Author Archives | by Matthew Jegers

Opinion: Cars or political statements?

If there is one name that has dominated recent news cycles, it’s Elon Musk.

The South African billionaire and owner of enterprises such as Tesla and SpaceX, previously a footnote within political coverage, became active within the political arena in March 2024 after he began vocally supporting now-President Donald Trump in his bid for a second term.

After the 2024 presidential election, Musk was famously named the head of the new Department of Government Efficiency, a body that was made with the goal of cutting over $1 trillion in government spending. As of March 24, DOGE claims to have saved over $130 billion in funding from a variety of government agencies, with only about $7.7 billion of that being able to be verified. 

These cuts, along with other forms of right-wing advocacy, have made Musk quite the controversial figure. While 46% of Americans said that they liked the idea of DOGE, in the same poll, just 39% of Americans held a positive view of Musk.

In turn, Musk’s largely negative public image impacts the reputation and overall viability of the companies that he owns.

Tesla is currently in hot water, as sales plummeted by over 50,000 cars within the first three months of this year. That represents a 13% decrease in overall sales for a manufacturer accustomed to quarterly sales growth between 20% and 100%.

Even Tesla’s current dire financial straits are now increasingly political. Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz joked that he enjoyed watching Tesla’s stock price drop on his phone.

“I don’t know if some of you know this, on the iPhone, they’ve got that little stock app,” Walz said. “I added Tesla to it to give me a little boost during the day.”

Dan Myers, an associate professor in the University of Minnesota’s department of political science, said that most large brands, especially brands that are so closely associated with a specific person, try to avoid politics at all costs.

“In general, mass market brands try to avoid political entanglement for the simple reason that you don’t want to irritate half of your customer base,” Myers said.

Ella Hanhan, a third-year student at the University, said she had some hope for Tesla originally, but her opinion of the car brand tanked as Musk got involved in politics.

“But Tesla overall, it was a decent idea, an energy-based car,” Hanhan said. “I mean, the manufacturing isn’t that environmentally friendly, but the idea behind it was.”

Unfortunately for the brand, the novelty of Tesla’s cars has largely worn off. The manufacturer, once the undisputed leader of the electric vehicle industry, is now facing large pressure from other automotive manufacturers who are eating into Tesla’s market share.

The loss of market dominance, combined with the latest in a series of recalls of Tesla vehicles and Musk’s controversial politics, paint a grim future for the once-booming electric vehicle brand.

Myers said Musk’s public image was much more positive and associated with technological innovation until quite recently, when he decided to get into politics.

“So, if you go back even a couple of years, obviously there was some backlash against Musk from the left just because of his extreme amount of wealth, but he really had a very different public image,” Myers said. “The way that that’s changed in the past year is remarkable, and almost entirely, you could say, Musk’s choice.”

Hanhan said she has noticed the public’s image of Musk shift the more he gets into politics and governance, especially with his touted budget cuts as the head of DOGE.

“There’s just been a collapse in him being viewed as this genius,” Hanhan said. “Instead, it’s more of him sticking his nose in everybody’s business.”

Even owning a Tesla has become divisive in our current political environment. Some celebrities, including actress Bette Middler and singer Sheryl Crow, have sold their Teslas to express their displeasure with Musk’s politics.

Walz said Tesla owners are not necessarily at fault for buying the car while also still making a joke about the brand’s public image.

“So, and if you own one, we’re not blaming you,” Walz said.”You can take dental floss and pull the Tesla thing off.”

Noah Olson, a third-year student at the University, said his opinion of Tesla as a brand has not been impacted by the political actions of Musk.

“At least for me, I think it’s easy to separate the brand and him,” Olson said. “I don’t see that he’s putting any political propaganda into his brand or his cars, so I guess it’s easy for me to look at it as a brand, and then there’s Elon.”

Hanhan said she doesn’t think Musk and Tesla are separable due to the abnormally active role that Musk took in the branding and shaping of the car manufacturer’s public image. 

“He was the figurehead of the company,” Hanhan said. “You thought Tesla, you thought Musk, and I think that involvement is the reason why there is so much backlash.”

Backlash against Musk’s politics is not just limited to the U.S., either. Largely due to his vocal support of far-right parties in Europe (including Germany’s AfD), Tesla’s sales in Europe have declined almost 50% despite the industry growing by almost 30%. 

Both Tesla’s cars and dealerships have also been the targets of vandalism and arson in Europe and the U.S., speaking to the profound outrage against Musk and his politics.

Olson said while he doesn’t hold Musk’s actions against Tesla, he would be less inclined to buy a Tesla if he ever had the opportunity.

“I feel like if I were to buy a Tesla, maybe that would be sort of like giving support to him,” Olson said. “I don’t know, it’s a hard thing.”

Myers said that despite rumors circulating about Musk separating from the Trump administration, Tesla’s image will not immediately be saved if he does leave politics.

“I think if that happens, there will be a pretty long memory,” Myers said. “Maybe in five or 10 years people will have forgotten, but it’s gonna be a while.”

Very few brands have become so politically divisive in just a few years. After years of financial success and domination of the electric vehicles market, it is clear to see that Tesla’s image very much lives or dies with Musk. 

Given the prominence of Musk’s actions within politics and government, buying a Tesla today could be seen as a declaration of your political loyalties. Whether that affects your choice to buy one or not is up to you.

So, if you’re in the market for an electric vehicle, you may want to ask yourself a question — am I okay with bringing the car equivalent of a political banner out with me in public in today’s charged political climate?

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Cars or political statements?

Opinion: The college cost conundrum

There’s no denying that one of the most pressing issues Generation Z is facing right now is the cost of college.

The price of a post-secondary degree has increased drastically over the past few decades. From 1980 to 2019, the average price (adjusted for inflation) to attend a four-year college increased 169%, with all kinds of schools becoming more expensive.

Christine Storms, the director of curriculum for National University’s School of Health Professions based in San Diego, said there are a variety of factors that cause tuition prices to increase, such as the cost of accreditation and demand for higher faculty wages.

“They want a salary that more closely mirrors what they can earn in the field,” Storms said. “For example, software or computer engineers can earn upwards of $120,000 in industry, but will probably start at around $80,000 teaching.”

These tuition hikes force many students to reconsider how they must pay for college. In the 2021-2022 school year, more than half of students at four-year universities graduated with student loans, with $29,400 being the average school debt balance.

As increasing tuition and the looming specter of student debt force students to closely plan their path to college, many are turning away from private colleges — which traditionally have had higher sticker prices — in favor of public institutions.

Abdulaziz Said, a first-year student at St. Cloud State University, said he did not even consider most private colleges during his college search due to affordability concerns.

“I wanted to take advantage of as much public funding as I possibly could,” Said said. “So I just kinda crossed out almost every single private school.”

It’s true that private colleges, both for-profit and nonprofit, are more expensive than their public counterparts on average. However, private nonprofit colleges also tend to give out significantly more aid than public schools, which can help to make up for the high price tag.

Although they often cost more upfront, an increasing number of colleges are taking steps to provide extensive financial assistance in order to attract more students.

Several high-profile private colleges, including multiple Ivy League schools, provide free tuition to students if their family’s household income is below a certain threshold. In the cases of Harvard, MIT and the University of Pennsylvania, that threshold is set as high as $200,000.

It’s not just exclusive Ivy League colleges offering this kind of program.

Concordia College in Moorhead, Minnesota, offers The Concordia Promise, which gives free tuition to students whose family’s adjusted gross income is less than $90,000. That ceiling is $10,000 dollars higher than the North Star Promise tuition funding that students at Minnesota’s public colleges can take advantage of.

Bryce Paulson, a student in his final year at Concordia College, said he wanted to attend the University of Minnesota, but financial circumstances and a lack of student aid prevented him from being able to attend.

“The University of Minnesota Twin Cities was my dream school,” Paulson said. “However, my financial package came in, and it was no longer feasible.”

While he regrets missing out on various opportunities at the University of Minnesota, Paulson said that, due to the basing of student aid on family income, he didn’t have much of a choice.

“Concordia won at the end of the day just by mere financials,” Paulson said.

As a society, we need to recognize that public colleges are not affordable for everyone nor are private colleges always prohibitively expensive. Different students will find that their aid and scholarships vary a lot from their peers due to different life situations.

Given how much college affordability depends on personal circumstances, is there anything that can be done to ensure students will be able to pay for their education?

Storms said a major problem is that students are not given adequate information about certain aid and scholarship programs.

“The free incentives do sway students, but only the students whose parents know or can navigate the systems,” Storms said. “The high school counselors are not good at providing that information.”

Storms also said while ideal paths may depend on major and institution, students should use published tuition and fee information to guide their college search.

“Students need to do their research,” Storms said. “Some tuition is low, but the program fees and books are horrible.”

Said said he does not feel like he was truly informed about the cost of college while going through the college search process.

“The money that I was being charged was not at all what the websites were indicating,” Said said. “I guess it changes from time to time, but it felt very confusing.”

Deciding what college to attend is not easy, especially when you are worrying about finances on top of everything else. But being more aware of your financial and educational situation, as well as consulting with educational experts, can do wonders to set you on your way.

Instead of being set on a particular path, students should be more open to different colleges and programs in order to balance the best experience with the most affordable education possible.

As it turns out, the only thing standing in between you and saving thousands of dollars on college costs is educating yourself about your education.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: The college cost conundrum

Opinion: More districts, more problems

Have you ever felt like the government does not represent your beliefs or that your vote doesn’t actually matter?

Even outside of the debate around more hotly contested election issues, like the Electoral College, there are plenty of problems with our elections that need to be discussed. 

For example, Minnesota has voted Democratic for every presidential election since 1976, yet its own internal politics remain curiously contentious. This was plain to see in 2024. 

Despite Minnesota voting for Kamala Harris by a margin of more than 100,000 votes and for Sen. Amy Klobuchar by more than 500,000 votes, the state legislature was still split with a 67-67 tie in the state House of Representatives.

So why is there a disconnect between the state’s overall results and its own internal politics?

As it happens, not every vote matters equally. After all, a vote for a party in an area where that party has 80% support makes much less of a difference than a vote in an evenly split district, as the winning party will only earn one seat, no matter how close the outcome is.

These “wasted votes” add up quickly, especially in urban areas with densely packed populations. Some state House districts in Minneapolis, such as District 62B, saw 2024 results for the DFL candidates soar past 80%, contributing to the gap between Minnesota’s federal and state election results.

Researchers Nicholas Stephanopoulos and Eric McGhee coined the term “efficiency gap” in a 2014 paper to measure the representation of legislatures by comparing the number of wasted votes to the overall number of votes cast. 

While the efficiency gap was initially created to measure the effects of partisan gerrymandering, it underlines a key problem with how we elect our legislators. 

Minnesota has a single-member voting system for both its Senate and House of Representatives, meaning that the winner of a district’s election takes the district no matter the number of votes for their opponents.

“The key insight underlying the efficiency gap is that all elections in single-member districts produce large numbers of wasted votes,” according to Stephanopoulos and McGhee.

If higher efficiency gaps are caused by single-member districts, why not try something new?

That’s where multi-member districts, also known as plural districts, come in. Despite what you may think about democratic elections, legislative elections don’t need only one winner, and it is possible to vote for multiple candidates in a single election.

As of Oct. 2, 2024, 10 states use a type of multi-member district in at least one of their state legislative chambers. 

Additionally, a plethora of nations around the world, from Brazil and Germany to South Africa and Indonesia, incorporate some kind of plural district in their national legislative elections. 

Unfortunately, due to a history of winner-take-all and general ticket use within state delegations, Congress banned the use of plural districts at the federal level with the 1967 Uniform Congressional District Act.

However, there are still people fighting to change that fact. A 2022 open letter to Congress, signed by more than 200 scholars (including seven affiliated with the University of Minnesota), urged Congress to lift the ban on multi-member districts and take steps toward proportional representation at the federal level.

“As the 2020 redistricting process comes to a close, it is clear that our winner-take-all system — where each U.S. House district is represented by a single person — is fundamentally broken,” according to the letter to Congress. “We call on Congress to adopt inclusive, multi-member districts with competitive and responsive proportional representation.”

The letter also said that, regardless of district gerrymandering, creating competitive districts under our current system is incredibly difficult due to uneven distributions of voters.

Andrew Karch, chair of the Department of Political Science at the University of Minnesota, said that while Minnesota is a politically diverse state, much of the support for each party, especially the DFL, is very concentrated in certain areas.

“In that sense, Minnesota really represents that growing trend of that urban-rural divide,” Karch said. “Historically, the DFL had more support in Duluth and the Iron Range, and as that support has evaporated a bit, the party strength has become more concentrated in the Twin Cities.”

This high concentration of voters makes it very hard to draw competitive single-member districts, leading to a higher statewide efficiency gap.

“Our arcane, single-member districting process divides, polarizes and isolates us from each other,” according to the letter. “It has effectively extinguished competitive elections for most Americans and produced a deeply divided political system that is incapable of responding to changing demands and emerging challenges with necessary legitimacy.”

Karch said one of the main obstacles to using multi-member districts is that political influences can affect our current process of drawing electoral districts.

“I think one of the challenges has to do with the fact that we have this redistricting process, and that process has become increasingly scientific,” Karch said. “Parties are very skilled at drawing maps, disadvantaging their opponents and advantaging themselves, and they can do so with a lot of savvy.”

Karch said multi-member districts, in combination with other electoral reforms like redistricting commissions and ranked-choice voting, could potentially help issues like high-efficiency gaps and political polarization.

“At this particular moment, people are thinking of lots of different ways to perhaps adjust the rules,” Karch said. “And so, putting together a reform package could help.”

Multi-member districts aren’t exactly perfect either. To get a multi-member district from our current system, several existing districts would have to be combined, forcing representatives to represent greater geographic areas and potentially putting distance between the voter and the representative.

There is also a concern about whether minority groups will be represented fairly under a plural district system.

“I think one of the concerns about multi-member districts has to do with who the winners are most likely to be,” Karch said. “For a while, the scholarly consensus was that multi-member districts might disadvantage historically underrepresented groups, particularly racial and ethnic minorities.”

Yet there is still hope for multi-member constituencies. While it has lagged behind on Asian and Hispanic representation, Maryland’s General Assembly, which uses plural districts to elect its representatives, has become increasingly more diverse over the past decade.

This could indicate that racial disparities are a result of how the multi-member districts were implemented, not the system itself.

Regardless, something must be done to reform our less-than-representative electoral system, and despite its potential flaws, multi-member districts stand a good chance of reducing Minnesota’s legislative efficiency gap. While it would be hard to implement on a national level, this new electoral system is still worth a try within our state elections.

So next time you go to the ballot box, you should ask yourself the question, “Would I mind marking a few more boxes if it means my vote has more of an effect?”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: More districts, more problems

Opinion: Autism testing needs some reform

You may not know it, but it is very likely that you know someone with autism.

Over 5 million adults in the U.S. are estimated to have Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), according to a CDC study from 2017. That is over 2% of the nation’s adult population.

That estimate could very well be low. 

Over the last few decades, the rate of ASD diagnoses skyrocketed, not because more people were born with autism, but because we got better at identifying the condition. From 2000 to 2020, the proportion of young children identified with autism went from one in 150 to one in 36, according to the CDC.

Barbara Luskin, a licensed counselor with the Autism Society of Minnesota, said she does not expect that spike in diagnoses to continue for much longer, as teachers and other professionals now know what signs and symptoms to look for. 

“My guess is, in the next few years, the number of children diagnosed (with ASD) will stabilize,” Luskin said.

But what caused this dramatic increase in autism diagnoses within the 21st century?

One of the main causes of the increase stems from a changing understanding t of what autism is. Much of the social stigma around autism comes from associations with Asperger’s syndrome, which was an outdated diagnosis that was lumped together with autism under the label of ASD in 2013, according to Cleveland Clinic.

This association led to the idea that autism was an easily recognizable condition with set symptoms when, as the name ASD implies, it is a spectrum. 

“It’s only in the past 30 years that we’ve really been looking at this population of more verbal, more academically-able people and saying ‘Yes, they have the same pattern of learning differences,’” Luskin said. “So, I think if you think about it in terms of that time frame, of course we’re still catching up.”

Despite the developments in ASD classification, much of the stigma around autism can still be seen in society’s views of the condition.

Linden, a first-year student at the University of Minnesota Morris diagnosed with ASD in 2023 and wishes to only use their first name due to personal concerns, said numerous signs of neurodivergence were noticed by teachers and doctors, these signs were handwaved as intelligence due to things like high reading speed and good academic performance. 

“It really felt like they had plenty of signs,” Linden said. “But it was literally just the ‘Nope, she’s smart.’” 

Unfortunately, stigma is far from the only thing keeping people from being diagnosed with autism. Insurance coverage, or lack thereof, can also keep people from starting the diagnostic process.

Luskin said Social Security and many major insurance providers will only pay for ASD assessments conducted by a provider with a doctorate, forcing patients to wait in a backlog for a select few providers.

“I think it is a way for insurance companies to do some gatekeeping,” Luskin said. “I think it’s a financial issue and not a competence issue because I have many colleagues at the masters level who are perfectly competent to do a diagnostic assessment.”

Outside of stigma and institutional issues affecting autism, there are also systemic issues within the diagnostic process that should be addressed. Significantly more boys are diagnosed with ASD than girls due to a gender bias within how autism symptoms are tested for and recognized, according to a study from the National Institutes for Health.

While she acknowledged that times are changing, Luskin said there is still a gender gap when recognizing the symptoms of autism.

“I think, particularly for women, there’s still a lot of ‘Oh, you can’t have autism, you’re a woman,’” Luskin said. 

Wait times for an exam, whether caused by a lack of providers, insurance regulations or other factors, can also be a barrier between patients and an ASD diagnosis. Over 60% of specialized autism centers reported a wait time of over four months, according to a study from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ Health Equity Conference.

“If you are not in an emergency situation, it can be up to two years at our clinic,” Luskin said. “There are only so many (examinations) you can do in a week.”

Linden said the diagnostic process, from when they first noticed signs of autism to when they received a professional diagnosis, took around eight months.

“The reason I got it so fast is because a ton of appointments were canceled for some reason before mine,” Linden said. “So, out of luck, I got it pretty quick.”

Long wait times for examinations encourage many patients to search for more information on ASD and effectively self-diagnose, only coming in when they want official confirmation, Luskin said. She also acknowledged that this research and introspection can help with the diagnostic process.

“In those two years, they’ve done a lot of reading and a lot of research,” Luskin said.  “And very rarely do I disagree with them.”

While they were a bit more nervous about self-diagnosing, Linden said the research process was incredibly helpful and reassuring to them during their journey to diagnosis.

“Do your research,” Linden said. “I think it is helpful to use, like, professional sources and keep it all in a document.”

People should not have to wait in doubtful limbo for a diagnosis. We must get better at diagnosing ASD, or many more children and adults alike will struggle alone without realizing why they feel different from everyone else.

From changing insurance coverage policies and speeding up the process to lessening social stigma and closing the gender gap, there are plenty of things that can be done to help those wondering if they have autism.

The key is taking action. 

Educating ourselves on neurodivergence and speaking out on these issues is the least that we can do for our neurodivergent friends, colleagues and family members.

You never know if someone you know is questioning why they think differently.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Autism testing needs some reform

Opinion: Autism testing needs some reform

You may not know it, but it is very likely that you know someone with autism.

Over 5 million adults in the U.S. are estimated to have Autism Spectrum Disorder (ASD), according to a CDC study from 2017. That is over 2% of the nation’s adult population.

That estimate could very well be low. 

Over the last few decades, the rate of ASD diagnoses skyrocketed, not because more people were born with autism, but because we got better at identifying the condition. From 2000 to 2020, the proportion of young children identified with autism went from one in 150 to one in 36, according to the CDC.

Barbara Luskin, a licensed counselor with the Autism Society of Minnesota, said she does not expect that spike in diagnoses to continue for much longer, as teachers and other professionals now know what signs and symptoms to look for. 

“My guess is, in the next few years, the number of children diagnosed (with ASD) will stabilize,” Luskin said.

But what caused this dramatic increase in autism diagnoses within the 21st century?

One of the main causes of the increase stems from a changing understanding t of what autism is. Much of the social stigma around autism comes from associations with Asperger’s syndrome, which was an outdated diagnosis that was lumped together with autism under the label of ASD in 2013, according to Cleveland Clinic.

This association led to the idea that autism was an easily recognizable condition with set symptoms when, as the name ASD implies, it is a spectrum. 

“It’s only in the past 30 years that we’ve really been looking at this population of more verbal, more academically-able people and saying ‘Yes, they have the same pattern of learning differences,’” Luskin said. “So, I think if you think about it in terms of that time frame, of course we’re still catching up.”

Despite the developments in ASD classification, much of the stigma around autism can still be seen in society’s views of the condition.

Linden, a first-year student at the University of Minnesota Morris diagnosed with ASD in 2023 and wishes to only use their first name due to personal concerns, said numerous signs of neurodivergence were noticed by teachers and doctors, these signs were handwaved as intelligence due to things like high reading speed and good academic performance. 

“It really felt like they had plenty of signs,” Linden said. “But it was literally just the ‘Nope, she’s smart.’” 

Unfortunately, stigma is far from the only thing keeping people from being diagnosed with autism. Insurance coverage, or lack thereof, can also keep people from starting the diagnostic process.

Luskin said Social Security and many major insurance providers will only pay for ASD assessments conducted by a provider with a doctorate, forcing patients to wait in a backlog for a select few providers.

“I think it is a way for insurance companies to do some gatekeeping,” Luskin said. “I think it’s a financial issue and not a competence issue because I have many colleagues at the masters level who are perfectly competent to do a diagnostic assessment.”

Outside of stigma and institutional issues affecting autism, there are also systemic issues within the diagnostic process that should be addressed. Significantly more boys are diagnosed with ASD than girls due to a gender bias within how autism symptoms are tested for and recognized, according to a study from the National Institutes for Health.

While she acknowledged that times are changing, Luskin said there is still a gender gap when recognizing the symptoms of autism.

“I think, particularly for women, there’s still a lot of ‘Oh, you can’t have autism, you’re a woman,’” Luskin said. 

Wait times for an exam, whether caused by a lack of providers, insurance regulations or other factors, can also be a barrier between patients and an ASD diagnosis. Over 60% of specialized autism centers reported a wait time of over four months, according to a study from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ Health Equity Conference.

“If you are not in an emergency situation, it can be up to two years at our clinic,” Luskin said. “There are only so many (examinations) you can do in a week.”

Linden said the diagnostic process, from when they first noticed signs of autism to when they received a professional diagnosis, took around eight months.

“The reason I got it so fast is because a ton of appointments were canceled for some reason before mine,” Linden said. “So, out of luck, I got it pretty quick.”

Long wait times for examinations encourage many patients to search for more information on ASD and effectively self-diagnose, only coming in when they want official confirmation, Luskin said. She also acknowledged that this research and introspection can help with the diagnostic process.

“In those two years, they’ve done a lot of reading and a lot of research,” Luskin said.  “And very rarely do I disagree with them.”

While they were a bit more nervous about self-diagnosing, Linden said the research process was incredibly helpful and reassuring to them during their journey to diagnosis.

“Do your research,” Linden said. “I think it is helpful to use, like, professional sources and keep it all in a document.”

People should not have to wait in doubtful limbo for a diagnosis. We must get better at diagnosing ASD, or many more children and adults alike will struggle alone without realizing why they feel different from everyone else.

From changing insurance coverage policies and speeding up the process to lessening social stigma and closing the gender gap, there are plenty of things that can be done to help those wondering if they have autism.

The key is taking action. 

Educating ourselves on neurodivergence and speaking out on these issues is the least that we can do for our neurodivergent friends, colleagues and family members.

You never know if someone you know is questioning why they think differently.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Autism testing needs some reform

Opinion: Immigration backlogs beyond the border

Picture this — you are waiting in line at everyone’s favorite government office, the DMV. Your driver’s license recently expired so you have to take a few hours out of your day to wait in a seemingly endless line to receive your new license.

Except, instead of your driver’s license, imagine you are waiting for a green card or asylum papers. And instead of a few hours, imagine you are waiting several years for the DMV to say if it will even give you a license or not. 

That is the unfortunate reality that many immigrants to the United States face. 

In 2023, the average wait time for someone applying for asylum was 1,525 days, according to PBS. That is over four years of waiting for an answer to whether you can stay in the country.

The cause of this absurd wait time is simple to define — case backlogs. At all stages of the immigration process (asylum or visas), there are massive backlogs of cases and applications. 

For example, the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Service (USCIS) had 4.3 million outstanding cases, exceeding their target processing times by the end of 2023, according to the agency’s archive. This is despite reducing the overall backlog by 15% from the year before, the USCIS’ first backlog reduction in over a decade.

The immigration court system is similarly overwhelmed.

In 2024, immigration judges completed just over 700,000 cases — which would have been an impressive number had the system not been left with 3.6 million outstanding cases by the end of that year, according to the Congressional Research Service.

So, what exactly is causing all of this backlog?

Dr. Michele Waslin, assistant director of the Immigration History Research Center at the University of Minnesota, said that a lack of investment and excessively strict investigative standards, amongst a variety of other issues, contribute to the backlog.

“There are many ways that this process can be slowed to a grinding halt,” Waslin said.

Sarah Brenes, executive director of the Binger Center for New Americans at the University’s  Law School, said the current focus of the immigration system strayed from its historical roots, becoming more rigorous and investigative.

“Over the past several decades, we have criminalized the process, when immigration has to do with simply regulating the movement of people,” Brenes said.

But what are the actual effects of this backlog? 

Immigrants, who are forced to try to plan their lives under a shroud of uncertainty, are most affected by the long wait times caused by the backlog.

“It’s a huge strain on people to be waiting,” Brenes said. “And then also just to have that uncertainty, wanting to put down roots or invest in their education and their communities… and always being stuck with that reality that it could be temporary and that they could be told they are no longer able to stay here. I think it really makes it a challenge for people to really feel safe, because it’s no guarantee.”

This crippling uncertainty does not make for ideal living conditions for anyone, and so it is understandable that some immigrants may want to avoid the process entirely. 

After all, who would want to go through years of uncertainty and strict scrutiny only to be potentially forced out of the country?

“We suspect that a lot of people who are here undocumented are part of the group waiting for their visa to be processed and part of that backlog,” Waslin said.

Despite all of the rhetoric around border security issues, the U.S.’ flawed immigration system is perpetuating the cycle of undocumented immigration through huge backlogs and long wait times. We must work to fix this issue or thousands more immigrants will be forced to navigate impossible positions in the hope for a better life.

Brenes said refocusing the priorities of the immigration system from strict enforcement to due process, as well as reallocating the powers given to bodies like USCIS and the Executive Office for Immigration Review could help alleviate the backlog.

“We’ve put a lot of attention at the border and really criminalizing anyone who is trying to seek safety in the United States rather than being creative and trying to find solutions that are sound for the day and age that we live in,” Brenes said. 

Waslin said hiring more immigration judges, helping judges manage their dockets better and moving some Congressional spending away from enforcement and toward processing staff would help reduce the backlog as well. 

“We need a good, functioning system for the 21st century,” Waslin said.

These are far from the only solutions that could be implemented to fix the backlog. 

A report from the Migration Policy Institute suggested a variety of solutions, including increasing representation for immigrants within the court system, allowing prosecutors to use more of their discretion during legal proceedings, and allowing USCIS asylum to resolve asylum claims on their own.

“The implementation of these measures would enable the immigration court system to reduce case volumes, increase the pace of decision-making and improve the quality of its adjudications,” according to the report. “To those ends, a nationwide effort at full-scale modernization and court reform is a central imperative going forward.”

No matter the solution we choose, we truly owe ourselves, our country and our immigrants a better immigration system.

The poem at the base of our Statue of Liberty provides an open invitation for people to come to a country largely built by immigrants, and we should honor that invitation with pride instead of slamming the door in their face.

Going to the DMV may seem tedious for all of us, but it’s important to remember that we are very lucky to not be going through a worse bureaucratic hassle. 

Let’s hope that, one day, the wait for immigration proceedings will be closer to a DMV wait time than a decade.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Immigration backlogs beyond the border