Posted on 25 September 2014.
Editor’s note: This week, the Emerald reached out to various student newspapers across the country to give a case for why their Heisman candidate could win the most coveted individual award in all of college football. The Daily Nebraskan, the Universe, and The Red and Black responded, giving insights and opinions on players who are in the race for the prize early on in the year.
Players like LaMichael James and Joey Harrington accomplished a lot after wearing the green and yellow on Saturdays in the fall, but only former University of Oregon quarterback Dennis Dixon’s experience can compare to the position that current quarterback Marcus Mariota finds himself in four weeks into the 2014 season.
In 2007, Dixon led the Ducks to a No. 2 ranking while becoming the favorite to win the Heisman trophy leading into the final weeks of the season. Then, Dixon’s knee eliminated any chance of that after he tore his ACL and was ruled out for the remainder of the season.
Now, Mariota has the Ducks right where Dixon had them as the month of October approaches. Oregon is 4-0 and in place to make the inaugural college football playoff thanks to its dual-threat quarterback who is currently on top of every Heisman board.
With 13 touchdowns to no interceptions and a monumental win over Michigan State under his belt, the third-year starting quarterback is looking like the best chance Oregon has to earning the Heisman Trophy next to its name. However, a crop of talent all over the nation is consistently being displayed every Saturday.
From Georgia’s bruising running back Todd Gurley to Texas A&M’s Kenny “Trill” Hill, college football’s most coveted individual prize has a handful of athletes validating their worth while providing full cases for why they’re deserving.
This is the break down:
The Case for Marcus Mariota
By Justin Wise, the Emerald
What can’t he do? It’s a question that his teammates and coaches can’t answer, let alone media members and fans. Oregon’s do-everything quarterback has passed for 1,135 yards and 13 touchdowns through four games, not to mention a completion percentage of 74%to go along with zero interceptions. In addition, he has proved to be a threat on the ground and through the air. He is averaging over 50 yards rushing per game.
What it all says is how much he is worth to the second-ranked team in the nation. With come-from-behind wins over Michigan State and Washington State now, in which whenever the Ducks needed a play, Mariota seemed to always come through with either his arm or his legs. As long as he stays healthy and as long as the plays keep falling into place for the Hawaiian native and the rest of this Oregon team, it seems logical to think that Mariota will be called the best player in college football at season’s end.
The Case for Todd Gurley
Taylor Denman, The Red and Black
Todd Gurley is Georgia’s braveheart.
The way he’s playing right now screams, “You can take my championship, but you can’t take my Heisman!” If Georgia’s hope for a national title is stomped out, Gurley may be fighting an uphill battle for the Heisman Trophy.
If a potential champion is under center, he’s got edge to take home the trophy. At Gurley’s current pace, I can’t imagine he’ll miss the trophy ceremony in December, but the two other players I see sitting in the front row alongside Gurley are Oregon quarterback Marcus Mariota and Texas A&M quarterback Kenny Hill.
Let’s get this out of the way: the Heisman Trophy loves quarterbacks. It’s in the books. Alabama running back Mark Ingram and USC back Reggie Bush are the only two non-quarterback winners since you traded your last Pokémon card in 1999 – and that winner was another running back.
Even if Georgia stumbles again on the way to the finish line, that won’t keep Gurley from gazing at the trophy in New York this December. Gurley will have the numbers and he’ll attract more attention as people start to ponder the NFL draft. But we aren’t talking about one game to win it all anymore; we’re talking about a playoff. If Georgia isn’t in the final four mix, it puts Gurley on the outside looking in.
Fair or not, a running back with numbers will be hard pressed to edge out a contending quarterback with flash and the stats to back it up. Gurley’s best bet is to keep grinding amd hope that the rankings get shaken up at the top.
The Case for Ameer Abdullah
Eric Bertrand, The Daily Nebraskan
With the Big Ten filled with disappointment, Nebraska is one of the few shining stars of the conference. The Cornhuskers success stems from one player: senior I-back Ameer Abdullah.
Not only has he been a bright spot for the Big Ten, but also the Nebraska program. This season, the Huskers have a different stride about them because Abdullah has been the pep in Nebraska’s step.
In four games this season, Abdullah has rushed for 625 yards, which is second in the nation. He has accumulated seven total touchdowns and has averaged 6.8 yards-per-carry.
Abdullah has also taken over the kick returning duty for the Huskers, and he has notched 115 yards on kickoff returns.
When the Huskers need the key play, Abdullah was ready.
Last week against Miami, Abdullah paced the offense with 229 yards on the ground and three touchdowns. On a third-and-goal situation in the second quarter, Abdullah caught a pass and there was no clear path into the end zone. Abdullah charged through a defender and got the touchdown to tie the game at 14.
The Heisman has become who is the best quarterback award in recent years, and the only running back to win the award in the part decade was Mark Ingram. For a running back to win the Heisman, they have to be far better than the rest. And Abdullah is just that.
The Case for Taysom Hill
By Trent Christiansen, the Universe
The Heisman Trophy, “annually recognizes the outstanding college football player whose performance best exhibits the pursuit of excellence with integrity. Winners epitomize great ability combined with diligence, perseverance and hard work.”
Taysom Hill is the best candidate for the Trophy when put up to those standards.
The 6-foot-2, 220-pound quarterback-in-a-fullback’s body is best known for his running abilities. He is the third best among quarterbacks over the past 10 years in yards per game at nearly 90.
Hill is an outstanding athlete who also exhibits the positive traits of a Heisman winner. He will rip your heart out on the field as a ruthless competitor, but carries himself with a quiet confidence off the field. He is polite, down to earth and deflects the praise to his teammates. He is never involved in off-field controversy.
Jay Mohr of Fox Sports radio tweeted, “I’m starting to think that (Taysom Hill) is going to win the Heisman. And you know what? I hope he does. At least we’ll know he went to class.”
Many college athletes stand out on the field, but rarely do they stand out as a person. And that’s why Hill will win the Heisman this year.