Author Archives | Craig Garcia

Justice Allison Apana will be present during Constitution Court’s discussion of her removal

ASUO Constitution Court Chief Justice Nick Schultz and Justice Cedar Cosner will be making their decision Monday, May 13, on Justice Allison Apana’s petition to review ASUO Sen. Bryan Vanderpool’s motion to remove her from office.

In her petition, Apana says according to the ASUO Constitution, the only reason a justice can be removed from office is if they are found guilty of nonfulfillment. Her petition requests the motion to remove her should be reviewed because according to her, Vanderpool’s motion is based solely on opinion, which doesn’t qualify as being a nonfulfillment of duties.

A court decision like this one is usually dealt with by all of the justices, but due to the petition coming from Apana, she won’t be involved in the process. Justice Caleb Huegel will also not be participating in the decision. According to him, he doesn’t want to be a part of the court’s decision because her petition isn’t valid.

“The Court has no authority,” he said, “to rule on Justice Apana’s petition for review because she does not have the right to submit it.”

He points to ASUO Constitution section 11.9 (PDF) where Con Court members are not allowed to refer such questions “regarding correct construction or interpretation of any part of the Constitution or any rule promulgated under it to the (court).”

In addition to claiming Apana’s petition is invalid, he also requested Schultz relieve himself of making a decision in this matter as well, due to the alleged romantic relationship between Schultz and Apana. Schultz rejected Huegel’s recusal.

“(Justice Cosner),” Schultz said, “didn’t feel that the evidence was sufficient enough for me to recuse myself.”

According to him, the court ruled in his favor by a vote of 2-1.

“Even though I’m named in this,” he said, “and that I’m upset with how I’ve been portrayed, and while I believe these statements are inaccurate, there’s no bias or self-interest in how I’ll make my decision on this matter.”

Also according to him, he and Cosner plan on making a decision on Apana’s petition Monday night, no matter how late it gets. Huegel will not be in attendance at all, but Apana will be present — even though the discussion will be about her removal. She is needed so that quorum can be satisfied — according to Court Rule 9.7 (PDF), she needs to be present in order to fulfill the bare minimum of justices who need to be present. Even though she will be present, she is not allowed to interact with Cosner or Schultz during the deliberation, in any regard.

“Justice Apana will not participate in any deliberations, any discussions and any voting,” Schultz said. “She will not be writing things down on paper or talking. She will be doing absolutely nothing except for sitting as quiet as possible.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Justice Allison Apana will be present during Constitution Court’s discussion of her removal

To make room for a central kitchen, UO wants to tear down historic cottages

*Copy editor’s note: The print and online version of this story originally ran a photo indicating the East Campus Graduate Village was slated to be torn down in addition to the historic cottages. Only the cottages are targeted for demolition, not the apartment complex. The Emerald regrets the error.

The University of Oregon sets out to accommodate undergraduate and graduate students to the best of its ability.

But, the UO plans on demolishing a dozen cottages built in the 1920s to 1940s, which are located on the east side of campus, so that it can build an $8.5 million central kitchen that will be more efficient and have more storage for food over the summer.

“Right now we’re in the center of campus,” said Tom Driscoll, the associate director of housing and director of food services. “It’s nice, except our trucks have trouble getting to the dorms because of all the foot traffic along the way. We want to be close, but not in the heart of campus.”

But for the sake of location and space, the UO has to uproot students and families to start on the project.

“They gave us reliable and affordable housing,” David Ozog said, a graduate student in computer and information science and a resident in one of the cottages. “I’m just really surprised and confused as to why they should replace such a good thing.”

University Housing is helping cottage residents by relocating them to the new Agate Apartments, but the move comes with a price.

“Fortunately, the new apartments are close, but they cost about $200 more in rent, and it’s less square footage,” Ozog said. “I still consider myself kind of lucky because I’m a single guy living with myself. Some of my neighbors have spouses and newborn kids.”

Justin Pack, his wife and his 2-year-old son are just the type of family Ozog is talking about. Pack is a graduate student at the UO and a graduate teaching fellow in the philosophy department.

“To some, these cottages might be a bit of an eyesore, but they enabled us to live close to campus with a single source of income,” Pack said. “There are 12 units here and they are the cheapest available family units the university owned. The decision to knock down these units must not have thought the existent of cheap family units very important.”

According to Driscoll, the new kitchen plans will be ready by December 2014, and even though Pack is disappointed by the situation, he and his wife were planning to move eventually if they decided to have a second child while he’s in school.

“I wish it was a priority for the university to keep such places around,” Pack said. “The low-income houses could have just happened to be in the best or easiest location. But I suspect low income housing just isn’t very profitable or of a high priority.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on To make room for a central kitchen, UO wants to tear down historic cottages

ASUO Constitution Court Justice Caleb Huegel allegedly leaked confidential information

In the midst of ASUO Senator Bryan Vanderpool’s motion to remove ASUO Constitution Court Justice Allison Apana from her seat, new claims have surfaced that  Justice Caleb Huegel has been leaking confidential information to the public and specific parties.

“I have received complaints from people saying that Justice Huegel has been leaking information to other parties,” Chief Justice Nick Schultz said. According to Schultz, the complaints have been from students and professional ASUO staff. “I’ve looked into them, and I’m still looking into them, but I have found no corroborating evidence at this point of time. Since there’s no corroborating evidence, I have zero intentions to go to Senate with this at this time.”

ASUO President Laura Hinman nominated Huegel for the position in October. In the ASUO Senate meeting that followed his nomination, some senators were concerned of Huegel’s past, and involvement as the president of the College Republicans, and overall being a very active member in college politics.

It was noted at the senate meeting that Justice Huegel voted for, and was a supporter of Hinman’s We Are Oregon campaign.

In the meeting, Senator Joe Junor asked Hinman if she had recruited Huegel for personal benefit. President Hinman said no, and that as far as she knew he wasn’t a volunteer and didn’t work for We Are Oregon.

“I have spoken to him, and he’s aware of the accusations, and I’ve told him that more than one person has approached me on it,” Schultz said. “But like I said, I still maintain that since there’s no corroborating evidence as of now, he’s done nothing wrong.”

Huegel released a statement regarding the allegations towards him.

“I firmly maintain that I have remained and will continue to remain an impartial and unbiased member of the ASUO Constitution Court,” Huegel said in his statement. “Furthermore, I would like to assure members of the Associated Students of the University of Oregon that I have already confessed any potentially concerning information regarding my involvement in college politics, and other potentially neutrality-comprimising activities…”

Huegel goes on in his statement to say that these claims are nothing more but defamation of character, and he commends Schultz for recognizing the lack of evidence that is towards the allegation.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASUO Constitution Court Justice Caleb Huegel allegedly leaked confidential information

Dennis Rodman asks North Korea to cut Kenneth Bae loose

Former NBA player Dennis Rodman wants North Korea to “do me a solid.” He went on Twitter to ask North Korean leader Kim Jong Un to release Kenneth Bae from incarceration.

The tweet is Rodman’s response to The Seattle Times writer, Thanh Tan, who suggested that Rodman should ask Kim Jong Un to release Bae.

Bae, a former UO student, has been held captive by North Korea since November and was recently sentenced to 15 years of hard labor by the North Korean Supreme Court.

Rodman went to North Korea in February, during a tense time between that country and the United States. During his trip, he and Kim Jong Un attended a exhibition basketball game together. According to Rodman, he plans on returning to North Korea again in August to vacation with Kim.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Dennis Rodman asks North Korea to cut Kenneth Bae loose

UO recognized as one of the greenest universities by The Princeton Review

From having one of the oldest and most well-regarded environmental law programs to being the first university in the nation to offer a green chemistry curriculum, the University of Oregon strives for excellence when it comes to being environmentally conscious. Now, the UO is being recognized by The Princeton Review as one of the greenest colleges in the nation.

In no particular order, The Review created a “Guide to 322 Green Colleges,” which was composed based on a school’s environmental course offerings, activities, career preparation and campus infrastructure.

“We’ve teamed up with The Princeton Review for the fourth year running to bring today’s environmentally-minded students the ‘Guide to Green Colleges,’” said Rachel Gutter, director of the Center for Green Schools at the U.S. Green Building Council.

According to her, the book is the only free, comprehensive and annually updated book, and it can be downloaded for free on The Princeton Review’s website. The book comes with a glossary of more than 40 green terms and a report on every school’s accessibility — from renewable energy sources and the availability of environmental studies at a university to the recycling and conservation programs a university offers.

She says more than half of prospective students look for a college or university having a strong commitment to sustainability and green campus initiatives. This has been the fourth year that U.S. Green Building Council has partnered up with The Princeton Review to produce a list — it’s also been the fourth consecutive year the UO has made the list.

One of the conservation programs that you’ll see in the book from the UO is the Center of Advancement of Sustainable Living, a program that’s been at the university since 2003. The program is currently building a low-impact house that will be entirely self-sustainable. The project has been in the works for a while now, but the center looks to use this recognition as a boost for the coming years.

“What we do at CASL is really trying to capitalize on that energy,” Events and Communication Co-director Emilie Froh said. “We’re hoping for this to continue our legacy.”

Programs like CASL are humbled to be a part of UO’s consistent recognition of being a green university. But for them, it’s not about rankings.

“Whether it’s ranked on a list or not,” Froh said, “people go to UO for it’s reputation of being a really green university that focuses on sustainability issues. Students can see when a university shows true concern for the environment.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on UO recognized as one of the greenest universities by The Princeton Review

ASUO Senate makes motion to remove Justice Apana, motion nullified by Chief Justice Nick Schultz

On tonight’s Senate agenda time was allotted to discuss ASUO Senator Bryan Vanderpool’s motion to remove ASUO Chief Justice-elect Allison Apana from the ASUO Constitution Court. However, Court Justice Cedar Cosner sent out a judicial order on Tuesday that would force the ASUO Senate to postpone discussion about the motion during Wednesday’s Senate meeting.

Even with the judicial order requiring the ASUO Senate to postpone discussion of the removal of Justice Apana to a later meeting, Vanderpool still moved with the removal of Justice Apana, and Senator Lindy Mabuya seconded the motion.

After the motion was seconded, the meeting continued on with the remainder of the meeting’s agenda. During the meeting, a press release was sent out by ASUO Constitution Court Chief Justice Nick Schultz about the body’s handling of Vanderpool’s motion.

According to Justice Schultz’s email, the body failed to comply with Justice Cosner’s judicial order, which voids Vanderpool’s motion, until the court lifts the judicial order.

In a response to Schultz’s email, Vanderpool said that Justice Cosner lacks any authority to enjoin his motion towards Justice Apana. Since the ASUO Senate didn’t vote on the motion, Vanderpool says that he is well within his senate rights, and that the Constitution Court’s interference is nothing more but an infringement of his freedom of speech.

“The fact that my motion is regarding the ongoing relationship between Justice Schultz and Justice Apana, a relationship Justice Apana appears to have lied about during her confirmation as Justice Schultz looked on, is an even further egregious breach of authority and decency,” Vanderpool said in a response to the nullified motion.

Vanderpool continues on his response to say that his motion is about protecting the integrity of the ASUO Constitution Court, and that he will move forward with his motion to remove Justice Apana from the Constitution Court.

“(The Constitution Court) have made their stance clear that Senate’s vote is voided,” ASUO Senate President, Matthew Miyamoto said.

The Senate’s vote might be voided, but according to Miyamoto, the Senate’s stance to keep the motion had its purpose.

“One part of the reason why the motion remained upon the agenda tonight was because the court did not issue a response to that ruling,” Miyamoto said. “I suppose part of Senate’s response will be circumstantial in that regard.”

On the Constitution Court side of things, Schultz said that under the ASUO Constitution, the court has final authority over all questions of interpretation of the constitution, and any rules that were created with it.

“My worry in all of this is that even though the motion doesn’t count, it still shows a dangerous attitude for student leaders to adopt,” Scultz said. “What they’ve done is just symbolic, and they can do it again at the next meeting, but it doesn’t show respect to the process.”

As both Miyamoto and Schultz said, the senate’s motion has been voided. That leads to the Constitution Court deciding what will happen to Justice Apana.

“In real life we have courts, whether you like it or not, you have to let the courts rule — there is a process in doing things. What’s happening here is that they’re infringing the courts ability or authority of the constitution,” Schultz said. “There’s a real constitutional issue here. This is a constitutional question, and we have a constitutional court to decide those questions.”

In the recent events that have happened between Vanderpool’s motion to remove Apana, Chief Justice Schultz still believes that this is a constitutional process, but it does involve the productive partnership of the other branches.

“We can put our heads together, and show students that we are leaders,” Schultz said. “I hope I’ll have a partner with President (Laura) Hinman and Senate President Miyamoto to move forward, and to prove to students that we’re mature adults that can respect the process.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASUO Senate makes motion to remove Justice Apana, motion nullified by Chief Justice Nick Schultz

ASUO Senate Meeting: May 8

Live coverage of Wednesday night’s ASUO Senate meeting:

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASUO Senate Meeting: May 8

ASUO Constitution Court issues order regarding motion to remove Chief Justice Apana

The ASUO Constitution Court has received a judicial order from Associate Justice Cedar Cosner to enjoin ASUO Sen. Bryan Vanderpool’s motion to remove Chief Justice-elect Allison Apana.

The judicial order means the ASUO Senate will have to postpone its ruling of Vanderpool’s motion to remove her from office.

One of the reasons Vanderpool motioned to remove her from office was due to how she handled the ASUO election results. Cosner is granting her petition asking the ASUO Senate if they have the ASUO constitutional right to remove a chief justice from office if they didn’t agree with how they handled a situation.

Cosner granted her petition in addition to issuing a judicial order, such that the court will have the proper amount of time to consider her opposing argument to Vanderpool’s motion.

Chief Justice Nick Schultz is recalling the court from recess early so that they can deal with the matter at hand.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASUO Constitution Court issues order regarding motion to remove Chief Justice Apana

Motion filed to remove newly-elected Constitution Court chief justice

ASUO Sen. Bryan Vanderpool filed a motion to remove Chief Justice Allison Apana from office, due to her handling of the ASUO election results. According to Vanderpool’s motion, the court’s ruling invalidating the election results was “unnecessary and against ASUO constitution.”

The invalidation almost led to another election, until the University of Oregon administration had to intervene and deemed the results valid.

“Right after the election results were thought to be invalidated was when I started to think about putting this motion together,” he said.

In his motion, he said the court’s ruling of declaring the election results invalid would have changed nothing and would have only been a waste of students’ time.

“I’ve talked to some senators about it, and there are definitely people on board with this,” he said.

This motion will be brought up during the next ASUO Senate meeting this Wednesday in the EMU Walnut Room.

He also questions Apana’s credibility, claiming that when she was asked if she knew anyone from the court prior to her nomination, she said no. But he claims in the motion that she did know of former Chief Justice Nick Schultz and suggested that the two were actually in a “romantic relationship.”

Vanderpool is requesting for her to be removed from office for not properly fulfilling her duties as a member of the ASUO Constitution Court and establishing that he — and other student senators — may not have voted for Apana if her relationship with Schultz had been known.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Motion filed to remove newly-elected Constitution Court chief justice

ASUO Senate may experience an increase in surplus, over-realized funds

The ASUO surplus saw a healthy increase in its surplus of $6,000. According to ASUO Sen. Taylor Allison, the funds came from a contract with the Sexual Assault Support Services that fell through.

“There is certain documentation that has to come from them to the ASUO,” she said. “There was some sort of problem with getting the documentation to us.”

Since SASS wasn’t able to turn in all of the necessary documentation, some — but not all — of their requested funding had to be returned back to ASUO.

The abrupt increase left the body with a decision on how to inform the student body about the increase. These funds are good news for student groups that will be requesting funds for these last few weeks of the term. But some senators predict there is a strong possibility that groups that had their requests turned down earlier in the year will be coming back again and looking for the answer they didn’t get before.

“A lot of funding decisions would’ve gone differently if we were aware of the situation,” Sen. Lindy Mabuya said at the senate meeting.

In addition to the increase in surplus, the over-realized fund may see an increase of up to $30,000. These funds would be taken out of groups’ line items that weren’t able to spend all of the money for a particular project.

The Over-Realized Fund Committee had planned for this money to come in much sooner in the year but wasn’t able to solidify anything until recently. Once the funds were within reach, the committee came to a unanimous decision recommending that the extra money should be used this year for groups that had requested earlier this year but were denied.

Despite a unanimous vote in the committee, the body wasn’t completely pleased.

Sen. Chase Salazar wanted to see the funds available to all students not just the specific groups who had met the prior over-realized application deadline. He mentioned wanting to have Senate on the same page before sending out information to groups about the increase in funds.

“Even sending out those emails. I don’t want that to happen,” he said.

Mabuya shared his sentiment.

“There needs to be a larger conversation, and as I said, I do respect the recommendation that the committee has come up with, but as a student body we need to understand that it is just a recommendation,” she said.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASUO Senate may experience an increase in surplus, over-realized funds