Author Archives | by Allison Ogren

Ogren: Fitness trackers vs the couch: a physician speaks

To follow up on my previous piece about fitness trackers, I spoke with William Roberts, a family medicine and community health professor at the University of Minnesota, about fitness trackers in a clinical setting. He had some harsh realities to share.

Fitness trackers can be a helpful tool for tracking activity, food intake and basic health parameters over time. Despite this convenience, fitness trackers are not always useful to doctors trying to encourage healthy habits in a clinical setting, Roberts said in an email to the Minnesota Daily.

While fitness trackers can have several benefits, Roberts said habit-building is likely not one of them. “I am not convinced the devices change behavior. My impression is that active people want to keep track of what they do and inactive people are not particularly interested,” he said.

Roberts himself uses fitness tracking: the app MapMyFitness by Under Armour. This app uses the built-in GPS technology in your phone to track the distance, route and speed of activities like running, walking and cycling.

In line with his personal fitness tracking choices, Roberts said, generally, fitness trackers are most useful for logging distance and time related to activity. However, fitness trackers and all of their colorful features may not be enough to get everyone up and moving. Roberts said, while he does encourage some of his patients to use fitness tracking features on their devices, it isn’t a one-size-fits-all solution.

“Most of my patients have a mobile phone that has an activity tracker embedded in it, and I encourage my patients to use them if it helps or motivates them to exercise, but I do not want to create a barrier to activity by asking patients to use the devices,” Roberts said.

Roberts suggested that a financial incentive in the form of discounted health insurance might be more effective than fitness trackers in getting people to form more healthy and active habits. With health insurance costs these days, I can believe that activity tracking and increasing your step count for a discount would be enticing.

Aside from tracking exercise, fitness trackers are capable of tracking your sleep patterns and how long you are sedentary during the day. Some can even calculate “stress management scores.”

Roberts said he is far more interested in getting people up off the couch than tracking their exercise, and while he is not deeply familiar with the stress management scores offered on the Fitbit platform, he is willing to support it if it helps people manage their stress and mental health.

In terms of clinical usefulness, fitness trackers’ heart monitoring features are much more attractive to Roberts.

“You can get trackers that will record your heart rhythm and produce a high-quality image that is on par with the medical device that I can order for patients,” Roberts said. He added that, in some cases, these fitness tracking devices are also a cheaper option.

Roberts said some of his patients have been able to catch instances of atrial fibrillation, or irregular heart rhythm, using these features in fitness trackers. This is a big deal. So much so, that he has an upcoming academic manuscript on the subject of cardiac rhythm diagnosis in wearable technology, which is not yet in press.

This is on par with what I mentioned in my previous piece about health-tracking devices being capable of cutting some costs in the clinical setting. A cheaper way to get good cardiac monitoring data also has the potential to remove some of the cost-related hesitations in seeking these types of medical testing: a win for both patient and doctor.

Roberts said because there are significant benefits to increasing activity, the goal—encouraging healthy habits—is more important than the strategy. “Inactivity is linked to every noncommunicable disease, and anything that gets people off the couch is a huge plus for public health,” he said.

It’s true. A paper published in Annals of Clinical and Laboratory Science in 2012 describes that a sedentary lifestyle can lead to “disuse syndrome,” which can lead to premature aging, obesity, cardiovascular problems, musculoskeletal fragility, depression and more.

This paper also noted the earlier you increase physical activity in your life, the more likely you are to see the benefits as you age if you maintain those habits.

It appears strapping on a smartwatch is not an easy shortcut to health and fitness. But, it is still essential that you find a way to maintain healthy fitness levels through a means that works for you. The quality of your middle age and elder years depends on it.

Would you like Allison to follow up on this topic or explore something specific? Contact her at aogren@mndaily.com with questions, comments or story ideas.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: Fitness trackers vs the couch: a physician speaks

Ogren: DNA privacy is a civil rights issue

DNA testing has myriad potential benefits. It can tell you what your cancer risks may be or help you find your relatives. However, this sensitive medical information might not always be adequately protected after you test.

Within medical settings, DNA testing is a growing factor in many specialties. Caroline Aragón is a genetic counselor at the University of Minnesota. She told me over email that, while DNA testing is most prevalently used in general and pediatric genetics, hereditary cancer and reproductive clinics, its use is expanding into many other areas as well while testing technologies and interpretation of results improve.

Individuals that use DNA tests are often concerned their genetic information won’t be kept private or could be used against them in some way.

This is a rational fear that can often accompany new technologies that collect and store personal information. Companies like 23 and Me, who provide what is called “direct-to-consumer” genetic testing, have tried to be proactive at assuaging these fears. Their privacy policy states that your DNA information will only be used for purposes that you consent to and will only be shared where you want it to be.

However, consistent privacy and communication policies are not necessarily in place everywhere your DNA information could end up.

A woman in California sued San Francisco Police because her DNA, which had been collected in a rape kit in 2016, was used to arrest her for several burglary offenses in 2021, CNN reported.

She argued that because her DNA was collected when she was the victim of a crime, the use of this information to arrest her for an unrelated crime was an example of unlawful search and seizure and therefore violated her civil rights.

As if rape victims need any more reasons to be hesitant about seeking medical care or reporting the crime.

The San Francisco Police has a policy of adding DNA collected from crime victims into a permanent database that can be searched when trying to identify suspects of crimes later on, CNN reported.

From fingerprints to DNA

Before DNA testing, fingerprints were the “gold standard” for differentiating between individuals that may or may not have been at a crime scene, and fingerprints are still used widely today.

“Fingerprints and DNA data are similar in that they can consist of a pattern unique to you,” Aragón said.

However, she cautioned that the risk of using DNA instead of prints may be higher. “The possibility for errors or wrongfully identifying a DNA match may be greater than when using fingerprints, due to the high level of similarity in the genetic code between individuals, particularly when closely related,” she said.

Aragón also sees the potential for privacy issues with using DNA in criminal investigations. “Because DNA information reveals much more about an individual than a single fingerprint, the possibility for infringing upon privacy rights in these settings seems much greater,” she said.

The case from San Francisco is not the only example of the criminal justice system overstepping ethical boundaries by using dubiously sourced DNA information to catch criminals.

Also in California, blood samples taken from newborn babies as part of newborn screening practices have been used by law enforcement to identify relatives as suspects in crimes, WIRED reported. In one case, a baby’s DNA was used to identify its father as a suspect of a crime.

In these cases, the babies are not even in the criminal justice system when their DNA information is acquired by law enforcement.

Newborn screening can help identify if a child has a serious medical issue following birth and ensure they get timely care. However, the case represents a “whole new leap forward” in the misuse of DNA by law enforcement, Technology Fellow at the American Civil Liberties Union Crystal Grant told WIRED.

“It means that essentially every baby born in the U.S. could be included in police surveillance,” she said.

In the age of patient-centered medical decision-making, how is it possible that we continue to see stories of patients—including victims of rape—having their private medical information shared with the government without their full understanding and consent?

It appears the government has decided that the personal privacy of patients or victims is ranked below that of solving even relatively minor criminal infractions.

If your state has a DNA registry like California’s, is HIPAA out the window?

Aragón noted there is a possibility of reaching a legal compromise in which the rights of the people could be respected while allowing for the use of DNA information in “last resort” circumstances.

She said this type of evidence could be used “if appropriate procedures and respect for privacy rights are followed.”

She cautioned that laws surrounding the use of DNA information should consider “to what extent DNA information may actually be helpful in leading to solving a case.”

Aragón emphasized that in any case involving the use of such private information as DNA, informed consent and proper restrictions are critical to protecting the rights of the individual.

The Declaration of Independence asserts that in order to preserve the unalienable rights of people, governments are instituted by the people “deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed.”

“Consent of the governed” is the operative phrase here. When state institutions lift DNA information from patients without permission, they are not only disregarding this principle of consent but also violating patients’ civil rights.

A crime victim has obviously had their rights violated. Violating the rights of someone else to make up for this is not justifiable. Two wrongs do not make a right.

It appears the current legal landscape surrounding DNA information is not informed by the principle of consent of the governed.

Would you like Allison to follow up on this topic or explore something specific? Contact her at aogren@mndaily.com with questions, comments or story ideas.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: DNA privacy is a civil rights issue

Ogren: Nuclear energy is more than clean; it’s unifying

Professor Todd Allen and influencer Isabella Boemeke advocate for nuclear energy in starkly different ways, but they are both fighting for our clean energy independence. Together, Allen’s pragmatism and Boemeke’s “cool” factor can lead us into the future.

Isabella Boemeke identifies herself as the world’s first nuclear energy influencer. She created the social media identity “Isodope” for this purpose.

In her recent TED Talk, Boemeke advocates for nuclear energy, which she calls our best hope for ditching fossil fuels. Boemeke describes how all of the relevant experts she talked to about nuclear energy agreed that “it’s good, we need it, people hate it.”

While Boemeke takes a more humorous approach to nuclear energy advocacy through sarcasm and the use of popular TikTok trends in her videos, she provides a lot of the same arguments as the technical experts pursuing the same goal.

Todd Allen is a professor and chair of the nuclear engineering & radiological sciences department at the University of Michigan. Unlike Boemeke, Allen takes a pragmatic approach to advocacy.

Allen has pursued becoming an advocate of nuclear energy because he wanted access to public discussions and wanted to make sure we’re not leaving out possible choices that would help us diversify energy sources to protect from cost or availability fluctuations.

Allen noted that nuclear energy plants currently produce 20% of U.S. electricity, which is currently more than 50% of the zero-carbon sources.

So, what are the arguments for nuclear energy according to these advocates?

Nuclear energy is clean, efficient and safe

When developing cleaner energy sources, the levels of carbon emissions (how clean the fuel is), efficiency and safety must all be considered.

“You get no carbon dioxide emissions as you’re producing electricity,” Allen said of nuclear energy. This places nuclear energy in a position to be a valuable alternative to fossil fuels right from the start.

Nuclear has a high energy density, so very little fuel input is needed to generate energy. “You compare one nuclear reaction to burning one coal atom to get a billion times more energy, so you get way more energy out of a fixed amount of fuel, and you also produce far less waste,” Allen said.

Nuclear energy is safer than many people have been taught to believe. Both Allen and Boemeke agree that many people have false assumptions about nuclear energy, often because of its association with nuclear weapons.

As Boemeke says in her TED Talk, “Their logic was nuclear bombs are bad. Therefore, nuclear energy is bad. Which, if you think about it, is like saying the electric chair is bad. Therefore, electricity is bad. The case against nuclear power was never based on science.”

Boemeke also notes that nuclear energy waste is “fully contained in concrete casks that are so good at blocking radiation that I [sic] might do a photo shoot there.”

Additionally, nuclear energy facilities can be built near enough to population centers that they may avoid some of the problems seen with wind and solar energy facilities.

Often, wind and solar facilities are built out in open fields far away from where the electricity is needed. This results in some loss along the transmission lines and land jurisdiction issues in building and maintaining those transmission lines.

Allen noted that when building transmission lines, difficulties can arise from crossing state lines, tribal lands and federal lands. “You may be going through different states who have their own rules, and the types of tribal and federal lands there. You’ve got all these different jurisdictions that may end up being part of the pathway,” he said.

Wind and solar facilities also take up large amounts of land and only generate electricity when the wind is blowing or the sun is out. Wind and solar “change the way you deliver electricity because they’re coming on and off, essentially, as the fuel is available,” Allen said.

Nuclear energy, however, can be generated constantly, regardless of weather conditions.

As Boemeke noted, “in the last 10 years, we have spent trillions of dollars on renewables, yet, we only get 8% of our electricity from wind and solar. Now, don’t get me wrong. I love renewables. But to me, it’s clear that we need more. We need a source of energy that’s clean and works 24/7 to complement them.”

Nuclear energy could mean energy independence

If the conflict in Ukraine has reminded us of anything in the past several months, it is that energy independence and diverse, reliable energy sources are critical to maintaining the security and financial health of nations.

We can plainly see that dependence on fossil fuels can contribute to and fund wars. Europe is currently suffering an energy crisis due to its dependence on Russian fossil fuels in the midst of the invasion of Ukraine. European countries are beholden to buying Russian oil, while simultaneously supporting Ukraine’s resistance.

Boemeke noted, “Poland will use similar technology to convert their aging coal plants into nuclear plants, they’ll use the same building, the same transmission lines, even retrain the same workers, but now make clean energy instead of buying dirty fuels from dictators.”

The United States currently has 94 nuclear plants in operation. However, we could build more and develop a mutually beneficial model for ourselves and our allies abroad who have weaker economies or fewer resources.

The United States could invest in nuclear energy domestically to help reduce our carbon emissions and sell natural gas abroad to provide a cleaner fuel to other countries and therefore reduce carbon emissions abroad as well.

This could allow for clean energy independence, not to mention the potential for job and economic growth.

Nuclear energy could provide political common ground

In an era of seemingly complete political divide on party lines, nuclear energy could provide some common ground in the political arena that we have not seen in a long time.

Congress members across party lines have begun to show agreement on the move to nuclear energy. Allen noted there was a recent nuclear energy bill in Congress that had four sponsors, including Democrats Sheldon Whitehouse (RI) and Cory Booker (NJ) and Republicans Mike Crapo (ID) and James Inhofe (OK).

Allen noted the reasons for supporting this bill are likely different in each case. Whitehouse is fighting for climate change goals while Booker is focused on the health risks of coal. Crapo is representing a state that is very supportive of nuclear energy and Inhofe, who is usually in opposition to Whitehouse, supported this bill out of interest in American energy competitiveness and jobs.

With so many arguments that serve so many people from different political viewpoints, could nuclear energy be the political unifier we have been looking for?

As Boemeke said, “What if, instead of viewing nuclear power as destructive, we view it as a force for energy independence, and even peace? What if this technology offers our best hope for the future? A future where wars aren’t funded by our addiction to fossil fuels. A future where energy is clean. A future where electricity finally makes its way to the 700 million people on Earth who still don’t have access to it. The idea that nuclear power is bad is costing us that future. And it’s time to let go of it.”

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: Nuclear energy is more than clean; it’s unifying

Ogren: From smartwatches to sweat sensors, data empower patients

From the Apple Watch, to Fitbit, Oura and more, the list of wearable health and fitness technology lengthens every year. These gadgets have proven to be popular for keeping track of daily activities, basic health parameters, exercise goals and more. As patients and doctors begin to use these data more in clinical settings, they are transforming the way medical care is done for both doctors and patients.

Wearable tech has gotten more sophisticated since the first heart rate monitors for fitness hit the market in the 1980s. The first “smartwatch” capable of everything a smartphone could do at the time hit the market in 2013, although it did not track heart rate.

These days, smartwatches are capable of so much more than accessing apps and making calls. They can measure heart rhythm and rate. They can detect and measure sleep activity, including whether you are snoring.

These data can be helpful if you are trying to work on a healthy lifestyle or discover what your habits are. The associated apps also provide small tidbits of information about how the data is collected and provide a little bit of interpretation to help encourage healthy patterns. An example of this is the “readiness score” on the Fitbit platform, which uses your sleep patterns, activity levels and heart rate variability to estimate your readiness for your day.

Blood and sweat, but no tears yet

Recently, health trackers have become able to monitor health information that used to be measured exclusively by professionals. Several smartwatch companies have integrated electrocardiogram (ECG) into some of their models to measure heart rhythm and detect irregularities, providing perhaps the most mobile ECG access we have seen so far.

But how accurate can these single-contact-point wrist measurements be outside of the controlled, clinical environment where you are lying still with 12 leads attached to your torso and limbs?

Clinical studies of these tracker-integrated ECG measurements suggest that, while the smartwatch ECG can be effective in detecting some abnormal heart rhythms, it still falls short of the 12-lead ECG performed in clinic and hospital settings. Smartwatch-based ECG can be prone to false negatives, where an abnormal rhythm happens but the watch does not detect it while the 12-lead ECG would. This could be dangerous if a person has an abnormal rhythm but they skip visiting the doctor because their watch said they were fine.

In August, scientists at the California Institute of Technology developed a new wearable device that can measure levels of different metabolites—circulating chemicals important for metabolism—in your sweat. When levels of certain metabolites are abnormal, this may indicate disease.

So far, this is a stand-alone device, but we could certainly see this technology integrated into smartwatches in the future.

Health tracking as a supplement to primary care

There will likely always be conditions that cannot be monitored by wearable health trackers, but could these devices ease some of the burden on health care workers?

If patients were to faithfully track their health habits and vital signs, this could alleviate some of the burden on physicians to collect this information and allow them to start visits one step further along in their patient assessment. Additionally, health trackers collect data over time and on a relatively constant basis, which captures trends that infrequent visits to the doctor cannot capture.

It is a big “if,” but research suggests that using health trackers does increase patient compliance to treatment recommendations.

However, doctors will always need to evaluate whether health tracking data that their patients bring in is relevant to their health status. This interpretive part of medicine will not be rendered unnecessary any time soon.

There is also a concern that this transition to “big data” in health tracking is taking over the human aspect of medicine, and app-based advice is replacing the trust we once held in our doctors.

In many ways, medicine has been moving toward “patient empowerment” because, when patients are more involved in medical decision-making, they are more likely to follow through on treatment and lifestyle changes.

This transition hinges on patients placing trust in their doctors, as well as the health tracking industry.

However, patient empowerment can also cause tension at times. While doctors generally have more relevant training and experience than the patients they are treating, patients have access to the wealth of knowledge and data that exists on the internet. This can lead to arguments over what information is real or fake, valuable or useless.

How do we determine what is real and what is fake in terms of health and medical “knowledge?”

The answer is unbiased data. This is what doctors need to base their recommendations on. This is what patients need to base their choices on. This is what smartwatches and other devices can contribute to the field of medicine in a way that no clinical anecdote can.

This is why patients need to collect their health data honestly and consistently, and the trends seen in individuals need to be evaluated by peer-reviewed studies with participant consent.

Human beings make interpretations constantly in life, but if we are to make informed decisions, we need facts and data to back us up. Collecting longitudinal data over time can tell us an awful lot about ourselves if applied correctly and collected honestly.

Would you like Allison to follow up on this topic or explore something specific? Contact her at aogren@mndaily.com with questions, comments or story ideas.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: From smartwatches to sweat sensors, data empower patients

Ogren: Mouse embryos cloned: will humans follow?

A laboratory at Cambridge University in the United Kingdom created mouse embryos from embryonic stem cells, circumventing the traditional sperm-egg fertilization process, according to an early edition of a manuscript published Aug. 25 by Nature.

Biologists say this could offer an alternative to using natural embryos to study early development by allowing researchers to see more developmental stages in mammals than previously possible.

However, this new science raises ethical questions about the use of clones in research.

In mammals, it can be difficult to study early development as the offspring grow in the uterus of the mother, out of sight. Because of this, biologists have been developing ways to generate early embryos for study for many years.

Through this research, we have learned that as an embryo grows from a single cell to many, the cells begin with broad capability to become anything in the body. Over time, however, these cells become more “specialized” and are less able to change to a different cell type. This cycle creates the many different cell types and organs of the body, which all perform specific tasks to sustain life and its processes.

The Zernicka-Goetz Laboratory at Cambridge University is the first to show they can grow embryos past the stage of “gastrulation,” the point at which embryos go from having one layer of cells to three. This process allows for complex structures to form, such as the heart and brain.

This research group was able to achieve this by cloning embryos using stem cells from the very early stages of development. They found when certain cells are taken from an early stage embryo, they can then be combined to generate a separate clone of the original mouse embryo.

Instead of dozens of baby mice being used and then euthanized in the pursuit of science, this advance would provide the opportunity to use the “same” mouse – a clone – over and over again.

“People are even having their dogs cloned now”

This presents a few scientific and ethical questions that we need to address now, before this science is applied to humans.

Walter Low is a member of the Stem Cell Institute and a professor in the neurosurgery department here at the University of Minnesota. He pointed out that cloning of animals has been happening for many years, starting with the widely publicized cloning of Dolly the sheep in the ‘90s.

To clone Dolly, her DNA was inserted into a sheep egg cell whose own DNA had been removed. This egg was then grown inside of a sheep to produce Dolly’s clone. Cloning technology has since become more popular, Low said. “People are even having their dogs cloned now,” he said.

For Low, the ethical boundary for embryo cloning is human reproduction.

“Cloning for reproductive purposes for humans … that is the line in the sand,” he said.

While he can see this technology being used to develop cellular therapies and potentially organs, Low said human cloning is as of yet unlikely, for both technical and ethical reasons.

As a historical parallel, Low brought up the example of former University faculty member Dr. Christiaan Barnard’s completion of the first successful human heart transplant in 1967. While the initial transplant was successful, the heart recipient survived less than three weeks after the surgery.

As exciting of a moment in medical history this was, it was also cause for ethical concern. The patient’s death raised concerns over the basis of a human soul, not to mention the safety of the surgery.

“Any time when technology really advances so quickly like this, there are ethical concerns,” Low said. “People thought at that time … the heart was the seat of the soul. And how can you transplant the soul of one person into another? But look at it now.”

Indeed, look at it now. Heart transplants are being performed all over the world and are considered standard care for heart disease that cannot be treated successfully by other means.

The question of soul

While society seems to have agreed since 1967 that the human soul is not based in the heart’s physical form, questions still remain as to the source of a human soul in the physical body and, importantly, when that soul begins to exist.

Stem cell-derived embryos in humans may be far off for now, but as they have become possible in mice, we should consider the potential implications for humans.

People who share identical DNA and originate from a single embryo that “splits” are known as identical twins. We do not refer to these people as “clones” for many reasons, most of which revolve around respect for their individuality.

Identical twins are not considered to share a soul any more than they are considered to share a body, even though science has suggested that they did share a single body for a very short period of time early in development.

The human soul is often considered to be the source of our capabilities in life beyond the basic abilities of our bodies. Because of our souls, we can think with reason and morality and act as individuals to accomplish great things in life.

Perhaps what identical twins reveal to us is our souls do not reside in any piece within us, but rather they originate from the whole of us when we, and our cells, were capable of almost anything. This idea shows that there is no such thing as a clone among human beings, and there never will be.

Would you like Allison to follow up on this topic or explore something specific? Contact her at aogren@mndaily.com with questions, comments or story ideas.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: Mouse embryos cloned: will humans follow?