Author Archives | Jonathan Ababiy

Ababiy: Dealing with crime before it gets too old

Earlier this week, a story that is becoming all too familiar happened again: A St. Paul man stepped away from his car while it was running then watched someone hop in and drive away when he turned around.

A couple days later, St. Paul police spotted the car and were prepared to pull it over until it sped away. They didn’t pursue the car, but it hit another car as it drove off. A few minutes later it hit a light pole and flipped over.

A 14-year-old boy died when he was thrown from the car, while another 14-year-old and a 16-year-old, the driver, were arrested.

I say familiar because this wasn’t the first time a young teen died in a carjacking this fall. In October, three boys, ages 13, 15 and 16, died fleeing Minneapolis police at around 2 a.m. in a chase that lasted just two miles when the boys lost control of their vehicle in a rollover crash.

These boys’ deaths are part of a pattern that has emerged this fall. The Twin Cities have experienced a dramatic increase in carjackings: up 537% in November in Minneapolis compared to last year. This statistic of 537% has come up a lot, but there is another one tied to it that is just as dramatic and important: 75% of solved Minneapolis carjackings were committed by juveniles. For a Nov. 24 story, the Hennepin County Attorney’s Office told KARE 11 that it had already charged 27 juveniles since July.

This is devastating because juvenile incarceration greatly increases the likelihood of incarceration as an adult. Amid the devastation Minneapolis has experienced this year, this is some of the most long-lasting damage. With school online and nowhere to go, young people are turning to crime, with little tangible preventive effort from the city.

Seriously — this fall, 27 teenagers may have started a lifelong journey in the criminal justice system.

Cubic tons of ink have been spilled on the city’s rising crime rates in the pages of newspapers and Facebook group comments. It’s not a secret. The statistics are grim with violent crimes up dramatically since last year in Minneapolis and in other cities like Milwaukee, Philadelphia and New York City.

The reform-minded Minneapolis City Council has definitely taken the heat for this. It just concluded a political battle with the mayor and police chief to cut $8 million from the next police budget.

But little has been said about a plan for preventing and reintegrating the young people turning to violent crime. More police, like Mayor Frey’s budget calls for, might mean Minneapolis police catch criminals more quickly, but it doesn’t change the factors that led that person to commit a crime or the societal consequences of that crime. Police don’t put victim’s or offender’s lives back together. As the last 30 years of American criminal justice policy have taught us, neither does jail.

The price of a brand new SUV is easily less than the price of one year of prison. According to the Vera Institute of Justice, Minnesota spends $41,366 on a year of prison. Getting better at sending kids into the incarceration pipeline is not a solution. Once the incarceration loop begins, it’s much harder to drag a person out of crime than it was in the beginning.

Our budget should reflect that and ensure that young people get an emphasis in the criminal justice system — ideally one focused on prevention, not prosecution. We will never get back the boys that lost their lives due to the mistakes they made. But, the 27 already charged and those who haven’t been caught yet are still out there in this city, as much a part of it as you or me. They still have a future.

Either we deal with the problems that lead them to the mistakes they made or we pay for it later. I hope it’s the former. We can’t lose any more kids.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ababiy: Dealing with crime before it gets too old

Ababiy: If you care so much about poor people, let them live next to you.

The proposed development at 2301 California St. NE should have made everyone happy. It had 164 affordable units, 40% of them 3-bedrooms and plenty of parking spots on a large, empty, vacant lot next to a busy road and a Metro Transit bus stop. It was even shorter than originally proposed and included 13,400 square feet of production space.

Yes, a 100% affordable — specifically 60% of the average median income — privately-built project with production space in the Northeast Minneapolis Arts District. A perfect building at the site of what two years ago was a tall, gray, concrete grain elevator.

Guess how the “community” felt.

The owners of the neighboring studio building filed an appeal against the rezoning, including a tenant of the building, a songwriter, who has his own appeal. The Northeast Minneapolis Arts District added in their own, as well.

Then, the Bottineau Neighborhood Association followed suit, adding their own appeal and a 147-signature petition opposing the project. The “community” said things, like:

“This Over, Too Big Footprint building, will create conflicts” about a site that was zoned industrial and is part of a string of industrial buildings along railroad tracks.

“An enormous 6 story building is completely out of place” at the site where an enormous grain elevator once stood.

“Stop gentrifying NE!” about a building that was 100% affordable.

“Affordable housing yes, one hundred and sixty cars parking all along our streets, no. Community doesn’t seem to be gaining on this one” about a building where every unit has a parking spot — more than what the zoning actually required.

By a considerable margin, public comments opposed the 100% affordable housing project. That is sad.

In a general sense, affordable housing is the kittens and puppies of politics. Everybody loves it, and anyone who does not is a monster. It is something that both rural farmers and urban tenant rights groups agree their communities need more of. That is especially true in Minneapolis, a city as politically blue as denim.

For example, Kenwood, a wealthy neighborhood with little affordable housing, and Cedar-Riverside, a low income neighborhood with lots of affordable housing, both are represented by city council members who say they support more affordable housing. Lisa Goodman, the Lake of the Isle-area city council member, even calls herself a “champion” for affordable housing.

But, as 2301 California St. NE shows us, affordable housing in your neighborhood is a different ball game. Everybody wants affordable housing, just not when it is next door. People’s impulse to say “not in my backyard,” is much stronger than any weak, abstract political commitment they have to housing justice. Sure, 2301 California isn’t perfect and our reliance on private developers to deliver affordable units is flawed, but either we can get 164 thoughtfully designed affordable units or we could get none. In the development process, the homeowners-association-like interests of homeowners have become the priority, not the future low-income tenants or future generations who will need housing. By ceding complete control to NIMBYs, we have their narrow definition of perfect the enemy of public good.

The Bottineau Neighborhood Association gives this away in its bylaws. The first listed goal of the organization is to maintain the “stability” of the neighborhood, while the second goal is “enhancing the social well being.” In the 1930s, the racist Federal Housing Administration used “stability” as a codeword for keeping neighborhoods racially and socially segregated. It deemed neighborhoods like Bottineau “hazardous” because of their minority populations or industrial backgrounds.

As a result of this pushback, 2301 California St. NE almost died in the Business, Inspections, Housing & Zoning Committee. Thankfully, it was later approved in the full City Council vote, but it came too close to dying.

It is disappointing that it is this difficult to build affordable housing in Minneapolis. There was a permitted encampment of unsheltered people at Marshall Terrace Park this summer, just a half mile from 2301 California. Our city is in an affordable housing crisis.

In a crisis or not, we cannot let the false or petty grievances of NIMBY neighbors dictate whether or not low income people can have housing. Minneapolis, especially industrial Northeast, is not Yellowstone National Park or a pastoral prairie. It is a thriving city that will grow and change over time.

To show that we care and advocate for affordable housing, we actually have to build it. I look forward to seeing how Minneapolis will continue to prosper because of projects like 2301 California.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ababiy: If you care so much about poor people, let them live next to you.

Ababiy: How “Build Baby Build” can have unintended consequences

The chief antagonists in this fight are the contemporary multifamily apartments that have sprouted up in Minneapolis and other growing cities across the country. Forced to embody gentrification, “neoliberalism” and the perceived decline of American architecture, they have been the sight of many rhetorical battlefields, in community meetings and on Twitter.

A new working paper from Anthony Damiano and Chris Frenier, researchers at the University of Minnesota’s Center for Urban and Regional Affairs, examines the hyperlocal effects of this new wave of multifamily construction. It’s an important study, because it shows the need for a multifaceted approach to make housing affordable, not just one that relies purely on delivering supply.

To give some background, the current approach to housing in Minneapolis and the Twin Cities metro could be summarized as market-based or YIMBY, “an acronym for “yes, in my backyard.” Some journalists have called it a “counter” to the “‘not in my backyard’ mentality” that has led to job and population growth outpacing housing growth in many cities. Damiano and Frenier humorously call this market-based approach “Build Baby Build,” given that you can’t just tell people and companies to stop moving and creating jobs.

The federal government, city government and all other governmental bodies in-between, with the help of nonprofits, build some units every year, but most new construction is built by the private sector. Private developers rent this new construction at the going rate, or “market-rate,” or sell units as condos or single family homes. These developers primarily build market-rate apartments in the urban core and inner suburbs and single family homes in the outer suburbs.

To aid the market, some cities, like Minneapolis, have relaxed zoning laws that regulate what someone can build on the land they own. The city’s 2040 Plan legalized duplex and triplex construction across the city and made it easier to build three-to-six story buildings near transit. This isn’t a bad thing. In Minneapolis, many of the older, beautiful apartments that we love are non-conforming, meaning that the current zoning code says they are too large and illegal. So, the physical form of the neighborhoods we love could never legally be recreated under our current zoning code.

Although the amount of legally affordable housing differs from city to city, every major American city is like this. As our population grows, people need places to live and private developers take on the cost (and profit) of providing it for them. No one builds apartments for free. You wouldn’t throw $1 million down a well. Developers, whether a large corporation or a regular person with some extra cash, build them because they believe they will make money — something that happened in the 1920s (my favorite era of construction), 1960s and now. Some developers do specialize in affordable housing, but their costs are usually financed by federal or state programs.

Unlike some European cities, much of our affordable housing is privately owned. This housing is often called Naturally Occurring Affordable Housing (NOAH). NOAH is often older, lower quality, in a less-ideal location or just not competitively priced. Housing experts often say that this housing has “filtered” down. An extreme example is the Francis Drake Hotel downtown. It was built as luxury housing in 1926, then converted into a low-cost residential hotel in 1997. Last December, a fire made it a total loss, displacing over 200 people of low incomes at a time when most shelters were full.

The government does not spend, or have (particularly in the case of local governments), the money to build the thousands of units that are needed to house people with lower incomes. The market does an “OK” job at it for everyone but the very poor.

It would be my dream for the city to spend a half-billion to build more affordable housing, but that isn’t financially feasible, especially in a 425,000-person city where minor property tax increases are unpopular. Sure, you could tax the rich or corporations, but they would do something they are very good at once the benefits of living in Minneapolis seem to fade: pick up their stuff and move somewhere else, like Edina or Aspen, Colorado. There goes your tax base!

With this background, it’s easy to see how housing is a Rube Goldberg machine. We know the machine isn’t giving us the result we want, but no one can agree what part of the machine to change, how much and why.

To circle back, Damiano and Frenier’s study highlights how the current market-based approach isn’t working the way we think it will. The need for more market-rate housing at a regional level in the Twin Cities is irrefutable, but at the smaller neighborhood level, the economics become dicier. Developers and people who recognize the regional and higher-level need argue that new buildings will help a neighborhood or block. They say that if you approve a project, it will go toward serving the broader goal of more housing supply.

The data that Damiano and Frenier use is high quality, and it looks at rents in buildings within 300 meters of new construction. They find that the effects of new construction “vary meaningfully across housing submarkets.” Their study classified buildings into market tiers based on the building’s quality relative to its zip code. Rents in nearby lower-tier rental units were 6.6% lower than comparison units, while rents in nearby newer buildings were 3.2% lower than comparison units. In other words, Damiano and Frenier see two possible effects at work. For higher-tier rentals, new buildings may add supply and increase competition, pushing down rents in nicer buildings. In contrast, for lower-tier rentals, new buildings serve as a signal to landlords that a neighborhood is improving and that they can increase rents. When these landlords raise rents, affordability can start to disappear in the neighborhoods that need it most.

Again, on the regional or citywide level, increasing the supply and production is an important goal. It increases competition and the quality of housing. In the Twin Cities and metro areas across the country, we do not build housing at the same level we used to. However, as Damiano and Frenier show, the effects of this new housing at the micro-level is not zero for lower income people.

The study does not mention tenant protections, but it highlights the need for more. In the Rube Goldberg machine of housing, increasing supply is not the only tool we can use to keep people in their homes. Other cities, like San Francisco and New York, are far ahead of the Twin Cities in the protections they offer those who rent. That should be the next step.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ababiy: How “Build Baby Build” can have unintended consequences

Ababiy: Should affordable housing be this expensive?

In Minneapolis, $900,000 can buy you pretty much any kind of pad you would like. If you want some help paying your mortgage, there is a $855,000, 8-bedroom duplex in cushy East Isles. Or, if you want lake views, there is a one-bedroom penthouse condo with views of Bde Maka Ska near Lake Street.

Maybe you are more of a North Side person. $900K can get you a huge 130-year-old restored Catholic rectory plus a newly renovated duplex, with $160K to spare. Save that $160K, or perhaps splurge on a studio pied-à-terre condo a few blocks from Bde Maka Ska. Wherever you decide, $900K gets you pretty far in Minneapolis.

Last week, Hennepin County and affordable housing developer Dominium confirmed what they and their partners were capable of with $172.5 million: 191 units at Fort Snelling’s Upper Post, just a thousand feet away from the runway at MSP’s Terminal 1. At a cost of $900,000 per unit, Dominium would build six studios, 60 one-bedrooms, 75 two-bedrooms, 33 three-bedrooms, 15 four-bedrooms and two five-bedrooms in the 26 crumbling buildings at the Upper Post.

In a public meeting last week, the Hennepin County Board voted 4-3 to provide the last piece of funding for that $172.5 million money pit, $88 million in bonds.

It’s a remarkable splurge because, as of two weeks ago, there were 222 tents scattered across 14 parks in Minneapolis. Hundreds of unsheltered people have spent an entire summer living outside in Minneapolis. The county has helped house unsheltered people, but it has also stumbled.

When the Minneapolis Park and Recreation Board (MPRB) forcibly evicted most people from the Powderhorn Park encampment, it was community members that helped encampment residents find a new home or move to a new park. It was community members who brought food and supplies for encampment residents. With enough community pushback, the MPRB began issuing permits for encampments, giving residents a sense of certainty. Additionally, it was the community who pushed Hennepin County to explore purchasing hotels. In October, the County agreed to purchase a hotel and a warehouse in Minneapolis for housing, providing at least 135 beds, while a deal for a Bloomington hotel fell through.

Even without these circumstances, the cost of this project is much larger than the average affordable housing project in the United States. It’s already triple the median home value in Minneapolis. A 2018 Government Accountability Office (GAO) report found the median cost for an affordable unit in pricey areas like Chicago and New York City was only $301,529 and $260,089, respectively. Even in San Francisco, one of the most expensive and difficult-to-build-in cities in the U.S., the price cap of publicly funded housing is $825,000.

The Upper Post is not in the center of a global financial hub, and it is mostly one and two-bedrooms, not the larger unit sizes that many families desire. It’s unclear how the costs could balloon to be so high.

Two years ago, the price tag was $600,000, just one year after the Minnesota Housing Finance Agency voted unanimously to not fund the project due to its excessive cost. Now, the cost is $900,000 per unit. The state and county should do more for affordable housing, but this project isn’t the right path. That $900,000 can go much further on other projects. The 26 crumbling buildings at the Upper Post are beautiful and of great historical importance, but the exorbitant cost can be better used elsewhere. People are more important than buildings.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ababiy: Should affordable housing be this expensive?

Ababiy: The Blue Line Extension blunder

Imagine you have $129 million to plan how you will build a light rail line from the Target Field station to an industrial park in Brooklyn Park. There is a giant Target office, two factories and a Tesla office at this industrial park.

Then, imagine directly in between those two locations, 13 miles apart, there is a nearly 45,000-person neighborhood with a high population density and some of the highest transit usage in the state. Also, imagine that the neighborhood has been historically ignored and divested by politicians.

And, just to make sure you spend every dollar of that $129 million, imagine also trying to negotiate with BNSF Railway, an entity that the state and federal governments have lavished with immense legal power for centuries, to let you put your trains full of people on the tracks they use to move oil. This is after you “grabbed” land the railway was going to use to expand its operations, then lobbied the state to pass a law protecting you from the railroad’s legal power to take it back. As a result, BNSF is a little mad at you.

Furthermore, imagine that you own most of the busy roads between Brooklyn Park and Minneapolis. Finally, imagine using that $129 million to study putting the light rail on that railroad’s tracks around, not through, the streets you own, in that transit-dependent neighborhood.

You actually don’t have to imagine anything because Hennepin County, the Met Council and partner cities did just that. They spent $129 million planning a Blue Line LRT extension that went around north Minneapolis. Luckily, leaders admitted negotiating with BNSF wasn’t possible and abandoned the alignment in August.

It’s important now to ensure that an alignment through north Minneapolis is pursued. Believing a negotiation with BNSF could be successful was a tactical and strategic blunder, but the old alignment’s side step of north Minneapolis is inexcusable. Nearly 45,000 people live in north Minneapolis, more than any other city on the line, besides Brooklyn Park. The neighborhood’s main commercial street, West Broadway Avenue, turns into Bottineau Boulevard, the core of the LRT’s route.

The LRT could serve as a valuable tool to connect north Minneapolis residents to amenities and jobs in the suburbs. It would also open up two-way access to the neighborhood from other parts of the city. The neighborhood is currently walled-off from the rest of the city with two freeways.

But an idea that bad doesn’t die easily. At the Blue Line Extension Corridor Management Committee meeting on Oct. 8, multiple committee members tried to revive negotiations. The mayors of Golden Valley and Robbinsdale attempted to pass a motion that directed the Met Council and County to exhaust all possible options with BNSF first, despite the $129 million spent on doing just that. Committee members saw through it and voted 11-6 against it.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ababiy: The Blue Line Extension blunder

Ababiy: Equity as practice, not branding/aesthetics

This Thursday, workers at the Walker Art Center declared their intent to unionize. Employees from a variety of departments gathered and displayed a banner over the yellow pedestrian bridge connecting the Walker to Loring Park.

The Walker is one of many “cool” institutions in the Twin Cities where workers have declared their intent to unionize in the last few months. The Walker is joining the likes of beer giant Surly Brewing Co., Fair State Cooperative, MPR and Spyhouse Coffee. Amid our current economic chaos, workers are seeking the stability and equality that organized labor provides. Unionized workers make more and have more benefits than non-unionized workers.

In addition, unions promote racial and gender equity. While the American labor movement wasn’t inclusive, unions have been vehicles to the middle class since their integration in the 1960s. A 2016 study found that the median wealth of a nonwhite union worker was nearly five times greater than their non-union counterpart. Similarly, the Economic Policy Institute found that the gender pay gap in unions is only $0.94, compared to $0.74 for non-union women.

However, an intent to unionize does not mean that the union is guaranteed to happen. Managers and owners don’t give up their power easily. They can jam the unionization process up with technicalities or put out spin that says unionized workers will surrender their voice to a “third party.” There is a small industry of law firms that companies hire to bog down and bust unionization drives. Or, companies can just lay off all employees.

Many of my columns this year have been about these various tests this summer has presented us. There’s been lots of rosy rhetoric about issues like racial justice, economic justice and COVID-19. It comes from companies, institutions and ourselves. We had all summer to talk and theorize, but now, in a new season, we must ask: Are the affirmative words and promises we heard from our institutions, politicians, friends and, really, ourselves real?

This is especially an important question because being a “cool” institution in Minneapolis means cashing in on the progressive social justice culture that this city thinks it has. We are an island of blue in a sea of red. It’s completely fake, as the police killing of George Floyd and our staggering racial inequality shows, but this progressive self-conception is something our city and its businesses are proud to wear.

Surly, Walker, Fair State and Spyhouse are cool because they aren’t “the Man.” They are “independent” and different from the stodgy old-guard that preceded them. Their success — and wallet — is inseparable from this branding.

Now, it’s important that the institutions that make Minneapolis move beyond an aesthetic of equality. Any brand or person can adjust their social media or make a donation to a non-profit. To show real commitment to equity is to recognize and support workers and their unions. The old Minneapolis image of progressivism is dead, and there is no better way to start anew than with a foundation of real economic equity.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ababiy: Equity as practice, not branding/aesthetics

Ababiy: We’re still waiting for real police reform

Since George Floyd’s death at the hands of Minneapolis police, there has been a profound cultural change in views on racial inequality. A CNN/SSRS poll in early June this year found that 60% of white people said that racism is a big problem, compared to 21% of white Americans in 2011. Another Yahoo News/YouGov survey found that 68% of Americans approved of charging former Minneapolis police officer Derek Chauvin, who knelt on Floyd’s neck, with murder.

In the midst of all this cultural change, it’s important to examine what about the practice of policing has actually changed in Minneapolis. The people think and feel differently about race and the police now – an accomplishment in itself – but creating actual structural change based on those feelings is another ballgame.

As our politicians have proven, we’ve struck out so far on any significant, progressive change in policing. To be fair, there have been changes and reform made in Minneapolis and at the state level. The problem is that what reform has occurred has been meager and behind schedule in comparison to other cities that have their own policing issues, like Chicago.

For example, in early June, Minneapolis Mayor Jacob Frey negotiated an agreement with the Minnesota Department of Human Rights that banned MPD’s use of chokeholds and other neck restraints, techniques already banned in some form by New York City and Chicago since 1993 and 2012, respectively. The agreement also announced a duty to report and intervene during unauthorized use of force, which brings up the question: Was MPD not doing that before? Strike one.

The divided Legislature took another pass a month later in July, when they passed a package of police accountability measures. The package banned chokeholds and warrior style training statewide. Frey already banned warrior style training, known for its “killology” vision of law enforcement, in Minneapolis, but the police union ignored the ban and offered the training for free. So, strike two.

The package also included funding for crisis training, better data collection and created a panel of expert arbitrators to examine police misconduct cases. Not bad, but better data collection and an ominous panel of arbitrators does not change the fact that police officers know that they won’t be punished for their misbehavior. Only 12 of 2,600 civilian complaints toward police in Minneapolis have resulted in discipline, a discipline rate of only 0.41% since 2013. Let’s call it a generous foul ball.

In late August, another set of reforms was announced by Frey: a ban on shooting at moving vehicles unless safety is an issue, and a requirement to explain whenever a weapon is unholstered. After an entire summer of meditation on the issue of police reform, the best Frey could come up with is a ban on something police already don’t do very often, and a requirement that police officers do more paperwork. Strike 3.

Frey ran for mayor as a police reform candidate, so it’s astonishing that it took until this summer for some minor, commonsense rewrites of the police handbook. In 2017, the nonprofit news site MinnPost reported that Frey called for changing department procedures to require officers to use all reasonable alternatives before using deadly force. What this proves is that Frey only reacts to police misconduct. He didn’t do anything to prevent it, even after the tragic death of Justine Damond in 2017.

Now, Minneapolis, like New York and Chicago, is in the midst of a crime surge despite no significant changes to the nature of policing before or during the surge. There are many potential reasons for the uptick in crime, like COVID-19, but the blame can’t be put on reform.

So, even with the wind of an entire social movement at his back, Frey struck out. With the new rise in crime, the winds have changed. One summer of activism later, a reformed, accountable and less violent MPD still looks distant.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ababiy: We’re still waiting for real police reform