Author Archives | Aishiki Nag, Opinion Columnist

Nag: Digital privacy and the Fourth Amendment

Over Memorial Day weekend, 105 undergraduate, graduate and law students convened at Washington State University in St. Louis to discuss the shortcomings of the U.S. Constitution and imagine creative solutions to make laws better. The last official federal constitutional convention convened in 1787, and leaders have yet to meet officially since then. 

From the 20 submitted amendment proposals, three of them aimed to address the lack of protections for digital privacy. When drafting the Constitution, the Founding Fathers could not have anticipated the rapid expansion of surveillance and data collection, and the Fourth Amendment desperately needs to include language to protect individuals from new forms of government overreach. 

Under “Riley v. California” (2014), the Supreme Court unanimously ruled that police generally must obtain a warrant to access records and data from a private individual’s phone. Under “Carpenter v. United States” (2018), the Supreme Court ruled that courts also need to obtain a warrant to access historical data. These rulings have been in line with traditional Fourth Amendment interpretations to keep private individuals’ information and property safe from unreasonable searches and seizures. 

However, one glaring loophole remains, weakening all aforementioned protections against government overreach. The third-party doctrine under the Fourth Amendment rules that individuals lose their reasonable expectation of privacy in any information they consensually share with third parties. This has been used to refer to bank information, phone records and internet search records. 

The third-party amendment allows for the government to work with third parties to receive personal information or surveil individuals without a warrant, as long as it was once voluntarily shared with the site. So what does that actually entail? 

People currently mail in their personal DNA to sites such as 23andMe; people rely on Alexa or other smart home devices to ask everyday questions, not noticing the microphone that is attached; people store important information and documents on Google, iCloud and Microsoft Teams. These are all technically under the third-party doctrine and can be subject to government surveillance. 

By adding an explicit mention of informational privacy into the Fourth Amendment, this would protect all persons from unreasonable surveillance by the government, and it could only access information after a warrant has been issued by a judge. 

Government agencies such as the National Security Agency, Federal Bureau of Investigation and Department of Homeland Security often collect bulk data from private third parties to monitor communication and activities of the general population. This policy overwhelmingly lacks checks and balances, and it currently allows for indiscriminate tracking.

Flock Safety, which has been a prominent company used for public safety technology to read license plates and a thorough video surveillance system, has been instated by over 5,000 communities – including Eugene at one point. 

Community residents were quick to point out that local police departments could choose to share community members’ data with a national database, which can then be accessed by Immigration and Customs Enforcement or Customs and Border Protection. The ACLU of Oregon heavily pushed back on this and advocated for Eugene to have their contract cancelled, because a national database that is shared with ICE would inherently break sanctuary state laws. 

Although the issues with Flock in Eugene have been addressed, states either need to adopt a constitutional amendment protecting their community members from data sharing, or the U.S. Constitution needs to adopt phrasing to protect everyone from government overreach in data sharing.

The post Nag: Digital privacy and the Fourth Amendment appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Nag: Digital privacy and the Fourth Amendment

Nag: The person behind the missing wallet

The hallway at the Museum of Natural and Cultural History is lined with framed photos of wallets, rosaries, waterbottles, pictures of family members, memorabilia from various pop-culture shows and house keys. These items all once belonged to migrants who were coming to the United States, and these items were taken from them by border patrol agents. 

The exhibit houses 40 objects, with 20 of them being through a rotational exhibit on a tablet at the end of the hall. This was a project curated by students in the “Migrant Belongings” course at the Clark Honors College, which sought to build empathy for people who migrate through the belongings that they have lost during travel, or when they have been apprehended by federal authorities. This project was led by professor Tobin Hansen, who specializes in deportation, migration, the borderlands and belonging.

Within “Shakedown,” a report published by a borderlands NGO called No More Deaths, they found that dispossession of belongings have become a widespread issue — with a third of the 400,000 surveyed deported migrants being released without money or personal belongings. Additionally, the survey revealed that 81% could not afford to travel home; 69% could not afford shelter, and 77% could not afford food as a result of being deported without access to their money. 

“I found it to be really a place of reverence. There was so much personal stake in personal belonging,” junior Piper Bringman said. 

Bringman said it was akin to “walking through a graveyard” — except in graveyards, you know a person’s name, date of birth and date of death, but not much about who they are as a person. Within this exhibit, Bringman said you understand what was important to every single person; however, you don’t find out key identifiers. 

“I think that in our culture, death is something that’s obviously very inevitable, but it’s not something that’s very normalized. Whereas, in the context of something like immigration and deportation, (death and dispossession) is something that has been incredibly normalized in our culture,” Bringman said. 

No More Deaths suggested important policy measures for the Department of Homeland Security  to stop dispossession during deportation. One of the most notable ones is to ensure access to vital belongings during deportation proceedings, including detention. One of the most problematic separations during the chain of custody is separating migrants from medication that they carry on them, which can cause detrimental impacts to health. 

“I think a lot of what we hear about what happens on the border is in the form of numbers, or testimonials, and I think that can lead to a middle ground where it can lead to an intellectual understanding that something is wrong,” Nitai Gaash, a senior studying human physiology, said after visiting the exhibit. “I think that this just showed me that seeing (the belongings) in front of you is completely different. I mean, it’s like hearing a news story about a tragedy versus knowing someone there.”

Gaash said the framed series of letters particularly stood out to him, which in the correspondence discussed a migrant’s mothers health, admissions of guilt and other personal details of their life, which were then intercepted by border patrol.

“I think part of it is how relatable it is. All of those people had things that the average person,  like myself, carried with them,” Gaash said. The stolen items create an important grounds for community building with UO students and Eugene community members to critically engage with the culture of cruelty within deportation processes in the US.

An interpretive art piece about the Sonoran desert, which has been deemed one of the most deadly foot crossing zones in the world for migrants. (Aishiki Nag/Daily Emerald)

The post Nag: The person behind the missing wallet appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Nag: The person behind the missing wallet

Nag: Lane County should declare a drought emergency before it’s too late

My roommate, who’s an avid skier, fervently checked snow predictions for Willamette Pass over winter term, and always ended up disappointed with the lack of snow. Her ski gear, which she covets dearly, was only able to ski on slush. 

Last winter was the highest temperature recorded, with an average of 7 degrees above normal for the state. The precipitation that fell was mostly rain, instead of snow up in the mountains. Mountain snow is crucial for Oregon, since it acts as a natural reservoir and slowly releases a steady stream of water through the spring and summer; meltwater is essential for downstream ecosystems, and those within valleys, providing up to 75% of the water supply in the Pacific Northwest.  

“Right now, our snow pack is about the worst it’s ever been measured in our state’s recorded history, which has gone back to before 1981. The previous year in which we had a snow pack that was this low was in 2015, and during that spring and summer, most counties declared a drought emergency. We had a lot of water shortages, especially for irrigation, agriculture and livestock,” Larry O’Neill, the state climatologist of Oregon, said. O’Neill is also an associate professor at Oregon State and director of the Oregon Climate Service. 

O’Neill mentioned that climate change and climate variability has had detrimental effects on fish populations, especially salmon that run through the corridors around rivers, which are at increased risk due to water shortages. Another issue is that the lack of water can interfere with wildfire prevention and having the proper resources to fight them once they have started. 

“Drought emergencies unlock a variety of tools and resources that individual jurisdictions, like counties, can use to basically prepare and deal with a drought that is coming this summer,” O’Neill said, when asked about potential solutions for addressing the ongoing water crisis. 

Drought emergencies are an official declaration that are made by government officials, such as county commissioners, and then approved by the governor to officially indicate that water supplies have fallen significantly below normal levels and are causing threats to agriculture or safety. 

Considering the historical lows of water reservoirs from the snow packs, Lane County needs to take a proactive approach to addressing the wildfire season, and consider declaring a drought emergency.

“For Oregon, there are statutes in our state legislation that will allow the transfers of water rights and easing of water restrictions, and allow you to pump water from a well or transfer water rights,” O’Neill said. Water transfers allow temporary transfers, leases or adjustments of water usage to address critical needs. 

As of May 2026, 12 of Oregon’s 36 counties have declared a drought emergency, having received approval from Governor Tina Kotek. A third of all Oregon counties have now been designated under this status. 

The Lane Country Commissioners need to come together and advocate for getting Lane County designated as a drought emergent county, and allow for increased water transfers and preparatory measures. Climatologists and forecasters predict a busy wildfire season, with the risk of wildfires occurring earlier in the year. We need to declare a drought emergency before it’s too late to take preparatory measures within the county.

The post Nag: Lane County should declare a drought emergency before it’s too late appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Nag: Lane County should declare a drought emergency before it’s too late

Nag: The money, the rematch and the law

During the 2022 midterm elections, individual political donors spent over $70 million in the Oregon gubernatorial race, which was held between democrat Tina Kotek, independent Betsy Johnson and republican Christine Drazan. This was a recorded 89% increase in spending than past gubernatorial races.

Considering Kotek’s dwindling approval ratings in Democratic strongholds, like Portland, and Drazan’s increased push for campaign fundraising — the 2026 general election is also set to be a high spending campaign.

Even within local elections in Eugene, candidates for nonpartisan elections saw an unprecedented increase in campaign donations. Nine candidates within the Lane County elections raised over $100,000: notably Jake Pelroy, a Lane County commissioner candidate, who raised $295,919. Protect Our County, the campaign against the Watersheds Bill of Rights, raised $435,350.

In 2024, the Oregon state legislature passed House Bill 4024, which limits campaign contributions from individuals to $3,300 and political action committees to $30,000. The initiative passed with broad bipartisan support and large amounts of community support. Although the bill is now set to be implemented in 2027, the Secretary of State’s office should work on taking initiatives to improve campaign finance laws and transparency in campaign spending sooner.

“I think that large private donations like that undermine the importance of the democratic process. It incentivizes politicians to focus on the wants and needs of the donors who are going to give them the most money rather than focusing on the needs of their actual constituents and everyday, middle and (working) class Americans and Oregonians,” Hailey Battrick said. She is a current University of Oregon student studying political science, and a regular voter in Oregon elections.

Phil Knight, the co-founder of Nike, single-handedly donated over $3.7 million to Johnson’s campaign and $1.5 million to Drazan’s campaign in 2022. Money has influenced major elections before, and it continues to dilute the average citizen’s voice within elections.

“It happens without voters even knowing about it, even though it’s technically public information. Voters don’t pay attention to campaign finances and they might not realize that their politicians are taking money from organizations that they might not necessarily support. I think that if you really want to have an ethical grassroots political campaign, then you should be able to get financial support from everyday middle class Americans because those are the people you’re meant to be representing, not the rich.” Battrick said.

The 2010 Supreme Court case “Citizens United v. Federal Election Commission” ruled that political expenditures by unions, nonprofits and corporations are protected under the First Amendment and not subjected to government restrictions. Overwhelming majorities within the U.S. have consistently disapproved of “Citizens United,” with 22 states and hundred of cities supporting a constitutional amendment to reduce the influence money has on elections.

“I think that the worse we get in terms of large contributions from people with a lot of money, the closer we get to autocracy and being controlled by wealthy interests. If we can’t have some sort of control over how much money gets donated, then I think that we will quickly run into very big issues of interest being compromised,” Shaye Beardsley, a University of Oregon general social studies student, said.

Calls to enforce campaign spending laws continue to rise across the country, and considering the upcoming election, Oregon needs to make a significant effort to increase transparency laws and work on implementing parts of the bill sooner than the proposed deadline.

The post Nag: The money, the rematch and the law appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Nag: The money, the rematch and the law

Nag: Accountability without a name

The saying goes that it never rains in Autzen, but Oregon is far from being considered a sunshine state – especially for transparency for police behavior. 

After the video was released of, now-resigned, Eugene police officer Martin Siller saying racist, anti-immigrant and domsestic-violence related comments, my journalism class started discussing laws related to public records. Bodycam footage is considered public records, and something that anyone can submit a request to attain, however, Oregon law does one thing that other states don’t always do. 

Currently Oregon anonymizes all footage from body-worn cameras, so before the footage is released to the public all faces are blurred, the identifying features are obscured, and parts of the audio may be required. Police officer names are further anonymized by using the word “personnel” to describe individuals. 

Bodycams were mandated to increase police accountability and transparency with the public, however what is accountability without a name? 

Sunshine laws, or laws that mandate government transparency by requiring access to meetings, records votes and deliberations, are still lacking in Oregon. In a survey of sunshine laws nationwide, Oregon ranked in the mid-tier, below states like Texas and Florida.  

The Oregon legislature should take action after looking at this controversy in Eugene, and turn to making all body cam footage available for the public, with full police names. This would be a step in the right direction, and echo the sentiment of accountability and transparency that the community has been advocating for. 

In a press conference hosted in Scobert Park on May 15, community organizers and local documentarians who have witnessed police violence on the streets spoke up. 

“These are conversations that happen so frequently, and that are so common, that (Siller) was just casually taking part in this horrific conversation,” Blair Hickok said at the opening of the conference. “After speaking with several community members there are some things that have come up that have been really frustrating to hear, but at the same time, it’s not surprising. They have heard stuff like this, and worse, said to their face.” 

Public records requests exist to hold officers accountable, and exist for press rooms to do further investigative searches on police misconduct. Without having access to names, faces and other identifying information, it’s much more difficult and expensive for the public to access the data.

One of the main reasons as to why the footage was not anonymized within the released footage was because local documentarian Tim Lewis, released it during the discovery process during his trial. Lewis made the decision to publish the videos and show the casual racist and sexist conversations which take place on duty.

“Unfortunately this system here is just like the rest of the country and it’s broken. Sorry, it’s not broken – it’s working exactly the way it was designed to,” Hickok said. “This is just one small snippet of a glimpse into that dark disgusting culture.”

It’s important to find ways to bring the public into these conversations, and by passing state level sunshine laws, Oregon would better accountability and transparency for police misconduct. Because what good is body cam footage without a name to hold an officer accountable?

The post Nag: Accountability without a name appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Nag: Accountability without a name

Nag: The labor candidate running for Eugene City Council

The May 19 election has brought electoral competition to the Eugene City Council elections. Currently, both Jennifer Smith and John Barofsky are running for the Ward Three position for the Eugene City Council.

Barofsky and Smith both have competitive resumes as to why they should be the next councilor to represent Ward 3, but Smith’s background in labor organizing and ongoing grassroots leadership is best suited to address the issues the community is facing.

Ward 3 encompasses the University of Oregon, and primarily where students and graduate teaching staff live. Smith has received numerous notable local endorsements, including those from the Democratic Party of Lane County, the Associated Students of the University of Oregon, the United Academics of the University of Oregon and University of Oregon Student Workers.

Smith has an active focus on making housing affordable and accessible amidst the rising cost of living, with specific focuses on expanding tenant protections and the creation of union jobs. She also is focused on making sure that Eugene is not only on track to meet its climate goals, but that the city becomes a national climate champion. Smith is also an active advocate for human rights, and has publicly condemned ICE within Eugene communities.

“Jen has been an ally of our union, she is the president of the UO classified staff on campus, SEIU, they’re great allies. We like to stand in solidarity with each other across campus labor issues,” said Jonah Dyk, a second year student and a current organizer with the political action committee at UOSW.

Notably, Dyk mentioned that Smith was the only candidate that reached out to UOSW for an endorsement during this race.

“I like her stance on transportation and reducing car infrastructure in Eugene, and swapping that with more bike-friendly infrastructure and policies,” Dyk said. “Personally, she doesn’t own a car, and neither do I. I think they’re expensive, and necessitating owning a car for student workers is a big burden financially that a lot of us can’t afford in Eugene.”

Smith has a long history of labor organizing, serving as the president of SEIU 503 Local 085 and the UO Labor Education Research Center Coordinator. She has also served in the Oregon Higher Education Coordination Commission, adding to her organizing background.

Collin Heatley is a rank-and-file member of the Graduate Teaching Fellows Federation and was most recently the graduate employee at the Labor Education and Research Center on campus. He also reiterated Smith’s commitment to Ward 3.

“I think what resonates with both my community of graduate students and me is her laser focus on cost of living, particularly on housing,” Heatley said, referencing the power the city council has on shaping housing affordability. “Having someone that’s going to fight for affordable housing but also do so in a way that’s going to create protections for tenants living in those units, has been my focus and it’s something that affects the graduate student community.”

Heatley also stresses the importance of students and community members voting in the May election. Usually, local and spring elections see low voter turnout among young voters, but this
particular election directly determines the future of student housing in this region.

“We are all members of this community while we’re living here, and ideally, there are good job opportunities, and it is an affordable place to live that people want to stay after they graduate,” Heatley said. “The stakes of this election are if we can elect Jen, we will have another pro-labor, pro-working families (councilor) and have somebody with an organizing mentality and ability to build people power in the city council.”

The post Nag: The labor candidate running for Eugene City Council appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Nag: The labor candidate running for Eugene City Council

Nag: Institutional apathy and the fight for a Latiné Center on campus: why the task force doesn’t work

After the April 23 meeting with ASUO President Prissila Moreno, UO President Scholz proposed a task force to assess the feasibility of a Latiné center on campus. However, the university has had a shaky history with task forces, and many within the Latinx coalition fear that this would be redundant and ineffective. 

Both Moreno and Giovanni Bazan-Espain, the Latiné Male Alliance president, referenced the history of the university’s initiative to be designated a Hispanic-Serving Institution and the lengthy, exclusive process undertaken by their task force. 

An HSI is a federal designation for accredited universities with a student body in which at least 25% of students are Hispanic.  This designation allows campuses to compete for Title III and Title V grants for academic programs and support services for Hispanic students, diversify educational access and provide further financial assistance.

Oregon currently has several HSI’s, such as Western Oregon University in Monmouth, Warner Pacific University in Portland, Columbia Gorge Community College and Chemeketa Community College. Universities like Portland State University and the University of Oregon are actively working toward the official designation. 

“The HSI status exists to show that a university has the proper resources in place to ensure that Latinx students thrive on campus,” Moreno said. “And we believe that directly related to that is a physical space for our people.” 

Bazan-Espain wanted to join the task force for UO’s HSI designation when he entered as a freshman last year. He found the process largely bureaucratic and exclusionary of student voices. 

“I said, ‘how can someone get on the task force?’ I really wanted to get to work. But you had to be nominated, and then after a whole year of practically begging to be on the task force, I was just shut out,” Bazan-Espain said. “I wasn’t nominated. I wasn’t invited. I wasn’t whatever process (required) that the administration has to add someone to the task force, and I didn’t get the time of day.”

After that experience, he reached out to ASUO; the current ASUO administration set a goal to expand cultural centers on campus, such as the SSWANA Center, and he pivoted to push for a Latiné center.

“Within three meetings, ASUO drafted a backward plan for the winter terms and how we can start ramping this up and getting to work,” Bazan-Espain said.

Both Moreno and Bazan-Espain emphasized the tangible wins they have seen through the Latinx coalition in building the center; they continue to meet every Friday and host public events to build support for Latiné students on campus. 

“Not even half of what the coalition has done has been done by the (HSI) taskforce that has been around since 2019. All they have done is release a study about the diaspora of Latinx students who are first gen.” Bazan-Espain said. “And then a Latiné commencement, which is great, but it took them seven years to get a commencement for their second largest ethnic group.”

Currently, the coalition has produced detailed studies on a budget proposal for over-realized ASUO funds that can be used for a center, a budget analysis and proposal for the total building costs and a comparative study on other Latinx centers within the Big Ten conference. 

Bazan-Espain mentioned that task forces meet monthly, and that the HSI task force has yet to meet this term; the infrequency of meetings and the bureaucratic aspects of the process further stall tangible commitment for the center. 

“It’s readily apparent to me that the upper administration is stalling and waiting us out with another task force – this institution does not have a good history with task forces,” Bazan-Espain said.

The post Nag: Institutional apathy and the fight for a Latiné Center on campus: why the task force doesn’t work appeared first on Daily Emerald.

Posted in UncategorizedComments Off on Nag: Institutional apathy and the fight for a Latiné Center on campus: why the task force doesn’t work

Nag: Institutional apathy and the fight for a Latiné Cultural Center on campus (part one)

The University of Oregon has claimed to be supportive of its students of color, with various emails and statements being sent out, but it remains one of the few institutions in the Big Ten that does not provide a dedicated space or service for Latiné students. Latiné students currently make up the second-largest ethnic group at UO, and, under the Latinx coalition, many are calling for institutional changes to improve services. 

The Latinx coalition was created over the winter to organize an effort to establish a designated Latiné Cultural Center on campus, similar to the South Asian, Southwest Asian and North African Center introduced last year. However, the road to meeting with administrators and sharing information with staff has been unfruitful.

“It’s one thing for (Scholz) to claim ignorance about an issue and say he doesn’t know how to address them,” Prissila Moreno, the ASUO president, said. “It’s another thing to have students in the room telling you exactly what they need and still refusing to (take action).”

Moreno has been a vocal advocate for this center and has spent weeks trying to get a meeting with the administration to discuss these concerns, and only succeeded after countless emails on April 23. Administration was unable to confirm support for the Latiné Cultural Center and instead proposed another task force. 

“I would have really liked to see the university recognize the political moment and find a way to support our community through a tangible center,” Moreno said. This was in relation to the prolonged response to ICE alerts and official campus-wide statements for threats on immigrant students and those with immigrant families. 

The Latinx coalition has been meeting every Friday to discuss next steps for the Latiné Cultural Center; the group includes ASUO, Latiné Male Alliance, MEChA de UO, Muxeres and UO YDSA. They have arranged conversations with Oregon legislators to build statewide support for the center as well, and have reached out to other institutions within the Big Ten Conference to learn about the logistics of building a Latiné Cultural Center. 

“Just to get into that room and to be told that our coalition starts and ends with conversations about how nice it would be to have a center, whereas an administrator’s job is to bring the doers into the room, is extremely disheartening,” Moreno said. “We have been the doers and we will continue to be the doers.”

LMA interns conducted a financial feasibility study and found that the building cost would be approximately $200,000. They drafted a proposal to allocate that amount from the over-realized ASUO fund; the proposed funds would cover staffing, infrastructure, programming and community-building investments for the center. 

“I went to visit Oregon State’s Centro Cultural César Chávez, and I saw how welcoming the staff was, and the communal ground where people can share their cultures. While I was happy to see that, of course, I felt jealousy, envy and disappointment – not at Oregon State, but it’s like ‘why aren’t we doing that?’” Giovanni Bazan-Espain, the president of LMA, said. “Why not? Why can’t we have one?”

In a past statement to the group, University of Oregon President Karl Scholz said, “I can almost guarantee there will be no commitment” to funding a Latiné Cultural Center. The most recent meeting prompted some consideration, but it ultimately failed to secure commitments.

“We just saw that UO needed to implement ICE notifications because of a mandate – it took them a government mandate to actually protect their students,” Bazan-Espain said. “The time to fight is now; we need to get to work now.”

The post Nag: Institutional apathy and the fight for a Latiné Cultural Center on campus (part one) appeared first on Daily Emerald.