Posted on 19 October 2026.
George Moncaster moved from the United Kingdom to continue his graduate studies at the University of Oregon this year. One week and one day into the term, he stood outside McKenzie Hall protesting the potential sunsetting of the history Ph.D. program, while faculty and deans met inside.
“Myself, but also several of my other colleagues and peers, have moved entire countries to be here, so it is not a small undertaking,” Moncaster, a first-year doctoral student, said. “We made significant sacrifices financially, personally, for the opportunity to be here and study.”
The university is considering program reductions and potentially restructuring across campus due to a $65 million projected deficit in its education and general fund. Final decisions on university department and program reductions will be made at the next Board of Trustees meeting on Dec. 14-15.
Though current Ph.D. students will likely be able to pursue their studies as planned, if the sunset proposal goes through, enrollment would pause or end starting next academic year.
“I feel a little bit kneecapped by the fact that I won’t have people below me that are bringing in fresh ideas and fresh approaches,” Moncaster said.
What are UO’s priorities?
At the Oct. 6 meeting in McKenzie Hall, faculty from the history department and Melissa Graboyes, the director of graduate studies in the Department of History, aimed to make the case for why graduate studies in history aligned with the university administration’s goals.
Chris Poulsen, Tykeson dean of the College of Arts and Sciences, and Bruce McGough, a divisional associate dean of the College of Arts and Sciences, listened to faculty suggestions, according to Graboyes and Ryan Jones, head of the history department. Graboyes said the deans at the meeting were “reasonable” and receptive to feedback.
The priorities for which programs may be sunsetted revolve around recruitment and enrollment numbers, time to graduation, reputation, employment and the interconnectivity of programs.
Graboyes said at the Oct. 6 meeting, the deans mainly focused on the size of the history graduate program –– looking at the viability of programs if the number of students were reduced by 40%.
According to Graboyes, the graduate program –– including both masters students and doctoral students –– has over 30 enrollees, including an incoming cohort of 12 students.
Graboyes said another reason the deans are considering sunsetting the graduate history program in particular is the role graduate students play as employees. For example, history graduate employees do more academic research and less laboratory work than graduate students in the sciences.
Graboyes said history GE labor adds to faculty “research productivity and liveliness.”
“Some of our faculty really did point out that having graduate students does contribute to our research productivity. It does contribute to us staying abreast of intellectual changes in our field and connects us to cutting-edge research,” Graboyes said.
As part of a proposed compromise aimed at saving the program, the department told the deans they would end the master’s program if the department could keep the doctoral program, according to Graboyes.
The vast majority of the Association of American Universities, a group of 71 competitive research institutions, have a doctoral program in history.
Research “confluences” and interdisciplinary work
UO’s goals for streamlining and prioritizing graduate programs, a “working draft” shared by the Office of the Provost, also focus on research “confluences,” or which programs can be paired together to support interdisciplinary work and broad goals.
Though Graboyes said this was not a major focus of the history program meeting, UO lists prioritizing programs based on “confluences” as the first priority.
“The confluences are intended to recognize that research at the University of Oregon spans fundamental discovery, applied work, and scholarship with direct public impact,” a document from the Provost’s Office outlining values stated.
Some of the research confluences listed by the Office of the Provost include a grouping of studies involving biology, psychology and education, while studies involving media, politics, law and economics are also grouped.
“The confluences were developed over the past few months in dialogue with academic leaders across the university, as well as the Senate’s Academic Modification Advisory Committee,” UO spokesperson Angela Seydel said in a statement to The Daily Emerald. “They seek to elevate the unique strengths of the university’s research and teaching in social, fundamental, and applied sciences, and in the arts and humanities, and across our professional schools and colleges.”
Several students pursuing a Ph.D. in history said they also value interdisciplinary goals and think history is an ideal example of an interdisciplinary field.
Michelle Fieser, a fifth-year Ph.D. candidate in art history, traveled from South Carolina to study in Eugene.
“I genuinely wouldn’t have moved all the way across the country if I wasn’t coming for a strong interdisciplinary program,” Fieser said.
Fieser said sunsetting one program at UO could produce a ripple effect, making other programs less competitive. Fieser’s connections with their fellow students, past students, professors and publications in their field has helped them feel like part of a strong academic community.
“A lot of my friends are from the history department … and history is such a fundamental, fundamental part of education in general,” Fieser said. “The fact that this is one of the first programs that is being openly sunsetted is really crazy.”
No official decision has been made on which programs will be phased out.
Taking a step back to focus on the future
UO has highlighted a strategy that groups programs into “Career Communities” to streamline the connection between education and the workforce.
While monetary value is far from the only consideration going into which programs will be reduced, some students like Grant Mongin, an ocean history Ph.D. candidate, feel like UO is “cutting from the bottom” unnecessarily.
Mongin chose to study dam construction and removal and analyze ocean environments over time to look for possible climate change solutions.
“Dam removal is a huge debate but understanding where that starts has massive intellectual contributions, (and) massive financial contributions,” Moncaster said. “I mean determining how people are making these decisions that impact the vast majority of the American West is a big deal.”
Moncaster said historians play an important role by “challeng(ing) modern assertions.”
“I think the assumption might be that other disciplines are more immediately equipped to enter places of work and non-academic work,” Moncaster said. “Environmental historians are uniquely equipped to contribute to current debates, because they have this long view. So we’re able to understand how we’ve gotten to the point that we’ve gotten to.”
The university is not immune to these larger societal goals of education; one priority of the Academic Modification Advisory Committee, which will make reduction recommendations to the university president, is to figure out the “significance” of UO programs “within the history of the University of Oregon and higher education in the United States.”
Moncaster and Mongin think the connection is clear.
“I think sunsetting is one thing,” Moncaster said. “But intellectually I think it is killing off a large part of what being in graduate school is about.”
The post History graduate students and director speak on potential program sunsetting appeared first on Daily Emerald.