In June, the Supreme Court upheld a ruling that allows states to ban transgender women from competing in sports at public schools. The ruling comes after years of right-wing contention surrounding trans athletes competing amongst cisgender peers.
This debate around transgender women athletes reflects a misunderstanding on the part of dissenters and a prejudice against female athletes that is sadly familiar.
Currently, 27 states have laws in place banning transgender students from participating in sports that align with their gender identity.
Right-wing government officials claim they want to “protect” women’s sports by putting rules in place against transgender athletes, but don’t give any indication that they care about women’s rights in any other aspect of lawmaking. Their opinions come from a place of hatred for transgender women, rather than a concern for female athletes.
The reality of transgender women who compete in sports is that their presence doesn’t change sports in the ways that those who are against them claim it does. In 2024, National Collegiate Athletic Association president Charlie Baker said he was aware of fewer than ten transgender athletes who compete in sports at a collegiate level, when at the time there were around 500,000 total athletes in NCAA schools.
With so few recorded transgender athletes at a professional level, it’s hard to imagine that transgender women are having an impact on public school sports enough to warrant Supreme Court rulings against them.
Additionally, studies done regarding comparing the performances of cisgender athletes and transgender athletes have found that their physical abilities tend to be equal.
The claim that allowing trans women to compete amongst cisgender women is an injustice to female sports is insulting, when the discrimination that women in sports face is based on real instances of misogyny. Most of which go completely ignored or are mocked by the same people who claim that transgender women competing is unfair.
The reality of transgender women in sports is that many of the arguments used against them seem to be less rooted in the reality of their sports performance and more tied to internal biases.
University of Minnesota Family Social Science professor Jenifer McGuire said that the pushback against transgender women in sports is linked to politics. The arguments we see are mainly focused on people in power who hate transgender people, rather than being tied to legitimate athletic concerns.
“It has nothing to do with trans women playing on women’s teams,” McGuire said, “And everything to do with mobilizing hatred and getting votes.”
The biggest problem with the dissent against transgender athletes is that, even if it’s not based in logic or genuine concern, it can still have devastating consequences for transgender people.
McGuire said that the risks for transgender people are dramatically increased when they’re forcibly outed and treated like second-class citizens.
“Whenever any segment of society is excluded, it’s a risk for that segment of society,” McGuire said. “And so we do see increases in mental health risk, suicidality, risk-taking behavior among trans kids when there are initiatives to restrict their rights.”
In states like Minnesota, there are legal protections for transgender athletes to play sports among cisgender women. However, with laws being upheld that allow states to pass firm bans, it’s concerning to think about how far conservative lawmakers will go to push their hatred for transgender women.
Transgender people are over four times more likely than cisgender people to be the targets of violent crimes, and transgender women are more at risk for these crimes than cisgender women.
While lawmakers and the general public express faux concern about transgender women harming cisgender women while playing sports, both groups of women face real threats of violence from cisgender men every day that go largely ignored.
The Supreme Court ruling emboldens people who already discriminate against transgender women, both in public and online. For a sect of individuals who are already predisposed to violent discrimination, the government laws that openly target them leave transgender women even more vulnerable to hate.
It’s crucial that we continue to fight against the targeted prejudice against transgender women who just want to be given the same chance in athletics as their cisgender counterparts.
Female athletes need people who will champion them, especially in a culture that continually mocks their abilities. And for transgender athletes facing even greater odds, it’s important that we support them on and off the field.
The post Opinion: We need to protect transgender women in sports appeared first on The Minnesota Daily.













