Author Archives | Lane Barton

Campus Event Bring Attention to Islamophobia

Prejudice and calls for legalized discrimination against Muslims has increased sharply in the last year, and Whitman community members are stepping up to converse about these issues.

A forum in Reid Coffeehouse on April 14 and a lecture about the Syrian refugee crisis given on April 27 were held to discuss Islamophobia and media coverage of events in the Middle East. The pair of events aimed to encourage dialogue and create a space for people to speak about issues that impact people globally and specifically in the Whitman community.

The forum featured a panel of faculty who spoke to personal or historical issues regarding topics such as the Syrian refugee crisis and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict before opening up to a general conversation amongst those in attendance. The group discussion was as varied as the panelists’ pieces, ranging from broader conversations about how information is presented by the media or impacted by different political biases, to a more local issue of how the ‘Whitman Bubble’ affects understanding of these issues on campus.

“There was some discussion about the ‘Whitman Bubble’ and how do we break it, but in a way we were doing that by saying ‘Not every Whitman experience is the same,’ and by sharing those differences we open up different ways of dialoguing with one another,” said Professor of History Elyse Semerdjian, a faculty panelist.

While many people appreciated the dialogue, the winding nature of the open forum conversations and the difficulty of fleshing out longer ideas within the allotted time were noted as a few reasons to have more forums or other opportunities for people to speak in different venues.

“I think these forums are definitely very important to have these kinds of discussions, and especially [with] it being regulated by professors I feel like that’s very important as well,” said first-year Fathi Assegaf. “But I feel like there’s still a difficulty in minority groups to voice their opinions and maybe to have some of the members of those minority groups into the moderation and to speak their mind before the discussion really takes place. I think that might be important to do as well in those forums.”

The second Islamophobia-related event of recent weeks was a presentation by Semerdjian on the Syrian refugee crisis, which was given as part of Immigration Week, a series of events sponsored by student collective Borders As Methods (BAM). The talk provided an in-depth look into impacts of the Syrian Civil War that has been ongoing since 2011, examining subtle ways that the media has depoliticized the issues by referring to the “migrant crisis” as opposed to a “refugee crisis,” and touching on Islamophobic rhetoric that has risen in recent times. However, the talk also had a personal touch, both focusing on pictures of refugees involved in the crisis and including personal anecdotes from Semerdjian herself.

“Sharing my story as a Syrian, who receives text messages from my family members as they’re passing through these borders in Europe fleeing Syria while I’m teaching you, that’s not a story that I walk into the classroom and tell…I have this whole other life that I’m experiencing outside of the Whitman experience,” said Semerdjian.

The Syrian Civil War has displaced an estimated 6.6 million individuals within Syria and resulted in 4.8 million refugees leaving the country according to a February 2016 report by the United Nations. Response in the global community has varied, from Germany accepting approximately 500,000 Syria refugees in the past year to Canada and the US taking in  25,000 and 1,400 individuals, respectively in the past year.

The talk reflected on some of these numbers but also highlighted the importance of how this seemingly global issue is something that can and does relate to individuals in the Whitman community.

“I think that when it’s deemed a foreign problem it’s kind of easier to feel that you don’t have to act or stay informed because it doesn’t impact you directly. But when you put the pieces together you start to realize, ‘Oh wait, no, even if it doesn’t impact me directly it can impact those around me,’ and as a community we need to stand together,” said senior Jackie Bonilla, a member of BAM.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Campus Event Bring Attention to Islamophobia

Divestment Discussions Continue in New Forms

Whitman community members are continuing a dialogue about divestment, both by providing feedback on the recent work of the Divestment Policy Work Group (DPWG) and with a resolution passed by Associated Students of Whitman College (ASWC).

Students, faculty and staff have utilized an open comment period to offer various critiques of the DPWG’s findings regarding a possible framework for evaluating divestment proposals, while ASWC unanimously approved a resolution asking the Board of Trustees for a response on a 2015 resolution that proposed a one percent cap on investments related to the fossil fuel industry.

The first form of discussion came via responses to the work of the Divestment Policy Working Group, a group which analyzed socially responsible investment policies at other peer institutions and drafted a possible endowment divestment policy which the Board of Trustees can evaluate. During the open comment period, nine students, four alumni and six faculty and staff took the time to respond to the draft policy.

One critique of the findings was that they seemed to require community members to petition to change an existing investment, without including an option for evaluating investments prior to making them for the first time.

“Instead of doing a pre-fact investment policy they did a post-fact investment policy. So now the Investment Committee can continue with the status quo, not recognizing social responsibility in their investments at all, and the onus is on the students, the faculty and the staff to retroactively correct the Investment Committee and we feel that’s an extremely problematic way of framing things,” said junior Dani Hupper, a member of student organization Divest Whitman.

Another concern noted by multiple respondents was the lack of clear definitions of what would constitute a violation of basic values of the Whitman community, which is the proposed baseline criterion for evaluating whether divestment can be considered by the Board.

“I wondered whether via such guidelines, the Board really wants to be put into the position of regularly determining whether all kinds of ‘investment’ activities around the world do not ‘threaten our basic human values.’ What are the criteria for determining whether such activities do or do not threaten our basic human values?” said Professor of Politics Bruce Magnusson in an email to The Pioneer regarding his response to the working group.

Regardless of what the basic values of the community are defined to be, multiple respondents noted that the requirement of near unanimous campus consensus on these values was an unreasonable bar for considering divestment proposals. Some argued that this would be a barrier to having conversations about divestment, as any somewhat contention issue may find it difficult to pass this standard for consideration by the Board.

“Open, respectful, and sometimes difficult contestation of ideas is what makes the liberal arts so dynamic and important.  Because of the impossibly high threshold and clear unease with contestation, the draft policy read to me like it was trying to shield the Trustees from difficult debates, rather than trying to create a framework to facilitate good quality debates in our community,” said Professor of Politics Aaron Bobrow-Strain in an email to The Pioneer.

The Divestment Policy Working Group itself cannot publicly comment on specific feedback as the process is not complete; however, they have met to discuss feedback and will be presenting their findings to the Board of Trustees during their meetings from April 27-29.

“The next step is to discuss the draft policy with the Trustees at their meeting later this week and to share with them the common themes in the feedback we received and the options we are considering to address that feedback.  After receiving the trustee input we will then circle back to some of the people who made comments on the policy and share the specific changes we are considering.  Hopefully, a consensus will emerge from that process,” said Treasurer and Chief Financial Officer Peter Harvey, a member of the DPWG, in an email to The Pioneer.

One last comment expressed by a number of respondents was an acknowledgement of the importance of the DPWG creating an ability for community members to provide feedback.

“We are very appreciative that they had the open comment period…it’s a great mark for transparency,” said senior Lorah Steichen, a member of Divest Whitman.

The second way in which students specifically are trying to continue the conversation is through a new ASWC resolution. In February 2014, the Board of Trustees issued a statement rejecting an ASWC resolution advocating for limits on new investments in fossil fuel companies and the creation of a committee to study divestment of fossil fuel investments. As a result, ASWC produced an updated resolution in spring 2015 that advocated for a one percent cap on fossil fuel investments in the college endowment. However, no formal response to this resolution from the Board was provided to ASWC; so during an emergency Senate this past Sunday, ASWC passed a new resolution written in conjunction with members of Divest Whitman that requests a reply.

“The purpose of the resolution, it seemed to me, was to advocate for a formal response from the Board of Trustees to ASWC Resolution SRS 15.4, which passed last spring. [Resolution SRS 15.4] was essentially an updated proposal for divestment from fossil fuels, but it was a little more nuanced and it relied on a little more of a sophisticated financial analysis of Whitman’s endowment, and ultimately that resolution advocated for capping the exposure of Whitman’s endowment  to fossil fuels at about one percent,” said ASWC President Jack Percival.

The new resolution, which will be presented to the Board during their meetings this week, aims to show that circumstances have changed since the 2014 rejection, and that a new response is warranted. From this, the hope is that a better dialogue about divestment can continue.

“The format of this resolution is a series of rebuttals or refutations on [the Board’s] 2014 statement on divestment, either with pieces of Resolution [SRS] 15.4, new information on Whitman’s endowment,…[or] just different pieces of evidence that show that [the 2014] statement is now wrong, mostly,” said junior Mitch Cutter, ASWC Senator and a member of Divest Whitman. “This needs to be a conversation that happens between the Trustees, Divest Whitman, and ASWC as well.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Divestment Discussions Continue in New Forms

Animated Whitman Statues Become “Liberal Arts”

The term “liberal arts” has a new meaning at Whitman after reports of campus sculptures moving about unrestrained across Ankeny Field during spring break. Although all photographs and video recordings have been destroyed by the Communications Office for “depicting an imperfect representation of our pristine environment,” eyewitness have gone on record about proceedings.

“It was crazy,” said Resident Director Lee John. “I saw the horse, ‘Twygz,’ chasing down a student and attempting to mount them, shouting something like, ‘Who’s riding who now?’”

Prospective students have also described two horned creatures, who are believed to be the Maxey statues affectionately know as ‘Mistress and Mister Demon,’ posing as tour guides.

“I should have realized something was wrong when I saw their hollow eyes looking me over as if they were trying to assess if I was wealthy, liberal and outdoorsy enough to acclimate to the Walla Walla area,” said Washington/Oregon/California native Jenn Eric. “But they were saying all the keywords I wanted to hear like ‘diversity’ and ‘accessibility’ and ‘24-hour climbing gym’ on campus, so I kept listening.”

The most widespread citation of statue activity was in regards to ‘Marcus Whitman,’ the bronze statue normally residing at the eastern-most edge of campus. Apparently upset by being placed out of sight and out of mind, Marcus was seen by dozens of community members graffiting messages such as “I’m still here!” and caricatures of his likeness onto the Memorial Building. All such images have since been replaced by more soothing options such as the clock tower or the modern “WC” logo.

After fielding multiple complaints about renegade statues, the college has since released a statement to the entire campus.

“In accordance with campus policy, we will be fielding a working group to consider whether a committee should be formed to draft a survey asking community members if they believe a committee should draft a proposal about how to address this perplexing situation,” said President Mathy Kurray in an email. “We expect the results to be returned sometime in the next year, or when student concerns have died out.”

Editor’s Note: The statues listed in this article were contacted but could not give a comment on the issue.

 

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Animated Whitman Statues Become “Liberal Arts”

Beyond Borders Club Hosts 5th Annual InterNation Celebration

The fifth annual InterNation Celebration was held in Reid Ballroom on Feb. 20, providing a space for Whitman students and community members to embrace the wide range of cultures on campus.

The InterNation Celebration includes various performances highlighting the talents of those involved and was hosted by Beyond Borders Club (BBC) with support from the Intercultural Center, ASWC and a variety of other clubs on campus.

“The InterNation [Celebration] is a platform where people can show the dances, music [or] clothing from whatever nation or culture they want to present–often it’s their own culture,” said junior Faith Nyakundi, a member of BBC.

This year’s edition of InterNation Celebration featured 11 different performances and a fashion show, with first-year Dorothy Mukasa and senior Annie Boyenneh serving as emcees to introduce each set. The performances ranged from dance numbers, such as those by Irish Dance Club River Rince and Club Latin@, to musical numbers frequently involving either traditional instruments or songs.

Another inclusion in the lineup was a skit by members of BBC, which involved a girl trying to understand various conversations in different languages through an online translation tool, poking fun at the common inaccuracies of such devices. The conclusion, in which the girl eventually speaks to the others in person and discovers they can converse, provided an important lesson about communicating with those around you.

“They actually have a conversation with each other…that conversation marked another step of understanding one another instead of relying too much on technology and creating our own technology bubble that separates ourselves from the person that is sitting right next to us,” said senior Phuong Le, a participant in the skit.

For others, the fashion show in which approximately 15 people got the opportunity to present traditional clothing that they may not frequently wear on campus was an excellent window into the diverse backgrounds of people on campus.

“I think [the fashion show] was the best part–you see your friends in a different light, in that even though we don’t get to live in that culture every day, there’s something special and unique that we’ve probably missed about them. That was a really unique part of the entire show…and being able to see my friends embracing their culture was really cool,” Mukasa said.

For all the artistry and glamor that may be associated with such performances, the cohesion and continuity of the InterNation Celebration also demonstrates that the talents of international students and other performers extend to that of bringing parts of the community together.

“I would not say that my opinion represents the rest of BBC, but as a performer the hope behind this is to show that there are a lot more to international students that we can bring to campus and actually get people from different cultural groups already on campus together–that we’re not just a set of numbers for diversity’s sake,” Le said.

All of these exceptional talents, whether in terms of performances or organizational and collaborative unity, are key reasons why the InterNation Celebration has become an annual tradition and a wonderful event for anyone to experience.

“It’s always amazing how much unique talent [there is]…you’ll definitely see something or hear something or watch something that you would have never been exposed to and you might learn something new,” Nyakundi said.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Beyond Borders Club Hosts 5th Annual InterNation Celebration

Students Speak Out on Global Studies

Over 300 students have signed an open letter calling for the reconsideration of the suspension of the Global Studies Initiative. ASWC also held a hearing on Global Studies and passed a resolution in favor of the Initiative and called on the college to address concerns about transparency, student involvement and commitment to students and faculty of color.

As it stands, there will be a director for Global Studies with one course release per semester to assist with an external review of the program, but all other course releases and the fall faculty development seminar will not be provided in the 2016-17 academic year. This compromise is an adjustment from the initial position that all course releases were off the table in 2016-17 and also leaves room for reevaluation of course releases after the external review period.

The first method of student engagement on this issue came in the form of an open letter in support of Global Studies that was circulated to a variety student listservs on Oct. 25. The letter was spearheaded by senior Lorah Steichen and junior Mona Law, who after consulting with fellow members of student group Divest Whitman produced a brief letter with space for students to type signatures or personal testimonials in support of Global Studies.

“[W]e came to the conclusion that creating some sort of space where students could stand in solidarity with faculty is important, because we heard a lot of discussions among students…but neither of us knew if there was some sort of organized effort besides an ASWC response. So I think we really wanted to create space for student voices in the discussion,” Steichen said.

The letter has gathered over 300 signatures and includes over a dozen individual statements on the importance of Global Studies. Students express concerns about the fact that administrators  use students as justification for taking away a program that benefits students.

“It’s problematic for me when the argument from the administration is that [Global Studies is] taking away from students because it brings faculty out of the classroom, but I think that it really does provide a lot for students in direct and indirect ways,” said junior Drew Edmonds, a signee of the open letter. “I think having…interdisciplinary interactions facilitates a lot of learning for faculty and brings a unique perspective to the classroom that students really benefit from.”

Students also believe that aspects of the Initiative that support faculty development consequently bolsters student learning in the long run.

“Students…benefit so much from a faculty body that is intellectually engaged with each other and excited to create new innovative classes, innovative programs and [bring] all this material into conversation with each other,” said senior Josh Rubenstein, a signee of the open letter.

Moreover, some students signed the letter to express their belief in the importance of global perspectives, something that the Initiative emphasizes and the college expresses as a value in their mission statement.

“I know that in Whitman’s mission statement today they outwardly…talk about how they present things from a multicultural angle and they seem to be  quite proud of advertising that and I want to make sure that [multiculturalism] actually stays in as a value rather than just a professed value,” said senior Tommy Breeze, a signee of the open letter.

The variety of opinions and large volume of public support that has come with this letter is a factor that Steichen and Law hope will influence the administration to change their stance. They presented the letter and additional testimonies to Provost Pat Spencer on Oct. 30 to demonstrate the level of student backing behind Global Studies.

While the letter was one forum for students to express their opinions on Global Studies, they were also provided an opportunity to speak their minds at an ASWC hearing on Oct. 29. Attendees expressed concern at the lack of transparency with which the decision was made and the detrimental effects to faculty and students of color that benefited from aspects of the programs were cited by multiple students.

“The point of the hearing was to solicit student feedback in a really concrete way. We’d seen the open letter but we also wanted to have a space for students to come and express different opinions that the open letter might not have reflected or nuances that were not necessarily in the open letter, although that was clearly a significant gauge of student opinion on the Global Studies Initiative,” said Percival. “But we wanted to provide the additional space for student voices before we went ahead and wrote a resolution that was speaking on behalf of students.”

After listening to student input and reviewing a variety of other factors, ASWC wrote and unanimously approved a resolution in support of Global Studies during the ASWC Senate meeting on Nov. 1.

“Ultimately I think there’s a few major things that [the resolution] asks for. It kind of generally expresses support for the Global Studies Initiative and urges the college to come to a redesigned program that can continue the [faculty development] seminar. So we ended up taking a stance that was very much pro-seminar in addition to being pro-program in general,” said ASWC Vice President Arthur Shemitz.

The resolution also includes some other important points beyond their thoughts on the Global Studies Initiative and fall faculty seminar. The resolution “calls upon the College to reaffirm its commitment to students and faculty of color” and asks the administration “to pursue a policy of transparent and inclusive decision-making, involving all stakeholders and interested parties, especially in this pivotal moment in the College’s history.” The college will be undergoing a strategic planning process in the coming year to shape its vision for the future.

The issue of student involvement comes in two key forms, as not only does decisions around campus programs like Global Studies involve students, but students’ ability to speak out and influence decisions is an important value espoused by many students.

“I think this issue in particular is really important to students … but even greater than that students have a lot at stake with decisions that are made and want to be included and involved in those processes and should have every right to be,” said Steichen.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Students Speak Out on Global Studies

Financial aid cuts leave some students short

Several junior and senior students returned to campus this fall in a more difficult financial situation than they had in their first years at Whitman, in many cases this was because of personal circumstances that affected the amount of aid they receive.

While Whitman’s aid process works for most people, as evidenced by the relatively low average debt which students leave with, it does not work for everyone. Unusual family circumstances can result in students’ aid being cut during their later years in college, when it is both emotionally and academically difficult to transfer.

According to the Whitman Factbook, the average debt for a graduating Whitman senior was $19,147 in 2014, far below the national average of $33,000. Data from the Office of Financial Aid indicates that in the 2015-16 academic year, the average need-based aid package without outside scholarships is $39,400 for first-years, $37,313 for sophomores, $37,757 for juniors, and $35,544 for seniors.

The difficulty for many students who have experienced aid cuts is that their financial aid situations are often in flux for more than just one year due to various personal circumstances. Senior Emily Carrick faced prospects of severe drops in need-based aid this summer, due largely to a tricky tax situation that was specific to her family, after addressing a similar issue prior to her sophomore year.

“There was just a lot of stuff going on [prior to sophomore year] and so [The Office of Financial Aid] was like, ‘You know, we gave you this before so we’re going to stay true to that,’ which we had hoped was going to be all four years. Then this past summer, I got my financial aid package and it had been cut by about 18 thousand dollars,” said Carrick.

Luckily for Carrick, conversations with the Office of Financial Aid about her situation resulted in an adjustment to a much more manageable aid package. However, other students with more common problems, like a sibling who graduated from school or an unexpected addition to family income, are not often able to adjust their package so easily.

Senior Marlee Raible, who faced changes in her financial aid every single year at Whitman, was unsure if a return to Whitman would be feasible for her.

“There was a week during the summer where I was like, ‘I don’t even know if I’m going to be able to come back to Whitman,’ which was really hard because [I’m] a senior and it’s almost worth it to take the huge amounts of loans and finish it than to try and go somewhere else,” said Raible.

Although Raible ended up returning to Whitman, she resorted to taking a course overload this semester in order to reduce tuition costs by paying per credit for her final semester. The experience has left her wishing that it had been easier to account for situations like her own.

“I understand when you’re applying for financial aid [The Office of Financial Aid]…put[s] it into a calculator…and so it’s not able to be subjective the way that in my mind I would hope that it could be for circumstances like my own. So, yes, I understand. Is it right? Is it fair? No, I don’t think so,” said Raible.

While most need-based aid is calculated based upon a family’s income from the previous tax year, Director of Financial Aid Services Marilyn Ponti notes that adjustments can be made on a case-by-case basis.

“There are many situations where we have to use what we call professional judgment, where we go in because a parent lost a job [or] there [were] a lot of medical [costs]…and adjust to help the student. But that depends on each individual student and I think that’s the one thing we need to remember,” said Ponti.

In some cases, transferring becomes the best alternative. Former Whitman student Cleo Young, who looked into transferring after her first year because she was interested in finding a different environment and had alterations to her financial situation, applied for transfers to three schools and received a generous $7,000 aid increase from Macalester College.

“According to [Whitman’s Office of Financial Aid], something unspecified had changed in my [Free Application for Federal Student Aid], and they were giving me $8,000 less than the year before. This made Whitman far more expensive than any of the three other schools I was actually accepted to at that point, and $15,000 more expensive than Macalester,” said Young, now a junior at Macalester, in an email to The Pioneer.

“Since part of me had been wanting this opportunity anyway and it was suddenly $15,000 [per year] less expensive, I took it.”

But even with the interest and incentive to transfer, the shift can still be disruptive for students’ academic progression. Difficulties in transferring credits can often set students behind their peers at their new school.

“I’ve had to contend with meeting a different set of credit requirements in a limited amount of time…I ended up making the decision not to study abroad, which was a good decision, but was something I probably would’ve done had I not transferred,” said Young in an email to The Pioneer.

This issue can be especially problematic for upperclassmen (and seniors in particular) who want to graduate with friends. Carrick notes that even having to consider transferring as a senior, whether or not that occurs, can be difficult because of personal investments in friends and academics on campus.

“No one wants to transfer senior year. I’d like to graduate with my friends and have my credits that I’ve earned here all count towards something. It’s not a great feeling to feel like you have to transfer – it kind of makes you question why you spend so much time and money in one place,” said Carrick.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Financial aid cuts leave some students short

New Encounters Syllabus Approved for 2015–16

A new Encounters syllabus has been approved for the 2015–16 academic year, with Encounters faculty voting in favor of the new curriculum by an approximate 2-1 ratio during a meeting on April 21. The syllabus, which will remove five texts and add four new works, was created by the Encounters Curriculum Subcommittee with the aim of reducing reading and providing more time for discussion of the materials in the syllabus.

In regards to specific changes, the syllabus no longer includes The Quran, “The Book of the City of Ladies,” “Hamlet,” “Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead” or “The Gospel According to Luke.” The new additions will be Jorge Luis Borges’ “Collected Fictions”, Shakespeare’s “Twelfth Night”, Freud’s “The Uncanny” and an examination of Dine’s “Carnival.” The study of “Carnival,” a sculpture on campus, is intended to increase the diversity of materials examined in the course. The new syllabus also includes additional discussion days and moves plenary lectures to a time that doesn’t reduce time in class.

The reason texts were added to the syllabus vary. “Collected Fictions” was suggested by multiple faculty in a survey; “Carnival” provides an artistic medium not contained in recent curriculum; “The Uncanny” offers a new angle on lingering aspects of transformations; and “Twelfth Night” allows Harper Joy Theatre to put on a new play for Encounters students, as has become a yearly part of the curriculum. But each new work was also chosen with consideration of how the selection introduces students to new aspects of “Transformations” that may not have been in the course previously.

“Importantly, [“Twelfth Night”] brings in more laughter to the course, because something that was lacking in the course was comedy. There’s a lot of somber, even traumatizing, subject matter that we examine, but very little laughter, and laughter is an engine of transformation,” said Professor of English Gaurav Majumdar, who serves as the director of Encounters, in an email to The Pioneer.

The removal of texts is also an important consideration in the creation of a new syllabus. Some Encounters faculty expressed concerns with the removal of religious texts such as The Quran or “The Gospel According to Luke,” not only because of their contemporary global importance but because of the way other texts in the syllabus come from and assume an understanding of religion.

“The texts that we read in Encounters assume [a] Western religious background. They’re assuming it’s floating around in people’s minds … so even within the course itself this [removal] is such an undermining of the ability to interrogate those texts critically,” said Professor of Religion Jonathan Walters.

Other faculty members, however, point out that all texts in the curriculum are valuable and the changes are not a judgement of any individual text. Instead, it is an attempt to address faculty concerns and produce new connections between selections under the “Transformations” theme and units.

“The texts the [Encounters Curriculum Subcommittee] removed are all exceptional texts. Their removal from the curriculum says nothing about the value that the [Encounters Curriculum Subcommittee] attributed to them individually. However, our task was to look at the interactions of the thematic units and address ideas, concerns and questions brought to us from the Encounters faculty,” said Associate Professor of Chemistry Allison Calhoun, the Chair of the Encounters Curriculum Subcommittee, in an email to The Pioneer.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on New Encounters Syllabus Approved for 2015–16

ASWC Content Warning Resolution passed

During their April 12 Senate meeting, ASWC passed a resolution calling for content or trigger warnings in the future Encounters syllabus. The resolution, which will require faculty approval in order to be implemented, was created in the hopes of preparing students for engagement in particularly difficult materials.

“[The resolution aims] …  to encourage the mental health of students on campus, and one way of furthering that could be to have some form of notification on a syllabus warning students of [potential triggers],” said first-year ASWC senator Emma Bishop, a co-author of the resolution.

The content warning resolution focused on three main areas, namely gun and physical violence, self-harm and suicide, and sexual assault as potential issues for which faculty should consider applying content-warnings in the syllabus. Although some professors already give verbal warnings in classes, the resolution called for written content warnings in order to create a more uniform safety net from potential triggers.

“[The resolution] also suggested that [warnings] be written down because verbal content warnings aren’t necessarily reliable, and if it’s up to each professor individually to decide a content warning, then there’s inconsistency among the sections,” said first-year ASWC senator AnnaMarie McCorvie, the other co-author of the resolution.

In crafting the resolution, Bishop and McCorvie had conversations with faculty members, some of whom expressed concerns that content warnings would be used in a way to avoid readings. The co-authors contend that the goal of the resolution is actually to enable students to possibly engage in more provocative readings because they would be prepared for potential triggers.

“[The resolution] should allow for more controversial texts to be on the syllabus because you’re giving students the ability to mentally prepare for whatever they are about to engage in,” said Bishop.

At this point in time, the resolution has been submitted to the Encounters faculty and will require approval in order to be incorporated into any individual professor’s syllabus.

“I appreciate students’ concerns about sensitive discussions in class. I have mentioned such concerns at the meetings of the Encounters faculty and asked the faculty to consider the inclusion of warnings before the reading and discussion of sensitive materials. Given that the curriculum is the purview of the faculty, however, each faculty member must decide the statements within a particular syllabus on his or her own,” said Director of Encounters Gaurav Majumdar in an email to The Pioneer.

Even though ASWC members recognize that the adoption of the resolution is the prerogative of the faculty, proponents of the resolution note that it helps open up dialogue about important mental health issues not only inside ASWC but between students and faculty.

“I think that as long as we can get this discussion going and faculty are aware that there are student concerns about this issue, that’s important,” said ASWC ombudsman Nate Higby, a sponsor of the bill.+

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASWC Content Warning Resolution passed

Debate team suspended for alcohol violations, allegations of misconduct

Emily Lin-Jones and Andy Monserud contributed reporting.

*Names have been changed at the request of sources.

On April 9, the Whitman Debate team was suspended for a minimum of two years after an investigation by administration revealed violation of team and school policies. The investigation primarily focused on violations of alcohol protocol by debaters and coaches during a 2015 tournament. Allegations of gender discrimination and potentially unsafe situations occurring over the course of the season were also presented to investigators.

Investigation into Alcohol Conduct

The investigation process centered on allegations of misconduct during a February 2015 tournament at the University of Texas at Austin. Later that month, Associate Dean of Students Juli Dunn and Dean of Students Chuck Cleveland interviewed some members of the policy team and coaches regarding possible alcohol policy violations and an alleged relationship between a coach and student. Prior to Spring Break, a decision was made to put the team on probation. During this time, it was expected that a Whitman Campus Security guard would chaperone the Policy Team to their next tournament to ensure the safety of debaters and that no further policy violations would occur.

One former coach, who asked not to be named for legal reasons, admitted that at least one alcohol policy violation had occurred at the Texas tournament, in which the coach had a drink in a hotel bar with a student who had recently turned 21. Team guidelines, which were established last year prior to the hiring of new coaches, prohibit students from drinking at away tournaments.

“Obviously [I] made a mistake. I didn’t think it was a fireable offense to have a drink with an of-age student … After that had occurred we took steps to rectify that misperception [on the team],” said the former coach, who recalled telling investigators about the incident while being interviewed in February.

That violation, along with separate allegations of misconduct on the policy team, eventually led to a decision to cancel the remainder of the Policy Debate team’s season. The decision was announced to team members on March 16, and the two policy coaches were dismissed from their positions on the same day.

On April 9 it was announced that the entire program — both policy and parliamentary procedure teams — would be suspended for a minimum of two years.

“To be clear … the primary reason Debate has been suspended for two years is a direct violation of their policies and procedures,” said Dunn.

Concerns with Gender Discrimination and Harassment

Though they were not the focus of this year’s investigation, concerns regarding gender discrimination and harassment had also been brought to the attention of the administrators running the investigation.

“The allegations of gender harassment, discrimination … I think it just adds to the decision which is ‘We’ve done this for [three] years with this team without a lot of impact in terms of being able to get the behaviors turned around.’ If in addition to alcohol there’s also these other concerns that are circling about behaviors that we weren’t able to confirm, that’s problematic,” said Dunn.

Although the administration could not disclose specific allegations, individuals involved with debate, some of whom wished to remain anonymous due to continued interactions with team members, spoke to The Pioneer about issues they claim to have experienced in the past year.

Instances of female debaters possibly being treated unfairly were among the complaints brought forward to administrators. A member of the team, who wished to remain anonymous, contended that some female debaters were sent to compete in fewer intercollegiate tournaments and were given less feedback than male debaters.

In a letter to The Pioneer, Director of Debate Kevin Kuswa cited the many steps taken to improve the program’s inclusivity since its Title IX review last year, denying that decisions to take debaters to tournaments were based on gender.

“Debate is a competitive activity that requires coaches to make difficult decisions … All travel-related decisions were made according to our team policy which was crafted with, and approved by, the Whitman administration. It is not for me to question the feelings of individual debaters … but I can say that we have worked extremely hard to provide coaching and support to all of our students,” said Kuswa in the letter.

Letter from Director of Debate Kevin Kuswa by WhitmanPioneer

Prior to the suspension of the policy team in March, some team members claim they brought forward concerns to administrators regarding their personal safety at debate tournaments.

“Women have felt unsafe at debate tournaments for reasons of sexual misconduct,” said Taylor*, another debate member.

In an email, President Bridges acknowledged that reports of harassment and alcohol use at national tournaments had influenced the administration’s decision to suspend Whitman’s program.

“The two-year suspension will give us an opportunity to explore [national debate] culture more carefully, speak with other institutions who are competing in [Policy or Parliamentary Procedure], and determine whether there [are] inherent or structural issues at the national level that would make it difficult for us to ever put a team back on the road and ensure, to a great deal of accuracy, the safety of all the participants involved,” he said in his email.

Former and current debaters claim that multiple complaints have been brought to the administration about gender, sexual misconduct and safety issues on the team over the past four years. Senior Annabelle Marcovici, a former debater who quit the team in 2011 during former director Jim Hanson’s tenure, mentioned feeling alienated by the atmosphere while on the team.

“It’s just sort of a climate that makes you feel like shit. My first semester on the team I couldn’t tell you why I hated [being on the team] so much … It’s because it just becomes so normal that you don’t even realize that people are saying shitty things to you and not looking you in the eye when they speak to you … It’s a bunch of things like that that add up to make you feel like you are nothing,” said Marcovici.

Although the program took steps to create a safer team atmosphere following a temporary suspension in 2013, some debaters feel that, in addition to the alcohol violations identified during the investigation, problems with team culture still persisted.

“It’s really easy for people to be like, ‘This is just about alcohol — point me to the specific instances since January that this has occurred,’ and it’s just not that simple,” said senior Lauren Hauck, a member of the policy team.

Reactions and the Future

In regards to the suspension itself, several debaters have taken to public forums, including social media, to express anger and sadness at the loss of an activity they value so much.

“The last week has been kind of heartbreaking. It’s immense, the loss that I feel, in terms of the opportunities that I no longer have access to because I can’t debate, as well as the relationships … that are no longer feasible because I can’t debate,” said sophomore policy debater Jack Lassiter.

At the same time, there are those on the team who recognize that the decision might have been necessary to avoid continuing the trends of the past couple years.

“I think the suspension was the only option. Maybe not four years ago it was the only option, maybe we could have saved the debate team if we had suspended it for a year last year, but I don’t think we can move forward from where we are right now without phasing out a huge portion of the debaters and coaches,” said Hauck.

During a short and tense meeting with President Bridges shortly before an email was sent out to campus, debaters were informed of the program’s suspension. They said, however, that they were not provided any more information that what was shared publicly.

Some debaters express concerns about the investigation process resulting in the suspension of the parliamentary team, even though only Policy team members were involved in the investigation and the allegations surrounding the February tournament. These debaters say they were not made aware, in their meetings with administrators, of specific violations of policy that would justify the suspension of the entire team.

“We were told that the team was being canceled because there were violations of policy. It was not explained to us what those violations were or why they were so bad that they justified canceling the entire program for everyone on the team for two years. It was not ever explained to us what degree of infractions regarding policy are sufficient to warrant a cancellation,” said Margaret Rockey, a junior parliamentary debater.

In the meantime, current and former debaters are organizing to possibly appeal the decision, although, some say, the lack of transparency from administrators has made it difficult to know how to proceed.

“I don’t know what I can and can’t do at any point in time because I have so little information,” said Lassiter.

Editor’s note: An earlier version of this article incorrectly labeled Lauren Hauck as a junior. She is a senior.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Debate team suspended for alcohol violations, allegations of misconduct

Tuition, salary increases chosen for 2015-16

February’s Governing Board meetings resulted in the approval of a new budget for the 2015–16 academic year, which includes a three percent tuition increase along with salary increases of 3.5 percent for staff and three percent for faculty. The tuition increase is similar to the 2.9 percent increase in tuition made last year and reflects the goal of the college to remain competitive with similar institutions.

Tuition pays for roughly 70 percent of the college’s budget every academic year. Increases in tuition fund a number of different initiatives across campus, including hiring new faculty and staff, improving programs and building new facilities. While faculty salaries did not rise as quickly as tuition for much of the early 2000s, raises in salary have been similar to those in tuition and other college spending since the 2013–14 school year.

“It’s a balancing act and the balancing act is between trying to keep a Whitman education as affordable as we can to prospective and current students, as well as to make investments in strengthening the college,” said Treasurer and Chief Financial Officer Peter Harvey.

The tuition and salary increases for the next academic year were selected by the Board of Trustees from a suggested range of increases put forward by the President’s Budget Advisory Committee. The board also considered recommendations by its Budget Committee that take into consideration factors such as inflation and competitiveness with similar institutions. For the past five years, tuition increases have ranged from 4.5 percent to 2.9 percent (or between 1.9 percent and 1.3 percent when adjusting for inflation). The upcoming tuition increase of 3 percent would be the lowest inflation-adjusted increase in the last five years, assuming inflation in 2015 stays at the five-year average of 2 percent.

Although tuition adjustments are important, another major consideration for the budget is figuring out salary increases for faculty and staff. Decisions regarding salary are important for Whitman to be a desirable school for new hires. For this reason, analysis of historic trends for salaries at Whitman and peer institution helps inform the decision of the both the President’s Budget Advisory Committee and the Board’s Budget Committee.

“It’s a balancing act in trying to retain and attract as many of our faculty and staff as we can with the knowledge that there is a constant fluctuation in what [peer colleges] are doing and trying to stay in the median or upper ranges [of salary] is something that’s strategic and important,” said AWSC Finance Chair Tabor Martinsen, who serves on the President’s Budget Advisory Committee.

The upcoming retirement of several faculty has allowed current faculty members to be given raises beyond the increase seen in the overall budget. Though the college is increasing spending on faculty salaries by three percent and staff salaries by 3.5 percent, the faculty members will see an effective raise in total funds equal to that of the staff due to the reallocation of funds.

“Because of some retirements, there’s going to be about another half-percent of monies available so the [faculty and staff percentages] will be in effect equal, but we didn’t have to use new monies to get the faculty up to 3.5 percent,” said Chair of the Faculty David Schmitz.

In general, the process requires a collaborative effort not only between the board, its Budget Committee and the President’s Budget Advisory Committee, but within each committee between various members as well.

“I’m always impressed with all of the students, faculty and staff. President Bridges and I ask all of them to wear the college hat as opposed to their individual perspective’s hat and look at what’s best for the college as a whole. I would observe that by-and-large everybody really does do that and considers all factors,” said Harvey.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Tuition, salary increases chosen for 2015-16