Author Archives | Rebecca Barkdoll, Opinion Editor

UnLODEing Zone

What a way to come back from Spring Break, right? I gotta say, I did not see this online thing coming. Part of me is happy about it, part of me is nervous about it and all of me is just weird out by it. I feel wrong-footed.

I’m a little grateful, though. As a person who has already had health issues nearly cause academic problems, I’m relieved to not have to be around so many potential sources for germs. This way, I can stop worrying so much about trying to keep going despite illness and health issues, because I can just do everything from home.

Also, I’ve always loved doing things on my own schedule, so having the freedom to be flexible in how I organize my day is great. Especially since I’m not really a morning person.

But I’m also a little disappointed. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t want to create more opportunities for the virus to spread, so I totally get why we’re pretty much finishing the year online, but I do like the variety that comes with class time.

I tend to be a homebody, especially with all the responsibilities that I need to deal with in my last semester here. But sitting in my house all day gets old, and I don’t usually have the energy to be social after all the homework is done. So it’s nice to have something that forces me to get out of the house but doesn’t mean that I’m ignoring my other responsibilities. I’ll miss that in the weeks ahead.

Plus, sometimes online classes can be a weird sort of difficult. They’re both more tangible and less so. They’re more tangible because they’re always there, almost always accessible. However, because the reminders are online and not being told to you face-to-face, sometimes it’s easier to forget about them or consider them less important. 

I think that’s the weirdest part for me. I like online classes, but I have to go into them knowing that that’s what’s going on. It usually takes me a few weeks to find the rhythm of the classes, and now my whole system just got majorly thrown for a loop. It’s manageable, but it still makes me worry.

What a way to end my college career.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on UnLODEing Zone

The three dramas: death, denial and deceit

I’m gonna start this article with a phrase that some of you might have seen me write several times before (so don’t roll your eyes too much, please): I’ve been watching superhero stories recently. It’s great, as always. But every time I start watching several episodes in a row, I end up noticing something that bugs me. This time, it’s drama.

Now, obviously, life is dramatic sometimes, and superheroes and other action/adventure main characters certainly have to deal with a lot more than normal. But there’s a strange pattern to drama in stories that is more clearly seen in action stories than in pretty much any other genre. It shows itself in three ways: death, denial and deceit.

Death—or more accurately, the plot twist no one is surprised about anymore, we just all hate the writers—is a really easy way for the writers to up the danger stakes. Need to show how deadly the situation is? Kill the sidekick. Need to motivate the hero? Kill the love interest. Need to turn the hero into a bumbling fool so they can’t win easily? Kill the mentor.

Death is very much a part of life, and certainly, people in dangerous situations are going to be surrounded by it more. But you know what I never see? A superhero story where the hero is permanently injured in a way that keeps them from using their abilities on the field. (Characters that have their abilities because of former injuries don’t count for this. Their new normal allows them to be on the field.)

Okay, so yeah, Professor X ends up in a wheelchair, but does that stop him? No. That’s not a bad thing. I love a good story where people aren’t considered useless or ignorable because they have some limitations that others don’t. Actually, we need a lot more of that type of representation.

But why do they still have to be powerful and useful to be important to the story? What about a superhero that has really bad PTSD and can’t fight anymore? Are their team members going to just forget they exist? Can’t they still have a positive influence on their friends and former team members just by existing and interacting with them?

They can, but writers think that’s boring and not interesting enough. Maybe for the people who are only there for the explosions and stuff. But the rest? The ones who are there for the characters, the loyal ones? They’re going to be wondering why it’s death or 100 percent healthy all the time. But in the end, writers kill characters off because they think it keeps people invested, because they think life-or-death conflicts are one of the few conflicts worth talking about.

The second aspect of story drama is always denial. The main character wants something, but for some convoluted reason, denies themselves that thing. This can be great if done creatively. After all, that’s also a very real, common thing to occur. But I’m pretty sure that it’s a higher-than-average rate of superheroes denying themselves a significant other because of dramatic, self-absorbed or insecure reasoning.

Because I’m fairly confident that most people do the exact opposite when feeling that way. There’s this belief in our society that being in a romantic relationship somehow makes us more worthy and special people, which is really messed up.

It also sets us up for abusive, co-dependent relationships because we look to the other person for validation and self-respect. Or, we get so desperate for sort of dynamic that we obsess and chase after someone regardless of their needs or desires (Like celebrities or your hot co-worker. Just stop being creeps, you all).

Denial as a plot device or character arc is great otherwise. Need to wear out a character’s patience? Have them go on a diet because they’re not getting enough veggies, but their best friend works at a doughnut place and always smells like doughnuts. I guarantee you the character is going to either start avoiding the friend when they smell like that or they’re going to break their diet. Which gives the villain places to wreak havoc since the hero can’t go near baked goods without being seriously tempted.

If you’re a writer, have fun with this sort of thing! Don’t just give in to the norm. Trust me, the readers are not interested in the whole “can’t have the girl, want her anyway, will have the girl, she dies.” That’s boring and we’re no longer paying attention. We know the plot, and we know the character arc, and we’re not invested.

The third part of this drama fiasco is deceit. You know the drill. Friends, lovers, family members, whatever, the hero has to keep their identity secret or they have to keep their recent activities secret or they have to keep someone’s heritage secret. The point is, there’s a secret. Someone deserves to know it. They don’t know it—because the hero is trying to be noble or avoid heartbreak.

Again, this is absolutely a thing that happens in real life, so we can’t just say that it should be avoided altogether. However, it needs to be less prominent. I’m pretty sure writers rely on secrets and deceit more than any other plot device in this sort of story. It’s a little less obvious in other genres because the stakes aren’t as high, but it’s there wherever you look. And it’s stupid.

Yeah, everyone has secrets, but not everyone needs to know them. And the people closest to you should absolutely know something that might affect them. You know, like villains targeting them or something. There’s lots of reasoning behind this, like plausible deniability or avoidance of heartbreak. But the former doesn’t mean that they can’t know part of the story, and the latter is likely to happen anyway if you know anything about clichés.

Writers need to get creative with what secrets are around, why they’re not mentioned, and how they may or may not be discovered. Otherwise, all the audience gets is another predictably dramatic tension that we know will end awfully, and we won’t care because we know that it is what it is.

But if writers were able to think for just one second about what would make a reader sit up and take notice, what would make them empathize, they would discover that almost all of their previous attempts have just been patronizing to the portion of the audience that isn’t there for the explosions. And there might be more people in the audience due to loyalty to the story if the explosions weren’t the only semi-unpredictable thing in it.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The three dramas: death, denial and deceit

Voting Inconvience

With all the Presidential debates going on and the primaries just around the bend, I’ve started thinking about how annoying our current system is. I know, I know: it’s a system that’s been in place for years, we’ve got the bugs smoothed out, and all those other reasons people don’t want to think about it except for when their candidate loses. But even if the system is okay, there are ways to make it better.

For example, why do we have to vote on a Tuesday? That’s pretty much the middle of the week and makes it difficult for people to find time to vote since they have to work. For those from lower-income brackets who have to work longer hours, this may mean that they work completely through the entire time voting is available. That’s not equal representation.

Why not make it a Saturday? Yes, there would still be a lot of people who would need to work and might still have to work long hours, but if it’s a weekend, at least a few more would be able to make it.

This leads me to my second thought: Why isn’t election day a national holiday? Why aren’t the primaries considered a state holiday? Some countries do this, like Israel and South Korea. Again, this wouldn’t help everyone, since there would still be businesses open, much like how people still have to work at food places on Labor Day, but it would help a lot of people to have better access to voting.

Or, if people aren’t ready for something so drastic, why not make it so employers have to give their workers a half-day off so that they can go vote? The workers can either work in the morning, afternoon or evening and if they work more than one job per day they should still be able to find some time to go.

Some might argue that it would just be easier for the voting polls to be open longer. Yes, it would be, for the people in charge. But for someone who might have worked a 15-hour shift and has three kids at home that they need to feed and get to bed, standing in line to vote is not what they need. If they had a few hours off before they had to take care of their home responsibilities, then they would be much more inclined to go vote.

Also, there could be a combination of any or all of the above suggestions and it would still be much better than our current system. We don’t have a very user-friendly system and it shows. For example, why don’t we automatically register citizens 18 and older for voting? The only time people would have to take care of it themselves would be if they move to a new voting district. The state of Oregon does something like this and so does Sweden and both have pretty decent voting turnouts.

But here’s my biggest pet-peeve about the voting system: you’re only allowed to vote for one person. That is so limiting and just adds to all the conflict we have about people “not wasting their votes” on third-party candidates who have important things to say. It would be much better to allow a first, second and third choice per political opening.

This way more people would be at least a little happy with the candidate that’s chosen, even if it wasn’t their first choice. I’m betting that we’d also have more cross-party communication since people might be willing to vote second or third for a moderate person from the opposite major party. And fewer party clashes would mean that future representatives might be more willing to listen to their people instead of but heads because of party principle.

See, these aren’t even all of the ways that our voting system could be better. Just look up “voting systems” or some variation like it and see what other countries are doing. It’s really interesting and is a great way to challenge our preconceived ideas of politics. Which is something we really need right now since our political debates too frequently turn into an “us-or-them” mentality. A little listening to others’ opinions is a great way to break that trend.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Voting Inconvience

Voting inconvience

With all the Presidential debates going on and the primaries just around the bend, I’ve started thinking about how annoying our current system is. I know, I know: it’s a system that’s been in place for years, we’ve got the bugs smoothed out, and all those other reasons people don’t want to think about it except for when their candidate loses. But even if the system is okay, there are ways to make it better.

For example, why do we have to vote on a Tuesday? That’s pretty much the middle of the week and makes it difficult for people to find time to vote since they have to work. For those from lower-income brackets who have to work longer hours, this may mean that they work completely through the entire time voting is available. That’s not equal representation.

Why not make it a Saturday? Yes, there would still be a lot of people who would need to work and might still have to work long hours, but if it’s a weekend, at least a few more would be able to make it.

This leads me to my second thought: Why isn’t election day a national holiday? Why aren’t the primaries considered a state holiday? Some countries do this, like Israel and South Korea. Again, this wouldn’t help everyone, since there would still be businesses open, much like how people still have to work at food places on Labor Day, but it would help a lot of people to have better access to voting.

Or, if people aren’t ready for something so drastic, why not make it so employers have to give their workers a half-day off so that they can go vote? The workers can either work in the morning, afternoon or evening and if they work more than one job per day they should still be able to find some time to go.

Some might argue that it would just be easier for the voting polls to be open longer. Yes, it would be, for the people in charge. But for someone who might have worked a 15-hour shift and has three kids at home that they need to feed and get to bed, standing in line to vote is not what they need. If they had a few hours off before they had to take care of their home responsibilities, then they would be much more inclined to go vote.

Also, there could be a combination of any or all of the above suggestions and it would still be much better than our current system. We don’t have a very user-friendly system and it shows. For example, why don’t we automatically register citizens 18 and older for voting? The only time people would have to take care of it themselves would be if they move to a new voting district. The state of Oregon does something like this and so does Sweden and both have pretty decent voting turnouts.

But here’s my biggest pet-peeve about the voting system: you’re only allowed to vote for one person. That is so limiting and just adds to all the conflict we have about people “not wasting their votes” on third-party candidates who have important things to say. It would be much better to allow a first, second and third choice per political opening.

This way more people would be at least a little happy with the candidate that’s chosen, even if it wasn’t their first choice. I’m betting that we’d also have more cross-party communication since people might be willing to vote second or third for a moderate person from the opposite major party. And fewer party clashes would mean that future representatives might be more willing to listen to their people instead of but heads because of party principle.

See, these aren’t even all of the ways that our voting system could be better. Just look up “voting systems” or some variation like it and see what other countries are doing. It’s really interesting and is a great way to challenge our preconceived ideas of politics. Which is something we really need right now since our political debates too frequently turn into an “us-or-them” mentality. A little listening to others’ opinions is a great way to break that trend.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Voting inconvience

Never giving up, never listening to sense

So, I absolutely love analyzing words, mottos, and proverbs and just in the past few days I started thinking about the concept of never giving up. It sounds really cool and admirable. It sounds brave and bold. It sounds like the perfect romantic notion. And if you think about it, it sounds really, really stupid.

See, not giving up is great when it’s something like not letting unemployment keep you from surviving and thriving. It’s great when it’s something like not abandoning a friend who’s going through a dark time and is struggling to connect with others. But there are also times when it’s not great.

For example, if someone says they’re not giving up on the person they love, but their love is actually unrequited, that’s not admirable, that’s called being annoying (at best) or stalkerish(really not good) or downright crazy (really, really bad). I can’t emphasize this enough: if someone turns you down, you don’t keep trying to convince them. They know now, and if they ever change their mind, they can come ask you if you feel the same.

Another example is if you are working really hard at a job or in college but you’re getting really burnt out, sometimes it’s best to take a break. It’s only a temporary giving up and sometimes the break is exactly what you need to set yourself on the right path. Trust me. This is coming from experience.

See, sometimes the way our society handles the concept of never giving up is a little like a person who wants to break a brick wall in one punch, only the brick wall is six feet thick. There’s no way that’s happening before the person permanently injures themselves. They would be crazy to think otherwise. After all, the definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.

We are really bad at this. We’ve absorbed this idea that we must be striving for something 24/7 and that we can’t take a break or choose a different direction without looking like we’re lazy or scared.

But sometimes the strongest things are the ones that are the most flexible and sometimes giving up and changing course is the most courageous thing to do because it shows humility and because it’s heading in a direction we may not know as well.

I’m all for striving for goals and seeing them through even when it’s hard. I mean, one of my life mottos is a quote from Avatar: The Last Airbender, which states “never give up without a fight.” But even in that quote, it doesn’t say that you can never course-correct. It only states that you don’t give up immediately. That’s fine. Sometimes you need to test whether the failure was a fluke or not. But then after that, you learn and you maybe change course.

So let’s all stop being the dramatic, stoic heroes that feel no pain and bend to no foe. We’re not invincible, we’re not always correct and our actions are not always harmless to either ourselves or others. And if giving up and surrendering can make us stronger, make us wiser and make everyone feel safer, then that’s what we need to do. Anything less makes us a coward to peer pressure and the familiar, even if both lead to continued failure.

Never stop trying. But feel free to change whatever it is that you’re trying. It’s life that you shouldn’t give up on. The rest is just flexible details.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Never giving up, never listening to sense

UnLODEing Zone

Ok, the start of this semester has already been a crazy ride of ups and downs and it’s only the third week. That doesn’t really bode well for me and I’m not looking forward to how much worse it could get as I try to graduate on time.

The positive side of the past few weeks has been that two of my classes have some really fun readings. While sometimes it can be time-consuming, I thoroughly enjoy all the short stories and novels that I’ve been reading so far. It’s one of the joys of being an English major.

I also enjoy that some of my co-workers here at the Lode are also in those classes. We have a good time chatting about the readings or about the creative pieces we’re writing. It almost always brightens my day, even if we do end up confusing our other co-workers as they try to figure out how robots are things that we would write about for the Lode (hint: we’re not).

But some of my other responsibilities are really stressing me out. For example, in my last required class for my writing minor, we’re working on a project that I’m having so much trouble understanding and the professor doesn’t give us a lot of detail or adequate warning for some of the steps required for the project. I’ve already almost had three panic attacks in the space of two weeks! Not helpful.

Also, I still haven’t found a job after I graduate, so whatever free time I’ve got is spent searching and interviewing. Not my favorite past time. But it has to be done, and hopefully, it’ll work out sooner rather than later so that I don’t have to deal with it during the last part of the semester. One can hope, right?

Anyway, that’s how weird the semester has been already and it’s barely even started. I don’t like it, but it definitely could be worse. I just have to remember that. Only a couple more months and then I’m done with school for good.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on UnLODEing Zone

Let action movie characters live a little!

So, recently I started the third season of a superhero TV show that I’ve been meaning to watch for ages now. I loved the first season, but life got in the way and I only recently have been able to make time to continue it.

Anyway, even though I’m only a couple episodes in, I already love this season more than the previous ones. It was hard to pinpoint why for a bit, but then I realized that it was because I got to witness the heroes living life. No, I don’t mean like a sitcom or anything like that.

One might ask why the first two seasons weren’t also showing them living. After all, aren’t all characters living? Well, yes, they’re all alive (unless this is a creepy, otherworldly or sci-fi sort of story), but there is a difference between surviving and living.

I often see the first show up in action movies. It makes sense, after all. The Big Bad tends to be after something like world domination, world destruction, universe destruction (looking at you, Thanos) or some other horrible end to a human life (if not humanity as a whole). So, obviously, survival takes precedence.

But people can’t go forever just based on surviving. No matter the situation, people have found ways to create bits of happiness, creativity and other positive, non-essential-to-survival moments. It’s good for the psyche, especially since long-term stress is really bad for us. We need good, frivolous things in life.

But action movies and TV shows don’t show a lot of those moments. Partially because of time limitations, so they have to keep focusing on the plot. But also partially because people are there for the action, not for the “boring” stuff.

But I would argue that it’s the small moments where we get to see people happy or creative or whatever that lets us get attached to their survival. Yeah, we’re going to care whether or not the world’s ending. But we’re going to care more about someone we’ve gotten attached to. The caring is no longer abstract, it’s personal.

A lot of films try to add those human moments, but usually, it boils down to either flirting with a love interest or a few moments with a best friend who eventually dies. That’s pretty limited and pretty boring if that’s all we get.

Marvel did a pretty decent job shaking it up in a couple places, like Tony Stark and Peter Parker or Clint Barton and Natasha Romanov. Close teammates or a mentorship relationship are also important relationships that tend to get reduced to survival. But, I mean, would we have cared so much about the Marvel characters that died or got dusted if we didn’t see how their loved ones grieved? We got to see them happy so we cared when they got hurt.

But even Marvel is more focused on the plot than the characters’ lives (other than how they can advance the plot). This is great for the imagination in a way since it means that I can headcanon a lot of smaller details and not be wrong, but it also means that the only reason I’m as attached to these characters is because I’m reading things where they might not exist because the writers and directors don’t care enough about character development that doesn’t parallel the plot. Which might totally explain why some characters in shows and movies keep doing things that don’t fit with their characters. Because nobody cares. They’re only here for the plot and explosions.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Let action movie characters live a little!