Author Archives | by Lucas Vasquez

Making a Minnesota lake summer possible for everyone

LUCAS VASQUEZ: Hello everybody, I’m your host Lucas Vasquez from the Minnesota Daily, and welcome back to another episode of In The Know, a podcast dedicated to the University of Minnesota.

Today, we are diving into a staple of our local identity: Minnesota summer lake and swim culture. It’s no secret that as soon as the ice melts, this state undergoes a massive vibe shift. We are, after all, the land of 10,000 lakes. From pontoons and tubing to neighborhood pool hangouts, water is the magnet that pulls Minnesotans together when the heat hits.

But beneath the surface of lake days and sunshine lies a critical conversation about public safety, historical access and a stark reality about who actually gets the chance to learn how to swim—and enjoy some of Minnesota’s quintessential summer activities.

To unpack this, I sat down with local lifeguards at the University of Minnesota, as well as a community aquatic center leader, to explore how water safety is evolving from general knowledge into an intentional push for equity. 

First, I wanted to understand what summer by the water looks like to those who watch it the most. 

I spoke with Andrew DeMare, an assistant aquatic program manager at the Aquatic Center in the University’s Recreation and Wellness Center. DeMare told me about the accessibility of water in a place like Minnesota. 

ANDREW DEMARE: I feel like, especially at least in Minnesota, I would say there’s definitely a lot more opportunity here of, even my work we’ll go out, we have a boat day, so we rent a pontoon and we sit out on the boat and go swimming or go tubing, things like that. And I feel like that’s definitely a lot more normalized here because of people’s access to the water.

VASQUEZ: I also spoke with Zoe Bel, a lifeguard at the Aquatic Center. She has six years of guarding experience under her belt, and she told me about what summer water life looks like for her. 

ZOE BEL: I love going to the lake and being around bodies of water. But since I’ve been a lifeguard for so long, when I go to lakes or something, I can’t relax and just enjoy the pool because I’m always on edge. I’m worried that someone’s going to need help or something like that. Just because we’ve been trained to like, see things. And so it’s just you can see someone splashing out the corner of my eye and I’m like, ‘Oh, my gosh, are they okay?’

VASQUEZ: While water offers leisure and fun for many, the physical risks are immediate and unpredictable. And they can catch even experienced swimmers completely off guard. 

However an even larger crisis is looming over public pools and open water: a systemic inequity of who has access to life-saving water education, and who does not.

To fully understand this gap, I spoke with David Albornoz, the aquatic director for St. Paul. In his 30-year career in water safety, Albornoz said that he’s observed how drowning rates are heavily related to socioeconomic and racial divides.

DAVID ALBORNOZ: I saw right away that there was a massive need for it. Because drowning, being a national epidemic, impacts disproportionately people of color, Black people, immigrant communities, and communities without access to education or swim lessons. 

We drown at the rate of three, four times the same as people that have access to water safety, which is usually white people that have access to swimming lessons or whatnot. 

So that was striking to me. I found a purpose in that. So I built my career around the concept of water safety and drowning prevention and making sure that we serve the audience that is most at need, the audience that is more at risk of drowning, which again, happens to be people of color and immigrant communities. 

VASQUEZ: Driven by this purpose, Albornoz approached St. Paul Mayor Melvin Carter and the city council in 2021 to pioneer a program that would go on to become the first of its kind in Minnesota and even the nation. 

Instead of traditional paid swimming lessons, St. Paul launched what Albornoz calls “priceless swim lessons.” They are completely free. 

But Albornoz realized that simply making a program free wasn’t enough to solve the core issue of swimming skill inequity in the Twin Cities. If he were to simply open registration online, the slots for free swim lessons could be instantly filled by families who could comfortably afford to pay for lessons. 

To fix this, Albornoz built a system called TER, which stands for Targeted Equity Recruitment.

ALBORNOZ: So what we did is that we designed a system which is called TER, Targeted Equity Recruitment, that allows me to save in any class, if I have 10 kids in a class, five of those kids have to come from these communities. So it takes more work. Because we cannot just open the classes online and people go and register. 

Because what that does, again, is prevent the people that is drowning are folks that don’t go online. So you have to reach into the communities. You have to work directly with them and make sure they get those spaces in the class. I’m really proud of that work. I really think that’s my life purpose. 

VASQUEZ: When you look at the numbers, private programs like Goldfish Swim School run about $30 per class, which quickly adds up to over $120 a month. Meanwhile, a class at a local community pool or the YMCA generally hovers around $20. By dropping those costs or providing classes completely free for youth through city parks, you’re making sure that safety isn’t just a luxury for families who can afford it.

By working to remove the financial barrier to swim lessons by actively reaching out to underserved groups, Albornoz’ program has broken traditional swim education models. 

He also applies this same equity-focused approach to building out his staff, ensuring the lifeguards on the stands actually reflect the community they’re helping to protect.

ALBORNOZ: If you look around, all these kids in the pool are kids that I have trained. So you’re going to find kids that are not traditionally what lifeguards look like. Usually lifeguards are white folks from swim teams. Nope. We have people from all ethnicities being lifeguards because we recruit them and we teach them how to be lifeguards. 

So now you got the lifeguards, you got the swim team that always opens up. We have the free Sundays in which people swim for free so people get used to water. 

Systemically, certain groups of people have been prevented from access to the water. And what we’re trying to do is break in those barriers.

VASQUEZ: Breaking these barriers requires shifting our collective mindset around public spending. Albornoz argues that providing free water education isn’t a drain on city resources—instead, it’s a massive long-term investment. 

ALBORNOZ: The biggest barrier you would think is money. It’s not. It’s political will. You’re able to convince the leaders. And understand the difference between saying, ‘Well, why would we give away free swim lessons?’

Keep in mind that one drowning on average to the city, besides the deep pain to the community, we’re talking of millions of dollars. So if you give away free swim lessons, you’re really saving money. You’re not losing money. You’re saving money. By making sure that your community is prepared to avoid death by drowning.

VASQUEZ: And while city-level equity recruitment programs are actively reshaping future swimmers and lifeguards, the day-to-day realities of staying safe in the water still depend on individual behaviors and understanding of water safety rules.

DeMare pointed out that even at the pool, strict codes dictate safety behind the scenes.

DEMARE: So there are specific state codes that are in effect that basically say, ‘Oh, if a pool has a certain depth’ or I think it’s square footage is the main thing, then that really delegates how many lifeguards you can have on duty.

VASQUEZ: But when you move from a regulated pool to an unorganized, minimally lifeguarded lake day, built-in safety measures can disappear. DeMare explained that dangerous behavior often gets masked as innocent summer fun.

DEMARE: Keeping in mind of what you’re doing, especially if you’re at the pool or at a lake over the summer, things may seem like, ‘Oh, hey, we’re just kind of fooling around, doing whatever.’

One of the big things is people holding their breath and having contests with that, or just other things that you, as a swimmer may not think off the top of the head, ‘Oh, we’re just having fun, whatever. I’m a good swimmer, nothing will happen to me and I’m okay.’

But I mean, there have been numerous stories, accounts, whatever, whatever of people having a swimming background and knowing how to swim, but still things happening. 

VASQUEZ: This type of unsafe behavior is the exact type of thing swim lessons can teach kids to avoid. Bel said she’s witnessed this phenomenon firsthand. She recalled a critical rescue that perfectly illustrated how quickly a situation can turn dangerous.

BEL: I wasn’t on stand, but my co-worker was and someone was with her group of friends and they decided to go in the deep end. Her friends could swim, but she couldn’t. But she was trying to keep up with them, and she just got in the deep end and then she was trying to swim and she couldn’t. And so my co-worker had to get in and save her. 

Luckily, she was fine. She just had some water in her lungs. But because we acted quick enough that it was okay. But because of that, I had to push for my company to get ropes for the deep end because we had rope, and then it was obviously in Texas, things decay in the sun and so we had to get new rope. 

But it was definitely a scary situation for the family to be in because all of a sudden their kid wasn’t next to them and all of the sudden we’re pulling her out of the water.

VASQUEZ: Bel noted that people frequently rely on the wrong things to keep themselves afloat in these moments, confusing pool toys with actual safety gear.

BEL: Actually a couple weeks ago I was at a lake and this kid was playing on an inner tube away from the actual swimming area of the lake. And his tube flipped over and I was almost up and ready to go. Because you know, you can be in an inner tube and then I don’t know if you can swim.

That’s why a lot of pool places won’t allow blow up pool toys in deeper ends because some people will just use the pool toys as life jackets. Even though nothing substitutes a life jacket other than a life jacket.

VASQUEZ: The data heavily supports a focus on foundational safety gear and education. Just this past Fourth of July weekend, Minnesota had four drowning cases. Albornoz pointed out that none of those tragedies occurred at facilities with active lifeguards or proper life jacket usage, proving that the core pillars of water safety are literally the difference between life and death.

Fortunately, the push for accessible water education is spreading across the state. Albornoz noted to me about the intention of replicating his equity-focused swim education model through partnerships at places like the University of Minnesota’s Aquatic Center.

And for those looking to get into the water, no matter your age, DeMare emphasized that the university offers ways to build those skills right here on campus.

DEMARE: We also have private lessons. So even if you’re a college age student and adult, you can still have that experience to learn how to be in the water and get that exposure to the water even if you didn’t as a younger child. So you can still be in the water and have fun like everyone else.

VASQUEZ: Ultimately, safety around summer culture in Minnesota shouldn’t be a privilege reserved for a select few, nor should the water safety knowledge that comes with it. 

On top of this, learning to swim might seem like a small detail for some, but it can offer people more opportunities for exercise, fun, socializing, and even opportunities for employment. When around the water this summer, stay safe, informed and take advantage of the amazing resources the Twin Cities have to offer. 

Thank you for listening. This episode was written by Lucas Vasquez and produced by Grace Aigner. If you would like to share your opinion on the topics discussed today, you can email us at podcasting@mndaily.com. 

Thank you again for tuning in. My name is Lucas Vasquez, and this has been In The Know.

The post Making a Minnesota lake summer possible for everyone appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Making a Minnesota lake summer possible for everyone

Making a Minnesota lake summer possible for everyone

LUCAS VASQUEZ: Hello everybody, I’m your host Lucas Vasquez from the Minnesota Daily, and welcome back to another episode of In The Know, a podcast dedicated to the University of Minnesota.

Today, we are diving into a staple of our local identity: Minnesota summer lake and swim culture. It’s no secret that as soon as the ice melts, this state undergoes a massive vibe shift. We are, after all, the land of 10,000 lakes. From pontoons and tubing to neighborhood pool hangouts, water is the magnet that pulls Minnesotans together when the heat hits.

But beneath the surface of lake days and sunshine lies a critical conversation about public safety, historical access and a stark reality about who actually gets the chance to learn how to swim—and enjoy some of Minnesota’s quintessential summer activities.

To unpack this, I sat down with local lifeguards at the University of Minnesota, as well as a community aquatic center leader, to explore how water safety is evolving from general knowledge into an intentional push for equity. 

First, I wanted to understand what summer by the water looks like to those who watch it the most. 

I spoke with Andrew DeMare, an assistant aquatic program manager at the Aquatic Center in the University’s Recreation and Wellness Center. DeMare told me about the accessibility of water in a place like Minnesota. 

ANDREW DEMARE: I feel like, especially at least in Minnesota, I would say there’s definitely a lot more opportunity here of, even my work we’ll go out, we have a boat day, so we rent a pontoon and we sit out on the boat and go swimming or go tubing, things like that. And I feel like that’s definitely a lot more normalized here because of people’s access to the water.

VASQUEZ: I also spoke with Zoe Bel, a lifeguard at the Aquatic Center. She has six years of guarding experience under her belt, and she told me about what summer water life looks like for her. 

ZOE BEL: I love going to the lake and being around bodies of water. But since I’ve been a lifeguard for so long, when I go to lakes or something, I can’t relax and just enjoy the pool because I’m always on edge. I’m worried that someone’s going to need help or something like that. Just because we’ve been trained to like, see things. And so it’s just you can see someone splashing out the corner of my eye and I’m like, ‘Oh, my gosh, are they okay?’

VASQUEZ: While water offers leisure and fun for many, the physical risks are immediate and unpredictable. And they can catch even experienced swimmers completely off guard. 

However an even larger crisis is looming over public pools and open water: a systemic inequity of who has access to life-saving water education, and who does not.

To fully understand this gap, I spoke with David Albornoz, the aquatic director for St. Paul. In his 30-year career in water safety, Albornoz said that he’s observed how drowning rates are heavily related to socioeconomic and racial divides.

DAVID ALBORNOZ: I saw right away that there was a massive need for it. Because drowning, being a national epidemic, impacts disproportionately people of color, Black people, immigrant communities, and communities without access to education or swim lessons. 

We drown at the rate of three, four times the same as people that have access to water safety, which is usually white people that have access to swimming lessons or whatnot. 

So that was striking to me. I found a purpose in that. So I built my career around the concept of water safety and drowning prevention and making sure that we serve the audience that is most at need, the audience that is more at risk of drowning, which again, happens to be people of color and immigrant communities. 

VASQUEZ: Driven by this purpose, Albornoz approached St. Paul Mayor Melvin Carter and the city council in 2021 to pioneer a program that would go on to become the first of its kind in Minnesota and even the nation. 

Instead of traditional paid swimming lessons, St. Paul launched what Albornoz calls “priceless swim lessons.” They are completely free. 

But Albornoz realized that simply making a program free wasn’t enough to solve the core issue of swimming skill inequity in the Twin Cities. If he were to simply open registration online, the slots for free swim lessons could be instantly filled by families who could comfortably afford to pay for lessons. 

To fix this, Albornoz built a system called TER, which stands for Targeted Equity Recruitment.

ALBORNOZ: So what we did is that we designed a system which is called TER, Targeted Equity Recruitment, that allows me to save in any class, if I have 10 kids in a class, five of those kids have to come from these communities. So it takes more work. Because we cannot just open the classes online and people go and register. 

Because what that does, again, is prevent the people that is drowning are folks that don’t go online. So you have to reach into the communities. You have to work directly with them and make sure they get those spaces in the class. I’m really proud of that work. I really think that’s my life purpose. 

VASQUEZ: When you look at the numbers, private programs like Goldfish Swim School run about $30 per class, which quickly adds up to over $120 a month. Meanwhile, a class at a local community pool or the YMCA generally hovers around $20. By dropping those costs or providing classes completely free for youth through city parks, you’re making sure that safety isn’t just a luxury for families who can afford it.

By working to remove the financial barrier to swim lessons by actively reaching out to underserved groups, Albornoz’ program has broken traditional swim education models. 

He also applies this same equity-focused approach to building out his staff, ensuring the lifeguards on the stands actually reflect the community they’re helping to protect.

ALBORNOZ: If you look around, all these kids in the pool are kids that I have trained. So you’re going to find kids that are not traditionally what lifeguards look like. Usually lifeguards are white folks from swim teams. Nope. We have people from all ethnicities being lifeguards because we recruit them and we teach them how to be lifeguards. 

So now you got the lifeguards, you got the swim team that always opens up. We have the free Sundays in which people swim for free so people get used to water. 

Systemically, certain groups of people have been prevented from access to the water. And what we’re trying to do is break in those barriers.

VASQUEZ: Breaking these barriers requires shifting our collective mindset around public spending. Albornoz argues that providing free water education isn’t a drain on city resources—instead, it’s a massive long-term investment. 

ALBORNOZ: The biggest barrier you would think is money. It’s not. It’s political will. You’re able to convince the leaders. And understand the difference between saying, ‘Well, why would we give away free swim lessons?’

Keep in mind that one drowning on average to the city, besides the deep pain to the community, we’re talking of millions of dollars. So if you give away free swim lessons, you’re really saving money. You’re not losing money. You’re saving money. By making sure that your community is prepared to avoid death by drowning.

VASQUEZ: And while city-level equity recruitment programs are actively reshaping future swimmers and lifeguards, the day-to-day realities of staying safe in the water still depend on individual behaviors and understanding of water safety rules.

DeMare pointed out that even at the pool, strict codes dictate safety behind the scenes.

DEMARE: So there are specific state codes that are in effect that basically say, ‘Oh, if a pool has a certain depth’ or I think it’s square footage is the main thing, then that really delegates how many lifeguards you can have on duty.

VASQUEZ: But when you move from a regulated pool to an unorganized, minimally lifeguarded lake day, built-in safety measures can disappear. DeMare explained that dangerous behavior often gets masked as innocent summer fun.

DEMARE: Keeping in mind of what you’re doing, especially if you’re at the pool or at a lake over the summer, things may seem like, ‘Oh, hey, we’re just kind of fooling around, doing whatever.’

One of the big things is people holding their breath and having contests with that, or just other things that you, as a swimmer may not think off the top of the head, ‘Oh, we’re just having fun, whatever. I’m a good swimmer, nothing will happen to me and I’m okay.’

But I mean, there have been numerous stories, accounts, whatever, whatever of people having a swimming background and knowing how to swim, but still things happening. 

VASQUEZ: This type of unsafe behavior is the exact type of thing swim lessons can teach kids to avoid. Bel said she’s witnessed this phenomenon firsthand. She recalled a critical rescue that perfectly illustrated how quickly a situation can turn dangerous.

BEL: I wasn’t on stand, but my co-worker was and someone was with her group of friends and they decided to go in the deep end. Her friends could swim, but she couldn’t. But she was trying to keep up with them, and she just got in the deep end and then she was trying to swim and she couldn’t. And so my co-worker had to get in and save her. 

Luckily, she was fine. She just had some water in her lungs. But because we acted quick enough that it was okay. But because of that, I had to push for my company to get ropes for the deep end because we had rope, and then it was obviously in Texas, things decay in the sun and so we had to get new rope. 

But it was definitely a scary situation for the family to be in because all of a sudden their kid wasn’t next to them and all of the sudden we’re pulling her out of the water.

VASQUEZ: Bel noted that people frequently rely on the wrong things to keep themselves afloat in these moments, confusing pool toys with actual safety gear.

BEL: Actually a couple weeks ago I was at a lake and this kid was playing on an inner tube away from the actual swimming area of the lake. And his tube flipped over and I was almost up and ready to go. Because you know, you can be in an inner tube and then I don’t know if you can swim.

That’s why a lot of pool places won’t allow blow up pool toys in deeper ends because some people will just use the pool toys as life jackets. Even though nothing substitutes a life jacket other than a life jacket.

VASQUEZ: The data heavily supports a focus on foundational safety gear and education. Just this past Fourth of July weekend, Minnesota had four drowning cases. Albornoz pointed out that none of those tragedies occurred at facilities with active lifeguards or proper life jacket usage, proving that the core pillars of water safety are literally the difference between life and death.

Fortunately, the push for accessible water education is spreading across the state. Albornoz noted to me about the intention of replicating his equity-focused swim education model through partnerships at places like the University of Minnesota’s Aquatic Center.

And for those looking to get into the water, no matter your age, DeMare emphasized that the university offers ways to build those skills right here on campus.

DEMARE: We also have private lessons. So even if you’re a college age student and adult, you can still have that experience to learn how to be in the water and get that exposure to the water even if you didn’t as a younger child. So you can still be in the water and have fun like everyone else.

VASQUEZ: Ultimately, safety around summer culture in Minnesota shouldn’t be a privilege reserved for a select few, nor should the water safety knowledge that comes with it. 

On top of this, learning to swim might seem like a small detail for some, but it can offer people more opportunities for exercise, fun, socializing, and even opportunities for employment. When around the water this summer, stay safe, informed and take advantage of the amazing resources the Twin Cities have to offer. 

Thank you for listening. This episode was written by Lucas Vasquez and produced by Grace Aigner. If you would like to share your opinion on the topics discussed today, you can email us at podcasting@mndaily.com. 

Thank you again for tuning in. My name is Lucas Vasquez, and this has been In The Know.

The post Making a Minnesota lake summer possible for everyone appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Making a Minnesota lake summer possible for everyone

Doomscrolling and the Gen Z brain

LUCAS VASQUEZ: Hello everybody, I’m your host Lucas Vasquez from the Minnesota Daily, and welcome back to another episode of In The Know, a podcast dedicated to the University of Minnesota.

Today, we are diving into the world of social media, specifically its emphasis on short-form content. As someone who spends a good amount of time on Instagram Reels, I began to think about how Gen Z is consuming more media daily than ever seen before. Then I began to wonder, what does routine consumption of rapid-fire content do to our brains? How does it change the way we learn, form ideas and think critically? 

To try and answer this question, I sat down with a student and researchers at the university to understand how short-form media is reshaping the modern mind. First, I learned about why we scroll as much as we do.

MARGUERITE OHRTMAN: We forget that it’s like a quick little dopamine hit. So every time you see a little video that 10, 15 seconds, get a quick little message, you go to the next one before you even swipe the next one. It takes you to the next one so you don’t have to make the decision.

VASQUEZ: That’s Marguerite Ohrtman, she is the University’s director of the School of Counseling, and a professor of educational psychology. What she’s describing is an intentional psychological design. The platforms we use aren’t neutral— they are engineered to keep us hooked.

This phenomenon is so prevalent that the National Library of Medicine has given it the name “dopamine-scrolling.” I spoke with Angelica Pazurek, a professor in the College of Education and Human Development. She elaborated on how “dopamine-scrolling” becomes a habit. 

ANGELICA PAZUREK: We’re constantly scrolling, because the social media and the apps and the technology devices, both hardware and software that we use, are designed to intentionally be sort of addicting to keep us scrolling. You know, that constant dopamine hit. So the designers, the technology companies, the developers, they know that about humans. They want you coming back to their app, their platform, their device.

VASQUEZ: And it isn’t just that these platforms are addictive, they are actively changing our brain’s mechanisms for how we process information. When we consume media in these rapid bursts, it can lead to what educational psychologists call “cognitive overload.” Essentially, the sheer volume of rapid-fire content crowds our working memory, making it incredibly difficult to actually retain what we are seeing.

To break down exactly what happens to our brains during this process, I spoke with Martin Van Boekel, a professor in the University’s Department of Educational Psychology. They explained that the ease of scrolling actually tricks us into a false sense of security about what we are learning. 

MARTIN VAN BOEKEL: Learning happens best when we struggle with the information a little bit. It’s called desirable difficulty. It’s like the way I like to frame it when I’m talking about it in my classes. And when we struggle a little bit, not so hard that we can’t possibly do it because then we’re not learning, we’re just frustrated. When we have this level of desirability, we’re going to form those connections in these really powerful ways. Now, when information is presented to us in a way that’s super digestible and interesting, we see it as, there’s again, air quotes there, we see it as, like, interesting because it’s tailored to our interest. So of course we see it as interesting in these short form videos. The ease at which we process that information— it may feel like we’re learning, just like at that direct lecture class where it sounds like, ‘Oh, yeah, I knew this all along,’ right? 

It feels it’s so easily just sort of heard and that we get overconfident that we learned this information. But then, when the reality is like, two days later, when I have to go recall that because I didn’t work with it, because I didn’t try to make those connections and make sense of this, it just felt like it just clicked. It’s kind of hanging around in brain space just like, really difficult to retrieve.

VASQUEZ: The algorithm hands us clips that are both easily digestible and tailored to our interests. As a result, our brains don’t do the heavy lifting required to lock that information into our long-term memory. Van Boekel said that psychologists study this using the “forgetting curve,” which shows that within just 24 hours of passively taking in information without actively reusing it, we lose about 60% of what we consumed.

To see how this plays out in real life, I wanted to hear a student’s perspective. Sawyer Henry is a third-year dual political science and journalism major here at the university. He said that while he’s caught himself in doom-scrolling loops, the content rarely left a lasting impression. 

SAWYER HENRY: Most of the stuff that I think we see when we’re scrolling is so not noteworthy at all. Things that you do remember are like, it’s kind of like a dream. If it makes you feel some kind of intense emotion, then surely you’re gonna remember it maybe the next morning, and then forget about it. But I wouldn’t say I remember everything, especially a lot of it’s just advertisements these days.

VASQUEZ: This lack of information retention is exactly what has sparked the popular rhetoric that Gen Z’s attention spans are ruined, and that our capacity for critical thinking is less than that of past generations. But is that the whole story? Or is Gen Z’s way of thinking simply evolving to match our environment?

When I brought this up to Pazurek, she pushed back against the moral panic. 

PAZUREK: I’m more interested in pushing back against that rhetoric to say that there are positive implications about the ways that young people are using, engaging with technology today. There’s lots of research to support that. So others like me in my field of learning science and educational technology or learning technologies make an important distinction between critical thinking and critical theorizing or critical engagement. 

VASQUEZ: She said it’s important to understand that from a learning science perspective, there is a difference between these two concepts.

PAZUREK: So critical thinking as an educational theory refers to this intellectually disciplined process of actively conceptualizing, applying, analyzing, synthesizing and evaluating information. And it helps us make more informed evidence-based decisions so we can learn how to do that, and we can learn how to do that more effectively through resources. Whether those resources be online or offline resources. 

We tend to spend a lot of time online today. That’s just the nature of our world, especially in the U.S. you know, I’m an American, so I’ll talk about U.S. context and U.S. culture. But it’s really important to understand that there’s potential and possibilities to learn to be a better critical thinker. 

And also it’s important to think about that as being limited because of the way that critical thinking has been framed as kind of an individual process. Because it tends to be very self referential, like I’m a critical thinker, I’m critically thinking about, you know, fill in the blank. 

But when we frame that as a personal attribute and as kind of a neutral tool of thinking, that way we can be objective in our critical thinking, that obscures lots of things. Because our critical thinking, our thinking in general, our understanding and our learning is all influenced by more than just what happens in our mind. 

VASQUEZ: She argued that it’s important to take into consideration the social factors that influence our thinking.

PAZUREK: So things like, you know, the social, the cultural, the historical and the political conditions under which we think, where we’re thinking, how we’re thinking and what we’re thinking about. So now I’ll move that a little bit further along that kind of continuum to think about critical engagement or critical theorizing. And that’s very different than critical thinking. 

So I encourage students in my classes to learn how to be critical thinkers, but also to be critical theorists, to think more critically about those social, historical, political influences on what we do, how we see things, our assumptions, our norms, our values, our behaviors, all of those things. So, critical engagement and critical theorizing is more than just critical thinking and it involves sort of wider structures of power, inequality, ideologies that shape our knowledge and that shape everyday life. 

So critical theory refers to a way of doing philosophically that involves kind of a critique of culture and it offers critiques of traditional views and assumptions, including views and assumptions about critical thinking, how that’s a self referential process and how it really sort of only happens in the mind. So we’re situated in society, in cultures. All of those things need to be included when we’re talking about critical thinking or critical engagement.

VASQUEZ: Pazurek’s distinction between critical thinking versus critical theorizing highlights something important: Gen Z isn’t experiencing a simple decline in cognitive ability. Instead, our learning styles are actively adapting to the cultural landscape around us. Rather than framing technology as purely detrimental, Pazurek’s research points toward how modern technology offers us unique competencies. 

Henry noted a similar sentiment. He emphasized that being immersed in a heavy digital culture doesn’t compromise a student’s individual critical thought. In fact, it often forces students to become hyper-aware of how corporate and algorithmic spaces try to filter their reality.

HENRY: I do try to be very aware of the way I consume media and very critical of the way I interpret it. I think that more people need to be taught how to recognize fallacies and rhetoric in a more nuanced way. But I definitely do think I’m more aware of it because, especially you see this in the poli-sci department, you catch a lot of people forming their thoughts and opinions off of what they see on social media, and then that shapes the way that they think a lot. 

And I, as someone who’s very critical of that, and as someone who promotes the idea of just thinking with nuance, just basic nuance, I feel like I try and stray away from that as much as I can. And I do try and be aware of the way that I interact with things online does impact my algorithm.

VASQUEZ: This awareness is vital because, as Van Boekel notes, when we become too passive in our consumption of media, we open ourselves up to algorithmic traps that are specifically constructed to target us.

VAN BOEKEL: It may give us the sense that we’re processing this information really, really clearly and we’re making all these connections, but we’re probably not making them as strong. But that’s just the hypothesis, because there’s something magic in these algorithms. Those people that develop these things are hiring cognitive psychologists, social psychologists to trap us. So they know. 

VASQUEZ: Beyond platforms’ engineered algorithms, the content we consume is heavily weighted by emotional hooks. Van Boekel explained how this constant stream of emotionally charged material directly interacts with our long-term memory. This process creates fragmented, but lasting ideas.

VAN BOEKEL: We may not be getting the full picture when we’re doomscrolling because we’re just looking at the headlines and just like getting things that get us worked up. But like we’re going to remember those things partially and that’s probably part of the problem is that we don’t get the full story. 

But there’s something really powerful in those negative, particularly negatively charged things in as far as memory goes. Like they stick. They stick . And they can be pulled up every time we get emotionally negatively charged because like those conditions align and that sparks.

VASQUEZ: This discussion can also be observed in the classroom. Because of the anxiety surrounding this generational technological shift and the rise of artificial intelligence, academia has found itself at a crossroads. Many educators have chosen a reactive path. Some are making strict bans on new digital media and pushing for a return to traditional, analog teaching methods.

But when I presented this concept to Ohrtman, she argued that a total prohibition is not only ineffective but entirely unrealistic in a world where technology is the new norm. Ohrtman shared that trying to separate students from the digital world usually results in the exact opposite of its intended effect. 

OHRTMAN: This may not be a positive opinion with my fellow educators, but I think it’s, I always say the same thing: it’s moderation. As educators, we have to work with it, not against it. Whether it’s AI, whether it’s, oh my God, the list could go on. But I think it’s like teaching yourself, like, how do I use it in a way, how to become a critical thinker? 

Like the DARE program didn’t work in schools because of like, “no drugs.” If you say no, people are going to want it more. So it’s like with technology, it’s not going away. It’s going to be here. So why don’t we use it as a tool to help us?

VASQUEZ: Ohrtman practices what she preaches. She actively structures her curriculum around digital interaction rather than trying to impose a more traditional, paper-only approach.

OHRTMAN: This past summer I started a May term class and I require my students to use technology in every presentation. If you’re gonna work with children, adolescents, you need to have technology, have videos. You need to get them engaged, move around. You can’t just sit up and talk at a PowerPoint anymore. That’s not how they learn. That’s not what they know. 

VASQUEZ: Pazurek echoed this philosophy, noting that closing the classroom door to digital spaces doesn’t protect students, it actually compromises their professional futures.

PAZUREK: Forcing students to do anything or not do anything is ill advised. I also believe that it’s not possible to learn about the practical uses of technology, regardless of what that technology is, without actually authentically using the technology. 

So if we close the door to social media and learning and how it can be used in higher ed, or AI and how it can be used for learning in higher ed, if we’re closing the door to that, it really limits the educational opportunity. 

Because if we ban things in the classroom, when students leave our classroom or they graduate from our academic programs, how will they make informed, ethical decisions about whether or not to use AI or any other technology throughout their career? They need to be empowered to use their agency to make informed decisions, to be informed consumers and ethical producers of new media in all its forms.

VASQUEZ: Ultimately, this shift forces us to reexamine the foundational goals of education itself. Van Boekel left me with a vital critique, asking us to look past the simple efficiency and examine the motives of both corporate tech platforms and modern educational design.

VAN BOEKEL: People stay hooked and interested on social media and short form videos. So like let’s do that, let’s bring more, more computers, like more short form video into the classroom. We’re trying to make these crossovers and are we like, I mean this is why this is really important. It’s like how, how much is learning, how much is lost? And it all comes down to capitalism and education. Can we commodify these things? And that’s a dangerous place. 

Also from my perspective, is the goal of education and learning in general to be an efficient system? I would argue, and I think I do this in all my classes, that no, I don’t think learning is an efficient process and I think efforts to make it more efficient, to a degree, is important. We want to support everyone. But like what’s the end point of efficiency in learning and in education? It’s so that we can be more productive earners in this rat race of capitalism. And it’s like, well, is that the goal? 

And like that’s a, in my mind, gross goal to be working towards. It’s problematic for the humans, it’s problematic for the environment, it’s problematic for a lot of our health, all of these different things. But I think those are, those are the questions we need to come into learning. How are all these things interconnected so that we can better understand why do we care? 

Because we know why the social media companies care. We know why they invest in the algorithms. It’s because they make billions of dollars. Why would a teacher care or an educational researcher care about porting this over? Like, what are the value gains? What are the value losses in those spaces? So, like, I think as we study these things, we need to come from an ultra-critical perspective to make sure we’re doing things carefully and for the right reasons.

VASQUEZ: Van Boekel’s critique strikes at the heart of the issue. When we look past the surface of our screens, we find that the conversation surrounding short-form media isn’t just about attention spans or classroom politics. It’s about recognizing the wider structures that dictate how information is built and distributed.

What makes Gen Z’s relationship with social media unique is that they are the first generation that has truly never had the option to ignore the digital world. As Ohrtman highlighted during our conversation, past generations had the ability to opt out. If a college student in the 1990s or early 2000s wanted to avoid the noise of the world, they could choose not to pick up a newspaper or switch off the news channel on a television set. 

Today, that barrier is gone. The digital landscape is immersive and inescapable. The moment we check our phones, headlines, videos, articles and highly polarizing viewpoints are aggressively pushed onto our fields of view. 

The challenges facing modern education, and this generation as a whole, isn’t solely about shortening or lengthening attention spans, nor is it about trying to slow down the use of technology in our daily lives. It ultimately comes down to standard digital literacy. The challenge is to move past passive, repetitive consumption and instead, to intentionally use the muscle we call our brain and critically evaluate and critique the information in front of us.

The ultimate potential of technology today depends entirely on how we choose to use it. Each of us has the ability to make conscious choices about our habits. We could allow the algorithm to select our content and shape our opinions for us, or we can actively seek out diverse ideas to come to more complete conclusions and, in doing so, hopefully make all of us better-informed people. 

Thank you for listening. This episode was written by Lucas Vasquez and produced by Grace Aigner. If you would like to share your opinion on the topics discussed today, you can email us at podcasting@mndaily.com. 

Thank you again for tuning in. My name is Lucas Vasquez and this has been In The Know.

The post Doomscrolling and the Gen Z brain appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Doomscrolling and the Gen Z brain

University voices weigh benefits and risks of AI in art

LUCAS VASQUEZ: Hello everybody, I’m your host Lucas Vasquez from the Minnesota Daily, and welcome back to another episode of In The Know, a podcast dedicated to the University of Minnesota.

This week on In The Know, we are looking once more at generative AI. The newest development that has greatly changed all of our lives. But we won’t be looking at what was spoken about on last week’s episode with Madina Elmi, with its uses in engineering or computer science, nor its uses in writing your emails, or your papers, or when you turn to it for some AI therapy. Instead, we will be looking at its uses, if there are any, in art and creative spaces, and how the University community feels about it.

I spoke to a wide variety of students and professionals on the matter and got mixed reviews. I started my search for an answer by speaking to John De Haan, an associate professor of voice, who has been at the university for over 20 years and is an internationally acclaimed opera singer. He told me that while AI is an excellent tool to aid in research, he is skeptical of its use for mimicking human voice. 

JOHN DE HAAN: The tenor in me will say that the human voice is not something that is in grave danger of being replaced by AI. Because it comes out of our, you know, our bodies, right. I’ll tell you there, there are things like if we, if we talk about going back in time, I have sung a lot of Bel Canto music. 

This is music from the early-ish 19th century, mostly Italian music and the performance practices of that time period in a, in a lot of ways is, is is passed down from, from generation to generation. I don’t know that, you know, things that I tell them, you’ve gotta do this, you’ve gotta start that trill on the above. 

You’ve gotta do this. You, you, the, the vibrato always has to be constant and, and I don’t know that I ever read any of that in a book. I think that that’s things that my coaches and my voice teacher told me, and then I’m passing this on to my people. Right? 

How does something as, as amorphous as that get into an AI program? So they might do a beautiful job of a, of a tenor singing this beautiful Bel Canto piece, but in terms of making it historically correct is it possible that AI would have that type of information? 

VASQUEZ: So it’s clear that from a vocal perspective at least AI still has some work to do, but what about the visual side? For that, I spoke to Marianna Arndt, a freelance digital artist who specializes in character design. She commented on her frustrations with generative AI in her field and how it is impacting the security of her work and of those around her.

MARIANNA ARDNT: I would say my first and foremost initial thoughts are, I would say I am probably in the same field as a lot of current artists right now, a lot of digital artists, but also probably traditional artists too, of not being very fond of AI. 

It’s been a huge thing of like, it is currently where it’s at, not being welcomed in the artistic space because it is a huge infringement of like intellectual property rights, but also like labor theft.

And it’s been used to basically kind of like, shortchange a lot of like very talented and passionate artists who have spent their whole lives working on their skills, you know, developing their style, their technique, and then having their work scraped off the internet and used in a bot that basically spits out something that they could have created, but with like slightly different filters and way more flaws that like most, most human artists would never in their lives make.

VASQUEZ: Arndt told me about how AI is shaping the way companies are viewing the animating process. As companies are always looking to make their processes faster, easier and cheaper, many turn to using AI. This results in the quality of animation decreasing due to AI failings. 

ARDNT: One of the number one ways to do that is to just cut people out of the process entirely. So, some companies what they’re doing is they’re basically having AI design characters for them. And they’re using that, which is also, you know, another big problem like I mentioned, AI makes a lot of mistakes because it’s not perfect and it’s not able to think critically in the same way that a human can.

That’s been one of the biggest tells of like, kind of being able to spot AI art and AI works is when you think about something where it’s like, well, would I make this mistake logically? A lot of the time AI makes those simple mistakes because it, you know, is not able to self-reflect. It’s not able to look at a piece of work and then go, how could I fix this?

Because it doesn’t understand what’s wrong in the first place. So it’s been a thing where lots of studios, they will basically hire a prompter who can prompt a bunch of like character designs or background designs, stuff like that. And then they cut that whole step out of the process entirely. 

They don’t have to have a team designing any sort of backgrounds for this project that they’re making. They don’t have to hire a bunch of character designers. They don’t have to spend weeks debating over how to do this, this and this because they got one guy to type into a search bar, you know, “Generate a princess.”

VASQUEZ: She did, however, tell me of one instance in which she saw an implementation of AI that she thought could be acceptable. 

ARDNT: This was in college we had a guest speaker from a video game development company come in and he was talking about how one of the things that his studio did was they were basically trying to make a huge 3D background in like a jungle setting.

And what they ended up doing was they made all the assets of like leaves, foliage, sticks, trees, dirt, rocks, mud, all that stuff. And they basically gave it to a system that would be able to kind of like randomly place it amongst the background so that they wouldn’t have to worry about populating the background with a bunch of different stuff. 

And they could focus on actually like building a scene that could focus on the points of interest as opposed to all the stuff that’s in the background that takes hours of tedious work of just like placing and scattering all over the place because, you know, you’re not necessarily too worried about stuff that’s gonna be far outside of the player’s range of focus. What you really want is to focus on like what they’ll be directly interacting with. 

And that was honestly, I think that was one of the few instances I’ve seen of like really well done use of AI where it was like it, none of the work was stolen. It was all stuff that the team had already made that was given to the bot. And then, it genuinely did shorten the process and the efficiency of building that background because they basically gave the tedious work to a bot.

VASQUEZ: Moving away from the world of animation, I spoke with John Bent, a TA in master’s level music theory, about AI and music interpretation. He argued that art is about recognition, finding your own human existence in a piece of music. Something that AI can not do.

JOHN BENT: The fact of the matter is, when AI creates a piece of music about, like a subject of human life or something like that it’s an imitation because AI is not a human person. So, I mean, what, in what way does AI express itself artistically? I don’t even think that people who have developed these language models even really know that yet.

I think more research needs to be done because the fact that AI is able to generate music and art is, it raises questions about what the difference really is between human generated art and AI generated art. And as of right now, we can recognize it, but as AI becomes more advanced and it’s able to make its own choices that mimic human choices, so well that we can’t tell. 

VASQUEZ: But not everyone agrees that AI lacks expression. Assistant professor of music education Adrian Davis told me to stop pretending this is new. We’ve been using predictive AI for years.

ADRIAN DAVIS: Predictive AI has been around for the longest. If you have an algorithm, if you have Spotify or Apple Music or YouTube, that’s AI. So we have used AI to our advantage to consume, and now I think perhaps the problems that we are seeing in AI are probably more so associated with generative AI and our ability to control what we’re consuming and what we’re producing and who has the, who has their hand on the control button.

VASQUEZ: He then raised a point of bias that no one else I had interviewed had brought up yet. 

DAVIS: I think maybe, perhaps sort of the hesitation of people using it is more so about who is creating the AI itself because the data sets that are used for AI actually come from HI: human intelligence, so. 

VASQUEZ: I’ve never heard that before. I like that. 

DAVIS: Yeah. AI comes from HI. And so, whoever the humans are that are creating the data sets is what we’re seeing in the AI and in that case, whatever bias, biases that humans have, they show up in the AI. 

VASQUEZ: And so I’m actually a little curious about this. So do biases show up in AI when it comes to things like, as such as art and music and whatnot? Like how, what would that look like?

DAVIS: They could, it just, it could perhaps be based off of whatever the art is or whatever the production is or, or the tools that are utilized in order to create it. I mean, whoever is creating the AI? Who is it? Who are these people? Who are these shadows? 

VASQUEZ: Yeah. 

DAVIS: What does that look like because AI is a subfield of computer science. Who, who are these people? Do they look, are they people that look like me? I identify myself as a, a black, African American male. Are we a part of that conversation? Are we a part of that creation process? In many cases are women, LGBTQ, et cetera, diverse populations, are they a part of the creative process within AI? A lot of research that is showing up now is highly suggesting no, they’re not.

VASQUEZ: What this suggests is that if the data set is biased, the art it generates is biased. You aren’t just stealing a style; you are perpetuating a stereotype.

Finally, I wanted a perspective from outside the art department entirely. I spoke to Juliet Murphy, a third-year majoring in psychology, who also volunteers at Radio K. She spoke to me about her observations on how AI and art can be a matter of ethical concern.

JULIET MURPHY: Considering how AI has been used to not only like I try to mimic that, but like more so the environmental costs that AI has and the way that it disproportionately impacts communities. I’m thinking specifically in the United States but this is true everywhere, obviously. 

It’s kind of antithetical to me to like consider it having a place in art because, I like to, I don’t know, since I like to center humanity in those spaces I think AI is hurting humanity by, you know, decreasing water access, putting air pollution in our communities. 

So I would say that I don’t think it has a place, at least in the art that I like to platform here at the station. If the art we’re making is ultimately harming our communities in some way, I don’t know if that will ever be the fuller solution. 

I think that if like we can create worlds where access to these technologies is improved and people can share creative ideas without it having to come at the detriment of our environments or ourselves.

VASQUEZ: So, does generative AI have a place in art? The answer from our panel seems to be a cautious, but qualified…it depends. And after all of these interviews were said and done, I came to the conclusion that if there’s a thread running through all of this, it might be that the problem isn’t the tool itself, but who controls it, who trains it, and what we ask it to do. And as art is in itself an expression of the human condition, then it is the responsibility of us humans to keep art well human. 

Thank you for listening. This episode was written by Lucas Vasquez and produced by Ceci Heinen. If you would like to share your opinion on AI and art you can email us at podcasting@mndaily.com. 

Thank you again for tuning in. My name is Lucas Vasquez and this has been In The Know. 

The post University voices weigh benefits and risks of AI in art appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on University voices weigh benefits and risks of AI in art

Are voter ID laws solving the wrong problem?

LUCAS VASQUEZ: Hello everybody, I’m your host Lucas Vasquez from the Minnesota Daily, and welcome back to another episode of In The Know, a podcast dedicated to the University of Minnesota. 

Recently, there has been a lot of debate surrounding voter ID and voting regulations and voter safety, especially now with both the primaries and midterm elections on the horizon. This conversation was sparked due to a major reform of these processes, which was proposed with the introduction of a bill from the Trump administration known as the SAVE America Act. 

Today, we will be diving into what voting looks like here in Minnesota and what this new bill could potentially mean for future voters. I spoke with Minnesota’s very own Secretary of State, Steve Simon, to ask him about what our state does to ensure that voting is both accessible and secure. 

STEVE SIMON: So in any election system, Minnesota’s or any other election system, I think when you’re designing it, what any person looks at is trying to get to the perfect blend, if such a thing exists, between access and security. Those are the two features you have to get in balance, you want both, right? 

Access, meaning, let’s not make this thing an obstacle course, let’s make it pretty straightforward and easy to use. Security means let’s make sure that only eligible voters and no one else is taking advantage of all this accessibility. And I think Minnesota over the last 50 years or so has done a really, really good job of getting that blend right. There’s no such thing as perfection. But we’re in that sweet spot of that blend.

VASQUEZ: He gave me some examples of what this blend looks like in practice.

SIMON: Let me give you a couple examples of laws that are on the books right now. So for over 50 years, Minnesota’s been one of the states that allows same-day or election-day voter registration. 

It means what it sounds like, which is that if you have never registered to vote, or maybe you have but you moved, or you had a name change, or for whatever reason you have to update it, you can do that up to and including game day, the election day itself in the polling place. That’s huge. 

I mean that more than maybe anything else in the last 50 years has put us in a good position. So that’s an example of an access law. Another example I would use is something like online voter registration or the ability of any of us who are eligible voters to vote from home. You don’t have to go to a polling place.

VASQUEZ: President Trump has notoriously been very outspoken against mail-in voting, claiming that it is a cause for immense fraud in elections. Simon detailed some of the security measures in place in Minnesota that hold voting both in person and by mail accountable. 

SIMON: On the security front we have all sorts of laws in place that provide integrity and security to our elections. Let me give you one example of that, so voting by mail, once in a while someone will say to me, and I don’t blame them one bit, they’ll say, “Hey, how can this voting by mail thing be secure?” 

You’re talking about hundreds of thousands of ballots, maybe a million or more ballots in a state like Minnesota, just out there floating away, floating out in the mail system. Maybe they’re in a stack in the post office, they’re being stuffed into residential mailboxes by the mail carrier. 

What’s to prevent some mailbox thief from walking around a neighborhood and plucking out one or 10 or a hundred of these things, these blank ballots, and just voting those ballots. The answer is, in Minnesota, when you order that ballot you have to provide not one, but two forms of personal identifying information: both a driver’s license number and a partial social security number. 

Then when you get the ballot, you have to sign the ballot and you have to have a witness sign the ballot, and you have to send it back with the same two personal identifiers that you used when you ordered it. So back to the mailbox thief, how can he possibly be successful? Well, the only way he’ll be successful is if he knows both forms of personal identifying information that the intended voter used when they ordered it, and he forges their signature and he forges their witness’s signature.

Unless all of those things are true, he thinks he’s getting away with something. He’s swiping those out of mailboxes and he’s voting them, but they will be destroyed and never counted. And the intended voter, once they figure out they didn’t get their absentee ballot, they will, of course, be given another ballot.

VASQUEZ: Now that we have an understanding of the voting system and how voting security works in the state of Minnesota, let’s take a look at the debate surrounding voter ID. I spoke with Michael Minta, the chair of the Political Science Department, who weighed in with his expert perspective. 

MICHAEL MINTA: There was this belief that there was a lot of fraud that’s going on that people are showing up to the voting polls they’re not representing who they really are. And so just like you go and you, oh, before when you could cash a check, you use voter ID or something like that, that you could use that type of identification to verify the person that truly is casting their ballot is who you are. 

So there’s been this push, I mean, it’s been a while, 1990s, 2000s, particularly in the southern states to pass these voter ID laws. Obviously the opponents usually on the Democratic side of the aisle have argued that voter ID actually disenfranchises voters that they’re a substantial proportion of the population. I wouldn’t say substantial, but a good portion of the population that they don’t possess any form of photo ID. 

And that it’s difficult for them to get access to get photo ID. So one, having the documents that you need, whether it’s a birth certificate, proof of residence, those types of documents, you know, like when you go to the DMV. You gotta take all of those documents in order to get an ID. 

And so if you don’t have all of those documents, then you can’t get an ID. Not to mention the cost that’s involved with purchasing a photo ID. So going through those extra steps this is what, you know, people who are against photo ID, is that it creates an extra burden and all it does is discourage people from registering to vote.

VASQUEZ: Minta also talked about the economic burden that voter IDs can impose on individuals, which would disproportionately affect people of color, the elderly and people who live in rural areas. 

I asked Simon what his thoughts were on the newly proposed SAVE America Act and what its implications would be for Minnesota voters.

SIMON: The SAVE America Act, which is being debated right now in the U.S. Senate, it already passed the U.S. House. That is a whole different breed of law, that isn’t just a voter ID law. That is a souped up version on steroids that would do something that we’ve never done in this country, which is it would require everybody who wants to vote to provide documentary proof of citizenship. 

Documentary meaning papers, actual papers that show and prove that you’re a U.S. citizen. Now, I totally understand how any of your listeners, or anyone anywhere might hear that and their first reaction would be, well that sounds not unreasonable. I mean, you know, to vote you have to be 18, you have to be a resident of the place where you say you are and you have to be a U.S. citizen. 

So what’s so wrong with asking someone to just show that with a piece of paper? It sounds reasonable on the surface, and I agree it does, but this is an example where the more you look, the less you like. I’ll give you an example. We have in America, 69 million women who have a different last name now than the one that they were born with almost entirely due to marriage. 

So, if those 69 million women all have passports, no problem, because a passport is a document that proves and demonstrates they’re a U.S. citizen. But what do you do with the tens of millions of those who don’t have a passport and who don’t have a special kind of real ID? That only 17% of Minnesotans have, which shows citizenship.

What do you do if you’re in those tens of millions? Here’s what you do. If you’re one of those tens of millions of people in that category, no passport, no other driver’s license that shows citizenship, then you would have to produce two documents, at least a birth certificate and a marriage record of some kind.

Now, there are plenty of people who will be able to do that. They’ll be able to track down their birth certificate. They’ll be able to track down the marriage record, but there are many, many people who won’t be able to, and that’s not just theoretical. 

VASQUEZ: Simon pointed to an incident about 10 or 15 years ago. In which the state of Kansas experimented with exactly this approach on the state level. In other words, they passed the SAVE Act within their own voting system. 

And before a federal judge struck down that law, they actually held an election. And this resulted in 31,000 eligible Kansans being shut out and kept away from the voting process.

SIMON: Now, Minnesota is what, two, two and a half times the size of Kansas. You can do the math. That is an extraordinary number of people who are eligible to vote, many of whom have been voting for years and decades who wouldn’t be able to do it. 

So you, you have to think through, in my view anyway, whether it is worth it and what is the “it?” When I say it is worth it, what is the scope of the problem?

VASQUEZ: The scope of the problem Simon suggests is illegal immigrants, but illegal immigrants might not be as big a problem as we are led to believe. He referenced a research report conducted by a law professor at the University of St. Thomas, who looked to answer the question of how much fraud is truly happening in Minnesota voting.

SIMON: He looked at 10 years worth of Minnesota voting from 2014 through 2023, 10 years. During that 10 year period, 13.4 million votes were cast in Minnesota, OK? So it’s 10 years, 13.4 million votes cast. 

Do you know how many non-citizens he found that had voted? Three.  Now that is three too many. All of us want that number to be zero. Our goal is perfection. We want the number to be zero. But three out of 13.4 million over a decade, that is a microscopic problem. 

And so the question we have to ask ourselves is, in order to catch three people over a decade, is it worth every single election disenfranchising tens of thousands of people to do that? I say, no. And that’s why I think this particular piece of legislation is flawed.

VASQUEZ: Simon also mentioned that of the three unregistered voters, all three were green card holders. So although they weren’t allowed to vote, they were still legal permanent residents. I asked Minta to tell me about some of the arguments surrounding mail-in voting and what it looks like in practice around the U.S..

MINTA: So say like you’re a college student and you live in, you know, your residency, say you’re from, I don’t know, Pennsylvania, but you’re not registered to vote here in Minnesota. You’re still registered to vote in Pennsylvania, so you can request an absentee ballot. 

So you’re registered there, you put a request in, they’ll send you an absentee ballot and you can send it in and it’ll count in Pennsylvania. Matter of fact, our current president is a resident of Florida and he uses absentee ballots in order to vote, so. And then there’s some states that rely totally on mail-in balloting, like the state of Oregon. 

You request your ballot, they send it to you, they have all type of ways that they can certify to make sure that you truly are the person they send it to the address, you get it, you cast your vote, send it back in and then they count it. And so it’s worked in Oregon for quite some time, very little evidence of fraudulent activity. And so, you know, Oregon does it. 

This has become an unfortunately kind of a partisan issue, right? Where, many Republicans have argued that it’s subject to fraud, that people are getting ballots and they’re mailing them in. But again, there’s this concern that Democratic voters will be disadvantaged and Republican voters will be advantaged. 

So it has become, you know, you can talk about the issues of fraud, but again, very, very limited evidence of fraud. States, again, like Oregon have been doing it for many years. Almost all states have been doing it in the form of absentee balloting, so. Donald Trump uses absentee and mail-in ballots, so.

VASQUEZ: Among all of these clashing rhetorics from both sides of the aisle, the question becomes, what are we willing to trade? Because every law has a cost. The question isn’t whether we want secure elections, because we do. The question is whether we’re willing to lock out millions of eligible American citizens, many of whom have been voting for years. 

If this bill were to pass, we could see it in practice as soon as the midterm elections. As the Senate debates this proposed bill, I hope that the legislative professionals who have a lot more resources than a college podcaster does come to the same conclusion I have: that voter fraud, both at the state and national level, is, microscopic at best, and maybe our time and resources are better focused on bigger, more pressing issues. 

Thank you for listening. This episode was written by Lucas Vasquez and produced by Ceci Heinen. If you have any questions, comments, or concerns feel free to send a message to our email inbox at podcasting@mndaily.com. 

My name is Lucas Vasquez, make sure you get out and vote this year, and thank you for listening to In The Know. 

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Are voter ID laws solving the wrong problem?

The long history behind the Fourth Gulf War

LUCAS VASQUEZ: Hello everybody, I’m your host Lucas Vasquez from the Minnesota Daily, and welcome back to another episode of In The Know, a podcast dedicated to the University of Minnesota. 

Over the past few weeks, the world’s attention has turned once again to Iran. A country that has spent decades in the headlines but remains, for many, profoundly misunderstood.

We’re around the end of the third week of what some are calling the Fourth Gulf War. Air strikes. Civilian casualties. Political upheaval. And beneath all of it, a nation with centuries worth of history, carrying the weight of a century of foreign intervention, and a people caught between survival and the hope for something different.

Today, we’re going to try to understand what’s happening, not just through the lens of current events, but through the deep history that got us here. And we’re going to hear from an Iranian student about what it feels like to watch your homeland burn from thousands of miles away. 

To understand the complex political history of Iran, I spoke with an assistant professor of political theory, who specializes in politics and culture of Iran, Arash Davari. He helped me understand where to begin. 

ARASH DAVARI: In my estimation, a good starting point is 1901, when the D’Arcy Concession was written, which was an agreement between the Iranian government and oil financier by the name of William D’Arcy, who was from Britain. 

And the idea here was that the Iranian government at the time, which was a monarchy, the Qajar Dynasty, did not have enough control over Iranian land, did not have centralized power in a sufficient fashion to be able to generate revenue through taxation.

VASQUEZ: He explained to me that Iran is a unique case in the sense that it is one of only five to six non-Western countries that were never formally colonized. This dynamic has led to a development in the country’s international and domestic politics that is unlike other non-Western countries. 

DAVARI: What that meant was that in order to survive in the 19th century when European empires and imperialism were expanding was that they had to inaugurate a series of procedures that were effectively the same as colonization onto themselves. One of those procedures is called defensive development.

But others were less voluntary, by virtue of not having, as I mentioned, enough revenue. So the state not having enough revenue meant that the state started to engage in the granting of concessions to foreign powers. At that point people were starting to get a sense of oil being and becoming a valuable resource, but before you could extract it or access it, you needed to develop the infrastructure. 

And states that didn’t have a ton of revenue coming in, didn’t have the capacity to develop that infrastructure.

So what they would do is they would grant permission to a foreigner, a foreign company, to be able to access the oil when it was drawn out of the land, if the company developed infrastructure. And so Iran basically would enter into, and these, there was precedence for these kinds of concessions.

VASQUEZ: So to clarify, what the D’Arcy Concession did was it granted permission for a span of 60 years for a British company, and by extension, the British government to have access to Iranian national resources. And so this sets the stage for both the history of 20th-century Iran, but also in the context of more contemporary conflicts to become a dispute about oil resources and the global political economy.

DAVARI: So the D’Arcy Concession occurs in 1901. But as much as we think about Iran in terms of the global political economy, geopolitics, we also have to think about domestic movements in Iran that are oriented towards democracy and I’ll use this word deliberately, constitutional rights. 

So another event that occurred, which reflects Iran’s peculiar encounter with Western imperial powers or Western traditions, Western politics, was the Constitutional Revolution of 1905 to 1911. And that was an event where you had a movement within Iran that was trying to adopt and develop a political system that existed, or that was modeled for them in Western states primarily. 

In order to secure and ensure equal rights and provisions, and also to break from prior forms of traditional authority. Constitutional revolution fails in the immediate short term, but it establishes a framework for constitutional monarchy. So we have these two events in the first decade of the 20th century: oil concession, constitutional revolution. And this really sets the stage for what comes to follow.

VASQUEZ: And what followed, as Davari explained to me, was the emergence of a figure known as…

DAVARI: Mohammad Mosaddegh. And Mosaddegh was a trained constitutional lawyer from an aristocratic background that was affiliated with the Qajar monarchy. So he had a kind of stature. He becomes a parliamentarian within the Iranian constitutional system.

VASQUEZ: What’s significant about this is that because of a weakened monarch between 1941 and 1953, there was a twelve-year window where the principles of constitutionalism that were established with the constitutional revolution were given a chance to flourish. This led to the eventual appointment of Mohammad Mosaddegh as the prime minister of Iran. His first priority as prime minister was to nationalize Iran’s oil.

The D’Arcy Concession was annulled in 1933 with the formation of the Anglo-Iranian Oil Company, later British Petroleum, at which point another 60 year deal was established. This led to a number of disputes and complaints at the international level because Mohammad’s aims involved breaking this deal. 

All of this eventually culminated in a CIA-orchestrated coup to overthrow the prime minister to protect foreign oil interests. But it wasn’t all just foreign influence. This event, a key inflection point in Iranian history, was also influenced by some internal Iranian elements and parts of a coalition that felt alienated by Mossadegh.

DAVARI: From 1953 until 1968 you get another inflection point. 53 to 1960, those are those dark years of repression. 1960 is when John F. Kennedy becomes president in the United States, and 1959 is when a revolution happens in Cuba. You also have a revolution happening in China. 

So all of a sudden there’s this concern with peasant-based revolts that people who are peasant classes are going to engage in uprisings and that dominoes are going to fall in the context of the Cold War that work against American interests. And the Americans are already quite invested in maintaining Iran on their side as exemplified by the 1953 coup.

VASQUEZ: This resulted in a tactical shift by the Kennedy administration on how to treat foreign interests.  

DAVARI: In the 1960s, you have the policy championed by Kennedy, of winning over hearts and minds. That if the United States provides welfare to people who might otherwise be inclined in engaging in revolts or revolutions, then they won’t engage in an uprising and the U.S. can maintain its friends and its allies in that context. 

Keep Iran on its side of the ledger in its competition with the Soviet Union. In the Iranian context that results in a set of policies that are known as the Shah and the People’s Revolution or more commonly it’s known as the White Revolution. 

Those policies are announced in 1963, and they involve land reform, which is yet another example of the Iranian state engaging in reforms that in other context, in other colonial or or non-Western context, would’ve been implemented by a colonizing power, which means that people would direct their anger at the colonizing power. In this case, they’re directing it at the state.

VASQUEZ: Alongside all of this in the mid-1970s, the Shah of Iran sought greater autonomy while working to remain aligned with U.S. military interests, working as a key figure in the Nixon Doctrine. The Nixon Doctrine was a policy that delegated the U.S.’s role as a policeman to regional powers. The U.S. benefitted by delegating the task to crushing left-leaning rebellions in the Middle East to a regional power. Iran under the Shah took on this role in exchange for being able to buy U.S. military hardware. 

Resistance against the Shah was anti-imperialist in nature, led by Marxist and Islamist groups who expressed solidarity with Palestinians, Vietnamese, Chinese and Cuban revolutionaries. These opposition forces condemned the Shah for violating human rights. 

They argued that Iranian oil wealth was not benefiting the Iranian people and contended that his policies served American imperial interests across the region. All while any space for dissent or democratic expression was at an all-time low. This eventually culminated in a revolution.

DAVARI: 1978-79 revolution occurs, and it is truly one of the rarest occurrences in human history in the sense that it was a decidedly popular revolution. The estimates are that about 10% of the Iranian population, which numbered around 38 million at the time, about 10% of the population engaged in street protests, we’re talking three to four million people.

The state collapsed rather quickly in the face of these masses of people demonstrating. You also have this peculiar phenomenon of the establishment of this thing called an Islamic Republic, which nobody knew what that phrase quite meant when it was first articulated. And that that bears some mention and some understanding in order to understand the circumstances that we’re in now. 

The Islamic Republic was voted in by a referendum in March of 1979 without much debate. It was voted in by about 98% in favor and 2% opposed. Which means that a whole generation of Iranians, many of whom are still present today, many of whose children are some of the dissidents against the state, they voted for this system. Admittedly, they didn’t know what the system was. 

The more interesting question, I think rather than pointing blame or ascribing responsibility for things, is to think about a revolution as a kind of, uh, experiment with something new at, at least from an analytic perspective. And what an Islamic Republic did was it established a system where you had both republican features, but also you had the maintenance of Islamic authority and rule.

VASQUEZ: Davari then recounted the infamous 1979 hostage crisis and its role in the development of political dynamics in Iran.

DAVARI: You then have the hostage taking, so the taking of the U.S. Embassy, which is a significant moment in terms of U.S. Iranian relations. And with the hostage taking, you have the marginalization of the people who were in the provisional government who had a more moderate or liberal stance with regard to political affairs. 

And so you have a radicalization of the process of the revolutionary process in favor of the Islamic Republican party’s interest, which is organized around the authority of Khomeini. You then have about a year after that, the start of the Iran-Iraq war. So neighboring Iraq decides that Iran is weak and that this is an opportunity for them to invade and take over Iranian oil fields that are on the border with Iraq.

This is done with the support of the Europeans. It’s also done with the support of the Americans. So the narrative from the Iranian perspective is that it was the Iranian nation against the entire world. This war rages for two years. Where at, at which point the Iranians fight back the Iraqi incursion in 1982 and they could stop the war there. And this is another key inflection point in terms of history. 

The Iranians decide to keep going, and so the war goes on for another six years until 1988. So that’s the first Gulf War, if you will. In many ways right now we’re in the fourth Gulf War. So with this first Gulf War, there was a policy by the Americans known as dual containment: supply arms to both sides so they can weaken each other.

VASQUEZ: During this conflict, war mobilization helped those in charge of the government to gain the upper hand in state consolidation. This tactic is speculated to be foreshadowing as to what the objectives for the current war in Iran are, which is to weaken the infrastructure and state apparatus in Iran so that whoever is in power doesn’t pose as much of a threat to American or Israeli interests in the region. 

But regardless, fast forward to the 1990’s and after the rewriting of the Iranian constitution and several other factors, there is a vibrant middle class that is starting to establish itself, which in turn was starting to lead to the organization of political freedom. 

Which led to 1997, when a reformist named Mohammad Khatami won the presidency in a landslide.

DAVARI: Those are the heights of the reform movement. He wins a second term. So there’s, same as the U.S. you have two four-year terms. At every step of the way he makes some advances. There’s a robust civil society that emerges with all kinds of newspapers that open. 

In 2005, the reformists make a mistake, I think, and they put forth three candidates for the presidency who siphon votes away from each other. And you end up in a runoff between Rafsanjani, the guy who was the technocrat in the 1990s, who’s associated with corruption and all kinds of profiteering off of the, the opening up towards capitalist investment.

And another figure, by the name of Ahmadinejad. And Ahmadinejad becomes quite popular. He becomes the president, he wins the election. And this was a surprise moment in Iranian politics because Ahmadinejad came out of nowhere and appealed to populist sentiment. So he’s arguing against the kind of oligarchic rule of Rafsanjani that was his primary opponent. 

But he’s also not making an argument for institutional welfare. Instead, he’s making an argument for removing and breaking down subsidies and putting cash in people’s hands. And this is popular in the moment of, but what does that mean for the state? What does that mean for the economy? 

VASQUEZ: The 2009 election in Iran brought forth The Green Movement, which was hugely significant, and the peaceful protests that followed were repressed, creating a turning point where people no longer believed that reform would fix things. Iranians began to become more revolutionary and people started to call for the fall of the regime. 

DAVARI: 2009 you have Ahmadinejad’s second election and he’s very socially conservative, advancing politically repressive policies more than his predecessor Khatami. So there’s a popular movement amongst the middle classes behind a presidential candidate by the name of Mir Hossein Moussavi, who was the prime minister in the 1980s, who was known for having steered the welfare program.

Interestingly, in those presidential debates, Moussavi does not make an economic argument. All of his arguments are actually about political liberalization and democratization. Perhaps we could say that behind that is creating the political foundations for an economic opening to the west. The numbers come in and the results come in at least two to three days before when they’re expected to arrive, which fuels rumors that they were doctored. 

Ahmadinejad wins 64% of the vote, Moussavi wins 32% of the vote. People had been out in the streets for about a month showing a significant amount of support for Moussavi. So, the understanding is that people’s votes had been stolen, and that becomes the primary chant at first of what is known as The Green Movement.

VASQUEZ: Now, we will fast-forward to the first Trump presidency and its more tense approach to Iran and its politics.

DAVARI: 2015, you have this brief moment in U.S. foreign policy where there seems to be an inclination towards shifting U.S. policy in the region away from primarily supporting Israel and Saudi Arabia and towards a kind of realignment around what’s known as the Shia Crescent, if you will, that Iran has considerable influence in Iraq and in Syria, and that it would be beneficial to the U.S. if it were actually allied with Iran. There’s pushback on this from the Saudis and from Israel. 

The Democrats lose the election in 2016. Trump comes into power in 2017, and one of the first things he does is he tears up the JCPOA, the nuclear deal, and he imposes what is known as maximum pressure sanctions. So going as far as possible in terms of placing economic pressure on Iran with, it’s now come out, the intention of inciting street protests that would destabilize the state.

The period from 2017 onward sees disaffection among greater and greater portions of the Iranian populace with the reformist project, the sense that they had promised that they would be able to deliver things from within the parameters of the state, and they were unable to do so. This is combined with the economic immiseration of the Iranian populace at an increasing rate partly due to the oligarchic class that was established in the 1990s. 

Which had been profiting off of black market economic exchanges that were actually fueled by the sanctions regime. So when sanctions happen, that means that people can’t engage in business ventures that are transparent. So what they do is they engage in under the table kinds of transactions that the members of the Iranian state who are embedded around the Supreme Leader benefited from.

VASQUEZ: This tense political dynamic led to a defining event in the build up of the current conflict, which was the Bazaar protest on December 28, 2025. Merchants in the electronics section of Tehran’s bazaar protested due to the economic frustrations that they had. 

This is a significant event because the bazaar is an ancient economic institution that predates capitalism in Iran and has historically been intertwined with the higher clerical class, providing them with economic support and legitimacy. The bazaar played a key role in the 1979 revolution and has functioned as a shadow-state institution ever since. 

When the bazaar protested on purely economic conditions, the state acknowledged their grievances as legitimate, but ordinary Iranians saw this as a signal: if even the traditionally government-aligned bazaar was willing to protest, perhaps this was the moment for broader action.

DAVARI: So then people start to come out and you have messages broadcast from abroad calling on people to come out en-mass on January 9 to overthrow the state. And one of those messages is broadcast by the son of the formerly deposed King Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, who has named his son after his own father. And that person is Reza Pahlavi who spent most of his life abroad in California and Washington D.C.. 

And he had issued a similar kind of call during the June, 2025 war when Israel had attacked Iran in the midst of nuclear negotiations. He issues another call on January 8, in this case, people come out. And from the reports that I have read, the people who came out, many of them, we still are gathering information, but many of them did not know what kinds of forces they were competing with. They were not trained political activists. 

And so they took the foreign news media that was being broadcast into Iran via satellite at its word. And a lot of those reports said to people that if you go out, we’re going to protect you. And so people took their kids, small children, they took their elderly aunts and parents because they thought that it was going to be safe. 

And they confronted a state that was willing to do anything that it needed to do in order to ensure its own survival, which involved snipers shooting on people from rooftops.

VASQUEZ: During these protests, there are many reports of agent provocateurs. U.S. officials like Former CIA Director and Secretary of State Mike Pompeo tweeted about Mossad agents in the crowd. 

There is also leaked audio of a reformist politician by the name of Ali Shakouri Rad who suggests that the security forces aligned with the hardliners sent agent provocateurs into the crowd, causing vandalism and burning mosques, so as to create an excuse to then attack the crowd. Shakouri Rad and other Reformist politicians were arrested days after this. 

The truth is murky. But what’s clear is this, there is frustration among a significant part of the populace that a number of them came out to protest and many were killed indiscriminately. These things we know.

And this is where I want to pause. Because we’ve been talking a lot about history, about geopolitics, about coups and revolutions and policies. But underneath all of it are actual people. People with families.

I spoke with a University of Minnesota student. They are Iranian, and have deep roots in the country. They have been watching this unfold from thousands of miles away.

ANONYMOUS STUDENT: To be honest. It’s the first time in my life that my country’s been at war directly. I still feel desensitized because I’ve seen what’s going on, what’s been happening the last, you know, two decades obviously, but even more, uh, in the neighboring countries. 

Whether it’s Lebanon, whether it’s Palestine, whether it’s, uh, you know, Syria, any of these countries. Iraq, literally a neighbor. I’ve seen it so much that, you know, there is a form of desensitization.

VASQUEZ: But being desensitized is not the same as not caring. He spoke about how, despite the desensitization that the media in America works to perpetuate, he is working on processing the events that are currently happening.

ANONYMOUS STUDENT: But you know, there is also still that, you know, a sense of like personal connection. I’ve been there so much. I know people there. I know places that like, like I can see a place I got bombed and I’ll be like, “Hey, I know that place.”

You know, that’s, that’s a whole new different feeling. So processing that all is kind of new. And it, it, it, it’s like now for the first time I can really feel what it’s like. Uh, it’s not just like a, “Oh, I feel for you.” But now I can actually, now I really do, like I can actually say I do.

VASQUEZ: He also spoke about the feeling of guilt that he is dealing with when it comes to watching this unfold from afar.

ANONYMOUS STUDENT: It also sucks to experience it from abroad in the sense that like, you feel kind of guilty. You feel like, why am I relaxing at home? In the safety of my, my home when my own people, you know, the roofs above them are collapsing, right? So.

VASQUEZ: We’re around the end of the third week of the war now, and there are thus far no signs of a ceasefire negotiation in place. Davari pointed out a dynamic that is unfolding with the continuation of this war. Davari noted how the ideal of the self-determined right of natural resources is falling apart before our eyes. 

DAVARI: And we are now seeing the right of the people being evoked by some of the people in order to justify foreign intervention. The terms of the debate are such that many Iranians felt that there was no other way to change the state. That the state had effectively lost legitimacy. And they felt that the only way the change could occur would be through foreign intervention.

There are many other civil society activists who are increasingly gaining a louder voice as this war progresses who are saying that war can never bring about any kind of desirable change, certainly not democracy, that something like democracy has to be authored by the people themselves, no matter how difficult the circumstances.

VASQUEZ: We’re now in the Fourth Gulf War, by Davari’s count. The first: Iran-Iraq, 1980 through 1988. The second: U.S. vs. Iraq, 1991. The third: the 2003 invasion, and now this. And in the beginning of this conflict, a moment that seems almost scripted for maximum symbolism, the attack and killing of the Supreme Leader, Ali Khamenei, on February 28. 

DAVARI: On the first day there was an attack on the Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei, who by all indications deliberately decided not to hide in a bunker. By all indications already had cancer and decided to go out in this manner such that it would increase the legitimacy of his cause. 

And we cannot forget that much of the revolutionary ideology in Iran is predicated around a principle in Shiism that is known as shahadat, which is variably translated as testimony, as witnessing but also as martyrdom. So if you sacrifice yourself, you’re bearing witness to the divine and you’re offering yourself as testimony of the divine.

VASQUEZ: He then commented on some of the contradictions and the polarization of the region coming to the forefront after that assassination.

DAVARI: This was a very powerful principle that was combined with revolutionary ideology in 1979. It was even more powerful in the context of the eight year Iran-Iraq war when a million people died on both sides. In many ways, Khamenei dying in the way that he did plays into this principle. And we see this in the support demonstrated by some of the crowds that gathered outside of Iran among the world’s Shia population.

In any case other Iranians were celebrating and were even engaging in TikTok dances around this event, dancing to the Village People song “YMCA” because it was Trump’s campaign song. So you can imagine how polarized the community is.

That same day there was an attack on a school in southern Iran that was close to IRGC facilities in a town called Minab, 175 people died. There are now reports one by a reporter who was recently laid off by the Washington Post when they contracted, Nilo Tabrizy, who had done what is called visual forensics around the January massacre. In order to demonstrate that, in fact it was a massacre by snipers. 

She used the same methodology to demonstrate that the attack was by the U.S. and the Israelis. You have a New York Times report that substantiates it now and the most recent thing that I’ve seen is that it was not only a double tap, but a triple tap. So one bomb was dropped, people came to help, another bomb was dropped, people came to help, a third bomb was dropped. 

VASQUEZ: Since the initial strike from the U.S. and Israel, President Trump has stated that he is looking to destroy their missile capability, their navy and prevent them from developing nuclear weaponry. Trump expects this to take four to five weeks, but it could be longer. Many more attacks have been made, and many innocent people have died. 

I started this episode wanting to understand the history behind the headlines. And what I found was a story that defies easy narratives. But it’s also a story about what happens when a people’s desire for self-determination gets caught between an unyielding state and foreign power with their own agenda. About what happens when the legitimate grievances of a population becomes a justification for intervention that has nothing to do with their liberation.

The complex history of this conflict cannot be fully understood in the time frame of a single podcast episode. Therefore, I think it’s important for all of us to do our due diligence when it comes to educating ourselves on global affairs and to draw from all perspectives. 

Thank you for listening and I hope you learned something new. This episode was written by Lucas Vasquez and produced by Ceci Heinen. If you have any questions, comments or concerns do not hesitate to reach out at podcasting@mndaily.com. We would love to hear from you. 

Thank you again for listening. My name is Lucas Vasquez and this has been In The Know. 

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on The long history behind the Fourth Gulf War

Understanding the controversial Board of Regents institutional speech vote

LUCAS VASQUEZ: Hello everybody, I’m your host Lucas Vasquez from the Minnesota Daily, and welcome back to another episode of In The Know, a podcast dedicated to the University of Minnesota. 

On March 18, 2025, the University of Minnesota’s Board of Regents voted nine-three to approve an updated version of a Resolution Related to Institutional Speech. This resolution provides guidance for when the university has to issue statements regarding matters of public concern and interest.

These changes have been a matter of great controversy among the university’s faculty as the guidelines have been described as both vague and complicated to work with. 

But before I dive into that, it’s first important to understand who the Board of Regents are and what their purpose is. As a college student myself, I was unaware of who and what the regents were and what they actually did. So I decided to do some digging. 

To start off, there are 12 members, and they each serve six-year terms. They are appointed to the Board by the Minnesota legislature, as is directed in the original University Charter. The very first Board of Regents was convened in February of 1851 making them 175 years old. 

To learn more about their daily life and to bring more clarity as to how they serve the U, I interviewed Regent James Farnsworth, who gave me a look into what it means to be a member of the Board and what his journey to becoming a regent was like. 

JAMES FARNSWORTH: In 2019 I had applied to run for the student at large seat, when then Regent Kenyanya was running. And we, you know, had a great time going through the process, learned a lot, met a lot of folks at the legislature. Didn’t end up being elected. Mike Kenyanya then ended up going on and serving in that position for six years. 

And, you know, had a great experience running for the seat, but I kind of went through the whole political process at the Capitol and I didn’t think I’d be doing it again anytime after that. And so in 2021 when there was another round of regional elections and the fourth congressional district seat came up, someone said, “Hey, you should consider applying.” 

And I kind of thought, “Well, I’ve been through the process before,” and I was actually running for St. Paul’s school board at the time. And didn’t, you know, think doing both at the same time made sense. And someone said, “Oh, well, you know, the process, why don’t you just apply anyways?” And I put in my application again to the Regent Candidate Advisory Council, went through the process. 

And ended up getting briefly, you know, knocked out of the official process in the middle when the Joint Higher Education Committee meets. Came back alive on the floor of the Joint Convention where I was nominated and elected. So kind of a whirlwind process. And then have been serving since March 15 of 2021.

VASQUEZ: Farnsworth also mentioned some of the other work he does outside of serving as a regent. 

FARNSWORTH: Outside of that service, because many folks don’t know that being a regent is actually a volunteer job. It’s non-compensated. It’s not a full-time job for folks. So, a lot of regents have been retired in the past, but of course, there’s folks that are still in their careers. So outside of serving on the board, I work full time for the YMCA Center for Youth Voice in a senior program director role. 

We do civic engagement programming for students in grade seven through 12th grade in our core programming. And then we actually do things across the whole state that impacts students in a wide range of grades and ages through our students’ voting program, respectful conversations and other things.

So I work in civic engagement and youth development full-time. Serve on the board in my volunteer capacity. And then I’m involved in some other nonprofits as well.

VASQUEZ: He explained how in terms of structure, the easiest way to understand the Board is to compare it to a K-12 school district’s board, but for the entire University of Minnesota system. It provides oversight for all five campuses. 

Just as a school board hires, evaluates and can dismiss a superintendent, they have the same authority over the university’s president, who is obligated to report to the Board. Additionally, the university’s chief auditor also answers directly to them.

FARNSWORTH: But those are kind of the only two direct reports we have as a Board from a staff perspective. And then there’s all sorts of things in Board of Regions policy, which if anyone’s interested, is accessible through our website, regents.umn.edu, of things that show what’s under the Board’s purview.

So there’s things such as any purchase over $5 million that the university is making goes to the Board. That’s kind of a financial threshold we have. A bunch of different appointment contracts and administration and athletics. We are the final stop on conferring of tenure for faculty members.

We vote on all sorts of other academic policy, real estate transactions, the final budgets for the university we vote on. So that’s obviously a huge responsibility. There’s all sorts of other things that are in Board of Regents policy that dictate how and what comes to the board and when.

And so, we have eight regular Board meetings a year, those are two date  meetings, so committees on Thursday all day, and the Board meeting and some committees on Friday. So that doesn’t sound like a ton, but there’s also a ton of different prep meetings that go into having those board meetings, particularly if you’re in committee leadership.

VASQUEZ: I then asked him since coming on the Board what some of his priorities have been and what he has done to see them through.

FARNSWORTH: I’ve served under three presidents. So I started under President Joan Gable, then she left and we had to bring on, and manage the process of working with an interim president, Jeff Edinger. And then we had the presidential search for Rebecca Cunningham and I was a part of the Presidential Search Advisory Committee.

So, that was, it’s been a huge priority since I’ve been on, is looking at leadership. And, and one of the most important things a board can do is participate in a presidential search hiring process and then onboarding and making sure that president is supported. I’ve also been very much focused on public engagement and accessibility and transparency of the Board. 

And so, you know, I actually really value opportunities like this to be able to talk about our work. Because most people aren’t familiar with the Board. I think sunshine and transparency equals good governance and gives better outcomes. And I think awareness of government entities leads to better outcomes and more accountability. 

And so I’ve been really interested in what are we doing to engage as a board across the system? How can we be talking about our work, making our processes more transparent? Getting feedback and hearing from university community stakeholders and folks from all across the state. Because I, you know, view our role as we are the public governing board of our state’s public land grant R1 institution. 

And so we need to be exercising and modeling what good public governance looks like. And so I’ve been always interested in that and making sure that our processes are good. Some other things, you know, looking at enrollment management, looking at what our new strategic plan is have also been priorities of mine.

VASQUEZ: Farnsworth commented on what he thought about the recent turmoil, everything from the university’s budget to ICE activity on campus, to the teamster strike last semester, and what he thinks about some of the frustrations expressed by student groups and faculty members.

FARNSWORTH: I think that’s a very fair question. And of course, you know, only being able to speak on behalf of myself in this interview. I always wanna make myself available to any group that wants to have conversations, even if they’re gonna be difficult, or even if we may disagree. 

At the beginning when you’re elected to the Board, of course there’s a bunch of onboarding things that happen, and different options and things that you’re working to get set up with the Board office. And so one of those options is you can decide what phone number you put on your regent webpage on the Board website. And so basically since week one, I’ve always had my real cell phone number up on there. I think there’s only a few of us that do that. 

All of our email addresses are always public. We have the Board public comment portal that folks can leave an audio visual, written comments to at any point, at, you know, 365, 24/7, and those get attached to the Board docket. And so I always am very careful in reviewing our correspondence that comes in that way.

VASQUEZ: He then expressed to me his desire of creating a space for public commenting during regent meetings. 

FARNSWORTH: That’s something that I’ve been working on for the last four and a half years on this Board, and have not been able to get a majority of the votes on the Board to support that. Which is unfortunate. I think that, in higher-ed boards, we are not the only university that doesn’t have that. 

But obviously if you look at the Minnesota legislature, any city council, county commission, planning commission, all of that, being able to, as a citizen, as a community member, show up to your seat of government and be heard, I think is a fundamental core value and, and something that we should be striving towards.

And so I believe that there should be built in time for people to be heard during Board meetings when the Board is formally convened in McNamara. We have a lot of meeting disruptions that happen because we don’t have that. Our current Board policy leaves it up to Board leadership to decide who can address the Board, and I don’t think that’s fair.

And that’s not a personal comment towards who’s in Board leadership now. I think that’s just unfair across the board that our leadership, whoever is in those seats, should not be the only ones deciding on behalf of all 12 of us who we get to hear from. So, I’m very sensitive to the feelings from the campus community on that. 

It’s something that from a system standpoint I’m working, you know, will be working towards every day until I’m not on this Board anymore about how we can make our processes more transparent and I will never support something that makes it harder for people’s voices to feel heard. 

VASQUEZ: Despite this, Farnsworth along with eight other members of the Board, approved a ruling that placed limitations on institutional speech here at the U, which has many members of the faculty concerned. I spoke with Michael Gallope, the chair of the Department of Cultural Studies and Comparative Literature

MICHAEL GALLOPE: So the institutional speech issue is hugely significant. For decades this institution, the University of Minnesota, alongside many other universities, have survived without any policies about neutrality or institutional speech that starts to regulate how we use the website and so on.

And under those conditions, in the past, sometimes presidents would take a position. During the civil rights era, you had some university presidents speaking in favor of civil rights, and yes, that did have an impact, right? You can go back further. You could look into the 19th century and see that some institutions were pro-slavery, some institutions were against slavery.

There’s a long history of institutions taking positions based in, you know, the expertise of the faculty. And within a certain political context that’s always changing. All of a sudden, we had this new policy in the wake of October 7 that was demanding neutrality, that was demanding restrictions on political statements. 

And this represents a very serious concern for our community because as a public university, not only are we obliged to comply by the First Amendment, which broadly assumes that everyone, including yourself as a student, myself as a faculty member, has First Amendment rights to speak our minds.

And under the assumption that you and I are not seeking to represent the institution, even when something is published in the university newspaper or on a university website, we’ve had those freedoms and we need those freedoms to be able to have those debates.

What this resolution that the regents passed last year did was, in a very broad, vague and quite confusing way, seek to regulate the way in which various groups of faculty and staff spoke to the public. Now, this is a very difficult thing to do because we saw immediately, just weeks after this resolution was passed, was that a series of statements about Israel Palestine were removed from the website. 

And these statements, there were specific requests from people in power legislators and donors to have these statements removed. Now, once you open the door to that kind of censorship, you know, that says, of all the things on the website, everything is okay, but these Israel Palestine statements, I just don’t agree with them and I need them taken down. Once you start doing that, you get into this terrain of discrimination.

VASQUEZ: He went on to comment about a few different examples of the struggles that this causes. He explained that people are wondering why certain statements were taken down, especially since all the statements on the murder of George Floyd are still up online. 

From his perspective, this creates a real problem for people trying to do their jobs and uphold the values of free inquiry, freedom of speech and academic freedom on campus. The issue, he said, is that there’s total confusion about what is actually permitted and what isn’t.

He described the language being used as vague and overly broad, leading to what looks like random acts of censorship. But, as he pointed out, they aren’t random at all; they’re coming from the people in power. The real danger is that this threatens any kind of community discussion on topics that are currently controversial. 

He feels they’ve gotten into a situation where they’re now trying to regulate things simply for being “too political.” And that’s the core of the problem. According to Gallope, no two people in the state of Minnesota are going to agree on exactly what is political and what isn’t. He gave examples: climate change is a political issue to some, but to others, it’s just a fact. Vaccine science is the same way. 

He extended that to topics like structural racism, transgender care or even reproductive health. The point is that, depending on your viewpoint, any of these subjects can be seen as either deeply political or completely non-political. This, he comments, has a direct conflict with First Amendment rights.

GALLOPE: The First Amendment obliges us to allow everybody to speak, and when you disagree, we invite you to speak as well. And with that playbook guaranteed by the First Amendment, we are going to be good as a community. We can disagree and we’ll keep talking and we’ll do it respectfully and with care towards the health of our community. 

But we’re not gonna do something like take stuff off the website because somebody complains. As soon as we start doing that, there really is no justifiable path. And in an era when repression and the risk of fascism is something that is a topic of public concern, it’s scary for many of us to see things being censored. 

So I think the institutional speech policy that the regents did was an example of something that really was overreach. It went beyond that kind of broad, idealistic and benevolent guidance that the regents have historically provided the institution, and started to interfere within our work as faculty and students doing our academic work and having debates and disagreeing about things. 

Once that interference begins it degrades the learning environment. It’s harder for us to speak freely. We are afraid of being, maybe being punished or someone could retaliate against us. It makes it much harder for us to do that work of discussing controversial issues. 

The only way we can solve our social problems is having that open debate. So I think that institutional speech issue was a mistake, and I really think the only solution is to pull it back and give those freedoms back to the faculty so we can establish norms of trust and of free expression that will allow everybody to thrive.

VASQUEZ: He also spoke about another example in which a concerning action was taken after specific statements were made, regarding the conflict between Israel and Palestine.

GALLOPE: I think the first big event was the un-hiring of Professor Raz Segal, who’s an expert in the field of Holocaust studies. This happened in 2024 and he was hired by the Dean of the College of Liberal Arts to run the Center for Holocaust and Genocide studies. And, he had said that Israel was committing a genocide in Gaza. 

And I think it was about a, a little over a week after October 7. And he was talking about a broader, sort of historical pattern of conduct, by the state of Israel in its treatment of Palestinians.

And, in the field of Holocaust and genocide studies, the topic of whether or not what’s happening in Gaza is a genocide is a very legitimate and central question for research inquiry. 

It’s also a question that a center of that kind has to be able to discuss openly. It has to be able to run programming with different kinds of speakers who would be able to, you know, help students, the public, other researchers, be able to grapple with the complexities of international law, the applicability of human rights, and how that impinges upon our understanding of the ethics and morality and the politics of what’s happening in Israel and Palestine. Which has been a massive topic of public concern. 

VASQUEZ: He told me about how there was a pressure campaign to have him unhired. 

GALLOPE: So an offer was extended and that was rescinded after it was already offered. It was rescinded by the Interim President Jeffery Edinger. Which led to a no confidence vote against the president and the provost, Provost Rachel Croson at the time. 

That’s a great example of academic freedom and an institution’s processes failing. There’s a reason, you know, once something like that happens where a group who has a vested interest in a certain point of view on a matter pertaining to foreign policy can influence the hiring outcome, it becomes very difficult for that position, in this case, a center director to continue that work, right? 

So once someone’s been un-hired for expressing a viewpoint that is disfavored, how can then that center go about having an open discussion about genocide? It becomes really difficult, and yet that’s something at a public institution we have to address. 

We do have to address the really challenging topics of genocide, of mass violence, of war, of racism. These are issues that affect our world in very intense ways, and we’re not gonna solve them if our universities don’t have a free hand to be able to engage the challenges head on. 

VASQUEZ: The next professor I spoke with was Jane Kirtley who is the director of the Silha Center for the Study of Media Ethics and Law at the Hubbard School of Journalism and Mass Communication. She told me from an attorney and journalist perspective her take on the issue.

JANE KIRTLEY: As you probably know from reading the various versions of it that have been floating around now for the past year or so, one of the positions that they have taken is that, you know, only the president of the university should be issuing any kind of statements on behalf of the university. 

And that only things that directly pertain to the university should be the subjects of those kinds of statements and the things that do not directly affect that. The university should not issue statements about it, and neither should any kind of unit, center, institute that could be construed as being speaking on behalf of the university. 

And you know, they’ve been trying to say that this is a viewpoint neutral position, that they’re not saying, yes, you can be, you know, pro-Israel, but you can’t be, you know, pro-Palestine or whatever the case is. They say you can’t talk about it at all. 

And I understand where that’s coming from because one of the worst things from a constitutional law perspective that a state institution like the University of Minnesota can do is to engage in viewpoint discrimination. It can’t say, you know, this view is acceptable and this view is not. 

VASQUEZ: Kirtley then commented to me about how this resolution has made it difficult for her to determine how she can issue statements to the public.  

KIRTLEY: So as an example, if I were to, as I’ve sometimes done, write an op-ed for the Star Tribune, that would be okay with them. I mean, it would have my name on it, it would have my affiliation, but they seemingly have accepted the proposition that reasonable people would not construe that as institutional speech.

People seem to think that professors that write things like that are speaking for the university, but the university at least has taken that position. But they don’t want academic units doing it, they don’t want centers like the Silha Center doing it because they think that it would be construed as institutional speech writ large. 

And the problem that I have with that as the person that is directing a center is that in the documents that created our center, it explicitly says that we’re supposed to interact and engage with the public on controversial issues. Again, that are relevant obviously to what we do here, which is study media ethics and media law. 

VASQUEZ: She then pointed out some of the issues with the resolution itself and some of the action she has tried to take. 

KIRTLEY: As soon as I became aware of this, I submitted comments explaining why I thought that this not only was a breach of the contract that created the Silha Center, but also that I thought it involved First Amendment issues. The main ones being that again, because we’re a state institution, the university is subject to the First Amendment, which means that it can’t just arbitrarily stifle or censor speech. 

And that the way the institutional speech resolution was written, it seemed to me to be, and this is again, getting into kind of constitutional law it seemed to be vague and overbroad. And the problems from a constitutional perspective with that is that you run the risk of chilling speech that is protected under the First Amendment. 

Because people are afraid that they’ll cross the line and be writing or saying something that, you know, you don’t wanna allow when in fact maybe you would allow it, but they don’t wanna take a chance.

VASQUEZ: Kirtley also commented on how the administration has struggled to implement the regents ruling because of how vague it is.

KIRTLEY: They don’t seem to have as much of a problem with, you know, me signing onto a brief or the Silha Center signing on as that would, if we posted the brief on our website. It’s OK to link to it, but it shouldn’t be posted there in full. So there are these kind questions about how do you, how do you know whether it’s OK or not? 

Is it OK to do it as long as you don’t tell anybody you’re doing it? And I think that’s, you know, that’s, that’s the thing. And what does, you know, suggests to me is that the people in the administration who are, are struggling with how to implement the region’s resolution don’t quite know how to do that.

VASQUEZ: She expressed how it’s understandable that administrations struggle with implementing the resolution, as something like this has never really happened before. 

KIRTLEY: It only matters because the First Amendment’s at stake. So of course it matters from my view, but I can understand that for some of the regents they just want us to be quiet and shut up because they don’t wanna get complaints from their constituents or from the legislature or from the Trump administration or whatever the case might be. 

Again, my maybe narrower view than some other professors would be that as long as we’re talking about something that is relevant to the center’s work, whatever the center may be, there shouldn’t be any question. There just shouldn’t.

VASQUEZ: Kirtley is also concerned about the process of which comments get attention and which don’t. The provost released on their website a section of frequently asked questions that are meant to help guide faculty and staff on how to move forward with the new ruling. 

She told me that she is concerned about how the process of complaints over certain statements and the determination of what is acceptable and what is not would look like. 

KIRTLEY: The provost would apparently then go to an advisory committee that she wants to create to get their take on it. Which would all be done confidentially, which means it would not be public. And then she would decide whether or not she wanted to pay attention to that or not pay attention to that. 

Well, I see that as really problematic on many, many levels, you know, there’s a concept of due process. And secret proceedings are not due process. And the fact that apparently this is triggered only by an outside complaint or even an inside complaint. I mean, it could be a student complaining, I assume. 

How would I know, how would I be able to defend myself against it? Would I have an opportunity to defend myself against it? I mean, they talk a lot about informal processes, but they don’t say what those are. And I understand, you know, they’re still kind of thinking this through, but I don’t like secret proceedings. 

VASQUEZ: She then told me about what she thought of Farnsworth’s idea of having a space for public comment at regent meetings. 

KIRTLEY: That would be really good. I was surprised to know that there really wasn’t a mechanism to take testimony from the public. I mean, you could submit written comments and I did that. But I’ve heard mixed versions about whether the regents get them, when they get them.

I mean, you were, we were always free to email a regent directly if we chose to, and I did that in some instances. But you still don’t really know if it’s reaching them, if they’re reading it, whether it’s having an impact at all. 

And the fact that if you file your comments through the portal whether they eventually get to the regents in a timely fashion, I mean I think they probably do end up in kind of the record of the meeting but that may be after the fact. 

VASQUEZ: Gallope also thought this would be a good idea. 

GALLOPE: Yes. I fully agree with Regent Farnsworth on this issue. I think he’s exactly right. If you look at the research on protest movements, particularly student protests. One of the main reasons that protests happen in the first place is because there’s no legitimate path for those who have a specific concern to achieve a policy outcome, or to be able to have a platform for advocacy that would allow them to express those concerns.

So if that does not exist, then people tend to go into the realm of protest. And protests, some of them can be more disruptive or less disruptive. But the idea behind protest is that there is some failure of communication.

There is some failure of representation of politics at the institution such that students, community members, faculty, feel silenced about an issue. 

VASQUEZ: So, where does this leave us? We have a Board made up of volunteers who oversee a massive public institution. One of its own members is fighting for more transparency and a formal way for the public to be heard. 

On the other side, we have faculty who feel that the Board’s recent actions, from the un-hiring of a professor to this new, vague institutional speech policy, are not just poor governance, but a direct threat to academic freedom and the First Amendment. 

As a student, I think it’s extremely important to be able to have open and constructive conversations on hard topics. In a classroom setting, this starts with the professor. But if the professor doesn’t feel comfortable breaching these topics either in their research or in their duties as an academic authority, because of discouragement from the Board that governs them. I fear that this apprehension could carry into the classroom. 

This would then, unfortunately, deprive students of conversations that could shape their perspective on some of the world’s biggest debates. All we can really do in times like this is continue to have the courage to speak up for what you believe in, to ask the hard questions and to exercise your constitutional First Amendment rights. 

Thank you for listening. I hope you learned something new. This episode was written by Lucas Vasquez and produced by Ceci Heinen. If you have any questions, comments, or concerns, don’t be afraid to reach out at podcasting@mndaily.com. 

My name is Lucas Vasquez, and this has been In The Know. 

 

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Understanding the controversial Board of Regents institutional speech vote

What does it mean to be Latino at the U of M?

LUCAS VASQUEZ: Buenos días, everybody, and welcome to In The Know, the Minnesota Daily podcast dedicated to the University of Minnesota. I’m your host, Lucas Vasquez, and today we are diving into the question of what it means to be a Latino at the U. Is it about the food you eat, the music you listen to, the language you speak or is it about something deeper?

This is the first episode in a mini-series in which we explore what it means to not be white in a predominantly white institution. We’re going to hear from a few students who are navigating these very questions. We’ll hear about their journeys, their challenges and the powerful community they’ve built in a group called Mi Gente.

My first question for these students was why did they choose the U in the first place? I can say for myself that cost was the principal factor in my decision to attend the U, and Minnesotan programs such as the North Star Promise, along with federal aid, were definitely pull factors for many members of Mi Gente.

SABRINA CORRA: I would say, OK, I gotta be so real. It was the free tuition.

VASQUEZ: Sabrina Corra, a third-year student majoring in food science and nutrition, told me that for her, cost outweighed academics when making her college decision. Rosita Ortiz, a second-year majoring in developmental psychology, also pointed to cost being important as well as family proximity.

ROSITA ORTIZ: It was mainly, I guess cost. Because I thankfully got my tuition paid for my first two years and proximity is very close to my family. So it kind of worked out both ways.

VASQUEZ: Cost, however, may change in the future, as the University of Minnesota approved the biggest tuition increase in the past decade in June. According to the Star Tribune, the $5.1 billion budget included a 7% cut to academic programs while also raising tuition by 6.5% for in-state students and 7.5% for out-of-state students.

In a school where 75% of the student population receives financial aid, this cost increase may deter many minority students in general from attending the U. According to the University of Minnesota’s student data, Hispanic students make up only 5.4% of the total 31,855 undergraduate students on campus. This is less than the 9.1% of Black students, 15.2% of Asian/Pacific Islander students and 61.1% of white students. 

When I first arrived at the U my freshman year, the lack of a Hispanic student population was something I quickly noticed. Being a Hispanic myself, it was important to me to find a group of people to connect with culturally. I asked Christian Barrera, a second-year majoring in business and management education, if he had a similar experience.

CHRISTIAN BARRERA: During my middle school and high school years, I was very in culturally diverse schools. So it was a bit of a culture shock to see, like the lack of Latinos just walking around campus. Seeing, this, this many white people was a little surprising and, and kind of having to look a little, little deeper for a Latino community.

VASQUEZ: Ortiz mentioned feeling the same way.

ORTIZ: It was very like, I guess, lonely at the beginning, because I didn’t know groups like this existed, or groups like Mi Gente existed. So I was very separated from everybody. It was very hard to like focus or find a place where I felt like a community was with me until I found Mi Gente.

VASQUEZ: Mi Gente is a student organisation located on the second floor of Coffman Memorial Union, its aim is to create a shared space for students of all backgrounds, but mainly Hispanic ones, to come together and socialise with one another. 

But for these students, it is a lot more than just that. They shared how Mi Gente feels like a second family of like-minded people who share their culture, a place where they feel safe to express a side of themselves that is deeply personal to their identity. 

Corra also commented about how spending time at Mi Gente events opened her eyes to wanting to connect with people who share her culture.

CORRA: I remember my first year, not to give TMI, but like I think it’s pretty important. I was in a relationship with a white person and at the time I had found out about the Orgullo event and I had invited them and I went with them. 

When I had asked them to dance with me, they were like, “No, that’s weird. Why would I wanna do that? I don’t even know.” Like, so for me it was like, it’s kind of big to have someone who would be OK with like accepting and whatnot.

VASQUEZ: But how did these students find each other? I asked Diego Luis, a fourth-year studying sociology of law, criminology and justice, about his experience. 

DIEGO LUIS: Man, love Mi Gente. I discovered Mi Gente before coming to university. I was a participant in Mi Gente’s high school weekend event that they had. And basically we had breakout sessions and I just, the board members had different workshops. We talked about things about the university and learning more about the university. 

We had lunch, but they specifically wanted it to be in the Mi Gente room. So, the first time I ever visited this room was in 2019. And, uh, I knew that if I were to come here I’d be a part of this family that I’ve seen that they’ve created in this community.

And I think for me being here for a while I think I fostered a stronger relationship with Mi Gente than I ever did in the years prior. And I think it’s because a lot of the people have been so genuine, but also like, you know, there’s just been a lot of transition that’s been very well with this organisation that I think has. It’s been something that I have been looking for that I have finally gotten.

VASQUEZ: For Corra, her journey to the Mi Gente room was a bit different than Luis’.

CORRA: In all, I’d say a big thing was their events, their events are super awesome. Like that’s how I discovered them was through, it was honestly the food. So going into food science, you probably already know this, but I’m a huge foodie. Their event had some amazing food and I remember the first event they just had a really good combination of just a lot of Mexican cuisine. 

And don’t get me wrong, I really loved it, but as someone who is Peruvian, I was really sad that they didn’t have a lot of Peruvian foods. So, or maybe even just a lot of South American foods. So hopping onto that, that was something that I really wanted to prioritize. 

And so moving forward from that to the, to this year, from 2023 until 2025 now, We’ve made it a priority to also make sure that a lot of the people on board are of different nationalities, so that the people here in the room feel more welcomed and relatable and accepted in some ways.

VASQUEZ: For Nayelli Loha, a second-year student majoring in architecture, it was friend connections that brought her to the room. 

NAYELLI LOHA: I found out about Mi Gente through a friend of mine. We just like saw each other walking the same direction and he was like, “Oh, you should go to Mi Gente. The people there are really chill, really nice, they’re welcoming.” And I was really hesitant about going just because like, I didn’t know anyone in the room, you know?

But I decided to just give it a shot, you know? And I really, I really enjoyed it. I mean, the first day I was there like, I didn’t know who anyone was. It was very scary to talk to anyone. But, I started coming to Mi Gente more often and all that, and then eventually made a lot more friends here. 

Eventually got to meet everyone. I think Mi Gente to me, I don’t know, it’s kinda just like a community, you know, a community where you are able to be yourself, feel safe no matter what.

VASQUEZ: Word-of-mouth was also how Barrera got involved.

BARRERA: It was during the first week where one of my friends ended up being told by their friend about Mi Gente and how there was a whole bunch of student multicultural student groups here at the second floor at Coffman. And so when me and him checked it out, I started getting more involved with, with not just like being around in the room, but also going to their events and participating in what they had to offer for my first year.

It really made me want to join and help. So I applied to be financial director for my second year, which is how, you know, I’m kind of here now. I really enjoy the atmosphere that it brings. Mi Gente is the main Latinx student organization here at the U. 

So having that, I guess like that standard to uphold, we do it very well. And, and giving a voice to the Latino community despite being on the smaller side of minorities here at the university. 

VASQUEZ: Existing as a Latino student on a large campus often means navigating two different worlds. I asked Corra if she felt a difference between the mainstream activities and events the university offers versus the events that are hosted by Mi Gente.

CORRA: That’s a really good thing to bring up first of all. It’s really funny, my best friend, she was voted like the most, the most prideful in our year for high school because she loved football games. So I think I’m an odd one out where I really don’t, I’m not a big fan of like football games, but a huge thing I will say is being a part of Mi Gente has made me kind of more immersed in my culture of being more into something like soccer. 

Where it’s kind of, it’s silly, but I’m kind of feeling that same amount of like pride I think she felt towards football towards soccer. Another thing I would say is something that we participated in this year was the parade. And I signed us up for it because I was like, you know what, if we’re walking through, we’re gonna be holding up all of our flags and said and done, yes, we did. 

And it was super awesome because, we kind of started making up a chant, and just as being in like a group setting, it just makes you feel so much more, first included, but also just recognised and not afraid, not as afraid to be like a part of these things.

VASQUEZ: Loha also talked about the difficulties of navigating the dynamics of multiculturalism.

LOHA: I like had a friend group and a lot of them are just like white people. So I feel like when I came here, it was just kind of like, I didn’t feel I could be myself, kind of, you know? I had to, especially with like white people, I had to like, “Oh, maybe I should skip this song because they won’t know what this song says.” 

You know, when, where we’re driving somewhere I can’t play a song that I would like, or I, or I can’t say a joke that only a certain people would understand, you know? So I think that’s the biggest thing. 

And then if I were to compare events from like more American culture and then Mi Gente, I feel like Mi Gente’s a lot more joyful. I’m able to express myself a lot more in a way, and then when I feel like when I’m at an American event or just like an event from the U, it’s more, I just, I don’t feel left out. I just feel like. 

VASQUEZ: A little out of place? 

LOHA: Yeah I feel out of place.

VASQUEZ: Now more than ever, the importance of spaces and events that promote the expression of one’s cultural background is needed. This comes especially during a time when Latin communities across the U.S. are facing increasing pressure from the current administration. Immigration and Customs Enforcement raids, especially, are fueling the fear facing these groups. 

Just this past Tuesday, November 18, ICE activity in St. Paul swept fear throughout the cities and drew many protestors out to the streets. Armed agents wearing ICE uniforms were sighted conducting a raid on a St. Paul business, and witnesses reported people being detained and dragged off to vans and trucks. Some activists tried to contest a line set up by agents, leading to physical altercations and eventually pepper spray being doused on the protestors’ faces.  

In a post shared on their social media platforms this summer, Mi Gente took a stance after ICE activity in Minneapolis, stating, “We are saddened and angered by the systems that continue to dehumanise immigrants and silence protest…Mi Gente stands firmly in support of immigrant and undocumented communities.” 

Additionally, more than 225 people have watched their immigration case be dismissed at the government’s request. According to the Star Tribune, they have then been arrested by ICE agents after leaving the Fort Snelling courtroom. This detainment is justified through a process known as expedited removal. 

Expedited removal is the process by which a noncitizen is detained and deported within days, without a hearing before a judge. This process was previously reserved for migrants caught within 100 miles of the border and within two weeks after entering illegally. Under President Trump, however, the administration is applying it to noncitizens living anywhere who can’t show they have been in the U.S. for at least two years. 

These tactics raise heavy concern among immigrant rights activists and attorneys, who argue that it undermines due process rights and coerces innocent people into detention. In turn, it separates parents from their children and tears both families and communities apart. 

For anyone the threat of being torn apart from your loved ones by policies like these can cause a great deal of stress and anxiety. And in that context, the idea of the family that students have found in a group like Mi Gente is priceless. It’s groups like these built here on campus that provide a buffer against the fear and instability happening just beyond the university’s borders. 

According to its members, this family isn’t just about shared joy; it’s also about shared concerns. It’s about having a place to turn to when you are away from your home and your loved ones. A place where you can feel safe and accepted by people with shared experiences. A place where you don’t have to feel like you are alone. 

LUIS: Honestly, the most important thing I can say is, you know, immerse yourself in your culture. That’s why I take the Spanish class. I’m always in the Mi Gente room. I’m always trying to, you know, mostly just listen to Spanish music because I want to expand upon it more than just like something that’s like baseline. You know? 

I think it’s really important to really take the time and, and the effort to really expand more than just the language, but also like the culture. You know, the way we write, the way we interact, the way we really speak properly with one another is really important, you know? So that’s one of the things that I’ve been taking seriously for myself. Especially being here at this university where I’m mostly speaking English.

VASQUEZ: Many people may think that being a Latino is just about speaking Spanish, but it’s truly so much more than just that. According to the United Nations, there are over 30 Latin countries, each with its own distinct culture. Luis talks about what growing up with this multicultural experience was like.

LUIS: My mother is from the Dominican Republic, and my dad is from Argentina. So for me, growing up in the United States has been a lot of trying to kind of understand both of the countries where my parents are from, both of my heritages. And just really kind of immersing myself in the culture, whereas I live with my mother but I don’t live with my father. 

So a lot of me and how I grew up was a lot of Dominican culture traditions and stuff like that. But also my mom did a really good job in maintaining my Argentinian side and teaching me about those values, but also the culture that came with that. Like we’d always watch national soccer team games together. 

You know she’d introduce me to the different drinks and food of Argentina. As well as, you know, living with her we’d obviously listen to music from the Dominican Republic. A lot of it was very much a flow. But my mom did try her hardest too, to make sure that I got the Argentinian side. 

VASQUEZ: Being a Latino student at the University of Minnesota is not only a journey of finding your people, but a journey about finding yourself. It’s about taking the time to look within yourself to answer the questions of identity and who you are. And although everyone’s answers to those questions will be different, communities like Mi Gente are vitally important. 

In an age where human connection is done mostly through screens, having a place where people can relate to you face-to-face, through shared language, music, food and culture, isn’t just a nice perk. It’s how you build a home away from home. It’s how you find your familia.

That is all I have for you today folks. Thank you for listening. This episode was written by Lucas Vasquez and produced by Ceci Heinen. If you have any questions, comments or concerns don’t hesitate to reach out at podcasting@mndaily.com.

My name is Lucas Vasquez and this has been In The Know. And as always, que tengan un buen día.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on What does it mean to be Latino at the U of M?

When Washington stops, we all feel it

LUCAS VASQUEZ: Hello and welcome to another episode of In The Know, a podcast dedicated to the University of Minnesota. I’m your new host from the Minnesota Daily, Lucas Vasquez. 

Over the past few weeks, the nation has been watching as the longest government shutdown in American history unfolds in Washington D.C. As this drags on, Students at the U and Minnesotans statewide are starting to feel its effects.

To help us make sense of it all, I recently sat down with two political science professors from the University of Minnesota: Kathryn Pearson, who specializes in congressional studies and Paul Goren, who specializes in public opinion. 

Today, we’re going to use their insights to understand not just what is happening, but why it’s happening, and what it means for all of us. First things first, however, how does a government even shut down? Pearson suggests that it begins with something called appropriations bills. 

KATHRYN PEARSON: So every year Congress is supposed to pass and the president is supposed to sign 12 annual appropriations bills that fund federal agencies, that pay federal employees and that provide money for the services that federal agencies provide. These 12 appropriations bills constitute about a quarter of the overall federal budget. 

It’s the discretionary funds that Congress is in charge of. It does not include things like Medicare and Medicaid and interest on the national debt, but it does include a lot of really important priorities. And so this year, on October 1 the House and Senate had not agreed on any appropriations bills and the president had not signed any into law. 

None of the appropriations bills have been passed, and so the House of Representatives passed another continuing resolution to keep the government funded through November 21 with just Republican support. And then the Senate needed 60 votes to do so, Republicans voted for it. Most Democrats uh, did not, and so the Senate could not pass their version. And so the federal government shut down on October 1. 

VASQUEZ: So, in sum a failure to agree on spending bills leads to a shutdown. But what makes this shutdown unlike others we have seen in the past? Pearson pointed out some key differences.

PEARSON: Well, at the heart of this shutdown is Democrats in the House and Senate are not voting for this continuing resolution because subsidies for the Affordable Care Act are set to expire on December 31 and Democrats want to work with Republicans to extend those subsidies, and Republicans will not do that. 

They say they will not do that until the government is open again. But Democrats are saying, you know, we won’t open the government again until we work out an agreement on extending these subsidies. So the two parties are locked in on different positions and there really hasn’t been a lot of negotiating. And so that’s a big difference, um, between now and past shutdowns. So, you know, there’ve been shutdowns in the past. There were a couple in the 1990s, one when Obama was president then the longest one when Trump was president in 2018 and 2019.

But in all of those cases the president was negotiating with Congress like there was movement, but we were just not seeing any movement. The president is engaged in sort of foreign policy and just telling Republicans, “Don’t negotiate.” And so there hasn’t been a lot of negotiating and it really is causing people to wonder how long the shutdown will go on, and I think people are concerned that it may be a very long time.

VASQUEZ: Another key difference she mentioned is that this is a full government shutdown. In previous shutdowns, some appropriations bills had been approved, resulting in only a partial shutdown. For instance, during the shutdown in President Trump’s first term, he was able to redirect Pentagon funds to pay military personnel. 

He was able to do this because the defense appropriation bill had already been approved, ensuring that the military continued to receive pay. In contrast, this complete shutdown that we are seeing today has created a far less flexible environment. This raises concerns about the lack of progress in negotiation and over how long it might continue. 

So now we have a full shutdown, with a deep partisan divide about healthcare and an administration who won’t encourage negotiation. This is truly something we have never seen before. But with all of this happening in Washington there is still another dynamic that plays a heavy role and that is the American public’s opinion. Goren says it comes down to one main thing, party identity.

PAUL GOREN: So what we usually see with government shutdowns is, public opinion research shows that people oppose the government shutdown when they can blame the other party. And then they accept the government shutdown when it’s being administered by maybe the president of their party. 

So Democrats disapprove of the current government shutdown because it’s happening under unified Republican control. In the past, I’ve seen public opinion evidence, which shows that when the Democratic Party has unified control of the government or a democratic president then Democrats now approve and Republicans disapprove of. So it’s, it’s mainly filtered through the lens of people’s party ID. If you can blame the other party, then you’ll do that.

VASQUEZ: But do Americans view shutdowns as a real crisis or just as political shenanigans and theater? Goren suggests it’s usually the latter.

GOREN: I think most Americans most of the time view it as theater. And very few government shutdowns last long enough to start having a major impact on people. 

VASQUEZ: But Goren was quick to add that this shutdown is unique. We’re well past a month now, as of today, November 7, 2025 the government has been shut down for a record number of 37 days and the effects are starting to be felt. And as the shutdown drags on and effects start to hit the general public, opinions start to change.

GOREN: The current government shutdown is an exception. I think we’re coming up on a month already. So usually most people see it as theater, especially if the shutdown is resolved within a few days, or even a couple of weeks. 

But, when it tends to drag on for a long time, like the current government shutdown, and people may start to feel loss of government benefits or inconvenience from the government shutdown. Then it becomes more than theater and it’s actually affecting people’s lives and that can influence their opinions. 

VASQUEZ: The reality of this is that the effects of the shutdown are being felt by millions of Americans nationwide. One group that is feeling its effect the most are federal workers. Half of whom are currently working without pay. And with the expectation of back pay, which has historically been a given in the past, now up in the air, who’s to say how long federal workers are willing to work without pay. 

PEARSON: So there are 1.4 million federal employees who are currently not being paid, and about half those federal employees are still showing up to work every day because their agencies have determined that they are “essential” and then the other half are furloughed and not able to go to work.

In every shutdown, federal employees have received back pay. Congress actually passed a law that President Trump signed during the last, the most recent shutdown, codifying that. But despite that legislation President Trump and other executive branch officials have been saying that some federal employees may not receive back pay. 

And there have actually been competing bills in the Senate that would only pay, you know, federal workers who are currently working. Um, those have not passed, but there is concern among federal employees that some will be paid back pay, some won’t. And that is just incredibly stressful and demoralizing for federal employees.

VASQUEZ: Despite this, the Trump administration has found the funding to pay certain federal employees during this shutdown. 

PEARSON: What is unusual about this shutdown is that actually during the shutdown President Trump has actually fired some federal employees, which has not happened before in the past. CDC workers and then also, we talked about military personnel, but President Trump in the administration has found money for some federal employees, for example, like ICE employees that the president really favors. 

And so it’s this situation where the administration is sort of picking and choosing among federal employees in a way that we have not seen in the past. 

VASQUEZ: The impact is also felt far beyond just government offices. According to an article from the New York Times, transportation officials’ are planning on slashing air traffic by 10 percent at 40 major airports across the country. This is largely because of the loss of air traffic controllers who are not coming to work because they aren’t getting paid. With the holidays just around the corner this will impact  families nationwide. 

PEARSON: So air traffic controllers are all essential workers. So they need to show up at their jobs every day, but they are not being paid. And this is a demanding job and they’re not being paid. And so many air traffic controllers are taking on second jobs or third jobs so they can get a paycheck. As we saw in the last shutdown, they’re beginning not to show up to work because they’re not being paid, and it’s just a really insecure job. 

VASQUEZ: Pearson commented that even in our own backyard we are starting to feel the consequences of the shutdown. 

PEARSON: If federal agencies can’t be working on federal research, whether that’s processing grants and applications or giving out money for federal research that they have promised universities. So the federal research component is huge. I also think about students who may be on some of the programs that have either ended or set to end, such as SNAP benefits, which the USDA and president have said will be out of money on November 1. 

VASQUEZ: Goren also flagged the ending of SNAP benefits as a potential tipping point in public opinion.

GOREN: The supplemental nutritional assistance program, SNAP benefits are gonna run out and it’s being fought over in the courts today. But if people who depend on substantial government benefits like that, or Medicaid or other kinds of government services, or just even, even help in social security offices for senior citizens. And those services are increasingly unavailable or those resources are not available.

Then I think public opinion is gonna shift in a way that that disapproval of the shutdown is going to rise. And then the Democrats and the Republicans will start blaming each other. 

VASQUEZ: The blame game, in congress especially, is fueling the American partisan divide. But who might walk away with the toll of responsibility for this shutdown in the eyes of the public? 

GOREN: It might be a hard sell for the Republican party since they have unified control of the government. And people don’t really know that much about who controls government, but they, they can get a sense if Republicans control everything, it’s their fault. 

Democrats will make that argument. Republicans will try to blame it on Democrats, but I think the Republican party could get beat up a bit moving forward. 

VASQUEZ: But do shutdowns actually hurt politicians come election time? With midterm elections happening just next year voters may consider the shutdown when they take to the ballot booths, but Goren suggests that maybe that isn’t the case.

GOREN: The public has a short term memory on many things. And so if this shutdown is resolved in two days or even two weeks, um, that’s gonna, you know, happen about 11 months before the next election. And, and so I don’t think, you know, people are really gonna focus on what happened 11 months ago. 

They’ll be focusing on, you know, what’s going on, what’s happening to my pocketbook, uh, economic condition of the country, you know, a few months before the election. 

If a shutdown like this happens right before an election though, because that would be in that short term window, people would remember. And then, and then the blame game might have political consequences. 

VASQUEZ: Nowadays social media and news outlets are becoming more and more partisan and because of this it can be tricky to distinguish between what’s fact and what is just party rhetoric. 

PEARSON: Well, you know, compared to, say, the 1995, 96 shut down when most Americans were receiving their information about the shutdown from the same sources.

Today Republicans are receiving their information from Republican leaning sources. Democrats are receiving their information from Democratic leaning sources. And so, you know, it’s easy for the two parties to talk past each other and for Americans to really sort of shut out the perspective of the party that they disagree with.

VASQUEZ: The latest polls to come out of CBS show us that only about 37% of Americans are very concerned about the shutdown, this is only up 9% since it was asked earlier in the shutdown on October 9. In contrast 59% of the democratic base approve of how their party is handling the shutdown, while the republicans show a bit more of a solid backing with a 71% approval rating. 

The question now is, who are the moderates backing through this shutdown. But how do we measure public opinion to determine these things, and when we do, how accurate does it tend to be? Goren argues that in terms of accuracy polling tends to be pretty good. 

GOREN: I mean, there’s questions about the accuracy of polls more generally, but the, the best high quality polls, gold standard public opinion polls usually ask questions very straightforward. You know, which side do you blame more for the current government shutdown or the current government impasse, the Democrats or Republicans? 

And those are standard questions. They work well, and what they usually find is, you know, again, there’s a strong partisan divide, what matters is the people who are sort of independent are only leaning slightly toward one party or another.

That’s kind of where marginal public opinion is and is 70% of independence, if it goes from 50% of independence blaming one side to 70%, that’s when that becomes politically consequential and, and these standard public opinion polls can identify those people pretty accurately. 

VASQUEZ: So where does all of this leave us? We have a full government shutdown, driven by a deep partisan divide over policy, with real consequences for millions of Americans and students here at the U. The public opinion is largely partisan, but could shift as the pain becomes more widespread. And while the political fallout might be minimal if it ends soon, the strain on our systems and our citizens is very real and felt right now. 

Will Republicans and Democrats come to the drawing board and look for compromise? Will federal workers receive backpay? Will this shutdown play a role in next year’s midterm election? Who’s to say. Feel free to leave a comment with your thoughts on our webpage at mndaily.com. I know I’ll definitely be thinking about this in the weeks to come. 

That is all I have for you today folks. This episode was written by me, Lucas Vasquez, and produced by Ceci Heinen. Thanks for listening and as always if you have any questions, comments or concerns, don’t be afraid to send us an email at podcasting@mndaily.com. We would love to hear from you. 

My name is Lucas Vasquez and I’ll catch you next time on In The Know. Until then have a great rest of your day!!

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on When Washington stops, we all feel it