“The Many Deaths of Laila Starr,” an opera about the goddess of death coming down to Earth, was set to premiere to the world on Halloween. Every member of the production — from performers to crew and orchestra members — had dedicated themselves to preparing for the show for the past three years.
But opening night would not go as planned. Rather than a full-cast performance in the Ordway Music Theater, the orchestra sat alone in Ted Mann Concert Hall on the University of Minnesota’s West Bank, performing a benefit concert instead.
On Oct. 26, five days before the opera would premiere, the Minnesota Opera announced they were postponing “The Many Deaths of Laila Starr”.
The Minnesota Opera Orchestra musicians, members of the Twin Cities Musicians Union, have been negotiating with Minnesota Opera management since May, seeking an increase in salary. Their pay, the orchestra wrote in an announcement, has been a flat rate for four years, and the proposal for the next four years showed no increase.
After months of unsuccessful negotiations, the Minnesota Opera Orchestra voted unanimously for a strike authorization in early October. Negotiations were still ongoing during this time, and orchestra member Jessica Findley Yang said there was another meeting scheduled with management before opening night.
“We’re all trying to stay positive,” musician Anne Ainomae said after the concert.
A viola player for 32 years and a member of the Minnesota Opera Orchestra for less than one year, she said the experience was great until these recent events. For her, the uncertainty of it all is the hardest part.
Karrin Meffert-Nelson, a clarinet player in the orchestra, is a member of the four-person negotiating committee for the orchestra. She said the committee has been trying for the past six months to come to a collective bargaining agreement with management that would add cost of living to their paycheck. The orchestra hopes to obtain this at the next meeting on Friday.

In the meantime, adrift from the show they had been working on for so long, the orchestra put on a benefit concert at Ted Mann Concert Hall.
The community showed up in droves to support the orchestra. PJ Parker was an attendee — an opera lover who couldn’t remember a time when she wasn’t a season ticket holder. Every time she went to a show, she said she would donate to the opera.
In light of the recent postponement, Parker sides firmly with the orchestra, though the opera management has disputed some of the orchestra’s statements. As she wrote in her letter to the management, it became difficult for her to even see the board of the opera welcome the audience to a show.
As for the audience, Parker was only one of many longtime opera fans. All ages were represented across the theater as well, from little girls in sparkly dresses to teens in “I Heart Opera” t-shirts. The murmuring of the crowd, of friends trying to find the best seat and sharing their excitement, was washed over by the calming chaos of the orchestra warming up.

When the performance started with the wave of the baton, it became apparent that watching the orchestra perform is just as mesmerizing as listening. Bows moved in rapid synchronization, stabbing up at the air in furious pace to the melody, and fingers moved across keys at lightning speed.
Since “The Many Deaths of Laila Starr” has yet to premiere, the orchestra was not able to play any of the music from the opera. Instead, over the course of that day, they composed a program of opera’s greatest hits.
“Toreadors” and “Habanera” from “Carmen” were the most recognizable, one of opera’s most ubiquitous soundtracks in movies and media.
The song “Méditation” from “Thaïs” was bassoonist Findley Yang’s personal favorite, a slow, contemplative, and soaring piece led by violinist Allison Ostrander, while viola player Ainomae was partial to “Song to the Moon” from “Rusalka,” featuring singer Liz Pearse.

While a number of the songs performed were instrumental, there were several with singer accompaniment. Pearse, Christine Amon, Scott Brunscheen and Philip Zawisa all brought traditional opera singing to the stage for their songs, while a chorus was featured in others.
Made up of choir members all across the Twin Cities, the chorus at the benefit concert was put together and rehearsed by the University’s own director of choral activities, Matthew Mehaffey. Every member of the chorus was a volunteer, including Barry Lau, an opera fan who said he jumped on the project after receiving an email from Mehaffey.
This kind of enthusiasm for the arts was evident in each of the performers, as some musicians were substitutes in the opera orchestra, and others were from the Minnesota Orchestra. As conductor Michael Christie said at the beginning of the concert, it really all came down to two words: More music.
This was echoed in a speech by the head of the negotiating committee, cellist Rebecca Arons, where she said the orchestra has already said what they have to say. What they really want, Arons said, is to go back to doing what they love in an environment where artists are valued and everyone is working together out of genuine respect.
The applause began before she was even done speaking, and when the orchestra played their final song immediately after, the standing ovation they received was long enough that they bowed four times.
“It’s a beautiful show of community,” Findley Yang said.
Musicians and audience members alike spilled out into the lobby afterward to chat, and union member Clare Zupetz said she was thrilled with the turnout. She didn’t know exactly how much cash had been put in the donation box, but the number of music-loving people who came to support gave her and all of the performers a great deal of hope.
The post ‘More music’: The Minnesota Opera Orchestra puts on a benefit concert amid uncertain times appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.



