impactful as the legal one. 

More broadly speaking, independent student publications, including the Technique, have a responsibility to take claims of discrimination seriously which may lead to biased hiring or reporting. Dually, publication’s independence from university and government oversight without fear of retribution allows them to cover difficult issues honestly and impartially. A publication is only as comprehensive as the voices and subject matters it chooses to present. This issue extends beyond student background; for example, college campus publications must consider club participation, field of study and personal interests when researching for news that impacts their readers.

The federal investigation into The Law Review calls into question the point at which biases are severe enough to require intervention from a higher body, whether it be a university or government. 

The case, as far as the government has disclosed, is predicated on the testimony of one cooperating witness, Harvard Law graduate Daniel Wasserman. In documents obtained by the Washington Free Beacon, editors at the Law Review make note of the racial and educational background of various authors and where their perspective may be limiting or may provide a new angle on a topic.

Interpreting the law is inherently biased, therefore it is necessary to include as many perspectives on a given subject as possible. Choosing to uplift a variety of expert voices, not just one, accounts for more biases and therefore tends to represent more of the people that the law presides over. 

The Law Review boasts an impressive roster of influential alumni including former President Barack Obama and late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, both of whom shaped laws and articulated important decisions in the government to Americans. Obama’s election was not a diversity hire by the American public; he is a gifted speaker and politician that struck home for a majority of voters — twice. It is impossible to know if working on the Law Review specifically propels alumni’s careers, but it is impossible to deny that the Law Review generates highly regarded information and interpretations. 

All publications should have the shared goal of generating the highest quality of content to inform their audience. Publications have an obligation to find the reporters and investigators that understand and can talk about issues clearly. They also have a duty to be thorough and cover a variety of topics within their scope, not just the headlines or titles that are interesting to one type of person. Finding the right writer or speaker to cover a topic is not dependent on if they align with the issue or affected group — it is dependent on their ability to holistically capture a subject matter. 

However, the looming threat of litigation or financial abandonment directed at student publications from the source that funds them tends to silent student voices even further if applied wantonly. The accusations levied against the Law Review and the ensuing investigation hurt the freedom of the press on college campuses and also stifles a voice that supports the system of checks and balances that maintain our democracy. If bias is the root cause of the concern, limiting research and threatening student publications is not the solution.

The post Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications appeared first on Technique.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications

Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications

In late April, the Justice Department (DOJ) initiated an investigation into claims of discrimination against white men at the student-run law journal, the Harvard Law Review, with a hearing now set for July 21. 

The investigation epitomizes President Donald Trump’s yearslong attack on the press for alleged corruption and bias and the administration’s more recent crackdown on higher education. As a top research university, Tech has already felt the effects of federal and state legislation shaping what projects receive funding and how our resource centers are structured. However, Tech is not alone in seeing how systemic change in higher education bleeds into the lives of all Americans.

The Harvard Law Review operates independently of Harvard University and is widely considered the one of the most prestigious law journals in the United States, with high-level courts using articles from the Law Review to support rulings and develop arguments. It is undoubtedly important to investigate and condemn instances of racism and bias when they occur, particularly in fields as impactful as the legal one. 

More broadly speaking, independent student publications, including the Technique, have a responsibility to take claims of discrimination seriously which may lead to biased hiring or reporting. Dually, publication’s independence from university and government oversight without fear of retribution allows them to cover difficult issues honestly and impartially. A publication is only as comprehensive as the voices and subject matters it chooses to present. This issue extends beyond student background; for example, college campus publications must consider club participation, field of study and personal interests when researching for news that impacts their readers.

The federal investigation into The Law Review calls into question the point at which biases are severe enough to require intervention from a higher body, whether it be a university or government. 

The case, as far as the government has disclosed, is predicated on the testimony of one cooperating witness, Harvard Law graduate Daniel Wasserman. In documents obtained by the Washington Free Beacon, editors at the Law Review make note of the racial and educational background of various authors and where their perspective may be limiting or may provide a new angle on a topic.

Interpreting the law is inherently biased, therefore it is necessary to include as many perspectives on a given subject as possible. Choosing to uplift a variety of expert voices, not just one, accounts for more biases and therefore tends to represent more of the people that the law presides over. 

The Law Review boasts an impressive roster of influential alumni including former President Barack Obama and late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, both of whom shaped laws and articulated important decisions in the government to Americans. Obama’s election was not a diversity hire by the American public; he is a gifted speaker and politician that struck home for a majority of voters — twice. It is impossible to know if working on the Law Review specifically propels alumni’s careers, but it is impossible to deny that the Law Review generates highly regarded information and interpretations. 

All publications should have the shared goal of generating the highest quality of content to inform their audience. Publications have an obligation to find the reporters and investigators that understand and can talk about issues clearly. They also have a duty to be thorough and cover a variety of topics within their scope, not just the headlines or titles that are interesting to one type of person. Finding the right writer or speaker to cover a topic is not dependent on if they align with the issue or affected group — it is dependent on their ability to holistically capture a subject matter. 

However, the looming threat of litigation or financial abandonment directed at student publications from the source that funds them tends to silent student voices even further if applied wantonly. The accusations levied against the Law Review and the ensuing investigation hurt the freedom of the press on college campuses and also stifles a voice that supports the system of checks and balances that maintain our democracy. If bias is the root cause of the concern, limiting research and threatening student publications is not the solution.

The post Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications appeared first on Technique.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications

Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications

In late April, the Justice Department (DOJ) initiated an investigation into claims of discrimination against white men at the student-run law journal, the Harvard Law Review, with a hearing now set for July 21. 

The investigation epitomizes President Donald Trump’s yearslong attack on the press for alleged corruption and bias and the administration’s more recent crackdown on higher education. As a top research university, Tech has already felt the effects of federal and state legislation shaping what projects receive funding and how our resource centers are structured. However, Tech is not alone in seeing how systemic change in higher education bleeds into the lives of all Americans.

The Harvard Law Review operates independently of Harvard University and is widely considered the one of the most prestigious law journals in the United States, with high-level courts using articles from the Law Review to support rulings and develop arguments. It is undoubtedly important to investigate and condemn instances of racism and bias when they occur, particularly in fields as impactful as the legal one. 

More broadly speaking, independent student publications, including the Technique, have a responsibility to take claims of discrimination seriously which may lead to biased hiring or reporting. Dually, publication’s independence from university and government oversight without fear of retribution allows them to cover difficult issues honestly and impartially. A publication is only as comprehensive as the voices and subject matters it chooses to present. This issue extends beyond student background; for example, college campus publications must consider club participation, field of study and personal interests when researching for news that impacts their readers.

The federal investigation into The Law Review calls into question the point at which biases are severe enough to require intervention from a higher body, whether it be a university or government. 

The case, as far as the government has disclosed, is predicated on the testimony of one cooperating witness, Harvard Law graduate Daniel Wasserman. In documents obtained by the Washington Free Beacon, editors at the Law Review make note of the racial and educational background of various authors and where their perspective may be limiting or may provide a new angle on a topic.

Interpreting the law is inherently biased, therefore it is necessary to include as many perspectives on a given subject as possible. Choosing to uplift a variety of expert voices, not just one, accounts for more biases and therefore tends to represent more of the people that the law presides over. 

The Law Review boasts an impressive roster of influential alumni including former President Barack Obama and late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, both of whom shaped laws and articulated important decisions in the government to Americans. Obama’s election was not a diversity hire by the American public; he is a gifted speaker and politician that struck home for a majority of voters — twice. It is impossible to know if working on the Law Review specifically propels alumni’s careers, but it is impossible to deny that the Law Review generates highly regarded information and interpretations. 

All publications should have the shared goal of generating the highest quality of content to inform their audience. Publications have an obligation to find the reporters and investigators that understand and can talk about issues clearly. They also have a duty to be thorough and cover a variety of topics within their scope, not just the headlines or titles that are interesting to one type of person. Finding the right writer or speaker to cover a topic is not dependent on if they align with the issue or affected group — it is dependent on their ability to holistically capture a subject matter. 

However, the looming threat of litigation or financial abandonment directed at student publications from the source that funds them tends to silent student voices even further if applied wantonly. The accusations levied against the Law Review and the ensuing investigation hurt the freedom of the press on college campuses and also stifles a voice that supports the system of checks and balances that maintain our democracy. If bias is the root cause of the concern, limiting research and threatening student publications is not the solution.

The post Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications appeared first on Technique.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications

Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications

In late April, the Justice Department (DOJ) initiated an investigation into claims of discrimination against white men at the student-run law journal, the Harvard Law Review, with a hearing now set for July 21. 

The investigation epitomizes President Donald Trump’s yearslong attack on the press for alleged corruption and bias and the administration’s more recent crackdown on higher education. As a top research university, Tech has already felt the effects of federal and state legislation shaping what projects receive funding and how our resource centers are structured. However, Tech is not alone in seeing how systemic change in higher education bleeds into the lives of all Americans.

The Harvard Law Review operates independently of Harvard University and is widely considered the one of the most prestigious law journals in the United States, with high-level courts using articles from the Law Review to support rulings and develop arguments. It is undoubtedly important to investigate and condemn instances of racism and bias when they occur, particularly in fields as impactful as the legal one. 

More broadly speaking, independent student publications, including the Technique, have a responsibility to take claims of discrimination seriously which may lead to biased hiring or reporting. Dually, publication’s independence from university and government oversight without fear of retribution allows them to cover difficult issues honestly and impartially. A publication is only as comprehensive as the voices and subject matters it chooses to present. This issue extends beyond student background; for example, college campus publications must consider club participation, field of study and personal interests when researching for news that impacts their readers.

The federal investigation into The Law Review calls into question the point at which biases are severe enough to require intervention from a higher body, whether it be a university or government. 

The case, as far as the government has disclosed, is predicated on the testimony of one cooperating witness, Harvard Law graduate Daniel Wasserman. In documents obtained by the Washington Free Beacon, editors at the Law Review make note of the racial and educational background of various authors and where their perspective may be limiting or may provide a new angle on a topic.

Interpreting the law is inherently biased, therefore it is necessary to include as many perspectives on a given subject as possible. Choosing to uplift a variety of expert voices, not just one, accounts for more biases and therefore tends to represent more of the people that the law presides over. 

The Law Review boasts an impressive roster of influential alumni including former President Barack Obama and late Supreme Court Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, both of whom shaped laws and articulated important decisions in the government to Americans. Obama’s election was not a diversity hire by the American public; he is a gifted speaker and politician that struck home for a majority of voters — twice. It is impossible to know if working on the Law Review specifically propels alumni’s careers, but it is impossible to deny that the Law Review generates highly regarded information and interpretations. 

All publications should have the shared goal of generating the highest quality of content to inform their audience. Publications have an obligation to find the reporters and investigators that understand and can talk about issues clearly. They also have a duty to be thorough and cover a variety of topics within their scope, not just the headlines or titles that are interesting to one type of person. Finding the right writer or speaker to cover a topic is not dependent on if they align with the issue or affected group — it is dependent on their ability to holistically capture a subject matter. 

However, the looming threat of litigation or financial abandonment directed at student publications from the source that funds them tends to silent student voices even further if applied wantonly. The accusations levied against the Law Review and the ensuing investigation hurt the freedom of the press on college campuses and also stifles a voice that supports the system of checks and balances that maintain our democracy. If bias is the root cause of the concern, limiting research and threatening student publications is not the solution.

The post Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications appeared first on Technique.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Consensus: Federal Probe in Student Publications