Author Archives | opiniondesk

Transgender students deserve protection

In May of 2016, President Obama informed all public schools in the United States that transgender students must be allowed to use the bathroom that aligns with their gender identity.

This declaration did not carry the same weight as a law, but was justified using Title XI Educational Amendments of 1972. Title XI states that “No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance.”

The Obama administration interpreted sex to include gender identity, and therefore was able to justify the federal guidelines. At this time, many conservatives argued that this was a gross overreach of federal power, whereas liberals rejoiced for this huge win for the transgender community.

Fast forward almost a year, and on Feb. 23, President Trump rescinded this declaration, arguing that this is best dealt with on a state level. Initially, Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos disagreed with this decision because of the harm it might bring to the students. However, faced with the ultimatum of resigning or getting on board, DeVos chose to agree with the action. I’m not entirely surprised by her choice; what else do we expect from an unfit Secretary of Education?

Because these federal guidelines are not law, it forces the question: What does it all mean? The same way that President Obama’s rule was a guideline, so is President Trump’s rule. Public schools can refer to state laws that regulate this issue, or make their own decisions if their state does not have rules. As of now, 14 states have non-discrimination laws that protect transgender students.

Although it seems that transgender students can still have some protection based on where they live, this decision has greater implications for the LGBTQ community. It sends a message that the people in the White House do not protect transgender rights. I struggle to understand people’s concern over letting students use bathrooms that align with their gender identity. As if the life of these students aren’t difficult and confusing enough, now they have to deal with bullying and hate.

People commonly argue that the privacy rights of others are harmed, people fail to understand what it means to be transgender. When a transgender person identifies with a gender, they resemble that gender. If you’re a female, another female using the bathroom doesn’t violate your privacy rights; the same way a female transgender individual using the female bathroom doesn’t violate your privacy rights.

Additionally, the argument about potential assault occurring when people pretend to be transgender is overwhelmingly unsubstantiated. Evidence from the National Center for Transgender Equality, the Human Rights Campaign and the American Civil Liberties Union say “there is no statistical evidence of violence.”

Furthermore, people who want to assault aren’t going to look at these guidelines and suddenly decide they will no longer commit those heinous actions. Regardless of bathroom laws, assault is still against the law.

The true problem isn’t these common, unsubstantiated concerns. Rather, the problem is the underlying construct of what society believes sex and gender are. People constantly show fear toward the things they don’t understand.

As a society, we haven’t made the effort to understand transgender people.

Fariha Jawed is an accounting and political science junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Transgender students deserve protection” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Transgender students deserve protection

Transgender students deserve protection

In May of 2016, President Obama informed all public schools in the United States that transgender students must be allowed to use the bathroom that aligns with their gender identity.

This declaration did not carry the same weight as a law, but was justified using Title XI Educational Amendments of 1972. Title XI states that “No person in the United States shall, on the basis of sex, be excluded from participation in, be denied the benefits of, or be subjected to discrimination under any education program or activity receiving Federal financial assistance.”

The Obama administration interpreted sex to include gender identity, and therefore was able to justify the federal guidelines. At this time, many conservatives argued that this was a gross overreach of federal power, whereas liberals rejoiced for this huge win for the transgender community.

Fast forward almost a year, and on Feb. 23, President Trump rescinded this declaration, arguing that this is best dealt with on a state level. Initially, Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos disagreed with this decision because of the harm it might bring to the students. However, faced with the ultimatum of resigning or getting on board, DeVos chose to agree with the action. I’m not entirely surprised by her choice; what else do we expect from an unfit Secretary of Education?

Because these federal guidelines are not law, it forces the question: What does it all mean? The same way that President Obama’s rule was a guideline, so is President Trump’s rule. Public schools can refer to state laws that regulate this issue, or make their own decisions if their state does not have rules. As of now, 14 states have non-discrimination laws that protect transgender students.

Although it seems that transgender students can still have some protection based on where they live, this decision has greater implications for the LGBTQ community. It sends a message that the people in the White House do not protect transgender rights. I struggle to understand people’s concern over letting students use bathrooms that align with their gender identity. As if the life of these students aren’t difficult and confusing enough, now they have to deal with bullying and hate.

People commonly argue that the privacy rights of others are harmed, people fail to understand what it means to be transgender. When a transgender person identifies with a gender, they resemble that gender. If you’re a female, another female using the bathroom doesn’t violate your privacy rights; the same way a female transgender individual using the female bathroom doesn’t violate your privacy rights.

Additionally, the argument about potential assault occurring when people pretend to be transgender is overwhelmingly unsubstantiated. Evidence from the National Center for Transgender Equality, the Human Rights Campaign and the American Civil Liberties Union say “there is no statistical evidence of violence.”

Furthermore, people who want to assault aren’t going to look at these guidelines and suddenly decide they will no longer commit those heinous actions. Regardless of bathroom laws, assault is still against the law.

The true problem isn’t these common, unsubstantiated concerns. Rather, the problem is the underlying construct of what society believes sex and gender are. People constantly show fear toward the things they don’t understand.

As a society, we haven’t made the effort to understand transgender people.

Fariha Jawed is an accounting and political science junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Transgender students deserve protection” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Transgender students deserve protection

A return of “real news” will take the Fairness Doctrine

The Fairness Doctrine is a tricky subject in American history.

The passage of the Communications Act of 1934 created the Federal Communications Commission. The FCC was established as the government authority that grants broadcast licenses. At the time, it was thought that there were only so many airwaves on which a radio or television station could operate. Therefore, the FCC was under the obligation to protect the public interest when granting licenses.

This became known as the Fairness Doctrine, which formalized, in a Commission Report, requiring licensees to spend time on controversial issues and to express contrasting views on the matter. The requirement was upheld by the Supreme Court and later repealed by the acting FCC chairman under President Reagan.

On the one hand, the requirements definitely attempted to control the broadcasters’ speech, which, if viewed as content-based requirements, is an infringement on First Amendment rights when viewed under strict scrutiny. On the other hand, the television and radio industries (both fall under the term “broadcasters”) have only grown more consolidated with higher barriers to entry than ever before.

The consolidation of the media industry has created a notion that cross-device outlets are synonymous with their broadcasting counterparts. However, there is a distinction. Broadcast outlets operate for free; this provides broadcasters the ability to reach a large audience.

The infrastructure needed to provide free content to the public across a city or even the entire nation is vast and expensive; it is so vast and expensive that, while the technological scarcity of the airwaves argument is no longer feasible, the barriers to entry ensure the airwaves are as scarcely populated as possible.

Since its abolishment, the Telecommunications Act of 1996 replaced the Communications Act of 1934, and the rest is history. A history that consists of media oligopolies, extreme political polarization and a struggling “public” broadcasting system.

With the recent push against major news outlets from the White House, it appears that it is time to establish a broadcasting standard for the public. If belief-affirming news sources have been deemed “fake” by the executive branch of the government, a codified communications standard should exist to compare broadcasters’ (or media outlets at large) operations with the interests of the public.

At what point do we consider broadcasters’ speeches commercial speech? The majority of broadcasters’ parent companies are for-profit organizations that are constantly advertising their offerings and transmedia storytelling platforms on their programming.

“You can follow us on Twitter at…” and “make sure to download our app…” are blatant advertisements for products that generate revenue and often mark the segue into a commercial break, ironically.

If the Fairness Doctrine’s First Amendment infringement was viewed under intermediate scrutiny, like many commercial speech cases, the unconstitutionality of the provisions of the Fairness Doctrine would not be as easy to distinguish.

The executive branch has made a hard stance on its preference of media outlets. To have a truly active marketplace of opposing viewpoints is an ethos aligned with the public. To have a truly active marketplace is the ethos aligned with a corporation. The two should not be misaligned together.

The relatively small group of broadcasters in the United States are beholden to corporate interests. If we truly want an ebb and flow of ideas, some sort of stopgap measure needs to be implemented for the structural basis of presenting opposing ideas across broadcasting outlets. That is, if the brandishing of news outlets as “fake news” that create false narratives of the executive branch is the main concern in the first place.

Otherwise, my concern is that the executive branch is beholden to corporate interests that create the fourth branch of the government.

Opinion columnist Nicholas Bell is an MBA graduate student and can be reached atopinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“A return of “real news” will take the Fairness Doctrine” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on A return of “real news” will take the Fairness Doctrine

A return of ‘real news’ will take the Fairness Doctrine

The Fairness Doctrine is a tricky subject in American history.

The passage of the Communications Act of 1934 created the Federal Communications Commission. The FCC was established as the government authority that grants broadcast licenses. At the time, it was thought that there were only so many airwaves on which a radio or television station could operate. Therefore, the FCC was under the obligation to protect the public interest when granting licenses.

This became known as the Fairness Doctrine, which formalized, in a Commission Report, requiring licensees to spend time on controversial issues and to express contrasting views on the matter. The requirement was upheld by the Supreme Court and later repealed by the acting FCC chairman under President Reagan.

On the one hand, the requirements definitely attempted to control the broadcasters’ speech, which, if viewed as content-based requirements, is an infringement on First Amendment rights when viewed under strict scrutiny. On the other hand, the television and radio industries (both fall under the term “broadcasters”) have only grown more consolidated with higher barriers to entry than ever before.

The consolidation of the media industry has created a notion that cross-device outlets are synonymous with their broadcasting counterparts. However, there is a distinction. Broadcast outlets operate for free; this provides broadcasters the ability to reach a large audience.

The infrastructure needed to provide free content to the public across a city or even the entire nation is vast and expensive; it is so vast and expensive that, while the technological scarcity of the airwaves argument is no longer feasible, the barriers to entry ensure the airwaves are as scarcely populated as possible.

Since its abolishment, the Telecommunications Act of 1996 replaced the Communications Act of 1934, and the rest is history. A history that consists of media oligopolies, extreme political polarization and a struggling “public” broadcasting system.

With the recent push against major news outlets from the White House, it appears that it is time to establish a broadcasting standard for the public. If belief-affirming news sources have been deemed “fake” by the executive branch of the government, a codified communications standard should exist to compare broadcasters’ (or media outlets at large) operations with the interests of the public.

At what point do we consider broadcasters’ speeches commercial speech? The majority of broadcasters’ parent companies are for-profit organizations that are constantly advertising their offerings and transmedia storytelling platforms on their programming.

“You can follow us on Twitter at…” and “make sure to download our app…” are blatant advertisements for products that generate revenue and often mark the segue into a commercial break, ironically.

If the Fairness Doctrine’s First Amendment infringement was viewed under intermediate scrutiny, like many commercial speech cases, the unconstitutionality of the provisions of the Fairness Doctrine would not be as easy to distinguish.

The executive branch has made a hard stance on its preference of media outlets. To have a truly active marketplace of opposing viewpoints is an ethos aligned with the public. To have a truly active marketplace is the ethos aligned with a corporation. The two should not be misaligned together.

The relatively small group of broadcasters in the United States are beholden to corporate interests. If we truly want an ebb and flow of ideas, some sort of stopgap measure needs to be implemented for the structural basis of presenting opposing ideas across broadcasting outlets. That is, if the brandishing of news outlets as “fake news” that create false narratives of the executive branch is the main concern in the first place.

Otherwise, my concern is that the executive branch is beholden to corporate interests that create the fourth branch of the government.

Opinion columnist Nicholas Bell is an MBA graduate student and can be reached atopinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“A return of ‘real news’ will take the Fairness Doctrine” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on A return of ‘real news’ will take the Fairness Doctrine

Focus Friday: How should we address US life expectancy on decline?

Life expectancy in the U.S. is falling. Why do you think this is? And how should we fix it?

Life expectancy declines can be attributed to a variety of things. First of all, the retirement age is on the rise. This means more people are working for larger portions of their life. This can be especially detrimental in job sectors that require physical labor. As Americans, we can increase our life expectancy by making it more affordable to visit the doctor and making it easier to afford retirement. Making it easier to retire doesn’t even mean reducing the age, or anything like that. It can be as simple as educating more Americans on how to be financially responsible. We should also examine the countries that are at the top of the longevity indexes and see what they do that is different from us to see if there are any practices that can be adopted.

Opinion editor Thomas Dwyer is a broadcast journalism sophomore and can be reached atopinion@thedailycougar.com.

Life expectancy in the United States is falling because of the unhealthy foods we consume and the inordinate amount of stress that comes from working, on average, more than any other developed nation on Earth. The United States is the most obese developed nation on Earth, while also being the most overworked developed nation on Earth. This combination of an unhealthy diet with an over-stressed workforce tends to lower the life expectancy of the population. The article also mentions drugs, alcohol and suicide as contributing factors to the declining life expectancy rate. These factors are also a result of overworked and  stressed people, as drugs and alcohol are used, in some part, to alleviate suffering or stress. While the United States has an abundance of resources, wealth, and prosperity, the work-related stress and our diets are decreasing the quality and quantity of our lives.

Opinion columnist Adib Shafipour is a biochemistry sophomore and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

A drop in life expectancy was always coming. Good and easy times create weak people who have a lot of free time, especially with the rise in life-easing technology. We’ve had to learn to adapt, and we still are. What are the appropriate uses of technology in correlation with a healthy life? This is something we still need to figure out as a society.

Along with that, we have ascended to a point where food is available and cheap. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing; more people are eating. But with that we’ve created extremely unhealthy food that is extremely cheap. But, as Ron Swanson wonderfully articulates, that’s the point.
It’s pretty easy to understand how we got here, but it’s more difficult to figure out how we get out of this slump (even though I like to pretend I have all the answers). Maybe it’s a societal thing; maybe it’s a personal thing. But honestly, everything is a cycle. We’ll go back up soon enough.

Assistant opinion editor Jorden Smith is a political science and creative writing junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Focus Friday: How should we address US life expectancy on decline?” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Focus Friday: How should we address US life expectancy on decline?

SGA presidential candidates unprepared for questions not involving platforms

The SGA Presidential candidates face off in a heated debate for the votes of studetns | Justin Cross/The Cougar

Winni Zhang of the Spirit RED party, Robert Comer of the Vote for MEME party, Jordyn Chaffold of the House of Innovation party and Shawn Bhatia of the REDvolution party had a bout of rhetoric and campaigned for almost three hours on Feb. 22 during the SGA presidential debate.

Zhang had the biggest shift in strategy over the course of the debate. Though she was poised, factual and strong in her platforms, she quickly turned that into a crutch, and her delivery was stoic in the beginning.

In the first round, The Cougar’s managing editor Alex Meyer asked, “What is the biggest struggle current UH students face?” She immediately tied it into alleviating textbook prices, which is one of her platforms. She claimed that she surveyed 30 students and that is how she came up with that platform idea.

With one of these issues afflicting a small sample size of the those present, it showed in the crowd: whenever textbooks were mentioned, you could feel the energy shift to apathy and confusion because the students in the room seemed to not consider that their main issue.  

Zhang slowly started to have a change offense as the round went on. Chaffold fact-checked Zhang about her CAPS relocation initiative, but she rebutted with her extensive knowledge on her platforms. Every time one of the candidates would shoot follow-ups at her, she was always ready and could quickly come up with a strong, clear answer.

In the second round, she started to add passion and personality in her answers, which helped her become more personable and get positive responses from the crowd.

Definitely the most comical of the candidates, Robert Comer was the black sheep of the debate. If you only knew him for his campaign, then you would think he was a joke. With a Facebook page filled with memes, as the representative of the VoteforMeme party, his platforms included filling the campus fountain with gelatin and making it illegal to wear other schools’ paraphernalia.

However, he still had some more serious issues he wanted to solve. He spoke on creating an online advising tool to make academic advising more efficient and also give students more campus resources to help with post-graduation plans. With his extensive experience in SGA and leadership roles, he had clearer goals based on how SGA works to put initiatives in motion.

This is not to say he didn’t have downfalls. With his humor came issues. At times, he would use it at inappropriate moments or when he couldn’t formulate a serious answer. However, Comer was one of the candidates who finished the strongest when asked how to go about getting the fountain fixed. His response was for the students to “actually sit inside” the empty fountain in a form of protest, which, honestly, isn’t a bad idea.

The most energized of the candidates was Jordyn Chaffold. Through most of the first round, he was a ball of energy and exuded charisma. He was the first one to challenge one of the other candidates on their platforms, and his main strength was how involved he was with the masses of students. He himself is involved in numerous organizations and is one with the student body.

He pushed a rhetoric of transparency with SGA and gave a good plan on how to do so. He wanted to do a version of FDR’s “fireside chats” weekly on updates with his administration. This is perfect because media is the quickest and most convenient way to connect with this generation of students. Like the other candidates, his strength, when overused, was his Achilles’ heel. Every answer, he brought back to his vast knowledge of the student body.

This is an important asset, but with no mention of other skills it comes across as a one-trick pony. Also, he consistently asked for the questions to be repeated. This shows that he was not paying attention and the audience definitely noticed that. If you aren’t listening during a debate, it won’t make the students feel like you are listening to them.

Lastly, Bhatia was the most “presidential” of the candidates. He boasted an impressive résumé of governmental experience in and outside of school. He also was questioned early in the debate by two different candidates on the same question, but was poised, showing prowess.

However, this rattled him; it made him reclusive for the rest of the debate. A lot of the questions he fumbled or didn’t directly answer at all, especially when it came to the student leader questions. He was just not memorable from that point on and that definitely hurt his campaign.

There are a few main points that all of the candidates struggled with. The second round were questions from and by student leaders. Wesley Okereke from the NAACP, Kadidja Kone from the Black Student Union, and even incumbent SGA President Shane Smith all asked questions. These leaders were not playing around. Their questions were specific and also outside of the candidates’ platforms.

The most notable came from Okereke when he asked how they would make SGA seem like they are needed by the students. He expressed his grievances about how his organization made a lot of accomplishments without them and didn’t “feel a need” to have them. The candidates had a hard time explaining their role and when they would “Conway” a question, he had no problem herding them back in.

This was all of their downfalls.

They struggled heavily with any questions outside of their own campaigns. SGA President Smith had individual questions for them, and he chewed them up. His carefully crafted questions and his cunningness with his words picked them apart and showed why he is the current president.

Lastly, there was a lot of talk about diversity, inclusion and relations among underrepresented groups. Everyone generically spoke on diversity and that inclusion needed to be the topic of conversation. That is fine and dandy, but the real issue isn’t inclusion. It’s visibility.

Even though UH is a special case where white students aren’t the majority, there still seems to be a stigma that minority problems are just one singular issue that is faced by all. This is not the case. There are specific needs that blacks, Latinx, Asians, Muslims, LGBTQIA+ and even handicapped students have. And when everything is lumped together, it makes it seem like everyone is covered over one blanket that isn’t comfortable for anyone.

The one thing is if any of these candidates can get their platforms pushed in office, then the school will be in the right hands. They are extremely sound in what they are campaigning and show genuine passion.

As the people they serve, we must do our part in raising our voices, singularly and as a unit, and hold them accountable for their actions, while also meeting them halfway.

Opinion columnist Dana Jones is a print journalism junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“SGA presidential candidates unprepared for questions not involving platforms” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on SGA presidential candidates unprepared for questions not involving platforms

In honor of Black History Month

Even before my consciousness grew, there was an annual time when I felt a bit more important.

February was the first time I saw myself. Whether it was in curriculum, movies, books or poetry, I felt less alone during my time in suburbia. My skin became a topic of conversation; us black kids bonded with each other, and we became accepted through stories on pages that looked like us.

But after the 28th day, and sometimes the 29th, the black ink in books turned white and we black kids turned back into gifted statistics. It wasn’t until I knew the culture behind my skin that I realized Black History Month meant so much more outside of these 28 days.

I saw the white customer curse my name from across the cash register. He thought me below the poverty bar until my white manager diffused the racial time bomb.

The basis of the plight of black people tends to be tied to the vast net of systemic racism. This is specific from the broader term of racism. Racism is not mutually exclusive to a specific group of people. It gets dangerous when some benefit from racism and can hurt others. It is embedded into the crux of society and is the fabric of what America is built on.

Equality is more than just having token black diversity cards for photo ops. It is more than just claiming affirmative action as a cure for the cancer that is racism.

It is having everyone on the same playing field. It is about not having colors of skin associated with crime. More importantly it starts with admittance that a problem exists.

Lunch tables acted as sound boards that my bones could make symphonies from that my white classmate imitated and the classroom loved him for it.

As young as seven, I learned that the things black people created were popular to many. Now, I am aware that popular culture is progressed from the creation of black people.

Music, the recycling of black actors, sports, hashtags, and even memes have a unruly notoriety after being festered through black social circles. The issue is not from the praise of other cultures for what we can do.

The issue is knowing the difference between appropriation, appreciation, and adaptation. Justin Timberlake is an example of adaptation. With the help of black producers, he put his own spin on the R&B genre and always acknowledged where the sound came from.

Appreciation is simply enjoying the culture and understanding the origins. What makes these a non-issue is the acknowledgement of the origin. The appropriation comes in when culture is stolen. The deeper issue is when the stolen culture is then used to gain profit. The everlasting task is trying to find that line between appreciation and appropriation when the line continues to be blurred.

I lived on the outskirts of what black was supposed to be.

Growing up, I always felt strange. I felt not black enough.

I listened to a wide range of music, I wasn’t into sports besides soccer and I was the only one in my school who made films. I was looking for my blackness to be validated by other black students and the notion of of white students claiming that I wasn’t “that black” confirmed my thoughts.

It wasn’t until I went to an HBCU that I saw that there are black band members, painters, poets, movie buffs, etc. The stigma of one type of black is told through media that we are forced to see.

There were strangers loving each other as if they were kin. It was safe among the congregation.

The church is more than just a place of worship in the black community. It gives strength and the hope that the circumstances will be better.

Many black people have stories involving their church. This is a place of unrelenting support and love on a level deeper than sympathy. It’s understanding rooted in the same way of life. This is why pastors are so favored. They speak specifically to a certain kind of person. With all of the people in there having similar nuances, everyone can relate as a whole.

This is why many times the black church has been attacked. It is not a coincidence, it is strategic. These domestic terrorists know the politics that reside in churches and their plan is to destroy from the base. Church is a place where safety is never questioned.

With attacks like Birmingham and Charleston, an attempt to crack that safety is made.

In the fight for black progression, we cannot move forward without everyone.

At the bases of black liberation, there have always been groups that aren’t given appreciation. Namely, queer blacks.

People like James Baldwin, Langston Hughes, Bayard Rustin and Marsha P. Johnson were beyond instrumental in awakening the black mind. They advocated both for black rights and at the time LGBT rights but didn’t get their recognition if they were open about their sexuality.

Johnson was the one of the first people to fight back during the Stonewall riots. When I learned of this event, Johnson was never mentioned. Not until I did research on the altercation did I find how instrumental she was in the act of liberation. Rustin was the strategist in the March on Washington and acted as Martin Luther King’s adviser.

As much as we have read and heard about MLK, why was his right hand man never mentioned? Queer blacks fight just as hard for black progression — if not harder — because they are fighting two fights at once.

My mother showed me the kind of love so unconditional that it was godly.

Black women are both the most sacred and most disrespected entities of black culture. Yet they serve as the backbone of everything concerning revolution, intellect, and progression.

Blackness cannot survive without women. They bring the life, yet their purpose is questioned and marginalized. Dorothy Dandridge, Shirley Chisholm, Maya Angelou, Michelle Obama and even Beyoncé are some of the most prominent figures in U.S. history, not only for black women, but for people in general. Often, because of their color and gender, their accomplishments are overlooked or downplayed.

For instance, one of the most dominating athletes is Serena Williams. There is never recognition or even notable talk about her being the greatest player ever. Maya Angelou is never considered as one of the greatest contemporary writers. Madame C.J. Walker hardly gets talk of showing what it means to be a self made boss and creating billions of dollars out of nothing.

Black women have done wondrous and remarkable things and it’s time they should be recognized, at least in their own communities.

The state of blackness is complex and forever changing and evolving. The fight for equality and a better standard of life will always be at the core. Whether one day we fight for gay rights, transgender rights, representation, or just the uplifting of black people as a whole, we must do it collectively.

Opinion columnist Dana Jones is a print journalism junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“In honor of Black History Month” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on In honor of Black History Month

Melania Trump’s libel suit is an abuse of status as first lady

 

Earlier this month, first lady Melania Trump refiled a libel lawsuit against Daily Mail, a British newspaper. This action followed the first lady’s settlement on a previous libel lawsuit against a Maryland blogger, Webster Tarpley.

In August 2016, Tarpley published an article that claimed Trump worked for modeling agencies as an escort in the ’90s. Tarpley issued an apology to the Trump family and is paying the Trumps for damages. The Daily Mail published a similar story, which led the first lady to refile the suit in New York.

Trump’s libel lawsuit is unprecedented because no president or first lady have ever filed such a suit. However, this isn’t the strange part about the suit. Her attorney isn’t arguing any damages to Trump’s personal reputation, but rather her financial position.

The lawsuit claims that Trump has a “unique, once-in-a-lifetime opportunity to launch a broad-based commercial brand in multiple product categories, each of which could have garnered multi-million dollar business relationships for a multi-year term during which Plaintiff (Trump) is one of the most photographed women in the world.”

Trump should not use her position as first lady to further her own personal and financial interests. First ladies before Trump have shown humbleness and respect for their position, and with these words, Trump seems to have disregarded her position.

Furthermore, since the landmark Supreme Court case of New York Times Co. v Sullivan, a strict standard has been in place for public figures claiming defamation. Trump’s position as first lady puts her in the public spotlight and unless her attorney can prove that there was malice and an absolute disregard for the validity of the statement, Trump should not be allowed to collect $150 million in damages.  

Since the suit was filed, Trump has received criticism for the statement, and her attorney has been quick to claim that her words were misinterpreted. However, her attorney fails to explain what the statement did mean. There aren’t many ways to interpret such a straightforward statement. Trump’s position as first lady puts her in the spotlight, and this would be an opportunity for her to expand her brand.

Although the trial will not be held until Nov. 6, it seems that Trump has already displayed a conflict of interest. Only time will tell how this will play out.

Fariha Jawed is an accounting and political science junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Melania Trump’s libel suit is an abuse of status as first lady” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Melania Trump’s libel suit is an abuse of status as first lady

Socialist Sanders could never defeat Trump

Bernie Sanders has some of the best press in the country—not just for a politician. Every time he’s mentioned, the “he would have beaten Trump” line that has become so commonplace in after-election analysis immediately follows. Everyone and their mother seems to hold this line of thinking; it’s almost blasphemous to even mention Sanders wouldn’t have beaten Trump.

So I’m going to commit blasphemy: Trump would’ve easily beaten Bernie.

It’s really not that crazy of a theory. Just because someone is a purportedly honest, sweet old man doesn’t mean he wins automatically. He has his issues.

A bad label

The clearest and most important reason for why Bernie wouldn’t win can be summed up in one word: socialism. And yes, Bernie advocated for “democratic socialism,” which just means that people vote for socialism; it’s still socialism. Just because there is no forcible takeover doesn’t mean it’s not socialism.

(Now, a discussion on the over-praising of socialism is for a different column on a different day.)

It’s about how people would perceive “democratic socialism.” You can forget about the “democratic” part of “democratic socialism” pretty quickly. No one would remember that after the Republican marketing strategy.

The Republicans never treated Bernie as a threat in the primary season. No matter people believed that he was actually going to win the primary, he never would have. Even without the superdelegates, Sanders still lost by about 500 delegates. There was no reason for Republicans to really attack him; they focused all the money on hurting the big dog, Hillary Clinton.

If there had actually been a focused ad campaign on Bernie, it wouldn’t have ended well. Everything would revolve around socialism:“Do you want a socialist in the White House?”

Even if people hated Trump, they still wouldn’t vote for Bernie because of the socialist label. He would lose 60 percent of the country right out of the gate. And the same is true with Democrats. Sure, he would’ve initially had support, but once things got hard, they would’ve run for safer ground.

Even the Midwest working vote would’ve run for the hills. Their bread and butter is industry, and they don’t want the government taking that over. 

Instead of Ohio Gov. John Kasich getting some votes, it would’ve been Hillary getting those votes from Democrats.

No foreign policy

Bernie is also really bad on foreign policy. The fact is Democrats lose on foreign policy nine times out of 10. It’s not that Republicans’ plans are necessarily better, but Republicans know how to frame those issues in a different way. Bernie does not—at all. He has his talking points, and they usually revolve around the economy and how to fix it.

He’s great at talking about the economy for hours. But foreign is not his strong suit; ask him to talk about foreign terrorism and he’ll tie it back to the 1 percent and the greed of capitalism. That’s not necessarily a bad thing. South Carolina Senator Lindsey Graham was great at tying everything back to ISIS in the Republican primary debates, and it worked for him (to an extent).

But that is not good for an actual presidential debate. There are whole sections (and sometimes entire debates) dedicated fully to foreign policy. If Bernie would have tied it back to the economy, at some point, the moderator would’ve gotten tired of it and called him out.

That’s fine in the primaries, but once you get to the real debates, you better have some real answers. 

Disconnect with average voters

Lastly, Bernie can’t talk to real people. He’s good at talking those who already agree with him—namely, young, white voters—but not anyone else, especially small business owners.

Take this example from his CNN Town Hall. A small business owner questioned him on Obama-era regulatory policy. Bernie’s response engaged him in a fight with the owner who’s actually on the ground dealing with the policies Bernie was disputing. To Bernie supporters, this was a great spat; support more regulatory policy and hit the 1 percent. To everyone else, this looked like a politician telling a struggling business owner he’s not struggling.

Then there was his response to a salon owner at his debate with Ted Cruz. Whether you agree with him or not that the woman should go out of business, that’s not how anyone, especially someone running for office, should respond to someone.

So Bernie Sanders is the cute, truthful old man who birds are in love with. None of this means he’d have actually defeated Trump. He breaks down easily, and he’s not as easy to support as people make it seem. Continue with the narrative if necessary, but at least be honest: there’s no way he would’ve won.

Assistant opinion editor Jorden Smith is a political science and creative writing junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Socialist Sanders could never defeat Trump” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Socialist Sanders could never defeat Trump

SGA election party platform breakdown

There are four parties each represented by a presidential and vice presidential candidate competing for your vote in this year’s Student Government Association election.

The following columns will analyze each party and the initiatives they plan on undertaking as well as the feasibility of the initiatives. For the sake of fairness and from the perspective of a typical student, all information was gathered from social media and the vice presidential debate that was hosted by CoogTV on Thursday. The presidential candidate debate will be on Wednesday.

What follows are my own personal opinions about each party in the election and issues that I see with each platform and their candidates.

Jordyn Chaffold | Jasmine Davis/The Cougar

The House of Innovation party is spearheaded by presidential candidate Jordyn Chaffold and vice presidential candidate Farah Islam.

Right out of the gate, Islam is a vital asset to the success of this party. She has extensive knowledge about fee-funded organizations due to her time as the vice chair of the Student Fees Advisory Committee. That knowledge proved to be essential during the debate, especially when she corrected REDvolution VP candidate Seth Crawford multiple times.

Another positive quality, while also potentially negative, is that the party is composed primarily of members that have not had an affiliation with SGA. Chaffold currently holds the post of Special Adviser for Campus Diversity. This allows the party to have an outsider’s perspective to the entire campaign and also stand out as a party of common students.

The party’s weakest point is its platform. Instead of having initiatives to focus on, the party has ideals that it wants to apply to their administration if elected. As Spirit RED vice presidential candidate Adrian Hernandez said in the debate, “Attributes aren’t going to affect the student body; it’s the projects that we work on.”

House of Innovation needs to have more ideas for its administration than just to improve student-SGA relations if elected. Their main goals are to change the way SGA interacts with the student body in an effort to draw more students into the organization, as well as have students become more involved and knowledgeable about it.

On social media, the party does a decent job. It replies quickly to inquiries, according to Facebook.

Islam barely snagged the lead in The Cougar’s poll asking followers who they thought won the debate. Chaffold will have to use his knowledge from the four committees he is on in order to maintain his party’s position as a front runner in the debate poll.

Shawn Bhatia | Jasmine Davis/The Cougar

REDvolution, led by presidential candidate Shawn Bhatia and vice presidential candidate Seth Crawford is focusing its platform on affordability, accessibility and diversity for the student body.

Both candidates are heavily involved through multiple facets of the school and its organizations. However, as Farah Islam of the House of Innovation party showed them during the vice presidential debate, perhaps the party is not as familiar with the school and the way it operates as it should be.

The platform chose to stagger the release of its platform as the election draws nearer. A better tactic would have been to release the entire platform when they started and then focus on specific details of it and explaining them as the election nears. That way, students who wanted to know more about it would not have to be searching for an entire picture and only get fragments of it.

The party is also advocating freezing or reducing mandatory student fees. The bulk of mandatory fees go back into student organizations. Reducing the amount fees come in would only make it harder for student organizations to secure funds for their endeavors.

A better idea may be to make some fees — for example, the recreation fee — optional. That way, students who wanted to use the Rec would pay for it, and students who did not want to use it would not be forced to pay for something that does not benefit them.

REDvolution has a lot of potential with Bhatia and Crawford at the helm. They cannot afford to squander any of it. In The Cougar’s poll asking followers who won the VP debate last week, Crawford was trailing Farah Islam of the House of Innovation party by a mere 3 percent.

Winni Zhang | Courtesy of SpiritRED

Spirit RED is headed by presidential candidate Winni Zhang and vice presidential candidate Adrian Hernandez. The party’s main initiatives are to improve parking, health services and textbook prices.

These are all good things to want to improve upon (especially health services). However, there are no actual plans outlined for them anywhere on their social media that explain how exactly the party plans on taking care of any of those initiatives.

The party website contains explanations of the things Zhang and Hernandez want to improve, but has no real description of how the changes are going to be made. For example, the website states that the party wants to move CAPS from its current location “to a nicer facility.” Where is this facility? Is it already built? If so, is it vacant? These are all important questions that must be addressed.

The only information found on any of their social media was about textbooks, and it was about something that SGA has already been doing: lobbying the state government for open source textbooks. Lowering textbook prices will most likely not be something that the student body will ever be against in the future.

The party and its members do bring several strengths to the table. Zhang and Hernandez, along with several students running in their party, are incumbent members of SGA. Zhang is the current Deputy Chief of Staff and Hernandez is the senator for the Hilton College of Hotel and Restaurant Management. This is important because it means that they are already familiar with the system as well as all of the committees overseen by it.

One potentially unethical quality about the party is that they inherited and repackaged former party Project Red’s Facebook page, and with that, all the people who were subscribed to Project Red’s page.

According to the poll hosted by The Cougar on Twitter, Hernandez was the third best performing candidate from the vice presidential debate hosted by CoogTV.

In the presidential debate on Feb. 22, Zhang must hold her party down against SGA Chief of Staff and VoteforMeme candidate Robert Comer.

Robert Comer | Julia Araica/The Cougar

Right out of the gate, VoteforMeme has the best social media and outreach presence out of any of the parties it’s running against. The memes are dank and also hit close to home for many students at the University.

Robert Comer has experience as the Chief of Staff in the current SGA administration. This means he has extensive experience with SGA and how it does business.

However, his vice president, True Furrh, shows inexperience. This is understandable because he is a freshman. Because of this fact, Comer will have to put in extra work to support his party.

Back to the memes that the platform is run on: the platform is composed of 16 initiatives. Of those, some are feasible, like playing more Houston rap during football games. The rest, like filling the currently empty fountain in Cullen Family Plaza with Jell-O…not so much.

However, the memes make the platform very appealing to students because it is something with which students are able to relate. The memes about parking and the fountain are especially accurate about the issues they portray and how many students feel about them.

This gives VoteforMeme a lot of power with its outreach among students. While it is evident that the party means well for students, they most likely will be unable to follow through on many of their initiatives.

Of their realistic initiatives, some are very good. They want to incorporate student design into the new housing that is scheduled to replace the Quadrangle. They also want to have subsidized Metro fares for students. Students would no doubt most likely end up paying more in student fees for free Metro. However, it is something that could really benefit students and make it an incentive for them to utilize that resource.

According to The Cougar’s post-vice presidential debate poll, Furrh’s performance brought up the rear out of the four candidates. It will be crucial for Comer to make up the lost ground in the presidential debate.

Opinion editor Thomas Dwyer is a broadcast journalism sophomore and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“SGA election party platform breakdown” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on SGA election party platform breakdown