Author Archives | Peggy Li, Opinion Editor

Peggy’s Hot Takes

  1. Spikeball isn’t real exercise and looks really stupid
  2.  Why do the palest guys ever take off their shirts on ankeny as soon as it’s like 59 degrees out
  3.  Low key STEM is super boring
  4.  Netflix just has a lot of mediocre stuff
  5. Half of the people who go here only bought birkenstocks so they could fit in
  6.  Goprint sucks
  7.  Why is there always one random dude who unicycles around
  8.  No one who goes here is actually responsible enough to raise a dog at this point in their life
  9. A lot of dudes take their intramural sport way too seriously
  10. Nobody actually cares what any person’s thesis is about
  11. A ‘thesis’ is literally just a longer than usual essay
  12. All the sororities are more or less the same, regardless of what they tell you
  13. Literally a quarter of our student body is just white dudes with brown hair who have really generic names like
  14. If all the girls named some variation of ‘emma’ suddenly disappeared, the gender ratio would be like 50-50
  15. No one cares if you’re ‘actually’ from Seattle
  16. Does anyone actually know what the word ‘dialectic’ means
  17. Some of the Chinese international students could pay tuition with their outfits
  18. No one actually loves STEM majors
  19. Literally like 5 people actually go through with making their own majors
  20. Everyone threatens to transfer halfway through freshman year but only like 2 people actually do

 

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Peggy’s Hot Takes

Signalling Through Stickers

Sitting in a classroom, I can almost guarantee that at least one person there will have some brightly emblazoned logo on their water bottle, computer or backpack, maybe with the words ‘Patagonia,’ ‘Bernie Sanders’ or ‘Green Dot.’  Some people you know will even have hundreds of stickers piled on top of one another on their possessions in what I think can only be properly described as ‘loud’ signalling. As a member of maybe the one-third of students on campus who eschew such visible displays of affiliation, I can only take wild guesses as to what might lead my peers to participate in such adornment. What really goes into the decision: to sticker or not?

I imagine the first line of defence for those who may feel attacked by such a question is ‘Oh, I had the sticker, why shouldn’t I just use it?’ To which I think, ‘There are so many means to decorate, but you instead choose the sticker.’ The decision ultimately must be a purposeful one, especially as these stickers usually reside on the surfaces of objects with very dear importance to the person. I acknowledge that some people really might sticker willy-nilly without any thought to aesthetics, but I suspect these individuals are in the severe minority compared to those who carefully plan out their projected ‘aesthetic’ on the surface of a computer so that others can understand what kind of person you are based on the stickers. After all, for items that are so visible in class, others are bound to see and make inferences about your character if they recognize the branding of the stickers.

And at the end of the day, isn’t it all about the branding of the stickers? Similarly with clothing, by utilizing stickers, you are, in effect, creating your own personal brand that you are projecting for other people to better understand you. ‘Bernie Sanders’ sticker? Oh, they must be vaguely aware of democratic socialism, and feel quite sad when thinking about the democratic nomination in 2016. But my real issue with that decision to sticker is the implicit shortcut it gives both to yourself and to others in terms of understanding or comprehending character. Obviously a person’s character and personality is so much greater than just their political beliefs or what they choose to project about themselves, but in choosing to sticker one’s possessions with these affiliations, onlookers can so much more easily pigeonhole a person into beliefs they may or may not have.

Sure, stickers can serve as conversation starter, but instead of actually engaging in conversation, I can now look at their possessions for a message I do or don’t agree with, either precluding or pursuing conversation as a result. The stickers eliminate an element of the mystery involved with seeing a person you don’t know, or starting a conversation for the first time. And for the people who choose to sticker relentlessly, I can only wonder what exactly it is that they are trying to say about their personality, and whether they truly know themselves well enough to be putting out a true, dare I say ‘authentic’ version of themselves. Or are they, like anybody else, trying to put out a version of themselves only to hide their own lack of self-knowledge and self-understanding, by instead projecting a protective, superficial layer of branding?

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Signalling Through Stickers

American Tourism in Mexico

In contrast with our President, who built his campaign on building a wall, and making disparaging remarks about mexicans being ‘drug dealers, criminals, and rapists,’ thousands of American tourists, often times college students, will inevitably make their way south of the border, often to Cabo or Cancun. I myself also participated in this quintessential ‘spring break’ experience in sunny Cancun, and later Mexico City, and was left somewhat bewildered. The local people were kind, forgiving of my linguistic failures, and helpful towards a tourist who really didn’t have a clue. They were also, notably, not all drug dealers, criminals, or rapists. My question then becomes, for all the american tourists to mexico who likely had a similar experience as myself, how can they condone such remarks about a country, especially when their experience proves that such a narrative is certainly false?Nathaly Pérez

While I admit my ignorance of Mexican politics and criminal history, it seems that the U.S. and Mexico are bound up in a mutually co-dependent relationship. Not only are the U.S and Mexico tied up in trade alliances, but the largest group of immigrants coming into the United states, by far, comes from Mexico. Mexico is the US’s southern neighbor in the same way Canada is the northern neighbor, but both the treatment and understanding of the two countries could not be more different. The general antagonism towards immigration within the United states as of late be it with regard to language (It’s america, speak english) or with xenophobic remarks like ‘go back to your country’ then makes little sense given the degree to which the U.S depends on foreign labor that is often sourced from mexico, and is itself a nation made up of immigrants. Perhaps the now-tenuous white majority is just fearful of losing their majority status.

However, what I especially don’t understand is how the majority of white voters, who likely can and have gone to mexico for vacation, or have encountered a real, live, mexican person before could have voted for Trump given his remarks. It’s one thing to demonize a hypothetical group of people, but quite another to have friends and know people who are Mexican, people that also have their families in the United States, and think that it’s good foreign policy to ‘build a wall’ making it more difficult for them to visit relatives. Furthermore, there seems to be a shocking amount of hypocrisy involved in going to a country for tourism, being welcomed by many of the people there, but not welcoming those some of those same people in return to one’s own country. And for those same people that proclaim that everyone in American should speak english, I sincerely wonder how much spanish those individuals learned before travelling to Cabo to sip cheap margaritas on the beach.

I can only conclude that those making xenophoic comments must have a different, possibly flawed conception of what America is meant to be. Because in my mind, idealistic as it may be, the United States largely represents a dream of a meritocracy, where those who have a vision, with the capability and ambition to achieve it, come for greater opportunity. Anyone from any country who is willing to work hard, and relinquish their given citizenship for values like democracy, fair play, and hard work can become an American. And for those tout the United States as a ‘white, christian, nation,’ I await impending census data that may show an intermixing of culture and race, shifts in religious beliefs, and the changing of the United States as a country.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on American Tourism in Mexico

Black and Asian Identities and Police Brutality

Although it’s been about two years, I still remember reading about the shooting of Akai Gurley, the indictment of the police officer Peter Liang and the outrage from the Chinese-American community who felt that he had been scapegoated. The case is somewhat unusual in two key respects: the death was accidental, and the officer actually faced indictment. As many news articles about the shooting will tell you, Peter Liang is the first officer in ten years to be convicted for an on-duty shooting in the NYPD, because although shootings certainly happen more frequently than that, through some machinations, the police force is usually able to shield their officers from most consequences. White officers like Darren Wilson or Daniel Pantaleo famously do not face punishment even when the shooting is more akin to murder than accident.

However, the reaction from the Chinese-American community at the time is what most concerned me: many were outraged, believing that Liang had been sacrificed to soothe mounting pressure from the Black Lives Matter movement and the many innocent black individuals killed, and that he should not face punishment since so many white police officers of similar or worse crimes get away entirely. And this reaction, while seemingly understandable, rests upon a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of justice and identity. It’s no secret that Asian-Americans, specifically east Asian-Americans have recently enjoyed privileges not usually extended to other darker-skinned or lower-income minorities: no one is shooting unarmed asian men for selling cigarettes, following them in grocery stores on the presumption of theft or incarcerating them in disproportionate numbers. The systemic racism that exists to the detriment of black Americans simply does not affect east Asian-Americans in the same way.

Yet the misunderstanding of justice seems seems to be fairly simple in this case: the justice system has never been truly fair, and has in fact always been designed for the benefit of white Americans. And at the end of the day, Asian-Americans are not white. The miscarriage of justice to the benefit of white police officers should not have galvanized the Chinese-American community to demand the same privileges, but rather re-examine what’s going on. If anything, the Chinese-American community is acute in seeing that yes, perhaps Peter Liang was a sacrificed to soothe the tensions, but he was sacrificed because he was Asian, and because he wasn’t white. The source of the problem is still white privilege. And the same racism that led Liang to have heightened awareness in the Pink House, and fear of black Americans is the likely the same racism that led to him being offered up, instead of shielded, and led to him being convicted when so many others weren’t. Yet ironically, because of mounting pressure from the Chinese-American community, Liang was only sentenced to probation and community service. No one wins. Asian-Americans, despite their demands, cannot have the privileges of white Americans, and black Americans continue to be killed.

And while these losses are in no way comparable, I think it’s fair to say that moving forward, the best plan of action for the Asian-American community is to remember the past: Asian- Americans were not always the facetious “model minority” and did not always have it as good as they have it now. Complicity in white hegemony and injustice works only as long as the white majority is willing to allow it. At any moment, things could change, and perhaps the exceptionally racist past will come back with a vengeance. One cannot and should not demand privilege that depends on whiteness as it merely serves to perpetuate the pre-existing power structures.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Black and Asian Identities and Police Brutality

Considering the Western Canon in General

You may have noticed it in the course catalog, there is now an offering for ‘East Asian Philosophy,’ where one can learn about the philosophies of Confucius, Mencius or any number of crusty dead Asian men, instead of the usual crusty dead white men. In a twist of irony, one may now imbibe the east Asian equivalent of the western philosophical tradition, where one reads Confucius instead of Aristotle, and learns about Buddhist philosophies in place of Descartes’ proof for the existence of God. Different flavor, more or less the same stuff.

Like traditional western thinking, learning about classic east Asian philosophy texts analogously face some of the exact same problems: few, if any female perspectives, and of course, knowing that sexism certainly must have been prevalent at the time, even if it’s not directly addressed in class or in text. Because for all efforts towards inclusion and diversity, most, if not all works of literature and philosophy before the 1800’s are unavoidably sexist. While there are some exceptional female philosophers like Christine de Pizan, Lady Anne Conway or Hypatia of Alexandria, it is undeniable that the majority of old ‘philosophers’ are male. And even of the female philosophers, they are almost always white, upper-class women; the rare minority who were allowed to be educated, in large part because of their social standing. The problem then becomes, how do we want to think about these philosophers, regardless of heritage, if they are sexist, racist or classist?

Yet, for all of my peers who proclaim their feminism, their intense love of social justice, who sticker their possessions with support for Bernie Sanders, and therefore may not want to take these sorts of classes, I ask you to please give the western canon a chance. Because a large part of why texts like “The Symposium,” or “Genesis,” are required is because of how old the texts are. And due to their age, the subsequent impact on culture, politics and thinking that these works have had is huge. Like it or not, many of the dead white men that we are required to read are part of an intellectual tradition that we unknowingly and possibly unwillingly participate in. It is only because of contingent factors that there were not more female philosophers (many were not allowed to be educated or to publish), whereas we now know that women are unequivocally capable of rigorous intellectual thought, and are just as good as the men. Nevertheless, our arguably patriarchal, racist and imperialist past remains unchanged. In order to gain insight into the present culture we live in, it is imperative we know the historically relevant ideologies that led up to our modern society, even if we don’t agree with their what they had to say.

Even more important than knowing our intellectual heritage in order to gain insight though, is to better understand the western tradition in order to better subvert it’s power over you. One cannot possibly be against western cultural imperialism, if one does not actually know the writers, thinkers and ideas that make up the western tradition. If you are so inclined, learn it in order to better voice your dissent.

Or, if you’re like me and you actually enjoy these classes about dead white (and now, Asian) men, just learn it, and appreciate that many of these writers and these works have universal appeal. You’d be shocked at how similar Confucius and Aristotle are, only furthering some philosopher’s claims at ‘universal truth.’  I certainly enjoy my east Asian philosophy class, and suspect that many Whitman students would also enjoy western philosophy classes if they gave them a chance.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Considering the Western Canon in General

Friendships are closer than they appear

I know that for many Asian Americans, they are caught in what feels like no-man’s land. Growing up, at first they may not understand that they are not the typical ‘American’ until someone rudely awakens them with questions that undermine their sense of belonging. And this issue of ‘belonging’ poses identity issues for the person’s foreseeable future. Peers see us as different from their quintessential ideas of what it means to be really ‘American’ and don’t see you as one of ‘them.’ Yet when I return to China, and other Asian Americans hop on their respective flights to revisit different ancestral roots, we are often not greeted by the sense of homecoming or welcome that one would imagine.

I know that, despite looking just like all the other residents, I am not truly like them, at least not in the ways that really matter. I don’t know the struggles of studying for college examinations or how they use their native social media apps, and my dreams at night are in English rather than Chinese.

This issue of being foreign in both the country you’re born in and the country your ancestors hail from while seemingly unique to second generation American immigrants is actually representative of a larger issue of what it means to ‘belong’ to any culture. Because despite all claims of wanting diversity and meeting new and different people, all evidence seems to suggest that we’d actually much prefer being around people that are just like us.

When I look at my closest, most trusted friends, in some way or another, we have some commonalities that make it easy to get along. Maybe some of my friends are Asian and we can discuss our common experience, or maybe we both grew up in the suburbs and can talk about how exciting that was. Either way, many friendships, in some way or another, are predicated on the idea of being similar. After all, the highest compliment we can bestow upon a friend is that of a family member like brother or sister.

The implication behind ‘family’ is the necessary shared experience of growing up together, or having been through so much together that they truly know you in a way that only those who have been with you from birth can. Yet the problem is brought up when we assume that superficial appearances or culture necessarily define our experience, or that culture defines who we are as people. Because while it is true that I likely will have an instantaneous and special connection with fellow Asian Americans (by virtue of our shared experience, and that initial ‘you look like me’ feeling), that does not preclude the possibility of connections with people that I don’t know as well.

Like many things, the problem is that we take the easy way out, use our eyes to gauge who we might get along with or rely on a safe clique of old friends rather than exploring other new possibilities for friendship. I assumed that I would be unable to make friends in China because of a language and culture barrier, thereby missing out on the chance for a meaningful connection with someone who would have been able to teach me more about life. But, regardless of who you are or where you come from, there are undoubtedly similar experiences, hobbies or even a sense of humor that can be shared and cherished.

While I am sure it has been said more eloquently than what I am about to write, there will always be something to be gained, so long as we are willing to put in effort. When we look past the superficial, there may be the closest friend we’ll ever make waiting on the other side.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Friendships are closer than they appear

Defense of Donald Trump supporters

At Whitman, we often like to believe that everything we do is more aware, more conscious, more reflective and more “right” than the average citizen. We go to college and take classes on a diverse variety of subjects, attempting to “learn to think” in a way that doesn’t   any underprivileged members of society. Yet at the same time, our understanding of the world is no more far-reaching than someone who wasn’t able to attend college, and it is no more objectively correct.

It is not a coincidence that a good chunk of our students hail from private schools in Seattle, Portland and California. We have 40 flavors of students, all vanilla. Yes, I know that I am both generalizing and exaggerating, but the problem remains that, for all we claim to care about with regard to diversity, many of our backgrounds are more or less the same. And arguably because we are so similar in upbringing and ideology, it often times makes us incapable of understanding people with different experiences. After having heard casual conversations throughout this political cycle, and what has been said about Trump supporters, I don’t think this problem has ever been worse.

Casually scroll through Facebook and you’ll see it. “Trump supporters are deplorable, racist and sexist,” or, “If you plan on voting for Trump, please unfriend me right this second.” Many have said that Donald Trump represents a fundamental rift in American society, and that might be true, but what I’ve noticed at Whitman is the knee-jerk, dogmatic rejection of Trump, or anything related to Trump.

Of course it’s very understandable. I also believe that Trump is racist, homophobic and sexist. But the lack of willingness to engage with Trump supporters, to absolutely, unflinchingly and unhesitatingly equate them with the icon who they support seems to a drastic oversight on any of our attempts to be understanding of different backgrounds. We are unthinking in our hatred in much the same way that Trump supporters may be unthinking in theirs.

While waiting in line at Seattle airport, I overheard a Mexican woman explaining her rationale of why she was voting for Trump. I know even telling this story incites an instinctual reaction of, “Oh well she must not know what she’s talking about,” or, “Oh she’s crazy,” but to think that is to fundamentally miss the point because we don’t know why she’s voting for Trump. Just last weekend, I saw a man wearing a Trump for president T-shirt outside Maple Counter. If you were to drive for 20 minutes in any direction, you’ll see the large TRUMP PENCE signs. A lot of students might say, “Well it’s because Walla Wallans are uneducated and racist,” which may be true for some people, but we don’t know that it’s true for everyone. There are those who will say, “There is no good reason to vote for Trump,” but they have just revealed their inability to put themselves in someone else’s shoes. Because what’s actually worth considering is that every person has a different upbringing, and different circumstances that have led them to be the person they are today.

Perhaps the native Walla Wallan votes for Trump because he’s a veteran who just wants his benefits and knows Hillary doesn’t place as much emphasis on the military. Or maybe, there is a recently unemployed factory worker who just wants to feed his family, and thinks that Trump is the better option for what will be best for him. What we shouldn’t ignore is that the majority of Trump’s voting demographic is poor and uneducated, and they arguably are part of the “underprivileged” members of society. Yet, what can we as (largely) privileged college students do? We care for the plight of the underprivileged, but it seems we fundamentally do not understand them on a human-to-human level. There are reasons to vote for Trump, but it seems from our perspective, we simply cannot understand them. We are limited by our experience, and in much the same way that Bernie Sanders’ and Clinton’s campaigns rest on the support of the millennials like ourselves, the Trump campaign rests largely on poor, white, men. Yes, you may not agree with Donald Trump’s Politics, and yes, he may be awful, but I feel that it is our duty as people to at least try and understand where others might be coming from, regardless of race, class and gender.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Defense of Donald Trump supporters