Author Archives | by Isabella Morden Wheeldon

UMPD terminates outside gun range leasing, ending ICE and outside police department contracts

The University of Minnesota will no longer rent its Rosemount gun range to outside law enforcement groups due to staffing maintenance and potential liability risks, effective Dec. 1, 2025, according to University of Minnesota Police Department Interim Chief Erik Swanson. 

The property will now be exclusively used by UMPD officers.

UMPD leased its gun range to groups outside the University, such as U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and individual renters, for $200 per hour. The University Board of Regents accrued upwards of $18,000 from the Department of Homeland Security from 2022 through 2025, according to public federal spending data. 

Regent James Farnsworth said he was fine with the fact that the University allowed ICE to train on the University’s property, but the decision was never his to make — nor was it the rest of the Board’s. Decisions surrounding the gun range have never been discussed by the board and have always been made by higher administration. 

“From my 30,000-foot lens, according to the Board, it’s not an issue that meets board policy around delegation of authority,” Farnsworth said. “It was definitely something that feels to me like an operational decision by the administration.”

Farnsworth said he had confidence in the University’s higher administration leaders.

“I trusted our University of Minnesota Police Department and our public safety leadership, judgment on how to, and who to, rent out the facility to,” Farnsworth said.

Regent Robyn Gulley said the topic had never been discussed by the Board and said she “did not even know if it was true.

After the nonrenewal contract with ICE was publicized over the summer, students recognized the controversial working relationship translated to larger University issues. To them, this meant protection of their fellow international students.

Luzia Stern, a fourth-year and multimedia director of the University chapter of Young Democratic Socialists for America, pinned responsibility on higher administration.

“There’s this general sentiment that there’s a rise of fascism happening in our country,” Stern said. “Cunningham does not have a backbone when it comes to standing for the students of the University.”

Fourth-year and YDSA activist Eleanor Kennedy said the news of the contract made her rethink her postsecondary education decision.

“I didn’t realize that the University had a relationship with ICE,” Kennedy said.
“If I had known about that, I would have done a little more thinking before I chose to come here.”

Kennedy said she would not put it past University leaders to maintain a relationship with ICE. Both YDSA members were not surprised by this working relationship.

Stern said making the University into a sanctuary school to protect international students is part of YDSA’s petition goal, but they are far from reaching it. 

The reason for the lack of contract renewal is currently unknown to the public.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on UMPD terminates outside gun range leasing, ending ICE and outside police department contracts

How UMN instructors feel about ChatGPT

“What are you trying to be free of? / The living? The miraculous task / of it? Love is for the ones who love the work,” wrote Joseph Fasano, in a poem entitled, “For a Student Who Used AI to Write a Paper.”

University professors like journalism senior lecturer Gayle Golden ask a similar question: “What is the purpose of you being here at a university? What are you trying to build? And how can AI, if at all, help you do that?” 

As AI begins to integrate deeper into our society, universities are now forced to contend with these questions on a massive scale.

At the University of Minnesota, guidelines surrounding AI usage have loosened. The University has partnered with Google’s Gemini as of July, as well as NotebookLM.

While the University has adopted generative AI tools for students and faculty use, instructors have struggled to delegate the role of AI in their prospective classrooms. 

Senior lecturer Nat Bennett at Minnesota Carlson said the journey to incorporating AI use in classrooms adjunctively was not linear..

“It was threatening. If students can just make this stuff without us, what are we doing?” Bennett said. “The more we get to know these tools and find out how they are used, we realize this is the educational relationship we have always been in with students; it’s a learning curve, we want to push them along.”

Bennett said his approach doesn’t involve an automatic F or expulsion arrangements. 

“I have better things to do than to be checking,” Bennett said about AI-written detection services. “It is about the quality of the product and why it matters rather than ‘I think you cheated’. That isn’t a very productive conversation.”

Bennett regularly practices an exercise with his students where they run an assignment prompt through AI and analyze its output.

“It seems like my students seem to think the same thing that studies show: ‘Yeah, it is really good at C minus (grade) level writing,’” Bennett said. 

There are assets and liabilities to these tools. 

Environmental and ethical qualms have sparked a growing culture of AI consciousness. 

Internet users have coined the term “AI psychosis” to describe an unhealthy and ultimately mentally deteriorating reliance on Large Language Model chat-based AI systems like ChatGPT.

16-year-old Adam Raine was one of two young people who committed suicide earlier this year after receiving misguided guidance from ChatGPT. The chat receipts of both suicides suggest long and codependent conversational relationships with the chat service, which was never intended to replace mental health services.

Now, Raine’s parents are suing OpenAI for wrongful death.

It’s not just codependent relationships that are rapidly spurring an anti-AI movement.

Global AI usage is expected to withdraw 4.2-6.6 billion cubic meters of water by 2027, which is more than the total annual water withdrawal of half of the United Kingdom, according to a Cornell University study.

Associate professor Jack Christian teaches the essential first-year writing class. He doesn’t subscribe to a uniform penalty system for AI usage, either. 

Beyond ethical caveats, both Christian and Bennett recognize that a student using AI to cut corners effectively delays a student’s ability to develop their basic writing skills, but they need to understand that on their own.

“I have steered away from viewing it as academically dishonest, even though I think that it is,” Christian said. “Instead, if I am actually grading an assignment, and I am pretty sure AI has been used, I still try to grade the assignment on its merits.”

Christian said he feared English language learners who may be leaning on AI could be subject to discrimination if called out.

“We are not always providing our English language learning students enough support that would be optimal for them to succeed in an English language writing class,” Christian said.

Bennett and Christian acknowledged that AI is everywhere. 

“In internships, they are being told to produce content using AI. If everyone is using it, I do not want to make my classroom kind of an artificial intelligence hermetically sealed chamber,” Bennett said. “I care about, kind of, continuing to have meaningful educational experience and practice with it.”

Golden said she prefers her students to use AI as an enhanced search engine instead of using it to do all the heavy lifting.

“In the end, it is up to the individual student to decide whether AI is deployed to make the ‘sail’ through college, or whether it’s deployed to help the student develop a critical mind,” Golden said. “If you choose that first path, you are really wasting your time and your money.”

Golden said she wanted to ask fatigued students who use AI as a crutch in their “precious years” questions we have not been asking.

“What is making you so tired? We rush around, right? Think about why you’re here at this time in your life and what you’re losing by doing what you won’t be able to, later on,” Golden said.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on How UMN instructors feel about ChatGPT

Students disgusted by US and local gun violence following Annunciation shooting

It has been nearly two weeks since the Annunciation Catholic School experienced one of the Twin Cities’ most significant shootings in recent years. University of Minnesota community members are hurting.

For many University students and alumni, there are only a few degrees of separation from a link to Annunciation Catholic School. Ella Knoell, a fourth-year student at the University, is one of those cases. 

“I worked at a country club in Uptown, so I know people who went to that school. My friends had friends at school that day at that school,” Knoell said. “Obviously, it’s never good to hear about a school shooting, but, it’s, when it’s in your backyard, like, it kind of hits harder, and you know the kids that were killed.”

The Twin Cities community has been showing support for Annunciation Catholic School through symbolic imagery. Across nearby neighborhoods, mourners have adorned trees, streetlamps and poles with blue and green ribbons, showcasing the school’s colors in support of victims.

Linden Hills Neighborhood Forum, a Facebook forum, created the website Bows of Love, in a quest to organize support efforts including volunteer opportunities, donations and ribbon requests. 

The major response to the tragedy has been a call for action, with protests around the state. Leah Kaiser, the mother of a child who was critically wounded by the shooting, recited an African proverb in her speech to Vice President J.D. Vance during his visit to Minneapolis. 

“When you pray, you move your feet,” Kaiser said.

Knoell agrees.

“You need to get mad,” Knoell said about ways to instigate change. 

She recommends community initiative in tandem with legislation.

“There needs to be community initiatives, but I just don’t know how effective they’ll be compared to actually banning AKs,” Knoell said. “Why do we have guns that are literally designed to kill people?”

Public Health Professor Patricia Jewett said she agrees with Knoell’s sentiment. Jewett said gun access is the problem, and the issue is specific to the U.S.

“The reality is I really truly do believe that 99% of gun owners in the U.S. are responsible,” Jewett said. “But we live in a country where it’s very easy to get access to a firearm and the one percent who are not responsible can do a lot of harm.”

The U.S. ranks in the 93rd percentile for overall firearm mortality, 92nd percentile for children and teens and 96th percentile for women, according to a research article from the Commonwealth Fund.

Jewett said we, as a country, are failing our children.

“The U.S. has been on a trajectory where health indicators in children have become worse,” Jewett said. “When you compare the U.S. to comparable OECD (Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development) 18 countries for the risk ratios of firearm injuries, it’s just horrifying.”

For Jesse Thomas, a fourth-year student, the University has never been a safe place. He said the news barely fazed him.

“(I feel) indifferent. Even with the shooting threat a couple winters ago, I wasn’t particularly shaken by it,” Thomas said.

As a mother of school-age children herself, Jewett said the looming threat of gun violence is like background radiation. 

“We live in this society where it’s just normal to be afraid, right? It’s like the background radiation to our lives,” Jewett said. “We always expect that this might happen, right? It’s unlikely that it will happen, but it’s not impossible.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Students disgusted by US and local gun violence following Annunciation shooting

UMN Career Services’ broadcast of U.S. Border Patrol Recruitment webinar sparks outrage

The University of Minnesota’s Career Services website advertised a virtual event for Sept. 3 hosted by the U.S. Border Patrol, which sparked outrage among the University community.

Though the event was still held, the Career Services website deleted the event listing prior to the webinar.

The webinar, which aimed to recruit members of the public for roles in Immigration and Customs Enforcement and Customs and Border Patrol, had faculty calling student safety into question as a result of the departments’ potential campus presence. 

The webinar offered a variety of benefits to potential applicants, including recruitment incentives totaling up to $30,000. 

While the University itself did not host this webinar and credited third-party career services platform Handshake, the Career Services website broadcasted the event listing to University community members.

Amelia Montes, department chair of Chicano and Latino studies, said the post left her feeling nauseated. Before the listing was taken down, Montes urged the University to cut any ties with CBP and ICE in an email to President Rebecca Cunnningham and Provost Gretchen Ritter, among other administrators.

“Such a recruitment (inviting our own students to become Border Patrol Agents) is directly connected to the parallel increase in deportations and vagrant human rights abuses,” Montes wrote in the email.

The webinar aired just months after ICE’s detainment of graduate student Doğukan Gunaydin, which sparked outrage on campus. 

Michael Gallope, professor and chair of cultural studies and comparative literature, said that the University’s mixed messages directly exclude a large group of students.

“It seems impossible to uphold the values of a safe and welcoming environment for international students and students of first-generation migrants while also recruiting students to serve as border patrol agents,” Gallope said.

This is not the first time the University has faced controversy for promoting government recruitment, according to Gallope.

Gallope said this offering reminded him of another recruitment promotion in the ‘80s, which resulted in a large-scale protest.

In 1986, University students attempted to occupy Fraser Hall in opposition to CIA recruitment on campus. This protest was one of a handful of occupations requiring a major police presence, according to the CLA Assembly Report on UMN Student Building Occupations.

During the webinar, one attendee protested the live webinar after being called upon to ask recruitment questions.

“You all should be ashamed of yourselves,” the attendee said. “What you are doing at the border is terrible.”

Rachel Carlson, a program manager for the Department of Homeland Security and one of the webinar organizers, quickly cut off the protester by muting their microphone.

“Please respect the people who work in the government,” Carlson said.

Comments in the webinar chat flowed in following the protestor’s remarks.

“Great job getting him out of here!!!” an attendee said. Another said, “Thank you for muting the libtard!”

The University’s Career Services functions to help students and alumni find employment opportunities, according to their website.

“While the University does not endorse any participating organizations, it is committed to offering a range of career opportunities for students and alumni to consider,” the University said in a statement.

During the webinar, Carlson outlined the hiring process and requirements for attendees interested in CBP positions. They recommended attendees under the age of 40 to consider ICE employment.

CBP and ICE both fall under the DHS, which has begun widespread crackdowns on immigration and illegal entry into the U.S. in recent months.

Webinar speaker Jeff Vining, a CBP agent and recruiter, told attendees that border patrol agents’ efforts aim to protect the U.S. by making sure “people use that front door”.

Some members of the faculty feel that clear-communicated support for immigrant and undocumented students from higher administration has been unreliable and shoddy. Race, Indigeneity, Disability, Gender and Sexuality Studies Director Jimmy Patiño said the University’s compliance is contradictory.

“An action like this reveals that on the one hand, you’re sharing resources and rhetoric that you support immigrant students,” Patiño said. “On the other hand, you’re basically inviting ICE on campus to discuss through career services.”

Patiño said when University leaders refuse to verbally protect undocumented and immigrant students, academic departments are left to pick up the administration’s slack.

Patiño said his department spearheaded the majority of ICE protocol procedures in communications with University legal services, where Patiño said he saw little support from administrators. He said the University’s response to the work done was often limited to little more than sharing available student resources.

“We do not get explicit support from the higher echelons of the University leadership,” Patiño said. “In the spring, we had to detail to our faculty in RIDGS on what the procedures would be if ICE were on campus.”

Montes said the webinar was a part of a bigger picture of tearing families apart.

“I am ashamed and shocked that this is happening in our name,” Montes said. “What this is doing is, this program is helping individuals ruin people’s lives.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on UMN Career Services’ broadcast of U.S. Border Patrol Recruitment webinar sparks outrage

Four vacant Board of Regents seats to be filled by Tim Walz

There are four vacant seats on the Board of Regents as of July 1, due to a deadlocked legislative process. These vacancies are now to be filled by Minnesota Governor Tim Walz, according to the Board of Regents website.

A year before a new regent is selected, the Regent Candidate Advisory Council, a group made up of legislators and community members, releases a regent candidate application. RCAC interviews a wide variety of candidates, with the average interview process reviewing 20 candidates, according to Regent Robyn Gulley.

After interviews are conducted, RCAC then recommends two to four candidates for each position to the Joint Higher Education Committee of the Minnesota Legislature, according to the University of Minnesota Alumni Association..

From there, the Committee votes in one candidate per vacancy. A regent is selected after a vote from a joint convention of the Minnesota Legislature, according to the University Alumni Association.

The joint convention did not happen this year. Gulley attributed it to the climactic January 14 legislative session.

“It really had to do with the makeup of the House and the Senate,” Gulley said. “It was a really tricky legislative session.”

GOP Rep. and Higher Education Finance and Policy Co-Chair Marion Rarick said the process got stuck when Rep. Dan Wolgamott, DFL, disregarded her after she asked him to sign a letter aiming to spur a joint convention to make regent selections.

The answer was an “‘expletive no’” from Wolgamott, Rarick said.

“He refused to sign and didn’t even answer my questions and my request to sign it,” Rarick said. “He just kind of ghosted me.”

Legislators did not get to vote, so the decision is in the hands of Walz. A law from the University of Minnesota’s Constitution states that governors hold the power to choose temporary board members until the Minnesota Legislature can hold a deliberative session.

Even with these vacancies, important budget decisions are underway without input from the four regent seats. The Board’s culture of a strong leadership model often leaves the other Board members out of the loop, according to Gulley.

“The most pressing and timely things come in front of the leadership team, and the rest of the Board isn’t looped in until later,” Gulley said. “Because those leadership elections took place before our new board members came in, it’s going to really affect the full culture of the Board and what we’re working on for the next two years.”

Through this turmoil, the Board was still functional after a few weeks of vacancies, according to Regent James T. Farnsworth.

Walz and his team will launch a new application process soon, according to Gulley. Gulley said she expects Walz to appoint his interim Board members in August or September. 

With these selections, Gulley said she trusts the governor to make good decisions.

“I have full faith in the governor’s ability to choose strong regent candidates,” Gulley said. “There are some folks from the original process that I would really like to see move forward, but we’ll just have to see what he decides to do when it comes out.”

But not all policymakers have faith in Walz. Rarick said she has little faith in Walz’s future picks, even though they are interim.

“I believe he’s going to do political appointments to probably reward somebody,” Rarick said. “And that’s not how you should choose regents.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Four vacant Board of Regents seats to be filled by Tim Walz

Four vacant Board of Regents seats to be filled by Tim Walz

There are four vacant seats on the Board of Regents as of July 1, due to a deadlocked legislative process. These vacancies are now to be filled by Minnesota Governor Tim Walz, according to the Board of Regents website.

A year before a new regent is selected, the Regent Candidate Advisory Council, a group made up of legislators and community members, releases a regent candidate application. RCAC interviews a wide variety of candidates, with the average interview process reviewing 20 candidates, according to Regent Robyn Gulley.

After interviews are conducted, RCAC then recommends two to four candidates for each position to the Joint Higher Education Committee of the Minnesota Legislature, according to the University of Minnesota Alumni Association..

From there, the Committee votes in one candidate per vacancy. A regent is selected after a vote from a joint convention of the Minnesota Legislature, according to the University Alumni Association.

The joint convention did not happen this year. Gulley attributed it to the climactic January 14 legislative session.

“It really had to do with the makeup of the House and the Senate,” Gulley said. “It was a really tricky legislative session.”

GOP Rep. and Higher Education Finance and Policy Co-Chair Marion Rarick said the process got stuck when Rep. Dan Wolgamott, DFL, disregarded her after she asked him to sign a letter aiming to spur a joint convention to make regent selections.

The answer was an “‘expletive no’” from Wolgamott, Rarick said.

“He refused to sign and didn’t even answer my questions and my request to sign it,” Rarick said. “He just kind of ghosted me.”

Legislators did not get to vote, so the decision is in the hands of Walz. A law from the University of Minnesota’s Constitution states that governors hold the power to choose temporary board members until the Minnesota Legislature can hold a deliberative session.

Even with these vacancies, important budget decisions are underway without input from the four regent seats. The Board’s culture of a strong leadership model often leaves the other Board members out of the loop, according to Gulley.

“The most pressing and timely things come in front of the leadership team, and the rest of the Board isn’t looped in until later,” Gulley said. “Because those leadership elections took place before our new board members came in, it’s going to really affect the full culture of the Board and what we’re working on for the next two years.”

Through this turmoil, the Board was still functional after a few weeks of vacancies, according to Regent James T. Farnsworth.

Walz and his team will launch a new application process soon, according to Gulley. Gulley said she expects Walz to appoint his interim Board members in August or September. 

With these selections, Gulley said she trusts the governor to make good decisions.

“I have full faith in the governor’s ability to choose strong regent candidates,” Gulley said. “There are some folks from the original process that I would really like to see move forward, but we’ll just have to see what he decides to do when it comes out.”

But not all policymakers have faith in Walz. Rarick said she has little faith in Walz’s future picks, even though they are interim.

“I believe he’s going to do political appointments to probably reward somebody,” Rarick said. “And that’s not how you should choose regents.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Four vacant Board of Regents seats to be filled by Tim Walz

Four vacant Board of Regents seats to be filled by Tim Walz

There are four vacant seats on the Board of Regents as of July 1, due to a deadlocked legislative process. These vacancies are now to be filled by Minnesota Governor Tim Walz, according to the Board of Regents website.

A year before a new regent is selected, the Regent Candidate Advisory Council, a group made up of legislators and community members, releases a regent candidate application. RCAC interviews a wide variety of candidates, with the average interview process reviewing 20 candidates, according to Regent Robyn Gulley.

After interviews are conducted, RCAC then recommends two to four candidates for each position to the Joint Higher Education Committee of the Minnesota Legislature, according to the University of Minnesota Alumni Association..

From there, the Committee votes in one candidate per vacancy. A regent is selected after a vote from a joint convention of the Minnesota Legislature, according to the University Alumni Association.

The joint convention did not happen this year. Gulley attributed it to the climactic January 14 legislative session.

“It really had to do with the makeup of the House and the Senate,” Gulley said. “It was a really tricky legislative session.”

GOP Rep. and Higher Education Finance and Policy Co-Chair Marion Rarick said the process got stuck when Rep. Dan Wolgamott, DFL, disregarded her after she asked him to sign a letter aiming to spur a joint convention to make regent selections.

The answer was an “‘expletive no’” from Wolgamott, Rarick said.

“He refused to sign and didn’t even answer my questions and my request to sign it,” Rarick said. “He just kind of ghosted me.”

Legislators did not get to vote, so the decision is in the hands of Walz. A law from the University of Minnesota’s Constitution states that governors hold the power to choose temporary board members until the Minnesota Legislature can hold a deliberative session.

Even with these vacancies, important budget decisions are underway without input from the four regent seats. The Board’s culture of a strong leadership model often leaves the other Board members out of the loop, according to Gulley.

“The most pressing and timely things come in front of the leadership team, and the rest of the Board isn’t looped in until later,” Gulley said. “Because those leadership elections took place before our new board members came in, it’s going to really affect the full culture of the Board and what we’re working on for the next two years.”

Through this turmoil, the Board was still functional after a few weeks of vacancies, according to Regent James T. Farnsworth.

Walz and his team will launch a new application process soon, according to Gulley. Gulley said she expects Walz to appoint his interim Board members in August or September. 

With these selections, Gulley said she trusts the governor to make good decisions.

“I have full faith in the governor’s ability to choose strong regent candidates,” Gulley said. “There are some folks from the original process that I would really like to see move forward, but we’ll just have to see what he decides to do when it comes out.”

But not all policymakers have faith in Walz. Rarick said she has little faith in Walz’s future picks, even though they are interim.

“I believe he’s going to do political appointments to probably reward somebody,” Rarick said. “And that’s not how you should choose regents.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Four vacant Board of Regents seats to be filled by Tim Walz

Four vacant Board of Regents seats to be filled by Tim Walz

There are four vacant seats on the Board of Regents as of July 1, due to a deadlocked legislative process. These vacancies are now to be filled by Minnesota Governor Tim Walz, according to the Board of Regents website.

A year before a new regent is selected, the Regent Candidate Advisory Council, a group made up of legislators and community members, releases a regent candidate application. RCAC interviews a wide variety of candidates, with the average interview process reviewing 20 candidates, according to Regent Robyn Gulley.

After interviews are conducted, RCAC then recommends two to four candidates for each position to the Joint Higher Education Committee of the Minnesota Legislature, according to the University of Minnesota Alumni Association..

From there, the Committee votes in one candidate per vacancy. A regent is selected after a vote from a joint convention of the Minnesota Legislature, according to the University Alumni Association.

The joint convention did not happen this year. Gulley attributed it to the climactic January 14 legislative session.

“It really had to do with the makeup of the House and the Senate,” Gulley said. “It was a really tricky legislative session.”

GOP Rep. and Higher Education Finance and Policy Co-Chair Marion Rarick said the process got stuck when Rep. Dan Wolgamott, DFL, disregarded her after she asked him to sign a letter aiming to spur a joint convention to make regent selections.

The answer was an “‘expletive no’” from Wolgamott, Rarick said.

“He refused to sign and didn’t even answer my questions and my request to sign it,” Rarick said. “He just kind of ghosted me.”

Legislators did not get to vote, so the decision is in the hands of Walz. A law from the University of Minnesota’s Constitution states that governors hold the power to choose temporary board members until the Minnesota Legislature can hold a deliberative session.

Even with these vacancies, important budget decisions are underway without input from the four regent seats. The Board’s culture of a strong leadership model often leaves the other Board members out of the loop, according to Gulley.

“The most pressing and timely things come in front of the leadership team, and the rest of the Board isn’t looped in until later,” Gulley said. “Because those leadership elections took place before our new board members came in, it’s going to really affect the full culture of the Board and what we’re working on for the next two years.”

Through this turmoil, the Board was still functional after a few weeks of vacancies, according to Regent James T. Farnsworth.

Walz and his team will launch a new application process soon, according to Gulley. Gulley said she expects Walz to appoint his interim Board members in August or September. 

With these selections, Gulley said she trusts the governor to make good decisions.

“I have full faith in the governor’s ability to choose strong regent candidates,” Gulley said. “There are some folks from the original process that I would really like to see move forward, but we’ll just have to see what he decides to do when it comes out.”

But not all policymakers have faith in Walz. Rarick said she has little faith in Walz’s future picks, even though they are interim.

“I believe he’s going to do political appointments to probably reward somebody,” Rarick said. “And that’s not how you should choose regents.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Four vacant Board of Regents seats to be filled by Tim Walz

Sterilization rates rose among young adults after Dobbs v. Jackson

Sterilization rates among young adults in the United States have increased in recent years as abortion restrictions and access to contraception have become limited in post-Dobbs v. Jackson America. 

Following the Supreme Court’s ruling, which eliminated the constitutional right to abortion, studies have shown adults ages 19-26 have sought out permanent contraception at higher rates since 2022, the year the ruling was decided. 

What the data tells us

Physicians are seeing increased interest in permanent contraceptives such as vasectomies and tubal sterilizations, according to recent research published by Health Affairs, a health policy journal. 

Researchers from George Washington University, the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and the University of Michigan found visits for both vasectomies and tubal sterilizations were higher in states likely to ban abortion among adults ages 19-26, according to data from 2021 and 2022.

Young adults living in states with a Republican majority were more likely to pursue permanent contraception than young adults living in Democrat leaning states, according to the study.

University of Minnesota professor and urologist Dr. Joshua Bodie said that while the number of vasectomies he can perform in a week is capped, which limits him from seeing an uptick in performed vasectomies, he agreed that there is “more demand and discussion” around vasectomies.

An OB-GYN and University associate professor, Dr. Jessika Ralph, said her patients have vocalized more interest around permanent contraception.

“I would say anecdotally that we’ve had more requests,” Ralph said. “I would say more requests from people who have never been pregnant and do not desire to ever be pregnant.”

Vasectomy procedures increased by 30% nationally in 2022 from July through September compared to the same period of time in 2021, according to research by Komodo Health. In states with restrictive abortion trigger laws, designed to ban or severely restrict abortions following the overturning of Roe v. Wade, vasectomies increased by 39%.

Tubal ligation procedures, where the fallopian tubes are blocked, clipped or removed, rose by 3% per month in states with abortion bans from July to December 2022, according to a JAMA Network study.  

Barriers to sterilization

Younger adults are commonly discouraged from sterilization procedures from their healthcare providers and for financial reasons, according to Health Affairs.

Vasectomies can cost up to $1,000, and tubal ligations can cost up to $6,000 in Minnesota, according to Planned Parenthood.

Almost all state Medicaid policies do not cover sterilization for patients who are younger than 21, according to the National Library of Medicine.

Melissa Saftner, director of the Nurse Midwifery Program at the University School of Nursing, said she experienced healthcare professionals reluctant to offer the procedures.

“When I first started practicing as a midwife, there was still this hesitation with my physician colleagues to offer sterilization to young patients,” Saftner said. “I think now physicians are more open to providing that care because they recognize bodily autonomy and legal policies.”

Ralph also said she heard similar feedback from her own patients. Patients sought out OB-GYN care at the University because other physicians refused the same care, according to Ralph.

Doctors have used the possibility of sterilization reversal to discourage young patients from pursuing permanent contraception procedures, according to the research published by Health Affairs. 

On average, only 6% of men who undergo a vasectomy seek a reversal, according to a study published by Springer Nature Link.

The interest in tubal ligation is higher compared to vasectomies, according to the research published by Health Affairs.

Tubal ligations are similarly performed at higher rates compared to vasectomies, despite vasectomies being considered “cheaper, less invasive, and lower-risk” procedures, according to the article published by Health Affairs.

Jennifer Gunn, associate professor in the History of Medicine program at the University, said this may be because women feel more responsibility when it comes to contraceptive use, and cultural fears from men surrounding vasectomies.

“Ultimately, the costs of childbearing are disproportionately borne by women, the risks for women are greater and the risks of childbearing and unwanted childbearing are greater for women,” Gunn said. “Women taking responsibility for this has always been a part of contraception, even when there were not reliable contraceptive methods.”

The future for contraceptives 

The rise in interest in sterilization stems from the fear of further rights being taken away, even in blue states like Minnesota, according to Health Affairs.

Ralph said she heard a significant number of patient concerns around the time of the Dobbs decision regarding contraception access.

“We had many patients express that anxiety and say, ‘Do I consider a permanent procedure?’” Ralph said. “Because we may not have anything available to us in the future.”

Saftner said the  Dobbs v. Jackson decision is eye-opening for many young adults when it comes to their reproductive health.

“It’s persuading people to make decisions that they might not have otherwise made,” Saftner said. “Maybe before they would have gone with something like an IUD or just pills, but they were concerned that if they were to get unintentionally pregnant, they wouldn’t have any choices.”

Gunn said anxieties about insurance coverage for all contraceptives could contribute to this.

“I wouldn’t necessarily say that people in states where abortion is still legal, actually, don’t worry about it,” Gunn said. “Given the current politics that everybody worries about a national ban or increasing access through things like lack of insurance like changes in insurance coverage for various kinds of procedures.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Sterilization rates rose among young adults after Dobbs v. Jackson

Sterilization rates rose among young adults after Dobbs v. Jackson

Sterilization rates among young adults in the United States have increased in recent years as abortion restrictions and access to contraception have become limited in post-Dobbs v. Jackson America. 

Following the Supreme Court’s ruling, which eliminated the constitutional right to abortion, studies have shown adults ages 19-26 have sought out permanent contraception at higher rates since 2022, the year the ruling was decided. 

What the data tells us

Physicians are seeing increased interest in permanent contraceptives such as vasectomies and tubal sterilizations, according to recent research published by Health Affairs, a health policy journal. 

Researchers from George Washington University, the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and the University of Michigan found visits for both vasectomies and tubal sterilizations were higher in states likely to ban abortion among adults ages 19-26, according to data from 2021 and 2022.

Young adults living in states with a Republican majority were more likely to pursue permanent contraception than young adults living in Democrat leaning states, according to the study.

University of Minnesota professor and urologist Dr. Joshua Bodie said that while the number of vasectomies he can perform in a week is capped, which limits him from seeing an uptick in performed vasectomies, he agreed that there is “more demand and discussion” around vasectomies.

An OB-GYN and University associate professor, Dr. Jessika Ralph, said her patients have vocalized more interest around permanent contraception.

“I would say anecdotally that we’ve had more requests,” Ralph said. “I would say more requests from people who have never been pregnant and do not desire to ever be pregnant.”

Vasectomy procedures increased by 30% nationally in 2022 from July through September compared to the same period of time in 2021, according to research by Komodo Health. In states with restrictive abortion trigger laws, designed to ban or severely restrict abortions following the overturning of Roe v. Wade, vasectomies increased by 39%.

Tubal ligation procedures, where the fallopian tubes are blocked, clipped or removed, rose by 3% per month in states with abortion bans from July to December 2022, according to a JAMA Network study.  

Barriers to sterilization

Younger adults are commonly discouraged from sterilization procedures from their healthcare providers and for financial reasons, according to Health Affairs.

Vasectomies can cost up to $1,000, and tubal ligations can cost up to $6,000 in Minnesota, according to Planned Parenthood.

Almost all state Medicaid policies do not cover sterilization for patients who are younger than 21, according to the National Library of Medicine.

Melissa Saftner, director of the Nurse Midwifery Program at the University School of Nursing, said she experienced healthcare professionals reluctant to offer the procedures.

“When I first started practicing as a midwife, there was still this hesitation with my physician colleagues to offer sterilization to young patients,” Saftner said. “I think now physicians are more open to providing that care because they recognize bodily autonomy and legal policies.”

Ralph also said she heard similar feedback from her own patients. Patients sought out OB-GYN care at the University because other physicians refused the same care, according to Ralph.

Doctors have used the possibility of sterilization reversal to discourage young patients from pursuing permanent contraception procedures, according to the research published by Health Affairs. 

On average, only 6% of men who undergo a vasectomy seek a reversal, according to a study published by Springer Nature Link.

The interest in tubal ligation is higher compared to vasectomies, according to the research published by Health Affairs.

Tubal ligations are similarly performed at higher rates compared to vasectomies, despite vasectomies being considered “cheaper, less invasive, and lower-risk” procedures, according to the article published by Health Affairs.

Jennifer Gunn, associate professor in the History of Medicine program at the University, said this may be because women feel more responsibility when it comes to contraceptive use, and cultural fears from men surrounding vasectomies.

“Ultimately, the costs of childbearing are disproportionately borne by women, the risks for women are greater and the risks of childbearing and unwanted childbearing are greater for women,” Gunn said. “Women taking responsibility for this has always been a part of contraception, even when there were not reliable contraceptive methods.”

The future for contraceptives 

The rise in interest in sterilization stems from the fear of further rights being taken away, even in blue states like Minnesota, according to Health Affairs.

Ralph said she heard a significant number of patient concerns around the time of the Dobbs decision regarding contraception access.

“We had many patients express that anxiety and say, ‘Do I consider a permanent procedure?’” Ralph said. “Because we may not have anything available to us in the future.”

Saftner said the  Dobbs v. Jackson decision is eye-opening for many young adults when it comes to their reproductive health.

“It’s persuading people to make decisions that they might not have otherwise made,” Saftner said. “Maybe before they would have gone with something like an IUD or just pills, but they were concerned that if they were to get unintentionally pregnant, they wouldn’t have any choices.”

Gunn said anxieties about insurance coverage for all contraceptives could contribute to this.

“I wouldn’t necessarily say that people in states where abortion is still legal, actually, don’t worry about it,” Gunn said. “Given the current politics that everybody worries about a national ban or increasing access through things like lack of insurance like changes in insurance coverage for various kinds of procedures.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Sterilization rates rose among young adults after Dobbs v. Jackson