Author Archives | Lane Barton

Student representatives influence policy from Governing Board Committees

Frontpage_Cooper-Ellis_StudentsonBoard_6

Illustration by Sophie Cooper-Ellis.

From Nov. 5 to Nov. 7, Whitman’s Board of Trustees will convene for their fall meeting. While the Board holds ultimate power over the college, students do not have voice or vote on the board. But after years of requests from ASWC for greater representation, in 2013 the Board of Trustees agreed to allow a larger number of student representatives to sit on Governing Board Committees which advise the Board of Trustees. November’s meeting will reflect the start of the second year with expanded student participation on committees.

Student representatives on governing boards play an important role on campus, providing students’ perspectives and advocating for student values to Board members who make the final decisions about how the college in run. However, without a direct voice when the full board meets to make decisions, student representatives are at times left unsure of when their ideas are having an impact on the trustees.

“It’s hard without being with the Board of Trustees when the decisions are actually being made to know how much those student perspectives are taken into account, because even if the decision that is made is different from what students are asking for, we can’t use that as evidence that they didn’t listen to students,” says ASWC President Tatiana Kaehler, who serves on the Student Life Committee this year and served on the President’s Budgetary Advisory Committee from fall 2012 to spring 2013.

Student representatives gain their position one of two ways. The majority of selected representatives, however, are picked through a rigorous application process. After submitting a cover letter, resume and answering written questions for the ASWC Nominations Committee, a smaller pool of applicants are invited back for interviews with the Nominations Committee. From this group, the Nominations Committee selects a candidate they believe will serve students well, and submits their name for ASWC approval.

“Our goal in selecting [student liaisons] is to make sure that they can represent students very well. So we want people who are articulate and who are comfortable speaking to a wide variety of students,” said ASWC Nominations Chair George Felton.

A small portion of positions are automatically filled by specific ASWC officials. For example, the ASWC finance chair is always on the Budgetary Advisory Committee. Other ASWC officials are also granted optional seats on governing boards, which operate separately from normal seats in that they do not detract from the number of positions available to other students; for example, the AWSC president and vice president are allowed to join Student Life Committee if they choose.

Currently there are a minimum of 14 total positions available on seven different Governing Board Committees. In spring of 2013, then-ASWC President Kayvon Behroozian reached an agreement with the Board of Trustees to increase the number of students on each committee from one to two . Since this increase, the Nominations Committee has attempted to reflect a range of student ages, to stagger the graduation of representatives and avoid having too many leave the college at once.

“The Nomination Committee also tries to balance out years … almost all [Governing Board committees] you’ll notice that [students on committees] have varying years so there’s at least one person that stays on and can help another person understand what the process is like,” said junior ASWC Club Director Allison Kelly, who served on the Nominations Committee in prior years and is currently on the Academic Affairs Committee.

Students who apply for Governing Board committees have different motivations for doing so, but a common interest expressed by many representatives is learning more about the college’s governing process and the board itself.

“I wanted to be on the committee in general to find a way to be more involved with the governing processes on campus and to see how decisions are made in this college. I think it’s easy to imagine the governing board as this lofty panel of higher-ups sending down mandates from above, but now that I’ve been on [a committee] I know that’s not quite true,” said junior Brenna Feeney, who serves as a representative on the Student Life Committee.

Once on a Governing Board committee, student representatives are required to attend meetings when the committees convene prior to full Board of Trustee meetings in November, February and late April or early May. Although roles vary by committee, common responsibilities for student representatives are giving presentations and engaging in deliberations in their committees, where they try to express student values and make committee members’ aware of the real effect of their decisions.

“I think we’re the ones who are usually the most useful to bring the conversation back to ‘These are really students here, and in fact this … affects me and you need to listen to us as students because we are the ones that this is affecting,’” said senior Evan Griffis, a Diversity Committee representative.

A wide majority of student representatives note how attentive Trustees and other members of the committees are to student opinions and how they actively ask them for input.

“I have been pleased to find that the committee is very interested in hearing a student perspective on the college’s academic program,” said Student Life liaison Grace McMurchie in an email with The Pioneer. “Often, the committee chair turns to [fellow student liaison Allison Kelly] and I and asks for our perspective before we have even volunteered.”

At the same time, many student representatives are conscious of the fact that there is a distinction between the committee being receptive to their thoughts as student representatives and students having an ability to directly sway outcomes of the committee.

“I feel like student’s voices are taken very seriously. It’s not like we’re dismissed … but it’s not the most important priority,” said junior Noah Stern, a Budget Committee member. “I don’t think I could make a huge change in the direction of Whitman’s budget if I wanted to.”

However, while immediate effects may not be possible, student liaisons can still indirectly influence outcomes by persuading board members to take action via their advocacy in meetings. In line with this thinking, some students on Governing Board committees would like feedback about which statements and how those statements are leading to tangible decisions by the Board of Trustees in order to improve their efficacy in future meetings.

“I think it would be really good to inform students on [committees] that their input actually does factor into the decision process and how … our input actually impacts those decisions,” said junior Jack Percival, who serves as a representative on the Enrollment Committee.

Another option that has been considered to improve student input into governing outcomes is the idea of placing a “student trustee” with a vote directly on the Board of Trustees, as most recently requested in a student referendum from May 2014. However, some students point out that the main goal of having this position, namely providing a student voice at the full-Board level, is served with student representatives on committees who also interact with Board members on those committees.

“The purpose of having the … student vote is so that the Board of Trustees know how the students think. But that symbolism is shown in the exact same way, and perhaps more effectively, when you have multiple students sitting in on meetings and telling them … what they think as opposed to showing through a single vote what they think,” said Kelly.

Because no student has been placed on the Board of Trustees, student representatives on Governing Board committees will remain the major avenue for students to reflect their interests and values. As many of these student representatives note, simply having those voices goes a long way towards making the Board of Trustees aware of the full scope of student concerns, even if it eventually comes down to the Board having to make the decision they think is best for the college.

“That’s my philosophy with the governing boards — we have students in those rooms, we have students voicing their opinions and I trust the Trustees to take those student perspectives into account,” said Kaehler.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Student representatives influence policy from Governing Board Committees

Alumni, Faculty Raise Concerns About Spending and Diversity

As articles and demonstrations question Whitman College’s financial aid and its effect on socioeconomic diversity, concern about the issues has been raised by alumni and faculty members. Although their perspectives vary with their different relations with the college, members of both groups are looking for answers about the direction of the college.

For faculty, a meeting with members of the administration on Oct. 16 will create a forum for have their questions answered. Meanwhile, alumni have begun dialogue with President Bridges via a letter distributed on Sept. 22 asking for a change to a need-blind admissions policy.

The Whitman faculty is scheduled to meet on Oct. 16 with Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer Peter Harvey and Dean of Admissions and Financial Aid Tony Cabasco to discuss the issues of tuition, financial aid, access, affordability and sustainability. The meeting is intended to be an informative space for the faculty members to raise questions that they have for the college’s administrators and to gain a better sense of the larger socioeconomic picture.

“We have questions, as [students] do, about the financial priorities of the institution — where the money is going and being spent?” said Professor of Politics Jeanne Morefield.

The faculty would like to hear more student input and support on this matter as well.

“We have a tendency at this institution to believe that Whitman is the end all and be all of the universe. I would encourage students to really ask the administration to do some serious work by comparing ourselves to schools that we aspire to be more like and to see how they have done it better,” said Morefield.

Chair of the Faculty David Schmitz suggests that as the campus move forward with this issue and that students should direct their energy towards becoming both more conscientious and well versed in the socioeconomic standings of the college.

“ I think [students] should try to get as much information as they can on the issue [and to] follow-up on the issues identified at the ASWC forum,” said Schmitz.

Meanwhile, some alumni have already taken action. A “petition committee” of 15 alumni ranging from the class of 1966 to the class of 2005 delivered a written petition (September 22 Letter to Whitman Trustees) to Whitman’s Board of Executives and President George Bridges on Sept. 22 asking for the return to a “need-blind” admissions policy.

“Our letter was really trying to say ‘go need blind,’ to think about value that each student could bring back to campus,” said Derek Jentzsch ‘93, one of the organizers of the letter, in a phone conversation with The Pioneer.

The letter was accompanied by a Facebook group functioning as a petition for other alumni to sign or write out support for the values explored in the letter. The group gathered support from over 700 individuals in a single week, with many more alumni adding on in the following weeks.

President Bridges provided a response on Sept. 26, thanking alumni for concern.

“If [Whitman] returned to a need-blind policy, the campus leaders and I firmly believe that we do not yet have enough scholarship dollars to meet adequately the financial need of the poorest students we would admit,” he said.

This position and other points in the response left Jentzsch and others looking for more.

“Alumni across multiple generations and classes [signed the petition] … This might not be representative [of the entire alumni base], but we would expect some recognition that the choice to go to need-aware (link to policy and explanation of what it means) changes the character of the student body and the school,” said Jentzsch.

This lack of recognition is also problematic for some alumni because the response follows a pattern of the administration highlighting Whitman’s strengths and promising to continue discussing the issue without taking any action.

“When I hear ‘We hear your concerns, but it’s not that bad’ from the administration, I have very little faith that there will be substantial necessary positive change,” said Nathan Neff-Mallon ‘11, in an email to The Pioneer. “Bridges also released some stats (and I’m very happy he did), but again, they tell a very incomplete picture that is designed to make the college look very good and certainly do not tell the whole story.”

Prior to publication of this article, Jentzsch and other members of the petition committee released their reaction to President Bridges’ response, stating in it that they are “deeply disappointed that the leadership of the school fails to acknowledge the depth of our frustration, articulate any real solutions or even provide a clear vision for what benchmarks and milestones to which Whitman should be accountable.”

Although agreeing with administration’s points about the narrow scope of data from recent articles in the New York Times and The Awl, the group contends that “These articles do highlight the active exclusion of many students on the basis of their families’ wealth.”

The committee also raises concerns about the provision of approximately 33 percent of all scholarship funds, mostly in merit-based aid, to the students from households of $120,000 incomes or greater. Noted as the cutoff for “the top 15% of all American Households,” the committee cites this large portion of all scholarship funds as another major example of the college’s lack of attention to lower and middle income students. The reply concludes by asking for a return to a need-blind admission policy, for an explanation of what “[vision] of a diverse student body does the leadership of Whitman College see” for the college, and how alumni can “work with the leadership of Whitman to help shape and achieve this vision.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Alumni, Faculty Raise Concerns About Spending and Diversity

Betas consider future of housing

With the conclusion of the 2014 fall recruitment cycle, all Greek life institutions will be winding down from a flurry of activities and welcoming new members to their ranks. But members of the Beta Theta Pi fraternity, in addition to greeting a new pledge class, have been dealing with internal discussions about the viability of their chapter’s off-campus housing options in consideration of fewer members living in the house in recent years.

This semester the Beta house is home to thirteen men. Before the fall recruitment, Beta had only 29 members, making it the smallest Greek organization at Whitman. No decision has yet been made about the fraternity’s house.

“The Beta house, after graduating two significantly larger classes than average, found that it had come time to have the tough conversation of how we wished to proceed,” said Beta Theta Pi President junior Nathaniel Dorlac in an email. “There is no set number for the minimum people allowed in a house … but with extremely low numbers it is rather impractical to keep it open [because of housing costs].”

While Beta Theta Pi has never gone without a fraternity house at Whitman, several other greek organizations have. Both the fraternity Phi Delta Theta and women’s fraternity Alpha Phi closed their housing in past decades only to reopen when their numbers increased later. Marcus House, which is currently owned by the college and used as a residence hall, was once the fraternity house of Delta Tau Delta. The fluctuating numbers of the fraternity led to the house closing, reopening and then closing again before the house was sold to Whitman.

Beta Theta Pi numbers are not as low as those of Greek organizations which closed their housing in past decades. According the Associate Dean of Students and Greek Advisor Barbara Maxwell, the membership of Beta has been around 40 to 55 for the last five to eight years, a consistent number that wouldn’t draw concerns unless those members were not living in the house.

“For the Betas … if they have the membership but aren’t getting people to live in the house, I think that goes back to the Betas to question, ‘Who lives in here and who doesn’t? Is this something where we need to create a policy? How do we create an environment so that people want to live in our house?’” said Maxwell.

The Betas could potentially receive help developing their decision-making process from the new advising board that started last year. Composed of members of the Walla Walla community with interest and expertise in working with college students, this collection of individuals may play a key role in supporting and guiding Beta Theta Pi as members create a new strategy.

“I’ve always said the difference between a good chapter and a great chapter is an advisory board who’s behind the scenes providing that continuity and support … I’m optimistic that it’s going to be enough to help the Betas move forward,” said Maxwell.

Currently the Whitman administration has little jurisdiction in regards to any fiscal considerations of the Beta house, as the land and house itself is owned by the national Beta Theta Pi corporation and its alumni. However, if the decision was made by Beta members to close the fraternity house, Whitman would have to step in to provide housing to any displaced sophomores currently living there. However, the number of sophomore men living in fraternities is low enough that administrators do not believe this would pose a challenge.

For the time being, the Betas remain committed to maintaining their house, which has been a center of the fraternity for decades.

“No one is willing to see the house close, so we have all deeply invested ourselves in the future of the house,” said Dorlac in his email. “What we have come to learn from having low numbers is that a small house is not necessarily a bad thing. I personally believe that having a small group of really close friends is the best foundation our house could have.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Betas consider future of housing

Whitman Buddy Program Celebrates During Buddy Ball

Reid Ballroom was a joyous location filled with music, food, and dancing on Dec. 4 as Whitman students and Walla Walla community members enjoyed the winter edition of the Buddy Ball put on by the Whitman Buddy Program.

The Buddy Program, which aims to form one-on-one relations between students and adults in the area who have intellectual and developmental disabilities, is now in its fifth year of fostering friendships between “buddy” pairs.

“Without a doubt the unique and wonderful friendships that are created through the Buddy Program are the biggest benefits. Whitman buddies and community buddies learn so much from one another and gain a rich relationship that is mutually beneficial,” SEC Community Service Coordinator Abby Juhasz said in an email to The Pioneer.

The Buddy Program started in 2011 after work from Michaela Lambert ’14 organizing students and activities and now-Board President of the Walla Walla Valley Disability Network Carla Nibler finding adults from the area to participate. After a year as an ASWC Club modeled after guidelines from Best Buddies International, the Buddy Program became an official community service program of the Student Engagement Center. Since then, the program has involved anywhere from 44 to 56 people each year. Those involved tout the program’s ability to personalize relationships between buddies.

“I would say it humanizes and normalizes disabilities. I think that would be the most important thing that it offers – a humanizing friendship with someone who happens to have a disability,” said senior Jeremy Nolan.

The program features bi-weekly activities for all buddies ranging from bowling to arts and crafts to gardening. Individual buddy pairs will often communicate via text, Facebook or phone and set up events like going to the movies or getting pizza even more frequently. Whitman’s SEC Intern for the Buddy Program, junior Megan Rocha, notes that these activities make the program less about Whitties helping people with disabilities and more about buddies helping each other.

“This is just hanging out with people. We’re not trying to save anyone or mentor anyone – we’re just here to hang out and be together. We’re serving a need that can often be forgotten about, the very basic need to have relationships with other people,” Rocha said.

In fact, many students and community members note that Whitman buddies may receive just as much benefit from the program as their community buddies.

“Our kids have a lot to offer and I’m sure many of the students would agree that they have learned a lot from their buddies.  Warm hugs, a big smile and laughter [are] enriching and from the smallest most infinitesimal things come enjoyment,” said Nibler in an email to The Pioneer

That idea of mutual benefit is epitomized by the Buddy Ball, an annual event that is often the highlight of the semester for all buddies. Although structured as a formal dance, Rocha notes that it is something that becomes a very loose and warm event after buddies have spent a full semester getting to know each other.

“It’s this formal get-together where everyone gets dressed up and we all go hang out in the Reid Ballroom and…it’s essentially what you would think of as a prom, but better…Everyone gets together and is so excited to be celebrating. It’s [a] warm and festive thing,” Rocha said.

The popularity of events like Buddy Ball represents the ever-present interest of community members to participate in the Buddy Program; as such, the program is always looking for new Whitman students interested in the opportunity to spend time with a new community friend. 

“If people are interested in signing up for it, there should be signups again the spring…People should know that if they want to join the program there’s no prior experience needed, we’re excited to have anyone and everyone on board, especially people who might have second language skills or sign language skills,” Nolan said.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Whitman Buddy Program Celebrates During Buddy Ball