Google’s AI Overview, an integrated service that summarizes results at the top of a Google search, severely limits website traffic obtained from search results, many Minnesota media professionals and journalists say, leaving traditional media organizations scrambling to adjust.
A study from the PEW Research Center shows that Google users click on links half as many times when presented with an AI overview, compared to when there is none. When users do not click on any link to find the answers they are looking for, marketers call this a zero-click result.
University of Minnesota professor and former TV news director Scott Libin understands the importance of media website traffic as a result of his experience in journalism.
“For every visitor, for every click, the publisher of that site is able to aggregate an audience to sell to advertisers,” Libin said.
Although AI presents a new challenge to publishers trying to aggregate an audience, Libin said the hunt for website traffic has never been straightforward. Social media is one tool the journalism industry has had to adapt to.
“Social media, in the early days of that phenomenon, was pretty good as a referral source,” Libin said.
Since its early days, social media and its algorithms have been engineered to increase audience retention, but providing links to other sources encourages users to go elsewhere.
“These things are constantly changing,” Libin said. “But what hasn’t changed is that as a publisher, I want to attract an audience.”
In light of an AI overview, how do media organizations aggregate an audience? The answer, as it turns out, can be social media.
Samantha HoangLong is the audience growth manager at Sahan Journal. She said an important part of adapting to AI is understanding what types of sources it prioritizes in its summaries.
“If someone’s Googling ‘best plumber in the Twin Cities,’ formerly they would have news sites pop up… but now, what Google prioritizes is like Reddit searches,” HoangLong said.
A study from PEW Research found the most frequently cited sources in Google AI summaries and standard search results are Wikipedia, YouTube and Reddit.
HoangLong said social media is becoming an asset to showing up in search results. She said brooding over caption wording on TikTok and Instagram posts can increase the odds that an overview links to something Sahan Journal puts out.
“[Social media is] also like an interesting path to kind of strengthening your position, like diversifying where your traffic comes from,” HoangLong said, “Also, I think social [media] really helps build loyalty and engagement.”
Differentiating content increases the likelihood of appearing in search results, Hoanglong added.
“Stories that reach a lot of visibility or do get clicks… are stories that are unique to Sahan,” HoangLong said.
Frederick Melo, a reporter for the Pioneer Press, said being unique is one way his organization is fighting to preserve web traffic.
Pioneer Press uses an analytics technology called Marfeel to garner insight into how to optimize the content they put out to engage the biggest audience.
“We’re increasingly looking to tools like Marfeel to look at not just basics like clicks, but how many unique users went to our website,” Melo said. “What are the top articles by traffic? What are the top articles that led to a subscription?”
As a reporter, Melo uses this software to understand what is working and what is not working for the articles he writes.
“We’re pulling out all the tech we can to professionalize,” Melo said.
Pioneer Press is involved in an ongoing lawsuit against OpenAI and Microsoft for using its content to train their AI models. What is different about Google’s AI Overview is that the service curates the results of a search, still providing hotlinks to these news outlets.
“Google is actually better than ChatGPT or some of the other platforms at providing an actual link… even though user behavior doesn’t translate to clicking the link anymore,” HoangLong said.
Curation has long been a part of journalism. Melo pointed to MinnPost, Axios and Bring Me the News as examples of media organizations that curate news.
“There’s a lot of established precedent for saying, here’s a summary of what’s out there with attribution and a hotlink,” Melo said. “What Open AI is doing is saying, ‘Oh, here’s what happened in the news today. We won’t even tell you where that came from.’”
Regardless of whether an AI overview links to the sources it summarizes, the underlying issue is still that it limits website traffic.
The direct cause of a decrease in website traffic is, of course, a decrease in potential revenue from advertisements on those websites. Another implication, Libin said, is a decrease in literacy about a given topic, due to the superficial nature of these AI summaries.
“It’s also users, readers, those using search, are not going to get the same depth or context or accuracy that they would get by going to the primary source,” Libin said.
Libin said this is not a brand-new issue. This has happened with any search result summary, whether AI-generated or provided from a trusted website.
There is a cognitive phenomenon known as anchoring bias, which causes us to rely heavily on the first piece of information we are given about a topic. When paired with the surface-level search results and the inaccuracy of these summaries due to the sources they cite, Google’s AI Overview becomes a real problem for media organizations and individuals alike.