Author Archives | by Jasmine Shackleford

Opinion: Old buildings should be repurposed, not demolished

Every building of a certain age has at least one ghost story attributed to it.

Humans can’t help but craft stories of ghosts and demons, labeling every old building as “haunted,” no matter how illogical it may be.

Ghost stories compel me as much as anyone else, but our shared tendency to assume old buildings are infested with ghosts and death reflects the common misconception that old is inherently worse than new.

Old structures are worth far more than the tall tales we associate with them. Maintaining and repurposing old buildings holds many benefits, including preserving memories of the past and connecting peoples’ heritage.

Todd Byhre, owner of Rebound Hospitality, operates several historic hotels including the Celeste of St. Paul Hotel and Bar, which maintains its legacy of a former convent despite major changes over the years.

According to Byhre, the hotel was originally constructed as St. Agatha’s Conservatory of Music and Art in 1913. Even after the convent closed in the 1960s and became an office space, members of the nearby Church of St. Joseph felt strongly toward the property, prompting excitement when it was refurbished and opened as a hotel in 2019.

“Six of the sisters who had been living here in the 1960s and twelve others from the order had a sleepover as our first guests,” Byhre said. “They brought back stained glass windows that were in storage and dishes that are now in the breakfast room that were used when it was a convent.”

Reconnecting with the past is an invaluable experience enabled by the preservation of old buildings. 

Michael Clark is the managing director of the Depot Hotel Complex in downtown Minneapolis, which consists of the massively renovated Milwaukee Road Depot.

“When I first worked here, I got all kinds of guests saying, ‘Oh, I remember when I traveled out of here as a kid,’” Clark said. “Now there’s less of that because those folks are aging, and who would have taken the train? But I continue to see, ‘Oh, my grandpa used to work here,’ or ‘My dad used to work here.’”

The Depot occupies two city blocks, made up of a Renaissance Hotel, a Residence Inn and large amounts of event space in the original train station’s hall and the train shed, according to Clark. The multi-use nature of the complex displays the creative ways old buildings can find a new purpose.

“Since this property was developed, the train shed has housed an NHL-sized ice rink that would cross-utilize those event spaces,” Clark said. “The space was expanded and enhanced for different purposes over the last 23 years.”

Many old buildings hold immense architectural beauty, but even those without it are worthy of preservation. 

Warehouses and industrial buildings that many would write off as worthless frequently undergo successful conversions to apartments or event space, such as the Pillsbury A-Mill in Minneapolis. 

Sarah Johnson, executive director of the Machine Shop event venue in the A-Mill’s original machine shop, said the main flour mill was converted into lofts that are rented out exclusively to artists.

Johnson said the many historic details of the Machine Shop are what make the space unique.

“The wood floors on the second floor with patches and marks, or the writing on one of the pillars from measurements back in the day, create a sense of community and history that helps people feel connected versus something that’s a brand new build,” Johnson said.

For every successful preservation story, many more old buildings are torn down despite the waste of resources. 

The cost of a complete renovation is often too high, but historic tax credits offered by the state of Minnesota and the National Park Service can help incentivize preservation, according to Byhre. Tax credits can offset up to 15% of expenses when a business repurposes an old building for the first five years of operation.

The tax credits require the preservation of key historical elements of the building which produce long-term income, but Byhre said the Celeste could not have opened without them.

“You have to abide by all the rules, but the rules they have are also the rules we want,” Byhre said. “Without that 15% covered by the historic tax credit, it would have been too expensive.”

Once the initial renovation investment is complete, operating a business from an old building like the Depot can be economically advantageous, according to Clark.

“Railroads, in particular, have a lot of nostalgia surrounding them,” Clark said. “I do think, as a business, it’s a competitive advantage for us to have the historic aspect to sell and make us different and part of the community.”

Johnson said blending the historic elements of the Machine Shop with modernization brings the most success.

“People really like something new,” Johnson said. “Especially when we’re trying to do things with LED and sustainability, sometimes the older features can be detrimental. But I think when it’s done thoughtfully, the restoration of an old space and bringing in those pieces combines the best of both worlds.”

Repurposing old buildings is not worse than new construction. Preserving them should continue to be incentivized through programs like the historic tax credits, even when considering the ghosts.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Old buildings should be repurposed, not demolished

Opinion: Stop turning college admissions into a game of prestige

College admissions is difficult and complex. The last thing any high school senior needs when deciding the course of their life via the intricacies of the Common Application is societal pressure only to consider “prestigious” universities.

Unfortunately, this is exactly what is happening.

Due to social media trends, peer pressure and parental influence, many prospective college students fall victim to the misconception that prestigious colleges, like Ivy League schools, are the only viable path to success.

Like countless other high school students, I turned to social media as a way to learn about different colleges during the application process. The most-viewed videos, however, are rarely genuine tips about finding the best college for you.

Far more popular is the trend of applying to dozens of top-ranked colleges and meticulously crafting the longest applications possible, all to get into a highly competitive school.

Idealizing prestigious colleges in this way fuels the idea that they are inherently more valuable. In reality, the degree matters more than the name of the institution on it.

Sai Tallapragada, a recent graduate of the University of Minnesota, said many high school students make generalizations that prestigious colleges are better before they even know what they are pursuing.

“When you’re in high school and applying to colleges, you get tricked into thinking it’s your top college or nothing,” Tallapragada said. “I think what you really get out of a more ‘prestigious’ school is the brand value on your resume rather than actual value in your education.”

However, the impact of brand value is rarely large enough to measure. Education itself is valuable no matter where it comes from and the professional experiences you glean during your college years are more important.

Gabrielle Brown Torres, the career and college readiness coordinator at Southwest High School with Achieve Twin Cities, a service providing college guidance to local high schools, said experiences are most important.

“I always tell students, ‘The education section is the smallest part of your resume,’” Torres said. “It’s your experiences, where you’ve had internships, where you volunteered that employers look at.’”

Nevertheless, the demand for prestigious colleges is stronger than ever with a record-high number of applications for the class of 2028.

According to Torres, heightened peer pressure is a major factor in the demand for prestigious schools. Torres said many students compare themselves to others and apply to prestigious schools because their peers are.

“I had one student this spring who told me he was probably going to end up at the U of M, but he wanted to apply to MIT and some other prestigious schools because his peers were doing it,” Torres said. “I just asked, ‘Why?’ The U of M is already a really great school with great programs.”

Nyesha Brown, the college navigator for Roseville Area High School who works with students to explore postsecondary education options, said families also influence students to focus on certain schools. When a student has a long history of family members who attended a certain Ivy League school, it exerts extra pressure to follow in their footsteps.

However, colleges less glamorous than Ivy Leagues can be just as valuable and far more affordable.

According to Tallapragada, many state universities, including the University of Minnesota, have programs of equal quality at a fraction of the price.

Brown said that local community colleges are equally beneficial due to lower costs of attendance and travel. Community colleges allow many students to get a feel for college and decide if it is right for them before transferring to four-year universities.

Even the process of submitting applications to prestigious colleges is far more complicated. 

“When you’re applying to five schools or so, it’s fine, but applying to twenty schools is just excessive and unnecessary,” Torres said. “It’s a lot of money because of application fees, and it’s a lot of time for the student because of the supplemental essays.”

According to Brown, students intent on studying at prestigious schools often try creating extremely long college applications, sometimes participating in activities solely to fill out a page on their application. Brown said this can be detrimental because it limits students from exploring their passion.  

“If you’re feeling the need to fill an entire page, then what exactly are you trying to identify as?” Brown asked. “Kids will burn themselves to the end of the stick to make sure that they are executing everything that will get them acceptance into these schools. So I say, ‘Hey, try to be a kid sometimes. It’s OK.’”

However, attending a prestigious college can be undeniably beneficial.  

Bhanu Narra, a second-year physics and philosophy student at the University of Oxford, said he wanted to attend a prestigious university because he believed it would open up paths to better graduate programs in research and academia.

Narra said the college’s prestige benefited him primarily because he sought out a specific physics program and knew what he wanted to do with it. The school’s prestige would not necessarily be equally valuable to other students.

“I knew from middle school that I would want to do physics, so I drilled down just on that,” Narra said. “But if you’re unsure about what you want to do, then it’s much less valuable.” 

Ultimately, when students consider which colleges to apply to, they should look for their best fit rather than feeling pressured by prestige.

“It’s really about the student and the journey they want to go on,” Brown said.

Nothing is wrong with wanting the best for yourself, but the gamification of college admissions causes students to forget that the best college is not the same for everyone.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Stop turning college admissions into a game of prestige

Opinion: Get a bike!

Last November, my third month as a college freshman, my bicycle was stolen.

I made the mistake of assuming that a cheap wire bike lock and the presumed security of using a bike rack directly outside my dorm was enough to keep my belongings safe. I was wrong, and I paid the price. For the next several months, my methods of transportation were restricted to public transit and my own two feet.

Initially, I thought I would be fine and decided to wait until the summer months to replace my bicycle. However, I ended up scarcely lasting a month into the spring semester before changing my mind and making hasty plans to get a new bike. During my brief period without one, I renewed my value for bicycles as the most convenient, affordable and sustainable method of transportation.

Brian Dowdy is a worker-owner of The Hub Bicycle Co-op, a cooperative bike shop based in Minneapolis that sells and repairs bikes for the community while also educating consumers and promoting bicycles as an ideal method of transportation.

According to Dowdy, biking is one of the most convenient and fun ways to get from one place to another, especially for students.

“When I was in school and riding my bike everywhere on the weekends, I would head out at night with friends on my bike,” Dowdy said. “I think it’s critical for folks to be able to get to class and work and not have to own, maintain and pay for gas with a car.”

Bicycles are also typically the fastest way to get around a college campus. The slowness of walking, the unpredictability of public transit and the hassle of parking a car means my bicycle is always the quickest and most logical way to get to class.

Zephyr Sheedy is an avid cyclist and employee at The Hub, working at their University of Minnesota location.

“As a young adult, I liked being able to ride my bike around and not think about other methods of transportation,” Sheedy said. “It’s nice to be able to lock up somewhere, walk inside and not have to worry about parking,”

Riding a bicycle also offers opportunities to build community and meet new people through races, events or challenge programs. 

According to Dowdy, the ZAP Bike Commuting Program is one initiative offered at the University in coordination with The Hub. Participants’ biking data is recorded via tags attached to each bicycle by electronic readers scattered throughout Minneapolis.

“When you participate in the program, you get periodic rewards,” Dowdy said. “You bring your student ID in, and then you get a gift card to a local restaurant or something like that.” 

Minneapolis has an extensive network of paths and bike lanes connecting campus to many shopping centers and scenic parks.

Marcy Levine, an employee at Freewheel Bike, a Twin Cities bike shop with several locations, including one in Cedar-Riverside near West Bank, said the Twin Cities are frequently ranked in the top three or five most bicycle-friendly cities in the country.  

“Hennepin County, and Minneapolis in particular, have very well-developed bike lanes, both separate from the street and straight on the street,” Levine said. “They’re well mapped out. They’re well marked, and the Hennepin County Transportation Board has done a good job of what they refer to as a ‘gap study,’ where they looked at existing bicycle lanes and places where the lanes could be made more useful if you connected one path to another.”

Riding a bicycle rather than driving a car also improves your health and the environment, according to Dowdy. Biking is a good source of physical activity and serves as a viable method of transportation that does not burn fossil fuels and contribute to climate change.

“The more you ride, the healthier you are and therefore the more you’re likely to ride, walk and get outside,” Dowdy said. “All things that don’t involve fossil fuel.” 

The cost of entry to biking can be very low, depending on one’s preferences. I purchased my current used bicycle for just $25, which many passionate cyclists would scoff at, but it has proven to be just as reliable as any other bike.  

The University has several programs to help students get bicycles at little to no cost, such as the Gopher Bikes Program, which currently allows students to rent a bicycle for an entire semester at no cost.  

According to Levine, the University Reuse Program also offers an annual used bicycle sale every spring in which abandoned bicycles found across campus are repaired by student mechanics and sold at affordable prices.

Unlike cars, bicycles do not come with the assumption of constant gas bills, expanding their affordability. Maintenance for bicycles is also far less expensive and easier to learn, Dowdy added.

“It feels good to have a reliable form of transportation that I know how to work on, fix and modify,” Sheedy said.

Regardless of which type of bicycle you ride — new or used, owned or loaned, cheap or expensive — all carry the underlying benefits.

“Our motto is, ‘All types of bikes for all types of people,’” Dowdy said. “If you love it, if it works, if it’s well maintained, it’s pretty good.”

Learn from my mistakes, and get a bike lock strong enough to withstand wire cutters.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Get a bike!

Opinion: Bus routes are hindered by the Twin Cities’ urban design

One of my largest deciding factors when choosing the University of Minnesota was the ease of access to public transportation. With a light rail line, several Metro Transit bus routes and even the University’s own network of campus buses, student life without a car should be simple in theory.

After my first year on campus, however, it is clear that relying solely on public transit is much easier said than done.

Even though getting around campus by bus or train is relatively effective, anytime I wish to travel to off-campus destinations for shopping or entertainment, the viability of public transit rapidly diminishes. This often isn’t due to any failures on behalf of bus operators, rather, the layout of the city itself is to blame.

Manager of Route Planning at Metro Transit Cyndi Harper leads the team that plans the stop locations and frequencies of bus routes in the Twin Cities. According to Harper, using public transit has many well-recorded benefits for the environment. For example, more people traveling together on public transit rather than driving alone in separate cars means fewer greenhouse gas emissions, helping reduce the speed of climate change.

Relying on public transit rather than cars for day-to-day travel is also beneficial for one’s quality of life, according to Harper. 

“Transit is one of the few places anymore where people interact with others that aren’t necessarily just like them and build a community and understanding that your particular outlook is not the only valid viewpoint that exists,” Harper said.  

With so many positive aspects of public transit, it holds value for thousands of students. The Metro Transit routes serving campus already provide efficient connections to many parts of the city. 

The campus is already served by two types of bus routes: local routes and commuter routes, according to Harper.  

Raymond Romero is a Como resident who relies solely on public transit in his daily life.

“It’s pretty easy to survive here without a car if you know how to use Google Maps,” Romero said.

Romero suggested that some bus routes could be improved in reliability, but appreciates the services overall.

“I’d like to see a higher frequency from the 4 (bus route),” Romero said. “That one went downhill after the pandemic.”

Living without a car in Minneapolis is far less feasible for other local residents. 

Brady Johnson, a recent graduate of the University, uses his car and occasionally the light rail for transportation, but rarely Metro Transit buses. Johnson said the Minneapolis public transit system is not extensive enough to be as reliable as cars. 

“Compared to D.C. or New York or Chicago or a lot of other major cities, I feel like we don’t really have as good of a train system,” Johnson said.

Ultimately, the extent to which living without a car is reasonable depends greatly on one’s lifestyle. 

Public transportation options to certain areas are often limited due to flaws in the city’s layout.  Many businesses not present in the immediate campus area, such as hardware stores, craft supply stores or even traditional movie theaters, require students to travel to suburban shopping malls like the Rosedale Center. However, accessing these via public transit is rarely practical.

“Transit service in suburban areas has certainly been traditionally much more challenging to provide just because you don’t have the density of land use and of employment that you do in a more urban area,” Harper said. “It is much more car-oriented. It is frankly sometimes uncomfortable or dangerous to be walking in some of those areas.”  

Harper said even when public transit is readily available to suburban shopping malls, it still requires customers to walk long distances across several parking lots between stores, sending the message that those who arrive by car are the preferred customers.

Taking public transit to these areas is still entirely possible. 

“Students trying to get between campus and Rosedale area, the quickest way to do that would be to take the Green Line to the Snelling station and then transfer to the A Line,” Harper said. “That takes you straight to Rosedale.”

However, the requirement of stopping to transfer means these routes are rarely very efficient. A new route connecting the University directly to Roseville could help solve this problem, but it may not be feasible when the region is still designed with cars in mind.

“We don’t go through all of the various parking lots for all the various big-box stores because it takes forever to do that,” Harper said. “Anybody who had another alternative would be choosing the other alternative instead.”

As long as key shopping areas near campus are oriented toward cars, a majority of students will continue to access them in cars rather than public transit. 

Metro Transit has already come a long way in providing accessible public transportation to students, but until urban design adjusts to allow for better shopping options to exist closer to campus in less car-centric areas, public transportation will always be at a disadvantage.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Bus routes are hindered by the Twin Cities’ urban design

Opinion: Don’t be afraid of downtown Minneapolis!

Every day at the University of Minnesota students eat, sleep and study within sight of one of the largest urban centers in the country. Yet many of us fail to engage with downtown Minneapolis frequently, if at all.

Whether due to concerns of crime or a general lack of familiarity, most students keep their lives confined to campus, with downtown serving little purpose beyond a backdrop for some scenic photos.

However, ignoring downtown means leaving a massive untapped potential for social, cultural and economic experiences.

According to Adam Duininck, President and CEO of the Minneapolis Downtown Council and University of Minnesota graduate, many other universities do not have access to an urban area as unique as downtown Minneapolis.

“My biggest draw to a campus like U was its proximity to downtown,” Duininck said. “It’s a big differentiating factor. Most of the Big 10 schools are in smaller towns like Madison, or at least not areas with large downtowns — thriving downtowns — like ours.”

Yet for many residents and students alike, downtown Minneapolis is immediately associated with one immense negative connotation: crime.

Bryan Weber, a downtown Minneapolis resident who moved to the Twin Cities in 2022, said he appreciates downtown for its variety of public spaces, such as Nicollet Mall and Government Plaza.

“There are a lot of people who do drugs and sketchy stuff,” Weber said.“They’re unpredictable, but you just don’t walk right next to them.”

Weber’s concerns reflect those of many locals who steer clear of downtown, dissuaded by assumptions and generalizations about crime. Ultimately, Weber and thousands of others choose to spend time downtown anyway, and most of their worries fade when considering the actual crime rates, simple safety protocols and potential benefits of downtown life.

The true statistics of crime in downtown Minneapolis show that it is far safer than many assume, and continues to improve with every passing month, according to Duininck.

“We watch these statistics and the reports very closely,” Duininck said “Crime is down here in this first quarter of 2024, anywhere from 15 to 20%, depending on the category.”

According to Duininck, the decrease in crime coincides with a greater law enforcement presence downtown in recent years.

“Our city has been through some tough times in the last few years,” Duininck said. “But I think what’s emerged is a significant commitment from the Minneapolis Police Department and some of the other bodies that oversee safety, such as the Metro Transit Police Department. Our own Downtown Improvement District is active in the public safety space.”

The effectiveness of law enforcement, plus simple mindfulness of one’s surroundings while downtown, are echoed by Twin Cities residents.

Darcy Frank, a volunteer for the Jehovah’s Witness church located downtown, spends time with her colleagues exploring the streets and skyways of Minneapolis.

“I definitely wouldn’t want to be walking around alone in a lot of it,” Frank said. “But we usually pair up, and so I’m not too worried about it.”

Similarly, Weber practices personal safety by avoiding certain parts of the light rail while traveling downtown.

“If you’re afraid of downtown Minneapolis, just don’t get off at the Franklin or Lake train station, and you’ve probably got nothing to be afraid of,” Weber said.

Downtown Minneapolis holds dozens of attractions for people as close as the University or as far away as international countries.

For many people, including Frank, Weber and myself, the best parts of downtown lie in its simple beauties, such as the relaxing sound of an ornate water fountain on Government Plaza or Nicollet Avenue, the astounding architecture of locations such as the IDS Center’s Crystal Court, the massive network of skyways or the diversity of thousands of people coming together in a single location.

Amid these unique locations also lie a wide variety of opportunities for anyone seeking entertainment or cultural experiences. For many years, downtown Minneapolis has been a hub for sporting events and massive concerts, which have only increased in popularity.

“Our attendance of events is through the roof,” Duininck said. “We had over 9 million people attend concerts, sports events and other things — conventions, conferences. We had the highest hotel occupancy last year that we’ve had since 2019, and the highest transit ridership.”

Downtown Minneapolis is an equally good location for smaller outings. Duininck said some of his favorite memories from his years at the University included going to bars, restaurants and theaters downtown.

The solution to downtown Minneapolis’s problems is twofold. It is not merely the responsibility of organizations like the Minneapolis Downtown Council, which continues to unite businesses and community members to improve downtown through active events and communication. It is also a situation we can help improve just by interacting with the vast opportunities downtown already has.

“Active streets are safe streets, so the more people that are downtown, the more feeling of safety it cultivates,” Duininck said.

Spending time downtown is not just beneficial for your experience, it also sparks a feedback loop that continues to improve the city for us all.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Don’t be afraid of downtown Minneapolis!