I initially thought Lou Reed was a jazz musician. When I first heard “Walk on the Wild Side” as my dad pulled into the parking lot of a San Francisco Safeway, my immediate instinct was to ask who it was. When I received a reply, the name sounded instantly familiar, but I’d always assumed he was the same as Louis Armstrong or something. My pubescent brain could not process the idea that knowledge of one of the most influential musicians of all time could have escaped me in a year and a half of what I thought was all-encompassing rock education.
But what I remember most clearly was how badly I wanted to know what I was listening to. Here was a guy essentially talking over music, but the amount of feeling in his barely sung words was beyond my comprehension. Emotion, I thought, had to come from beautiful notes. How was this possible?
I got my first iPod at 13. My parents took turns burning their favorite albums onto the machine, and I listened to all of them. Janis Joplin’s Pearl, Prince’s 1999, Marianne Faithfull’s Strange Weather — all gems that I still listen to. Yet in heaviest rotation was Rock ‘n’ Roll Animal, a Lou Reed live album from 1974 consisting of four Velvet Underground versions and one solo cut. Rock ‘n’ Roll Animal was the album I became most immersed in when I started high school. I usually listened to it while scouting for places to eat in the neighborhood and it soundtracked my introduction to San Francisco’s Sunset District — a neighborhood with which I still have a deep connection.
A lot of fans consider Rock ‘n’ Roll Animal a joke, an attempt at cashing in on ’70s hard rock. It’s ludicrous at times, but there really isn’t anything on it that doesn’t work. The extended guitar jam intro to “Sweet Jane” is drop-dead gorgeous. The version of “Rock ‘n’ Roll,” with its five-minute ostinato jam, is at least on par with the original. The over-the-top textures of “Heroin” are a far cry from the spare arrangement on the Velvet Underground version, but the excess makes the raw helplessness of Reed’s vocal stand out even more, in addition to adding ambiguity over whether or not Reed is glorifying or demonizing heroin use.
I might just be sentimental and I might have a skewed opinion of it due to hearing it before anything by the Velvet Underground — but I still get the same feels when I listen to it now as then. It’s a haunting album, and as a kid, it scared me in the best way possible.
I first heard the Velvet Underground at an Andy Warhol exhibit at the de Young Museum near my house. A room was devoted to Warhol’s Exploding Plastic Inevitable events, at which the Velvets were regulars and Lou Reed’s original Gretsch guitar was on display. I remember scanning it for several minutes, looking for a fingerprint or some other vestige of my new musical idol’s presence. “Venus In Furs” played on loop.
Though I’d never heard any Velvet Underground music before, I knew exactly what it was. Its tugging dissonance, its impossibly dark strings, its candid lyrical content, Reed’s dry yet ominously sexy vocals — that chuckle on the last line. It was the same thrilling fear of the unknown I felt when I first walked into a headshop at the age of five. I introduced the Velvet Underground to my high school jazz band long after, which had turned into a sort of free improv ensemble after everyone who could actually play jazz left. We played “I’m Waiting For The Man” and “I’m Sticking With You” at one of our recitals, and soon, we were having contests to out-noise each other just as the Velvets did on their epic “Sister Ray.”
Lou Reed was the first musical hero I ever had who I idolized for not giving a fuck. The classic rock I listened to before Lou Reed elicited emotional responses the way I expected music to, through musical cues like the slow strumming that meant sadness or the overdriven riffs that meant sexual passion. Reed was different.
This was an artist whose work revealed itself with focus, whose ugliest musical moments were still rich with emotional content. This was a man who could make great art from a sensitive string ballad or an hour of feedback, who laid the nastiest aspects of himself bare on the table with little regard for how he would be perceived. As far as I was concerned, there was no studio-shined filter between the artist and the art. Lou Reed was his songs. And though it’s cliche to say he’ll live on through his music, he and his songs are still a part of me, living on as long as my memories last.