Author Archives | Ian Campbell

ASUO spring ballot measure results released

OSPIRG: Yes. 2,373 – 2,101

The passing of this measure will send an advisory statement to the ASUO that OSPIRG should be funded at a level for professional staffing.

Post deadline budget: Yes. 2,844 – 867

The ASUO president no longer has the ability to unilaterally put together the budget if the ASUO Senate does not meet its deadline.

Qualifying ballot: Yes. 2,532 – 1,005

The ASUO president is no longer able to unilaterally place a measure on a ballot. The president must seek a simple majority vote from the ASUO Senate (50 percent, plus one vote).

Non-fulfillment: Yes. 2,406 – 731

The ASUO Constitution now has a three-prong test to determine non-fulfillment: Whether the ASUO official acted in good faith, damage caused by non-fulfillment and remedial measures taken by the ASUO official. The ASUO Constitution Court is now able to determine other sanctions other than removal or vacancy.

Elections board structure: Yes. 2,328 – 596

The ASUO Elections Board is removed from the ASUO Executive’s purview and a new process to remove a board member is created.

Elections operation: Yes. 2,379 – 537

The ASUO Elections Board will need to outline deadlines to stipulate the response time of grievances and posting election rules.

Office hours: Yes. 2,248 – 956

ASUO senators will now be allowed to serve one of their office hours outside of the ASUO office.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASUO spring ballot measure results released

ASUO elections results withheld as Constitution Court reviews campaign practices

No one wants to be the one to say there has to be another election, but after the ASUO Constitution Court ruled to invalidate the 2013 ASUO election results and ordered the Elections Board to administer a new election, someone may have to.

On Friday afternoon, the student court filed a judicial order staying the election and its results until it could review a grievance filed by Ducks for a Difference Campaign Manager Andrew Rogers. The grievance accused representatives of United Oregon — but naming only Nicholas Seymour — of bribing students with T-shirts in exchange for a vote for their slate.

Just over 24 hours later, the court released a ruling invalidating the results and requiring a new election. The ruling cited that both Ducks for a Difference and United Oregon were guilty of violating Oregon elections law.

In a recent article, ASUO President Laura Hinman mentioned neither she nor Pat Chaney, the ASUO elections board coordinator, intend on having a new election during week three of spring term.

“I personally will not run an election next week until we have more clarification,” Hinman said. “It’s my understanding that we’re going to keep the election results from last week as valid, pending further conversation with the Constitutional Court and other folks … Based on Con Court’s interpretation, they saw both parties guilty — not based on the campaign rules, but based on state laws. Pat did not find the parties guilty based on his rules, and therefore, he’s continuing to keep the results from last week.”

She feels members of the court are “overreaching their jurisdiction” by interpreting state law instead of citing the ASUO Constitution.

“Interpreting state law is something left to the courts of the State of Oregon,” ASUO Chief Justice Nick Schultz said. “We merely apply what is already obviously stated and mandated by state law … I believe there is a crucial difference between interpreting state law and applying what the state has already made clear.”

ORS 260.665 states “a person, acting either alone or with or through any other person, may not directly or indirectly subject any person to undue influence;” “undue influence” has been defined in part as “giving or promising to give money, employment or other thing of value.”

In addition, the court cited the Election Law Summary, complied by the Oregon Secretary of State, which “clearly and unequivocally finds that T-shirts ‘should not be given away without charge because they are not readily available to the public free of charge.’”

In terms of holding a new election, Schultz is confident that the court’s ruling will be enforced.

“As far as the Constitution requires, Article 5.1.8 requires the ASUO president to enforce all rulings of the Constitution Court under the consequence of being in nonfulfillment of duties,” he said. “And I don’t mean that to imply that all as a threat; I’m just saying that because of that — and because of how important I know the ASUO as an institution is to President Hinman — I have full faith that she will carry out all of her duties as she has this year.”

The ASUO Constitution states May 25 to be the first day the newly elected president would take office.

“(A new election) could happen any time between now and then,” Schultz said, speaking to the May 25 transition.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASUO elections results withheld as Constitution Court reviews campaign practices

Ballot measure results to be released Monday

Due to a clarification filed by ASUO Senator Ben Rudin, the ASUO Constitution Court has ruled that the ballot measures will be released Monday morning.

Rudin argues that despite the 2013 election results being invalidated by Con Court earlier this weekend, the ballot measures were not impacted by both campaigns bribing students to vote.

“If the evidence demonstrated that the United Oregon and Ducks for A Difference campaigns had plainly endorsed one ballot measure over another, the Court may have been inclined to disagree,” the court ordered.

The court agreed with Rudin and suggested that “it would be unfair and inequitable to require that they muster up the resources once again to support their cause.”

Because of this decision, the Elections Board is ordered to release and enforce only the 2013 spring ballot measure results.

 

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ballot measure results to be released Monday

Election results voided by ASUO Constitution Court, Hinman: election won’t be rescheduled

UPDATE:

ASUO President Laura Hinman, on behalf of the ASUO Executive and Election Board Coordinator Pat Chaney, reported there will not be an election next week.

“At this point, the Constitution Court is interpreting state laws and not constitutional laws. Until more communication occurs, there will not be an election next week; we will not be having DuckWeb active,” she said. “We will be keeping the results from last week.”

ASUO Constitution Court announced Saturday the Elections Board must schedule a new week of ASUO elections due to a recent grievance filed against the United Oregon campaign regarding bribery.

The original grievance, filed by Ducks for a Difference campaign manager Andrew Rogers, accused members of the United Oregon campaign of withholding t-shirts for votes.

Just after 3:30 p.m. on Friday, the last day of the election, the student court issued a judicial order postponing the results of the election until it could review the grievance.

In response to the grievance, ASUO presidential candidate Sam Dotters-Katz mentioned there was little evidence to prove the campaign had bribed voters.

“Because (United Oregon) does not know who is being accused, it cannot produce evidence or testimony to disprove the allegations by (Andrew Rogers),” he wrote. “Except with the testimony of Amy Jones regarding Nicholas Seymour.”

A Findings of Fact submitted by Chaney reports that Seymour denied the testimony given by Jones.

“He stated that he did not remember the specific voter interaction Ms. Jones witnessed,” Chaney wrote, “but that he was certain he said no such thing to any voter.”

In the court opinion, it was concluded there were three important points suggested in Chaney’s Findings of Fact. First, there was evidence United Oregon had a campaign policy not to offer t-shirts in return for a vote. Second, there was evidence United Oregon offered t-shirts but only to increase voter turnout. Third, there was enough evidence to suggest that isolated incidents of representatives from United Oregon were violating their own campaign policy.

Chaney also testified that representatives from United Oregon contacted him to ask whether t-shirts could be offered to voters to encourage voting as long as requesting the voter to vote a specific way was not demanded.

“I immediately offered both campaigns the same advise,” he wrote. “In my opinion the Rules forbade giving, or promising, T-shirts in return for a vote for any specific candidate, but that offering T-shirts as an incitement to vote without demanding a specific vote was acceptable.”

The court was not satisfied with Chaney’s advice.

“Unfortunately, the ASUO Elections Coordinator erred in offering this advice,” the court’s opinion read. “Elections Rule 6.2 (PDF) clearly states the ‘members of the Elections Board … will not provide explanations, offer interpretations, or give advice regarding state and federal laws.’”

It also found that while the grievance was filed by a representative of Ducks for a Difference, both campaigns were distributing t-shirts to get students to vote. Because of these findings, the court ruled both campaigns had violated the rules.

“The Court concludes that both campaigns have violated the ASUO Election Rules because they have failed to comply with Oregon election laws,” the court wrote in its opinion.

ORS 260.665 states “a person, acting either alone or with or through any other person, may not directly or indirectly subject any person to undue influence,” including, “giving or promising to give money, employment or other thing of value.”

The court summarized this law to mean that nothing of value can be given to an individual with the intent to influence how that individual votes — or whether that individual votes at all.

To remedy the violations, it ordered the Elections Board to “schedule and administer a new election in whatever timeframe in deemed appropriate.”


Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Election results voided by ASUO Constitution Court, Hinman: election won’t be rescheduled

Election results postponed by ASUO Constitution Court

Associate justice of the ASUO Constitutional Court, Cedar Cosner, issued a judicial order on Friday, April 12, withholding the results of the ASUO election.

Ducks for a Difference Campaign Manager Andrew Rogers requested that the court rule on the recent grievance filed regarding bribery before the results get announced.

In an email from Chief Justice Nick Schultz, the court will gather at 4:30 p.m. today to decide on Cosner’s stay.

“I think it’s fair that students get a fair elections process that is unadulterated by dirty politics,” Rogers said. ” The gravity of what had been going on seemed to make it necessary.”

The judicial order, authored by Cosner also brought up the severity of the accusations.

“I am issuing this judicial order and staying the release and enforcement of the election results because of the seriousness of Petitioner’s accusations,” Cosner wrote. “There has not been adequate time to review respondent’s brief in a fair and accurate way and if the election results are released, those remedial tools which can be employed by the court become further limited.”

UPDATE:

The ASUO Con Court has issued an injunction, postponing the release of the election results until Monday morning.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Election results postponed by ASUO Constitution Court

Former Oregon running back LaMichael James endorses United Oregon

Former University of Oregon football player and current San Francisco 49er LaMichael James recently took to Twitter to endorse Sam Dotters-Katz and the United Oregon slate.

James was a freshman enrolled at the UO during Dotters-Katz’s first term as ASUO president.

“We are so proud to have received the endorsement of the state house majority leader, the Emerald, and now a great alumni, LaMichael James. Go Ducks, ” Dotters-Katz said.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Former Oregon running back LaMichael James endorses United Oregon

ASUO Senate: April 10

Live coverage of Wednesday night’s ASUO Senate meeting:

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASUO Senate: April 10

United Oregon accused of bribery, grievance filed with Elections Board

Three days into campaigning, a grievance has been filed against leaders of the United Oregon slate, alleging that members of the platform were bribing students to vote for them by offering them a shirt.

The grievance, filed by Ducks for a Difference Campaign Manager Andrew Rogers, provides five testimonies from students saying that they were bribed for their votes.

Four of the individuals testifying cited that they were approached on Monday afternoon between 3 p.m. and 4:30 p.m.

Kevin Post, one of the individuals who testified, said that he was approached by a female behind the United Oregon tent.

“She informed me that they had computers set up for me to log in and vote,” Post said. “I asked her if I could just have one of the T-shirts, but she told me that I had to log on and vote first. I asked her if I had to vote for them to get the T-shirt and she said that I did not, but they really hoped that I would. I got on the computer and voted, accepted my T-shirt and left.”

Vice presidential candidate Amy Jones also testified, swearing that she witnessed bribery as well.

“I watched and heard Nicholas Seymour approach a student on 13th,” Jones said. “He offered to take his name off their phone list and said, ‘I’ll give you a T-shirt if you vote for United Oregon right now.’”

The Emerald contacted Seymour, who is running for a two-year at-large PFC position, but he declined to comment.

The grievance cites Elections Rule 9.7 as being violated, which according to the Elections Rules (PDF) defines bribery as a “severe campaign violation.”

The consequences for such a violation are outlined in Elections Rule 9.7.1.

“Consequences may include, but not limited to, loss of all campaigning privileges including presence on the ballot, and, should sanctions be applied after election, removal from office,” the rules read.

The grievance has been filed with the Elections Board who will rule on the issue. Elections Board Coordinator Pat Chaney had no comment for this article.

Sam Dotters-Katz, the presidential candidate for the United Oregon slate had a chance to comment.

“I am running for president because these kinds of smear campaigns and dirty political tricks straight out of Karl Rove’s playbook have come to define ASUO elections and university politics,” Dotters-Katz said. “When the United Oregon slate wins this campaign, our student body can look forward to being represented by student leaders interested in solving problems facing our campus instead of engaging in race to the bottom politics.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on United Oregon accused of bribery, grievance filed with Elections Board

Ducks for a Difference receives sanctions from the Elections Board

After initial suspicion that the Ducks for a Difference campaign was collecting signatures and contact information for it’s campaign under false pretenses, the Elections Board has ruled in favor of providing sanctions for the Lamar Wise’s slate.

ASUO Senator Ben Rudin filed a grievance on April 9 against Ducks for a Difference alleging the campaign is guilty of illegal campaigning and fraud.

The grievance came hours after Brent Rovianek, a United Oregon candidate running for Senate Seat 14, testified he was contacted Monday night from a list that was originally put together for the sole purpose of repealing the Social Host Ordinance.

He recalled the phone conversation and stated the caller identified the reason for calling: “Hi my name is (Don’t remember name). I’m from Ducks for a Difference and I’m calling you because you signed a petition against the Social Host Ordinance.”

Rovianek remembered signing the petition weeks ago but was assured then that the information was to be used for the ordinance repeal only.

“I approached them, and they told me they were gaining signatures for a ballot measure in order to revoke the ordinance,” he said. “I signed the petition, and upon speaking with them further, they told me they were there on behalf of Lane County Young Democrats.”

In the Election Boards opinion, Ducks for a Difference argued that the numbers collected from the Social Host petition were not used directly. Instead, the information gathered was uploaded onto a software called the Democratic Voter Engagement Software. This software allows users and subscribers to access the Voter Activation Network (VAN), a gathering of information for potential voters. With the software, these potential voters may be “tagged” with specific preferences.

The Board used the example of tagging an individual for supporting the rise of minimum wage. After tagging individuals, the software can sort the information to present the subscriber with all contact information of individuals who have been tagged.

Is response to the grievance, Ducks for a Difference argued four points.

First, the campaign argued that subscribing to a database to access information is not a violation. Secondly, they argue that all of the numbers were already in VAN. Third, the campaign states that the contact information from individuals who supported the Social Host Ordinance petition was in VAN so only information collected from VAN was used. Finally, the campaign argued that anyone with a subscription can access the numbers.

The Elections Board was not persuaded by the arguments and suggested that the action of “tagging” the individuals merits a violation.

“If only the contact information was uploaded to the VAN database this assertion might have more merit,” the Board’s opinion read. “However, the information was not only uploaded but tagged as well. Consequently, Ducks for a Difference had access to the contact information of every student that signed the petition. This fact leads the Elections Board to believe that the purpose of collecting signatures and contact information was intended not only to protest the Social Host Ordinance but also … engage in premature campaigning.”

As a result, the Ducks for a Difference campaign is prohibited from phone banking between 5 p.m. and 7 p.m. on April 10.

“I am confident,” ASUO Elections Board Coordinator Pat Chaney said, “that any attempts to disobey the sanctions will be brought to the attention of the Elections Board.”

Lamar Wise was disappointed with the ruling, but wasn’t planning on letting it effect his campaign seriously.

“It’s unfortunate that the Elections Board ruled against us, but we will just continue to organize to do things that matter to students,” Wise said. “We will just have to readjust our hours accordingly.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ducks for a Difference receives sanctions from the Elections Board

ASUO Elections: You may know the slates, but do you know the measures?

Funding OSPIRG

After having its budget cut earlier this year, OSPIRG placed a measure on the ballot that will poll student interest on whether the organization should be funded to hire a professional staff. The idea behind the professional staff is that it will be able to work full-time in Portland, Salem and Washington, D.C.

A “yes” vote would send an advisory statement to the ASUO that OSPIRG should be funded.
A “no” vote would support the current defunding of OSPIRG.

Post-deadline budget

Currently, if the ASUO Senate fails to pass a budget that itself and the ASUO president agree upon before the deadline, the president receives full control of the budget. This measure asks whether the ASUO Constitution should be amended to prohibit the president from changing budget line items greater than what the Senate has approved and allow the Senate to repeal any final budget decision made by the president with a two-thirds vote.

A “yes” vote would amend Article 5.8 and disallow the ASUO president from unilaterally constructing the budget.
A “no” vote would keep the ASUO Constitution Article the same.

Qualifying ballot measures

According to the ASUO Constitution, measures can be placed on the ballot in three different ways. The first is by submission of a petition with enough signatures totaling at least 5 percent of the student body. Secondly, the Senate may place a measure on the ballot with a two-thirds vote of its seated members. The third way, which is the process in question, is that the ASUO president may unilaterally add a measure to the ballot.

The proposed measure asks students whether ASUO Constitution Article 15.3 should be amended to require a simple majority vote of the ASUO Senate to approve a measure added by the ASUO president.

A “yes” vote would amend the Constitution and require and measure submitted by the ASUO president to be approved first by the ASUO Senate.
A “no” vote would keep Article 15.3 as written.

Non-fulfillment

This measure asks whether the ASUO Constitution should be amended to specify that when ASUO officials are charged with non-fulfillment of duties, such cases should be determined on a case-by-case basis. It would create a three-prong test to determine non-fulfillment: Whether the ASUO official acted in good faith, damage caused by non-fulfillment and remedial measures taken by the ASUO official.

In addition, the court would be allowed to order sanctions other than removal or vacancy.

A “yes” vote would amend the language in ASUO Constitution articles 11.3 and 14.3 changing what the Constitution Court could consider and what it could order.
A “no” vote would make no changes to the articles.

ASUO Elections Board structure

Currently, the Elections Board is under the ASUO executive and all five positions are appointed by the ASUO president. There is also no current procedure to remove Elections Board members.

This measure would make three changes to the ASUO Constitution: Establish the Elections Board as independent from the ASUO executive branch, give the elections coordinator the authority to appoint the other four members of the board and create a system to remove a member of the board, requiring either the Constitution Court to remove a member due to non-fulfillment or have three-fourths of the Senate authorize the ASUO president to remove a member due to non-fulfillment.

A “yes” vote would remove the Elections Board from the executive’s purview and create a process in which a board member can be removed by adding Constitution articles 3.9, 13.14 and 13.15 as well as amending Article 13.5.
A “no” vote would leave the Constitution unchanged in this area.

ASUO elections operation

This measure has the potential to change the Elections Board by giving members deadlines for responding to grievances. Currently there is no requirement for the board to respond to a grievance within a given time nor is there a date when the board must submit the elections rules.

The measure would require the Elections Board to rule on a grievance within 48 hours, post the elections rules by week five of winter term and require the members to be neutral in all ASUO elections during their involvement on the board. Currently the Elections Board does not have to remain neutral.

A “yes” would create deadlines for responding to grievances and posting elections rules as well as requiring the board to be a neutral body by amending Constitution Article 13.5.
A “no” vote would not create new deadlines or require the Elections Board to be neutral.

Office hours

Currently, all ASUO senators are required to serve three hours in the ASUO offices each week between 8:30 a.m. and 5 p.m. during weekdays. In addition, there is no limit set on the number of office hours each senator is required to serve.

The measure asks whether senators should be able to serve one of their three office hours at another location on campus other than the ASUO office between the hours of 8:30 a.m. and 9 p.m. Monday-Friday.

Some senators have suggested serving their office hours in a location more appropriate for their constituents. Other senators have stated that the ASUO office provides a consistent and reliable area where constituents will always be able to find assistance.

A “yes” vote will amend ASUO Constitution Article 6.27 and allow senators to serve one of their three hours outside of the ASUO office with extended hours and create a limited amount of hours that each senator must serve.
A “no” vote would retain the current rule.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASUO Elections: You may know the slates, but do you know the measures?