Author Archives | editor

Hundreds killed and nuclear disaster possible after earthquake devastates northern Japan

Northern Japan was hit by an 8.9 magnitude earthquake that occurred roughly 80 miles off the nation’s coast this morning. It caused a 12 foot tsunami to hit parts of the country and has prompted a nuclear emergency for two nuclear power facilities.

Over 200 people were killed by the quake and hundreds more have been injured.

Chief government spokesman Yukio Edano said that the earthquake was the largest ever to hit Japan and it has already caused “enormous damage.”

According to MSNBC, there have been at least 90 fires reported, a train missing and the coast guard is searching for a ship that was carrying roughly 80 people.

Now, pressure is rising at a nuclear power plant in Fukushima after its cooling system failed.

Nearly 3,000 residents near the plant are being evacuated as pressure inside the reactor is approaching 1.5 times the normal level.

Shortly after the quake hit, a nuclear emergency was also declared at a nuclear power facility in Onagawa when a fire broke out at the plant.

This morning, President Barack Obama released a statement expressing his condolences for the people of Japan and saying that the U.S. “stands ready to help the Japanese people in this time of great trial.”

NYU vice president of student affairs Marc Wais said the university will be sending out e-mails offering support to students who list their permanent address as being either Japan or Hawaii.

Wais added that the university is monitoring the situation closely and given the current path of tsunamis may send letters to students with families on the West Coast later in the day.

‘NYU spokesman John Beckman said, “I am sure I speak for the entire NYU community when I express our sorrow at the events in Japan, and our deep sympathy for the Japanese people; the images of destruction are horrifying, and our thoughts are very much with people of Japan and all those who have suffered because of this natural disaster.”

Due to its sheer magnitude, the quake can now be categorized as a “mega-quake” and it is one of the largest recorded earthquakes in history.

Four million homes in Northern Japan are reported to have lost power  and there are also concerns over fires started in oil refineries in the area.

The largest quake ever recorded occurred in Chile in 1960, and was a magnitude of 9.5. The earthquake that occurred in Haiti last year was a 7.

MSNBC footage shows water and mud flooding into small towns, clearing boats and cars, as well as the image of an incredibly large boat overturned. All modes of transportation have been suspended, and reports say Sendai Airport was destroyed by the flooding.

NYU’s Stern school had planned an annual trip, “Japan Trek 2011” in which Stern students would travel to the country, including to the city of Tokyo. It is currently unknown if that trip will proceed as scheduled.

A tsunami watch was put out for all of the Pacific, including the west coast of the United States and Hawaii. So far, no serious damage has been reported.

Posted in News, Other, TravelComments Off on Hundreds killed and nuclear disaster possible after earthquake devastates northern Japan

Penn State upsets Badgers, improve tourney chances

Five weeks ago, senior Talor Battle hugged his coach after the Penn State men’s basketball team upset Wisconsin at the Bryce Jordan Center.

It was a special moment for both of them.

The two shared a similar moment Friday night after the Nittany Lions pulled off yet another upset of the Badgers. Only this time, there was a lot more at stake.

Despite mighty offensive struggles, Battle and the Lions extended their season at least one more day after knocking off the No. 3 seed in the Big Ten tournament, nationally ranked No. 13 Wisconsin, in a low-scoring 36-33 effort at Conseco Fieldhouse in Indianapolis.

And as the team’s season survives, so does it’s NCAA tournament hopes. Sitting on the wrong side of the bubble entering the Big Ten tournament, the Lions have pulled off back-to-back wins by defeating Indiana and Wisconsin to set up a showdown against Michigan State on Saturday in the semifinals.

However, it wasn’t easy or pretty. In a game that featured Battle breaking Jesse Arnelle’s school scoring record, the Lions and Badgers combined for the lowest single-game scoring output in the conference tournament’s 14-year history.

“It’s really important for us,” coach Ed DeChellis told the Big Ten Network. “It wasn’t pretty but we gutted it out and I’m really proud of our kids. We got out to a great start and then we just kind of went flat.”

The Lions jumped out to a quick, 18-2 lead to open up the game, but the Badgers slowly chipped away until knotting the game up.

Penn State would make only five more baskets for the rest of the game.

None were as big as a contested 3-point attempt by Battle in the final minutes that gave the Lions enough to hold on for the eventual victory. That shot was one of the only bright spots on the game for the senior, who finished with only nine points. However, those nine points were enough to give the guard 2,140 career points as he now sits alone atop the Penn State record books.

“The win is the most important thing,” Battle said in an interview with the Big Ten Network. “I’m not going to lie, I’m a little happy that the record of Jesse Arnelle is out of the way. I probably shot 3-of-16 from the field today, but we won the game and as a team we just really competed.”

Wisconsin was led by Jordan Taylor’s 16 points and Jon Leuer’s 10.

Down by two points in the final minute, Taylor had a chance to give the Badgers the lead with a 3-point attempt from the top of the arc. That shot missed the mark, and Battle hit a free throw to extend the lead to three. Taylor had one more shot with 1.9 seconds left, but that shot didn’t come close as Tim Frazier grabbed the rebound to lock up the win.

“Jordan Taylor is a heck of a player,” Battle said. “He made it really tough. He’s big and strong. I haven’t hit a shot yet all tournament but we are 2-0. I’ll trade all the missed shots to keep winning these games.”

Posted in Basketball - Men's, Other, SportsComments Off on Penn State upsets Badgers, improve tourney chances

Coalition targets fake IDs among students

If you clicked on a Facebook ad last semester offering fake IDs in Lawrence, you’re not alone. More than 5,000 other people did, too.

The ad was created by the New Tradition Coalition, an organization that includes law enforcement, local bar owners and school and health officials. The ad was just one of the coalition’s efforts to increase awareness about alcohol abuse and underage drinking.

“The number of people that we have documented as clicking on the ad were between the ages of 16 and 20,” said Jen Jordan, director of prevention for the Douglas County Citizens Committee on Alcoholism. “This is just representative of the fact that underage drinking is a big issue in Lawrence and at KU.”

In the spring of 2010, the project “Fake ID 101” was launched. TheLawrence Police Department, the Douglas County Sheriffs Department, the KU Public Safety Office, the DCCCA and theAlcoholic Beverage Patrol all combined forces to enact it.

When Fake ID 101 began, its main method for combatting underage drinking was to send officers into bars to ask patrons for identification. Officers were out on four separate nights and gave out 48 citations for alcohol violations.

KU Public Safety Office captain Schuyler Bailey said that when teams go out, they are made up of police officers, the sheriff and University officers.

“This just wasn’t working,” Jordan said. “Kids would immediately set down their drinks and walk away or go to the bathroom. The officers stood out and anyone who was underage would leave.”

Last fall, officers were out on nine separate nights. Overall, 731 IDs were checked, 105 citations were written for minors in possession of alcohol and 60 citations were written for fake IDs.

The increase in citations was due the officers’ new methods, which included wearing plain clothes, checking IDs outside bars and liquor stores, patrolling the KU area on football game days and visiting house parties.

Alycia Futrelle, a manager at On The Rocks liquor store, said officers have visited the store and stood at the end of check-out lanes to check IDs of customers.

“Fake IDs are probably more likely to be used at bars than at liquor stores,” Futrelle said. “Bars are darker; it’s harder to see the picture. And when a customer uses a credit card, we check to make sure it matches the name on their ID.”

Jordan said it was often hard for clerks or doormen to spot fake IDs because state IDs change so often.

“When you are in a college town, it is reasonable to think that kids are from all over the country,” Jordan said. “Kansas IDs are more difficult to fraud. When kids buy fake IDs online, they are almost always out of state.”

To help with this issue, the New Tradition Coalition will provide bars and liquor stores with a book that has a photo of every state ID and its marking characteristics.

As spring break nears, Jordan said bar and liquor store employees would be warned to look for an increase of fake IDs.

“A lot of students are either getting fake IDs to take on spring break or getting them when they get there,” Jordan said. “Destinations like Florida and Mexico have spots set up that have them for sale, so officers will be looking for these.”

The exact dates of bar and liquor store visits were not disclosed. The possession of a borrowed, altered or fake ID may result in fines up to $2,500 and one year in jail.

Posted in Campus Safety, News, Other, TechnologyComments Off on Coalition targets fake IDs among students

Scouts flock to Auburn for Pro Day

For those former Tigers not invited to last week’s NFL Scouting Combine, there was one final chance to prove their worth.

Twenty-two former players competed during Tuesday’s annual Pro Day, which took a little more than four and a half hours inside Jordan-Hare Stadium.

“I think we’ve all talked about it at times,” said former center Ryan Pugh. “It’s almost like it’s four years in one day.

“I don’t think it’s that intense as far as combining all four years in one day, but it’s just a way to fill in the blanks as far as what kind of player you are.

“They get to interact with you and see how you interact with your teammates, and they want to see you compete. I think I did that today. I think we all did that today.”

Auburn split workouts into two sessions.

In the first session, groups were separated alphabetically and conducted workouts including 40-yard dash, standing long jumps, vertical jumps, 225-pound bench presses and shuttle cone drills.

“Probably my routes and showing my feet—that’s the biggest thing that I think the scouts wanted to see,” said former running back Mario Fannin. “Also my hips, I’ve kind of been stretching them out more and being able to get out of my turns faster and be able to have bursts of speed. I think I did a great job just doing that today.”

After those tests were completed, the players then participated in position-specific drills one group at a time.

Groups included kickers, defensive backs, linebackers, running backs, tight ends, offensive linemen, defensive linemen and quarterbacks/wide receivers.

“I didn’t feel any pressure,” said former quarterback Cameron Newton. “I just wanted to come out here to have fun and compete because that is the name of the game for me. I was out here for a long time just rooting my teammates on.

“I want to see them excel in whatever they were doing. It is fun reuniting with a lot of guys, and that was fun for me. I enjoyed this whole day.”

Since NFL owners and players have yet to agree on terms, a lockout might still be possible, although a 2011 without football seems unlikely.

“I think they extended talks because they don’t want a lockout,” said former linebacker Josh Bynes. “I strongly believe that there won’t be one.

“If there is a lockout we are still going to have to do what we need to do because they will still have a draft. I think they will get everything settled so that they can have a season.”

The first round of the NFL Draft will take place April 28 followed by the second and third rounds April 29.

“It doesn’t really matter what they say,” Bynes said. “All that matters is what happens when the draft comes around April 28, 29 and 30.

“You may hear your name called or you might not. The only thing you can do is wait to hear your name called.”

Posted in Football, Other, SportsComments Off on Scouts flock to Auburn for Pro Day

Marquette wins “dog fight” 67-61 over West Virginia

It was characterized as a “dog fight” by senior forward Jimmy Butler before the game, and he couldn’t have been more right.

Marquette (20-13) pulled out a tight one, 67-61, over the West Virginia Moutaineers (20-11) in part because of sophomore guard Junior Cadougan’s 15 points, five assists, and one turnover.

Junior guard Darius Johnson-Odom, with the game tied at 55 with 4:46 left, hit 3-pointers on back-to-back Marquette possessions to open up a 61-55 lead.  Marquette never trailed the rest of the way.

“You could argue that those two shots changed the game,” coach Buzz Williams said. “Definitely changed the momentum.”

It was Cadougan who found Johnson-Odom on the fast break on the first 3-pointer and it was Cadougan whom Johnson-Odom gave credit to.

“He really helped me get back into the flow, and kept me in the game,” Johnson-Odom said.  “We put this game on Junior, Junior carried us, he controlled the game and he did a great job doing it.”

Johnson-Odom finished with 11 points. Prior to those 3-pointers Johnson-Odom had been 0-of-3 from deep and had only four points.

Williams said Johnson-Odom’s performance Tuesday reminded him of his performance in Marquette’s 74-67 overtime victory at Connecticut on Feb. 24.

Johnson-Odom had eight points in regulation but went off for nine in overtime.

Williams said he and Johnson-Odom butted heads that game, like they did tonight, and that Johnson-Odom used his disagreement with Williams as motivation when he’d go back into the game.

“Typically when he comes back in, he’s trying to prove me wrong,” Williams said. “Typically that translates into us having a good chance to win.”

Much of the first half was a back and forth battle. But with 3:21 left in the half West Virginia went on a 12-1 run to end the half and was down 36-29 at that time.

West Virginia hit 58.3 percent (14-of-24) from the field and 63.6 percent (7-of-11) from beyond the arc in the first half.

In the second half Marquette got after it on the defensive end, holding West Virginia to 22.2 percent (6-of-27) shooting from the field and 27.3 percent (3-of-11) on 3-pointers.

West Virginia coach Bob Huggins said his team simply didn’t make its shots in the second half.

“It’s been a year-long problem: We just don’t make open shots.  I don’t know what to tell you,” Huggins said.  “We don’t have people who can drive it to the basket. That’s not the kind of guys we have.”

The third-seeded Louisville Cardinals (23-8) are Marquette’s reward for victory. Game starts at 8 p.m.

Last time the teams met was Jan. 15 when Louisville pulled out the 71-70 victory when Marquette had an 18-point lead with 5:44 left.

“You could argue that the meltdown shook us. I don’t think we every fully regained our composure.  I don’t know if we have yet even today,” Williams said. “I thought the first 34 minutes at the (KFC) Yum! Center was the best we’ve played all year.  And I thought the last six minutes were as bad as we have played all year long.”

Posted in Basketball - Men's, Other, SportsComments Off on Marquette wins “dog fight” 67-61 over West Virginia

Petition calls for end to water bottle sales on Michigan’s campus

Members of the University community who buy bottled water instead of filling up at a drinking fountain may have been getting disapproving looks from a group of students recently.

Through a new petition, members of the Michigan Student Assembly’s Environmental Issues Commission are urging the University administration to ban the sale of bottled water from all vendors on campus. However, top University administrators, including University President Mary Sue Coleman, have said that such a move would most likely not be executed.

The petition proposes to eliminate bottled water from on-campus stores and vending machines and states that single-use bottled water is expensive, wasteful and harmful to the environment. Instead, the petition’s supporters want the University to install more water-filling stations, like the two that were installed in Mason Hall this year, to encourage the use of reusable water bottles.

Art & Design senior Lauren Sopher was inspired to write the petition by her work on the LSA Water Theme Semester Student Steering Committee. Sopher worked with Maggie Oliver, chair of MSA’s Environmental Issues Commission, to create and promote the online petition through MSA’s UPetition website.

Though the commission held events that raised awareness about bottled water in the past, Oliver said, this term seemed like a good time to launch the campaign because of the LSA Water Theme semester.

“LSA was doing the water-themed semester, so it’s going to be on people’s minds,” Oliver said.

Sopher said buying bottled water just doesn’t make sense.

“The thing with water bottles is water is a resource that should be available to everyone. It shouldn’t be a commodity,” Sopher said.

But, Tom Lauria, vice president of communications of the International Bottled Water Association, said water is a product that “has no special claim to being free.”

“As a commodity, water is in everything. It is ubiquitous,” Lauria said. “It is collected from private property like any other natural resource.”

At a fireside chat with students last month, Coleman said she was impressed with the level of environmental activism on campus, but said it was unlikely the administration would ever implement a ban of plastic water bottles.

“I think a more effective strategy is to convince people not to buy bottled water,” Coleman said, adding that University administrators make an effort to use reusable pitchers and cups instead of bottled water at their meetings.

“I encourage you to let your voices be heard,” Coleman said. “But just from a standpoint of what we can to do as an administration, to say we’re not going to sell things on campus, that’s more difficult for us. But, I certainly think you should advocate for more sustainable practices.”

For individuals who prefer bottled water because of its convenience, Oliver said, this reasoning isn’t worth its costs to the environment.

“I understand it could be frustrating having to take a few extra seconds to grab your water bottle and clean your water bottle,” Oliver said. “It’s hard to change your behavior. But I’m asking you, please make that change, not for me, but for our environment.”

However, Lauria said there is no reason to target bottled water as an environmental threat.

“It’s just easy to get natural spring water or purified water,” Lauria said. “It tastes better. Its mineral content gives it a brighter flavor. It is physically clearer when you put it up against the tap water. And I don’t understand why anyone would be questioning me consuming this, particularly when I have a recycling bin in the kitchen.”

The Environmental Issues Commission has advertised the bottled water petition on campus, in the residence halls, and by e-mailing professors and student groups to raise awareness of the issue.

Even if the commission doesn’t persuade the administration to ban the sale of bottled water on campus, Oliver said the petition will have succeeded in the most important goal in spreading the commission’s message.

“We have nearly 2,000 signatures right now, and that’s 2,000 people who said they are willing to change,” Oliver said. “If this act got people thinking, and got people to use reusable water bottles, and got people more environmentally aware, that’s what EIC is trying to do.”

— Daily News Editor Joseph Lichterman contributed to this report.

Posted in Campus Events, Green, Health, News, Other, PoliticsComments Off on Petition calls for end to water bottle sales on Michigan’s campus

Notre Dame installs remote video system at football practice fields

Notre Dame began installation Tuesday of a remote video system for its football practice fields, which will eliminate the need for elevated scissor lifts to film practices, according to a University press release.

Junior Declan Sullivan died Oct. 27 after the scissor lift from which he was filming football practice fell. He was a student videographer for the football team.

“I said in the days after Declan’s death that we would do everything in our power to make changes to ensure that such an accident does not happen again — here or elsewhere,” University President Fr. John Jenkins said in the press release. “This system is at the forefront in a completely new and innovative way.”

The University expects the new video system to be in operation at the LaBar Practice Complex when the football team begins spring practice March 23, according to the release.

The system, designed by XOS Digital, will be the first of its kind and include four Panasonic cameras mounted on 50-foot poles, the release said. Three of the poles will stand at the south ends of the three practice fields, with the fourth pole at the north end of field No. 1.

University spokesman Dennis Brown said student videographers would still manually film from the permanent towers and work to edit and produce films.

Brown said Notre Dame began to work with XOS on the new video system in the weeks following Sullivan’s death. The Florida company has installed several systems in Notre Dame facilities in the past 10 years.

“In looking for a way to improve safety in the weeks after the accident, Athletic Department officials asked the experts at XOS Digital about any ideas they might have, particularly in regard to somehow trying to mount a camera on top of a pole that would eliminate the need for hydraulic scissor lifts,” Brown said.

Brown said XOS presented a proposal for the new system in January. Tuesday began the process of installing the cameras, which Brown said are the size of television broadcast cameras, on top of the poles and raising the poles to full height.

The cameras will remain on top of the poles in temperature-controlled units, the press release stated. A fiber-optic network will transmit video to a control room in the Guglielmino Athletic Complex for members of the athletics video services department to edit and produce for players and coaches.

“In bringing its tremendous technology expertise to the table, XOS has worked hand in hand with our football program to form a partnership that now provides a new method of obtaining video materials that our coaches and players utilize,” Notre Dame Director of Athletics Jack Swarbrick said in the release.

Both Notre Dame and the Indiana Occupational Safety and Health Administration (IOSHA) are conducting ongoing investigations into the Oct. 27 accident.

IOSHA’s investigation is still in progress, said Stephanie McFarland, spokesperson for the Indiana Department of Labor.

“Everything is progressing along the investigative line and there is nothing new to report at this time,” McFarland said. “They’re going to go into the organization and they’re going to essentially look at anything and everything within the scope of the law that they’re allowed to look at in relation to the incident.”

IOSHA investigations result in safety orders when appropriate, McFarland said. These orders reveal findings and inform institutions of citations or fines.

McFarland said she is unable to say when IOSHA’s investigation at Notre Dame will be complete.

“The law does not state anything specific to how quickly an investigation should be concluded,” she said. “They just take as long as they need to do [investigations] properly.”

Brown said Notre Dame also does not currently have additional information to release on its own investigation.

Executive Vice President John Affleck-Graves is overseeing the University’s internal investigation, Brown said. This role includes coordinating University personnel and outside experts involved in the investigation.

The University appointed Peter Likins, former president of the University of Arizona and Lehigh University, to conduct the external review of Notre Dame’s internal investigation.

Likins told The Observer in November that his role would include assessing the University’s investigation results.

In addition to creating the remote video system, the release stated that XOS will contribute to the Declan Drumm Sullivan Memorial Fund established by the Sullivan family.

“We appreciate this wonderful contribution by XOS to the Sullivan family’s memorial fund,” Swarbrick said. “Our staff remembers Declan fondly, and our prayers remain with his family and friends.”

Notre Dame officials are working with the Sullivan family to determine how the University can honor Sullivan’s legacy, the release said.

“We are committed to memorializing Declan’s zest for life and presence at Notre Dame in a meaningful and lasting way,” Jenkins said. “Our conversations with his family members will shape Notre Dame’s memorials of Declan in a manner that give authentic and proper tribute to their son and brother.”

Posted in Campus Safety, Football, News, Other, Sports, TechnologyComments Off on Notre Dame installs remote video system at football practice fields

$200 million donation largest in USC history

USC has received its largest single donation since the university was established in 1880.

Dana and David Dornsife, longstanding patrons of the USC Brain and Creativity Institute and the university’s neuroscience program, have donated $200 million in an unrestricted endowment to the USC College of Letters, Arts & Sciences, which will now become the USC Dana and David Dornsife College of Letters, Arts & Sciences.

“This historic investment by Dana and David Dornsife in USC’s humanities, social sciences and sciences — the largest naming gift in the history of higher education for a college of letters, arts and sciences — is both transformational and inspirational,” President C. L. Max Nikias said in a press release. “Even more remarkable is that this unqualified support comes during such a challenging time for many in higher education.”

Nikias has only been president of the university for about seven months, but USC has already received three sizeable donations.

When Nikias was inaugurated Oct. 15, trustee Ming Hsieh announced a $50 million donation to the university for cancer research, and the Annenberg Foundation announced a $50 million donation to construct a new building for the Annenberg School for Communication & Journalism.

This donation from the Dornsifes, however, is unrestricted and will allow the College to decide how and when to spend the money.

“The College of Letters, Arts & Sciences plays a vital role in the life of USC, and we wanted our support to be unrestricted in order to give the university lasting flexibility,” David Dornsife said in the same press release. “We firmly believe that the College will lead the way in solving the major problems facing society and the world today.”

The gift is not targeted to a specific cause, though it is expected to be used for faculty hiring, research and fellowships, according to the Los Angeles Times, which broke the story Tuesday night.

The university will also implement a new Dornsife Scholars Program to recognize impressive seniors who graduate from the College and plan to continue their academic pursuits and study social challenges on a national and worldwide scale.

“Dana and David’s gift demonstrates their deep understanding of a basic truth — that all human progress and enlightenment rest on a firm foundation of outstanding scholarly inquiry across traditional and emerging fields within letters, arts and sciences,” Howard Gillman, dean of the College of Letters, Arts & Sciences, said in the press release.

David Dornsife graduated from USC in 1965 and is a USC trustee. He is also the chairman of the Herrick Corporation, the largest steel fabricator on the West Coast. Dana Dornsife graduated from Drexel University and is the founder of the Lazarex Cancer Foundation.

The $200 million donation by the Dornsifes is larger than the donation by Star Wars creator George Lucas, which helped to design a new building for the School of Cinematic Arts. Lucas donated $175 million in 2006.

Currently, the single largest gift to any college or university in the United States is the $600 million from Gordon Moore, the co-founder of Intel Corp., his wife Betty and their foundation, given to the California Institute of Technology in 2001, according to The Chronicle of Higher Education.

The College enrolls about 10,000 undergraduate and graduate students, has 33 academic departments and 31 research centers and institutes.

The College will permanently be known as the USC Dana and David Dornsife College of Letters, Arts & Sciences following a celebration in Bovard Auditorium on March 23 at 11 a.m.

Posted in Campus Events, News, OtherComments Off on $200 million donation largest in USC history

Physics student works on ‘Optical Tweezers’

For the past year and a half, senior Eric Brost has worked on a physics project that uses lasers to move particles.

The experiment, which is called “Optical Tweezers,” could possibly be used in cell surgery, but for now, Brost said he is trying to improve the experiment.

“It was incorporated into this class that all physics majors have to take, as an open research project,” Brost said. “I asked the professor one day if I could work on it full time and see where I could take the experiment.”

At first, Brost said his goal was to create a more research-quality setup for the experiment. Now he is comparing it to other research papers to see if “it is on par.”

“It might not be me, but maybe a student in a couple years could write a research paper using this experiment,” he said.

Brost said he hopes to collaborate with the biology department on a project sometime soon as well.

“Through this project, it’s given me a lot of confidence to do sort of academic things on my own and learn on my own, and be more motivated to be a better learner and teacher at the same time,” he said.

Brost works on the project every week, sometimes for a total of 20 hours, and he said he hopes another student will take over once he graduates.

Posted in News, Other, Research, TechnologyComments Off on Physics student works on ‘Optical Tweezers’

Editorial: Guantanamo about-face a necessary concession

President Barack Obama on Monday rescinded his two-year-old directive banning military tribunals at Guantanamo Bay. In a new executive order, Obama clears the way for resuming military trials at the naval base. This is regrettable, considering the president campaigned on — and committed to, once taking office — closing Guantanamo within a year of his inauguration. Still, the concession is a prudent one. Guantanamo is a nearly impossible issue, one that may be black-and-white in moral terms but is very gray in practice, and the reforms that the president has included in his most recent order alleviate much of what Americans have found so distasteful regarding the military base.

In order to deal with the 172 prisoners currently detained at the naval base, the new executive order reinstates a system allowing prisoners to be tried by military courts. Numerous obstacles have stood in the way of trying prisoners in civilian court and have forced them into legal limbo and indeterminate detention. The new executive order remedies this by allowing prisoners either to be tried on-site by a military tribunal or to make a plea bargain.

Because many of the detainees were tortured in an effort to obtain information, evidence gained from such tactics would be thrown out in court, weakening the prospect of conviction. The new order attempts to solve this problem by requiring compliance with international treaties barring inhumane treatment. But a fundamental problem remains: Because evidence obtained under duress is inadmissible — even in these military tribunals — the government faces a “Sophie’s choice” between releasing or illegally detaining people it reasonably believes to be terrorist threats to the United States. This is the fundamental problem of Guantanamo, and the Daily does not profess to have a ready solution.

Perhaps most important of all, the order establishes a process of periodic review by several federal agencies of the prisoners’ threat to our security. This will decide whether prisoners should be tried, released or transferred to a third-party country. Reviews of each detainee must occur within one year of this order and at least once every three years after that. In the sea of difficult options the administration faces, this step is laudable in that it gives detainees at least some framework for legal recourse.

Nonetheless, the new executive order fails to address many core issues pertaining to Guantanamo. The reinstatement of military tribunals merely reopens an avenue that is widely considered less desirable than civilian trials. Administration officials have insisted that the president remains committed to closing the base in the near future, but the order sheds little light on when that will be. And because Obama made it clear that the order only applies to current and not future detainees, it is unclear how the base will be used in coming years.

The administration faces only bad options when it comes to the detention camp, and it is commendable that Obama has acknowledged his mistake in prematurely steering away from military tribunals. Nonetheless, the new decision has left the long-term plans for Guantanamo up in the air. We do not hold the answer. But if it is indeed Obama’s intention to close Guantanamo, we can only hope that his administration devises a well-thought-out plan of action before making yet another promise to the American public. Commendable as this executive order is, it is far from resolving an issue that has remained a sore point in the United States for years.

Posted in Editorials, News, Opinion, Other, PoliticsComments Off on Editorial: Guantanamo about-face a necessary concession