When David MacKinnon was still in high school, many people told him that he wouldn’t be able to play Division I sports since he was coming from a small town. Now as a junior in college, he has not only disproved that theory by being able to play one DI sport, but by playing two sports.
MacKinnon is one of the rare two-sport student-athletes in Division I collegiate athletics. What makes him even rarer is that he’s a standout in both sports. The University of Hartford junior stars as the starting goalkeeper on the men’s soccer team and the starting first baseman on the baseball team.
“I was blessed with the ability to play baseball, and I’m good in soccer and I’m good at reacting to the ball,” MacKinnon said. “I have more fun with baseball, but I love soccer too.”
As a freshman, he was named to the All-Conference Rookie Team in both sports, and then as a sophomore, he earned Second Team All-Conference honors once again in both sports. Also as a freshman, MacKinnon was named a New England Intercollegiate Baseball Association All-New England Third Team Selection. He has led the baseball team in multiple categories through his first two full seasons, including key ones such as batting average and on-base percentage.
Out on the soccer pitch, MacKinnon finished his rookie season leading the America East Conference in shutouts with nine, which also set a single-season school record. Currently, he has a total of 19 career shutouts, ranking him tied at No. 3 in school history.
Although the 2015 soccer season saw the men’s team finish last in the conference, the 2013 and 2014 seasons saw the Hawks make it all the way to the America East Championship game, due in part to the stellar defensive play of MacKinnon.
But that wasn’t supposed to be the plan.
MacKinnon was originally only going to play baseball in college. But while taking a recruiting visit to campus, he walked past Al-Marzook Field and the thought crossed his mind that maybe he could play soccer here too. Not taking that thought to heart, MacKinnon committed to the Hawks baseball team before his senior year of high school.
As a senior, MacKinnon showed early flashes of being a dominant soccer defender on his way to being named league player of the year, an All-American and an Eastern Mass All-Star. It was then that Hartford men’s soccer coach Tom Poitras went to check out MacKinnon in the all-star game.
Later discussions between Poitras and Hartford baseball head coach Justin Blood allowed MacKinnon to represent the Hawks on both squads.
But even then, MacKinnon wasn’t expected to be a starter and was only supposed to add depth at the goalkeeper position for the men’s soccer team. Well, it took only took a couple of games before he was tabbed as the Hawks’ starting goalkeeper in just his third collegiate game.
On the field, on the diamond and in the classroom, @dmack1124 is a star for the @HartfordHawks #3Pillars https://t.co/u6YEGW2O0u
— America East (@AmericaEast) March 29, 2016
Baseball has always been MacKinnon’s No. 1 sport, where he feels that he can be more at ease and laid back when approaching the sport.
“I put a lot of pressure on myself in soccer so it’s a lot tougher,” MacKinnon said. “Since I play goalie, it’s more of a focus because if I screw up, the game is kind of on me. There’s so many games in baseball and you get so many at-bats, so one at-bat or one play on the field isn’t going to kill you.”
In the summertime, MacKinnon plays baseball in summer collegiate leagues so he really only gets a few weeks off each year in the winter time. Juggling two sports and academics can be tiring for student-athletes, but MacKinnon has no problem and thinks that the three months he spends playing soccer every year has helped him from not burning out.
“If you’re good at two sports and have a decent head on your shoulders, don’t let people tell you it’s not possible because it is. Just prove them wrong. Stay focused and work hard,” Mackinnon said. “You don’t have to give up your sports until you’re playing at a professional level.”
MacKinnon has his sights set on playing professional baseball, but if he continues to rack up the accolades, opportunities for the next level could open in both sports. Perhaps only then will he have to choose one over the other.