Author Archives | Maddox Brewer Knight, Opinion Columnist

Brewer Knight: Citizenship premium

“When Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best… They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists.” These words, uttered by presidential candidate Donald Trump, galvanized the nation in 2015. 

Trump won his first presidential election on a campaign of fear, and this fear was a prominent motivating factor for many of his voters. According to Pew Research Center surveys from 2016, 79% of Trump voters identified immigration as a very important issue in their voting decision. 

This wall, so often referenced in slogans and chants, was Trump’s selling point: a glimmering beacon of exclusion that promised to preserve the sanctity of a white, English-speaking nation. 

Trump justified his xenophobia by focusing on the alleged criminality of Mexican and Central American immigrants — these were “bad hombres,” and their immorality disqualified them for entry through the golden door. 

In his 2024 campaign, Trump doubled down on this rationale, this time shifting his focus to Caribbean immigrants. During the presidential debate, he reiterated the unconfirmed claim that Haitian immigrants were eating cats and dogs in Springfield, Ohio. But never fear — concerned voters could protect their pets and their neighborhoods by voting him into office, allowing Project 2025’s deportation sweeps to restore law and order to their communities. 

And vote they did. Trump rose to power once more with 49.8% of the popular vote. He immediately implemented Project 2025, a political initiative devised by a conservative think-tank that aims to restructure the federal government to support authoritarian right-wing policies. One initiative came as a particular shock: the Gold Card visa. 

Proposed as a way to reduce the United States’ national debt, the Gold Card allows wealthy foreigners to effectively purchase permanent U.S. residency for $5 million each. 

This program is intended to replace the EB-5 immigrant investor visa program. EB-5, established by Congress in 1990, allowed foreigners to obtain a Green Card by investing in a U.S. enterprise and promising to create and maintain at least 10 full-time jobs for U.S. workers, bringing wealth to underprivileged regions.

The Gold Card program entirely abandons this community-focused prerogative, reducing the wealthy foreigners’ obligation from a long-term commitment to a simple one-time fee. 

Furthermore, this program contradicts Trump’s supposed preoccupation with moral purity. During his campaigns, Trump claimed that his immigration policy would protect Americans from rapists, drug dealers and criminals. 

However, some of the most infamous criminals of our era could have easily afforded this fee, speeding down the path to citizenship while asylum-seekers languish in limbo. Sinaloa Cartel co-founder Ismael “El Mayo” Zambada possessed roughly $3 billion at the time of his arrest in July 2024. Alleged serial rapist and Egyptian luxury mogul Mohamed Al-Fayed had $2 billion at the time of his death, while convicted rapist and British entrepreneur Lawrence Jones was a multimillionaire at the time of his arrest. 

Additionally, the Gold Card could open the doors for Russian oligarchs with whom Trump has personal ties. This list includes figures such as Dmitry Rybolovlev, whose offshore wealth concealment was cited in the Panama Papers, or Roman Abramovich, an investor guilty of bribery, loan fraud and over-pollution. 

The Gold Card confirms that Trump never truly cared about protecting Americans from crime — after all, he is a white collar criminal and sexual abuser protecting his own. Instead, Trump’s immigration policy is motivated by racism and a deep disdain for the poor and needy, those who could most benefit from American residency. 

America has long prided itself on being a bastion of democracy, refuge and freedom, but Trump’s Gold Card is a threat to core virtues, treating residency as a commodity to be sold instead of a right to be upheld. The damage done by this policy should serve as a warning for future voters — greed and corruption cannot make America great. 

The post Brewer Knight: Citizenship premium appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Brewer Knight: Citizenship premium

Brewer Knight: Money Talks. Should The University Listen?

Anyone who has ventured onto the University of Oregon campus has undoubtedly noticed one name adorning various buildings: Knight.

From the Matthew Knight Arena to the Knight Campus, the specter of Nike co-founder and multi-billionaire Phil Knight looms large over the school, thanks to his donations totaling over $1 billion — but how much power do donors like him really wield over the university? 

UO receives less state funding per student than any other Oregon public university, receiving only $5,647 per fundable student compared to Oregon State University’s $11,580. As a result, the school relies more heavily on student tuition and “gift money” — otherwise known as private donations.

From 2010-2021, the university raked in $3.2 billion worth of donations from 147,081 donors, only 70 of whom donated over $5 million. This small group of large-sum donors decides what to fund and, as an extent, what to value, shaping the UO’s budget for academics, athletics and infrastructure.  

 Notably, donors can choose where their gift money goes. 

While they can’t control precise expenditures or the output created from their gift, UO donors can designate their donation to a specific program or area of study. 

As a result, the university’s priorities rely increasingly on the whims of donors. It can be difficult to find funding for the issues that don’t attract philanthropists’ interest, such as building upkeep or worker’s wages.

“Passively, through more negligence than malice, faculty have fallen multiple rungs down the school’s list of priorities,” Mike Urbancic, a senior instructor II of economics and the president of the United Academics union, said. 

Currently, Urbancic is leading unionized UO faculty in negotiations with the administration for fairer pay, an issue rarely addressed by donors.

 “Maintaining things just isn’t as flashy as building something new and shiny,” Urbancic said. “It doesn’t burnish the resume of the upper administrators, who want something impressive to highlight to donors — it’s difficult to convince donors that what we really need is to maintain existing operations.” 

The need to justify improvements to donors leads to increasing privatization, as more money is funneled into lucrative or flashy endeavors that reflect the donor’s personal interests. 

This systemic neglect of mundane maintenance is visible in instances like the delayed demolition of dorms containing asbestos or the closure of the useful but unprofitable American English Institute. 

This privatization also impacts instructors, and, as a result, the curricula of students’ classes. “Everything boils down to fees,” Jon Jaramillo, a career instructor of Spanish, said.

“Our department pays the university to use classrooms for special events, and then there’s facility and parking fees. There are so many little things that are designed to suck money out of people,” Jaramillo said. “We also have some administrators managing this educational institution who come directly from the corporate world. They are used to focusing on the bottom line, so they apply those same techniques of operating a business to the university, which stifles innovation and creativity.”

Of course, the donor system has its benefits. As a lifelong Oregon resident, I acknowledge that donations from rich and powerful philanthropists have given me access to a higher caliber of education than I would otherwise receive — however, if my interests don’t align with the subjects that donors deem fit to fund, I will struggle to pursue my passions as budget cuts may decimate my discipline’s programs, faculty and opportunities. 

Some students have already felt limited by their majors’ lack of funding. “The history department has been chronically underfunded in the UO,” David Reynaud, a sophomore history major, said. “McKenzie Hall is in dire need of repairs compared to many of its better funded counterparts. Its outdated design, poor maintenance, and limited classroom size has proven detrimental to my and other students’ learning.” 

This issue of privatization is more pressing now than ever, as private interests increasingly intertwine with the function of public institutions. President Trump has assembled the richest administration in American history, appointing 13 billionaires to positions of power in his cabinet. We live in an era where magnates control our government — do we want them controlling our universities as well? 

The post Brewer Knight: Money Talks. Should The University Listen? appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Brewer Knight: Money Talks. Should The University Listen?

Brewer Knight: Why The Faculty Strike Matters 

When I met with Mike Urbancic, a senior instructor II of economics and president of United Academics, he illustrated the University of Oregon faculty’s plight with a metaphor.

“We’ve got that lovely collection of world flags around Hayward Field. They were gorgeous when they were put up, but over time they’ve fallen into miserable disrepair. They’re tattered, torn and snagging on trees — it’s a powerful visual. The university is really proud whenever we create shiny new things, but when it comes to maintaining them, it’s just not a priority — they’re left to be weathered, bedraggled and fall apart,” he said.

UO’s faculty endure a similar state of neglect as they bargain for their new agreement. UO’s United Academics (UA), a union representing 1,728 faculty members, has been bargaining with the administration since Dec. 5 for contract improvements such as more sick leave, fairer workloads and a salary raise. 

Campus has rippled with discussion over what this strike would entail for students — no classes, no research and a total academic blackout — but what would it mean for instructors? What do they stand to gain? What are their reasons for such drastic action?

Currently, UO faculty have the lowest salaries out of any Big 10 university. While in-state tuition has risen 37% since 2014 in inflation-adjusted dollars, faculty salaries have declined by 5%. 

This deprivation, however, doesn’t stem from financial hardship — UO’s general budget has grown by 5.7%, and the six highest-paid administrators rake in a combined yearly total of $3,037,800. 

This injustice spurred the UA to submit a proposal requesting an across-the-board 8.5% raise for all faculty in 2025. The administration countered with 4%. If the administration refuses to budge, faculty say they will strike in spring term.

“My personal reason for being involved in the union is that right now, we’re facing a complete societal transformation with the incoming presidential administration,” Jon Jaramillo, a UA-affiliated Spanish career instructor, said. “Truth is not as important, and our work (as scholars) has been devalued. We’re seeing a shift toward running the university like a corporation — it’s destroying students’ creativity. If we don’t do everything possible right now with this contract, when will be the next opportunity for us to adjust our pay?”

While federal changes may threaten the future of public universities, Urbancic notes a promising change on the state level. Due to increases in Oregon’s budget forecast under new state economist Carl Riccadonna, there will likely be $1.3 billion more of tax money available by 2027 for public uses such as paying state university faculty. 

In other words, the scarcity long used to justify underpaying instructors has vanished. 

“There can be more investment in higher education and K12 and housing and healthcare because the pie is simply bigger,” Urbancic said. “We’re done with this idea that we’re squabbling over a fixed budget. We’ve had years of underinvestment in higher education relative to other states; now is the time to do something about it.”

Instructors form the foundation of our university, and their current wages are not only unacceptable but unwarranted. Labor activism is having a renaissance on campus, as evidenced by graduate educators’ and classified staff’s successful fight for better compensation and the prospective student worker strike, and faculty should not be forgotten in this push for equity.

“I think students should hear both sides out — listen to what both the administration and the union have to say, look at the data and decide for themselves who to support,” Jaramillo said. 

“We hope that students will be supportive and understanding of our struggle…because really what we’re struggling for is to secure the conditions to continue providing our students with an excellent education. We’re struggling to create the conditions for us to be successful in helping them to be successful.” 

The post Brewer Knight: Why The Faculty Strike Matters  appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Brewer Knight: Why The Faculty Strike Matters 

Brewer Knight: The Issue with “States’ Rights”

For the past sixty years, abortion has been a hotly debated topic in the United States — but in light of the 2024 election, it is one of the most crucial domestic issues for our country to address. 

Due to its controversial and sensitive nature, discussions of abortion access have often been brushed aside or silenced in the name of politeness. However, as the death toll rises higher and millions of women lose their autonomy, this pattern cannot persist. 

On the personal level, the choice of whether or not to seek an abortion should be determined by the individual’s own circumstances, medical needs, and personal beliefs. On the national level, abortion is a right that should not be denied to all due to the objections of particular religious and political groups. 

Following the overturn of Roe v. Wade in 2022, abortion has been portrayed as a states’ rights issue. “Whatever [the states] decide must be the law of the land,” stated president-elect Donald Trump on his privately-owned platform Truth Social — “In this case, the law of the state.” Conservative arguments have cited the United States’ cultural diversity as a justification for state-by-state legislature: what works for California may not work for Mississippi, they argue.

The loss of this federal constitutional protection enables individual states to decide the legality of abortion for themselves, a decision with grave consequences: fourteen states have almost fully banned abortion, while four states remain in flux. These bans have caused unthinkable tragedies, such as a 12-year-old rape victim forced to give birth to her rapist’s baby and a woman forced to carry a stillborn baby to term. 

In the mere two years since the overturn, maternal fatalities in states with abortion bans are 62% higher than in states where abortion access is protected, a disparity which is bisecting our country. 

States’ rights are currently prioritized over human rights, and the red-and-blue maps that dominate the news document two very different realities for women in America — but this is not the first time that the issue of states’ rights has caused such division. 

Since the Constitutional Convention of 1787, American politics have been split into warring factions of Federalists and anti-Federalists. These names are rarely mentioned in the 21st century and the attached political parties are now obsolete. Nevertheless, this dichotomy persists as politicians divide themselves into opposing camps: those who want important laws to be decided by a central authority and those who want states to have the independence to decide for themselves. 

The Civil War, which sought to eradicate the human rights-abomination of American slavery, provided an important contribution to this discussion — namely, it confronted the question, “do human rights end at state lines?” The conclusion was a resounding “no,”, affirming that slavery was unconstitutional and could not be tolerated by the U.S. government simply because a state voted to legalize it. 

Abortion access and slavery are vastly different topics which should not be equated or compared. However, the Civil War provides important precedent that should be considered today as Americans discuss “States’ rights issues” such as abortion, prison labor, gun control, and the death penalty. 

Human rights shouldn’t be compromised at state lines. If the government considers something a “fundamental right,” as abortion was deemed under Roe v. Wade, that right should not be provided or revoked at the whims of a state.

 One moment in the Roe v. Wade trial poignantly encapsulated this idea: when Texas Assistant Attorney General Jay Floyd remarked that a pregnant woman seeking an abortion has already made her choice, SCOTUS Justice Potter Stewart exclaimed, “Maybe she makes a choice when she decides to live in Texas!” 

As this sarcastic comment expressed, it is ludicrous for women in red states to have fewer rights than women in blue states, despite belonging to the same nation. The U.S. is a union of states, not a collection of separate powers, and we must act as such — especially when human autonomy is on the line. 

 

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Brewer Knight: The Issue with “States’ Rights”

Brewer Knight: An (Amateur) Artist’s White Whale

In elementary school, my favorite time of the day was art class. Each week, my classmates and I would be corralled into two snaking lines and shepherded down the hallways, our sneakers squeaking on the linoleum as we filed into the art classroom. 

Passing through that hallowed door was like entering fairyland. Smudgy charcoal sketches papered the walls from floor to ceiling. Knickknacks lined every shelf: vases full of plastic flowers, artist mannequins mid-arabesque, cakes of muddy watercolors. Even the chairs were painted into the fantastical forms of dragons, castles or allusions to Andy Warhol’s pop-art. 

For many students, the art classroom was a safe haven. Even those of us who didn’t particularly enjoy sculpting pinch-pots could appreciate the refuge it offered — art was a break from the math, reading and writing that occupied the rest of our day. It allowed us to unwind and think creatively. 

Studies show that art is beneficial for elementary school students, both improving the school environment and giving students more confidence, but what about college students?

For those of us venturing into adulthood, avenues of creative expression are just as crucial as ever.    

College is stressful, and navigating adult responsibilities even moreso. In the everyday frenzy of school and work, it is easy to become overwhelmed, anxious or detached from the things which once brought us joy. 

Unsurprisingly, I was thrilled to learn that UO has a Craft Center open to all students in the EMU. My tour guide let us peer through the window at the impressive array of gadgets and announced that the center was free for students to use — all you had to do was pay for materials and the studio was your oyster.

Bolstered by this knowledge, I waltzed into the center during week one only to be politely turned away. If I wanted to use a studio, the receptionist informed me, I had to sign up for an orientation. She offered me a clipboard, but I balked at the long list of names and sheepishly declined. 

My preconceptions had been sorely mistaken — The Craft Center might technically be open to all, but this doesn’t mean it’s simple to access. 

In order to access most studios within the Craft Center, students with prior experience must complete multiple-session orientations to learn Center-specific guidelines. Total novices must enroll in workshops to learn how to use the materials. 

Such precautions are reasonable considering the professional equipment within (which ranges from blowtorches to table saws), but they do severely limit the amount of students able to utilize the highly-demanded Craft Center services — limited orientation and workshop spots open at the beginning of each term, inciting an inevitable mad dash as students race to secure a spot. 

 “Getting into the Craft Center was really bizarre. On tours they made it sound like anyone could just pop in and do a little ceramics, but when I became a student I found out that there was an entire process that they never mentioned,” said Rain Roark, a sophomore. 

They continued, “For me, getting in is always a process of figuring out when they are gonna open up the slots in the first place, mark it on my calendar, make sure that I have the time to reserve my spot, because they fill up in 5 minutes max.” 

“Since the studio is so small, it can max out and they won’t let more people in. Plus, they have classes that reserve the studio for a couple of hours at a time, so it can be confusing to figure out when they are even open. Basically, they need a remodel or expansion.” 

Some of the most unique opportunities, such as the glassblowing or ceramics studios, are inaccessible without completing specialized workshops. Unfortunately, these workshops can cost up to $280, making them cost-prohibitive for many interested students. 

Despite these obstacles, students flock to the Crafts Center because it is often their only resource for arts on-campus — many art classes are restricted for majors and minors only, leaving clubs and workshops as their only recourse.

With consistently growing freshman classes and record revenues, the University of Oregon would benefit from expanding its Craft Center services. With the help of larger facilities and increased funding to reduce the out-of-pocket cost of workshops, this haven of on-campus arts could allow more students to indulge their artistic streaks.

 Art is a valuable and often-overlooked facet of campus life — and with the Craft Center, UO has the chance to prioritize it.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Brewer Knight: An (Amateur) Artist’s White Whale

Brewer Knight: Are Your Secrets Safe With UO Therapists?

In 2014, a University of Oregon freshman known anonymously as Jane Doe made a chilling report to the Eugene Police: the student alleged that she had been cornered in a bathroom and repeatedly gang-raped by three Ducks basketball players. 

Jane had survived the barbaric incident, but her ordeal was far from over. She pursued justice through the school’s official channels and did what most would do when confronted with such unthinkable trauma — she sought therapy. 

But neither of these resources provided the safe haven Jane had been promised. UO purposefully delayed their internal disciplinary proceedings, allowing the three players to finish their sports season before expelling them. 

The players – Damyean Dotson, Dominic Artis and Brandon Austin – were ousted from the university two months after the incident occurred, but their punishment was hardly draconian. Despite the UO Director of Student Conduct deeming them guilty of sexual misconduct, the students were banned from campus for a mere four years. Their records were scrubbed, allowing them to transfer to other colleges and continue their careers without consequence. 

However, this crass prioritization of sports revenue-generated profit over safety was just the beginning. In a shocking violation of trust, the UO General Counsel’s office worked with the UO Counseling Center to access the private records from Jane Doe’s post-assault therapy sessions. 

The UO Counseling Center shared these sensitive transcripts with the university’s lawyers in an attempt to preemptively formulate a counterclaim — in simpler terms, powerful institutional officials rifled through transcripts of the woman’s darkest hours, twisting her own words against her to squash a lawsuit she hadn’t even made yet. 

This atrocious act was brought to public attention when Karen Stokes, the Counseling Center’s director’s assistant, defied orders and showed the paper trail to Jane Doe’s therapist, Jennifer Morlok, who had not been informed that her patient’s records were being distributed behind her back. 

As dedicated mental health professionals, both women were appalled — therapists are sworn to protect their clients’ sensitive information, not to deliver it into the malevolent hands of litigators. 

As mandated by her oath, Morlok reported this infraction to the Oregon Bar and the Psychologist Board, breaking the story. News of their whistleblowing circulated and Stokes was dismissed by the university, while Morlok cited social ostracism as the reason for her resignation. 

In the light of this news, Jane Doe filed a lawsuit against UO for mishandling her sexual assault claim, asserting that the university had abused her therapy records and that the basketball coach, Dana Altman, had recruited her alleged assaulter Brandon Austin despite knowing his history of sexual misconduct. 

This was the moment they had been waiting for. UO replied with a vicious counterclaim, in which they accused Jane Doe of fabricating her claims and damaging the credibility of real victims with her “frivolous” complaints.   

The court ruled in Jane Doe’s favor and the student settled for $800,000, but the grievous lack of privacy at the root of this case has not been amended. UO’s actions were, and still are, technically legal. 

As an extension of an educational institution, UO Health Services are regulated by the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act, instead of Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, which regulates most federal healthcare. As FERPA is the less-protective of the two privacy acts, students have far fewer privacy rights when seeking care on-campus than they would with an off-campus, private practitioner. 

A legal loophole entitles UO to access their students’ personal healthcare records whenever they are deemed necessary for a litigation defense — i.e., if the school thinks the student is going to sue the institution. This lack of confidentiality is especially dangerous with regards to sensitive matters like therapy, sexual assault response, substance abuse counseling, STD screenings and contraception — all treatments which UO Health Services provides. 

Following the 2015 controversy, the school amended its confidentiality policy to grant students more power over their own records, but their new policy still entitles the school to subpoena information in the instance of an “actual or anticipated lawsuit.” This update is a step in the right direction, but the underlying vulnerability of FERPA-based healthcare has not been fully erased.   

Each fall, campus lampposts flutter with fliers encouraging students to enroll in the UO Health Plan — but only in the fine print does the university acknowledge the plan’s inadequate protections of privacy. 

UO junior Emma Deutschman says she was not made aware of the privacy policy during her visits to campus clinicians. “If it was in any of the agreements, I definitely scrolled right past it,” Deutschman said.

University of North Carolina law professor and disability rights specialist Katie Guest Pryal advocates to avoid FERPA-regulated campus healthcare entirely, but the solution isn’t so simple — for many students, especially those whose parents don’t have health insurance or have coverage in a different state, the insufficient UO Health Plan is all they can afford. 

The current system preys on students who can’t afford off-campus healthcare, portraying privacy as a luxury to be bought and vulnerability as a price to pay. 

Additionally, navigating off-campus healthcare can be confusing. 

“All the off-campus psychiatrists didn’t take my insurance or they weren’t accepting new patients,” Deutschman said. “There’s a lack of knowledge on who is in practice in Eugene and where to find them; it’s just not something that’s advertised very much. UO makes frequent emails about getting healthcare and therapy services. It seems convenient since it’s right on campus, but then the waitlist is twelve months long.” 

But how do we fix such a malignant systemic issue? On a local level, it should be required to verbally and explicitly inform all incoming students, parents and university therapists that any information shared in UO Counseling can be used against the patient in the case of a lawsuit. Students have a right to know their risks when utilizing campus services, especially to prevent themselves from possible self-incrimination. 

Nonetheless, warnings are only a Band-Aid solution. The crisis will not be resolved until FERPA is amended to grant students greater rights to privacy — at the very least, schools shouldn’t be able to weaponize student’s private information in a counterclaim until after the student makes an initial lawsuit. 

Like Morlok, most UO counselors are trustworthy professionals who strive to provide high-quality care for students. 

Unfortunately, they aren’t the only ones with access to your private information — school officials can also obtain your records, and they are less interested in ensuring your mental wellbeing than in covering the school’s back. If you ever face such a situation, you should not trust the institution to keep your best interests in mind. No student should have to go through what Jane Doe went through. 

As a major institution, UO wields extensive power over its students. This is more than just a local or isolated issue; this is a national power struggle in which institutions’ financial interest in preventing costly lawsuits increasingly encroaches upon their students’ rights. 

Any students who seek on-campus healthcare must be aware of their limited rights to privacy. All students should be careful about what they share with campus healthcare practitioners. When you share something with a UO counselor, you might unintentionally be sharing it with UO lawyers as well.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Brewer Knight: Are Your Secrets Safe With UO Therapists?

Brewer Knight: The $18K Article: How Paywalls are Gatekeeping Knowledge

At age sixteen, I vowed to become civically informed. I had just registered to vote, and the political jargon behind the plexiglass windows of newspaper boxes blinked out at me with pressing urgency. Soon, I would have to actually understand these headlines, and I would be trusted to cast my ballot accordingly.

I began in the most straightforward way I could imagine: I googled “New York Times.”

Within two seconds, my journey of civic literacy hit a wall — or more precisely, a paywall. From the “Los Angeles Times” to the “Atlantic,” each article I clicked was swiftly concealed behind a demanding pop-up. 

Knowledge came at a price, and it was oftentimes upwards of $20 per month. Stingy as usual, I pieced together my understanding of world events from online trials and free newspapers from swanky hotel lobbies until I arrived at the University of Oregon.

My UO ID was a masterkey. With an institution attached to my name, I could bypass paywalls for the “New York Times,” the “Los Angeles Times,” the “Washington Post” and unlimited academic articles on JSTOR. My newfound access was dizzying, yet I was struck by the realization that I never should have lacked it in the first place. 

College students pay hefty tuition fees for access to curated classes, professors’ instruction, tutoring and certifications for their field — but, unbeknownst to many, they are also paying for the privilege to teach themselves. Due to institution-wide subscriptions, knowledge hidden behind paywalls becomes an unspoken perk to college tuition. 

Instruction, interaction and unique experiences make universities worthwhile, but access to raw information shouldn’t be gatekept for those who can afford a college degree. On the contrary, free scholarly materials are even more crucial for those who don’t have the wisdom of librarians, tutors and professors at their disposal. 

This inequity only furthers the divide between college students and the rest of the world, promoting elitism and division — students who feel privy to exclusive information are quick to weaponize their “I’m-an-intellectual-and-you’re-not”  attitude, a phenomenon which I have encountered all too frequently throughout my freshman year. 

This predicament becomes even more important during election season, when misinformation can run rampant. As easy as it may be to mock your uncle who reposts falsified articles on Facebook or your neighbor who regurgitates fear-mongering “Fox News” features, how can we blame readers for getting their information from reactionary right-wing sources if those sources are free, yet more reputable newspapers charge prohibitive access fees?

In this instance, entire points of view are being gatekept, disseminated through articles written by and for the affluent and educated. There is no chance for dialogue or constructive conversation in a world of echo chambers, and people are unlikely to challenge their own beliefs if they can’t afford access to opposing viewpoints. 

But how can we remedy this situation? Public libraries offer a promising solution.

As a paragon of open access, libraries have successfully implemented open-access programs like Kanopy, a streaming service that allows anyone with a library card to watch up to six free movies per month. While niche, Kanopy has found major success in the fifteen years since its release, providing education and enjoyment to thousands of users — but this trend doesn’t have to stop with cinema. 

With federal funding, libraries could arrange subscriptions with prominent publications to grant cardholders access to a set number of free weekly articles from various sources, allowing readers to access a diversity of opinions and bridging the information gap. 

After all, knowledge is a power that should not be gatekept by private institutions, but instead freely available to all those who wish to seek it.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Brewer Knight: The $18K Article: How Paywalls are Gatekeeping Knowledge