Author Archives | artseditor

Movie Review: “The Prince Of Persia”

The film “Prince of Persia: Sands of Time” is not that smart, but it’s thoroughly enjoyable, thanks in most part to Jake Gyllenhaal.

Gyllenhaal plays a former street rat who has been adopted by the king of the Persian Empire and raised in nobility. Fast-forward 20 years: after leading the charge up the ramparts of a formidable city, the Prince of Persia claims a peculiar dagger as his booty. Soon after the prince is framed for the murder of his regent father, and forced on the lam, trekking across the harsh climes of Middle East.

Along the way, the prince picks up the mouthy, conniving princess of the recently vanquished city-state. When the princess makes an attempt on his life, Dastan discovers the power of his found dagger, which lets him rewind time and replay the previous moment’s actions. With this weapon in hand, the prince and princess embark on a mission to expose the assassin and save the empire.

As far as plot goes, “Prince” is pretty average for an action movie. Many of the tropes are culled from a variety of sources. You’ve got your Prodigal Son parable, your Hamlet-ian motivation and your Disney’s “Aladdin” origin story. Even Dastan’s dagger seems a quick talismanic swap for Aladdin’s lamp (unfortunately, it doesn’t produce a coke-addled Robin Williams). Yet for all these disparate structural appropriations, the story gels. It’s a cookie cutter script, but “Prince” is still an appetizing cookie.

The only problem is the successive creeping reminders that you’ve seen this movie somewhere before.

Fortunately, with plenty of action, director Mike Newell paces the film well and keeps those uneasy feelings of deja vu from boiling over. Along with the motley plot, the film has a few twists that surprise, but a few that feel like clunky Shyamalan reveals.

But a good story isn’t what people who see tent poles like “Prince” pay for. Jake Gyllenhaal is the main attraction and he does an admirable job playing a sheepish if somewhat underdeveloped hero.

While the prince is widely acknowledged as an elevated urchin, Gyllenhaal never seems to incorporate this in his performance. Gyllenhaal doesn’t plumb many emotional depths here as he’s been known to (as in “Brothers” and “Zodiac”), but he brings something far more enjoyable to the table with his sense of humor. He sidesteps looking ridiculous by adding a smile to some cheesy dialogue, and flashes a cocky grin when outnumbered.

It might be blasphemy but the Prince of Persia recalls a bit of Han Solo. The Gyllenhaal-as-chiseled-hunk phenom also makes him a much more believable successor to Harrison Ford than the profane designation of Shia LaBeouf in the latest “Indiana Jones.”

Supporting the Gyllenhaal peep show are Gemma Arterton and Ben Kingsley. Arterton, playing the princess, is repeatedly described as a “great beauty” in the film. Sure, she’s a pretty face, but her fiery persona is the real jewel. That feistiness couples perfectly with Gyllenhaal’s nonchalance, making the requisite romantic interest of summer action flicks, well, actually interesting. On the other hand, Ben Kingsley does an adequate job as a Persian noble but the fact that he’s schlepping for a piece of blockbuster pie is just depressing.

All in all, “Prince” is pretty solid summer fare. In reality, all of the aforementioned elements are slices of Wonder Bread to sandwich the meaty action. And the action is where the movie delivers. The sword fights, brawls and acrobatics get the adrenaline pumping.

Mike Newell has a much better handle on action now than when he made his first departure from romantic comedy in “Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire.” There are still vestiges of the hurried and awkward cuts that plagued “Potter,” but for the most part, Newell succeeds.

One of the reasons Newell does so well with “Prince” is his appreciation of its source material. The “Prince of Persia” video game franchise dates back to 1989 and has been a staple of the fanboy community ever since. Yet these same fanboys have had a rocky relationship with film studios that treat video games like a scriptwriter’s farm league.

The myriad video-game-to-movie adaptations have been butchered on film. “Super Mario Bros.” was the first and made a lot of money. Yet the film simply took the story and left the elements of gaming behind, as if it was simply another book adaptation.

More adaptations followed suit: “Mortal Kombat,” “Double Dragon,” and “Resident Evil.” All the while non-video game-based films started to feel more like Mario. The “Star Wars” prequels adapted the structure of bosses and mini-bosses while “Cloverfield” took up the camera pioneered by first-person shooters. When video game adaptations did start incorporating elements of the medium, in “Doom” and “Hitman,” the attempts were often half-baked or overdone.

“Prince” successfully transposes elements of the video game medium into a movie. The first 25 minutes uses first-person (“GoldenEye”), faux-cutscenes (“Syphon Filter”), shots that locate enemy weaknesses (“House of the Dead”) and wide-angle army movements (“Rome: Total War). The Persian archers even point their crossbows like Marines point their rifles in “Call of Duty.” These features conflate the two mediums, which is a perfect move for “Prince.” It not only sates the fanboys but also makes what could be a routine summer action flick into something far more interesting.

Posted in Arts & Entertainment, Movie Reviews, OtherComments Off on Movie Review: “The Prince Of Persia”

Concert Review: Frightened Rabbit/The Fillmore/San Francisco

Great concerts usually have that moment, often tucked away in the middle of the set or reserved for the end of the encore, where the band approaches an emotional pinnacle. As the song builds, the drummer pounds more intensely, the guitarists strum more manically and the singer reaches the upper limits of his range, screaming in an intense release.

Frightened Rabbit aimed for this effect on every song they played at the Fillmore in San Francisco May 19th. It proved to be exhausting, and not necessarily in a good way.

The Scottish indie rockers, at their best, play endearing tunes filled with male post-breakup angst. The chord progressions and melodies are designed to pack an emotional wallop, not necessarily to be innovative or interesting. Scott Hutchison’s lyrics combine testosterone-filled spittle with darkly humorous self-loathing. Add in his thick brogue and these lads have an undeniably powerful formula. Indeed, many of their numbers hit close to home during their concert. All the couples in the crowd making out and tightly holding each other were obviously getting something out of it.

But the scope of Frightened Rabbit’s sound often belied their attempts to connect with the listener on a personal level. They used to be a trio, and watching three dudes go to town on their instruments only to muster a thin, ramshackle sound had a real charm to it.

At their Fillmore appearance, they were a bloated quintet, and their newly found, stadium-ready sound was problematic. The bass (conspicuously absent from their previous lineups), synths and electronics seemed anachronistic. Everything added up to a monolithic tidal wave of sound that didn’t wash over the audience so much as drown them.

This move towards grandiosity was quite alienating. Frightened Rabbit weren’t the earnest, lovable self-deprecators that they were on 2008’s wonderful The Midnight Organ Fight. Rather, they were self-aggrandizers. They used to approach subjects like dissolving relationships and sexual frustration within their proper scope, treating them as the kind of confusing, enervating shit that everyone goes through.

At Wednesday’s concert they turned these molehill-sized problems into Mount Everests of neurosis. They postured themselves more like martyrs than people going through ordinary sufferings. Between songs, Hutchison joked about being twice as good as Jesus, and given what he was trying to achieve during the show, the quip didn’t come off quite as ironic as he might have liked. Straight from the opening number, “Skip the Youth,” they aimed for chest-thumping, shirt-clenching catharsis. But, there’s a limit on the number of peaks and valleys one can go through before the roller coaster starts making you feel queasy and want off.

Bombast didn’t suit them well. Great, caustic lyrics like “You’re the shit and I’m knee deep in it” and “This girl, she was nothing like you” got buried under all the overwrought heaviness. The best moments of the concert were when the band stripped away the histrionics, as on songs like “The Twist” or “Old Old Fashioned,” both undeniably catchy and clever tunes. On each, Hutchison pleads for human connection. And with more modest, humble arrangements, it was easy to get on his level.

Even better was when Hutchison took the stage solo for the encore, playing the fingerpicked, plainspoken ballad “Poke.” This simple forthrightness was much more moving than the rest of the overdone show.

As I filed out of the Fillmore, brushing up a little too close to my fellow concertgoers, I felt tired and lonely. No matter how hard I tried, the band’s huge sound kept me always just at arm’s length.

Posted in Arts & Entertainment, Concert Review, OtherComments Off on Concert Review: Frightened Rabbit/The Fillmore/San Francisco

Book Review: “Tell-All” by Chuck Palahniuk

In “Act One, Scene Five” of Chuck Palahniuk’s latest novel, the narrator, Hazie, rips up a letter and flushes it down the toilet. “Folding the parchment, I tear it once, twice. Folding and tearing, until the sentences become only words. The words become only letters of the alphabet, which I sprinkle into the toilet bowl.” This is essentially what Palahniuk does with language in “Tell-All.” And a toilet seems like a cozier place for his prose than the 179 pages his narrative occupies.

Palahniuk is no stranger to the neighborhood of contemporary fiction. His 1996 debut, “Fight Club,” remains a much-lauded part of popular culture’s lexicon. “Choke” (2001) inspired a cult following that fashioned a fringe writer into a literary mogul.

Both these novels were made into films. While most of Palahniuk’s books read as if tailor-made for book-to-movie adaptation, his 11th novel literalizes this trend and takes it too far.

In “Tell-All,” Palahniuk employs the jargon of a screenplay, such as dissolving “into flashback” or “a panning shot.” To a cumbersome degree, he conflates this trope with the language of playwriting, directing us to “stage right” or “stage left.” The point of this uninspired leitmotif is never really established, nor does it really support the novel’s content. Demarcating chapters into acts and scenes is equally befuddling.

With this in mind, the book reads like a script written by the narrator, Hazie Coogan, who in describing herself says, “I was Thelma Ritter before Thelma Ritter was Thelma Ritter.” Palahniuk stages his novel in the milieu of Old Hollywood before smog and cynicism set in. Hazie is a self-proclaimed “Pygmalion,” a housekeeper and life coach for the actress Katherine Kenton.

“William Wyler, C.B. DeMille and Howard Hawks may have directed her in a picture or two, but I have directed Miss Kathie’s entire adult life,” Hazie surreptitiously tells us. As the narrator, Hazie works to keep Miss Kathie from falling out of stardom and to preserve the illusion that her mistress’ life is founded on more than just a backdrop of washed-up Hollywood nobodies.

If Shakespeare’s right and the world is truly a stage, then what happens in the wings of Miss Kathie’s life is far more interesting than the production itself. She has an illicit love affair – orchestrated by Hazie, of course – with the bachelor Webster Carlton Westward III that quickly goes from passionate to putrid. Miss Kathie and Hazie discover that Webster has written a draft of a memoir he calls “Love Slave.” Not only does it contain a litany of Miss Kathie’s filthy, intimate indiscretions, like a soft-core “120 Days of Sodom,” but Webster’s book also foretells the actress’ death. Doesn’t it make you wish that instead of a few excerpts, the whole novel were “Love Slave?”

Miss Kathie seems to cherish the longevity of her career rather than her life itself. Immediately she panics about how Westward’s draft will be received after her death. Never mind that Westward plans to run her over. And in the world of “Tell-All,” the words “death” and “kill” have double meaning. They refer to dying yet more than that, these words refer to one’s Hollywood career and clout: To kill is to kill a reputation.

It takes about 100 pages for Palahniuk to get the narrative wheels turning and once he does, the book’s almost over. In lieu of taut, tightly wound narrative structure, he fills the book with page upon page of digressions. “Tell-All” is certainly a telling title because Palahniuk, in his plain yet affected prose and his awkward metaphors and similes, tells rather than shows.

His hubris is in full form here. He makes more than a few nods to canonical writers that would only sate the most undeveloped of literary palates (“Katherine Kenton will sit alone as abandoned as Miss Havisham in the novel by Charles Dickens.”). Through every act, scene, whatever of “Tell-All,” Palahniuk, like a bad film critic or a paparazzi with Tourette’s, namedrops ad nauseam. In a failed act of postmodernist flourish, he boldfaces each name – and often in quick succession. In one particularly overstuffed paragraph, Pocahontas, Athena, Hera, Juliet Capulet, Scarlett O’Hara, Ophelia and Marie Antoinette, among many others, are all mentioned in 12 lines of text. Fortunately, “Tell-All” doesn’t demand that we understand every reference. Most are more irrelevant than irreverent, and if you don’t get one of them, you’re bound to get the next one.

In typical Palahniuk style, he’s at his best in the book’s bawdiest scenes. There are some grotesquely comic moments, like Miss Kathie shopping for a baby by matching its skin color with a paint chip, and her stupidity is often the brunt of Hazie’s jokes (“‘I love that word … au pair it sounds almost like … French,'” Kathie says). Yet sometimes Palahniuk is too self-consciously witty, such as neologisms like “was-bands” for husbands.

Palahniuk was once the guy who put every public service ad about masturbation to shame with his short story “Guts.” And he’s also the guy who told us what “filching” means in the novel “Invisible Monsters.” What happened to that guy? Is he still in there? “Tell-All” is less hysteric and less daring Palahniuk. Without the kinky sex, flesh-curdling gore and even the occasional insight of his previous books, we’re left with a mere skeleton of a novel that isn’t even worth pulling out of a closet and hanging in a classroom.

Posted in Arts & Entertainment, Book Reviews, OtherComments Off on Book Review: “Tell-All” by Chuck Palahniuk

TV: Thumb Wars. Debating The “Lost” Finale

Love It

Go ahead. Say “Lost” was stupid. I dare you to cite those trite and overused examples I’ve had thrust my way these last six years. “Why are there polar bears on an island with a tropical climate?” or “How can that one guy still be obese after half a decade of a sea urchin and mango diet?”

What the “Lost” opposition didn’t realize is that we Lost fans asked these very questions too. We are not idiots, but instead, we are people of faith. We couldn’t be scared off by the ridiculousness of time traveling or voices whispering in the wilderness. It only bonded us more.

We fans know television isn’t always meant to be an easy escape – that there isn’t always meant to be an indirect relationship between the remote control and our brains (aka “TV turns on, mind turns off”).

If J.J. Abrams and company presented a character named Daniel Faraday; we knew we had to research his namesake, 18th century physicist Michael Faraday, and his work on electromagnetism. If everyone’s favorite island cowboy Sawyer was reading Steinbeck, we knew we couldn’t fully understand the episode without a fairly respectable grasp of the themes in “Of Mice and Men.” Six seasons have required me to research (through Wikipedia, mostly – I do have a life) Christian theory, enlightenment philosophers and ’60s pop song lyrics.

But, above all else, what made this show so rewarding to its faithful audience was all of those naysayers – those who cast us “foolish fans” away as dopes who could believe in smoke monsters and magic numbers. It was they who tested our faith and only made us stronger. And now that the show has been completed and we saw our fidelity rewarded with answers, closure and perhaps a little too much sentiment, we know it is they who officially lost.

-Maggie Owens

Hate It

I walked into my living room Sunday night and started to ask my sister what she was watching. Before I could get two words out, she screamed, “SHUT UP! FOR JUST FIVE MINUTES!” as she and her friend gripped a box of tissues, intently focused at the edge of their seats.

In a few minutes, the “Lost” finale they had waited six years to see, a resolution to all the maddening plot puzzles was over. And at the end of it all they both just said “huh?”

Then the debates started. Were they dead the whole time? Was the new place heaven? Was the island purgatory? What the fuck does everything mean? And now, after six years of waiting for “Lost” fans to shut up about the show, they get a vague ending that just leaves more questions to talk about.

Seriously? Are you surprised the end was confusing? Did you actually think they were going to resolve anything?

Fans like my sister, who are addicted to the show like crack, have been duped. They got emotionally hooked to a show that left them theorizing and arguing over what each little code or mythological reference meant and how they were going to get off the island since “Lost” began. These are all mysteries that never had an answer to begin with.

The writers have been stretching and milking the plot with no destination for as long as people were interested. Creators Carlton Cuse and Damon Lindelof have said they’ve been making stuff up as they’ve gone along. The only reason they ended the series was because it seemed people finally started to get tired of them spinning their wheels.

Now nobody’s happy. “Lost” fans will continue to debate an unsolvable mystery until they get sick of talking in circles, and the rest of us are still stuck listening.

-Camden Andrews

Posted in Arts & Entertainment, Other, TelevisionComments Off on TV: Thumb Wars. Debating The “Lost” Finale

Album Review: Crystal Castles “Crystal Castles”

Like some tenacious, self-replicating bacteria, Torontonian duo Crystal Castles now has two self-titled records. They’re hardly the first perpetrators of this nomenclatural laziness (think Weezer), but on their new release, the retreading is worrisome.

This isn’t to say the album is a clone of its predecessor. Indeed, it’s a harsher affair all around, shriller and buzzier than the band’s motley but enchanting 2008 debut. The new record starts out strong, earning weird points with the distorted shrieking on “Doe Deer.” But Castles 2.0 peaks too early – the fourth track, “Baptism,” is a brilliant number, with airy synth volleys and Alice Glass’s best shouty vocals, so low in the mix it sounds like she’s submerged in water.

From that point forward the repetitive album title looms as a bad omen. Castles 1.0 existed in a glitchy sonic microcosm that, though not exclusive territory, seemed to set Crystal Castles apart from the herd. Instead, this album is disappointingly uniform, sounding more redundant than cohesive. The tracks are formidable – there are good songs here, especially the vocal distortion playground of “Vietnam” – but they’re all buzz and blip and Glass’s dead-robot vocals. This might work for dance parties or mixtapes, but it’s mediocre album listening.

There are occasional moments where the album’s crunchy electro aesthetic breaks down and an iciness seeps in, as at the end of “Suffocation” or during the aforementioned synth passages of “Baptism.” It’s these nuggets of glassy simplicity that recall the novelty of first hearing Castles 1.0 opener “Untrust Us.” Something in the duo’s music is absolutely unearthly, and hopefully they will find new uses for that transcendence in the future. Here, though, it’s all swaddled in the obvious.

Posted in Album Reviews, Arts & Entertainment, OtherComments Off on Album Review: Crystal Castles “Crystal Castles”

Album Review: Janelle Monae “The ArchAndroid”

Janelle Monáe is probably the first pop star ever to write and record a multi-suite album about robots in a made-up Metropolis. But if anyone can pull it off, Monáe can. The Kansas native and aspiring Broadway star-turned-singer-songwriter is an extremely gifted vocalist and writer.

After giving up the stage and making her way to Atlanta, Monáe made nice with Big Boi and eventually Diddy, who made it his priority to produce her EP Metropolis, Suite I: The Chase for Bad Boy Entertainment. Inspired by Fritz Lang’s sci-fi film “Metropolis,” Monáe crafted an ambiguous and ambitious space opera to frame her music. With a taut, slick and fresh production touch, The Chase brought her recognition and tour material. Fast-forward an excruciating three years and we have all the hype and screaming that comes with her towering, long awaited, first full-length release: The ArchAndroid.

With 18 tracks, overtures, segues and high-gloss production pop, The ArchAndroid is a beast of an album. Running over an hour, it’s essentially two EPs laid back-to-back, barreling through just about every popular (and unpopular) genre in pop music’s recent memory.

With a foundation in soul and funk, Monáe’s Android is a fresh, boundless trek through melody, concept and performance. Its wide-reaching drive recalls sprawling landmarks like Stevie Wonder’s Songs in the Key of Life and Prince’s Sign ‘O’ the Times. Monáe’s voice is a remarkable beauty — it’s funky and pretty, and does just about everything it set out to do. And with Android, Monáe accomplishes quite a bit, even when the end result slips.

Highlights on a varied album like this are tough to pull out because for most listeners, they’ll be entirely subjective. “Tightrope” is a blistering take on James Brown funk, with more melody. It’s a production masterpiece; with a cluttering kit drum backbeat, chicken-scratch guitar, gospel backing vocals and just about every trick thrown on top — with Monáe cast strong as bandleader. Following “Suite II Overture,” the first three proper tracks on the album are an exhilarating bunch, from “Dance or Die” with its Fela stomp to the Off the Wall-era MJ disco of “Lost Inside.” Throughout, Monáe is a flexible, commanding and powerful presence. From breezy bubblegum pop on “Wondaland” to heartfelt soul on “Neon Valley Street” to piano balladry on “Say You’ll Go,” the list of successes goes on and on.

And yet, for all of its sublime moments, Android has some clunkers, and some of the worst mistakes trip up otherwise great songs. “Tightrope” swings along under Monáe’s powerful voice — until Big Boi’s tacky verse takes a shit on the whole production. “Oh Maker” blends a delightfully kitschy serving of ABBA, Stevie Wonder and the best of Mariah Carey ballads, but it ends before it can amount to much of anything. Of Montreal’s “collaboration” features so little of Monáe that it simply doesn’t fit in at all. The two overtures and recycled tracks like “Neon Gumbo” are skip-able diversions that cut Android’s flow in nasty ways. For an album with so much on its plate, Android could afford to lose some weight.

In the end, The ArchAndroid thrills and chills with equal impact, hitting rapturous highs and scraping occasional, unmemorable lows. But Monáe is such a refreshing presence that her full-length debut is required listening, even if you only dig half the tracks.

It’s a ridiculous, ambitious effort from a creative new talent, and here’s to hoping Monáe’s in it for the long run. With a little bit of focus, she can paint a clearer picture of her quirky, limitless Metropolis — God knows she has the talent to do it.

Posted in Album Reviews, Arts & Entertainment, OtherComments Off on Album Review: Janelle Monae “The ArchAndroid”

Book Review: “The November Criminals”

Pretentious, rambling and naive are just a few of the less-than-desirable traits that describe Addison Schacht, the young protagonist of “The November Criminals” — Sam Munson’s debut novel, (released April 20). Munson adopts the voice of his whiny protagonist for this first-person narrative, and somehow manages to make Addison’s story into a halfway decent and even likeable book.

Addison is not your typical high school senior — at least not in most areas of the country. He attends an elite private school in Washington, D.C., where he deals marijuana to his rich classmates and sleeps with Digger, his spitfire “hipster” non-girlfriend. “She is NOT my girlfriend,” Addison says of their relationship. “I would fight you for saying so. SHE would fight you for saying so.” Instead, Addison says that he “[prefers] a life of free-ranging … concubinage.” Pretentious statements like this highlight some of Addison’s less endearing qualities.

Addison’s atypical adolescent existence is enabled by his father — a well meaning but absent parent still coping with the loss of Addison’s mother, who died when he was a child. The plot revolves around the homicide of an African-American student at Addison’s prep school, as Addison becomes obsessed with finding the killer.

Despite Addison’s penchant for detective hood, however, “The November Criminals” is neither a mystery nor a thriller. Rather, it is a novel, as the book’s jacket correctly claims, of “teenage maladjustment.” And strangely enough, this tale comes alive primarily through Munson’s use of Addison’s imperfect, yet undeniably original voice.

The novel is written as Addison’s 258-page response to a question on his college application for the University of Chicago: “What are your best and worst qualities?” Addison’s approach to this question alone makes “The November Criminals” worthwhile reading material for high school seniors agonizing over their college essays.

Instead of writing the standard and desperate essay about saving children in Africa last summer, Addison tells it like it is — and his honesty and candor are incredibly refreshing. Granted, I don’t know how admissions officers would react to an essay that openly talks about “selling small-to-medium amounts of weed to safe, calm rich kids,” but I do think that they would be thrilled to find Addison’s truthfulness in their application folders.

In keeping with its focus on college admissions, the novel draws a great deal of inspiration from the school it depicts (Munson graduated from the University of Chicago in 2003). And just as the University of Chicago has a highly intellectual environment that would probably not appeal to the majority of America, “The November Criminals” is an intellectual book that may turn some people off. Addison, for example, is obsessed with Virgil, and makes references to his writings constantly.

During class one day, for example, Addison says quite seriously to his teacher “[Virgil] was talking about the first time Aenaes and Dido — the insane queen of Carthage, remember? — have sex.” Even as an English major, I have never read any Virgil, and don’t know this. He begins to yell at his teacher, “You can’t judge Virgil. Are you planning on writing something that we’ll still be reading in thousands of years? Are you? You have no right! You just don’t. Okay?” Again, I thought, enough with the Virgil obsession.

While Addison’s intelligence comes off as arrogant and irritating at times, at other points, it makes for great comedic writing. In one chapter in particular, when Addison and his girlfriend think they are going to find the murderer of their classmate (and instead find a pot-bellied, slow-talking teddy bear of a man), they made me laugh out loud. The book is littered with sarcastic comments that make for a fun and humorous reading experience.

I’m very picky about books that use an adolescent voice. Getting it right and avoiding clichés is a steep challenge. This adolescent’s narration is better than average, but Munson still has a lot of work to do before he gets it just right.

Posted in Arts & Entertainment, Book Reviews, OtherComments Off on Book Review: “The November Criminals”

Book Review: “Taming The Gods: Religion and Democracy On Three Continents”

In his new book Taming the Gods, British-Dutch writer Ian Buruma recalls the outrage and death threats that greeted the publication of Salman Rushdie’s The Satanic Verses. The incident united British intellectuals, Buruma writes, leading “many multiculturalists, anti-racists, and pro-Third Worldists to join conservatives in their stand against Islam.” Since the 9/11 attacks, however, debates about Islam in Europe have been vigorous, and accusations of appeasement and xenophobia have flown back and forth.

Taming the Gods seeks to offer a reasoned discussion of the proper relationship between religion and politics. Buruma approaches this perennially vexing problem with a unique blend of political theory and history, spanning Europe, Asia, and North America. While the novelty of his approach yields fresh historical perspective and some insight on European Islam, it does not offer a truly unique contribution to the larger church-state debate. Instead, Buruma advances the standard liberal line that the passions of religion must be “tamed” and all citizens must follow the rules of democracy, without offering concrete solutions for applying this framework.

Buruma begins with a crash course on the Western problem of church-state relations. While his summary of classical thinkers like Hume, Spinoza, and Rousseau occasionally becomes textbook-like, he offers fascinating connections between those writers and the historical development of democracy. For example, he says that Tocqueville’s idea that “unbelievers attacked the Church more as a political rather than religious enemy” explains both the persecution of Catholics in revolutionary France and their marginalization in 19th century America.

Buruma argues counter-intuitively that modern-day Europe and America are not as different as American critics of godless Europe and European detractors of American zealotry hold. He finds that every European country has a distinctive way of balancing religion and secular government, and that the United States is a variation on, not a departure from, this theme. The religious-fundamentalist elements in America, he points out, historically have supported democracy more strongly than similar factions have in France or Germany.

Eastern Promises

Buruma then turns to the East and examines China and Japan, disputing “the notion that only monotheistic religions pose problems for secular politics.” Confucian thought, though it contains the oldest formulation of the right of rebellion against unjust authority, has strong themes of obedience that have been manipulated by leaders like Mao to thwart democratic movements.

In Japan, State Shinto suppressed secularizing trends in the 19th century. The divine authority of the emperor ruled out the possibility of democracy until after World War II. While Buruma shows that the issue of political and religious authority is not a uniquely Western problem, the lesson he draws is not particularly earth shattering: government and religion often make a dangerous combination.
Buruma’s central argument is clearest when he criticizes those frequent warnings about how Islam is a threat to European society. He lines up with other liberals in that he condemns Islamophobia and argues that the emergence of a democratic European Islam is possible. But he also warns of the great danger posed by the refusal of Islamic fundamentalists to recognize the legitimacy of the secular European states in which they live. This problem creates the necessity of “taming the gods,” or reigning in religious extremism.

Distancing himself from conservatives, Buruma points out that this cause will be hindered not helped, by xenophobic and exclusionary reactions against Muslims. He argues that liberal tolerance must extend even to illiberal doctrines and practices, as long as they are pursued peacefully. Liberalism for Buruma is not a way of life but a mediator between different ways of life, not all of which need to be perfectly liberal or modern.

Buruma’s recommendation for the future is simple, perhaps too simple. Maintaining a liberal society that includes illiberal citizens is more easily said than done. Buruma’s work admirably rejects the reprehensible extremes of theocracy and xenophobia. But his elegant writing hides a dearth of real proposals for some of the thorniest issues, such as how to assimilate Europe’s swelling Muslim population and how to incorporate religious viewpoints into public debate without violating the spirit of secularism. Ultimately, in spite of its vagueness when it comes to practical solutions, the strength of Buruma’s book lies in his call to tame not only religious extremism, but extremist reactions against extremism as well.

Posted in Arts & Entertainment, Book Reviews, OtherComments Off on Book Review: “Taming The Gods: Religion and Democracy On Three Continents”

Movie Review: “Green Zone”

Nighttime. Baghdad. March 19, 2003. The city bursts into light as “Shock and Awe” sweeps across the desert. Director Paul Greengrass (United 93, The Bourne Ultimatum) begins his latest release, Green Zone, with a black screen as the sounds of air-raid warnings and the crescendo of American bombs slowly fills the theater. After a riveting skyline view of Iraq’s capitol city under siege in the opening hours of Operation Iraqi Freedom, the viewer is thrown into the terrifying perspective of an Iraqi awoken in the night to the sounds of war.

The scene cuts, and now the viewer is in the company of Chief Warrant Officer Roy Miller (a stoic Matt Damon), as he frantically searches a Baghdad facility for weapons of mass destruction. Greengrass’s characteristic slingshot camerawork and skilled pacing masterfully convey a sense of immediacy. In the first two scenes alone, Green Zone creates a world that more closely resembles the maelstrom of Iraq than any film yet.

Unfortunately, the film’s bracingly realistic style is soon put into the service of a caricature-laden plot and a thinly veiled leftist politics. This turn for the worse is disappointing but not all that surprising. Green Zone continues a long line of recent Hollywood films that fail to engage politics and war in all their grim and tragic complexity—resorting to one-dimensional characters, clichéd monologues, and a conspiracy theory-based plot.

Where are the Weapons?

Roy Miller and his squad keep coming up empty-handed at every potential WMD site they visit. Suspicious and frustrated, Miller teams up with Martin Brown (Brendan Gleeson), a veteran CIA officer, and the two begin a rogue mission to determine the reason for the intelligence failures. Their efforts place them in opposition to Clark Poundstone (Greg Kinnear), a top official in the Department of Defense, and a composite figure clearly drawn from L. Paul Bremer, Donald Rumsfeld, and Douglas Feith. Poundstone is a quintessentially Machiavellian bureaucrat. His every move seems choreographed to provoke the viewer’s disdain.

Miller’s investigation also leads him to a close encounter with General Al Rawi, Saddam Hussein’s top general. Al Rawi becomes the missing link in Miller’s investigation. As he slowly puts the pieces together with the help of Lawrie Dayne (Amy Ryan), a Wall Street Journal reporter who was Poundstone’s mouthpiece in the run-up to the war, he begins to realize that Poundstone is hiding something about the missing WMDs. Predictably, to get to the bottom of things, Miller has to defy orders and take matters into his own hands—for a moment, one almost expects Poundstone to shout “Bourne’s gone rogue!” into a satellite phone.

Greengrass returns to form with a brilliant chase scene at the end of the film. As Miller and one of Poundstone’s cronies from Special Forces (Jason Isaacs) chase General Al Rawi through the streets of Baghdad, an American helicopter follows them from above as they weave and wind through the city’s tight neighborhoods amid a barrage of bullets. The editing in this scene is amazing, as the viewer switches between the three parties at a nearly inconceivable pace. When the dust has cleared, Baghdad is ablaze and the descent towards sectarian violence has begun. The sequence will remind fans of Greengrass’s admirable work in the last two Jason Bourne movies.

The Lessons of War

Nearly seven years have passed since the futile search for WMDs portrayed in Green Zone. With almost 4,400 American soldiers and countless Iraqi civilians dead, the country has witnessed the tragic and bitter consequences of war. Yet for some, the war provides the opportunity to promote a simplistic agenda. Green Zone’s paranoid plot does little to dispel the perception that Hollywood liberals can’t think of anything more sophisticated to say about Iraq than “Bush lied, people died.”

There is no doubt that a huge intelligence failure occurred in the run-up to the Iraq War. However, Greengrass turns the intelligence community into a locus of preposterous corruption, purposely constructed to justify American imperialism. Greengrass’s Iraq war is a game in which powerful officials push misinformation in order to lead innocent soldiers into a vicious, deadly quagmire. Reasonable critics and supporters of the war might enjoy the film, but they need not accept its maddeningly simplistic political message.

Posted in Arts & Entertainment, Movie Reviews, OtherComments Off on Movie Review: “Green Zone”

Book Review: “The Quants”

Wall Street titans like Lehman Brothers CEO Dick Fuld, AIG CEO Hank Greenberg, and scam artist Bernie Madoff have emerged as the central villains of the financial crisis. But in The Quants, Wall Street Journal reporter Scott Patterson introduces us to a breed of mysterious figures who played a crucial role in the crisis but have largely avoided media scrutiny. They are the Quants, analysts who use arcane mathematical techniques to reap enormous financial rewards.

More Riemann than Rothschild, the Quants bring advanced mathematical knowledge from academia to Wall Street in order to execute complex and lucrative trades. Patterson focuses on the men behind the formulas, giving us a fascinating glimpse into their motivations and eccentricities, without casting judgment. Ultimately, though, his story suggests that the quant subculture and methodology helped bring about the financial crisis. And despite the huge losses they sustained, the Quants will remain stars on Wall Street for the foreseeable future, relatively safe from populist anger.

Patterson appropriately begins his book with a poker game, in which young quant prodigies vie for the respect of their bosses. Card games are a favorite pastime of the Quants; the mix of competition and calculation is intoxicating for them. Edward O. Thorp, a noted mathematician and legendary investor, did pioneering research into blackjack strategy before realizing that his ideas could be applied to trading convertible bonds. The entire cast of The Quants began their careers after reading Thorp’s classic 1962 book, Beat the Dealer.

Patterson’s Quants are, at heart, math whizzes out to solve a challenging problem whose solution, only incidentally, can make them billions of dollars. What lures them to Wall Street is the desire to win more than the desire to earn money—hence the fascination with poker and blackjack. In cards and in investing, the Quants look to win for winning’s sake; taking home the pot is just a bonus.

The Quants got their start as star students in math and science, and then migrated to New York to test their algorithms in an industry then run largely by men making gut decisions. (Not all even waited to graduate. Ken Griffin, Harvard Class of 1989, put a satellite dish on the roof of Cabot House and traded convertible bonds on his grandmother’s bank account.) Patterson describes the tension on Wall Street between the Quants and the old-guard traders, whom the Quants affectionately deride as “Big Swinging Dicks,” and traces it back to tension between the nerds and the preppy jocks at Harvard.

The Biggest Casino of Them All

While The Quants is a story about geeks, Patterson helpfully assumes that his audience will not necessarily grasp the difference between Brownian motion and Gaussian copula. Nor must one be a banker to appreciate the book. Although some knowledge of finance is certainly helpful, you need no PhD or MBA to understand Cliff Asness’s computer-smashing rampages at Goldman Sachs or Ken Griffin’s single-minded quest to build Citadel Investment Group into an empire. At its best, The Quants is more about the people than the formulas.

But even as Patterson focuses on the unique personalities of his subjects, he links them with a theme that he, quite frankly, pounds into the reader’s brain. In fact, he repeats one narrative so frequently that the book can be summarized thusly: the Quants, looking for “the Truth” in “the biggest casino of them all,” nearly brought down the whole system. Patterson ends a chapter with this page-turning tease: “If Boaz Weinstein could hold on long enough, [the trades] would pay off. They had to. The market couldn’t avoid the Truth. Or so he thought.” How could the market avoid the Truth? We do not find out for another 150 pages. Lines like “Those close enough to the action could almost feel the fabric of the financial system tearing apart” add vague tension but clarify little. The repetition of such clichés is a symptom of Patterson’s attempt to make a complicated financial crisis seem like the inevitable result of his subjects’ high-stakes games.

Quants in the Crisis

Still, Patterson offers an interesting theory about how common quant strategies exacerbated the financial crisis. He starts with the common intellectual heritage and tight-knit community of the Quants. Nearly all see themselves as the arbitraging “piranhas” from Eugene Fama’s Efficient Market Hypothesis. Fama famously posited that an asset’s price in efficient markets (including the American stock market) would reflect all of the available information about the asset. Thus, the only way to beat the market would be to have information that no one else has, or to act fastest on newly released information. Like piranhas devouring fresh meat, traders arbitrage “incorrect” prices until they reach equilibrium. The Quants designed models to discover the closest approximation of what the “true” value of an asset should be, and used the best computers to act fast on newly released information.

Ultimately, these lucrative methods turned toxic when the sub-prime crisis arrived. The quant funds had grown large enough that “hall-of-mirrors-like, it became difficult to tell the difference between the model and the market itself.” The Quants believed that their models represented, rather than approximated, true asset values, and they made trades that were big enough to move the markets toward those values. But when sub-prime losses led one large fund to scramble for cash to cover its loans, it unwound the entire quant system, causing the market to move in the opposite direction from where it was expected to go. Since nearly all of the Quants had similar investments, as each quant fund cut its losses, it made the next fund’s losses worse. The rapid computer-executed trades only added to the volatility.

The New Deans

Still, in spite of the huge losses that Patterson recounts, the Quants are probably here to stay. This is in part due to the tight-knit quant culture that the book so ably portrays. They are endlessly devising new moneymaking strategies, and are once again earning enormous profits for the banks and hedge funds that employ them. It was the same story after the crises of 1987 and 1998. It seems that, for all of their recent failings, the Quants have permanently upset the old “Big Swinging Dick” order. The professors are the new barons of Wall Street, and they appear poised to accrue even more power. They are like “civil engineers … after a bridge collapse,” Patterson writes: they’re to blame, but they’re also needed for the rebuilding. The Quants is a great starting point for understanding how the members of this new financial elite brought down, and might again build up, our nation’s economy.

Posted in Arts & Entertainment, Book Reviews, OtherComments Off on Book Review: “The Quants”