Author Archives | by Wren Warne-Jacobsen

Opinion: The VP debate was civil — Trump is not

Remember the vice presidential debate? 

Ohio Sen. J.D. Vance and Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz faced off in a debate that was, at times, borderline civil — a welcome contrast to the hostility of the presidential debate between Vice President Kamala Harris and former President Donald Trump, in which Trump falsely claimed immigrants were eating pets and Democrats supported killing infants.

Vance went as far as to show respect for his opponent and the moderators — a far cry from the hostility and name-calling both Trump and Vance use on the campaign trail. This illustrated a theme from Vance throughout the debate where he appeared more reasonable than his ideas.

This civility, while encouraging for the future of political discourse, walked a thin line between refreshing and dangerous.

As a society, we need to find more common ground in politics and learn to work together, but we’re not there yet. Don’t let the political bromance of the VP debate shield you from what the GOP ticket would mean for the country.

Howard Lavine, a political psychology professor at the University of Minnesota, said Walz and Vance appeared to be two people who could agree with each other but didn’t like each other’s running mate. When discussing Vance’s performance, Lavine said Vance’s skills give him an advantage in debate.

“He is very capable of talking about things in a relatable way,” Lavine said. “He didn’t tell the truth about a lot of things. A lot of things that a lot of people won’t know are not true.”

Vance made irrational ideas sound rational to viewers who weren’t listening with a critical ear.

Emily Vraga, a mass communications and political psychology professor, said politicians who lie and spread misinformation in the U.S. do not suffer significant consequences and do not lose much appeal among voters.

“Polarization in the U.S. is really strong,” Vraga said. “That leads us to believe our side and disbelieve anyone who’s trying to say our side isn’t right.”

While Vance delivered some misinformation in a believable manner, we also saw the staple outlandish statements the Trump campaign is known for, including Vance’s assertions that Trump will bring back common sense and put the people first — both of which he does the opposite of whenever he walks into a room.

Vance also falsely asserted that Trump peacefully gave up power in 2020 and refused to acknowledge the results of the election when Walz asked him if Trump lost.

“Tim, I’m focused on the future,” Vance said.

If you take one thing into this election, let it be that Trump and Vance are dangerous for American democracy, no matter Trump’s outlandish statements or Vance’s mask of rationality.

Michael Edwards, co-communications director for the Undergraduate Political Science Association at the University, said Vance’s debate performance was different from what he’s seen from him in the campaign so far. Edwards said Trump’s age could be a significant factor in the difference between his and Vance’s debate performances.

When comparing Trump’s and Vance’s debate performances, both men reflected very different perspectives on the state of this country.

“We have the greatest country, the most beautiful country,” Vance said in his closing statement.

Compare this to Trump’s description of the U.S. in the presidential debate between him and Harris.

“We’re a failing nation,” Trump said twice during the debate. “We’re a nation that’s in serious decline.”

These two statements paint very different pictures of the GOP ticket — only one of whom is running for president. Vance could present himself as a respectful, optimistic patriot, but it doesn’t change the fact that Trump will take this fear-mongering negativity and use it as his basis to govern, should he be elected.

Lavine said while we can hope our political discourse will begin to reflect the respect and civility of the VP debate in the future, that is not likely to happen with Trump still engaged in politics. He added that Trump uses the status threat felt by many of his supporters to fuel division and fear of social and demographic changes.

“Trump is tapping into a significant level of resentment in the public,” Lavine said.

When discussing whether Vance’s performance could sway undecided voters, Vraga and Lavine both said voters who are still undecided are likely to be tuned out of politics and probably didn’t watch the VP debate at all.

Ashaar Ali, a second-year strategic communications student, said the VP debate seemed more composed and respectful than the presidential debate between Harris and Trump, but she doesn’t think this will change voters’ minds. Ali added the lack of fact-checking in the debate bothered her because misinformation is already such a significant issue.

Vraga said the partisan nature of fact-checking in this misinformation-filled environment makes it difficult to reach people with fact-checked information.

“Democrats spread fact-checks about Republicans and Republicans spread fact-checks about Democrats,” Vraga said. “If your side lies, and even if there is a fact check issued, the odds are you won’t see it, and if you see it, you’re likely to be very skeptical of it.”

Vraga said people should make an effort to seek out perspectives that challenge their own and that we as a society have the power to change systems that perpetuate misinformation.

As voting begins, the VP debate is probably the furthest thing from your mind. It gave us a glimpse into what politics post-Trump could be but also a reminder that the GOP ticket does not respect fair elections or a peaceful transfer of power.

The Harris-Walz campaign is the only rational party in this presidential election and the only one that will work to protect democracy. Trump and Vance lie about many issues, but they reflect their true colors when they refuse to accept the results of fair elections. 

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: The VP debate was civil — Trump is not

Opinion: Responsible Citizenship 1001

Did you take civics in middle school? If you weren’t required to take government in high school and have not sought out a similar class in college, you might be relying on your sixth grade education to form your understanding of the political process. 

Students learn the basic structures of government, such as the separation of powers, but required education doesn’t go far beyond that. Many students who don’t focus their studies in government and social science don’t gain an understanding of what their representatives are supposed to do and how they can get involved to elect representatives who support their interests. 

News literacy skills and learning to responsibly consume political messages also get lost in the void between primary education and post-grad life, leaving some students susceptible to misinformation that has become prevalent on social media. 

The University of Minnesota should implement a required course for all students that teaches basic civic engagement and news literacy skills, empowering them to be responsible, active citizens. 

Higher education must equip students with these fundamental skills and resources, including how to navigate voting, analyze political messages and identify misinformation and bias in the media.

Sixteen percent of Generation Z who did not register to vote in the 2022 midterm election said they did not know how to or had difficulty completing the application. Of those who did not cast a ballot, 42% reported being too busy or forgot to vote. 

This shows some Gen Z voters lack the resources to effectively begin engaging in the political process compared to earlier generations who are more frequently targeted by campaigns. 

The University had the highest student voter turnout of any four-year institution in the country in 2020 at 80% — in part thanks to initiatives such as Row the Vote. Still, many students don’t get the knowledge they need to be responsible, active citizens in post-graduate life.

Alexa Drescher, a first-year graduate student at the University, said the last government class she took was in sixth grade, and feels she didn’t get sufficient education to do her own research and navigate civic engagement. Drescher said a University-wide required course is important, especially for informing students about the roles of state and federal representatives.

“What does my state representative do?” Drescher said “What does the president do? Who has the power to do what?” 

Drescher said she only recently understood the limited roles of the vice president when observing the Republican Party’s criticisms of Vice President Kamala Harris for both the actions and inactions of the Biden administration — which she has limited power to control.

When citizens lack understanding of how the government operates and who has the power to make significant policy changes, they become vulnerable to misleading claims like those about Harris. College education must help students eliminate this confusion by implementing a required class for everyone. 

Timothy Johnson, a political science and law professor, said civics education is essential for all students to learn to critically evaluate politics and understand the governmental process. 

“From K to 12, as well as in higher education, we simply need to do a better job as educators of teaching students civics,” Johnson said. “It’s just better for how we are as citizens if you understand how government and the process works.”

Johnson said he mostly works with students who are genuinely interested in politics and government in his upper-level courses, but some who come into his introductory course lack critical knowledge of how the government works. Johnson added that students who understand how the government operates are more likely to trust the government and view it as legitimate. 

Nina Maxwell, a first-year student, said she would support a required civic engagement and news literacy course similar to the First-Year Experience courses required in colleges across the University, even if students already learned the content. 

“Even if you know, it’s always good to have a reminder,” Maxwell said.

In our digital world, news literacy is increasingly relevant, and being able to identify misinformation and bias is essential to being a responsible citizen. 

The News Literacy Project, a nonpartisan nonprofit organization, works nationwide to increase news literacy for K-12 students by providing educational resources that prepare them to be informed members of society. 

According to one of their five news literacy standards, “Students express and exercise civic responsibility by seeking, sharing and producing credible information as effective participants in a democracy.”

Students across the country do not meet this standard by their high school graduation. This makes it even more important for higher education to teach all students basic skills and expand on them to help students become critical thinkers and decision makers. 

Johnson said he wants his students to be able to take the knowledge they learn in class and use it to be active citizens and responsible consumers of information. 

“My job as a teacher, as a social scientist, as a political scientist is to help my students learn how to think, but don’t teach them what to think,” Johnson said. “I don’t concern myself with what they actually believe, as long as they can back it up with good evidence and that the sources they are using that help them suss out those beliefs are good sources.” 

With the spread of misinformation on social media and biased content online, the ability to identify credible sources and use reliable information to form opinions is a cornerstone of effective civic engagement.

Ellias Bjorback, a second-year post-secondary enrollment student, said there needs to be more focus on teaching students how to identify bias in messages online. Prior to taking a government class at the University, Bjorback did not know much about how the government and legislative process works. 

College students invest tens of thousands of dollars in their education, and many will become our future leaders. Higher education institutions have a responsibility to help them become informed and engaged citizens. 

Johnson said he is hopeful students in future classes will enter college with a better understanding of civics because of legislation passed in the 2023 Minnesota legislative session requiring all students to fulfill a citizenship and government course requirement in 11th or 12th grade.

Still, not all students have these requirements in high school and students at the University represent a small percentage of students nationwide. Even fewer will take government courses during their time at the University and those in unrelated majors may not see the need to. 

By requiring civics education and news literacy for all students, the University can give students an advantage in becoming thoughtful, engaged citizens and serve as a model for institutions across the country that are educating the next generation of voters and leaders.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Responsible Citizenship 1001

Opinion: The 2024 ballot — hope vs. hate

As a member of Generation Z, the first presidential election I followed was the 2016 election when I was 13 years old. Filled with hope, I accompanied my parents to the polls, thinking we were about to elect the first female president, only for reality to punch me in the face the next morning. 

Over the next four years, I watched a dark cloud of violence and hatred descend over the nation’s political future with which I had not long been acquainted. 

As I navigated high school, I felt increasingly discouraged by the political division spreading across the country, only occasionally finding the will to laugh at the absurdity while watching Saturday Night Live. I realized I needed to use my voice to help create a future where people work together instead of against each other. 

Since 2016, Gen Z has come of age in an era marked by political division, gun violence, racial violence, climate change and a global pandemic. The news over the past eight years has delivered one discouraging story after another. 

In the 2024 presidential election, Gen Z voters have a choice between two paths — one covered by the same dark cloud and the other with sunlight peeking through. 40.8 million members of Gen Z will be eligible to vote in 2024, including 8.3 million new eligible voters since the 2022 midterm elections. Additionally, nearly half of eligible Gen Z voters are people of color. 

Gen Z voters have an opportunity to make their voices heard in the upcoming election and show which future they will create for the U.S. and the world. We can leave behind violence and hate and focus on progress and positivity. 

Larry Jacobs, founder and director of the Center for the Study of Politics and Governance at the University of Minnesota, said Gen Z will likely make a difference in the 2024 election.  

“The Gen Z voters and citizens are the difference makers,” Jacobs said. “The country is essentially knotted into two large groups of partisans, and Gen Z is coming in with a dismal view of both parties and wanting to see change in the way we do our politics and the tenure of our politics.”

Jacobs said this is a hopeful generation who can step in and provide leadership for America.

When asked about the violent and hateful rhetoric prevalent in American politics and its impact on young people, Jacobs said Gen Z faces conflicting messages of hope and hate. 

“I think it’s one of the reasons Kamala Harris introduced her campaign as one about hope as a way to try to really reach out and connect with younger voters,” Jacobs said.

Using hope and joy to reach young voters, as the Kamala Harris campaign is doing, acknowledges the turbulent political environment Gen Z voters have come of age in since the 2016 election.  

Carmen McLaren, a second-year student at the University, is among the Gen Z voters who see the 2024 election as a turning point with two very different paths. McLaren said she feels cautiously optimistic about the upcoming election but remembers the challenges of processing the 2016 election as a child. 

“We were quite young to be able to comprehend all of it,” McLaren said. “But I was able to comprehend it and be stressed about it.” 

McLaren said observing the political violence and division in the U.S. since the 2016 election can become overwhelming, and it is important for Gen Z to take a step back. 

“At some point, you just can’t really hold all of that in you,” McLaren said. “You do have to be kind of stoic about it in a way and not feel such intense empathy toward everything that’s going on.” 

Many of the would-be shocking events, such as multiple assassination attempts on former President Donald Trump and his baseless accusations about migrants that inspire violence in others, have become part of the political nature we expect in the U.S., according to a New York Times news analysis. 

Riley Hetland, director of civic engagement for the Undergraduate Student Government (USG), works with USG’s non-partisan Row the Vote campaign to register students to vote and get students to the polls. Hetland said the politically divided nature of the 2024 election is motivating students to get involved and vote. 

“I’m seeing a lot more attention and a lot more engagement honestly because of how divided everyone is,” Hetland said. 

Hetland said it is important to her that young people make their voices heard, regardless of their political beliefs.

“I’ve always felt that I could make a change, despite being young,” Hetland said. “I think it’s really important that youth do know and young voters do know that they can make meaningful change.” 

This is a critical moment for Gen Z to find our collective voice as decision-makers and affirm the future we want for this country and our place in the world. We may have grown up with politicians abusing hateful rhetoric and inciting violence, but we don’t have to lose trust in our government. 

It is up to us to take action and fix it. 

Jacobs said that, in his career studying American history, this moment stands out as crucial. 

“There are moments that represent tipping points,” Jacobs said. “This is a tipping point, and the tipping point is going to be over whether America is engaged in the world.” 

Jacobs said getting involved with others who share hope and optimism for the future can make people realize they can make a difference and regain their lost hope. If you feel discouraged by what is going on, the best thing you can do is get involved. 

This isn’t the first time youth voters have decided they must be the change they want to see, and it cannot be the last. Gen Z can choose hope over hate. 

“Get involved, Don’t sit on the sidelines,” Jacobs said. “Grab a pale of water and run toward the fire.”

Eight years ago, I accompanied my parents to the polls in hopes of making history. Now, it is our turn, and I hope you will join me. 

Let’s run toward the fire.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: The 2024 ballot — hope vs. hate