Author Archives | opiniondesk

Trump did not create the divide among Americans

We must come together as Americans and care for one another again. | Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons

Here we stand, on the edge of a vast divide, with of our friends, family and countrymen on the other side. Donald Trump didn’t cause this divide. The ascension of Donald Trump was caused by this divide.

The most frightening aspect of Trump’s rise is that we as a nation allowed such absurdity to become our reality. When assigning blame, we must understand that for every finger we point, three point back.

Trump’s appointment to our nation’s highest office wasn’t a coup. Not a single weapon was drawn. Rather, nearly 63 million Americans (46% of voters), of their own volition walked peacefully into a voting booth and allowed themselves to be grifted by a populist autocratic charlatan.

But what about all the American people who didn’t vote for Trump? Unfortunately, you too are culpable; if not on voting day, by your complicity every other day.

Our national decay didn’t happen overnight. It has long been festering. Our utter lack of priority in education coupled with our penchant for greed have allowed corporate interests to take hold of the reins and shake us around like the puppets we have become.

Our society now treats the anti-intellectual as king. Children are raised on iPads by any stranger with a YouTube channel, granting the Pewdiepies of the world dangerous influence. We have come to believe that those who are not fortunate enough to have what we do simply must not be working hard enough.

People hurl words like Muslim, liberal, gay and socialist around as insults. People treat political affiliation with the same zealotry as our favorite sports team. We have allowed fear to encroach upon liberty.

More than 20 years before the American Civil War, Abraham Lincoln prophesized during the Lyceum Address, “All the armies of Europe, Asia and Africa combined, with all the treasure of the earth…in their military chest; with a Bonaparte for a commander, could not by force, take a drink from the Ohio…in a trial of a thousand years. If destruction be our lot, we must ourselves be its author and finisher. As a nation of freemen, we must live through all time, or die by suicide.”

During the two times in American history when we were attacked, Americans showed amazing solidarity, putting aside petty squabbles and coming together. We must come together as we did after Pearl Harbor and Sept. 11.

We will always be our own biggest enemy until we learn to view one another as American before anything else. Labeling our fellow citizens with political epithets as an excuse to write them off cannot continue.

We must learn to listen to opposing viewpoints without letting our fear and anger blind us.

Columnist Anup Desai is a pre-business sophomore and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com. 

—
“Trump did not create the divide among Americans” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Trump did not create the divide among Americans

Focus Friday: Uber, Lyft and the new apps in Austin

New ride-sharing apps are popping up in Austin after Uber and Lyft were ousted from the city last year.

Apps like Ride Austin and Fasten are beginning to dominate the Austin market for ride-sharing, since they conform to regulations and pay more per ride than Uber and Lyft. CNN reports that some Houton residents are commuting to Austin to drive for the new apps.

This week, the opinion writers discuss whether these new apps will expand or stay primarily in Austin.

I was fortunate enough to witness the rise and fall of Lyft and Uber first hand, since I spent the last decade in Austin. The city was the perfect place for these platforms to thrive. Unlike larger and more spread out cities such as Dallas and Houston, Austin’s relatively small size with the majority of its activity occurring downtown was what made Lyft and Uber so appealing. Combine this with the rest of Austin’s appealing features, and you have the Mecca of ride sharing.

This is why drivers from Houston are commuting to Austin during their weekends. It’s the frequency of demand coupled with the shorter and more centralized routes that allow drivers to pack in more rides in a shorter time frame, which leads drivers to making more money.

Even though the newer Austin platforms might provide additional revenue per ride than Lyft and Uber, they’re more specialized and lack the market share and infrastructure that Uber and Lyft were able to attain by being first on the scene. These newer companies were only able to grow because the two titans left the city. We will see if they can survive once Lyft and Uber come back to town with a bag full of money and free ride promotions for all.

Opinion columnist Anup Desai is a pre-business sophomore and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

I think that these apps will have a niche in Austin. The problem these apps is in direct response to what Uber and Lyft can no longer do. If they can’t expand out across the globe, country or even different cities in Texas, then they won’t overtake the market that Uber and Lyft have already created.

Opinion columnist Dana Jones is a print journalism junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

Uber and Lyft will continue their market dominance because they have already established a brand. Everyone has Uber installed on their phone (and less people have installed Lyft), which creates an issue for newer apps. While Ride Austin and Fasten are doing well in Austin, they’re ultimately niche products that serve a niche audience.

Now, there is potential to expand if both apps are able to keep their shares per ride at the current rate, but expansion might change that. It is ultimately up to the market to decide if these apps will stay mainly in Austin or expand. Either way, they entered the game late and it’s hard to beat the giants at their own game.

Assistant opinion editor Jorden Smith is a political science and creative writing junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Focus Friday: Uber, Lyft and the new apps in Austin” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Focus Friday: Uber, Lyft and the new apps in Austin

Marginalized characters deserve real representation

Emma Watson is reason enough to flock to a nearby theater to see “Beauty and the Beast”; it will no doubt be an amazing live-action movie.

The movie is unique in many ways: it features an interracial couple and a gay character. In this version, Belle is the inventor — not her father — and she doesn’t have to wear a corset.

Although the movie hasn’t yet premiered, a leak about gay representation in the movie has caused some to erupt in thunderous applause while others were less than thrilled.

In the 2017 version of the Disney classic, the character LeFou comes out as gay. In the original 1991 version of the movie, LeFou was Gaston’s avid compatriot. He worked with Gaston to win Belle’s hand, and when that didn’t work, they conspired to have Belle’s father locked away in an insane asylum and to kill the Beast.

Disney fanatics are not unfamiliar with homosexual characters — Oaken from “Frozen” and the lesbian couple in “Finding Dory” — but LeFou is the first openly homosexual character with significant screen time. But although he is relatively prominent in the film, he’s not exactly what the LGBTQ+ community had in mind when asking for more representation in movies.

Some people say that featuring variations of sexuality and identity is good; it brings social issues to light. Some people believe the lack of positive representation in “Beauty and the Beast” forces moviegoers to acknowledge the existence of marginalized people, but this reasoning is incorrect.

The reason why people are advocating so intensely for giving “Frozen’s” Elsa a girlfriend is because she is iconic: a powerful female in a Disney movie whose bond with her sister was more important than a romance with a man.

That’s the kind of representation that gives people hope, and giving her LGBTQ+ status would help to normalize different sexualities.

Killing off that marginalized character or writing a marginalized villain into the script with no ‘good’ marginalized counterpart is almost as bad as refusing to acknowledge the existence of that character’s identity at all. Refusing positive representation is harmful.

Adults, who are mature and usually have solidified opinions about the world, can see gay characters and differentiate sexuality and evil intentions. Children, the intended audience for fairy tales, may not be able to make that distinction.

It’s not just children who need to see marginalized characters represented; adults do, too. It’s not bold for people to want themselves properly reflected in media they consume.

By employing stereotypes, the audience already decided LeFou was gay before the announcement, and it’s merely a step toward inclusion for LeFou to come out.

However, do we really want the first, second, third, even the seventh time a kid sees their sexuality represented on screen to be represented by a character who doesn’t get a happily ever after? Who stands on the side of evil — a trope that is produced on screens again and again? Whose name quite literally translates to “the fool?” Whose love interest treats him horribly?

Despite problematic writing, boycotting the film isn’t necessary. It will still break boundaries, challenge commonly-held ideas, and it’ll be entertaining, too. “Beauty and the Beast” looks gorgeous with all the costumes and songs and French provincial life — also the sure-to-be-incredible library.

Having a positive reflection of oneself in the media is exceedingly important. Giving Elsa a girlfriend is now in more dire need than ever — that would be cause for celebration rather than the disappointment that LeFou has induced.

Columnist Jackie Wostrel is a Public Relations freshman and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Marginalized characters deserve real representation” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Marginalized characters deserve real representation

After celebrity President Trump, could Oprah be next?

It is rare for someone unpolished, like an actor or television personality, to get elected into the highest office in the United States. Two notable examples of partisan shifting administrations are President Donald Trump and former President Ronald Reagan; an “outside” candidate is always a possibility.

In a direct response to the 2016 election’s outcome, the mogul queen of media and black billionaire Oprah Winfrey may be considering a run for president.

When the news first broke, I had the same reaction as I did when I heard about Trump’s campaign — I didn’t believe it. Then, I started to think: If Trump could win, then so can Oprah. She, too, is a billionaire; she’s a philanthropist, especially in South Africa; and people don’t actively hate her.

However, there are still many things that could stop her from succeeding. The two big ones are petty, but viable reasons for people not to vote for her. Oprah is both black and a woman. It shouldn’t be a factor, but being a woman is the same reason why some didn’t vote for Clinton. Likewise, some refused to vote for Barack Obama because he is black. That being said, it works both ways. Some might go to the polls and vote for her for those same reasons.

For the rest of the voting population, Oprah has issues that she would need to address. For one, she has not made a public stance on many issues. Some of her main platforms ones can only be inferred from her actions. Oprah has performed charity work domestically, particularly in Chicago, and abroad; Oprah’s friendship with talk show host Ellen DeGeneres infers that she’s pro-LGBTQ+ rights; and judging from a luncheon Oprah attended to, it seems that she’s pro choice. But even these are up in the air.

As president, you must be well-versed and have a clear stance on each topic that may come your way. Oprah would have to acknowledge topics like foreign affairs, economics, energy, poverty and trade deals — things that the more politically interested voter will be looking for.

In an interview on The David Rubenstein Show, Oprah said that she thought, “Oh gee, I don’t have the experience.” Even though she’s speaking her true thoughts, when even teasing a run for president, candidates need to be aware that people record everything they say. They need to appear confident because the voters they try to attract are independents, those still on the fence. Even people in that candidate’s preferred political party often would rather choose a more classically trained politician.

If Winfrey is seriously considering running, she needs to get her strategies and crash course in politics together starting now. Oprah: Do not wait until campaign season. Start voicing your opinion on legislation, and let it be known where you want to see the country go. Understand that you are Oprah Winfrey, and that when you speak, people listen.

Opinion columnist Dana Jones is a print journalism junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“After celebrity President Trump, could Oprah be next?” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on After celebrity President Trump, could Oprah be next?

Celebrities have entered the Oval Office, and they might not leave

Barack Obama accomplished something that no other president was able to achieve during his time in office: he became a celebrity. During his tenure, Obama changed the way the American public viewed the presidency. He was Mr. Cool, starring in a Buzzfeed video, reading his own mean tweets (twice!) and releasing his Spotify playlists.

No other president has ever been so influential in pop culture while in office. Sure, Ronald Reagan was a celebrity before he became a politician, but he didn’t act like it when he was in office. There’s a distinctive and inherent difference in the way the two presidents treated the office in regard to themselves.

In 2012, conservative thinker and commentator Bill Whittle predicted that the next President would come from pop culture. Turns out he was completely correct. Trump was a pop culture phenomenon before he stepped into politics; everyone knew him as the crazy guy from “The Apprentice.”

There is a reason that an actual celebrity is now president: We expect the president to be a celebrity. A pop culture presidency is now ingrained into who we are as a society, which may or may not be a bad thing. We are only about a month and a half into the Trump presidency, so it’s hard to make a determination. 

We’re in a new reality in which people are not as apprehensive toward celebrities running for president. Voters used to want politicians or lawyers or respected members of their community to represent them. Now, it seems constituents want someone they know and someone who makes them feel good. They want George Clooney (who will probably run for president one day) to look them in the eyes and pretend he’s one of them. 

After Trump’s improbable election, a string of celebrities began to talk about possibly running for president, even though they don’t have prior political experience. In 2020, we could see Oprah Winfrey, Dwayne Johnson or even Kanye up on a debate stage espousing their political policy on the Middle East or on health care. Musician Kid Rock is possibly running for a Senate seat in Michigan, a sight possibly even crazier than seeing our current president on a debate stage.

Maybe even UH’s resident billionaire, Tilman Fertitta, will make a run for the presidency. The parallels to Trump are uncanny: they’re billionaire business moguls and reality show hosts with a flair for dramatic statements.

Every U.S. president from now on might be a celebrity. We have entered an age in which people vote based on how well they like a candidate and how well they know them. Voting is centered on celebrity status, not real initiatives or experience in office. It sets a dangerous precedent. We could have wholly unqualified people running the country, but because they’re a celebrity, we vote them into office.

In 2020, we’ll have to decide as a country what we want in a president after experimenting with Trump, the ultimate celebrity president. But now, the presidency is not restricted to only politicians with decades of policy experience. What does the celebrity status of the presidency mean for the future? That’s for the voters to decide. 

Assistant opinion editor Jorden Smith is a political science and creative writing junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Celebrities have entered the Oval Office, and they might not leave” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Celebrities have entered the Oval Office, and they might not leave

The history of Hofheinz Pavilion will not be forgotten

Hofheinz Pavilion had its own personality. There was a magic to Hofheinz, even during the toughest and ugliest of games. | Courtesy of UH Athletics

Tilman Fertitta walked out of Hofheinz Pavilion with the last game ball ever to be used in the arena. At the end of Sunday’s game, the days of the Pavilion came to a close. All the history, all the wins and all the good times have become a memory.

I remember going to Hofheinz as a kid, thinking how different it looked compared to all the other basketball arenas.

Hofheinz Pavilion was its own; it had its own personality. No other arena felt as wide open as it did.
Whenever there was energy through the crowd, you could feel it all throughout the Pavilion.
You were never cut off from the game, no matter if you were grabbing snacks by either of the entrances or heading to one of the few bathrooms on either side of the circle.

There was a magic to Hofheinz, even during the toughest, ugliest games.

So thank you, Hofheinz, for being part of the Golden Age of University of Houston sports.
It was the house that Guy V. Lewis, whom the court is named after, built. In the early ’80s, Houston basketball was the best thing going in college sports as Phi Slama Jama put Hofheinz on the map and ultimately changed the way college basketball was played.

All the memories of future NBA Hall of Famers Hakeem Olajuwon (the man who took the final shot at Hofheinz) and Clyde Drexler started at Hofheinz.

The 1982-1983 team was so important and spectacular that ESPN made a documentary detailing how great Phi Slama Jama was. Throughout the documentary, Hofheinz was always there; the home of the greatest team that could’ve won it all.

Men’s basketball, however, wasn’t the only sport played in the pavilion. Women’s basketball and women’s volleyball also called it home. Though their legacies aren’t as well known, both teams have had their moments and are important to many Cougars, past and present.

There is a lot of history we shouldn’t forget and hope to preserve. Hofheinz was, and for the time being still is, a staple to being a Cougar. The taunts thrown at the opposing team as they line up for a free throw is the embodiment of school spirit that football games never seemed to encompass. We will miss the heckling crowd and the band singing songs like “It’s a Small World” and the theme to Spongebob Squarepants.

But it’s more than past time to make some sort of renovation. From the outside it looked like a building that had seen more years than it could handle. The inside looked old and as though a facelift was necessary years ago.

We should all be thankful that Tilman Fertitta stepped in and helped to create a new home for Cougar basketball and volleyball. In 2018, when Fertitta walks onto the court with the game ball, introducing the new Fertitta Center, the history of where the center stands won’t be forgotten.

In the end, the University won’t soon forget the history of Hofheinz, even if the building no longer stands. So thank you, Hofheinz Pavilion, for everything.

Assistant opinion editor Jorden Smith is a political science and creative writing junior and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“The history of Hofheinz Pavilion will not be forgotten” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The history of Hofheinz Pavilion will not be forgotten

Godwin’s Law remains relevant in today’s political climate

Godwin’s Law, first articulated by Mike Godwin in 1990, states that as an online discussion grows longer, the likelihood of a Nazi/Hitler comparison also grows.

A blend of scientific formulation and comical hyperbole, the law is more of a rule-of-thumb than a statute of nature. Its humor draws from the fact that even if Godwin had exaggerated, we can all recognize the kernel of truth embedded in the law. Like any cleverly designed adage, its meaning is readily appreciated.

In the Internet’s nascent days of the 90s, people discussed and debated ideas in forums (as it happens, Godwin conceived of his law following observations of discussions on Usenet, an international system used for topical discussions). In 1995, the Internet had 16 million users.

Today, the digital space is occupied by over 3.5 billion of us. But that’s not the whole story; those who wished to have a presence online back in the day were confined to desktops. Now, anyone with a smartphone has access to the rest of the world in their back pocket. And they don’t just have forums to play with. The Internet has evolved from a pond to a vast and dynamic ocean.

Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, Reddit, and other social media platforms meet the demands of the babbling, arguing, thinking ape.

While online discussion itself has witnessed a meteoric rise in the last twenty years, it’s an empirical question as to whether or not Godwin’s Law is upheld more or less accurately than when he first formulated it. Here, the adage’s usefulness is preserved by its recourse to humor.

It was never meant to be taken literally; Godwin himself later explained that the law was an attempt to imply that those who invoke Nazis in a debate are not “being thoughtful and independent”. To be sure, such a comparison can be enlightening, or even legitimate. On the other hand, anyone with enough creative juices can concoct a “legitimate” comparison between any two entities.

It’s time to bring forth the elephant in the room. The correlations between Hitler and Trump are many. Both, for example, appealed to the downtrodden with confident promises — that much is true. But inferring equal outcomes from such correlations is a game for the narratively driven.

It is all too easy to project one’s biased narrative onto the world. A thought experiment is illuminating — it’s true that both Obama and Hitler were democratically elected. To imply, based on the fact that both were voted into office, that Obama was the next Hitler would have been a position worthy of ridicule. Why? Because this correlation would apply to any democratically elected official, rendering the Hitler comparison worse than useless.

But this applies to any correlation you might consider. Take another commonly cited parallel between Hitler and Trump — the notion that both leveraged nationalism to galvanize their electorates. Yes, but so have many politicians. As I noted above, any two people (or objects, or ideas) can be compared, given enough creativity.

To be clear, I am not defending Trump, his policies or his campaign: I’m defending reasoned and honest discourse.

If we exclude violence as legitimate means to bring forth change, then conversation is all we have. Personal attacks, name-calling and heedless comparisons simply will not do. We are better than that, and our society deserves as much.

The next time you’re tempted to obey Godwin’s law, hold your tongue, take a breath and engage the argument.

Guest columnist Logan Chipkin is an ecology and evolution graduate student and can be reached at opinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Godwin’s Law remains relevant in today’s political climate” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Godwin’s Law remains relevant in today’s political climate

Hate crimes do not go unpunished in Georgia

Two members of a Georgia group named “Respect the Flag” have gotten double-digit sentences two years after rolling in a convoy adorned with confederate flags through a neighborhood and threatening a black family having a birthday celebration.

The convoy also reported to have stopped at a shopping center and a convenience store where more hostile exchanges were made with people of color.

Jose Torres and Kayla Norton were both sentenced on March 3 to serve time in prison for a myriad of things. Torres got 13 years and Norton got six.

The video of them crying and pleading in court during their sentencing went viral. Kayla Norton, the woman who was sentenced, pleaded with the judge and everyone else in the audience.

“I want ya’ll to know that is not me,” Norton said. “I would never walk up to you and say those words to you.”

Obviously, that’s untrue. Norton knew full well what she was doing. She would have taken a plea bargain if she really did regret her actions. The fact that she did not plead guilty in the first place gives her even less room to suddenly regret her actions and break down in the courtroom.

Torres got his sentence for wielding a shotgun during the altercation with the family and was also found guilty of breaking several laws that take measures against hate crimes and gangs.

If either of them had pled guilty, they most likely could have gotten less-harsh sentences. But as the saying goes: Play stupid games, win stupid prizes.

It is good that the video of them breaking down in court after being sentenced reached a wide audience. It made an example of them to anyone who is thinking of taking part in the rising wave of hate crimes occurring in the United States.

It’s one thing to spew racist rhetoric on the grounds of free speech where it is allowed but another thing completely to show up to a private celebration armed with a weapon and to make threats and hurl racial slurs at a family and their children.

Torres and Norton serve as a good example of what should happen to anyone who tries to intimidate others on the grounds of trivial things like skin color or religion.

Even though it took two years for justice to be served, it finally came.

Opinion editor Thomas Dwyer is a broadcast journalism sophomore and can be reached atopinion@thedailycougar.com.

—
“Hate crimes do not go unpunished in Georgia” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Hate crimes do not go unpunished in Georgia

Sessions is latest controversy for Trump administration

Nearly two months into President Donald Trump’s administration, the news is filled with stories about another key member of the Trump administration having ties to Russia.

Since the beginning of Trump’s term, these allegations have been widespread, ranging from allegations of hacked elections to former National Security Advisor Michael Flynn being forced to step down because of his contact with Russian officials. While investigation and resolutions on these topics are necessary, it doesn’t seem like an actual conclusion is being reached.

Just last week, it was revealed that Attorney General Jeff Sessions met with Russian Ambassador Sergey Kislyak during the presidential race. Sessions was a key adviser to the Trump campaign, and he was also the first senator to endorse Trump. During his senate confirmation hearing in January, Sessions claimed to have no contact with the Russians.

It’s not entirely clear how a senator could just forget meeting with a Russian official, not once but twice. A spokesperson for Sessions tried to clear his name by arguing that the question in the hearing wasn’t clear. The question asked whether the Trump campaign was in communication with the Russians, not Sessions. That is why Sessions said no.

However, Sessions said: “I have been called a surrogate at a time or two in that campaign, and I did not have communications with the Russians.” Even if the question was unclear, he responded by saying he didn’t have any communication with Russia.

To make matters more suspicious, Sessions claims he met with the ambassador as part of his job on the Senate Armed Services Committee. However, of the 26 members on the committee, 20 responded that they did not meet with the Russian ambassador as part of their duties.

Members from both parties weighed in on the situation.

Democrats were calling for the resignation of Sessions because he lied under oath. Furthermore, Sessions’ involvement with the Russians meant that he couldn’t be impartial in the investigation regarding Russia’s alleged hacking of the 2016 presidential election.

Some Republicans defended Sessions, claiming that the question asked during his confirmation was unclear and that he was only acting as a senator. Some Republicans have condemned Sessions’s actions and called for him to recuse himself from matters involving Russia. Trump supported Sessions during this controversy.

Sessions called a conference where he discussed the events of the past few days and closed by saying that he would recuse himself from investigations regarding Russia. This means that the investigations will instead be overseen by Deputy Attorney General Dana Boente.

This decision seems like the best alternative to resigning from the position. Just last month Flynn was forced to step down because of his communication with Russia, and miscommunication with Vice President Pence regarding this matter.

Since the beginning of the year, the Trump administration has been under attack for its relationship with Russia, and the entire issue seems to be a constant distraction from many other important matters.

While these allegations should be resolved, the process has been extremely prolonged. The Department of Justice should expedite the investigation to reach a conclusion.

That seems like the only way we can move past this Russian consumed phase of the Trump administration and focus on many of today’s pressing issues.

Fariha Jawed is an accounting and political science junior and can be reached atopinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Sessions is latest controversy for Trump administration” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Sessions is latest controversy for Trump administration

Amazon Echo is a Fourth Amendment conundrum

In late 2015, police issued a warrant to Amazon regarding data collected by Amazon’s Echo device as possible evidence in a murder case in Bentonville, Arkansas. Amazon recently filed an argument against the warrant and intends to have the warrant thrown out on a First Amendment grounds.

Amazon Echo is a smart speaker fitted with microphones that acts as an intermediary for a number of personal user requests. It is concerning to the privacy of Amazon Echo users as well as the users of smart devices at large that the grounds for what can be used to track digital footprints and reasonably searched is clearly communicated.

Certainly the First Amendment is implicated here. From a commercial standpoint, forthright knowledge of the ability of law enforcement agencies to track your purchases and search requests has the potential to have a chilling effect on consumer’s purchases and queries. From a consumer standpoint, the freedom of inquiry as well as the freedom to purchase materials, both qualities of Amazon’s product, are First Amendment-related concerns.

Although, the First Amendment argument has merit and Amazon deserves praise for taking such measures, It will surely be interesting to see how this case address some of the uncertainties that surround technological advancement and the Fourth Amendment.

In Katz v. United States, the protection from unreasonable search and seizures was afforded by the Fourth Amendment. It established both that public telephone booths still had a right to privacy under certain conditions largely because a physical intrusion through the booth’s door constituted a search. This intrusion was considered a breach of a reasonable expectation of privacy. If sliding a telephone booth shut constitutes a reasonable expectation of privacy, It should be safe to assume that a personal device that operates within a person’s home is a protected privacy as well.

The third party doctrine insinuates that consumers have no expectation of privacy with their information, even in regards to institutions such as banks, and is a flawed theory with devices that continue to facilitate the convergence of different platforms and facets of a person’s public life.

The very idea that the device is meant to consolidate other unrelated devices makes it analogous to a smart-remote. This signifies that if privacy and speech protection doesn’t suffice from case law concerning one of the devices it consolidates, it inevitably will in another. For instance, the decision in Riley v. California largely protected from warrantless searches of digital data on cell phones under the Fourth Amendment, even though United States v. Knotts didn’t provide the same protection to the defendant when concerned with a radio transmitter used for surveillance. Amazon Echo can act both as a radio transmitter and with the capacity to record user-specific data, companies and the supreme court should err on the side of caution.

The Supreme Court historically decides the precedents for search and seizure of information piecemeal as the new technology surfaces and changes how information gets transmitted. First Amendment arguments can lend credit to the case against surrender of personal digital footprints, but the argument for Fourth Amendment protection has interesting possibilities when you consider devices as intermediaries to your “smart” home.

Opinion columnist Nicholas Bell is an MBA graduate student and can be reached atopinion@thedailycougar.com

—
“Amazon Echo is a Fourth Amendment conundrum” was originally posted on The Daily Cougar

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Amazon Echo is a Fourth Amendment conundrum