Author Archives | by Sam Hill

University police escort music professor out of Alex Pretti vigil for wearing ICE OUT sign, ‘You know we aren’t taking sides here.’

What does one wear to the memorial of a killing?

Music professor Stephanie Arado, asked by University of Minnesota administrators to perform at a streamed community event for alum Alex Pretti, two days after he was killed on Jan. 24 by Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents, decided on a long black tunic.

The music Arado would perform and how she would present herself would be important. She was volunteering, without pay, to provide a service as a faculty member.

Administrators told her to find a fitting music piece under three minutes, so her choice was a beautiful unaccompanied work by Eugène Ysaÿe, called “Malinconia.” Affixed to the front of her garment were five words in small lettering: “The evil must end now.” On her back, she put “ICE OUT,” — knowing it was there for people to see, but not visible when she played for the live stream. 

Arado said she was given absolutely no guidelines as to repertoire content or dress. The University did not respond to multiple requests for comment on event guidelines.

Arado carpooled with her colleague to Northrop, where the event would be streamed. Around ten minutes before her performance was due to start, she said she was approached by a dark-suited woman.

“We have a problem,” the woman said. “You need to take that off, or we won’t allow you to play. This is intended to be a solemn occasion.”

Arado said she was taken aback, thinking nothing she was wearing distracted from the occasion’s solemnity. 

“No, it’s not. It’s not possible,” the woman said, according to Arado. “You know we’re not taking sides here.”

Arado said she told the administrator she was not going to play under these circumstances and began to pack up her instrument. She said she went to wait in the hallway as her colleague elected to perform in her stead.

“It was very upsetting to me, of course, because this meant a lot to me,” Arado said regarding the vigil. “I was upset. And I said, ‘but you know what? I’m glad that you made it clear to me, and I’m leaving, and I’m out of here.’”

Arado said she was waiting in the hallway with her instruments when two armed police officers came to escort her out of the building.

“I’m a professor here,” Arado said to the officers. “I’m not a stranger here. And I was invited to this event.”

Arado said the officers were told by organizers to make her leave the building right away. She said despite carpooling with a performer and lugging around a valuable instrument, the officers insisted she go out and find another building to stand in.

“I had to leave Northrop altogether because the organizers decided I was a guest, not welcome anymore, and some kind of a threat,” Arado said. “I don’t know. It was pretty, it was a very, very upsetting afternoon for me.”

Arado said she was set to discuss the event with Executive Vice President of Finance and Operations Gregg Goldman later that evening, but her calls went to voicemail. 

As of publishing, Arado has not confirmed with the Daily whether the administration has reached out to her since.

University communications said in an email to the Daily that the UMN community gathering event was intended to be a space for community unity, not a venue for political activism. The University did not respond to requests for comment regarding the officers involved.

Arado said she was incredibly disappointed by the whole situation.

“Given the nature of how Alex died and the situation that our community is in, that they would be so afraid to allow for that kind of authenticity is incredibly disappointing to me,” Arado said.

The First Amendment, academic freedom and creative expression

Academic freedom, the freedom of teachers and students to teach, study, and pursue knowledge and research without unreasonable interference, is a professional norm for Universities codified by the American Association of University Professors, a national academic association.

Academic freedom has been recognized as a constitutional right by courts across the country, and even the University takes AAUP principles into account during faculty senate and Board of Regents meetings. Academic freedom also extends to creative expression.

University speech and academic freedom have been the subject of scrutiny and debate following protests and encampments surrounding the war in Gaza. The Board of Regents passed a 2025 resolution allowing the president to limit institutional speech on matters of public concern, which led to faculty pushback.

Jane Kirtley, the Silha Professor of Media Ethics and Law at the Hubbard School of Journalism and Mass Communication at the University, said to determine whether this is a freedom of expression issue, one has to look at whether there were clear guidelines for the event. She added the University has the authority to set parameters for planned events, although it gets complicated when creative expression is included.

“Did the administrators who put this program together fully communicate to those that were participating in the event what was expected of them, in terms of content as well as attire, or did they basically just leave it up to them?” Kirtley said. “The question is, ‘what were you invited to do?’”

Kirtley said she still believed there was a huge overreaction and failure of communication by the University. She added based on Arado’s reaction, the police should not have been involved.

What other Professors are saying

Michael Gallope, the College of Liberal Arts assembly chair and professor in the department of Cultural Studies and Comparative Literature, said academic freedom policy covers all forms of creative expression and that faculty artists should not be censored if their work is considered too controversial.

Gallope emphasized that AAUP guidelines are clear in stating how creative expression is not representative of the institution that hosts it. He added this must be assumed as a professional principle, for faculty artists to do their work with true freedom of the imagination.

“If President Cunningham is going to ask a professor to present work at a memorial event like this, she is under an obligation to respect that artist’s freedom of creative expression,” Gallope said. “To ask a faculty artist to edit their work as a condition for its exhibition is a violation of their academic freedom.”

Geography professor Kate Derickson said she found it incredibly troubling no University speakers acknowledged how and by whom Pretti was killed. She added not acknowledging the reason for the event is not neutrality, but capitulation.

“The speech expressed on (Arado’s) shirt was a demand that the agency that not only killed our former student –– but shot him nine additional times in a display of viciousness that shocks the conscience — leave the state,” Derickson said. “To disallow a faculty member from expressing their solidarity with the murdered man at his own memorial service is not ‘neutrality,’ it is complicity.”

Gallope said the handling of this event showed the staggering moral cost of neutrality.

“As a University, we can’t even defend the basic principles of human rights for Minnesotans,” Gallope said. “It’s terrifying.”

Derickson said not allowing University members to arrive at independent truths is effectively allowing certain narratives to dominate popular dialogue. 

“If we relinquish the ability to speak the truths that emerge from our research, observation and analysis in order to preserve ‘neutrality,’ we are undermining our mission, compromising our value proposition, and staking out a position whether we want to or not,” Derickson said.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on University police escort music professor out of Alex Pretti vigil for wearing ICE OUT sign, ‘You know we aren’t taking sides here.’

Home2 Suites noise demonstration dispersed, University Ave SE blocked off by police

A noise demonstration held outside of Home2 Suites by Hilton led to arrests and deployment of flares and tear gas on the crowd outside, according to video analyzed by the Minnesota Daily. For about an hour, over 40 police officers secured University Ave SE in front of the hotel.

As of 11 p.m., University Ave SE is no longer blocked off by police. 

Around 9:30 p.m., video and photo footage collected from bystanders show multiple buses and vans full of police in high visibility vests parked in the nearby Discovery Lot on 2535 4th St. SE. 

At around 9:50 p.m., sirens can be heard as a column of police approach from the east. A couple of minutes later, tear gas was set off in the vicinity of the protestors and the perimeter was secured. 

The demonstration was in response to allegations of ICE agents staying at the hotel located on University Avenue. It remains unclear who organized the protest, with flyers anonymously submitted to the Twin Cities Ungovernables Instagram page.

This is a developing story. Check back for updates.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Home2 Suites noise demonstration dispersed, University Ave SE blocked off by police

Home2 Suites noise demonstration dispersed, University Ave SE blocked off by police

A noise demonstration held outside of Home2 Suites by Hilton led to arrests and deployment of flares and tear gas on the crowd outside, according to video analyzed by the Minnesota Daily. For about an hour, over 40 police officers secured University Ave SE in front of the hotel.

As of 11 p.m., University Ave SE is no longer blocked off by police. 

Around 9:30 p.m., video and photo footage collected from bystanders show multiple buses and vans full of police in high visibility vests parked in the nearby Discovery Lot on 2535 4th St. SE. 

At around 9:50 p.m., sirens can be heard as a column of police approach from the east. A couple of minutes later, tear gas was set off in the vicinity of the protestors and the perimeter was secured. 

The demonstration was in response to allegations of ICE agents staying at the hotel located on University Avenue. It remains unclear who organized the protest, with flyers anonymously submitted to the Twin Cities Ungovernables Instagram page.

This is a developing story. Check back for updates.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Home2 Suites noise demonstration dispersed, University Ave SE blocked off by police

UMN protest of Israeli diplomat’s speech prompts UMPD barricade

Pro-Palestine student groups marched to Huntington Bank Stadium from Coffman Union to protest an Israeli diplomat’s speech Thursday afternoon. 

The speech was given to a private audience inside Huntington Bank Stadium as security personnel, caution tape and barriers prevented protestors and reporters from entering. 

According to Students Supporting Israel vice president Tagore Pathak, the speech was a private event for SSI members and other people on an invite list. He said the diplomat, Yinam Cohen, was going to discuss Israeli diplomacy and was not planning on discussing anything University-specific.

Cohen is responsible for assisting and promoting U.S. and Israel relations in nine Midwestern states, including Minnesota. 

Reporters met Cohen at a table near the John and Nancy Lindall entrance to ask him questions. He did not talk to reporters, who were not allowed to enter the building, and only ushered in people who were allowed into the event.

Student groups protesting included Students for a Democratic Society, Students for Justice in Palestine and other students in the Divest Coalition. About a hundred marchers left Coffman Union around 3 p.m. and arrived at Huntington when the speech was scheduled to begin around 3:20. There, the protesters met barriers, caution tape and a dozen University police officers.

A previous meeting between University of Minnesota administration and Cohen on campus in March of last year prompted a hundred protesters to march for divestment from Israel, according to Fight Back! news. 

 

Image by Hannah Kovnar

 

Thursday’s protest comes after 11 departmental statements on Israel-Palestine and Russia-Ukraine were taken down by University administration after a Saturday Zoom meeting between Provost Rachel Croson and department chairs, the Minnesota Daily reported. 

Administration said they did not want an email record of the statement removals, according to sources who participated in the meetings.

Pathak said SSI was not intimidated by protesters but he has experienced death threats and has reason to be concerned for his safety.

“We are here, we are proud, we are not going away,” Pathak said.

Veterans for Peace member Tom Bauch said he joined the protest to support students protesting for Palestine. He said academic restrictions on freedom of speech were shameful to the University. 

“Freedom of speech is what universities are supposed to stand for,” Bauch said. “Why would any students want to go to school in this climate?”

Merrilyn Downes, 75, was on the private list of invitees to the speech. She said she was concerned about protesters’ hate.

“Everyone has rights to freedom of speech as long as they aren’t hurting anyone,” Downes said. “As long as it’s a safe protest.”

SDS member Fae Hodges said the turnout to the protest was high despite students not knowing about Cohen’s speech until late yesterday afternoon. She said the plan for the protest was to peacefully chant outside and then leave.

 

Image by Hannah Kovnar

 

“Students dropped what they were doing and engaged with us at the last minute,” Hodges said.

Hodges said the coalition was here to tell the University to divest from war crimes and genocide.

“We are not here to harm or scare students,” Hodges said. “Attacks on free speech are a threat to all students.”

SJS member Noora Ahmed said the invitation to have an Israeli diplomat speak on campus, protected by University police, does not send a message of neutrality. 

“How is it neutral to invite a war criminal to campus?” Ahmed asked. “This is upsetting, and we don’t even know if admin is there.”

Ahmed said protesters from different backgrounds came to show support. She added that this was a huge deal for Palestinians on campus.

“This isn’t just a Palestinian issue,” Ahmed said.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on UMN protest of Israeli diplomat’s speech prompts UMPD barricade

5 Mankato international students’ visas revoked, told by ICE to ‘self-deport’

Five other students at Minnesota State University, Mankato have had their student visas terminated, The Minnesota Star Tribune reported Wednesday night.

Mankato State University president Edward Inch said in a Wednesday night statement neither the university nor the students were notified of the termination of their Student Exchange Visitor Information System records, which is used to maintain visa information. According to the statement, staff discovered the terminations after running a status check.

MSU-Mankato history professor Jameel Haque said in a statement to the Star Tribune that the students have not been detained by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), but rather asked to self-deport within 60 days.

This follows the recent ICE detainments of two university students — Dogukan Gunaydin at the University of Minnesota and an unidentified Mankato state student late last week. The circumstances regarding why these students were arrested are not yet clear.

International students at universities have been arrested and detained across the country in recent months, mostly for demonstrating pro-Palestine activism. According to a statement from Secretary of State Marco Rubio, over 300 protestors have been arrested for engaging in destabilizing activity.

“We gave you a visa to come and study and get a degree, not to become a social activist that tears up our university campuses,” Rubio said in the statement. “If we have given you a visa and then you decide to do that, we’re going to take it away.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on 5 Mankato international students’ visas revoked, told by ICE to ‘self-deport’

Campus mobilizes to protect undocumented, noncitizen community following ICE compliance

Students across the University of Minnesota Twin Cities campus are full of fear and anxiety. Administrators are trying to juggle Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) compliance with the safety of undocumented and immigrant students, and many say more needs to be done.

A coalition of students, staff, faculty, administrators and community members are circulating a petition to support non-citizen and immigrant community members. The nine demands include University President Rebecca Cunningham joining the Presidents’ Alliance for Higher Education and Immigration, restoring the now-defunct Immigration Response Team and ensuring UMPD does not assist ICE operations, among others.

As of Feb. 3, the petition has garnered over 3,100 signatures in four days, double the amount of signatures of the 2016 petition to make the University a sanctuary campus.

The University’s Center for Race, Indigeneity, Disability, Gender & Sexuality Studies (RIDGS) Director and Chicano Studies professor Jimmy Patino Jr. said the Faculty Senate Social Concerns Committee has agreed to write a statement requesting the administration join the alliance and follow its recommendations. 

Finance and Operations Vice President Gregg Goldman said in an emailed statement Friday that the University is committed to keeping community members affected by immigration policy safe and well informed. Goldman provided links to resources and FAQs regarding resources and advice in the email.

“In my role overseeing the Department of Public Safety on the Twin Cities campus and in public safety matters systemwide, I want to reassure you that the University has personnel and resources in place to support faculty, staff, and students who may be affected by these changes,” Goldman said in the email.

Chicano and Latino Studies professor and Faculty Senator Jessica Lopez Lyman said past University presidents were very active in communicating that campus was a safe space where campus police would not aid and abet ICE. She added that a limited message sends a message.

Lopez Lyman said undocumented and immigrant students might not be safe walking the streets downtown or in their neighborhoods, but they should not have to fear ICE coming into their classes.

“One of the things the President cares a lot about, and I agree with her, is that wellness for students should be first and foremost.” Lopez Lyman said. “Right now we have had limited word from the administration, and we want to ensure that our undocumented students and students who are non-citizens feel supported on campus.” 

Cunningham reaffirmed in a Feb. 3 email that campus departments of public safety do not have a role in enforcing immigration laws and added officers “do not view it as their role” to inquire about immigration status.

“Personnel and resources are in place to support international students, faculty and staff who may be affected by these federal policy changes,” Cunningham said in the email. “This webpage is a great resource for answers to frequently asked questions on this topic.”

Cunningham did not provide information regarding whether she would sign the Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration.

Former University presidents and petitions on ICE

This petition is not the first time University measures for federal immigration policy have been considered.

In 2017, former University president Eric Kaler expressed disappointment in President Donald Trump’s previous attempts at revoking Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) and told the Minnesota Daily that it “takes a human toll” on DACA students. This came after a 2016 petition to make the University a sanctuary campus garnered over 1,500 signatures, and Kaler vowed support to all members of the community.

In 2020, under former University president Joan Gabel, the University joined other universities across the nation in signing an Amicus Curiae brief in a lawsuit against ICE restrictions. The brief said ICE’s restrictions were neither safe nor educationally advisable and would have devastating effects on international students.  

“We cannot stand by in good conscience as international students are forced out of the country through no fault of their own,” Gabel said in a University news release. “We stand with our international students, and international students across the country, in asking that the ICE directive be overturned immediately.”

Former University Interim President Jeff Ettinger is a current member of the President’s Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, according to their website. 

The President’s Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration is an alliance of American college and university leaders dedicated to understanding how immigration policy affects students and campuses. They say universities across America need to mobilize strategies to protect access and equity under new ICE guidelines by challenging legislation, ensuring safety and promising to stand with students.

What the University is doing

After Trump’s Jan. 20 executive order to end birthright citizenship and revocation of former President Joe Biden’s “Churches and Schools” executive order, the University said it will still comply with federal court orders when it comes to ICE requests, according to the Minnesota Daily. 

This means the University will not release student immigration data, and UMPD will not be responsible for enforcement of ICE directives. However if ICE agents have official judicial warrants, they can access campus locations as well as student data.

According to Axios, schools can set policies that support students impacted by immigration enforcement, as well as train faculty and staff on how to interact with officers. What schools are not allowed to do is reveal most personal information without parental permission or a subpoena signed by a judge, Axios reported.

University of Minnesota President Rebecca Cunningham released a video Jan. 29 about the new presidential administration and how it will impact the University. She said she has tasked a group of “University leaders” to monitor these developments. 

“Please know that I’m fully committed to supporting the success of our students, faculty, and staff systemwide so that you can continue to do the great work every day in support of our mission,” Cunningham said in the video. “We will continue to closely monitor this evolving situation to determine how these policy changes affect our community and impact University operations.”

Ward 2 City Councilwoman Robin Wonsley issued a Jan. 31 statement on X saying, “I am extremely disturbed by the news that the University of Minnesota will be complying with ICE immigration orders. Schools should be a protected space for students, and this is another unacceptable byproduct of the Trump Administration.”

Policy context

Trump’s executive order asserts the children of noncitizens are not covered by the 14th Amendment’s guarantee that “all persons born or naturalized in the U.S. are citizens of the United States and the state wherein they reside.” ICE is responsible for immediate enforcement of this order.

Previous precedent listed schools and churches as protected spaces for noncitizens, but now ICE is empowered to search such areas, the Minnesota Reformer reported. The St. Paul ICE office has already set a new target of 75 arrests per day, according to MinnPost.

One week ago, Trump signed a memorandum to prepare Guantanamo Bay for the housing and subsequent deportation of 30,000 immigrants.

The LA Times reported ICE posted on X on Jan. 27, writing,  “In one week, law enforcement officials have removed and returned 7,300 illegal aliens.” The Trump administration views all undocumented immigrants as criminals, according to White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt.

Minnesota was one of the states that signed on to a Jan. 21 lawsuit aiming at blocking Trump’s executive order, the Minnesota Daily reported. The order does not go into effect for 30 days as executive branch agencies figure out how to implement it and the courts decide on its legality, according to the article. 

University law professor Linus Chan said in a Jan 17. MPR interview that under current Minnesota law, state and local officials are not legally required to contribute any resources or release any information in immigration enforcement.  

“Local and state officials will continue to have a tremendous amount of discretion on whether or how much they want their resources to be used for immigration enforcement,” Chan said in the interview. “There is no mechanism in a Minnesota statute that will force them to be involved in immigration enforcement, even in the face of losing federal funding.” 

Immigration History Research Center Assistant Director Michele Waslin said while there are ways communities can make immigrant communities feel safer, no sanctuary status is absolute due to federal policy. She said we likely are going to see ICE try and enter more locations.

Waslin added it is important to stand firm and continue to have strong non-cooperation policies. She said to be aware of your rights — you do not have to let ICE into your home without seeing a warrant, and you do not need to speak to them.

“The University is basically saying they will follow the law,” Waslin said. “I would like to see affirmative statements from the University saying that they are committed to immigrant faculty, students and staff.”

Resources:

Wilson Law Group said for the time being students should get their Minnesota driver’s license so that they always have a valid form of identification on them. For students arrested by ICE officers, they should remain silent and contact an attorney.

Additionally, the University of Minnesota issued the following statement: “Students should contact Student Legal Service, which provides advice and guidance, and legal representation where appropriate, for students in a variety of immigration-related cases. Employees and students may reach out to the Law School’s Binger Center for New Americans for advice and guidance, and limited legal consulting and a discount on referrals is available to benefits-eligible employees via the Employee Assistance Program.”

Correction: A previous version of this article misstated Jessica Lopez Lyman’s last name. It is just Lyman.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Campus mobilizes to protect undocumented, noncitizen community following ICE compliance

Board of Regents host first student input session

The University of Minnesota Board of Regents hosted the first student listening session on the Twin Cities campus Dec. 4. Now, the Board is planning more for spring semester.

University public relations director Jake Ricker said in an email statement to the Minnesota Daily that the Dec. 4 listening session at the Terrace Cafe inside the St. Paul Student Center was the latest in an ongoing series of listening sessions the Board of Regents is holding on each of the University’s five campuses. 

The Board intends to host two more sessions on the East Bank and West Bank areas of the Twin Cities campus in addition to the session in St Paul.

Board of Regents Chair Janie Mayeron said in the Dec. 13 Board of Regents meeting that she found the session she attended to be quite valuable and informative. 

“These in-person opportunities provide yet another avenue for us to understand what is going well and where there is room for improvement as we seek to fulfill our three-part mission,” Mayeron said in an email statement to the Minnesota Daily.

Regent Tadd Johnson said in the meeting he was able to hear about both research and common issues of Duluth faculty, staff and students.

Regent Kodi Verhalen added the Regents have received feedback from staff and input on opportunities for growth.

“These interactions and the input we receive are really invaluable,” Verhalen said. “It provides us an opportunity to actually dialogue with members of the University community and those who care about the University of Minnesota as a whole.”

Regents have hosted listening sessions in Crookston, Duluth, Morris and the St. Paul portion of the Twin Cities campus over the past semester, according to the Board of Regents Office.

Ricker said other spring sessions are still being planned. 

The listening session stretched from 11 a.m. to 1 p.m., with approximately 40 individuals stopping by to talk with Regents inside the St. Paul Student Center. 

The time and location were strategically selected to take advantage of increased foot traffic during the lunch hours, according to University Public Relations. 

Sessions will be promoted through colleges and units with representation on each campus, as well as through student government groups, according to the Board of Regents Office.

“The listening sessions are a chance for you to meet the Regents and share any feedback with them, while also enjoying a cookie,” one Board of Regents office worker said.

If folks are unable to attend in-person times the Board’s Virtual Forum is another means of sharing input with the Board.

Individual Regent emails are also available on the Board’s website and correspondence sent to uregents@umn.edu is regularly shared with all Regents, according to Board of Regents Office personnel.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Board of Regents host first student input session

UMN anticipates Comstock heating issues to be fixed by today

Several Comstock residents have reached out to FOX 9 reporters regarding multiple rooms that have been experiencing heating issues. FOX 9 reported the problems arose from air trapped in the system when Comstock Hall made the seasonal transition from air conditioning to heating.

Housing & Residential Life (HRL) director Susan Stubblefield wrote in an email to the Daily that HRL has received reports of Comstock rooms experiencing heating issues. HRL anticipates that the issues should be addressed to mitigate these one-off room requests by the end of the day today.

HRL did not respond in time to a request to provide the number of rooms affected or what the technical issues in question were.

“During routine heating system maintenance in the fall, issues can arise,” Stubblefield said in the email. “Because we’ve had an exceptionally warm fall, some of those issues weren’t apparent until the dip in temperature last week led to cooler than expected rooms.”

Stubblefield said in the email there are certain areas or rooms of Comstock that may need to be fixed individually from a mechanical standpoint, but anticipates that the issues with one-off room requests should be addressed by today.

“We sent a message to Comstock residents yesterday reminding them to submit a maintenance request (called a Fix It ticket) if they are experiencing a lack of heat in their room, so that the facilities staff can fix it,” Stubblefield said.

Stubblefield said that maintenance staff has responded within 24 hours to cold room reports. She added electric space heaters were also made available to residents experiencing issues.

This is a breaking news story. Check back for updates.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on UMN anticipates Comstock heating issues to be fixed by today

Greystar management company stays quiet on student security deposit troubles

Editor’s note: Sam Hill lived at Doyle Apartments and did not receive his security deposit three weeks after forwarding a bank transfer request. Here is what he found after looking into it.

In the lobby of Doyle Apartments, books sit in neat little piles, a modern-looking coffee machine sits on one side and a tenant checks her mailbox. It is Sunday evening — meaning it has been almost two months with no real word on her security deposit return from the previous year. 

“I find it to be absolutely ridiculous that the management doesn’t have the most basic skill of communicating with their tenants,” the tenant wrote in an anonymous email to the Daily due to fear her deposit would not be returned. “I have inquired about my deposit continuously over the past few months and I have only ever been met with vague answers of ‘I don’t know,’ and ‘It’s an issue with multiple people’ and ‘Thanks for your patience,’ and that’s if they bother to answer me at all.” 

She said she was furious because she asked in person, over the phone and through email and said this was another prime example of apartment managers taking advantage of students.

Hao, a tenant who asked to be referred to only by his first name, said management kept communication to a minimum.

“I realize that it’s also because Doyle got bought by another property company, but still not a good look for them,” Hao said.

Greystar, the largest apartment management company in the U.S., manages several properties at the University of Minnesota — including The Marshall and briefly the Doyle. 

According to multiple anonymous sources, many students at Doyle have not received their security deposits promptly despite forwarding receipt addresses months ago.

According to the University of Minnesota Student Legal Service (SLS), a landlord is obligated to return a security deposit or provide a statement outlining any withholding of all or part of the security deposit within three weeks of receiving the former renter’s forwarding address or delivery instructions. There is no legal obligation for a landlord to affirmatively ask for the information when a renter is moving out.

SLS lawyer Shana Tomenes said the SLS housing legal team sees about one security deposit case each week during each fall semester. She added skirting the edges of legal limits on returns is something all management companies in the area do.

If a student does not know their new address and does not affirmatively provide that information, there can be a significant delay between the time when a student moves out to when they receive their security deposit, according to Tomenes. 

One tenant shared her emails to Greystar from several weeks ago. The Greystar point of contact, given to her by Doyle management, told her they would get ahold of the accounting department and follow up on if and where the deposits were sent. 

That tenant never received a response. She is currently filing a small claims court claim against Greystar.

Another anonymous source said he had seen many former Doyle residents with the same security deposit issues on social media. He eventually received his deposit and encouraged anyone being held out by management companies to reach out to legal services. 

“I had to contact UMN legal services and had an attorney send them an email threatening legal actions and over a thousand dollars in fines if they didn’t get the return to me by the end of October,” the source said. “The next day they sent over the return.”

Some students described their experiences with Greystar management in other apartments. 

Fourth-year student Samantha Clark said she requested to not have a bed at The Marshall because she was bringing her own. Her room came with no bed or mattress, but at the end of the year, she received a $500 missing bed charge.

“I called and spoke with their corporate office about it and they said they would get back to me,” Clark said. “I have been dealing with this since Aug. 9 when I moved out and it still hasn’t been resolved.”

Management responses

Doyle property manager Sydney Dreyer said in an email to the Minnesota Daily to direct any inquiries to the former Greystar management company contact for “any questions regarding the time period prior to October 1, 2024.”

“I believe your inquiry is related to security deposits and tenancies that ended prior to October 1, 2024,” Dreyer said in the email. “The Doyle’s ownership, and management company, recently changed as the result of a sale that closed on October 1, 2024.”

The Greystar company contact in said emails has not responded to multiple requests to connect from the Daily. Greystar public relations later directed the Daily to connect with the owner but did not respond to requests to disclose the owner’s identity.

In an email to an anonymous source, Dreyer said she had “no clue where the security deposits were” on Oct. 3. In a phone conversation with the Daily, Dreyer said all deposits were mailed out the week prior to Oct. 22.

“I have been trying to work with Greystar for an update and they say they are approving them,” Dreyer wrote in the email. “As far as I know, no one has received their deposits or even the email from smart disburse so this is news to me!”

Greystar communication director Andrea Davis said in an email to the Daily that any questions regarding the timing and return of security deposits should be directed to the former owner. 

“We are not authorized to speak on behalf of the former owner of The Doyle, which we have ceased managing,” Davis said in the email. “Any questions regarding the return of security deposits and the timing of such should be correctly directed to the former owner.”

Greystar did not respond to the Daily as to whether they were in charge of collecting security deposits from former tenants.

Why it matters

The Minnesota Daily reported that increased housing development in the Dinkytown area has led to increased legal dilemmas for student renters, with a vast majority of student legal service casework being related to housing in the present day compared to 10 years ago.

Greystar Management is the largest apartment management company and property owner in the U.S., according to 2024 NMHC rankings. As a property management company, it is responsible for collecting rent and security deposits, marketing, and addressing tenant and maintenance concerns.

From Dec. 12, 2023, to Oct. 1 of this year, Greystar was responsible for managing Doyle Apartments. After Oct. 1, management and ownership transferred to Go Gopher Rentals Management company.

Go Gopher Rentals did not respond to the Minnesota Daily with comments on missing security deposits.

Emails from former Doyle management from December of last year suggest that Greystar was responsible for both owning and managing the property.

“The security deposit plus 1% interest in the amount of $500.00 has been transferred to the new owner and manager as listed below,” the email from Dec. 8 read. “New Management: Greystar Management.”

The Minnesota Daily reached out to Northstar management, the company in charge of managing Doyle Apartments prior to Greystar. The Northstar contact said that the current Northstar manager was assisting Doyle management on security deposit issues but did not provide further details.

Renter legal protections

Tomenes said University Student Legal Services advises students on the likelihood of legal success and helps them find solutions other than going straight to small claims court. She said their office also helps students fill out the required paperwork and prepare them to testify before the court. 

“Renters have strong legal protections when it comes to security deposit disputes,” Tomenes wrote in an email to the Daily.

Tomenes added students generally report satisfaction with the results of their small claims court claim. She added that when there are multiple unresolved cases with a landlord, or if students have three or more substantiated claims, such as a security deposit court ruling in their favor, the landlord is placed on the University non-compliant landlord list.

“Often if one student is having a security deposit problem with their landlord, others in the same building are facing the same problem,” Tomenes said. “Student Legal Service recommends reaching out to our office whenever you have a legal issue with your landlord, and encouraging your neighbors to do the same.”

Correction: A previous version of this article misstated that Greystar owns The Marshall and Doyle apartments. They manage those properties. Other edits made for clarity and accuracy.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Greystar management company stays quiet on student security deposit troubles

USG Row the Vote exceeds registration goal, students lock-in for election season

Projected to a University of Minnesota display board in a dark lecture hall on Sept. 11, Kamala Harris and Donald Trump’s 7 p.m. Presidential debate was on the big screen. When Trump delivered his now infamous line about immigrants eating people’s cats and dogs, a room of about 300 students exploded into laughter.

Event moderator and Journalism professor Christopher Terry was not having it.

“Settle down, settle down!” Terry said.

It was a substantial crowd, about 10 times the projected attendance of 20 to 30 journalism students, according to Terry.

It has not been the only big crowd of the past few weeks. The Vice Presidential debate had similar attendance, and with four weeks left before the Presidential election, the Undergraduate Student Government (USG) “Row the Vote” Initiative is at an all-time high in voting registration.

As of Oct. 10, Row the Vote has already counted 10,200 pledges and over 1,200 registrations, according to USG Civic Engagement Director Riley Hetland. The Minnesota Daily reported that the initial goal for this year was 7,000 pledges and 3,000 registrations.

The Row the Vote Initiative is a USG program that attempts to register and educate as many student voters as possible, according to Hetland. She said USG is keeping track of all students who have registered or pledged to vote.

MinnPost reported that Gen Z engagement in this election is expected to be high, with 65% of eligible voters aged 18 to 29 casting a ballot in the 2020 election, compared to a nationwide average of about 50%.

The Minnesota Daily reported that Row the Vote started in 2020 and was taken over by USG in 2022. USG met their benchmark of 6,000 pledges for their last Row the Vote in 2022, according to Hetland.

“Our country is very, very politically charged currently and so we’ve been seeing that reflected in the amount of people who have been signing pledge forms and registering to vote,” Hetland said. “Last year, the election was pretty unemphasized among the student body.”

Hetland said Row the Vote visits classrooms in what are known within USG as “class blitzes,” where they go into classes, get student vote pledges, register voters and educate people on when and how to vote. Their goal for the year is to visit 1,000 classes by election day.

“We’re going into hundreds of classrooms a day,” Hetland said. “I’d say for sure we’ve been to eight or nine hundred classrooms already.”

Hetland added that it is important to note the electricity behind the student body this year.

“It is truly, truly important for students to make change when they want to see change happen,” Hetland said.

Student engagement goes up

Terry said when he started the University’s Hubbard School Presidential Debate watch parties in 2016, he had a much smaller crowd of only journalism students. 

Terry said students from math, economics, chemistry and a whole contingent from mechanical engineering joined the journalism students for the 2024 Presidential debate after the event was mentioned on Reddit.

“We only had enough pizza for a handful of people, but then people from all over campus showed up for it,” Terry said. “I mean, that tells you something about the interest in it.”

Terry said the idea that students are not engaged and interested in politics is not true.

Terry said there has been a lot of open dialogue and competing viewpoints in University watch parties. He said they have 99.9% productive debates — besides the occasional snag comments — because you learn from people by talking to them in face-to-face interactions.

“I’m gonna watch the debate anyway,” Terry said. “Here is a productive environment to watch it.”

Who people are voting for

The Minnesota Daily asked University of Minnesota students face-to-face who they were planning to vote for and to briefly explain why. Last names have been omitted to incentivize unfiltered political expression. 

All prospective voters interviewed said they either supported former President Donald Trump, Vice President Kamala Harris, Green Party presidential candidate Jill Stein or said they were either not voting or undecided.

Why are you planning to vote for Trump?

A quarter of University students surveyed said they would support Trump in the 2024 election.

  • “Trump is overall better for the country’s economy. He’s not easily intimidated by other countries,” said Jackson, a first-year student.

 

  • “I am not voting for the woman who would judge me for my outfit in high school,” said Steven, a third-year student.

 

  • “His economic policies are better. I’m not a huge Trump fan, but it’s obvious under his presidency the economy was running better,” said Soren, a post-secondary enrollment option student.

 

  • “He more aligns with my personal beliefs and he is better for international relations. I believe he would do a better job reducing inflation, and if Kamala could’ve done it she would have by now,” said Shane, a third-year student.

 

  • “Most likely Trump as I lean conservative fiscally, as well as for jobs. Minnesota isn’t doing great with that right now,” said Molly, a third-year student.

Why are you planning to vote for Kamala?

Out of 30 students who shared their opinions with the Minnesota Daily, a little less than two-thirds said they were planning to vote for Harris this November.

  • “Her policies are just better, and she didn’t try to overthrow the government. I’d also prefer it if my girlfriend had her rights,” said Luke, a third-year student.

 

  • “Trump is a convicted felon. It would also be cool to see a woman as president. It would be a big deal,” said Laria, a third-year student. 

 

  • “My mother, my sister and my girlfriend would like to have rights,” said Stafford, a third-year student.

 

  • “I hate Donald Trump a lot more,” said Nathan, a second-year student.

 

  • “She is pro-climate change, human rights and would lead to a more united country,” said Amya, a first-year student.

 

  • “Trump’s an egomaniac lesser of two evils,” said Jordan, a prospective graduate student. 

 

  • “Not having access to abortion is the difference between life and death,” said Albra, a first-year student.

 

  • “Her economic policies are better. Her attitude is better and she is more compassionate and trustworthy,” said Nate, a graduate student. 

Independent party supporters

Two students said they would be voting for Jill Stein, as neither major party candidates have a preferable stance on the Israel-Hamas war and ongoing Palestinian humanitarian crises.

  • “Both the Democrats and the Republicans are in support of Israel. The Green Party vice president is Muslim and Jill Stein supports Palestine,” said Izhan, a third-year student.

 

  • “Both sides aren’t trying to stop a genocide or having a ceasefire. Jill Stein supports reparations, free healthcare and is more genuine than both major party candidates,” said Subi, a third-year student.

Republican and DFL engagement on campus

Christopher Flemming,  Minnesota College Republican chair and St. Olaf chapter of College Republican president, said there has been high Republican engagement with the St. Olaf chapter of College Republicans, but there is not currently a College Republican chapter on the University of Minnesota Twin Cities campus. With the Turning Point USA club dying out recently, there is not currently a major Republican group on the Twin Cities campus.

Flemming said the plurality of Republican students he has talked to said immigration was their biggest concern. He added that people would also talk about things like the economy, inflation, crime and housing costs.

“I just think a lack of enforcement of our current policies, a feeling that it’s an issue the government could fix while both sides don’t really want to,” Flemming said. “I think it shows anger with the establishment.”

Minnesota DFL Party Chair Ken Martin said in an emailed statement to the Minnesota Daily that the DFL college campus turnout operation is the strongest it has ever been.

“We have student organizing programs at 23 different colleges and universities, we are promoting pop-up early voting locations near students, and we are investing time and resources into providing students the information they need to make voting easy and accessible,” Martin said in the statement.

Martin added that DFL legislative action has contributed to students from low-income families having access to free tuition from Minnesota’s state colleges and universities and access to paid family and medical leave when they graduate. 

DFL Twin Cities Campus Fellow Nora Wilcek said most of what the DFL does on campus involves tabling, direct voter recruitment, registering students to vote and knocking on dorm doors. She said the DFL mostly does this through face-to-face interaction and is looking to increase the number of events on campus as election day approaches.

Wilcek added she has not seen or interacted with many Republicans on campus.

“I think we are probably the core presence that’s on campus,” Wilcek said. “I think around Minnesota there is a lot of excitement about the DFL.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on USG Row the Vote exceeds registration goal, students lock-in for election season