Author Archives | by Allison Ogren

Ogren: You got a doctorate in what?

The degree might make you a Doctor of Philosophy, but how many recent doctoral graduates have really reached that level of philosophical understanding in their field?

In theory, the doctoral degree program in any field should supply the student with comprehensive education not only in the basic technical knowledge of the field but also in the predominant philosophies surrounding that field.

For instance, in biology, one should learn the basics of how life and cells work, but also the philosophical concepts of life, the scientific method and ethical frameworks that reach well beyond one particular thesis project.

Gundula Bosch at Johns Hopkins University agrees. Along with her colleague Arturo Casadevall, she has been pushing to put more philosophical training back into curricula. In conversations with faculty, they found these philosophical gaps appeared in broader scientific skills like using appropriate statistical tests and experimental controls and explaining their work to non-experts.

So, they developed a new program specifically designed to combat this deficit. Bosch wrote in a Nature article that her “students learn to apply rigour to their design and conduct of experiments; view their work through the lens of social responsibility; and to think critically, communicate better, and thus improve reproducibility.”

Not everyone gets such support for their growth as a thinker as they work toward their doctorate. Many may end up feeling more like they have learned one very limited set of skills and know very little about the broader field they work within.

I know I am not the only doctoral student out there who feels that, while I know a lot about one very specific thing, as soon as I step outside of my current lab, I will be starting from scratch.

One could call that “imposter syndrome” rearing its ugly head, but it comes from a very real place. Equipping doctoral students with a broader base of pure thinking skills may help alleviate some of these feelings of inadequacy.

I consider myself somewhat lucky in that my program does try to include opportunities to grow skills in science philosophy, or what I would rather call “figuring it out” skills.

For instance, my program — the molecular, cellular, developmental biology and genetics program — forces students to step outside of their comfort zone during preliminary exams. For our written exam, we were to choose between three publications and write a grant proposal for a project launching from the paper we chose. We then had two weeks to write the grant proposal. Lastly, following faculty review, we were to defend that proposal as part of our oral exam.

Student sentiment can be a bit split on this because some feel it is a waste of time to do all of that literature research and create a grant proposal for a project you will never pursue.

On the other hand, this is a great exercise in using a broad set of necessary skills that every scientist will absolutely need to have if they wish to continue their career in science. Plus, these are the very same skills that make you useful beyond your specific subfield if you wish to spread your wings to something else after receiving your doctorate.

The “figuring it out” skills, indeed.

Some concerns have arisen around implementing the education that Bosch and Casadevall have been working on, especially with regard to productivity, time to graduation and rote knowledge. Bosch argues against this concern because she believes teaching students how to think more broadly and critically will contribute to better productivity.

It seems plausible that the ability to better sift through literature, evaluate and design experiments with appropriate statistics and controls, and then communicate the conclusions to a broad audience could contribute to more overall productivity if it means there are fewer re-dos and mistakes along the way.

Additionally, while I can appreciate the desire for fast graduation time and good levels of productivity, the doctorate is about much more than that. You could spend five years of your life working as a bachelor- or master-level staff scientist and gain the same amount of technical knowledge about a specific scientific discipline, and likely get paid a lot more than a doctoral student.

If the doctorate is going to become a five-year technical training intensive, then it calls into question whether someone with a doctorate is inherently more qualified — and therefore deserving of any higher positions or pay — than someone who worked in a staff scientist position for that same amount of time.

What sets the doctoral journey apart is the broader skills: the philosophy part. Providing doctoral students ample opportunities to think critically and creatively in ways they may not get elsewhere is the most essential part of the journey.

If doctoral programs are going to cut that part out for the sake of publication numbers and graduation rates, then the value of the letters after your name will diminish and we will end up with highly credentialed scientists lacking essential skills to push the field forward.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: You got a doctorate in what?

Ogren: Time is a flat circle

“A lot of people think that time moves in a straight line, but that is not quite right,” Glenda Holste said.

Holste is a retired journalist who began her career during volatile times in history and now works to mentor the new generations. She shared with me that the 1960s — when she began her journalistic career — was a volatile time for the U.S. In fact, she said she was in Memphis when Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated.

Over the last 55 years, Holste said while a lot has changed, some things remain the same and other things have come back around.

We discussed the recent Wall Street Journal and NORC poll, and what it shows about how traditional American values are changing.

The poll showed several key values’ importance to Americans has declined in recent years, including patriotism, religion and having children.

Holste said one of the key American values is self-determination, or the ability to determine one’s outcome in life. She noted this was truly the most important value to most Americans.

The poll uses the term “self-fulfillment,” which has subtle differences in meaning and could refer to a concept more similar to happiness. The poll showed that 91% of Americans find this value important.

There is also some irony in the poll, as 90% of Americans hold that being tolerant of others is important. Current times, however, feel divided, and one does not have to look far to see people being intolerant of one another’s immutable characteristics, let alone choices or opinions.

So, how can this be that Americans can value something so highly, and yet don’t appear to practice the value often?

Perhaps the issue is that we are asking the question the wrong way. Traditional American values could be considered the outward expression of the actual underlying values that are more abstract but more universal.

For instance, patriotism does not need to be a partisan political issue, but it is in some ways being made into one by focusing too narrowly on the ways in which it is expressed.

Patriotism does not always look like flag waving and fireworks. It can also look like volunteering to scrub gravestones to preserve the dignity of the dead. It can look like preserving historical documents and stories so that future generations can continue to learn from the past. It can look like advocating for political change as we as a society learn more and come up with new ideas about how the world and society should work.

What stays consistent in patriotism, when you strip down all of the external expressions of it, is the belief that your country is something you can respect and believe in, that it can and will get better with the proper care and that it is worth fighting for.

Holste and I discussed this idea at length, that Americans may indeed share more values than they think they do. They just disagree, sometimes strongly, about how to express those values.

She put it in historical context and described how, over time, history moves in lulls and “pushes.” She said the 1960s was a decade of “pushing” in several ways, from the Civil Rights movement to the Vietnam War and the sexual revolution, among many other movements occurring simultaneously.

She said current events are similar in some ways, where society does not attack one problem at a time, but rather “pushes” to reevaluate many things at once.

These “pushes” are indeed important for establishing or re-establishing a way of life for a society. Not every single issue in society can be solved during these periods, but one can hope that the best ideas can win out if discourse proves effective and common goals are acknowledged and served by the changes. Many positives came out of the tumultuous and painful times of the 1960s, but by no means was every problem solved or scar healed.

Holste said time seems to move faster during these periods, and then it slows down again in the lull that follows, as society settles into a new status quo and we wait for problems or societal shortcomings to bubble to the surface once more. She also said technology, and particularly that which allows people to communicate faster over large distances, contributes to this cycle speeding up, leading to shorter lulls between “pushes.”

Holste also said the breakdown in civil communication in American society concerns her. She said while communication is faster and reaches more people, it seems there is less ability to remain civil with others when discussing their opinions, leading her to fear society’s ability to problem solve.

When asked what the most critical American value is to preserve, for the sake of the continuation of this country, Holste named tolerance.

If we do not have tolerance for others and their points of view, she said, then we would not have much to talk about.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: Time is a flat circle

Ogren: Outsourcing thought to AI bots

In a March open letter from the Future of Life Institute, more than 1,500 tech leaders expressed their concerns about the pace of AI development, calling for increased regulation of this breakthrough technology.

The letter suggested a six-month pause on AI development to allow regulations to be implemented — a pause that would allow us to think critically about the future of AI and its implications, both positive and negative.

If it happens, this will be an important period for thinkers both in and outside of the tech community to have real, open discourse about potential uses and developments in AI, and what safeguards will need to be put in place.

The writing of an open letter suggests these tech leaders want to include broad input in future decisions about AI. This in itself is a huge positive, as tech leaders are seeking transparency between themselves and the public.

One major issue to consider with the AI boom is how to preserve the development of critical thinking skills in future generations as more and more intellectual labor is outsourced to AI programs.

While AI may not surpass human abilities, it is possible intellectual outsourcing may cause human skills to deteriorate below the benchmark.

AI has already begun to spread to educational tasks like essay writing and workforce tasks like document preparation. While outsourcing menial tasks to AI may contribute to better efficiency and productivity, it may also have negative side effects on our critical thinking skills over time.

Critical thinking skills are hard to develop but are absolutely crucial for human intelligence. One of the most common ways students are asked to practice and showcase these skills is essay writing. If this task is outsourced to AI programs and these generated essays are able to achieve satisfactory or exemplary grades, then the student may skip most opportunities to develop critical thinking skills.

Now, students can and definitely should review their AI-generated essays for accuracy and make sure they understand what their essay is arguing, but critique is a far cry from full-form critical thinking.

And critique will be necessary to weed out the misinformation that AI can produce. AI platforms have a tendency to generate misinformation, as Sandra Wachter, an expert in technology information at Oxford University, told Science.

She also pointed out the six-month pause is fairly arbitrary and is unlikely to be a complete solution, and these questions need to be decided among people beyond just the tech community.

So far, the Biden administration has put out an AI “Bill of Rights” to try to regulate AI platforms, but the principles are voluntary.

From the regulatory end, the story is far from over. We will have to wait and see how it pans out, and speak our concerns to help shape the developments. We also must act now to prevent the critical thinking deficits that may arise in students from missed learning opportunities.

It may be unpopular, but in-person, real-time written or oral exams need to be regularly used in classrooms. These put a lot of stress on students, but it is absolutely essential that students learn to generate their own thoughts and communicate them effectively. With the growing popularity of AI, stepping away from evaluations that are easily completed with AI support may be the only feasible and affordable way to ensure our students develop these crucial skills.

Schools are already struggling. Declines can be seen in many aspects in schools, from skills to graduation rates. At least a large part of this is likely due to declines in available funds, which affects some schools more than others. If schools were able to enjoy some of the cash flow and developer interest AI platforms are currently enjoying, school outcomes might turn around.

AI can be a wonderful tool, but we need to be very picky about what it can and cannot be used for in terms of outsourcing intellectual labor. We need to preserve the ability of human beings to think critically because that may be the only way we can continue to outsmart machines.

We cannot let ourselves fall behind while technology charges ahead.

Would you like Allison to follow up on this topic or explore something specific? Contact her at aogren@mndaily.com with questions, comments or story ideas.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: Outsourcing thought to AI bots

Ogren: Crossing the placenta to block HIV, Zika

A Cell study published last week showed the antibodies created by RNA vaccines for HIV and Zika virus can cross the placental barrier and inoculate baby rabbits.

The authors noted a major route for passage of infections is from mother to child shortly after birth, and so some way to mitigate the spread from an infected mother to an uninfected child is needed.

This is particularly true during disease outbreaks, like in 2016 with Zika because this virus was especially harmful to newborns. Another application of this strategy would be for HIV, which can linger in the body throughout life and eventually develop into AIDS.

In mammals like humans and rabbits, the placenta provides a barrier during pregnancy that prevents the growing fetus from being subjected to most infections. However, some infections and antibodies can get through this barrier, allowing the growing baby to develop its own immunity, or gain what is called “passive immunity” from the mother’s antibodies. In this way, vaccines can potentially help babies gain immunity before birth to prevent transmission of infections.

For this study, the researchers used a different form of RNA vaccine than with the mRNA COVID-19 vaccines. The RNA used in this study is what is known as “self-amplifying replicon RNA” (repRNA), which means the RNA within the vaccine can self-replicate many times and produce a large dose of antibodies in the body.

The researchers found their vaccines were able to produce a large enough antibody response in pregnant rabbits that some of the antibodies were then transferred through the placenta into the baby rabbits — kits — before they were born. The kits then showed antibodies present in their blood after birth without being vaccinated themselves and without changes of litter size, suggesting there was no obvious pregnancy loss associated with the vaccines.

While these results look promising, the researchers did not look at whether the kits could be infected with these viruses after receiving passive immunity from their mothers. Plus, looking at litter size is not a full measure for changes in pregnancy health and neonatal health.

This is where we must consider and set our benchmarks before these types of vaccines are relied upon in future disease outbreaks.

Obviously, we need to be able to see that there is a real reduction in infection transmission in the newborns born with these passively delivered antibodies before we move forward. If the point of these vaccinations is to reduce transmissibility, then that needs to be a minimum requirement.

Additionally, scientists must conduct extensive safety research, and look for any changes in development or health in the newborns. This includes tracking individual fetuses in-utero via ultrasound or other means, not just looking at litter size.

Then, the issue becomes a simple matter of relative risk assessment.

In the cases of Zika and HIV, one can see the potential for trading a small risk of a vaccine to prevent the much larger health risks associated with these viruses.

However, if the vaccines pose the potential for serious side effects up to and including pregnancy loss or developmental defects, that fact should be clear and the vaccines should only be recommended with extreme caution.

New tools can be exciting. Once a new technology shows some success, it can be tempting to apply it widely and expect fantastic results. Caution and risk management are less exciting but equally important pieces to every new innovation, and must walk alongside the developments, especially where pregnancy and babies are concerned.

In the case of COVID-19 mRNA vaccines, studies on the effects during pregnancy have shown the mRNA vaccines themselves do not cross the placental barrier, and there has not been evidence of adverse effects in the placenta or overall pregnancy outcomes with the vaccine.

Instead, as with every other vaccine commonly given during pregnancy, the maternal antibodies resulting from the vaccine are transferred, giving the baby temporary, passive immunity.

Hopefully, the Zika and HIV repRNA vaccines will eventually prove to be safe and effective during pregnancy following this same strategy of passive immunity transfer. This would be a huge breakthrough in mitigating the spread of such horrible and insidious infections.

Regardless, in today’s age of patient-centered care in medicine, the pregnant mother should always have the final say about which vaccines or other treatments she wants to receive during her pregnancy. There is some level of risk associated with every intervention, and that decision should fall on the person taking on the risk.

With Zika and HIV, not everyone is at equal risk of contracting these viruses, so the exposure risk at that time and in that area will be a factor.

Even with evidence and examples from young and old vaccines, each new iteration or shifted vaccine strategy deserves the highest level of scrutiny we can possibly give it. Rigor in safety testing should always match if not exceed rigor in effectiveness. The only way to repair the schism between hesitant patients and recommending providers is rigorous study of the concerns, preferably before they hit the mass market.

Would you like Allison to follow up on this topic or explore something specific? Contact her at aogren@mndaily.com with questions, comments or story ideas.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: Crossing the placenta to block HIV, Zika

Ogren: The government vs. gas stoves: a new strategy

In service to the long-term goal to phase out fossil fuels, new policy proposals about banning gas-powered appliances in homes are coming out, and deserve some of the ire they have attracted.

Late last year, news of possible bans on gas stoves in home kitchens was circulating. The word at the time was that the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) might take some regulatory action in the face of growing research linking gas stoves to pollutants that harm human health and the environment. There were plenty of negative reactions to this, citing varied reasons from personal preference to government overreach.

Early in the new year, the CPSC backed off of the idea, and White House officials also said they were not going to ban gas stoves. But now, there is a new regulation up for consideration from the Department of Energy (DOE) regarding regulations on efficiency of gas appliances.

In theory, encouraging energy efficiency is a workable compromise that could be more widely accepted if the benefits are large enough.

In this case, however, it appears government actors are side-stepping the direct path, choosing instead to attack the problem through regulatory channels because the policy was so unpopular when floated late last year. Even worse, the proposed regulations would do almost nothing for climate change or consumers.

The DOE said the purpose of the regulations is to reduce energy consumption and save consumers money. But these benefits are meager at best. The department estimates a reduction in energy use by a mere 3.4% from current levels, and consumers on average would save $21.89 over a cooktop’s lifetime.

I would be willing to bet most consumers would be willing to absorb the $21.89 in cost over the lifetime of their stove, especially as stoves tend to have quite long lives if maintained properly.

Despite the DOE’s stated goal of saving consumers money, it seems possible this regulation could pass more costs onto consumers.

A spokesperson for the Association of Home Appliance Manufacturers told the Wall Street Journal in February that gas cooktops would have to be completely redesigned to comply with the new DOE regulations.

The costs of switching to these compliant stoves would be passed on to consumers through increased prices because manufacturers would need to recoup the multi-million dollar cost of redesigning stoves, the Wall Street Journal reported.

Aside from manufacturing and replacement costs, electrical infrastructure needs updating to support this shift.

If the U.S. were to phase out gas as an energy supply to homes now, the electric grid would not be prepared to pick up the slack. This step cannot feasibly be taken until the electric grids are better supported.

Another issue that arises is the fact that electric grids are often partially supported by coal, which means drawing more electric power would make us more reliant on burning coal. Instead, there need to be changes to energy sourcing such that electric grids can be fully supported by low- to no-carbon sources if the switch away from fossil fuels is really going to work.

Rather than strangling consumer choice and implementing costly regulations with few benefits, the government should focus on supporting innovation in energy production and infrastructure. Plus, focusing on energy infrastructure and innovation is much more in line with the government’s job description than micromanaging home appliances.

Alternatively, there are other opponents to gas stoves that cite health concerns from emissions due to burning gas in an enclosed space and affecting air quality inside homes. While this is a valid concern, it is also asking folks to give up a lot for very little perceived benefit.

Sure, warn consumers that gas stoves can pose a health risk through air quality, but ultimately, consumers should have the ability to assess the risk to themselves. Many people looking to hold on to their gas stoves for eternity are also the types of people who cook at home from scratch and use lots of fresh, unprocessed foods in their diets, which mitigates a whole host of health risks as compared to processed or mass-prepared foods.

While many can easily get behind regulations meant to make home air quality safer, consumers should also know that plastic and non-stick surfaces and cookware pose a threat.

Additionally, the scientific links between gas stoves and health risks like childhood asthma are a bit on the tenuous and out-of-date side, sparking skepticism about whether this change would be a health benefit at all. To opponents of this change, there seems to be little obvious benefit, while likely resulting in increased costs and dumping of refuse into landfills, ultimately contributing to pollution through a different route.

In the end, it all brings us back to where the greatest benefit for the smallest cost lies. It appears encouraging people to cook fresh foods at home rather than telling them to be afraid of their stoves is the better course of action until innovation in energy production brings us to a place where we can zero in on these smaller sources of emissions.

Would you like Allison to follow up on this topic or explore something specific? Contact her at aogren@mndaily.com with questions, comments or story ideas.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: The government vs. gas stoves: a new strategy

Ogren: No reviewers? An opening for change

“Quiet quitting” has entered academia, with academics pulling back their effort and commitment to the less lucrative but still strongly expected tasks. This could help make real strides in the academic power structure and manage burnout.

Earlier in March, an article was published in Nature discussing burnout and “quiet quitting” in academia. While many working in academia reject the term “quiet quitting,” it has become a common phrase among burnt out employees across industries and titles.

“Many researchers disdain the term, noting that they’re neither quitting nor being quiet about their desire to create healthier work-life boundaries, prioritize their mental health and reject toxic workplace cultures,” wrote the authors.

According to a 2022 survey in Nature, 75% of Nature readers reported cutting back on some tasks, with 67% noting burnout as the cause. Other reasons included not being willing to work unpaid overtime and lack of credit or recognition for the work. No wonder academic workers are cutting back on tasks they feel that they get no reward value for doing.

So, if researchers are not shirking their duties, and are instead setting boundaries and vocalizing their need for cutting back on thankless responsibilities to avoid burnout, what tasks are being cut from the list?

It turns out that the most commonly cut tasks were peer review and conference attendance.

Coincidentally, these tasks are also some pretty important ones to keep the academic research machine running smoothly.

Without peer review, research loses rigor and sometimes the recognition and knowledge sharing that comes from publication. Without conference attendance, scientific networking and open discussion could be stymied.

While the participation rate in these is not low enough to grind things to a halt just yet, issues are beginning to arise. More researchers are getting their manuscripts kicked back by academic journals due to inability to find reviewers with enough relevant knowledge of the subject matter. Additionally, poster sessions are starting to feel like ghost towns.

Graduate students seem to be more willing to step up, but they are often barred from participating in peer review and are less commonly selected to give talks at conferences.

Conference attendance was on the chopping block for both early-career and senior researchers. Research trainees, like graduate students and postdoctoral researchers (postdocs), often go to conferences hoping for networking opportunities for not only their current research but also the next step in their young careers. They want to meet senior researchers and learn about open positions. When senior researchers are absent, conferences lose some value for trainees, and they may stop attending as well.

I attended a conference last summer in which the graduate students and postdocs were highly engaged and each presented a poster, but almost none of us were selected for talks. The senior researchers were largely absent from networking and poster sessions and were clustered in closed-off conversation groups with each other during free time.

In terms of conferences and networking, senior researchers have a responsibility to make themselves available to the newer researchers on the scene, to give back to science and help develop the next generation of researchers.

Senior researcher participation in conferences needs to either be encouraged somehow, or there needs to be more ability for them to send delegates from their labs to network who can actually influence hiring decisions and foster research collaborations. Private companies use this model, so there is little reason why such a system could not be implemented in academic groups.

There could be an opportunity to allow graduate students and postdocs to participate in some other tasks at a higher level, which may be of greater value to them than it is to the senior participants who could be using their unique wisdom elsewhere.

Almost just as many senior researchers noted peer review as a task worth skipping as reported conference attendance. The credential based gate-keeping of peer review could be reevaluated to close this gap.

For instance, it may be reasonable to have one reviewer be a trainee at times. Ultimately, many graduate students and postdocs are interested in academic careers, or working in the science writing and publishing industry, and this would allow them to gain experience in a skill set that is not currently easy to access. It would give them a chance to experience the peer review process from both sides, as both submitters and reviewers.

It would give trainees an opportunity to contribute to maintaining the integrity of science from an early stage in their careers.

A criticism of this idea may be that graduate students and postdocs lack the breadth of knowledge that a professor might possess, and therefore would not be able to contribute meaningful insight and critique to the manuscript being reviewed.

However, if we take a step back and consider that scientific subfields often get “siloed” by specific jargon and communication styles, not to mention varying sets of what is considered “common knowledge,” perhaps it would be beneficial to have a reviewer that may push writers to better explain their scientific findings to a broader audience.

Graduate students may balk at this idea, as many feel they are grossly underpaid and overworked as it is, and many struggle with setting boundaries and preserving a work-life balance conducive to mental health.

To some graduate students, the learning opportunity and the ability to cite the experience on a resume may be worth it, however. Graduate students would also be more amenable to much smaller cash bonuses for serving as reviewers than a professor with classes to teach, a lab to run and committee memberships already squeezing their energy for a 6-figure salary.

As many researchers in any stage of their career can understand, it becomes a balance of using your limited energy and specific skills most effectively to avoid wasting your time or getting burnt out. The current shifts due to burnout may be showing us a way to shift the balance of responsibilities in a way that could benefit many.

Would you like Allison to follow up on this topic or explore something specific? Contact her at aogren@mndaily.com with questions, comments or story ideas.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: No reviewers? An opening for change

Ogren: Listen, and you might finish each other’s melodies

New scientific advances suggest the brain can compile musical experience and predict the coming notes in a new piece. This phenomenon could partially explain the musical creation process and demonstrates that diverse musical experience aids in music production.

A December 2022 study in eLife modeled the predictions a listener makes in music and evaluated how the different models compare to real brain responses to melodies. For each model, the evaluation included two parts: how different model algorithms compare in predicting the upcoming notes in a melody and how well they predict listeners’ brain responses to the notes.

The authors found that musical melodies are best predicted by models taking into account long-term experience of musical melodies, whereas brain responses are best predicted by applying these models to only a few most recent notes.

In other words, the models need musical experience to predict musical notes, and human brains need relevant context.

The models used in this study involved machine learning and therefore needed “teaching” sets of musical data to understand what is and is not music. These sets inform the model’s ability to predict something that would be music instead of, perhaps, morse code or the sound a creaky door makes.

It makes sense that the models only predicted melodies well when they had long-term learning on their side, and therefore a large data set of possible common melodies and note combinations to choose from for the prediction.

The humans involved in this study, of course, came in with whatever long term musical experience they had been exposed to in their lives and were better able to predict, or be less surprised by, the melodies they were exposed to once they were prompted with the style of music in the study.

The study also noted it has been known for a long time that humans have a remarkable ability for implicit auditory memories. So, even if you are listening to a type of music that you don’t normally listen to, you may still have this predictive ability without really realizing it.

This is fascinating knowledge because of the implications it could have for understanding how humans create and dance to music.

If you can understand the music around you and you happen to possess a few dance moves to string together, your musical experience could turn you into a better social dancer than you may realize.

In theory, listening to several genres of music from different time periods could help you gain musical experience that could inform not only your taste in music, but also give you the tools needed to create music.

This brings to mind jazz musicians. Often, jazz musicians are trained initially in classical, orchestral styles of music, but also listen to other genres that can vary widely. As they grow as musicians, they often start dabbling in other genres with their chosen instruments and eventually gain the kind of experience necessary to possibly play improvisational jazz.

There, musicians work together “off script” and the music kind of creates itself. That takes a lot of experience, talent and group cohesion to make it work well. But, that is why improvisational jazz is so impressive as a musical form.

Many of the best musical creators likely spend most of their lives listening to music, to draw inspiration as well as to study combinations and movements.

Sometimes, music creators can have styles that sound like they are inspired by a given genre or specific artist’s work. Sometimes, artists do this on purpose to pay tribute or to make a statement with their music, but other times it could simply be an example of this context-driven musical prediction ability that humans have.

This could be viewed cynically or lead listeners to believe that no music is “truly” created, but rather is a compilation of known motifs. But, that does not explain the creativity seen so often in musical creation. For instance, it does not explain how musical styles continue to expand into completely new genres that never existed before.

Music is created to convey emotions and stories. It is a mode of expression that can be just as unique as the person telling it.

All of this is to say that music, in all of its various forms, is a common experience among people. It is another way for us to communicate, connect and share experiences with one another without speaking a single word. Music transcends language, religion and culture even if each has their own unique style.

Because of this, music can help us understand each other beyond words. If our diverse exposure allows us to predict what is coming next in a song, that sounds a lot like being able to finish someone else’s sentence, and such a bond is remarkable.

 

Would you like Allison to follow up on this topic or explore something specific? Contact her at aogren@mndaily.com with questions, comments or story ideas.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: Listen, and you might finish each other’s melodies

Ogren: The latest political football is off the rails

Of the many train derailments that happen each year, one has snagged national headlines for both safety and political reasons. The residents of East Palestine, Ohio, are caught in the middle on the line of scrimmage in a political football game that largely misses the point.

On Feb. 3, a train with several cars full of hazardous materials derailed, resulting in a spill and subsequent containment measures by Norfolk Southern, the company that owns the train. These containment measures involved evacuating the area in a one, then two-mile radius and burning off the chemicals in the cars.

The justification behind the controlled burn was to prevent an explosion, but the cloud of smoke inspired a different kind of explosion: a political battle.

Politicians in Ohio and beyond began commenting on various angles of the derailment: infrastructure concerns, chemical containment measures and water safety. This eventually devolved into commenting on who did and did not visit East Palestine in a timely manner.

Ohio Sen. J.D. Vance (R) was vocal about his trip to East Palestine, but he was certainly not the only politician to schedule a visit. Former president Donald Trump also visited the town, and, subsequently, Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg.

One could quibble for hours, days or weeks about the motivation and timing of each visit, and many politicians and journalists have. But that part really does not matter.

What does matter is the safety of the residents of East Palestine and the surrounding land and water following the chemical spill.

As early as seven days after the derailment, the Environmental Protection Agency reported that carcinogenic chemicals were detected in local creeks and streams. These chemicals are not something that should be ingested, as they are all considered toxic.

State and federal officials have reassured residents the city water supplies are safe, so at least the city treatment infrastructure seems to be doing its job to keep residents safe from their tap water. However, tap water is far from the only consideration here.

Contaminated and carcinogenic groundwater can lead to a host of other problems in farms, local wildlife and beyond.

Residents of the area voiced safety concerns a week after the derailment, and they should keep voicing their concerns. State and federal officials said air, soil and water supplies were safe and the contaminated waterways were contained. But, the remnants of the giant smoke cloud were still hovering over them at the time, so it is hard to believe with certainty that the issue was completely resolved.

Continued monitoring of the safety of the air, soil and water supplies is absolutely critical in the coming months. But, there are other steps that need to be taken as well.

The health of the local residents is important and should be monitored. If residents contract health conditions related to the fallout from the chemical spill and burn, then they should be able to connect it to the incident and receive proper care and compensation.

However, we do not want it to get to that point. While the initial month following the incident is already in the history books, long-term exposure can still be prevented.

The chemical cleanup process must be swift and complete. Norfolk Southern ultimately should be responsible for cleaning up their mess, with the government enforcing regulations regarding when the area is considered cleaned up.

Unfortunately, there really is not a great incentive for rail companies to invest huge amounts of money in safety, especially if the government jumps in to help them out with spills and derailments.

There is a need to make safety more profitable, so this becomes a choice companies make on the front end, rather than choosing the bare minimum requirements and tolerating a certain amount of loss due to derailments and spills.

The residents of East Palestine deserve better, and so do the many other towns that have hazardous chemicals riding the rails through them every day.

 

Would you like Allison to follow up on this topic or explore something specific? Contact her at aogren@mndaily.com with questions, comments or story ideas.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: The latest political football is off the rails

Ogren: Treating a theory with a bandaid

A 2022 study review in Molecular Psychology revealed the link between a serotonin imbalance in the brain and depression is more tenuous than many researchers previously thought. When this link was considered fact by so many until now, how it is handled going forward could show how trust can be salvaged in science and medical care.

Depression has existed throughout history, although the scientific and cultural understanding of the condition has shifted and changed.

One of the earliest terms for depression was “melancholia,” which can be traced back to Mesopotamia, where mental health conditions were considered to be related to demonic possession and were usually treated by religious leaders.

While the name, understanding and treatment for depression have shifted and grown through the ages, not all of the theories and treatments have been winners. Lobotomies, for instance, are not looked upon in history with kind eyes.

While lobotomies were recorded to have helped patients appear calm, they had severe and unethical side effects like personality changes and cognitive damage, and they could lead to death.

Now, treatment strategies for depression have shifted toward seeking the best treatment of symptoms with the fewest severe side effects possible – a shift made possible, tragically, through the deaths or maltreatment of past patients.

Depression treatment strategies used today include psychotherapy, medication or some combination of both. The Mayo Clinic states there are many options for depression treatment available that can be discussed with a doctor or therapist.

Some medications to treat depression target serotonin systems in the brain to improve mood and energy. These medications were developed because the best medical knowledge at the time suggested serotonin contributes to maintaining mood, cognition and reward systems in the brain. This understanding led to the idea that boosting the function of serotonin in the brain could help people with depression symptoms.

According to surveys, 80% of the general public was under the impression that depression is caused by a “chemical imbalance” in the brain.

But, given this new revelation from Molecular Psychology, is it ethical to use serotonin boosting medication if the source of the problem does not lie there?

Side effects matter, and unfortunately, the unpredicted side effects of having either too much serotonin or having it artificially boosted are starting to reveal themselves.

The authors of the study review wrote that serotonin-modulating antidepressants actually can lead to reduced serotonin levels over time, which means these medications could actually cause the very problem they were meant to alleviate.

This, paired with the fact that reduced serotonin levels are not strongly associated with depression, could mean the medications can cause a problem that did not exist in the first place.

Prescribing a medication that could cause a serious brain chemistry problem that a patient did not have to begin with could be an unethical choice. These medications can also come with a whole host of other side effects, including nausea, sleep changes, appetite changes or issues with sexual desire and function.

Additionally, antidepressants do not have a particularly high success rate of reducing depression symptoms. Studies have shown that antidepressants improved depression in only about 20% more people compared to a placebo treatment and prevented recurrence in only about 27% more people than the placebo.

While antidepressants can be helpful for some, they are far from being a solution for everyone suffering from a disease. If the drugs are not treating the root of the problem, their effectiveness is likely limited.

Instead of targeted treatment of a chemical imbalance, it is like sticking a bandaid on a bullet wound. Worse, it is like closing up the wound without removing the bullet. Yes, it can stop the bleeding, but the source of the problem is still there under the surface, hiding itself as it can fester into a much larger problem.

This non-specific approach can lead to frustration and ultimately mistrust between care providers and patients and potentially be dangerous to some.

So, how do we move forward with this revelation to ensure trust in our providers following the science as it grows and shifts?

First off, providers need to be honest about these drugs, what they can and cannot do and what the risks are, especially with long term use. Many providers already do this, but as complicating scientific results arise, it is all the more important to avoid mistrust. A positive benefit may be worth the risk, but physicians need to be cautious about misinformation and risks.

If serotonin boosting antidepressants are being considered, it is time to implement serotonin testing in patients before, during and after treatment. This would help providers and patients know how the drug is affecting their levels. This strategy would also help reduce the chances of serotonin levels dropping.

This monitoring is a common practice in many medical conditions that can last years or an entire lifetime, such as diabetes or thyroid conditions. It is time that depression is monitored in this way as well.

Second, it is time to move these drugs down on the priority list. Serotonin should not be a reflexive target when selecting treatment options for patients.

Additional research is being conducted to develop more effective targets for drugs to treat depression, and as the understanding of the underlying biology of depression grows, then so will the available treatment options that actually treat the source. It is okay, and often very good, to let go of an old treatment to make room for a new, more accurate and effective choice.

Third, therapy needs to be moved up the priority list.

Depression is a condition that is likely as individualized as the person experiencing it, and therefore, the key appears to be to develop as individualized a treatment strategy as is needed. Drugs can help slow the bleeding, but ultimately therapy is the most individualized treatment a person can find at the moment that can reach beyond the abilities of current drug options.

 

Would you like Allison to follow up on this topic or explore something specific? Contact her at aogren@mndaily.com with questions, comments or story ideas.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: Treating a theory with a bandaid

Ogren: A gift guide for your heart and soul

As we near the end of American Heart Month, we should reflect on how much our hearts do for us every day. Expressing gratitude for that — or anything else — can improve our well-being and connect with the people around us in deeper ways.

Your heart is the first organ to start functioning early in development, and it never takes a day off until the day you die. For that alone, hearts deserve gratitude for their unending and constant support, on good days and bad.

And, as it turns out, showing gratitude can benefit our little blood engines. The American Heart Association says gratitude practice can help your health by reducing stress, which can in turn reduce blood pressure and even improve immune function.

As practices of self-love continue to gain popularity, showing gratitude to your body for all the things it does for you is becoming more common. This is a good thing, but appreciating and nurturing your physical body is not the whole picture.

Self-love does not need to be self-focused, nor does it have to include mud masks, massages or exercise. These strategies can help, but there are more options at your fingertips that may have deeper and longer-lasting effects.

One of the ways you can truly love yourself is by practicing gratitude. Looking outside of yourself to things, people and circumstances you can be grateful for can be a wonderful way to love and nurture your soul.

When you think of gratitude practice, you may think of writing down a simple list of all the things you are grateful for. This may include your health, your relationships and your pets.

Lists, it turns out, can be a great start. The Earl E. Bakken Center for Spirituality and Healing at the University of Minnesota explored gratitude practice in the form of writing a list and the ‘why’ for each list item for 21 days.

They found the key to gratitude practice is practice. It takes time to see the effects, but once it becomes a habit, they noted it becomes easier to experience gratitude in the moment, which can have a deep, lasting impact and help you weather life’s storms.

The American Heart Association suggests building a list in the following categories is a good way to start: health, eating, activity, relationships and time.

If lists are not your thing, longer-form gratitude practices could be more effective. A 2022 study in Affective Science looked at different types and lengths of gratitude practice and found that longer-form writing exercises like letters were generally more effective than lists. The authors also pointed out that individuals who wrote letters to specific people expressing their gratitude experienced the strongest effects.

Alex Haley, an assistant professor at the Bakken Center, said in an email that his family practices gratitude daily as an important part of their family dinner routine. “My daughter who is five years old often smiles as she talks about her day in kindergarten. Her smile is my daily reminder about why intentionally reflecting on gratitude matters,” he said.

Haley said different people likely benefit from different strategies.

“I generally recommend that if you’re interested in gratitude, then try out a small practice of gratitude and see for yourself if you notice a difference in your own life after trying the practice for a while,” he said. “This practice can be as simple as intentionally saying ‘Thank you. I really appreciate it’ anytime you’re the recipient of an act of kindness.”

He also provided a resource for additional ideas for gratitude practice.

As we near the end of February, we approach the beginning of two long-standing religious periods intended for introspection and re-centering oneself in faith. Lent begins Wednesday for Christians and Ramadan for Muslims starts in late March.

While gratitude practice is typically thought of as secular, it can be easily related to these and more religious practices because self-sacrifice and gratitude are major components of spiritual introspection and living in and reconnecting with faith.

Regardless of if a person is religious, it is remarkable that certain soulful practices can be common among all people. This should not be ignored, especially in recent years when it can feel like society is more fractured than ever.

Gratitude practice can make us kinder and more compassionate to others, resulting in a more connected and supportive society. There is a reason why so many religions have incorporated this practice throughout history.

Haley said this commonality makes sociological sense as well.

“Human beings are social creatures, so it would make sense, at least to me, that being kind and expressing gratitude (especially for past kindnesses received) helps us as a species,” he said. “By recognizing and reflecting upon all the ways that others have benefited our life, we are more likely to be kind and help others in turn.”

Would you like Allison to follow up on this topic or explore something specific? Contact her at aogren@mndaily.com with questions, comments or story ideas.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Ogren: A gift guide for your heart and soul