Author Archives | Craig Garcia

The US Supreme Court rules Defense of Marriage Act unconstitutional

The law excluding the federal government from recognizing same-sex marriages legalized by states, known as the Defense of Marriage Act, was brought down in the Supreme Court on Wednesday morning.

The Supreme Court ruled DOMA as unconstitutional in a 5-4 vote. Justice Anthony Kennedy announced the court’s decision and was accompanied by justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan.

“DOMA is unconstitutional as a deprivation of the equal liberty of persons that is protected by the Fifth Amendment,” wrote Kennedy in the Supreme Court’s majority statement. “By seeking to displace this protection and treating those persons as living in marriages less respected than others, the federal statute is in violation of the Fifth Amendment.”

Along with the DOMA decision, the Supreme Court chose to not take up a challenge of California’s Proposition 8, claiming that the proposition had no legal standing to be case brought forward to the Court. With the new Court Decision, California is now able to resume having same-sex marriages.

With the new rulings on DOMA and Prop 8, states such as Oregon that haven’t legalized same-sex marriage now have the support of the federal government behind them on the issue of marriage equality. But no matter what courts or states think of same-sex marriage, any change that’s made to marriage equality comes down to the people, and their power and willingness to either make a change or stay the same.

“There’ll still be a battle against this decision — no doubt about it,” said Nina Nolen, a volunteer for the Women’s Center and the ASUO Senate liaison for the center. “What’s important is that we have the decision, and that’s going to be the ultimate push for other states to go about legalizing same-sex marriage.”

The reaction from social media has been positive for the Supreme Court’s ruling, but affluent groups such as the National Organization of Marriage (a group formed in 2007, who’s specific goal was to pass Prop 8) are showing their opposition to the new ruling. NOM’s current President, Brian Brown was in front of the Supreme Court during the ruling, and according to The New York Times, Brown is pressing forward for a federal ban on same-sex marriage which was last brought up during President Bush’s 2004 election.

“It’s a big leap for the LGBT in our country, and I initially gave myself permission to be really excited,” said Maure Smith, assistant director of the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender Education and Support Services Program. “I’m really excited, but I know things are about to get complicatd.”

Smith was married to her partner four years ago in Boston, Massachusetts. It was important to her and her partner to be married under the court of law, even if they knew it wasn’t going to last. “When we married in Boston we knew it wasn’t going to matter, but it was still really important to us.”

Smith and her partner moved to Oregon knowing their relationship would have to be considered a domestic partnership due to Oregon’s Measure 36, which is essentially the state’s version of Prop 8.

Smith is hopeful that with the new ruling, laws like Measure 36 will be invalidated come November and that this will hopefully lead to more change for the LGBT community.

“The hope is that states with domestic partnership will be the first ones to change their policies,” Smith said. “I’m so excited for this hopeful change, but it’s important to keep in mind that this still isn’t enough to end the violence and discrimination against the LGBT community in schools. That needs to go just as much as DOMA needed to go.”

The American Civil Liberties Union and Oregon United for Marriage are hosting a rally at the Wayne Morse Free Speech Plaza on the corner of 8th Avenue and Oak Street today at 5 p.m. on the matter.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The US Supreme Court rules Defense of Marriage Act unconstitutional

Legal fees in the UO’s fight against the NCAA rise upward of $200,000

Even for the University of Oregon, keeping up with all of the fees that come with fighting the NCAA’s charges is becoming a costly venture. The University has spent $208,991.08 in legal fees alone for going to court against the NCAA. Invoices from the law firm, Bond, Schoeneck & King show that they have charged the UO upward of $200,000 between September 2011 and March 2013.

For over two years, the NCAA has been investigating the University’s recruitment practices for football, and if they are violating the NCAA recruitment standards. The University tried to reach a plea bargain with the NCAA in October, but they rejected it, and instead charged the University with seven recruitment violations in December.

According to the invoices from the law firm, the University saw a dramatic increase in fees starting in December and going through March, in order to prepare for the court case.

So far, the University has admitted to at least one violation regarding that the scouting services the school used did not issue quarterly reports, which is a direct violation of NCAA rules.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Legal fees in the UO’s fight against the NCAA rise upward of $200,000

ASUO’s year of concerts and controversies

Wrapping things nicely and putting a nifty a little bow on top: that’s not how ASUO does things. From the threat of the Oregon Marching Band having its funding cut to the three week expulsion of former President Laura Hinman, the ASUO’s controversies and triumphs will be a standout memory for the 2012-2013 school year.

Before school had really started, controversies surrounding the UO hiring a marketing firm to convince students to vote “yes” for the EMU renovation began to spread around campus. The firm, which was suggested by the EMU Task Force, would help reach the goal of receiving the appropriate amount of votes to support the renovation. The move was ultimately canned.

In November, the ASUO Senate made one of its most controversial moves by allocating $142,000 to the executive’s Mallard Madness project. While the executive has a fair chance to receive over-realized funds, many students, groups and organizations were concerned that Mallard Madness was not subjected to the same process. Ultimately, the project received funding, but after a few more funding and defunding conversations.

In late January, a grievance filed by Joanna Stewart toppled the We Are Oregon executive branch by ousting Hinman from the president’s seat. The grievance cited that Hinman had been in non-fulfillment for three weeks for not appointing an elections board. After a trial, the ASUO Constitution Court ruled to vacate Hinman’s position until ASUO Vice President Nick McCain was able to appoint an Elections Board — nearly a month later, Hinman was reinstated.

During the tail end of the Hinman debacle,  the Oregon Athletic Band was fighting for funding against a Department Finance Committee that wished to move its funding to sources that weren’t directly paid for by students. The band was originally defunded with the intention that the UO administration, Athletics and the School of Music and Dance would pick up the slack — a plan that wasn’t outlined to the band, or the sources. The move ultimate led to hundreds of band members attending a heated DFC meeting that lasted for hours. The band is currently still funded by the ASUO.

After years of relatively controversial ASUO elections, this year would be no different. The battle between Senator Lamar Wise and former ASUO President Sam Dotters-Katz would prove to be relatively calm — until the first grievance started a wildfire. Claims of illegal phone banking, bribery and collecting voter information under false pretenses were the major issues that sprung out of the annual process, but the release of the results proved to be the strangest. The United Oregon campaign was allegedly bribing voters with T-shirts — an act made illegal by Oregon State Law — and the elections board and Con Court felt uncomfortable releasing the results, knowing that it could impact a fair re-election if it came down to it. After UO administration stepped in to clarify that ASUO elections do not follow all of Oregon’s laws, the results were released which produced Dotters-Katz as the next ASUO President.

In May, the Con Court had two court justices threatened with removal from office due to a non-fulfillment of duties. Although on top of the non-fulfillment, Justice Allison Apana was allegedly having a romantic relationship with Chief Justice Nick Schultz, and Caleb Huegel had been allegedly releasing confidential information to outside parties.

And then all in one day, the ASUO members who were calling Apana and Huegel out decided to withdraw their allegations towards them. After one of the most publicized weeks for the Con Court, everyone came out with not a scratch on them.

Just like everyone else who’s involved with a group on campus, the ASUO is made up of students — students who are learning, and who will continue to learn through their mistakes and successes. With a new administration comes new accomplishments and a whole new group of students ready to learn from their oversights.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASUO’s year of concerts and controversies

How the recommendations from the previous ASUO administration could affect students

From the previous ASUO administration, former Sen. Lindy Mabuya, former Vice President Nick McCain and former President Laura Hinman sent out three documents with recommendations in regards to how to lower the budget for the ASUO in the future. Current ASUO members have criticized some of the recommendations in the memos, saying that the recommendations ask for students to be less involved with the negotiating and contracting process with outside organizations that the University of Oregon are involved with.

On the surface, this looks like nothing more but internal conflict between different members of the ASUO. It’s true that the conflict primarily resides in and will be settled by the ASUO, but the outcome of this will affect all students — whether we realize it or not.

“There is a group (of recommendations) which contains what could potentially be very beneficial but have anywhere from small amounts to a large amount of effects on student groups and organizations,” ASUO President Sam Dotters-Katz said. “We can’t go forward without any broad consultation.”

One of those recommendations being to move funding for centers such as the Women’s Center, Men’s Center, the LGBTQA and the Sustainability Center from the Program Finance Committee to the EMU Board.

Even for those not involved with a center, the incidental fee funds the PFC, which is a fee that all students pay at the beginning of year along with their tuition. One of the primary objectives from these recommendations is to lower the incidental fee, but transitioning funding duties from the PFC to the EMU Board could mean that funding would be cut.

Some centers, such as the Women’s Center, are just as concerned as Dotters-Katz with the transition as well.

“I believe that a move from the Program’s Finance Committee to the EMU Board is a process that needs heavy involvement from all members of the centers discussed,” said Nina Nolen, a volunteer for the Women’s Center and the ASUO Senate liaison for the center. “There needs to be many more discussions about the pros and cons of each choice, and ultimately the decision it needs to be based on if a move would ensure the best possible services being provided to student.”

And this is just one of the multiple changes that have the potential to go into effect and change the course of how students are able to get an overall exceptional experience during their time at UO. Since the recommendations come from an administration that’s no longer active in the ASUO, all these recommendations could be dead in the water. However, these were sent to the UO administration, and if they like what they read, some changes could be made without the student’s consent.

“The process of administering items on the incidental fee will always be led by students,” Dotters-Katz said. “We will not allow the fire sale of decades of autonomy and the ability of student leaders to administer contracts for the benefits of our students.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on How the recommendations from the previous ASUO administration could affect students

ASUO Senate appoints the Summer Senate

For the last ASUO Senate meeting of the school year, the Senate appointed who would be on the Summer Senate and who would be the Summer Senate President and Vice President.

For the Summer Senate, there are six stipend positions, but eight people were nominated for the Summer Senate. However, when it was Sen. Miles Sisk’s turn to state his reason for why he should be in the ASUO Summer Senate, he decided to withdraw his nomination so that they wouldn’t need to do a vote.

“I’ll have a job for the summer, and I don’t need the stipend so I’ll go ahead and withdraw my nomination to save us the awkward voting,” Sisk said. Even though he won’t be a paid member of the Summer Senate, Sisk says that he’ll still be apart of the Summer Senate, which is an option that is open to all senators.

The ASUO Summer Senators will be Josh Losner, Stephanie Schie, Alivia Feliciano, Taylor Allison, Parker Williams and Amy Jones.

For the ASUO Summer Senate President, Jones and Allison were nominated for the position, and the Senate voted for Jones to be the Senate President during the summer. With Jones elected as the Summer Senate President, Allison was nominated for the Summer Senate Vice President position, along with first-year senator Feliciano. Losner and Schie were also nominated for the position, but they both withdrew their nomination.

Allison was voted unanimously as the Summer Senate Vice President, but the decisions were still difficult for some Senators to make.

“Senator Allison really deserves this,” ASUO Senate President Matthew Miyamoto said. “But the Summer Senate Vice President seat has had first-year senators in the position in the past, and they benefited greatly from it.”

The ASUO Senate will no longer meet during the school year, and the Summer Senate will have to meet at least once a month during the summer.

Miyamoto says that the Summer Senate usually meets every two weeks, and traditionally, the Summer Senate meets for the first time two weeks after finals week.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASUO Senate appoints the Summer Senate

ASUO Senate Meeting: June 5

Live coverage of Wednesday night’s ASUO Senate meeting:

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASUO Senate Meeting: June 5

UOPD releases a sketch of possible suspect from recent campus thefts

With the help of a witness, the UOPD has been able to draw a sketch of an alleged suspect from a string of campus burglaries. The burglaries occurred in the faculty and staff offices in Gerlinger, Lawrence and Willamette halls, where computers and other electronic devices were reported stolen on April 26 and May 23.

The incidents happened at approximately 6 p.m. and midnight. With the help of an employee from Columbia Hall who said they saw a suspicious man at those hours, the UOPD has been able to release a sketch of the suspect.

The witness described the man as 150 pounds who is in his 20s or 30s and is white with a gaunt face and rosy cheeks.

The UOPD is currently investigating the crimes, and warns UO staff and students to be extra careful with all of their electronic devices and to make sure all devices are properly protected.

The UOPD has asked that if anyone has seen any suspicious activity on campus, or needs to report a similar incident to call (541) 346-2919.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on UOPD releases a sketch of possible suspect from recent campus thefts

Protestors demonstrate at UO President Gottfredson’s Investiture

Fifty protestors were outside Matthew Knight Arena during Thursday’s Investiture for University of Oregon President Michael Gottfredson.

Former ASUO Sen. Jeremy Hedlund was one of the protesters, with his primary motivation for being there to show his support for lowering tuition rates.

“The education is already too expensive,” he said, “and we’re forcing a lot of people out of an education.”

Another concern he mentioned was how UO faculty members are one of the lowest paid university members in the American Association of Universities — with some of the faculty not even getting a raise in pay since 2008.

“The money that they’ve been charging us has clearly not been going to the faculty members,” he said.

Among the 50 protesters, 15 of them went inside Matthew Knight Arena during Gottfredson’s Investiture. Once everyone was on stage, these protesters chanted a mic check. They then vocally protested their disdain over the tuition increases and how the UO is spending a significant amount in lawyer fees to fight against the faculty’s demand for raises.

The protestors were eventually escorted out of the building.

“We hope that if there’s pressure from a lot of different sources,” Hedlund said, “that he’ll start paying attention to students and their needs. We’re the ones getting a 4.5 percent tuition increase, and he’s the one getting a fancy party.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Protestors demonstrate at UO President Gottfredson’s Investiture

ASUO talks about recommendations sent to the UO Administration

With over $10,000 in the special requests for Wednesday’s meeting, the  new 2013-2014 ASUO Senate didn’t start their first meeting with slight and ease. Before they were able to get to the special requests, the Senate heard former ASUO Senator Lamar Wise regarding his concerns over the recommendations that were sent out to the UO administration from former ASUO President Laura Hinman, former Vice President Nick McCain, and former Sen. Lindy Mabuya.

One of Wise’s biggest concerns from the memos were the incidental fee cap being lowered from seven percent, which he believes would do more harm than good.

“We only have so much to grow programs with as of right now. I just think that shrinking the room of growth deplete how we will be able to provide growth for other services,” Wise said.

Wise was also concerned about giving the ASUO less control over negotiations and contracts with outside organizations.

“If you look at it in plain writing, it implies that there is a process going on without student’s being apart of a section of the process,” he said.

Hinman and Mabuya weren’t in attendance for the meeting, but McCain was, and he allowed himself to answer any questions that the Senate, or the audience had in terms of the recommendations.

He responded to Wise’s thoughts of ASUO having less control over contracts by saying that the reason for the contract recommendation is because he doesn’t want ASUO members who have little experience in negotiations to be taken advantage of by outside organizations who aren’t looking for the best interest of the students.

“The emphasis based on the whole of the recommendation is on better preparing students so that they’re not being taken advantage of during the contracting process,” McCain said. “The ASUO still has the contracts, but we’re wanting for the ASUO to pick somebody who is more skilled and qualified for the process.”

McCain says that the contract recommendation comes after seeing too many times students not being aptly prepared to deal with the negotiation of contracts, due to senators being busy with other ASUO duties, schoolwork, and so on.

In regards to the incidental fee, Wise and McCain agree that they both have fundamental differences with how they perceive the fee. In response to Wise’s thoughts of the fee depleting all-around growth, McCain says that the fee is something that definitely needs to be talked about more thoroughly and that the incidental fee is just one small idea in the memos of recommendation for how to spend less time worrying about budgets, and more time focusing on other ASUO matters.

The other prominent topic for Wednesday’s meeting was funding the Student Activities and Resource Center $9,148 for office supplies and furniture for its new space in the EMU.

“I think starting tonight we need to be very careful with how we spend the money,” Sen. Amy Jones said, in regards to spending surplus money. It was a sentiment that many senator’s agreed with, as they suggested to the SARC to go about finding furniture through UO’s surplus furniture exchange, and to possibly consider buying some Windows computers instead of all Apple computers.

Eventually the motion was passed for SARC to receive $6,102, however, it was a close vote. Sen. Taylor Allison voted against the lower motion because she believes that the $9,148 was already the bare minimum SARC could ask for.

“They’re not asking for curtains — they’re asking for desks and filing cabinets — things that are crucial for all offices,” Allison said. “I see this resource center as something that all programs can be apart of, and it’s vital that they get the proper supplies that they need to better serve all students.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASUO talks about recommendations sent to the UO Administration

ASUO Senate Meeting: May 29

Live coverage of Wednesday night’s ASUO Senate meeting:

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on ASUO Senate Meeting: May 29