Author Archives | by Seamus Haney

Minnesota media professionals say Google AI Overview poses threat to news

Google’s AI Overview, an integrated service that summarizes results at the top of a Google search, severely limits website traffic obtained from search results, many Minnesota media professionals and journalists say, leaving traditional media organizations scrambling to adjust. 

A study from the PEW Research Center shows that Google users click on links half as many times when presented with an AI overview, compared to when there is none. When users do not click on any link to find the answers they are looking for, marketers call this a zero-click result.

University of Minnesota professor and former TV news director Scott Libin understands the importance of media website traffic as a result of his experience in journalism. 

“For every visitor, for every click, the publisher of that site is able to aggregate an audience to sell to advertisers,” Libin said. 

Although AI presents a new challenge to publishers trying to aggregate an audience, Libin said the hunt for website traffic has never been straightforward. Social media is one tool the journalism industry has had to adapt to.

“Social media, in the early days of that phenomenon, was pretty good as a referral source,” Libin said. 

Since its early days, social media and its algorithms have been engineered to increase audience retention, but providing links to other sources encourages users to go elsewhere. 

“These things are constantly changing,” Libin said. “But what hasn’t changed is that as a publisher, I want to attract an audience.”

In light of an AI overview, how do media organizations aggregate an audience? The answer, as it turns out, can be social media.

Samantha HoangLong is the audience growth manager at Sahan Journal. She said an important part of adapting to AI is understanding what types of sources it prioritizes in its summaries. 

“If someone’s Googling ‘best plumber in the Twin Cities,’ formerly they would have news sites pop up… but now, what Google prioritizes is like Reddit searches,” HoangLong said. 

A study from PEW Research found the most frequently cited sources in Google AI summaries and standard search results are Wikipedia, YouTube and Reddit.  

HoangLong said social media is becoming an asset to showing up in search results. She said brooding over caption wording on TikTok and Instagram posts can increase the odds that an overview links to something Sahan Journal puts out. 

“[Social media is] also like an interesting path to kind of strengthening your position, like diversifying where your traffic comes from,” HoangLong said, “Also, I think social [media] really helps build loyalty and engagement.”

Differentiating content increases the likelihood of appearing in search results, Hoanglong added.

“Stories that reach a lot of visibility or do get clicks… are stories that are unique to Sahan,” HoangLong said. 

Frederick Melo, a reporter for the Pioneer Press, said being unique is one way his organization is fighting to preserve web traffic.

Pioneer Press uses an analytics technology called Marfeel to garner insight into how to optimize the content they put out to engage the biggest audience. 

“We’re increasingly looking to tools like Marfeel to look at not just basics like clicks, but how many unique users went to our website,” Melo said. “What are the top articles by traffic? What are the top articles that led to a subscription?”

As a reporter, Melo uses this software to understand what is working and what is not working for the articles he writes. 

“We’re pulling out all the tech we can to professionalize,” Melo said. 

Pioneer Press is involved in an ongoing lawsuit against OpenAI and Microsoft for using its content to train their AI models. What is different about Google’s AI Overview is that the service curates the results of a search, still providing hotlinks to these news outlets. 

“Google is actually better than ChatGPT or some of the other platforms at providing an actual link… even though user behavior doesn’t translate to clicking the link anymore,” HoangLong said.

Curation has long been a part of journalism. Melo pointed to MinnPost, Axios and Bring Me the News as examples of media organizations that curate news.

“There’s a lot of established precedent for saying, here’s a summary of what’s out there with attribution and a hotlink,” Melo said. “What Open AI is doing is saying, ‘Oh, here’s what happened in the news today. We won’t even tell you where that came from.’”

Regardless of whether an AI overview links to the sources it summarizes, the underlying issue is still that it limits website traffic.

The direct cause of a decrease in website traffic is, of course, a decrease in potential revenue from advertisements on those websites. Another implication, Libin said, is a decrease in literacy about a given topic, due to the superficial nature of these AI summaries. 

“It’s also users, readers, those using search, are not going to get the same depth or context or accuracy that they would get by going to the primary source,” Libin said.

Libin said this is not a brand-new issue. This has happened with any search result summary, whether AI-generated or provided from a trusted website. 

There is a cognitive phenomenon known as anchoring bias, which causes us to rely heavily on the first piece of information we are given about a topic. When paired with the surface-level search results and the inaccuracy of these summaries due to the sources they cite, Google’s AI Overview becomes a real problem for media organizations and individuals alike.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Minnesota media professionals say Google AI Overview poses threat to news

Minnesota media professionals say Google AI Overview poses threat to news

Google’s AI Overview, an integrated service that summarizes results at the top of a Google search, severely limits website traffic obtained from search results, many Minnesota media professionals and journalists say, leaving traditional media organizations scrambling to adjust. 

A study from the PEW Research Center shows that Google users click on links half as many times when presented with an AI overview, compared to when there is none. When users do not click on any link to find the answers they are looking for, marketers call this a zero-click result.

University of Minnesota professor and former TV news director Scott Libin understands the importance of media website traffic as a result of his experience in journalism. 

“For every visitor, for every click, the publisher of that site is able to aggregate an audience to sell to advertisers,” Libin said. 

Although AI presents a new challenge to publishers trying to aggregate an audience, Libin said the hunt for website traffic has never been straightforward. Social media is one tool the journalism industry has had to adapt to.

“Social media, in the early days of that phenomenon, was pretty good as a referral source,” Libin said. 

Since its early days, social media and its algorithms have been engineered to increase audience retention, but providing links to other sources encourages users to go elsewhere. 

“These things are constantly changing,” Libin said. “But what hasn’t changed is that as a publisher, I want to attract an audience.”

In light of an AI overview, how do media organizations aggregate an audience? The answer, as it turns out, can be social media.

Samantha HoangLong is the audience growth manager at Sahan Journal. She said an important part of adapting to AI is understanding what types of sources it prioritizes in its summaries. 

“If someone’s Googling ‘best plumber in the Twin Cities,’ formerly they would have news sites pop up… but now, what Google prioritizes is like Reddit searches,” HoangLong said. 

A study from PEW Research found the most frequently cited sources in Google AI summaries and standard search results are Wikipedia, YouTube and Reddit.  

HoangLong said social media is becoming an asset to showing up in search results. She said brooding over caption wording on TikTok and Instagram posts can increase the odds that an overview links to something Sahan Journal puts out. 

“[Social media is] also like an interesting path to kind of strengthening your position, like diversifying where your traffic comes from,” HoangLong said, “Also, I think social [media] really helps build loyalty and engagement.”

Differentiating content increases the likelihood of appearing in search results, Hoanglong added.

“Stories that reach a lot of visibility or do get clicks… are stories that are unique to Sahan,” HoangLong said. 

Frederick Melo, a reporter for the Pioneer Press, said being unique is one way his organization is fighting to preserve web traffic.

Pioneer Press uses an analytics technology called Marfeel to garner insight into how to optimize the content they put out to engage the biggest audience. 

“We’re increasingly looking to tools like Marfeel to look at not just basics like clicks, but how many unique users went to our website,” Melo said. “What are the top articles by traffic? What are the top articles that led to a subscription?”

As a reporter, Melo uses this software to understand what is working and what is not working for the articles he writes. 

“We’re pulling out all the tech we can to professionalize,” Melo said. 

Pioneer Press is involved in an ongoing lawsuit against OpenAI and Microsoft for using its content to train their AI models. What is different about Google’s AI Overview is that the service curates the results of a search, still providing hotlinks to these news outlets. 

“Google is actually better than ChatGPT or some of the other platforms at providing an actual link… even though user behavior doesn’t translate to clicking the link anymore,” HoangLong said.

Curation has long been a part of journalism. Melo pointed to MinnPost, Axios and Bring Me the News as examples of media organizations that curate news.

“There’s a lot of established precedent for saying, here’s a summary of what’s out there with attribution and a hotlink,” Melo said. “What Open AI is doing is saying, ‘Oh, here’s what happened in the news today. We won’t even tell you where that came from.’”

Regardless of whether an AI overview links to the sources it summarizes, the underlying issue is still that it limits website traffic.

The direct cause of a decrease in website traffic is, of course, a decrease in potential revenue from advertisements on those websites. Another implication, Libin said, is a decrease in literacy about a given topic, due to the superficial nature of these AI summaries. 

“It’s also users, readers, those using search, are not going to get the same depth or context or accuracy that they would get by going to the primary source,” Libin said.

Libin said this is not a brand-new issue. This has happened with any search result summary, whether AI-generated or provided from a trusted website. 

There is a cognitive phenomenon known as anchoring bias, which causes us to rely heavily on the first piece of information we are given about a topic. When paired with the surface-level search results and the inaccuracy of these summaries due to the sources they cite, Google’s AI Overview becomes a real problem for media organizations and individuals alike.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Minnesota media professionals say Google AI Overview poses threat to news

Students make personal sacrifices as Iran War continues

As the United States is launching attacks on Iran, many University students are feeling the reverberations back at home. 

The war in Iran drives gas prices up, forcing many students to think critically about how they are spending their money and how they are managing their free time.

Many students pay for gas for their commute to school on their own. Ameer Ait Daoud drives his car every day, and the rising gas prices have led him to drive faster in an attempt to save money.

“Global politics shows up in our gas tanks, it shows up in our bank accounts,” Ait Daoud said. 

Jocelyn Chimborazo commutes four days a week to school, and she has noticed it takes about $13 extra to fill her car up every two weeks. She works as a babysitter for extra funds, part of which goes toward gas.

“If prices continue to rise, I’m going to have to pick up another job,” Chimborazo said. 

Rising gas prices do not just force students to seek additional sources of income. For many, an increase at the pump can mean less time with friends. Saad Saleem said the current situation has caused him to rethink his social life.

“I try to not go out [on the weekends] when there is no need to,” Saleem said.

A few students noted their financial anxiety around gas prices has caused them to forego other opportunities they could use to advance their careers. 

“It’s access to opportunity in your life, it’s the ability to not feel constantly like you’re being drained financially for just trying to move forward in life,” Ait Daoud said. 

Prices are not only blowing up at the pump, but in grocery stores and restaurants that students frequent on a night out. 

University of Minnesota economics professor Jeff Peterson said, energy like gasoline, is an input for many goods in the economy.

“If costs of these inputs stay high, businesses will eventually pass them on to consumers in the form of higher prices,” Peterson said.

Chimborazo is one of the students who has noticed these higher grocery store prices. 

“I’m not sure if this was before the war, but I’ve noticed egg prices are more expensive,” Chimborazo said.

Egg prices spiked at the beginning of the war, the United States Department of Agriculture reported.

Ait Daoud has noticed a similar trend, too, when shopping for food. 

“You get five things, and it randomly goes up to 200 bucks, how can you survive? You gotta work harder,” Ait Daoud said. 

As if personal finance concerns are not bad enough, emotional stress has doubled for students. Though miles away, students divulged their deep sympathy for those intimately affected by the war.

“Although it’s far away, it’s hard to see the innocent people being killed,” Chimborazo said.

Frustration with the war appears to be a top emotional stressor for students as well. 

“Innocent lives are being lost, and we don’t have a reason to fight this war,” Saleem said.

While life is difficult for many students as a result of rising prices, Ait Daoud also recognizes his privilege. 

“I’m not in Dubai or Saudi or Iran or whatever, so I’m not having their struggles. So their struggles [are] 10 times worse,” Ait Daoud said.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Students make personal sacrifices as Iran War continues

Students say midterm stress heightened in the wake of Operation Metro Surge

Editor’s note: This story contains references to heightened anxiety and seeking mental help resources.

 

As midterm season comes to a close, many students say they have experienced heightened levels of anxiety due to the longstanding effects of Operation Metro Surge in Minnesota.

Gaomong Xiong felt that heightened level of anxiety this winter, especially during the height of Operation Metro Surge. 

“I felt like there were things out of my control, and it was happening in my city,” Xiong said. “It was really heartbreaking and just a lot to process.”

Xiong used to take walks to relieve her stress. Due in part to what Xiong said was a lackluster response to ICE on campus from the University of Minnesota, she did not feel safe doing so, and her mental health suffered because of it.

Not all students think the University responded poorly to Immigration and Customs Enforcement’s presence in the Twin Cities. Ishan Panwar understands why the University did not take a strong stance against ICE, noting the importance of securing federal grants to its operations. 

“The U is a major receiver of federal grants, and I don’t think the government is going to think twice before holding them off,” Panwar said.  

Knolan Wattnem believes the University responded well to ICE on campus. Wattnem lives in a fraternity on the St. Paul campus and rarely felt ICE’s presence in the winter. 

“Having students being able to attend class online was really good, and [the University] being vocal about what was going on,” Wattnem said. “So students knew [the University] was recognizing what was going on.” 

For many students, the stress originated not from concerns of their personal safety, but from a duty to fight for what they believe is right. 

Noami Breeden is an active member of the University’s Students for a Democratic Society. She has worked with groups outside of campus to organize protests against ICE’s activities, such as those at the Graduate Hotel. 

This work, Breeden said, translated to more anxiety.

“Being within rapid response group chats and knowing and seeing photos, my stress was definitely high,” Breeden said. 

Regardless of how much the University’s response to federal law enforcement activity on campus affected students, midterms were commonly cited as a top stressor. 

Breeden had several projects and midterms due before spring break. She uses breaks from her schoolwork to relieve stress, but has sought out mental health resources at the University in previous years, which panned out to be a disappointing experience.

“I tried getting a therapist last semester, but it was a very long wait time, so that didn’t necessarily help with anything,” Breeden said. 

Breeden believes students’ tuition should be used for expanding the number of licensed mental health professionals. The University offers a mental health crisis hotline, but notes this is not a substitute for therapy.

Panwar believes all mental health resources should be free to students. Some resources are free, but others require payment. 

“Mental health help, especially, shouldn’t be paid,” Panwar said. 

As a result of often inaccessible mental health services, students have found relief from their academic stress through their professors and teaching assistants. Prestan Lilliberg is one of these students. He has turned to his professors during moments of stress. 

“I think the professors are really good if you ask for help,” Lilliberg said. “Most of my professors will stay back and talk with me after class.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Students say midterm stress heightened in the wake of Operation Metro Surge

Students find themselves polarized following UMN’s heavy lean into AI integration

As the University of Minnesota delves deeper into the world of artificial intelligence, students are left questioning the benefits and drawbacks of AI integration in seemingly every part of their modern lives. 

Over the past few months, the University has worked closely with Google and its AI language model, Gemini, in an effort to keep students competitive in a modern, AI-driven market. On Tuesday, the University announced in a brief that they plan to continue this push, even going as far as to announce Galin Jones, the director of the University’s School of Statistics, as vice provost for AI.

Archit Lal studies computer science at the University. Over the course of last summer, he developed an AI agent for his startup, Altivis, that companies can use to collect sales data from customers, among other tasks.

The agent’s purpose is to automate many processes that normally require human work. After working so deeply with the technology, Lal advocates for AI in any field where it can replace traditional human work.

“Get as much of your work that can be done by AI, just make it do it,” Lal said. “Why not?” 

Not everyone is as sold as Lal. Jack DeCapua, a civil engineering student, worries about AI replacing an individual’s autonomy, a concern he has developed after observing his and others’ use of it in their schooling. 

DeCapua noticed himself getting lazy and uploading his homework assignments to the University-funded Gemini language model. He later realized that this was destroying his ability to learn the content.

“I always wonder how there are some people who ask, ‘How did you make it through your first 18 years of life without AI,’ and now all of a sudden you can’t go without it,” DeCapua said. 

After his realization, DeCapua said he replaced time spent with chatbots with office hours and online resources, and noted that his life really has not changed after implementing this decision in his life. 

Neither DeCapua nor Lal expressed concern about AI taking their future jobs. Jayla Petersen, a nursing student, did. 

Petersen understands the importance of decision-making as a nurse. She said she understands the human element to making those decisions, but worries about AI doing it for nurses — a move she can see disrupting the nursing profession. 

“You have to make really fast decisions, and AI can make those decisions that fast,” Petersen said. 

Petersen, like Lauer and DeCapua, is concerned about technology replacing human autonomy. She is especially worried about the efficiency of nurses after whisking their work away to a chatbot for four years. 

“[AI] destroys critical thinking skills and people’s ability to focus, because you just put it in and it just does all the work for you,” Petersen said. 

Petersen also said she has concerns about the environmental impacts of this technology. This concern is shared by Claire Lauer, an undergraduate at Carlson.

“It’s really bad for the environment, a lot of water is getting wasted,” Lauer said. 

Despite her concerns for the environment and others about individual autonomy, Lauer still uses the technology. She said she uses AI for her schoolwork, most often when she gets stuck on a problem.

“I’ll usually just plug it in,” Lauer said. “I definitely don’t use it very ethically.”

Lauer expresses concern for the younger generations’ ability to think creatively. For this demographic, Lal too asks what the impact of this technology may be. 

Lauer calls on government policy to make a decision one way or another about AI’s place in society. 

“We either need to ban it, or we don’t,” Lauer said. 

She believes the technology is bad and should be banned. But until it is, she will continue to use it.

Lal echoes this all-or-nothing approach, but argues for AI’s total assimilation into society. He believes in AI’s potential to free up people’s time.

“Why is a human wasting his precious time?” Lal said. 

In a hypothetical world that subtracts the environmental impact of AI, DeCapua could see himself using the technology, but only sparingly. He sees the real benefit of an agent in saving time.

“It can be a really nice, useful tool,” DeCapua said. “Honestly, there’s so many things you can use it for.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Students find themselves polarized following UMN’s heavy lean into AI integration