Author Archives | by Callie Burch

Opinion: We can learn about self-compassion from Alysa Liu

At only 13 years old, figure skater Alysa Liu became the youngest woman to place first in the U.S. Figure Skating Championships. Three years later, she quit the sport entirely.

Liu longed for the freedom that came with leaving the fiercely competitive world of figure skating. As a child, her world revolved around strict routine and discipline. This lifestyle isn’t unusual for young figure skaters.

Infamous Russian figure skating coach Eteri Tutberidze is known for casting aside skaters once they reach around 17 years of age, or the Tutberidze expiration date. Much of the sport revolves around the idea that younger bodies are better at sustaining the physical demands of figure skating. Its culture is also fraught with athletes who suffer from eating disorders and are pushed past their physical limits in the pursuit of achievements.

In January of 2024, one of Tutberidze’s former students, Kamila Valieva, was banned from the Olympics for four years after a failed drug test before the 2022 Winter Olympics. The Court of Arbitration for Sport discovered that she was given 56 medications, nutritional and dietary supplements to improve her athletic performance, though she was still just a child. 

Looming at the back of every young athlete’s mind is the fear that without harsh treatment, they can never improve. The pain is supposed to serve as proof that you earned your success.

Leaving a career that was negatively impacting her wasn’t a sign of weakness for Liu. It was a sign of resilience. University of Minnesota psychology professor Patricia Frazier said we are resilient creatures by design. Our culture can push the idea that experiencing hardship or tragedy devastates you for the rest of your life, but Frazier said this isn’t always true. 

Viewing setbacks as personal failures and punishing yourself when you don’t meet expectations is counterintuitive to making progress, no matter the area of your life or the skill you’re trying to accomplish.

Liu’s comeback signaled a shift in this culture. Coming out of retirement, Liu was the one making demands. She declared she was going to pick her own music, decide how much she pushed herself and not let anyone starve her in the name of athletic success. 

At the 2026 Winter Olympics, 20-year-old Liu took home the gold medal in women’s singles. Watching Liu’s triumph, despite the rigid standards set for figure skaters, gave me a sense of optimism for how we can positively change the way we motivate ourselves and define achievement.

Before Milano Cortina, Liu talked about how she views struggling as something to appreciate rather than as an obstacle or something to fear. Her focus on sharing her artistry triumphs over a need for perfection.

In a sports culture dominated by extreme comparison, University athletes are also changing the relationship they have with their athletics. First-year rugby player Olivia Spencer said that although rugby is a physically demanding sport, there’s space for everyone to play.

“The beautiful thing about rugby is that there’s a place for everybody all the time,” Spencer said. “You don’t have to be super fast or super strong, or you can be a combination of the two or neither at all.”

Motivation in the sport isn’t fueled by negative attitudes. For Spencer, the most important aspect of motivation for improving in her sport comes from her connection with her teammates.

“I think a big part of it is just really taking the time to get to know each other outside of rugby,” Spencer said. “We do so much together, and I think that’s like, a big part of motivation is just showing up to a group of people who want to see you all the time and want to be there with you.”

The mindset with which you treat yourself can impact your overall well-being, both positively and negatively, so why do we view suffering as the best path to improvement? Frazier said that while self-criticism acts as a coping mechanism, there are more positive methods of motivation.

“The way you think about situations has a really strong impact on how you feel about them and what you’re going to do about them,” Frazier said.

Liu won gold by prioritizing being kind to herself and viewing her struggle as something to be celebrated rather than shunned.

We should learn from these athletes who are changing how they perceive their own success and motivation, and begin to understand the benefits of looking at our personal progress through a more compassionate lens.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: We can learn about self-compassion from Alysa Liu

Opinion: Female aging isn’t negative, and the media can help prove it

Generation Z women have a harrowing fear of aging. In all fairness, it’s not exactly their fault. Media targeted at young women tries its best to justify those fears by how it portrays getting old.

Older women in movies and television are often seen as entirely sexless and devoid of the pleasures reserved for their youth, from drinking and going out with friends to enjoying any type of fun in their lives.

University of Minnesota cultural studies and comparative literature professor Maggie Hennefeld said Gen Z women seeing negative representations of aging can have personal ramifications for young women.

“That’s a really sad reality to think that any young woman or young person has to expect the second or third decade of life, they’ll simply age out of relevance,” Hennefeld said. 

The important cultural shift taking place is young women discovering media that dispel negative stereotypes about aging.

“As we know, dominant images and the culture sort of trickle down to other walks of life and professions,” Hennefeld said. “And people really build their hopes and dreams around their identification with celebrities, movies, TV shows, popular culture means a lot to people.”

In season one of “Sex and the City,” Samantha Jones was 40 years old. She wasn’t married, she had a public relations career where she dominated in her field, she regularly partied, and she was having casual sex whenever and with whomever she wanted. Her lifestyle went against popular ideas about what it means to be a woman in your 40s.

Carrie Bradshaw is 38 years old in the final season, yet she still struggles with several relationship and life problems and isn’t contemplating having children any time soon. Her life still correlates with the lives of women younger than her.

Looking at the show now, it makes our cultural obsession with preventing aging so early in our lives seem ridiculous. The portrayal of the women in “Sex and the City” quieted some of the fears that Gen Z women have about losing an imagined spark that comes with being in their late teens and early 20s.

Aesthetic fears also play their part. To sell young women on preventative aging measures like retinol and Botox, businesses must make sure girls view growing old as a negative aspect of their future.

These fears tie into a male-dominated culture obsessed with how women look. When the men who run media corporations decide older women are less attractive, they continually push the narrative that being an older woman is something to be ashamed of. With this comes a loss of agency for women in how they’re portrayed on screen.

University communications studies professor Mary Vavrus said we need more women in media industry roles.

“Breaking up some monopolies that control our media would help too, because they’re owned and controlled mainly by older white men, and so they tend to not have great representations featuring older women being powerful,” Vavrus said. “Because it goes against what their sponsors want, it goes against probably what they want in their own personal lives.”

How women are viewed in the media is largely dictated by people who have never had women’s best interests in mind.

Hennefeld said there’s a long tradition of fetishization of women in popular culture and that it can play into how we view women aging.

“Feminist film theorist Laura Mulvey has this term she coins called ‘To-be-looked-at-ness,’” Hennefeld said. “I think it’s spot on as an analysis of the kind of dominant tropes of representation, at least in classical Hollywood cinema, that women are just sort of there to be looked at. They’re the bearers of the gaze, not the subjects or agents.”

In January, actress Demi Moore won a Golden Globe for her portrayal of Elisabeth Sparkle in “The Substance,” a female-directed horror movie about the cost of older women being subjected to Hollywood’s misogynistic standards.  

Moore is 63, and despite having numerous roles as a young star, has gotten immense acclaim for her recent performance and has seen a surge in interviews surrounding her career. Praise for older women in Hollywood has special meaning, as those in the industry are often the ones being pressured the most to stay looking youthful.

Vavrus said media representations give us so much information about one another.

“There’s this theory of representation that says media representations are what we use to constitute the meanings of things and people,” Vavrus said. “And so positive media representations of anyone help us to dispel stereotypes and create more information that we can use to have positive interactions with one another. They can be very pro-social.”

Although it’s important to learn to validate ourselves, it’s significant that Gen Z women are able to internalize seeing actresses like Moore receive admiration, because in the digital age, so much of our self-perception comes as a result of the media we’re viewing. 

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Female aging isn’t negative, and the media can help prove it

Opinion: Female journalists need support

Watching iconic 2000s-era rom coms didn’t make me want to fall in love. It made me want to be a journalist. 

Seeing various film protagonists live glamorously while pursuing fulfilling writing careers led me to believe the real-life industry might also share that same support for leading female voices.

Looking around at my peers in my journalism courses, I would expect that graduating and pursuing a career in media would entail working in a female-dominated environment. But while women make up two-thirds of students pursuing degrees in journalism, the reality of newsrooms doesn’t reflect this.   

In plenty of U.S. media outlets, the highest-paying positions still tend to be overrun by men. Female journalists are also underrepresented in the types of stories they cover. Men largely dominate sports, politics and science coverage, and women’s perspectives on these important topics often go unheard.

To see more women succeed in journalism, we need to address the barriers that prevent them from breaking into the industry and staying in it long-term. Workplace environments play a large part in the pervasive problems within the industry.

University of Minnesota journalism studies assistant professor Carolina Velloso said women already working as journalists need better support.

“Lots of women have reported leaving the industry for other reasons, such as professional difficulties, gender-based harassment and a general lack of support in the forms of robust maternity leave programs and things of that nature that would allow women to remain longer in the industry,” Velloso said.

Women who do decide to have children often fear that their journalistic careers will fade or be sidelined, a worry their male peers don’t seem to share. Having to shape your career around family life is a burden often reserved for women, and in a fast-paced newsroom environment, that can hurt your career. Even if you don’t decide to have children, the way you’re treated by your peers can greatly impact how long you decide to stay actively working and pursuing your goals.  

University media and journalism studies associate professor Diane Cormany reflected on starting at a male-dominated engineering magazine, where her presence drew negative attention. 

“I was one of three or four women in the entire field,” Cormany said. “You have to kind of work to be respected and considered an equal.”

In 2026, the influence of the internet adds another layer of pressure, giving users a platform to anonymously intimidate and harm female journalists. A combination of unchecked workplace harassment, higher levels of scrutiny and rampant online abuse work in tandem to prevent female journalists from doing the work they love at full capacity.

“If you watch a live press conference, the women get overlooked constantly,” Cormany said.

Discrimination during press conferences is especially volatile during Donald Trump’s term as president. Trump continues to shut down and insult female reporters, even in front of large audiences. 

Publicly rejecting the poor treatment of female journalists is the starting point for creating an industry where women are treated with the same dignity as their male peers.

Velloso said her time researching gender and media was impactful for how she saw disparity in the journalism field.

“It’s been eye-opening to see how many women prematurely leave the industry,” Velloso said. “Larger cultural shifts need to happen in order to support all journalists in having long and successful careers in the industry.”

Cormany said supporting anyone going into the field of journalism is vital, considering the number of people joining has dwindled. We need to encourage the people who feel journalism is a viable career for them and continue to support women once they’re in the field.   

“People just feeling like this is a field they want to pursue, that’s important,” Cormany said. “There’s the overall industry trends that are kind of fighting against even having those editor roles to begin with.”

There are bright futures for female journalists as long as we’re willing to stand by them along the way. 

“I think women need to support women and help uplift people to succeed in those roles,” Cormany said. “When I was out there, and I was getting into editorial, it was because I had people I was working alongside who were kind of seeing something in me and making sure to hold me up and push me forward.”

Listening to the experiences of female journalists and preparing women for the field in college will help future writers navigate their careers better.

“Women leaving the journalism industry is a systemic issue that can only really be solved by a large concerted effort across the industry to improve working conditions for all journalists,” Velloso said.

In the meantime, we need to better prepare and support student journalists if we want them to go far in their careers. 

Although female journalists continue to succeed and break barriers, gender-based discrimination should never be part of a job description.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Female journalists need support

Opinion: We need to start rocking the boat instead of just rowing it

Chances are, we’ve all been in a situation where a friend or family member gave their take on a social or political issue that we didn’t agree with, and it made us take a step back. While our first instinct may be to flee or deflect, we need to stop trying to keep the peace.

In talking to my Generation Z peers, a common denominator always seems to be a distaste for confrontation and a need to be liked by everyone, even if it’s someone they fundamentally disagree with.

This fear of ostracization from those who disagree, or even from friends who want us to stay silent, encourages a bad habit of not speaking our minds even when we know we should. 

University of Minnesota sociology professor Claire Kamp Dush said Gen Z might be afraid of losing connections with friends in a world where it’s already hard to make them. She said it can help to talk to people individually and explain why what they said made you uncomfortable, and we can try approaching someone with the idea of  “How would I want to be told that?”

Kamp Dush said a potential source of misinformation for people could be the kind of content they’re encountering on social media, which can play a large role in their opinions.

“I think it’s hard today given that people are in such echo chambers,” Kamp Dush said.

Gen Z’s connection to social media has been a powerful tool for change, but it’s also led to a dangerous rise in conservatism and a fall into alt-right thinking. 

Although in the moment it seems challenging to confront someone we know, it’s actually one of the most significant things we can do to stand with our communities against intolerance and push back against hateful right-wing narratives.

At a time when our state is facing historic levels of violence against marginalized communities, staying silent always has a cost. Studies show exposure to racial and ethnic discrimination correlates with higher positive screening for mental health problems.

University philosophy assistant professor Dwight K. Lewis Jr. said when we stay silent, we’re setting a precedent for the discrimination that is inflicted upon marginalized groups.  

“When we don’t stand up, we become another checkmark in allowing people to give harm,” Lewis said.

For a lot of Americans, existence is political. Many people don’t have the luxury of ignoring the news or turning their heads away when it comes to conversations about race, gender and class because the views and decisions of those in power directly influence their everyday freedoms.

Lewis said how you address situations with the people you’re close to has wide-reaching impacts.

“The reason why you’re not silent is because you have a demanding love towards a community, and you’re also trying to implore your smaller community, your family, your friends, to be loving towards the larger community,” Lewis said. “It’s really about not giving the permission to make people feel unsafe and alienated and protecting those people’s dignity.”

Lewis spoke about a class assignment in which he has students read James Baldwin’s “A Letter to My Nephew.” He asks students to choose someone in their lives that they want to write to, whether it’s a younger version of themselves or someone close to them. The letter is meant to convey what it’s like for the student to move through the world based on their class, race, gender or other positions in society.

“We want to demand them to love others more instead of harming others more,” Lewis said. “Speaking is an act of courage.”

A hallmark of Minnesotan social cues has always been our passive-aggressive demeanor. In some scenarios, it’s just easier to put on a cheerful front even when you don’t feel like it.  

However, our democracy depends on our ability to tell those closest to us when they sound ignorant. We must understand the significance of using our voices to call out prejudice among our peers and family.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: We need to start rocking the boat instead of just rowing it

Opinion: Why are we all so nostalgic for 2016?

As we move into the new year, a wave of reverence for the past has begun to take over Generation Z. We’re returning to our roots: Musical.ly, Kylie Jenner lip kits, Zara Larsson’s “Lush Life,” PINK and the Snapchat dog filter.       

Social media is flooded with people calling for us to collectively go back to 2016 in 2026, and while it might not seem like it means much, our generation clearly longs for a time when life seemed more stable. 

2016 was a time when most Gen Zers were in middle school and high school, before Donald Trump was elected president and before the complete isolation of the COVID-19 pandemic.

As we moved through the years, our world and our surroundings seemed to become murky and confusing. These feelings were coupled with the fact that Gen Zers are becoming adults for the first time, learning how to navigate on our own in a world that has changed significantly from when we were kids.

University of Minnesota journalism professor Matthew Cikovic said nostalgia is often a response to strange and troublesome times.

Gen Z is becoming an incredibly lonely generation, and our economic and political systems add to that stress. The cost of living continues to rise, student debt is an ever-looming presence, and the burdens of being an adult are no longer a worry for your future self. To deal with the stress, Gen Z turns to times when we didn’t feel so weighed down.  

A large part of our attachment to the past is connected to our collective desire to feel more bonded with each other, despite isolation, and to regain the whimsical and carefree attitudes that we possessed when we were younger.

Cikovic said nostalgia has always had complex ways of connecting us.

“Svetlana Boym, the late Russian scholar, talked about how with reflective nostalgia we can find community in our longing,” Cikovic said. “We can find friendship and groups of people that miss the past the same way that we do in ways that are healthy and productive.”

For Gen Z, turning to the past represents more than just a love for the specific aesthetics and popular culture of the time.

University second-year design student Sydney Steiner said bringing back the past also ties into a desire Gen Z has to feel more accepted. 2016 represented an era where people were trying new things and welcoming different styles, such as bright patterns and flashy trends.  

“Especially after COVID, we kind of conformed because, you know, we were so stuck online,” Steiner said. “And I think that now we’re trying to break free from that conformity and embrace more individuality, which we saw a lot of in the 2016-2015 era.”

Steiner recalled attending a 2016-themed party with her friends recently, noting how listening to the cheerful, pop-like throwback music made her reminisce about how the 2016 era felt more lively.

The world appeared to be more fun 10 years ago. There wasn’t an online obsession with the clean girl aesthetic, and everyone seemed to appreciate being more unapologetically colorful, loud and messy.

Although 2016 popular culture is fun to celebrate and look back on, it’s important to recognize the pitfalls of continually looking back at the past through rose-colored lenses. The issue lies in using nostalgia as a way to cope, rather than reflect.

Cikovic said when you become so into the past, you stop seeing it as something to be explored with others. Overwhelming nostalgia can lead people to get stuck in cycles of thinking everything in the past was good and everything in the present is bad, or not what it should be.

“Boym has a line that I think should be over every comment section of the internet, which is, ‘Unreflected nostalgia breeds monsters,’” Cikovic said.

Being continually sad about not living in the past will only make us more jaded and isolated than we already are.   

Although it’s easy to lament about our current difficulties, of which there are plenty, it’s important not to let your love for the past lead you to give up trying to make the present a better time to live in.

Learning to take the positive attributes of past years — while also working to foster a better sense of community and understanding in the present — could be Gen Z’s greatest asset, as they navigate the future ahead.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Why are we all so nostalgic for 2016?

Opinion: AI is enabling abuse of women online

What would you do if you no longer had control of your likeness? This daunting question has become the new reality for any woman not completely off the grid in the 21st century.

If you’ve scrolled through your social media feed recently, you may have noticed an alarming trend emerging: images powered by artificial intelligence, particularly of women, referred to as deepfakes.

Deepfakes often consist of images and videos of real women that have been altered in any way their creators envisioned, forming Frankenstein-esque scenes of women ranging from altering the amount of clothing they’re wearing to putting them in compromising sexual scenarios.  

Users on X have found that they can take images and videos of women and feed them into X’s AI bot, Grok, with little to no obstacles. The consequences are a total loss of consent.

University of Minnesota computer science professor Lana Yarosh said there are currently few laws enacted and enforced around distributing deepfake material. This type of content is very easy to make and post, and it is almost impossible to garner consequences for doing so.

“You don’t have to have any kind of a technical background,” Yarosh said. “If you can use an app, or you can use a program on your computer, you can create deepfake content — especially deepfake content of women, because essentially like 98% of these systems are designed to make deepfake content of women.”

At the center of the problem with deepfakes lies our societal oppression of women and our need to control them. Being told “no” carries less weight in online spaces when men decide it’s okay to find ways to bypass that rejection.

The use of AI technology as a means of control will inevitably lead to nightmare scenarios for the women involved. Yarosh said despite people’s assumptions that online content can’t actually hurt real people, its impacts are incredibly significant. 

Deepfake content of women with public-facing jobs like teachers and people dealing with custody battles, where content could be used to affect court decisions, are only a couple of ways the internet could bleed into reality, Yarosh added.

University second-year student Natalie Dillon said it’s scary just how easily deepfake images can be spread.

“Things could just get leaked,” Dillon said. “That ruins reputation, that creates shame, it’s just terrible.”

Many men in the United States already have issues understanding consent, and how they are choosing to utilize AI is indicative of that. Coupled with the fact that there’s little precedent for how to handle evolving AI technology, it is clear we need to pressure tech companies to tighten the reins.

There’s only one problem: will they want to?

Dillon said tech companies will not eliminate deepfake technology when profit is involved. If AI-generated nudity can generate revenue, they won’t be interested in getting rid of it.

X already put Grok behind a paywall, which strengthens Dillon’s argument and proves that companies are ready to profit from the control of women’s bodies. 

Elon Musk even referred to the British government as fascist, after ministers threatened to block X due to the rise in dangerous deepfake technology being used against women.

Companies have to start caring more about protecting women than placating male users to appropriately manage deepfake content.

Yarosh said companies can refuse to host harmful images and content and could make reporting and removing the content easy. Additionally, the tech teams responsible for creating and managing this kind of content need to be liable. 

“The law needs to catch up,” Yarosh said. “And systems advance so quickly that it’s very difficult for the current processes to actually make the kinds of changes that need to be happening, in order to create systems of accountability that would protect women and allow abusers to be held accountable.”

We desperately need to change how we understand consent and our cultural attitudes toward women’s autonomy. A good place to start is rethinking how we handle AI-generated content made to hurt women online and in real life.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: AI is enabling abuse of women online

Opinion: College students should practice better body acceptance

While college is the perfect time to grow into yourself physically and mentally, it can also be a time when you’re evaluating how you measure up compared to your peers. Navigating a setting where you’re suddenly observing so many different people can lead to an unhealthy amount of comparison.

University of Minnesota professor of social work Ginny Winter said negative body image starts in adolescence and rises through young adulthood.

“It all goes back to the negative messages we’re receiving around bodies and sometimes that’s equated with weight and health,” Winter said. “The reality is that we know you can be healthy at any size, that your size doesn’t determine your health and vice versa.”

Students who continuously consume social media content and peer opinions that promote and uphold rigid body standards can have a hard time forming a good relationship with their bodies. Additionally, being in college at a time when the rise of weight loss drugs is skyrocketing puts pressure on students who already have a propensity for comparison.

Winter said many of the messages around weight loss drugs perpetuate the idea that being thin is always healthier and better, despite research showing that this is not true. Although she said she doesn’t judge anyone who chooses to take these medications, the messaging behind them is harmful.

“It’s very possible that in order to maintain weight loss from these medications, that would mean taking them for the long term and we just don’t know what that means in terms of side effects,” Winter said.

An easier alternative to trying to physically “fix” what we don’t like about ourselves is learning to sit with our thoughts and question why we feel the way we do about our bodies. As we go through the life transitions college brings, one of the most important things we can do is recognize that our bodies aren’t accessories.

Positive or even neutral self-image of our bodies is a skill that we need to teach ourselves in college so we are better equipped to embrace the inevitable changes our bodies will go through as we age.

Because it’s not always realistic to tell college students to have unwavering love for their bodies, learning to develop neutral viewpoints about our bodies and valuing what our bodies can do, rather than how they look, can be a useful tool for students who are struggling with body image. Being able to acknowledge what our bodies do for us rather than what they look like is a key starting point in valuing ourselves more.

Winter said it can be hard to filter through the memos we receive about our bodies and still walk away with a positive body image.

“A couple of things that I would recommend are to set clear boundaries about your body and the messages you want around you,” Winter said. “That might look like telling people closest to you that you’re not going to talk about body size or dieting and that you would appreciate it if they wouldn’t engage in those conversations with you.”

Winter said another way to help is by curating your social media feed to counter negativity around body image.

“There’s a lot of negative imaging and messaging on social media, but that doesn’t mean you can’t be really intentional about following accounts on Instagram, or whatever platform you’re on, that are sending positive messages,” Winter said.

Winter added that refusing to engage in conversation with family members about food over the holidays can help. Steering a conversation away from making comments about how much you’re eating or how you’re going to have to work off your holiday weight can help students cultivate better relationships with their bodies when they’re away from school.

The reality is that after college, our bodies are going to continue to change in ways we might not expect, and that can be intimidating.

If we learn to develop strategies that help us cultivate and maintain a healthier and more balanced connection to our body image in college, we will all be better off mentally and physically for years to come.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: College students should practice better body acceptance

Opinion: UMN nursing students deserve more respect

Some of the most passionate and hardworking students I know aspire to pursue careers in nursing. I have always appreciated the dedication nurses have, but talking to a close friend about her nursing school experience was the first time I realized just how passionate they are.

The way her face lit up while talking about spending long nights working in a pediatric unit, and the fact that she could balance a social life, school work and clinicals and still come out of it all with pure enthusiasm for her work, gave me a pretty good sense of the type of people who choose to go into nursing.

Director of the University of Minnesota School of Nursing’s Office of Student and Career Advancement Services, Kathryn Schwartz, said the nursing program has students who are wonderful to work with.

“They come to a problem with the desire to help and make it better, but also the skill set to really bring value and a different lens into how we might solve those problems,” Schwartz said. “So I think that that’s a beautiful way to go through the world, but also to contribute to the campus community.”

The U.S. Department of Education recently proposed redefining which programs are considered professional degrees. Notably excluded from this new definition are graduate nursing programs.  

If approved and implemented next year, students pursuing further education in nursing would be eligible for less financial support for graduate programs. These programs are already incredibly expensive.

While not every student pursuing a bachelor’s degree in nursing may want to continue schooling, those looking to become advanced practice nurses or further their education in other ways could face a harder path.  

A loss of funding could also discourage prospective nursing students from pursuing their education altogether, which would be bad news for a field that is already desperately looking for more people.  

University School of Nursing Dean Connie Delaney said some hospitals don’t have beds open due to low staffing.

“We have the most dire shortage going on in literally every state, every care environment,” Delaney said.  

The Education Department recognized that professional programs are ones that lead to licensure and practice, which nursing certainly does. But their actions don’t match their words.

Beyond monetary limitations, the decision symbolizes a clear disregard for a population of healthcare professionals who have already fought so hard against bias related to their careers.

Registered nurses comprise the largest healthcare occupation, and the profession is dominated by women. The message the department is relaying echoes the sexist sentiment that predominantly female workforces are less worthy of respect.

The rigor of nursing programs, especially at the University, is exhaustive.

“The program’s intense, it’s highly ranked,” Delaney said. “It has everything from classroom to laboratory and simulation to essential clinical experience and actual people’s lives within very complex health systems and in complex communities.”  

The reality is that without nursing, the healthcare system would crumble.

“Nurses, in how they work with patients and families, literally have the pulse on that individual family 24/7,” Delaney said.

Delaney added that the commitment, knowledge and skill inherent to nursing are just some of the factors that make nursing vital to the whole healthcare system. 

“Nursing, by the public, is rated as the most trusted profession, and there’s a reason for that,” Delaney said. “Because we keep the patient and the family first, not ourselves.”

Schwartz said nurses have a deep skill set they utilize when navigating a complex health system.

“Our nursing students bring that compassion and that scientific mind together in a way that we just don’t see in a lot of other professions, and they do it with grace,” Schwartz said.

Learning about the virtual reality scenarios nursing students complete stuck out to me as an example of their dedication to patient care.

School of Nursing communications and marketing director Steven Rudolph described one scenario where a patient is going to go home but then realizes they don’t have a ride, and the nursing students must navigate the situation. That situation, and others like it, demonstrate how nursing reaches beyond a hospital setting.

It’s clear that nursing students go above and beyond to hone their craft while also pursuing a rigorous education path. University faculty and students should acknowledge the endless effort it takes to pursue nursing and view it with the respect it should have received from the Education Department.

Schwartz said understanding that nursing students are navigating busy schedules and offering flexibility goes a long way.  

Simply acknowledging the tremendous mental and physical effort put into nursing and having someone to talk through the struggles and celebrate the wins with can make a big difference.

The first steps to validating the incredible impact of this profession are to check your biases around female-dominated professions and continuously encourage and affirm students who dedicate so much of their lives to keeping our families and communities healthy.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: UMN nursing students deserve more respect

Opinion: Our relationship with true crime has become toxic

In the 21st century, it seems like nothing is able to shock the generation of young adults who were raised with immediate access to the internet. Online content is now being produced at a rate meant to satisfy and intrigue our brains, which have had uninterrupted doomscrolling privileges for most of our lives.

One of the best examples of content produced with little regard for its ramifications is true crime. Whether it’s a podcast, YouTube video or TikTok, it’s hard to escape the endless barrage of content creators recounting violent crimes like they’re the audience’s personal bedtime stories.

Gruesome murder and assault details are sandwiched between brand deals and makeup tutorials, and it makes me question exactly how we got to this point in our media consumption.

The problem is that we get bored quickly. Especially in terms of online content, it’s easy to try to hunt down the next gory retelling of a case or find a new, more detailed one, all in an attempt to pander to our vivid curiosity.

University of Minnesota communication studies professor Laurie Ouellette said we’ve seen a dramatic surge in the amount of true crime content produced.

“With that surge, we begin to think of true crime as entertainment, and so we might watch it differently than we would a serious documentary or a news report,” Ouellette said.

When content creators and consumers view criminal cases the same way horror fans view slasher films, it becomes easy to disconnect from the fact that the victims in true crime content are real people. It’s also easy to foster misconceptions about how and why violent crimes occur. 

University Ph.D. sociology student Sara Kadoura, who has done extensive research on true crime content and how criminal processes are represented in popular media, said creators don’t have time to critically examine the systems of power at play.

“They focus on the goriest details for that shock value because it’s easy, it’s fast,” Kadoura said. “They know where to look for it.” 

At the root of the issue is how true crime can dull our empathy for victims and their lives. It’s even more unsettling when you factor in that the population disproportionately affected by crimes involving intimate partner violence and sexual assault is women.

Our culture already has a problem with persistent violence against women. True crime content trivializes the lived experiences of victims, oftentimes focusing on gritty details rather than examining how these crimes happen in the first place.

Women, and victims in general, become the details attached to their cases. How they were killed, where they were found, when they went missing and what their injuries were all become fodder for the true crime junkie.

“A lot of true crime, when it addresses violence against women, it’s taking a kind of victim-oriented approach, which can also be problematic in the way that it’s done in an entertainment format,” Ouellette said.

When we continuously engage with this content, it becomes easier for us to get lured in by the cinematic nature of retellings and lose sight of the fact that real tragedy is being summarized for mass consumption. The trivialization that occurs in true crime doesn’t just treat victims as content farms, but also gives the average audience member a warped perception of real-life criminal cases.

“I think it gives people a false sense of danger in places where there isn’t, and maybe makes them less likely to see danger where it is,” Kadoura said. “A woman is far more likely to be victimized by somebody who they know personally than by a stranger, and yet a disproportionately high amount of true crime content has to do with stranger crimes.”

The cases depicted in true crime are often created to narrate something that resembles “Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark” more than an actual crime story that investigates every component of a case.

Kadoura said the accessibility of the internet makes it so anyone can weigh in on cases, even if they aren’t qualified to do so.

“Everybody can look at a Wikipedia page and come up with a really compelling story about murder really quickly,” Kadoura said. “The producers of these podcasts are not doing investigative journalism work, they are not finding this information out themselves.”

Factual errors matter because the content being published about a case ultimately becomes how the general public views its history and impact. When you rely on creators whose main mission is to garner an audience to recount a real-life tragedy, the narrative often falls short.

Kadoura said true crime didn’t always look the same as it does now. She said an early example is the true crime podcast “Serial,” which sheds light on the wrongdoing of the police and justice systems rather than focusing on the crime details.

We can’t do away with true crime content entirely, and I don’t think we should.  

However, if we learn to take a serious look at the quality and quantity of the content we’re partaking in, we may be able to reach a more empathy-based approach to true crime.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Our relationship with true crime has become toxic

Opinion: Media connects us more than we may think

I’ve never seen a better display of collective effervescence than when I sat down with my friend to see the “Nosferatu” remake opening week at The Main Cinema.

The theater was so packed that people who arrived right before showtime opted to sit on the floor for the entire runtime, as there were no options for seat reservations and the theater was already full.

Watching a group of people collectively react to every big story beat and admire in awe at a classic horror remake, which many of them likely already knew the story of, cemented in my mind the relational power media holds.    

When I picture the people I am closest to, a common thread that connects us is what kind of media we like. It’s so much easier to bond with other people when we share favorite movies and TV shows.

Watching something with others feels like a natural, low-pressure environment to bond, and it serves as a way to experience the world and the narrative of a story at the same time as another person.   

University of Minnesota fourth-year student Isabel Alexenko said movies are one of the ways she bonds with her close friends.

“We have a projection set up in our basement, so we’ll have, like, small, intimate screenings of stuff, and it’s been really fun,” Alexenko said.

University second-year student Greta Meissner said a lot of her inside jokes or references with her friends can be traced back to film.

“It kind of becomes this cultural phenomenon, but in a kind of small way in your own life for relationships,” Meissner said.

While it may seem obvious that it’s easy to click with people who share your interests, it’s important to understand the many reasons why media is one of the most powerful connection points we have with those we love.

Fourth-year student Walker Banaszak said media tends to be a relationship jump starter.  

“I understand all this about you based on these things that you like,” Banaszak said, “It’s an easy way to just kind of get to know someone.”

For Banaszak, media is how he first connected with his girlfriend.

“We had a mutual friend who was hosting a movie night, and so we met that way, and [we were] just kind of watching movies for the sake of watching movies,” Banaszak said, “She happened to work in a movie theater so it was kind of like a perfect thing where I’m going to come in and see you because I want to see this new movie.”  

Our favorite movies and TV shows can act as insight for others into our personalities. Although some people may not be quick to show their cards when it comes to their inner selves, their taste in media can reveal some of the more intimate sides of their disposition. Analyzing a person’s favorite media could mean knowing whether someone is a romantic at heart or if they take a more stern approach to life.

Second-year student Anisse Bosu said being a fan of a certain piece of media can even serve as a red flag for her when talking to new people and trying to gauge their personality.

“If someone likes something, it kind of gives you an idea of what they value,” Bosu said.

Knowing what elements of media speak to people can help you comprehend their emotions and get to know them better, before you start to try and form a deeper connection with them socially.

“It is a really good litmus test for whether or not somebody’s cool, is if you enjoy similar media,”  Alexenko said.

Media’s varied narratives can also teach us how to empathize with others’ perspectives in a more approachable way.

Banaszak said media can allow for more productive conversations in a divided time. Discussing what you liked or disliked about a piece of media and what it says about what’s going on around us is an easier way to facilitate discussion.

“Media has been sort of a mediator in terms of talking about hard things,” Banaszak said. “I think recently, when people talk about politics on a surface level, I feel like no one gets very far.”

When it often seems increasingly difficult to talk to one another in our current culture, movies and TV are the best resources we have for representing our different perspectives to other people.

I am, and always will be, the biggest believer that the stories told in movies and television are vital to our collective empathy.

When your professor wants to show you a movie clip or make you read part of an essay, pay attention. Not just because that piece of media is probably costing you around $700, but also because you can gain vital insight into another person’s point of view from the story they’re telling.

College will inevitably present you with an abundance of diverse perspectives, and learning to have compassion for your peers will ultimately make you a better and more well-rounded student and individual.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Opinion: Media connects us more than we may think