Author Archives | Lily Sawyer-Kaplan

Herald 100: Best Yale grad school

If you’ve ever seen the space station planted in the middle of Whitney Ave, you know that SOM is the best Yale Grad School. The whole building is constructed from glass, because they promote “transparency” in the business world. The have a café that’s like Bass Café, but the snack selection kills and the coffee is from Oren’s and therefore drinkable. They have their own Sol Lewitts that decorate their dining hall. Use all your Eli-Bucks here!! Lunch is $2 less than a meal swipe, and the day I went they had food cart samplings. It’s also possible to take over the sound system of a classroom, and watch the “Sorry” music video on repeat on a huge projector that is probably meant to forecast markets. All these amenities are right here, right now available to the future business leaders of America.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Herald 100: Best Yale grad school

Letter from an editor: October 30, 2015

I grew up a few blocks from Planned Parenthood. When I was little, I thought that moms and dads went there to figure out when they were going to have kids. But I realized pretty quickly that there wouldn’t be crowds of people holding signs and protesting outside of the clinic every Saturday morning if that was all Planned Parenthood did. In high school, I remember running past one time with a friend, who yelled, as we passed, “Keep your rosaries off my ovaries!” I was too timid to echo her, but I threw the protesters what I thought was a menacing glare from across the street.

I had a similar reaction when I first heard about crisis pregnancy centers, which provide women with options—that don’t include abortions. But Sophie Haigney, ES ’17, offers a more complicated look into the role they play in providing women with choice.

Health care, and access to it, carries through into the Features section. Matthew Wrocklage, CC ’18, writes about the Fair Haven Community Health Clinic’s new facility, and how it will increase underserved populations’ health care access. Sarah Holder, SY ’17, takes a look at the impact of Neighborhood Housing Services, which aims to help another underprivileged community in Newhallville by turning abandoned houses into beautiful, affordable homes.

If you get hungry while you’re reading, sample some pumpkin spice treats over in Culture to celebrate the season. Order a chaider, split a scone, and open the Herald.

Keep it spooky,

Lily Sawyer-Kaplan

Features Editor

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Letter from an editor: October 30, 2015

An exodus

For days, an unidentified stench permeated Shaqwella Payne’s apartment in New Haven’s Church Street South building complex. When inspectors from New Haven’s Livable City Initiative arrived, Payne watched Rafael Ramos, the deputy director of Housing Code Enforcement, pull her fridge forward and recoil at what he found. Mold, in shades of white and black, caked the pipes inside her kitchen walls.
Payne’s apartment is one among the increasing number of units at the affordable housing complex that LCI has deemed unlivable. The apartments have cracked walls, peeling ceilings, rampant mold, and water damage from frequent flooding—they have been dilapidating for over a decade. That trajectory would have continued uninterrupted, if not for a group of residents that brought overdue attention to their rights violations. This past August, they filed legal action against the negligent private developer, Northland Investment Corporation, which has owned the property since 2007.
Now, Northland, the mayoral administration, the Housing Authority, and the City at large face the challenge of relocating all 289 families while determining the future of the site.
On Wed., Sept. 16, the Federal Department of Housing and Urban Development, Northland, and the City determined that all residents will be evacuated. After years of being ignored, it is, in some ways, a victory for the residents. But as they prepare to leave their crumbling homes, an uncertain future awaits them—and Church Street South.
***
Church Street South sits across from the stately, Beaux-Arts train station that attracts most of the attention and traffic along Union Avenue, a stark contrast to the low-slung, concrete bunker-like structures. But long before the housing complex existed, before the collapsing ceilings, and before the high asthma rates, the land across from the gates to the city offered hope for New Haven’s
prosperous future. The city’s economic development administrator, Matt Nemerson, said, “It is part of the whole history of how New Haven thinks of itself.”
The property has figured largely in city planning for the past century. New Haven’s 1910 Civic Improvement Plan designed a grand boulevard that would occupy the valuable real estate, connecting the train station to the downtown business district. Frederick Law Olmsted, Jr. (son of
the Frederick Law Olmsted who designed Central Park in New York) and Cass Gilbert, the architect behind Union Station, envisioned a beautiful plaza, but the city never executed the plan. “The city couldn’t afford politically or financially to realize such grand plans,” Yale Architecture and Urban Studies Professor Elihu Rubin, SY ’99, said.

The site still figured in the imagination of the next generation of New Haven city planners. In 1955, Mayor Richard Lee hired Yale Professor Maurice Rotival to update his 1941 city plan for New Haven, which resulted in the construction of the Oak Street Connector and the destruction of a neighborhood. Rotival originally hoped to use the Church Street Property as a commercial boulevard consisting of shopping centers, parking lots, and hotels to connect the train station

to downtown. In a 1955 letter to Lee, Rotival wrote, “Extended Church Street will become beyond question New Haven’s ‘Fifth Avenue’—the main thoroughfare along which the commercial and business life of the city will be arranged. The area in which we have been concentrating so much of our time, and which presently is depressed, will become one of the most valuable sections of the city.” Looking back, the idea that Church Street South might be to New Haven what ritzy Fifth Ave
is to New York seems distant and improbable. But the ultimate choice of housing on an inhospitable site for residency should have seemed more so.
Ironically, the population dislocation and dearth of low-income housing caused by the Oak Street Connector prevented Rotival’s dreams for the Church Street property. Nemerson said, “The city had a set of challenges because they were required to replace housing, affordable housing that was torn down.” The city’s demolition of a neighborhood, along with the burgeoning political movements of the 1960s, forced the city to abandon its plans for commercial zoning. The city hoped to restore housing as physically close to the old neighborhood as possible, which, according to Nemerson, qualified the developers for federal funds. Residents’ voices had been heard, a precursor to the impetus behind today’s action at Church Street South.
Initially, the city commissioned Mies van der Rohe, who contributed to the birth of modern architecture, to design luxury housing units in 1965. His plans, which included some middle- and low-income housing, did not come close to meeting the community’s needs. Two years later, a riot engulfed the city after a white merchant shot a Puerto Rican boy. The tide of public opinion in relation to racial and economic injustice which swelled after the riot pushed the Lee administration
to reconsider the plan. Van der Rohe walked away from the project, and the new plans, designed by Dean of the Yale School of Art and Architecture Robert Moore attempted to address the housing needs of the city’s low-income citizens.
***
When Church Street South was built in 1967, city planners across the country replaced existing buildings and streetscapes with high-rise modernist structures broken up by parking lots.
Many geared the idea of the city towards suburbanite-driven cars rather than the urban pedestrian. Moore worked against that dominant mentality. “Moore was trying to do something more enlightened than the high-rise projects that were going up in New York, Chicago, everywhere,” Rubin said.
Moore worked against more than just popular urban planning policies. Interstates, freight yards, and train tracks isolate the property from the larger downtown area. “It’s not the most sympathetic site for housing,” Architectural Historian Richard Hayes said. But Moore attempted to overcome the unfortunate realities of its location through a commitment to social justice in his architectural choices.
Looking for opportunities to create community spaces despite the inhospitable location, Moore hoped to make the Church Street South property as livable as possible. Looking back at photographs taken of the development in 1968, colorful graphics adorn the gray walls and young kids ride bikes around the tree-lined property. Accommodating the buildings’ position between heavily trafficked four-lane roads, Moore oriented the housing units inward—parents could look out their windows and watch their children playing in the courtyards, instead of at the smog-filled highway and freight yards. He crisscrossed the land with wide, grassy walkways. To give the living spaces individual
identities, he divided the property up into smaller villages with names like Christopher Green, Station Court, and Malcolm Court.
El Crudup grew up at Church Street South in the late 1970s. “It’s sad because it was a beautiful place back then, and there was a lot going on for the kids,” he said. “There were block parties, there
was no violence.” He described an idyllic childhood in a family-oriented community; he played basketball, baseball, and football with his neighbors.
Moore had a wider audience than New Haven families like Crudup’s in mind as he conceived of Church Street South’s role in New Haven. “One of Moore’s ideas was to use it as an example of city building, to make it a part of the fabric of New Haven,” Hayes said. Church Street South made the architectural headlines upon its completion—magazines in France, Germany, and Japan featured it on their covers. A bold image of one of the structures against a bright blue sky filled the cover of the May 1972 edition of Progressive Architecture.
Moore’s plan foreshadowed the trend of mixed-use complexes, which gained popularity as part of the New Urbanism movement beginning in the 1990s. Moore tried to introduce commercial spaces
within the housing development—when the site opened, a laundromat, convenience store, and offices for community agencies opened with it. “He wanted to create a microcosm of the city. It was a big gesture trying to introduce commercial and small civic scale uses that would bring life,” Hayes said.

Those commercial spaces didn’t last long—today, there are no businesses at Church Street South.

***
Soon, there won’t be any residents either. Mayor Toni Harp, ARC ’78, has projected that full relocation of the 289 families will take a year, with priority given to those already living in hotels
and those with serious health issues. “It’s a nightmare. Something should have been done years ago,” Mayor Harp told the Independent.
Long before Northland acquired the property in the 1990s, the complexes had deteriorated. Ward Six Alder Delores Colon, BR ’91, said, “I got here in 1989, and the apartments were in terrible condition.There was vermin, mold, and they needed serious repairs.”
El Crudup’s family moved out of Church Street South in 1982, when his sister bought a home in West Haven, but he lived there long enough to witness the complex’s decline. “The downturn came in late 80s and 90s, when you had the drugs come in. Once that infiltrated into the city, it hit the housing project hard.” The timing of the influx of drugs from New York was compounded with the passage of its ownership to increasingly disinterested developers. The community-oriented Church Street South of Crudup’s childhood transformed into a symbol of the city’s economic, racial, and social tensions.
Little has improved in the apartments since the 80s. Made evident by the recent, more thorough LCI inspections of the property, neither Northland, which acquired the buildings in 2007, nor the previous private owners, have invested in the maintenance of Church Street South. For decades, Northland has ignored the decaying property through a strategy of evasion. “Inside those apartments when I first tried to seek the votes of residents, they would talk to me,” Colon explained. “Things they would say: ‘Oh, I wish I didn’t live here, the owners are so terrible. You tell them things are broken and when they show up to your apartment they say they didn’t bring the right
tool.’ And then they never see the person again.”
When I walked down to Church Street on Sat., Sept. 12 with Colon, she seemed to know everyone we passed. “They don’t all know my name, but they do know me as ‘The Lady,’” she said.
Before I met her in the central courtyard, she had already run into Wanda, a tenant at Church Street South. Within minutes, Wanda took me into the apartment her parents have rented for 15 years. She
apologized for how dark it was inside, and pointed out the evidence of disrepair with the familiarity of a seasoned tour guide.
Her elderly father, an amputee, lives in a room with water-stained and molding walls. In the hallway, her family has patched a gaping hole in the wall where a fan should have been. Every time someone flips on the power switch in the bathroom, an odd whirring noise starts up as the lights flicker—they do not turn on the bathroom light anymore. Many of the outlets do not work. Upstairs, fresh curtains, family photos and potted plants brighten the living room, but black spots stain the ceiling near the windows. Wanda said that they usually try to paint over the peeling walls and mold stains, but the newly involved lawyers told the tenants not to cover anything up.
The opening text on Northland Investment Corporation’s website reads, “We own and manage our properties with a focus on customer service and long-term success.” Church Street South isn’t apparent among their property listings.
***
In 2007, Northland Investment Corporation acquired the site with the intention of gutting Church Street South and constructing a development that would capitalize on its valuable location. Although it was the only Department of Housing and Urban Development-subsided property in their portfolio, they recognized its advantageous location, so Northland began working with New Haven’s Livable City Initiative on developing a new complex. The City Plan Commission had already received funding from HUD to create a master plan for a mixed-use, mixed-income development to help connect the Hill neighborhood to downtown businesses. Church Street South fit nicely into that
picture. Erik Johnson, the former director of LCI, said, “It was a city issue since the building was on the verge of ending its useful life. There were housing code issues, and [issues with] dealing with the
relocation of 300 families in the largest concentration of four to five bedroom units in the city.”
Despite these difficulties, the 2013 Hill-to-Downtown Community Plan pointed to the repurposing of Church Street South as an opportunity to strengthen the neighborhood and connect it to the rest
of the city. It proposed 750 residential units, and included spaces for offices, retail, and entertainment centered around a public square—it named Church Street South “a new destination open space at the doorstep of downtown.”
Execution of that plan required cooperation and investment from Northland alongside a coordinated effort from the city—in the end, Northland decided that the financial and political risks outweighed the benefits of pursuing the project. Post-doctorate Chloe Taft, GRD ’14, who teaches “History of Housing in America” at Yale College, described the mentality of many private companies running affordable properties: “I’m a developer, not a social worker.” By letting Church Street South stand, they would avoid messy public opposition, and continue to receive an annual $3 million in rental subsidies from HUD. “They know they’re sitting on a gold-mine, and that parcel will only
increase in value,” DuBois-Walton said last April, before the current crisis peaked this month. Northland backed away from the project, and internal politics within New Haven stalled further action.
The fate of the site divided the Board of Alders and the Mayor’s office. Former LCI Director Erik Johnson said, “Mayor DeStefano wanted aggressive action. He wanted to pursue eminent domain, because he thought Northland was taking advantage of the city and its residents.” He tried to leverage his power at the federal level, pressuring HUD to revoke their funding of Northland. From HUD’s perspective, however, Church Street South was meeting the minimum criteria for safe and sanitary conditions, so they couldn’t defund the property on those grounds.
The Board of Alders opposed the Mayor’s Office, because, according to Johnson, they did not want to deal with the political consequences of displacing the people they represented. Colon explained her opposition to the plan: by only designing smaller one- and two-bedroom apartments, Northland failed to accommodate the larger families that under federal law have the “right to return.” Ultimately, inaction won out as Mayor DeStefano, lacking the financial and political capital, did not pursue eminent domain. Northland backed off, while continuing to make a profit, and the city turned its attention to other, less controversial redevelopment projects.
The lack of political will and a disassociated developer left Church Street South in the same deteriorated state for two more years, until the residents mobilized and demanded attention this past August. “There’s a level of urgency about Church Street South,” DeStefano said. “There’s the
emerging consensus that they need to come down—it’s not a fit solution for families.”
The attention these residents have attracted from the Harp administration and from HUD has, in fact, compelled some response from Northland as well. “You never saw Larry Gottesdiener [Northland’s chairman] quoted back in 2012, 2013,” DeStefano noted. “One thing you notice [now] is that Larry has been to New Haven several times. He’s made himself available. All of a sudden you see the principal being quoted. That’s different.” Although Gottesdiener couldn’t be reached for comment, he and Northland have been responsive to the city’s inspections. Residents generated the
requisite urgency, and now Northland has money to lose and and a public image to maintain.
***
Church Street South’s concrete courtyards buckle and sag, uneven from years of hasty patch jobs. Clear from the physical evidence at the site, Northland has invested little of its HUD-subsidized
income stream into maintaining the property.
Northland now needs to figure out how to move mounting numbers of families out of the complex and it has the help of the city, the Housing Authority of New Haven, Legal Aid, and other property owners to try to find adequate relocation options.
Since Northland has no prior experience relocating tenants in an affordable housing market, they have been meeting with HANH for assistance. Karen DuBois-Walton, HANH’s executive director, said, “We can assist with community meetings, getting real time info to residents. Then we’ll proceed with individual assessments of each household. Our role is to help residents find safe and decent housing.” According to DuBois-Walton, HANH has successfully redeveloped 1,200 units, so it can offer the community trust that Northland lacks.
On Fri., Sept. 11, Northland requested pass-through vouchers from HUD, which would transfer Northland’s subsidy to landlords offering temporary housing for displaced residents. Those vouchers are temporary, so federal housing and city officials along with Northland need to find more permanent housing solutions. Rhonda Siciliano, HUD spokesperson said, “We haven’t seen anything like this on this scale in New England. It’s complex because of the location and the shortage of affordable housing. With a large development with 301 units, it adds to the complexity of the issues we’re facing.”
Yet vouchers do not offer a instant solution. DuBois said, “The beauty of vouchers is that you can go any place. But the reality of life is that people have constraints. There might be a beautiful four-bedroom in Cheshire, but if you’re reliant on public transportation for school and a job, you can’t
move to Cheshire.” As of Sept. 10, 13 families have been living out of hotel rooms. Finding apartments for the families that need four to five bedrooms or wheelchair access will prove a major challenge, requiring a city-wide effort. “The mayor’s primary concern is the several hundred city residents who live [at Church Street South] and are made to live in substandard conditions. They are her primary concern,” spokesperson Laurence Grotheer said.

Soon after Raphael Ramos of LCI discovered the mold behind her fridge, Payne was given a notice of her relocation. She received the keys to her temporary apartment on a Friday, and the developer told her she needed to be gone by the following Monday. “I couldn’t afford the moving expenses on such short notice, so I moved everything over in my van,” she said. She has four children who need to catch the school bus every morning, and so was relieved to find that her new housing, one of the few five bedroom units available, was nearby at the South Orange affordable complex. But after the

Friday and Saturday rain storms, water flooded the floors—the new location offers little improvement.
When Payne returned to Church Street South to visit with friends, she found her old apartment boarded up. Across the courtyard, fresh plywood covered up her former windows. “They’re going to move people back into my apartment,” Payne said. Though they’ve made a commitment to move
people out in the next year, Northland may have to shuffle residents around the property as they wait for new housing options. “I will kindly tell them, they are getting set up for failure,” Payne added, as she waved around her iPhone, displaying a photo of her molded pipes.
Colon walked to the adjacent complex to knock on Mathilde Osario’s door. Colon brings her an absentee ballot every year because Osario has knee trouble, and just recently had surgery. Osario’s health has deteriorated in recent months; she raised her faded housedress to reveal a knee swollen
and scarred.
In the apartment, Colon translated Osario’s Spanish, explaining that after her apartment got inspected, she received a letter stating that the city inspectors would return. Two weeks passed, and she hadn’t heard back. Inside, the air felt dense and steamy. Osario pointed to cracks in the wall that unqualified handymen had supposedly “fixed” on previous occasions. In the bathroom, hot water gushed from the tap in the tub. It wouldn’t turn off, which accounted for the apartment’s climate. She opened the cabinet under the sink, and a swath of black mold was visible. More mold crept across the walls in her bedroom. “If they offer her a voucher, she’ll take it running,” Colon translated. She’ll get her voucher within the coming weeks or months, but where she will go is uncertain.
***
The question of how to house American cities’ many low-income residents has occupied the country for as long as New Haven has considered how to best utilize its property across from the train station.
The concept of building low-income housing developments emerged from progressive 1930s New Deal policies. “It was controversial because it faced resistance from homebuilders and real estate people who thought it would undercut the market for housing, and we still hear those same
arguments today,” Taft noted.
Initiatives that had been first viewed as opportunities for upward mobility developed the stigmas around public housing by the 1950s. Government- subsidized residences became associated with housing poor people in poor conditions. Taft said, “There was never enough funding poured in, no money for maintenance, and with maintenance budgets based on rent, low rents meant that the housing fell into disrepair—it’s harder to take pride in where you’re living.” The combination of deindustrialization and urban population loss sponsored by government programs encouraging white families to move to the suburbs contributed to the downward spiral of low-income housing.
Alongside internal infrastructure and funding shortages, those factors ghettoized low-income housing, which became a racially coded word.
New Urbanism seeks to push back against that historical trajectory which still oppresses communities like Church Street South. The focus of affordable housing should look beyond the buildings. It should operate with a set of values in mind, values that help residents exercise agency and access opportunities. “Communities work much better with services that help folks improve economic outcomes,” said DuBois-Walton.
The Church Street South of today failed in that mission. Jim Paley, director of Neighborhood Housing Services in New Haven, said, “If you are an investor-owner of property, you have two commitments: one to the people who are tenants in building. For whatever rent you are collecting, you have a responsibility to provide decent and sanitary and up-to-code apartments. The second has to do with neighborhoods. We’re rebuilding neighborhoods, with sound houses out of blighted buildings.”
It took aggressive action and the assertion of a long-denied public voice on the part of residents for Northland to recognize this two-fold responsibility. Even now, under federal and city scrutiny, media attention, and a suddenly present owner, the residents obtaining full access to their rights to safe, affordable housing remains uncertain.
Back at the property on Sept. 12, Colon and Payne discussed the recent community meeting held at the Wilson Branch of the New Haven Public Library—many residents could not attend. “We’ll hold the next one right here outside, and we’ll get chairs and tables. You need to know your rights,” Colon offered. Payne responded, “We’ll be there, and we’ll stand.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on An exodus

Opening up

People drinking Kombucha beers were filtering in and out of a fishbowl-like gallery at the end of the block. Inside the building, I joined the packed crowds to catch glimpses of hundreds of small, framed works filling the walls in dense rows. The gallery brought together work from the 350 local artists featured in City-Wide Open Studios, a month-long festival designed to activate a collaborative conversation about art in New Haven.

Artspace, a non-profit contemporary gallery positioned a block from the New Haven Green towards Union Station, has hosted Open Studios each October for the past 17 years. When I was little, my parents used to drag me here, hoping to expose me to a bit of culture. Instead, I usually spent the time running from studio to studio searching for artists who had put out bowls of candy.

Now, I can appreciate Open Studios as more than a trick-or-treating preview: it provides a space for local artists to build a creative community with participants from all around the Northeast. The festival catalyzes encounters between artists, appreciators, and the spaces they occupy. It’s helped New Haven build its art-based community, and has invited regional influences to shape it, as well.

Artspace’s Executive Director Helen Kauder said that the aim of constructing an artist community began at the event’s inception. She described a photo, taken at the end of Open Studios’s first year, of the participating artists standing together and shaking hands in front of the main building. “Many had just met each other for the first time,” Kauder said. “Open Studios connected them and created a community.”

This year, Artspace divided the Open Studios events into four weekends. The first included the Friday night exhibition opening at the Orange St. gallery, while the second featured the immersive, alternative space of the Goffe St. Armory, a 240,00 square foot former warehouse for which 18 site-specific works had been commissioned through grants from the Warhol Foundation and The National Endowment for the Arts. The third weekend brought visitors to private studios around New Haven, and the fourth unfolded at Erector Square, a former toy factory in Fair Haven that’s been repurposed for studio spaces. While Open Studios ended a few weeks ago, the work displayed at the Armory in particular demonstrates its power to expand the reach of the artistic community for artists and visitors alike.

***

Barbara Marks, one of the artists whose work was exhibited in the Armory, said her space in the Armory strengthened her pieces and facilitated new connections with her audience. Tucked away on the fourth floor of the space, her assigned room had blue paint peeling away to reveal the crumbling masonry beneath. She displayed a large wall installation of 625 small canvasses painted with colorful rock shapes, inspired by Tibetan prayer flags. Marks described “the play of light and shadow off the wall, with the blue paint chipped away to reveal odd white shapes,” which she said “evoked the sky and clouds you’d see behind these flags if they were displayed on a mountaintop.” Marks told me that she participates in Open Studios each year “to give back to the community, to open the studio door outside of the preciousness of an exhibition.”

Engineer and artist Scott Schuldt said that, in the weeks leading up to Open Studios, he had to resolve spatial and suspension problems in his own designated space in order to address the needs of the 18 other artists installing com- missions, and to deal with a week-long power outage that left the Armory in the dark up until the week before the opening. He displayed his own work in a double stairwell that leads to the main entrance, hanging canoe paddles from the ceiling and decking the walls with framed copper boxes of specimens he had collected while canoeing and hiking. On the experience of working with the other artists, Schuld said, “I liked pretty much 175 of [the artists]. There are five we won’t talk about. But that’s a pretty good ratio if we think about mankind. That says a lot of good stuff about artists.” Working within the parameters of the Armory not only allowed for adaptability and responsiveness in the art itself, but also built upon the interactions among the art- ists, many of whom were encountering each other, and each other’s work, for the first time.

Just outside Schuldt’s stairway, Allison Hornak spent Saturday and Sunday on the Armory lawn. With one leg strapped into a wooden four-by-four cube, Hornak attempted to paint the missing limb she couldn’t see on the other fives sides of the box. She said that the work, titled A Struggle, A Painting in Two Acts, “relit a crucial fire” in her career. Hornak performed outside, in the rain, for a total of 12 hours, and said she hadn’t taken into account the physical pain the performance would demand. Sarah Fritchey, Artspace Gallery Manager, praised the work in the context of the goals of Open Studios. “We’re not going to make easy art. We’re going outside of where we normally operate,” Fritchey said. Hornak’s work contributed to a weekend that she said was about “talking to people face to face” and “being around art close together.” She said that this process is “being a part of real history, where your history is other people’s history.”

Artspace hopes to return Open Studios to the Armory for a weekend again next year, but the organization will continue to adapt the program to best speak to the New Haven community. Kauder told me that Artspace is planning to commission projections for the Armory façade, with an advanced video mapping technology that recognizes the form it’s projected onto, transforming, transcribing, and talking back to it. Expanding the Artspace show into November, Open Studios will plan opportunities for artists to meet with one another, debrief, and take stock of the intensive October period. These plans speak to the progressive cultivation, and gradual evolution, of the New Haven art scene. Fritchey described the developments in terms of dialogue: “We need to look at each other’s work, and push each other.’’

-Graphic by Alex Swanson

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opening up

A toxic asset

“A substantial threat,” the Coast Guard said in a statement on Tues., Sept. 30 concerning an oil spill leaking into New Haven’s Mill River. The contamination he referred to stems from English Station in Fair Haven, an abandoned toxic power plant that has afflicted the environment, government, and community for the past two decades. Backed by the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and Connecticut’s Department of Energy and Environmental Protection (DEEP), Coast Guard boats have been patrolling the river for the past two weeks, attempting to clean the waters and assess damage.

But the Coast Guard’s latest warnings merely echo the many about the plant that have accumulated over the years. City officials, state agencies, environmental activists, and New Haven locals alike have been advocating for action for decades, but unreliable and irresponsible owners have repeatedly prevented the cleanup and redevelopment of the site.

Situated in Fair Haven just one and a half miles east of Cross Campus on a small island in the middle of the Mill River, English Station has been the focal point of New Haven’s industrial transformation and decline, the formation of an environmental justice movement, and decades of clashes among the interests of the local community, the Connecticut state government, and predatory real estate companies. Right now, the plant is a vacant “weapon of mass contamination,” according to local environmental activist Aaron Goode, a member of the executive board of the Downtown and Wooster Square Community Management Team.

Currently, the plant can be classified as a “mothballed brownfield,” a contaminated industrial site whose owners refuse to adopt a feasible plan for reuse. A potentially unstable structure, the plant is susceptible to severe weather patterns—one major storm could jeopardize water quality, public health, and the city’s economy. Unless the current web of litigation is resolved or more accountable owners take over the site, the degradation of English Station could potentially prove disastrous for the larger Fair Haven area and the surrounding environment.

***

“Somber, huge, mysterious—seen only from a distance beyond locked gates—this building towers over the dark river. Futurist fantasies, reveries of medieval strongholds, and electric minarets in a white cloud of smoke produce one of the city’s most haunting architectural images,” reads an excerpt from Elizabeth Mills Brown’s 1976 book New Haven: A Guide to Architecture and Urban Design. Despite the nearly 40-year gap separating its publication and the moment when I stood on Grand Avenue gazing at English Station last Wednesday, this description still applies.

Brown captured the essence of the now abandoned power plant, built in the 1920s and in operation until 1991. As I stood facing the plant’s home, Ball Island, on a weed-lined sidewalk littered with broken glass and disintegrating food wrappers, I tried to imagine English Station in its prime, when United Illuminating (UI) operated it for powering the city’s factories.

In 1881, a group of local businessmen founded UI, originally named the New Haven Electric Light Company. New Haven soon became one of the first cities in America to be lit by electricity. To accommodate the increased post-war demand for electricity, UI built English Station on an island in the center of Mill River. The area was initially a fishing village situated over marshland, but the neighborhood soon expanded and urbanized. With a steady power supply, factories operated more efficiently, and streetcar lines brought residents directly from their homes to the Winchester Repeating Arms Factory, a major employment hub. According to Corsets and Clocks, Carriages and Locks, a book about the industrial history of New Haven, English Station provided power to more than 120,000 individuals, businesses, and industrial customers within a year of its construction. Over the course of the next decade, UI continued to expand the capacity of the station and build up the landmass at Ball Island.

The plant was initially fired by coal until UI converted it into a gas plant in the 1940s. English Station continued to provide power to the city of New Haven until the early 1990s, when the outdated equipment made the plant no longer economically feasible to run. The amount of power it could produce wasn’t worth the cost of fuel combined with the polluting impacts of burning diesel. Decades of coal sludge, metals, and cancerous PCBs accumulated on the site, seeping into the structure of the building and the surrounding soil. Other companies must have realized this, too. Failing to find a buyer, UI sat on this unwieldy, toxic asset for several years. Eventually, in 2000, UI paid the company Quinnipiac Energy 4.25 million dollars to take the plant off its hands.

***

The EPA defines environmental justice as “the fair treatment and meaningful involvement of all people…with respect to the development, implementation, and enforcement of environmental laws, regulations, and policies.” Across the United States, the placement of transfer stations, polluting industries, and waste management facilities frequently leads to environmental injustice. Often, policies force low-income neighborhoods to suffer the burden of environmental costs from proximity to toxic plants like English Station. Quinnipiac Energy’s plans for the site fit this trajectory of violating this ideal of a shared environmental hazard burden.

Quinnipiac Energy’s first and only attempt to make the plant economically viable triggered mass community action and the formation of an environmental justice movement in New Haven. When Quinnipiac Energy assumed the property, they planned to convert English Station into a peaking plant. Peaking plants produce energy only at times of highest demand—the height of the summer, for example, when businesses and homes run air conditioners. Quinnipiac Energy planned to provide this power to upper-middle class areas in Fairfield County and Long Island, rather than the surrounding working class, low-income neighborhood of Fair Haven.

Christel Manning, the former president of the New Haven Environmental Justice Network (NHEJN), described that it would aggravate New Haven air quality, making it among the worst in the nation during the summer. At the time that Quinnipiac Energy took over, child asthma rates in New Haven were three times the national average. Manning said, “This neighborhood was going to suffer so that people in Long Island could get cheap power.” Lee Cruz, the community outreach director at the Community Foundation for Greater New Haven, added to this picture. “Many Fair Haven residents can’t afford air conditioning, so in the summer they’re opening up their windows and breathing in the toxins,” he said.

In response, these activists, alongside other citizens-turned-activists, mounted a campaign to stop Quinnipiac Energy from converting English Station to a peaking plant. Local environmentalists joined a group of Fair Haven residents to form the NHEJN. “The regulatory process gives the public the opportunity to partake in community decisions,” said Lynne Bonnett, a board member of the Greater New Haven Green Fund and former chair of the NHEJN. “We can educate ourselves and get polluting facilities to pay attention to what they are doing, and how they can help.”

As a result of their efforts to call attention to the situation in Fair Haven, the organization connected with the national environmental movement, seeking to illustrate how poor people end up bearing the brunt of pollution and environmental hazards. Manning cited zoning codes that have contributed in part to this trend—because cities tend to have industrial zoning rights, it’s easier for companies to build polluting plants in urban centers. But government regulation isn’t fully responsible for environmental injustice. People with resources can better defend themselves and their property, triggering a recurring cluster of trash incinerators, dumps, and other polluters in poorer communities. No one wants an environmental hazard in their backyard, but low-income neighborhoods often lack the time, funding, or resources to combat these decisions.

Despite these systemic hurdles, the NHEJN held meetings, staged rallies, and attended hearings to push their message and mission. Bonnett explained that the NHEJN made the movement easy for people to understand and ultimately support. The odds weren’t exactly stacked in their favor, though. Manning explained the basic premise behind environmental regulation—when a company wants to open a polluting facility, their permit must fall within the state’s pollution guidelines. But these regulations don’t account for clustered facilities or peaking plants, which typically fall well below the limit of the allotted energy use per year. At the state environmental hearings, overseen by the DEP, the agency then in charge, Quinnipiac Energy’s measurements continued to meet the necessary criteria. The committee recommended approval for the peaking plant permits.

But then Richard Blumenthal, LAW ’73, the Connecticut attorney general at the time, intervened: he threatened to sue the DEP if they upheld their own committee’s findings. This action thrust the DEP Commissioner, Arthur Roque, into the spotlight of what had turned into an impending legal and environmental mess. Roque, with an eye towards upcoming changes in national EPA regulations, overturned the committee’s ruling on the proposal. “The commissioner has the power to accept or modify proposals,” said Dennis Schain, the current spokesperson for DEEP, the agency that replaced DEP. “To totally deny it is unusual. To this date, that doesn’t happen often.” In the final decision, Roque wrote, “I believe that the costs or impacts, both real and potential, of reopening a power plant that could have a detrimental impact on the health of the residents of New Haven outweigh the proposed benefits the small amount of electric power the plant will provide to the New England grid.” He added, “Solutions to real societal needs or problems, be they energy shortages or air pollution, are only indirectly served and the most environmentally sound solution is even more tangential.” The tenets of environmental justice had formed the basis of the language of his decision.

Bonnett, of the NHEJN, commented on the personal consequences of the decision, calling it a fluke: “Art Roque took a tremendous amount of heat from the industry doing what he did.” Roque retired within the year. Depending who you ask, his decision either led to the downfall of his career or it represents his parting gift to the State of Connecticut. Both the environmental activists and the former New Haven city government officials I spoke with reflected on this ruling with gratitude. “The DEP Commissioner had a lot of credit. He didn’t get a lot of support from his boss, but he did it. It was a big victory for New Haven,” said Robert Smuts, SM ’01, the city chief administrative officer in John DeStefano’s mayoral administration.

Despite this initial victory, it soon became clear that finding a solution for English Station would continue to present a formidable challenge for the community and New Haven at large.

***

Once the Fair Haven neighborhood and the statewide environmental justice movement finished celebrating, remediation for English Station stagnated. Over 10 years have passed now, but the power plant still sits empty, haunting Ball Island and towering over the Mill River District. The legal disputes, environment hazards, and government interventions, however, haven’t ceased.

A few years after Roque denied their permits, Quinnipiac Energy sold the plant to two companies, Asnat Realty and Evergreen Power. Since then, the record of responsible ownership has not improved. Granted, touching the property requires a serious investment in decontamination procedures, because the site is practically a toxic bomb from the asbestos, PCBs, and almost a century of oil and coal contaminants that have soaked into the soil and lace the plant’s entire structure. “The current owners are pursuing a demolition by neglect strategy,” Smuts said. Power stations are built substantially, with internal steel structures, but the lack of maintenance and its exposed position on the island leave it vulnerable to potential collapse. Neither residents living and working down the street nor people driving down the heavily trafficked Interstate-91 can neglect its presence, or its impact on the space.

Asnat and Evergreen in turn tried to hand off the property to another company, also called Ball Island, in 2010. The closing kept getting delayed. During this time, Asnat and Evergreen, without filing for permission, tried to sell some of the oil from the old transformers in the plant to an oil recycling facility, which ended up reporting the incident to the EPA. The oil was 99 percent contaminated by PCBs, cancer causing toxins that have been banned by the EPA since 1979. “Oil from old transformers is going to have PCBs. You don’t need a PhD from the Yale Forestry School to know that,” said Aaron Goode, of the Downtown and Wooster Square Development Team. When Ball Island heard about this incident, and the subsequent investigations by the EPA and DEEP, they attempted to drop the deal. They hoped to evade the burden of these mounting legal problems and possession of the toxic property.

While this case has been pending, the tensions between ownership, environmental damage, and Connecticut’s regulatory powers have continued in full force. In the spring of 2013, the Connecticut attorney general’s office and DEEP issued an administrative order calling for a cleanup of the site. In compliance with environmental policy, all owners, previous and current, have responsibility to address the contamination. Britton Rogers, ARC ’14, who studied Environmental Design at the Yale School of Architecture and serves on the board of directors of the Urban Resources Initiative at the Yale School of Forestry and Environmental Studies, summed up the situation: “It’s intended to be confusing. No one wants to take possession.”

Consistent with previous attempts to evade accountability for the property, the owners contested the order. According to DEEP spokesperson Dennis Schain, it’s currently wrapped up in court. “Because of the costs involved in cleanup, people are not eagerly stepping in and assuming them,” Shain said. “It often takes time and pressure and lots of legal wrangling on some sites to get cleanup underway.” All signs point to more time, increased pressure, and extended legal wrangling for all parties involved in English Station.

As I learned more about the impossibly complicated and dangerously neglected property, I wondered if there is any end in sight to the stagnation. New Haven’s Economic Development Administrator Matthew Nemerson, SOM ’81, offered a different perspective, countering the voices that lauded the peaking plant decision as a victory. He argued that the reopening of English Station as a peaking plant would have necessarily spurred the same actions that environmentalists are now asking for. “It was a metaphoric concern,” Nemerson said. “These neighborhoods tend to get treated badly by industries. People pollute and walk away. But it probably would have resulted in cleanup and brought in taxes and jobs.” In fact, according to Nemerson, most of the pollution that affects Connecticut actually comes from Ohio.

The current reality of legal and political entrenchment is daunting. UI still carries some of the liability in their accounts, but the question of what portion of cleanup each past and present owner should assume is unclear and contentious. Stewardship of the property has been neglectful at best and deleterious at worst, not only for the property, but also for Fair Haven, the Mill River, and New Haven as a whole.

At one point, Asnat and Evergreen pursued an ill-conceived demolition strategy that the city halted because it endangered the environment, according to Smuts. Recently the two companies discussed a preliminary plan to convert the station into residences, but power plants rarely translate well into homes or offices, because, unlike factories, they aren’t built for a human scale.

For most involved parties, the most attractive solution would entail the preservation of the historic structure, not its demolition. The building’s Gothic arches, high windows, and intricate detailing along the upper brickwork serve as physical reminders of the plant’s significance to the city’s history. In a rare moment of clarity in an otherwise entangled affair, the economic, environmental, and historical interests might just intersect. The question remains exactly how.

***

The day after visiting English Station I walked down tree-lined State Street to the offices of the New Haven Preservation Trust. The offices fill a converted Victorian home that bears the oval blue plaque that signifies its designation on the National Register of Historic Places. If English Station were added to this registry, remediation could be potentially sped up. I meet with Preservation Services Officer John Herzan in a simple, light-filled room. Herzan pulled one of the Historic Resources Inventory volumes from the shelves. Connecticut amassed this list of historical and architectural properties in the 1980s. “The state regards it as a historic place even though it hasn’t been officially listed. Connecticut has a wealth of these industrial sites,” Herzan said.

According to Anstress Farwell, the President of the New Haven Urban Design League, the State Historic Preservation Office has indicated interest in designating a district of the city that would include the power station and a nearby trolley barn, thematically connecting its industrial and architectural history. At this point, English Station has not been formally nominated. Trying to untangle the legal struggles, determine ownership, and assign responsibility for cleanup seems to supercede concerns regarding its historic status.

At the same time, the historic weight of the property is evident, as is its central role in New Haven’s history. The grand Art Deco style plays on its identity as a power station, and self-referential motifs such as lightning bolts represent this idea. Farwell said that during the 1920s, when English Station was under construction, factories, streetcar owners, and power companies jumpstarted the use of electric power in cities around Connecticut and around the country. They faced public concern over electricity; many people thought it would be dangerous in the home. To combat this image, “A lot of power companies built something that suggested a larger civic purpose,” Farwell told me. “They could be put into plain sheds, but what they did was create something with enormous weight and gravity and design that was really a civic presence, an institution on par with others in the city.” Britton Rogers similarly praised the physical presence of the plant: “It’s a cathedral of power generation.” Throughout the 1920s, Farwell said that companies invested in architecture to establish faith and goodwill in a community, while simultaneously combating skepticism and fear regarding urban industrialization.

These themes of community faith and goodwill eroded over the course of the century. The abandoned power plant stands as a constant, looming portent of future environmental calamities, a corrosive vacuum where remediation could provide the key to the economic betterment of Fair Haven. Examples of successfully redeveloped and cleaned up power plants provide hope for this site. In London, Bankside Power Station was transformed into the Tate Modern. In Seattle in the 1970s, the architect Richard Haag executed a plan that converted the property around a rusting and decrepit power plant into a public space, called Gasworks Park. He left the plant standing as a sculptural civic element, fencing the actual structure off but covering the ground in new soil to seal off the toxicity. Now, visitors can explore the landscaped hills and children can play in a piece of the structure that has been converted into a play barn. Seattle bought the property for park purposes in the sixties, so the community never dealt with the ongoing ownership battles that English Station has faced.

Rogers, who graduated this past spring, enrolled in Wild Urbanism, a School of Architecture course, in which he envisioned an alternate future for English Station. The class focused on reclaiming abandoned industrial sites, and the students had to identify locations in New Haven to “reuse, rejuvenate, and remediate,” Rogers said. He chose English Station for his project, proposing the use of green space and plants to remediate the soil and transform the station into a biofuel power generator. The plants used for cleaning the soil could then be burned in the station for fuel, establishing a cycle of sustainability. “I thought that with the towers and roof lines, the smoke stacks on top of the plant could be used as a bird sanctuary. It’s right on the river, situated on a corridor for bird migration.” Siding with the historic preservation contingent, Rogers is firmly against demolition: “It’s the best thing on the skyline.”

***

City officials seem inclined to agree with Rogers’ desire to preserve the structure. As I was exploring the area around English Station, I came across several fresh white street signs branded with a black image of the power station, designed to fuse the historic and the futurist. The title “Mill River District” sits on top of the graphic; the bottom reads “Made in New Haven.” At first, it seems ironic that this recently conceived rebranding strategy would showcase the symbol of the neighborhood’s decline and subsequent inertia, but at the same time, that image signifies a reimagined future for the plant.

DeStefano’s administration commissioned the Mill River District Planning Study and Redevelopment Framework in 2014, which laid plans for job growth, a build up of coastal resiliency, and expanding industrial and commercial bases. Mike Piscitelli, New Haven’s deputy economic development administrator, said, “One of the real insights we got from the study was that the Mill River lacked identity. We tasked design consultants to create identity for the district, to find something to capture it. You can see the plant anywhere from the district, and it has a deeper symbolism in that visual identity for the area.”

Matthew Nemerson, another New Haven economic administrator, added, “When you have a massive box with huge smokestacks in the middle of an island in the middle of town, you become iconic for good and for bad.” The proliferation of that image in rebranding the neighborhood serves as a subtle reminder for the work left ahead, particularly in light of the recent oil leak and the ongoing ownership litigation. While Goode called the plant “the linchpin of reactivating the area,” Nemerson recognized the difficulties that this reality represents. “Obviously we will be doing lots of reimaging and reinvesting in Mill River before we start getting to the power plant,” he said.

But with the ongoing oil leak threat, English Station may not be able to wait another 23 years. On Tuesday, after hearing about this latest development in the perpetual saga on the Mill River, I contacted Nemerson again. He offered some words of assurance, “It’s clear what our powers are in terms of regulatory enforcement and what the mayor’s powers are from the bully pulpit. We’ll be on top of this.”

It’s unclear if this latest disaster will finally urge the owners into action, or if English Station will continue to poison the environment and threaten the safety of the Mill River District. Without a change in ownership, progress seems unattainable. When I asked Mayor John DeStefano about the future of the site, he responded, “It’s a puzzle. This may be a piece of property whose future doesn’t get resolved for a number of years. Keep an eye on what happens between I-91 and the Mill River.”

 

-Graphic by Zachary Schiller

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on A toxic asset

The fourth dimension

When I woke up on Thurs. morning, it didn’t occur to me that five hours later I would end up sitting in a red armchair holding hands with a stranger as he sang “And I Am Telling You I’m Not Going” to me.

But I should have—particularly after having coffee with Yale School of Art Director of Graduate Studies in Sculpture Martin Kersels. Kersels dresses his large, unwieldy body in dark tops with open vests and jeans. A pair of purple glasses in a geometric version of a cat-eye shape frames his face. I admitted to Kersels upon meeting him that I don’t have much of a background in performance art; I learned from our conversation that the only way to define performance art is to not define it at all. Kersels likes to think of “performance as sculpture in time.”

This definition makes particular sense coming from Kersels, who currently teaches a class at the School of Art titled “Performance as Object.” With it, he strives to create an environment free of dogma, stressing that he “doesn’t want to back [his students] into a corner in terms of what they think of as performance.” It’s a necessary move, he argues, because standards shift so radically depending on the performance. Even responding to the same prompt, artists will carry out the results in completely different directions. Rules become irrelevant.

It sounds like a lofty ideal to speak so abstractly about an art grounded in something so primitive and physical as the body. After all, in performance art, “The body becomes both the subject and the object,” Kersels told me. Henry Wolf, TC ’16, an undergraduate in Kersels’ class, views it as an extension of more precedented forms of art. “I think that artists realized that they could be a part of their sculpture,” Wolf said, “and that they could put their body into their work and activate it that way.” Samantha Vernon, ART ’15, explained that performance art has allowed her to understand the agency of the body with greater specificity, while adding texture to her work. Wolf described this additional layer, the body in time, as a “fourth dimension” present in performance.

 

IT WAS WITH THIS MYTHIC FOURTH DIMENSION in mind that I set out for 36 Edgewood, the School of Art’s sculpture building, for Kersels’ Thurs. “Performance as Object” class. This week, five students simultaneously performed individual two-hour pieces in spaces spread throughout the building.

As I stepped into the elevator, large, blank sheets of paper taped to fishing wire obscured my view of the artist, Shahrzad Changalvaee, ART ‘15. She was leaning forward, facing the wall, her lips pressed against a sheet of paper, speaking. Occasionally lapsing into a mutter, she said, “What man has made man has always able to make again.” Later, she told me that she was recording her conversations, but removing the forms of words in the process.

By the time I found Constanza Alarcon, ART ’15, she had worked her way up to the top floor, moving up the stairs in a low crouch as she scraped white dust into jagged cracks in the concrete floors. Alarcon wanted to call attention to the double standard represented by these cracks. “This super strong, fancy building is breaking apart,” she noted. “I wanted to highlight this tension.” She also acknowledged the second level of interpretation inherent in her work. A janitor had already washed off the dust on the third floor landing. In this world of performance art, the two-hour framework is fleeting—everything, including our bodies and the spaces we work in, is moving towards dissolution. Kersels explores similar themes in his work, focusing on the scientific fact of entropy taking over our bodies and our environments.

In the discussion and critique that followed, Kersels summed up my feelings well: “In hindsight, all the pieces left a lingering discomfort.” I felt uncomfortable watching Changalvaee’s body contorting to speak into the paper; having a stranger serenade me to a power ballad; hearing one artist tell off-color jokes while targeting the online presence of people sitting in the room; watching as another artist aimed his camera at me through a glass window, inviting my participation in a selfie. Still, over the course of the two hours I also felt confused, I laughed, I despaired. I thought about what it means to expose one’s self to potential scrutiny, judgment, and wonder—and use the body to do so.

I had entered the Sculpture Building that afternoon with my head up and my eyes open, ready to stumble from one performance to the next. At the end of the afternoon, I walked out with my eyes fixed to the floor, tracing the cracks that ran under my feet.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The fourth dimension

Framing a vandal

“BOOBZ.” Not a word that someone strolling around campus would expect to see affixed to the Yale University Art Gallery (YUAG). But on Tues., April 1, a plaque engraved with this text mysteriously appeared on the steps of the YUAG: “NATIONAL REGISTER OF HISTORIC PLACES. This plaque marks the site on which Sam Dilvan used a felt marker to scrawl the minimalist yet emotionally complex tag ‘BOOBZ,’ preceding such works of artistic genius as ‘ASS BUTT’ and ‘GILF MAGNET.’ This oc- curred during his oft-celebrated ‘BALLZ’ period. Although the original is no longer visible, Dilvan’s penchant for using words carelessly throughout his environment remains a guiding force in modern society and culture.”

This piece of street art, created by the New Haven guerilla artist Be- lieve in People, or BiP, as a sort of April Fools’ Joke, challenges its viewer to question assumptions of artistic value, permanence, and the intersec- tion of high and low culture. In a city whose resources and spaces are dominated by an institution of higher learning, it seems to say: there’s something to be learned from the streets, too.

***

“Sam Dilvan” is an anagram for vandalism—the medium of all the works that BiP has created around New Haven, and, more recently, Brooklyn, Detroit and Hong Kong. His pieces, spray-paint and stencil murals that include portraits of Geronimo (pasted to the wall of Skull and Bones’ tomb), a young man aiming a spray paint gun at his head, and Anne Frank (on a Crown Street building), began popping up overnight around New Haven beginning in Oct. 2010. Though BiP has successfully kept his identity hidden throughout this time, he has leaked small bits of his biography along the way: he allegedly graduated from Princeton in 2007 and pursued a “2-percenter” job in finance before a near-death experience led him into graffiti—tagging the institutions he had once been inside.

Robert Storr, Dean of the Yale Art School, points out that BiP “is not a nontraditional artist, and he’s working in a known tradition.” In many ways, Storr is right. In the 1970s, graffiti plastering subway cars prolifer- ated across New York City, a symbol of blight and decline. It represented the reign of the unsanctioned—a raising of the middle finger to the eco- nomic, political, and social institutions of the city. But while the spray painters of this era wanted to impart permanence in their transgression of these boundaries, a new decade marked a turning point for this phe- nomenon. In 1981, Keith Haring, who started his career with spray paint cans in subway tunnels, displayed his work at the Shafrazi Gallery in New York. Seven years earlier, Tony Shafrazi had painted the words “KILL LIES ALL” over Picasso’s Guernica at MOMA in political protest. The culture of vandalism effectively came full circle in this moment: one convicted vandal sanctioned another vandal as an artist worthy of legalized, high- brow public exposure. Haring’s work began to sell at high prices. Today, 30 years later, I carry around a Keith Haring water bottle.

The BiP plaque, coincidentally mounted on April Fools’ Day, has taken a similarly circular journey through the New Haven art scene. When the YUAG discovered the plaque, they removed it; it was illegally defacing property. Almost immediately, however, the museum’s director, Jock Reynolds, recognized an opportunity
for thoughtful dialogue: he had the plaque reinstalled in a glass case in front of the gallery the following Thursday. The move transformed and legitimized the piece as public art (rather than street art or vandalism). Finally, the Gallery decided that they would give the artist two weeks to claim the piece, or they would offer it to the annual auction of Artspace, a local, non-profit gallery. BiP, whose sustained anonymity calls to mind the internationally renowned Banksy, protested. The New Haven Independent quoted BiP as saying, “I loved this piece. It might be the first half-decent piece of art I’ve made. But I would rather see it destroyed than corrupted. It’s not morally justifiable to auction a piece of public art.” Perry Obee, an employee of the the YUAG and a New Haven artist, offered an explanation for BiP’s reaction. “The illicit nature of street art adds a sense of immediacy and importance to the artist’s message.”

Enter Artspace, which seems to occupy an intermediate on the spec- trum between Yale and New Haven street art. Sarah Fritchey, Artspace’s visual arts coordinator and gallery manager agreed with the principle of keeping graffiti art away from the gallery space. This story of blurred (or desecrated) lines between vandalism, cultural capitalism, and avant- garde art is echoed in the fate of some of Banksy’s work. In an attempt to bring art to the lower and middle classes, he stenciled work on the sides of gas stations. Recognizing an opportunity for profit, several of these gas station owners removed the sides of their buildings and sold them at auc- tion. Artistic intent and artistic value, on both the cultural and monetary ends of the spectrum, frequently get sidelined or ignored.

Here, with BiP, the narrative might be heading in a different direction. After all, Artspace’s mission describes their goal as “to catalyze artistic activities; connect contemporary artists, audiences, and resources; and to enrich art experiences and activate art spaces.” Helen Kauder, the director of Artspace, said, “We are grateful for the gesture the Yale Art Gallery has made, but we have a responsibility to the wishes of an artist. We want to advocate for them in the way that they wish.” BiP has offered Artspace a replica, and Artspace will not auction off the piece.

***

This controversy came at a timely moment for Artspace as they plan an exhibit that will open this summer, called “Vagaries of the Commons.” The exhibit will pose the question of who has access to what resources, focusing on public space. While at quick glance the YUAG represents the traditional, conservative “institution” in opposition to the open, accessible presence of street art, the YUAG may doesn’t necessar- ily fit the bill as a target for BiP’s satirical work. Free and open to the public, the gallery functions as a teaching museum. In fact, its mission overlaps with that of Artspace, which both emphasize an educational goal. Perhaps, at the end of the day, BiP’s plaque is testament that

the amorphous artist really does “believe in people” and their ability to take an April Fools’ joke just
seriously enough.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Framing a vandal

17 million Hillhouse Ave.

What can Yale do with 17 million dollars? Pay a full-time professor for 94 years. Pay full tuition for 290 students. Complete 85 percent of the renovations on Sterling Memorial Library. Or, renovate one house. This September, University Provost Ben Polak announced in a campus-wide email that the President’s House at 43 Hillhouse Avenue would be undergoing a 17 million dollar renovation, entirely funded by an anonymous gift. The staggering price tag of the project has been raising a few eyebrows, as well as voices, around campus over the past six months.

Renovations on the residence actually began last summer and should finish this coming fall, when President Salovey, GRD ’86, his wife Marta Moret, SPH ’84, and their dog Portia will move in.

To complicate the perception of this project, just after the announcement of the renovation, news of Yale’s 39 million dollar budget deficit spread throughout campus. Budget cuts, layoffs, and reductions in funding followed. With the backdrop of the deficit, the renovations were cast in further doubt.

As high as 17 million dollars sounds, the original budget was even higher. Polak scaled back the original plans in order to cut down on the cost. “We went through and looked for ways to do things more cheaply and cut things out of the project,” he said in an inter- view. It’s possible that the roof may still leak because a repair was removed from the plans. An expensive HVAC system was cut and the second floor air conditioning system along with the design for its fence were ultimately lessened. Neither President Salovey nor President Levin have been involved in the renovations because of a conflict of interest. “The capital projects process was altered because the president usually plays a big role, but he was removed from the decision making here,” said Judith Chevalier, co-chair of the University Budget Committee.

There are 17 million other ways for donors to spend 17 million dollars, such as endowing more professorships, hiring more professionals to help with student mental health, and raising wages for facilities workers. At face (and numerical) value, the project sounds exorbitant. But if Salovey uses the home at its full capacity and for its ideal purpose, then the space has the potential to better foster community, tradition, and connections for all of Yale—from matriculation to life past commencement.

***

Both Mark Twain and Charles Dickens called Hillhouse Avenue, where the President’s House stands, the most beautiful street in America. The street originated as the urban center of an agricultural region transforming into a city, a process that accelerated after the Revolution- ary War and into the early 19th century. Henry Farnam, an upstate New York farm boy turned railroad magnate, settled in New Haven and built the mansion at 43 Hillhouse in 1871. Its original incarnation as an elaborate, turreted Victorian Gothic structure stood until the 1930s. When Charles Seymour became the first Yale president to inhabit the house, after Farnam bequeathed his home to the University, the house underwent a major facelift. “[President Seymour’s] wife refused to live in such a monstrosity,” said Yale archivist Judy Schiff, “because by that time, this very high Gothic style had become very unfashionable and the style of the day was Colonial Revival.” Except for some minor updates and improvements, the over- all structure of the house has remained unchanged since the transformation from Victorian to Colonial in 1934.

Considering the number of decades that have passed since then, renovation was ultimately necessary: the house was in desperate need of repair. Window frames were rot- ting, the structure was not up to fire code, the electrical wiring proved hazardous, and the inefficient heating and cooling systems needed updating. According to Polak, “the furniture was famously falling apart.” The renovations aim to make the house easier to run for the staff. In addition, the house also functions as a mini-museum, displaying major artworks from the collection at the Yale University Art Gallery. The safety of the paintings on view required both security and sprinkler system improvements.

The planned improvements range beyond the operational. Polak stressed the identity of the house as a gateway to Yale, and a gateway must be accessible. “The only way you could get a wheelchair in there was going down the driveway and then taking a tiny service elevator that only a small wheelchair could navigate,” he said. The construction of handicap-accessible bath- rooms and the installment of an elevator will fill this gap. Accessibility is the most important aspect of president’s house, as it serves as much more than just a liv- ing space. Salovey, along with his wife and dog, will occupy an apartment on the top floor—the majority of the house provides a gathering place for the community and visitors. Traditionally, parents drop off their freshmen here on the opening days of school, and return at graduation. The president welcomes new faculty, visiting professors, and donors in the bottom two floors of the house. Both Prime Minister Tony Blair and former Presi- dent George W. Bush, DC ’68 were recently hosted there.

Salovey will be the first president to live at 43 Hill- house since 1986, when former president A. Bartlett Giamatti, SY ’60, and his wife moved out. When he was President, Giamatti’s successor, Benno C. Schmidt, Jr., TC ’63, LAW ’66, maintained residence in New York, and attracted criticism for his physical distance from campus. Most recently, President Levin, GRD ’74, lived with his family in East Rock. Salovey’s decision to re- turn to the House at the center of campus is a promising prospect for his connection to students and the com- munity. “He’ll be picking up his newspaper in the morn- ing in his pajamas and he’ll see students running past up to science hill—if they’re up that early,” said Polak.

While a pajama-clad Salovey on Science Hill in the ear- ly morning may seem like wishful thinking, it’s clear that Salovey has shown a commitment to making Hillhouse Avenue more accessible to all within the Univeristy. On a warm Sunday in mid-October, Yalies, professors, and community members all flooded the street to celebrate the president’s inauguration. “It was treating Hillhouse as a public space that could have bluegrass music being played, children running around, and students singing,” Polak said. “Having Peter be right there as a part of that will add to student life, and it will make him very connected to the community.” Salovey could extend that moment of celebration in New Haven and Yale if the house continues to be a microcosm of the spirit of that day.

***

“When I occasionally traveled with President Levin we saw the houses of other college and university presidents and they often looked well appointed and impressive,” commented Penelope Laurans, Master of Jonathan Edwards College. “I am not saying we have to compete for elegance. But Yale should have a president’s house worthy of its name. It should be safe for the fabulous art displayed therein, i.e. secure and safe from fire or damage. It should be workable for the staff who have to run literally scores of events. It should be comfortable for the president’s family. It hasn’t been any of those things and it is pleasing that it will be.”

Now, blue fencing and scaffolding obscures parts of the house, and a wide array of trucks that only my six-year-old cousin could name clog the driveway, the backyard, and the short stretch of pavement in front. Yet in a few months the vehicles will drive off, the construction fences will come down, and the grass will regrow. Yalies and New Haven residents will have the opportunity to wander the sizeable gardens that will open up as public space behind the house. As an in- vestment in a space to cultivate community and spirit, this 17 million dollars promises to be well spent.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on 17 million Hillhouse Ave.